0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 133 views15 pages5th Amendment Case Khandakar
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Th Gondbere Déluare Hotsain, Seonelary NP 6 anctiur Ve
Bamladesh Talian Marke Wonks 4 orlete
CAD) 298
| Paltttioners ¢
Responders? a
Case No; Givi! Peltion fon Leave 10 Appeal
No: 44 4 lo46o{ 2009 Cfetom Yhe 3!
oord oredare doled 294" Aupust parsed by the
u ah Cours
Gore of 2000)
84M, dushce
a Me. Dustee
Division bn ret Petition Ne,
Md. Toe
Sarr ul aslom theif duster
Mmonommad Fazlul karin
Abdul Metin
* Mr. Jushee Md-
% Me. Dashee
* Me, dustee
A mee. Jase
| Courct Appellore Dwision
re Deloare Hossa
vhond ke
vb Oko Ee
Gureenda Fumore Sinha
nd
angladesh Talian Monble Works 4
2021/10/6 18:38Tntrtodaetion?
This. qudgement har rashaped the eonst-
fever! lancea pa, of Bangladesh . Following Riba qedee
pment on 03-67. 20, +2 Parblament pancd the
| Gonstittion Chlkenth Amendment Aet), 201 dont
|
| Resonted tb tba ereovisioms of Ae cee purer
-Oure Apex Courch (neti —
J4o a eomsidertatle. exten
o& Merhiol laws im oure
doted +2 exis Yen
yp ond bid Larawell Ao
@ondriutioral disper hie
Set A
ny ee of extra- conehtwttonal Advent
| forsver.
Bw0, Hue company and Ce
“Va oO Wredt Perrion
ph Aran dment Aer oF
No suprero-|)
|
| Fant? ox 10 December *
|
| Diecaetore, eon Cinema wai 4
te Vices: Op Ut
| \
| Challeng
[ru Gnenrution os be
yey of aonstitution naevpens2"*
is oe basia *
of qudered reavie
tha Congh sutton. Tay eho SouRte
m i The Mi wt Divi
mn Cinema ‘Holl. et
issued Rule Nisi calling upor yn
Show Caupe dg -to why Ae teof Mann CinemaHall ond purported" tabhtea! eugne
comfiremahow of Rguletion No. Vit of PFA and
Reclamation Ondere NO. 1 of 1OFF with magarcd 4s
Fourth Sehedely.
lof Ale Corgttution by parcagtcaeh 49 af Metordh
Ave Conchiuton by Aan Constitichon
£1979)
mserchon of Parcagnoap BA +o
[Se hed Of
\97m (Act. No.1 0
ICFiMth Amendwant Oe)
hove, been Made without
ad +e
of me Gs AS
y_ should nehbe!
jon Of Meon
deelore
Should nol be
; eet and
Hlawful authosty and
|
further. 90 to Ushy he Responder
Tecate Ao hond ove Sage. POSES]
Peo abg Aa hue Comena “he Resper dents
Peeates ie bale by Gling ASS idavit- in-bppesr
jen. ey Submited veforea, She br@h pena |
[ Division Jot the Moor @inemo: Hola akondcnel
ana TMONOR
property; possessing
toon teatified and confirmed by
Amerdmom ; Here wor imordne
filling Abe wrt Pettion end
% bores boy Res: Qudieted
vide Ho quigewr! and ©Th early 2509,
L
; ecvenens Peiionem ag
j Six rove. petitions , Aaac
eee
din Rule absolute! tre wih ‘Court Ohta
dl declared Jie Constitution CFAth Arrendenert ) tags
llega! ond void ob Mmitio subgeet eo Cerrone,
land oho declorid rcodrhieodion omd cork ecretin
Peo DL laheon Www ob ter hewing been
Ee esaick (acral muse one » of mo Vpp tied
he High Gourd Division Furcthere dirceoted Has.
Rec porderts te oer) everc Haan Py ereee pesse sep, j
of Moon Cinemo. Leal tottus fompony, Tha
condored SOTre provi sions |
whoh Srmullad the provisions OF Fourcts Amst
4 Ge Gourd Diwision
2
| ment -
| “Tha overcn rent and the
Freedom Holsters
Welfare Trust Fild civil Petition No. (se of ui
206 Gnd 1320 of 206—- rus peenvely
and anot har Ai
Delware Hossain
Praying Sorc GP PLOFLNG fn JytereVe nT
Hae Judgment end Or
ot to Pieessie).
feenvens Gad petitions or leave. 40 Appeat
die Appellate Division allowed
| Taree. ere,
[te prayers of The. Government and Hue trust
dia ivtercvenetes @
,
fn +e lenee. petrhons,
nd and oredere OF Fue Hah Courct Divs
On 01-02-2010, tle Appel lote, Division upheld dhe
of tte High Courct Divici on
and dismissed teleore
4 and the Company
re yes
sadzmies Gnd Ordere
wit, cfew wmoedicech ons
The Govercmen
pebtions es
Pelthons, “Ms Aepallete Division
Silod Poview .
De ie. oktdere doled l10m. 28 disposed of |
Pee quiets petition with come ‘Modefreoctions
im die Opercadi v4 prction of Ala gudgenent of
dhod Division. i
|
Coursels
[Men TH. Ehan, mre, Moudud Ahmed Senior
loth Amecom A. Siddig, Advoeode LP
ttle Petitionercs, On the Otherc hand”
: Alam, A Horney - General, Addition
= Generan , Deputy Atioemey
i
[| Attorney Generoh A ppeoned
| Farcthen, tre. Aymatal Uoa
Jars ABM Siddique Rahamen khan. Mdvoosdhe , Mn.
[Burftqua Neewa2, Gainiore Adveele , Mr. Mohsin Rashi,
Pa Me. Malmmudeal Telam, Mr, APM Mesbahuddi,
|
|Mr. Yusuf Hecsadr Humayun, Mee AM coe
Mec. Sheikh
| Leddin Mee. Abdut Mechm Khas,
| )
lTaale Noore “Tapas, Mire. Nurul Islam Sugomstha pe
Giddeki, Me-SM Retaul karim |
|Shabidal karim 4
| ha
[4 Me, Momtaguddén fakire appeared fo Mule
teespechve Raspondat , :
Arauernent ° |
Assue:
UW) Woleet tue p ‘ ; om
| late Primetpes of Nodionalism
,
| Soaralisrm, Seon'‘larusym ane due basi a Strceetines
| Of tte Conshiieion of Beogocksh, aT
| OY Sletiore oll ta lepistotive Measures 1.€,
tue Proclamations, Marcial Lato Pes
and orders, were presmulaced |
Aus period from th August, 1376 |
1979 by Wy eomsh tated :
a UGurnpers and if by us
those Laslett ve measures
Miod and non- est.i (eee e 7 —- an
Cin) Wheture Wu stuction anit existed onaugust
15, (935 necessitated +t tanpetitions of ie
Martial Low.
QV) Whetuere Poth Amendment neped 4s thee
Bast i
Gonetitutien, and reapugmern Ao tus Vasie. x
etrcuetures [Seotunes OF bus aonchtuonand — ae
are Vinos. tte Conetitudto h. ‘
C) Whettare St High Counc Division fan 4
b
exeercatse +a legis ledive. power 27 ey :
|
of eondonation
Are ash
mie. Aymalul Hossain, Ge Car-1#) 4 saute
reNFleocke.
t Abpeol aay ve bicouas teh) Oo
; - Cad of
ia
Under. Provisions of Sub- arhele ©
Aa Wave OF
| Artiok 103 ort with
2. Tere i» Conflict betweoan as
Property on guaranted Gen dere”
and +e in fremgerra oF Thin
Sst Amendment .
B. Te Court wil) olyoys
Cocgtidution arte Supe
tue lars parsed byJothare body ore authority,
| Mic. Tausque Netway € Aawortdeng to Para -%.) Satd Are,
a
4. Every functionany of +h clakete SUb}ee le
Sy die wil of fe Reophe
5. Bosie. Feature of Comptitudton ton TOT
be homers: s
vee
b Members of tH. Anmed fortacs core the
servard of dle Peoplu. an d eon not bermorter
of dus people 2
hi. Gomptodesh enter
{+ lasted lora fore le years.
” a ote bs
tod He pertod of Detiquer
im log and
g. We, tur people of Bowpladesh
pole Sian.
\ The petcpatratora of On Laneonctonal
oat lan been aranted 9
by doettune oF meee ssity,
2 c
“The = Doetruine of reoe ssV
a mMiseonceived ond mispl
and uneonstitetiona Dust:
tte benefit of tus perped
ps
bneonsttutioral acts(tare, Mah n\ a ” real CA
b
mabey Nan , atore =F Gremet al ¢ daoreding. j
tau
Ft earca= 109
As tue ntenvene :
re petitioners
weree mot pak
pabchics
Peo
act oon stoge of te pecasec \oe-fo rea. Ae
| -
Ih Could Division, Avay tome) Sila Aue love
petitions @haven 4 ie
PY) leo Jud errant of *Meltic
@ouct Division m9 q a
Silas pucpomled
2. Velhonacs cannot support
of tus Corstrutionm meds by Tee
amerdmerns
USUIc peices,
om tthe @onstrtetion
2. Primerple of soeuerclant
th ome of ue base atarennteres OF TAG IS
4. fitth A mortmot aarnc\ be. Lecoocted Onan
aera of the Consiivtem becouse rs
han beer amursiores ccapere dQ) E
of the Gonsiiv
alterced Ort oe
Arcelss. ;
mH. As Are OO previ SIONS 1!
Sore ratification of eantiere
fist
Aso die Prcovision
wien, which
Lehituded im Pass
Amanda? ie
of Andie| @. Due to abserte ee pajercerdum, a Fifth Amand
|
Pet Garret be Fee valid ond legal.
| &- Ament rt “mode, during Awe marcos bw
Tregine: coxmmdt be @ volid comerdirert -
fora 20) said Shab
hove no. locks ‘nw
public imperckanee
| Mr.Mk Rahman ( Accosudir By to
|
iniercvercS
1. Tired pardy
|
whan ne \ssue of
| especially
ie imvoived
2. Figth Brenden of Me Consttitlon 1 Baed
ok Arce \az2 and hee
Nee Audhorw*7
involtd,
&. We
empower OP7
agnatitudon Stk Pet
autrenty ot power. >
yy Utany Rule.
om AWN
impor [sstee of constieding |
Trans forcing. a eivel sust
Litigedtions
| Alter tle Wdapendenee of Ef
die cbandon properches oe
on- Bengalis wore acquired. G
even befora tur constitution 1
enacied, a deenes, of thaa —<—<——<$______
a
Nod , December 31, 1941) SAoded trot “meny pre :
[Hes tere, Aequircad cv Govern mento tomad
cates, Moon ttmema to 0 Such properchy
Hie acquired Property, tar ladere Lomded over
|fnom Jha govercrment te Hue, Mnuketiyoddne, Wel
Trust Freed from eaphvity (1m Pakistan, Sheth ”
| Mugib returned tothe eorertny 6m AO darian, |
| 25. The mann Crrema Hall case began lo |
| deform tie took offier. Tuan nm Appa! 1972, he,
{ t . .
[oRaimal onan wert to various minisinies |
|
| and started Submitting
Feo
| Goverement ofdtees to get tue preopertty bad, Feam
[Ane Aime Of Shaikh Muqills rule Ord even och
hin death , Vorcious tubes amd reg 4
leophotes inctha lato arulted , There
of taking hoek so Many abode ed
act fa honds oly the minishy, oF C
written application to
2
‘Tn feasponse to Sueh ay apple
t
tha ovoner of Moon Cinema, |
logtoben 19%, 4 ue Aban dors
[OF He mimicry of Tr ;
of =~ iPreosidertl ates VU
ura Welfarce
owelcs
Mimsy Se ks
do retain
rust. Latere 19 1997, milcteny
dere deerae Stee tat
| Rohman isstad
any preopetay dcelored abon dored by
Govern? Geol eo be alenibenge t in Courel
petition 4? Ailed I 1233 Jo rato,
Tn Hele ana, pray ios owe
prasemas an an
| A este) wrt
dum eroperty,
yssue 19
clutp eovye C007
Tssuh
pe. eons jutonal @ooe
wins od conetitutenal quniedter +o
\or7 tate ©
quieren hort
ores.
pohetiare, 21> hod OE oat
ln lope Gnd toletiett as
Presi dent
aoe
Coup plement 07Tudgemert?
the Supreme
Gemiier isn on eee Sid by tle
laa ovare dhe ouershiy
Cour OP febnuany 1,200
Pomsed the
Molton Manbe Works
Holl.
Apired on Macefivedelee
Cluaig gushes
pean ee enema,
Judice, Metin
Division &
ettoz2 ot Ts tom
y ene ee eeleny= ae =
peat avallangi 7% Abe
vyerdae’ declorirg ye
Aunal .
waq Tht
ner Led by
on Bwbruany 312616
ol Lhodéere |
i Avot
dismiss?
Hossoun’s ap
Division's
on UMCONS:
Deleware
Pantevenre Courch
Jifth Armd
da verted Oona Je four )
pomid
“pdiaes te) Aslom
ovhort audge S ogre
Judiee ABM kKhaicul Woq ue
Pee AO Vane 2 7 ae 8
hod declared duo Sifth Amend :
on August 2¢,2005 19 dig POS
petition .dispecting
coed wrth hivne
warMasts Matis oc! due digestion eatd | the
Highest gure, pares lanly tle Appeltot sieve
1
rot 9 ott Of OMY issue Lefora 11"
Should
As dus KOU of due ToGan Marble dorks
Cone, wor do deerda dus Moon Gieme hal’c
olomercshdp, you can't Say
s ede, to +s eonch'tution dune,
Aue mantal law reapim 25 wera Inearnaas,
eo AS:
Conelusion: Th the Judge ment tan the Sth
Soma impordant
| Amendrent ease Upheld ;
Welecons Wy the Gppellose
Division Yobimna
bhetum V. Geongledsch , Saltom
Eleetion Comision, aNosie F
Bomgtosesh wilt po athected eam
arent acoepred Anat srorcio\ Vase
teauloction ete,
Gonshitetion lost
lass Constitution ' kus Sup
tend SYP
{Xs @harcocte te a4reflection ef people's esistes and desieee ae
Sovermment should
making, any fen domenteal aronaes in EP
Should reetreatn Steen mroking “rrorjore charges
sug % reached. sy
oS Aha Comsttion
tua, Grovercrmnent
Sruitfel epee eae
wesnOry ara division
wlityand ny
UmtesS OH nononal eomseh
tells us Sumdomen fal enonges
cakton Sau
by athe umiledercah
hove ret brovgint
\b eraoted bitter
tal eounrty cola sto
toithin +
toerce. immensely mneed 2d Sor mettion ak pro sae
fry. Ta ony event / Ween y Sunder
acces 3 eucntandt
ehamee s eae be
Comemtution, Fae preaserctbe preo
ta Ave Verty Bonsnienom mus
cedures, ote nel