0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 65 views14 pagesBaugh 2013 Chapter 11
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
argues,” suggest that the paradigm of theatrical performance may
be structurally alien to any quest for certainty and stability. The
consequent breaking down of the binary and the neat hierarchical
relationships between page and stage, between producer/artist and
consumer/audience, should be located alongside the paralle! economic
migration away from industrial manufacture with its focus on material
product, to economies and industries that are predicated upon infor-
mation, performance and knowledge with a focus upon service and the
customer experience. The technologies of computation that have had
such significant effects upon the theory and practice of theatre, perfor-
mance and scenography, and that have simultaneously both enabled
and reflected the ‘de-framing? and destabilisation of the theatrical
experience, have also been the technologies that have enabled Internet
access to knowledge and information and have generated an unprece-
dented ability to interrelate with the world in ways that are similarly
not ‘framed’ in colonial authority. The presentation and performance
of self through the creation and ‘uploading’ into the virtual theatre of
a social networking site or personal web space, or interaction with a
performance website, have created significant alternatives to existing
narrative modes, forms of representation, dramaturgies and physical
places of performance. Within digital dramaturgies and within virtual
theatres of performance, the virtual actor, the avatar, may be brought
into existence and may walk upon an entirely new space and within a
completely re-functioned scenography of performance.
Scenography as
Dramaturgy of
Performance
Given the volatile global situation, what should artists do?
Richard Schechner, 2002"
‘The earlier chapters of this book have examined the development of
scenography over the last hundred or so years and have been con
cerned primarily with activity within the institution and architeceures
of the theatre, The understanding of scenography that has been con-
structed has been primarily about the creation of the mise en scene for
the staging of plays. One way or another, scenography as a devel-
oping form of artistic practice has been applied within the service
of dramatic literature. But as Kershaw says, *...post-modernity sig-
nals an acute destabilisation...an end to all the human certainties of
the modernist past’.? Alongside artistic and cultural destabilisation,
increasing ecological, environmental and global political concerns,
and their volatility noted by Schechner above, are provoking the artist
towards ever greater questioning of the function and purposes of per
formance. In addition, and as we saw towards the conclusion of the
previous chapter, the certainties of earlier twentieth-century modernist
ambitions for theatre have been significantly challenged by, amongst
other considerations, the increasing diversity of multi-ethnic perfor-
‘mance cultures. Of course, plays are still written and performed, but
the earlier theatrical certainties of dramatic literature and narrative,
and therefore scenery and its framing within theatre architecture are
no longer primary. Institutionalised Western producing theatre compa-
nies have become similarly decentred and replaced with performance
forms and values that tend, as Christopher Balme suggests, towards:
223
5«the visual image over the written word, collage and montage instead
of linear structure, a reliance on metonymic rather than metaphoric repre-
sentation, and a redefinition of the performer's function in terms of being
‘and materiality, rather than appearance and mimetic imitation.
Scenography in the service of dramatic literature continues to play
a significant role in major theatre centres and draws upon the larest
technologies of manufacture and control. But'whilst digital technolo-
gies are increasingly used to serve many of the traditional values of
spectacle in the theatre outlined in the introduction to this book,
scenographers and scenography are simultaneously moving away from
theatre architectures and formal spaces of performance. Floating
freely, stimulated by increasing research interest in the subject in col-
leges and universities, scenography has grown and in some ways been
transformed into an applied art practice that is finding new ways to
engage and interact with audiences. As_a rescarch-driven art prac-
Se tis engaging with GvEnf/RrsCEMUTY HUES the environment
global warming, ecology, vanishing resources, political inadequacy
and corruption, and effects of globalised capitalism without first
waiting upon the dramatist to write the play?
In this chapter, I therefore want to examine some of the ways in
which scenography has grown, developed and is being transformed
within a post-dramatic culture of performance. In particular, how has
scenography responded to globalisation, economic stringency, failing
energy supplies, global warming and climate change, and shrinking
resources? Do the energies and attitudes to theatre and performance,
for example, the founding principles of Appia and Craig - the genetic,
of scenographic theory ~ still have resonance and value within
contemporary practice? Since scenography has conceptually grown so
broad and may lack, for example, the focusing centrality of plays and
‘J theatre architectureanchop a discussion, my survey must be wider
Staging, more selective and inevitably somewhat less comprehensive.
‘These are new and challenging buttons that have been added to the
button box and which may determine ‘play’ during the twenty-first
century.
‘Working within the culture of performance and with ever increasing
presence within university research, scenography has become a vital
constituent within applied theatre practice, Nevertheless, I believe that
jin many ways new approaches extend and significantly develop the
energies that I have identified as conditioning scenography through-
out the twentieth century: rejection of the past; the idea of the scene
J om Osada TEAMS.
es thie — K TEATRO, APLICH DD
ep orig
To ANCHOR : AWcLAR
THIN © DEN TRO be
as machine; the materiality and performance-making qualities of light;
the collision and collusion of scenography with architectures and
a of technology. Therefore, although I want to consider
approaches, applications and interventions of scenography, the
values and attitudes that they represent may be determined within
much of its founding theory and practice. Therefore, and consis-
tently with the approach of the book, I would want to place these
nme developments within chit historical context and theatica
ECOOEIY) 9 Tn # veng premature iw
. rechat seen, almost as soon as he had articulated end Geng
S the atelier studio place of performance at Hellerau in 1910, Adolphe
= (Bs jected the formality of its architecture along with any physical
3 "Forms of separation between the performing artist and the specta-
Stor He struggled for a theory that would account for a completely
interactive form of performance and he urged its importance to the
<<
S community. Although ‘$carcely couches iscourse of contempo-
> rary performance theory, his final essay,‘Art Is an Attitude’, }
'S 1927 as an introduction to Walter René Fuerst and Samuc
Twentieth-Century Stage Decoration, is of striking relevance to the
concluding examples and arguments of this book:
RecHAzO
5
* We have loft our chairs. We are erect, we want to be ‘of itt, we shrink
from no violence to reach our goal, we seek for art and we wish to tind
it in ourselves, We break the barriers asunder, surmount in a stride the
‘steps that separate us from the slage, [and] descend unflinching into the
arena... The time will come when professionals in the theatre and the
plays written for them will be a thing of the past, never to retumn, When
mankind, free now, will sing in living symbols, more or fess dramatic, and
adopted by all, thelr joys and their sorrows, their harvests, thelr labors,
their struggles, their defeats and their triumphs; and they alone will be
spectators whom age or infirmity will gather round us in common, living
sympathy, The time when we shall be artists - living artists — because we
willed it so*
maviFesT.
Every 4 years since 1967, the Czech Republic has held an inter
national exhibition of stage design and theatre architecture. The
Prague Quadrennial is the most comprehensive and important bring-
ing together of architects and designers and their practices from all
over the world. Significantly in the context of the developments out-
lined in this chapter, for the 12th edition held in 2011, its name was
changed from an International Exhibition of Scenography and Theatre
architecture to the Prague Quadrennial of Performance Design and!
!
Space — PQ2011. The change of name reflected the expansion and
dramaturgical potential of scenography, and the mutability of the
concept of the architecture of theatre and the space of performance.
The following examples, many drawn from PQ2011, illustrate some
of the ways in which scenography has become imbricated within
performance-making; how it may operate as a dramaturgy; and how
itis responding within the ‘volatile global situation’ to concerns of the
contemporary world.’
Rejecting the theatre and its architecture and even the ‘non-
architecture’ of the black-box studio, the finding and making of sites of
performance has become a constant concern of scenographic practice.
For example, the imposing and disturbing materiality of industrial,
= used to create scenic spaces for performances that explore commu-
nity_and collective memory. Mike Pearson identifies suck Spaces a
representing *.--new Kinds oF informational site in changing techno-
SF logical circumstances, and the role of human agency in place-making
in a transitory moment of spon atari things and an
intensification of affect ...”* Pearson Tinvolved in an Arts and
Humanities Research Council (AIRC) ‘Landscape and Environment’
network research-grant project during 2006-2008, which had used
the Sennybridge Training Area (SENTA) Ministry of Defence training
village at Mynydd Epynt in the Brecon Beacons, Wales, for one of its
case studies.
Under the direction of Pearson, working in collaboration with Mike
Brookes and scenographer Simon Banham, the mock village, nor-
mally used to simulate house-to-house combat, became the focus of
scenography for The Persians by Aeschylus, which was staged in asso-
ciation with National Theatre Wales in August 2010 (Figure 11.1),
The production drew particular resonance, meanings and ‘an intensi-
fication of affect’ from its site specificity, since, as a forcible requisition
by the army in the 1950s, the village remains a contested place that
resonates with concepts of the violent colonialism that has historically
been inflicted upon the Welsh countryside.
‘The everyday use and connotations of the SENTA village clearly
provided @ powerfully resonant scenography for The Persians, but
the presence and history of an abandoned building may generate
an especial ‘intensification of affect’ for performance events. Perhaps
(pase eoernem Becomes a more appropriate phrase than mise en
‘Scone for the Tange of visual performance and scenographic exper-
iments that work in conjunction with, and build upon their site
ABsORE TION Puusta, om EVENTO
- Arvonaw +
Puta im ESUENE
g
&
abandoned buildings and the disturbed landscape are frequently being {gyj|
bh
a
and
enlily
i
{
x
Figure 11.1. The Persians, Sennybridge Training Area (SENTA) Ministry e 7
Defence training village, Mynydd Epynt, Wales (Sinton Banham). 4
ig village, Mynydd Epynt, Wales ( Wok .
specificity. For example, in the mid-1950s, an experimental nuclear
reactor named R1 had been constructed into the rock beneath the
Royal Institute of Technology just outside Stockholm in Sweden,
It produced electricity from 1954 until it was decommissioned in
1970. The bare walls of the original reactor hall are almost com-
pletely covered in diagrams, cable and pipework pathways, letters,
numerals and other traces of the technology of its nuclear past. The
remains of conduits and valves surround an exposed, bare, exca-
vated and very ominous space in the centre of the building ~ again
marked by numbers igsaglyahs nda divisions. The reclaimed
space provides ad isa es aaa Y that reflects*eerily, before
any event of ‘performance’ takes place, upon the immensity and yet
transience of science within the natural world. The reactor space is
now used as a cultural centre and performance laboratory for Operat
“Mecatronica, a company that represents collaboration between light-
ing scenography, dance and robotics. Anders Larsson and Magaus
Lundin make performances using electro-acoustic and acousmatic
music and explore interfaces between_dance, robotics and light.
“Through light and sound, science and technology are embodied in the
performance of dance, which confronts this resonant and disturbing
space.
EERILY » JvguieTAMENIE.Similarly unsettling and challenging to personal and social memory,
the Hungarian artistic group Krétakér took over the former Prague
headquarters of the Czechoslovak Communist Party newspaper Rudé
Pravo for their project Crisis Trilogy Part 1: jp.co.de during the sum-
mer of 2011, The building was temporally suspended, frozen at the
conclusion of its function and awaiting the demolition that occurred
a year later in 2012. The project focused on a group of 12 young
people selected from all over the world whose task was to create a
community over a period of several weeks living amongst the ruins
of Soviet industrial grandeur. The audience was told that the project
had been based upon the ideas of a Hungarian professor, Miklés
Hida, who gave a short lecture on the sociological theories by which
communities are built. To that end the young people had taken over
the building, and the performance was organised and framed by the
audience visit to their living spaces. Within the building the audience
saw an installation of beautifully mounted and lit photographs and
images that illustrated psychological abuse by parents of teenagers,
and, following the introductory lecture, a film was shown of the inter-
viewing and creation of the group of 12. The audience then moved
down into the huge, ruined printing hall and met the group and ques-
tioned them about their durational attempt to create community in
and through this space. Footsteps grated upon the rough flooz, and the
smell and taste of stale engine oil from the removed printing machinery
dominated the senses. Industrial buildings provide complex sensory
combinations. As Stephen Di Benedetto asks: ‘If artists harness words,
line color, and movement, are not smell, taste, and touch just as viable
and malleable stimuli?” What was true and what was a performed fic-
tion? A social experiment, founded upon seemingly true sociological
theory, had been constructed and performed in the ruins of a build-
ing thar had, for almost half a century, been committed to communist
truth (Figure 11.2),
Abandoned buildings inevitably offer associations and relationships
with the past, and an important feature of contemporary scenographic
practice invites its audience to reflect upon the construction of mem-
“ory. In Memory, History, Forgetting, Paul Ricoeur asked the question
‘Does there mot exist an intermediate level of reference between the
living memory of individual persons and the public memory of the
* Mexico’s Teatro OJO's ;NO?
project in 2008 focused upon the performative dimensions of both
individual and collective, politically generated memory. NO? created
a series of interventions and what the company called ‘image-actions’
Figure 11.2 Krétakér Crisis Trilogy/Part 1: jp.co.de, performed in the
formes Prague headquacters of the Czechoslovak Gommunist Pacty
newspaper Rudé Privo, 2011 (photograph by Christopher Baugh).
in Mexico City’s public spaces. These site-specific events and installa-
tions were described by the company as ‘struggles against forgetting”
and served to evoke accounts of what had or might have happened
in those spaces. Their aim was to provoke a confrontation between
official, state-generated history and possible, alternative personal his-
tories. In this way, scenography acted asa mode of archaeology
pondering over the traces and material remains of the past. The
process of the act of performance — the event itself ~ became an archae-
ological interpretation that in the case of ;NO? aimed to resist the
‘induced amnesia’ of politically constructed collective memory. Teatro
OJO asked, ‘How to recognize those erased footprints embedded in
the thoughts and behaviors of the subjects and the social urbanized
life within Mexico City?” They consider their performance instal-
lations as “... poetic interventions that seek to set off, interrogate
or provoke the social, urban fabric, and by makii i
_and by making spectators into
“participants that reconfigure the actions according to the degree of
their collaboration’."® But importantly the burden of (re)constructingmemory must be a
shared responsibility between the performer and
‘What Ileana Diéguez called the ‘processuality’ of the event
‘was more important than an attempt to create or display (as in a
‘muscum, gallery or theatre) described objects or captioned artworks
of memory. Through this process, ‘meanings’ were generated by the
audience and acted in confrontation with their own memories, rather
than being offered to them ‘ready-made’ by the actors. Both Appia
and Craig would recognise this concern to reject imitation of a pre-
interpreted reality in favour of a focus upon the lived reality and
process of performance.
Official history and memory were again brought into confronta~
tion when Teatro OJO’s performance Within a Failing State (2010)
took over the abandoned, former building of the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs in Mexico City. Four audience members, ata time, were guided
through the abandoned building by eight performers, who made, as
Hector Bourges Valles described:
--- [a] series of minimum actions, just the necessary amount to establish
precise relations with space, an object or with the process itself. In other
words they should make a space, an object or a document visible, auci-
ble, perceptible... Rathor than lodging a roprosentation, it had to deal
with the disposition of a direct link between the spectator, the actions
and the real."
Teatro OJO have renounced traditional forms of theatre, architecture
and scenography so that their practice might serve as an interven-
tion: as a way of relating a contemporary audience with its collective
past ~ perhaps in order to conjure new memories and perhaps to effect
some kind of reconciliation. The industrial or government buildings,
as grim emblems of state power and authority, in their desolate and
abandoned forms may serve as powerful stages where memory may
be constructed and reconfigured. As Ann Stoler said:
Itthe ruin stands as a tangible form that activates the past in the present,
toopen the question of potential futures, maybe the ruin, as a remain [sic]
of the past, can be a setting to locate the relationship between the colo-
nial past and the imperial present in a way that itre-activates postcolonial
thought in the blind spots that resist thought.*
The sites of old, abandoned and ruined buildings may be expanded to
include the pervasive urban ruined cityscape of globalised capitalism.
Brazil’s Teatro da Vertigem project BR-3 was performed in 2007 along
Figure 11.3 Teatro da Vertigem, BR-3 performance and image actions on
the Tieté Rives, Si0 Paulo, 2007 (photograph by Nelson Kao).
3 miles of the industrially heavily polluted and ferociously dirty Tieté
River, which runs through Sao Paulo (Figure 11.3).
Audlience/spectators were invited to board a boat, which presented
itself as a kind of floating evangelical church with a neon sign
announcing anodyne religious promises accompanied by the recorded
voice of an evangelical minister seemingly offering redemption and
salvation. The ‘narrative’ of BR-3 concerned three historical states of
Brazil: Brasilia, the monumental and powerful contemporary Brazilian
capital; Brasiléia, a lost city of the River Amazon; and Brasilandia,
an impoverished drug trafficking district of S40 Paulo. The river is
a powerful and noxious result of rapid, unplanned development and
urbanisation, Beyond the banks of the river could be seen the brightly
lit, distant cityscape. The darkness of the slowly moving water, the
bridges and warehouse buildings were used for lighting and as screens
to receive projections. Actors served as guides who referred the spec-
tator’s attention to performance actions and tableaux created by
sophisticated projection, but also towards images of frequently very
simple scenic resource. Examples of these were the disturbing stillness
of a hanged man suspended from a mast, called into service to perform
as a gallows on a small boat that slowly floated past the spectator; or
‘on the river bank the tableau of a distraught woman who was search-
ing for her lost husband, whose cheap labour had been exploited tobuild vast ‘global’ cities such as Brasilia, Anténio Araijo, the direc-
to/scenographer of BR-3, used the iconography and resonance of
Brazil’s Catholic history, live action and performance, alongside tech-
nologies of sound and projection to reflect on the globalised passion
play of urbanisation and development, and the seemingly remorseless
exploitation and transfiguration of the political underclass.
There are strong similarities between the dramaturgical processes
of Krécakor, Teatro OJO and Teatro da Vertigem and those of
many contemporary site-specific performance artists. For example,
UK scenographer Louise Ann Wilson makes performance where the
journey either metaphorically as narrative or literally as 2 mode of
spectating forms a focal part of her work and reflects her scenographic
dramaturgy. She says:
My concern is to create relationships between space, performer and
audience, and to find ways of revealing, reshowing and re-enchanting a
place by saying: 'Look anew at what is here; witness the surface of things,
and then look again and you will see something more profound about this
piace and perhaps about the world, and how we experience it, and our
Place within it’... Rather like an archaeological dig, making work like
this involves an approach to performance-making in which | ‘excavate’
the performance ‘out of a specitic landscape or place.”
As the company Wilson +Wilson, Louise Ann Wilson and Wils Wilson
made House (1998), which took two abandoned, and soon-to-be-
demolished, Yorkshire workers’ cottages in Huddersfield, UK, and
‘excavated’ them to make a performance event where found objects,
images and sounds were used to create imagined histories. Louise
‘Ann Wilson says: “This source material was a jumping off point
for the artistic team, feeding our preoccupation with time, change,
the evolution of buildings and private space, and raised questions
relating to how we read the past.” As in the earlicr examples,
small audiences, frequently limited to the intimacy of single figures,
were guided or led through the performance. In House, the audi-
cence progressed through rooms of the houses whilst events and
‘image actions’, ‘fragments of human stories’, unfolded before and
around them. Later work by Louise Ann Wilson has focused pri-
marily upon the relationship between rural landscape and human
events, but the scenographic inspiration, dramaturgy and performance
methodologies are similar.
In these examples, the guided journey has formed the basis of
the dramaturgical_ infrastructure of new scenographic site-specific
practice. But the intervention of the actor/performer may not always:
provide the means of guiding the audience. Increasingly, hand-held
computers and smartphone technology have been used to provide
guidance and instruction, which enables the individual participant
to control their exposure and perhaps their response to perfor-
mance. Dutch scenographers Lena Miller, Roos van Geffen, Theun
Mosk and Marloeke van der Viugt used this technology to provide
impulses, sounds and guidance in Looking For...(2011), in which
visitors/spectators/audience were invited to make a guided journey
through the streets of Prague. The narrative framework was provided
by the (supposed) discovery in 2003 of some rolls of undeveloped film.
“These were images of Prague during the 1960s and showed individuals
and groups posed within recognisable city locations. The participant
(or ‘attendant’, as Di Benedetto has usefully called such engagement")
used a smartphone to guide them on a tour through the locations
of the photographs where they were invited to use the camera on
the phone to imitate the 1960s” images. The photographs were later
compiled alongside both the originals and those of other participants
to form a complex artistically mediated and multi-layered gallery of
remembrance of a journey through the city. As with the Krétakor per-
formance, uncertainty about the truth of the narrative framing, in this
instance, the ‘discovered’ film from the 1960s, generated a heightened
sensitivity to city spaces within the participant. The client community
has become inseparably participant, attendant and audience.
Bat it is the process of the journey that enables meanings and reso-
nance, which, in some instances, may require significant commitment
by the audience. For example, the UK company Blast Theory, who
have consistently experimented with hand-held computers and smart-
phones, described their 2007 site-specific work Rider Spoke as a piece
which
.-linvites the audience fo cycle through the streets of the city, equipped
with a handheld computer. They search for a hiding place and record
a short message there. And then they search for the hiding places of
others... It invites the public to be co-authors of the piece and a visible
‘manifestation of it as they cycle through the city. Itis precisely dependent
‘on its local context and invites the audience to explore that context for its
‘emotional and intellectual resonances... Rider Spoke has @ high thresh-
old for the audience: you must be willing to cycle, alone at night, through
the city. And this sets the stage for a very personal and intimate form
Of participation. Instead of ‘User Generated Content’, the artists have
approached the project as inviting 'Publicly Created Contributions’.The generation and interrogation of memory has become a frequent
theme within contemporary performance scenography. Canadian
scenographer and scholar Kathleen Irwin explored scenography as
a technology of remembrance in both her own work (largely in
abandoned sites) and her writing about web-based performance.
In ‘The Wilderness Downtown’ (the Montreal rock group Arcade
Fire’s project launched online in 2011), which focused upon selation-
ships between the individual and the location(s) of their childhood,
she had an especial concern for the opportunities, and a distinct
sensitivity to the challenges, offered by the ‘found spaces’ of dig-
ital technologies and the consequences of intermedial intervention
in the making of memory. “The Wilderness Downtown’ used digital
technology to explore memory and identity in both local and global
neighbourhoods. She said that performance may be ‘... extrapolated
from the specificities of the site itself and, importantly, the communi-
ties that claim ownership of it’. In this instance, the site was real,
although digitally mediated, but the context of memory was virtual,
“The Wilderness Downtown’ used Google Maps-based software to
lead the individual ‘audience’ on a virtual journey through the land-
scape of their youth where *,.. material traces evoke worlds that are
intangible and unlocatable: worlds of memory, pleasure, sensation,
imagination, affect and insigh¢’.® But Irwin also acknowledges the dif-
culties where third-party mediatisation frames the memories that are
‘generated; in this instance, the hoodie-wearing young person (suppos-
edly oneself} who guides us on a journey through the neighbourhood
‘where we once lived has both positive and negative connotations.
In applying the skills and practices of scenography to social engage-
‘ment, artists may use a combination of sophisticated, or at least
complex, technology alongside a celebration of alternatives. For exam-
ple, glass is made from primal elements of silicon fused into formation
at very great heat. It is also one of the most frequently recycled com-
modities and seems to typify the opportunity for a regeneration of
scarce resources. Performance scenographer Richard Downing, work-
ing in Aberystwyth in Wales, is currently (2012) making a work called
“Butterfly Man’, where a ‘village’ of some 300 pairs of hands is cast
in recycled glass. The hands are cast with thumbs together and fingers
spread wide in imitation of ‘butterflies’. These are suspended in ‘flight
as it were, as a site-specific landscape intervention. Equally important
to the scenography, however, is the process of smelting and moulding
the glass. Downing is using a new kind of glass-melting furnace pow-
ered by low-carbon biomass fuel -at once sophisticated and advanced,
and yet inexpensive, ecologically sensible and completely accessible to
the artist. He described his ambition:
this is important to me for the transformative ‘chain’ underpinning
the work a chain ultimately embodied in the ‘butterfly’ metaphor and
anamorphic assembly, Roughly, it goes like this: sunlight captured and
stored by plants; this energy released - the whole work should read as
a release of energy ~ by new technology to transform (melt) waste glass
(itself once sand) to be re-shaped as individual butterfies*hands, cap-
{ured In one moment of their change; these gathered as both unique
individuals... and a sum of parts transforming/ revealing further poten-
tials (depending upon viewer and viewpoint) all revealed, in a loop, by
Tight?
“The process of transformation and change that has been a consistent
feature of scenography throughout all ages, to which has been added
concern for the exploration of alternative technologies, is an impor-
tant and significant development within socially engaged performance
and scenography. Downing sees this work as a process of making
scenography, but equally important as a process of research. Such
research increasingly serves as the starting point for scenographic
practice and performance: in practice, this research becomes the
initiating energy of creation and has replaced the dramatic text —
the play.
Proactive scenographic performance is increasingly being used as
an active intervention to register and empower the collective and
individual memories of local communities. Through space, objects,
memorabilia, playful procession, dance and clothes — all essentially
scenographic qualities, intangible, ephemeral and transient ~ memo-
ries may be generated and archived. In abandoning theatre buildings,
scenography is taking to the community its skills of modelling, graphic
representation, costume and public celebration, alongside sophisti
cated new technologies and digital archiving skills. These are provid-
ing a forum for research, interrogation, publication and performance
(and of course the Internet plays an important role in this work).
Scenography is offering a paradigm of performance whereby com-
munities may collaborate with artists and work to develop skills to
record and celebrate thoughts, memories and emotions collectively
experienced.
UK scenographer Fiona Watt used a form of scenographic
dramaturgy to make a community celebration within the context of
the changing North Kent urban landscape located within the larger‘Thames Gateway regeneration zone. Her work formed part of the
Créativité sans Frontiéres, a transnational collaboration of artists
and musicians that was formed through the Interreg IV Cross Bor-
der Programme of the European Union. ‘This worked to make links
between local communities in Medway and Dunkerque. Watt and
fellow artists based much of their work on the traditions of hawk-
ers, marker traders and travelling showmen and musicians. Reflecting
upon Marcel Duchamp’s Béite-en-Valise,® performance narratives
were made from the simplest, most portable means. Using small
models, memorabilia and ephemera, ‘suitcase museums’ were made,
which served to memorialise individual past lives and communities,
In procession through the streets and dockyards on both sides of
the English Channel, they served to reflect upon the transformation
and (regeneration of the urban environment. The suitcases of arte-
facts and models helped articulate, develop or interrogate the memory
and identity of individual people and a community who have been
subjected to a globalising process — in this instance the dockyard clo-
sures and the subsequent regeneration (and inevitable gentrification)
and their effects on communities in Chatham (UK) and Dunkerque
(France). The actions of Créativité sans Frontigres involved walk-
ing aud wavelling, which brought about mapping and discovery;
scenography and performance served to reveal and to guide both
participant and spectator on the shared journeys. In such instances,
‘we might well think of scenography as an archiving technology of
memory.
‘We have seen that the guided journey and the concerns of identi-
fying, shaping, showing and labelling - map-making ~ have become
recurring tropes of scenographic dramaturgy and_performance-
making. Such techniques and socially engaged practices have been
used elsewhere by artists working with communities coming to terms
with, for example, dislocation and diaspora, enforced urbanisation or
the destruction of rainforests or community farmland. For example, in
Brazil, interventions have taken the memories of current and former
inhabitants and questioned inherited assumptions such as progress,
the unquestioning generation of wealth and happiness. ‘They have
used a dramaturgy of processions, street dance, celebration and par-
ties in order to confront social restlessness. It is significant that in
exhibition catalogues and websites announcing and describing this
work, scenographers frequently list their range of skills as those of set
designer, costume designer, painter, sculptor, fashion designer, teacher,
graffiti artist, historian, researcher and fine artist.
‘The process typically involves an encounter between official artists
and indigenous artists and their communities. The ambition is to
make a provocation and a playful intervention that disturbs every-
day life, and where eventual efficacy lies in the ability to empower
both participant and audience. The communities frequently have tra-
ditions of community performance and diurnal practices that may be
extended and celebrated by the artists and which, through their tradi-
tional forms, serve to enrich and empower the community. As Dwight
Conquergood says
Porformance studies is a border discipline, an interdisoiptine, that cult
vates the capacity to move between structures, 10 forge connections, to
see together, o speak with instead of speaking about or for others. Per-
formance privileges threshold-crossing, shape shitting, and boundary-
violating figures, such as shamans, tricksters and jokers, who value the
carnivalesque over the canonical, the transformative over the normative,
the mobile over the monumental.
Parades, street dance, ‘shape shifting’ and the carnival may become
essential parts of the scenography and utilise existing, traditional
technologies of costume and musical instrument. Local customs are
important. For example, where street children sell strips of sweets
hanging in ribbons from their shoulders and have them converted into
bright and exuberant carnival costumes. Hélio Leites, as a solo street
performer and craftsman, tells epic stories including a personal adap-
tation of Romeo and Juliet, which he performed using tiny models and
finger puppets at a street market at Largo da Ordem in Curitiba. But
crucially, the challenge for scenography and its artists is to work with
the poetry of the images, the actions and the collective movements and,
not to impose a ‘theatrical’ dramaturgy or aesthetic, to bring a vision
of performance that, patronisingly, simply exploits local artistic tradi-
tions, The artist can too easily become the “big game hunter’ seeking
‘out ever moze unique and rare indigenous songs and dances. Helen
Nicholson properly cautions:
[W)hatever the cifferent values of the practitioners and participants, the
efficacy and effectiveness of the work depends on the formulation of
praxis ~ the embedded synthesis of theory and practice — rather than a
particular battery of drama strategies, forms or tachniques.*
Low or indigenous technologies may become extremely sophisticated
means of achieving community objectives, of asserting a powerful self-
sufficiency and of engaging practically with the concern for waning,resources. In Slovakia, the process and technologies of making a place
of performance adjacent to an abandoned railway station became a
public spectacle and an act of community performance. The outcome
was a permanent theatre space, but the process and act of build-
ing became a statement about ecology, resource and recycling, and
offered a spectacle of community independence and solidarity. The
performance space called $2 Stanica Cultural Centre in Zilina-Zarietie
(2009) was built from ‘recycled’ plastic beer crates donated by the
Cerna Hora brewery. These form a remarkably modern-looking exter-
nal shell placed beneath the ‘tof’ of the overhead roadway, whilst
an old stee! shipping container created the foyer and entrance. But
the walls of the performance space inside the piled-up crates were
made from bales of straw ‘puddled! in several lorry loads of local clay.
‘The theatre has been built entirely by the local community respond-
ing to desires for a place of performance, but also with a concern for
the recycled and the regenerated conservation of resources, and an
urgent need for community self-sufficiency within a climate of severe
financial stringency. $2 give the recipe for their building on the Open
Architecture website:
\What you would need if you make [it] yoursot: roof ofthe concrete bridge
in the neighborhood, 3.000 beer crates, 800 straw bales, 10 m3 of wood
and 60 OSB boards, 120 railway sleepers, 1 old shipping container, 2
lorries of mud, 12.000 nails, 1 km of screw-bars, 3.000 wood and metal
‘screws and other joining components, 120 volunteers’ hands, 5,000 vol
Untoers' hours within three months, 7.000 €....and...no need of official
permission”
‘The project was inspired by Tom Rijven, an expert in alternative archi-
tectures and building with straw bales, who worked alongside the
builders and advised on its practical construction. The unusual nature
of the building process that involved an entirely voluntary workforce
and the spectacle of the wall of beer crates and especially the daily
“puddling’ of clay into the straw became an act of extended community
performance and a playful celebration of independence, sustainable
architecture and self-sufficiency (Figure 11.4). Iti a significant exam-
ple of the way in which low-expense technologies may enable artists
to confront and respond to both local and to global issues. In this
instance, the aim was to offer a ‘fresh solution to public authorities
investing money in huge national and municipal cultural venues that
have soon after [sic] problems with money for program, because they
spend all for heating and maintaining’.
“Tdésign’. I has become transformed into a very full,
Figure 11.4. $2 Stanica Cultural Centre in Zilina-Zriedie, Slovakia (2009).
A performance space built beneath a road bridge from plastic beer crates and
straw bales puddled in mud (photograph by Jitka Sedlékoud).
_Itis evident from these examples that contemporary ‘scenography”
if no longer mere re sophisticated synonym for ‘theatye
socially engaged
Tand active ‘participant ii am extraordinary expansion of activities as
Kershaw sayss
But the extraordinary expansion of creative activites that the theatre- and
performance-orientated writings analyse, from scripted drama staged
in traditional theatres to improvised performative interventions at sites
as varied as genetically modified vegetable fields and an oil rig in
the North Sea, is especially challenging as it reflects the interna-
tional and centripetal dynamics of ecologically engaged live perfor
mance practices...So by the early twenty-first century an Interna-
tional movement of environmental and ecological creative performance
groups was emerging to span a plethora of forms, genres, aesthet-
ics, venues, locations, sites, purposes, policies and, last but not least,
pleasures.”*
Of course, the job of designing scenery, costumes, lighting and sound
for theatrical productions of plays, opera and musicals continues
throughout the world. But scenography is no longer primarily the
servant of dramatic performance; it has floated free and may create
from within its own practices and research, To this extent, it hasclearly begun to fulfil what I have called Craig’s ‘agenda’ for the
last hundred years: ‘Today they impersonate and interpret; tomor-
row they must represent and interpret; and the third day they must
create.
One might argue that scenography has become the principal
dramaturgy of performance-making - perhaps close to a direct transla~
tion of scaena and graphos ‘drawing with the scene’ ~ where all aspects
of ‘the scene’ (scenic space, embodied action, material, clothes, light
and sound) may become the materials laid out on the performance-
maker's ‘palette’. Perhaps because scenography yields no useful verb,
many contemporary artists prefer the linguistic familiarity of litera~
ture and refer to this inclusive manipulation of forms and materials
in performance-making as ‘writing’ performance, The point is that
scenography throughout its short critical life has been a remarkably
unstable concept and has proved obstinately elusive in both theory
and practice. Attempts at linguistic definition are generally reduced
to an all-embracing, and not very useful, blandness as they aspire to
express the breadth and inclusivity of the concept. We can only define
scenography through a description of what it does and how it works
within broader understandings of performance.
‘We may properly speak of scenography in the context of small-scale
site-specific performance in a landscape that uses a bare minimum
of technology and that develops a close, interactive relationship
with its audience. We can also speak of the scenography that trans-
forms a site into the location of a drama, for example, Joanna
Scotcher’s setting of The Railway Children (2010) within the aban-
doned Eurostar terminal at Waterloo railway station in London. And,
of course, as we have seen, the dystopian visions of authoritarian
government and globalised capitalism have become a distinctive qual-
ity of contemporary scenographic activism. But we can also speak
of scenographic performance in the very different context of the
multi-million-pound expenditure on high technology for large pub-
lic events of popular spectacle. This would be illustrated in Es Devlin’s
scenography for Lady Gaga’s Monster Rall world tour (2009-2011),
scribed by Gaga as ‘the first-ever pop electro opera’,” but also
where the work of a vast team of scenographers and technicians,
led by Mark Tildesley (set) and Suttirat Larlarb (costumes), deter-
mined the dramaturgy and narrative process that formed a spectacle
of national ‘community’ celebration created in Danny Boyle's open-
ing ceremony performance at the London Olympic Games 2012
(Figure 11.5).
Figure 11.5 Opening ceremony, London Olympics 2012: technology creates
the scenography for a vast spectacle of community and national celebration
(Workers’ Photos/Rex Features).
‘The online call for contributions made by editors Sodja Lotker
and Richard Gough for the journal Performance Research 18.2
“On Scenography’ (2013) reflected the very wide range and potential
inclusivity of contemporary scenographic practices in the making of
performance:
Performance consists of two actively interacting layers - ‘movement’
and ‘environment’, action and space, dramaturgy and scenography. The
interaction between the two creates the potential and possibilty for exp>-
riencing time and space within the performative act. But the boundaries
between the two are often blurry and porous. Dramaturgy becomes
scenography, and scenography is dramaturgy...Scenography 1s the
many-layered environment of a performance that oreates spatial contexts
and activates positioning, The movement of positioning (spatial and men-
tal) is a crucial aspect of contemporary performance perceived as an
‘experience and an event rather than a place for meaning or illustration.
‘Soenography is acting out the historical, architectural, cultural, dramate,
situational, lyrical, archaeological, fragmentary, political, authentic, the-
atrical, social, physical, catastrophic, psychological...and many other
dramaturgical contexts for and of the performance.A Reflection and a Conclusion
Interlude: An interval in the performance of a play; the pause
between the acts;...an interval in the course of some action or
event; an intervening time or space of a different character. To come
between, as an interlude; to interrupt.
From the Shorter Oxford Dictionary, 1973
‘Towards the beginning of this book, I suggested that Gordon Craig's
opinion was that the theatre must be restored, but that since it was cur-
rently ‘lost’, it could not be reformed — it was too late for that. Whilst
significantly expanding the definitions of theatre and performance,
the evidence of this final chapter has illustrated tremendous energy
and creativity, and particularly a passionate sense of engagement
with social and community purposes. Furthermore, these examples
sive Craig’s ‘agenda’ of impersonation moving towards representation
and leading to creation, which has been quoted on several occasions
throughout the book, an especially new resonance in the light of the
creation of new articulations of theatre and performance as well as
creativity within scenographic performance practice.
Tt may well be the case that theaue artists have taken the best part
of a century, since the revolutions of Craig and Appia, to extract them-
selves from an attitude towards theatre that perhaps ought, in reality,
to be thought of as little more than a short interlude, ‘an intervening
time or space of a different character’ within the much longer his-
tory of the anthropology of theatre and performance. Such a history
suggests that aboriginal and early forms of theatre and performance
throughout Western and non-Western cultures served as important,
and indeed vital interventions within communal life. Performance
vwas occasional ~ that is, it served the needs and purposes of an
‘occasion of some significance and importance to the community. Per-
formance served useful cultural functions within the social, religious
and political life, and places and spaces of performance (architecture
and scenography) were determined by the nature of both the occa-
sion and the relationships that existed between performers and their
audiences. Scenography included masks, marionettes, dumbshow and
pantomime, and ic involved procession, dancing, pageants, journeying
and celebration, But for @ short period ~ a mere interlude — within
this much longer history, theatre and the act of performance became
an institution, and buildings were designed and created where theatre
and plays would be commodified and ‘sold’ commercially. Although
precise dates are not important, we might suggest that this interlude
began at about the time when James Burbage built a building called
“The Theatre’ in London in 1576 and managed a company of actors
and artists who established a profession and who made theatre to earn
their living and for profit. From that time, theatre could be made what-
ever the occasion and to anyone who could pay the price of seeing
its product; and the audience began its 300-year journey towards the
passive anonymity of the darkened auditorium. The architecture that
was developed for this theatre became a commercial marketplace —
indeed, during the early period, theatres were frequently referred to as
“marketplaces of wit.
‘The introduction and the first two chapters of this book outline
some of the changing qualities of these attitudes and the resulting
scenographic practices of this theatre of the interlude, of this brief
caesura within the history of theatre and performance. These chapters
conclude with an account of the state of artistic, scenographic and
social crisis ~ the crisis of mimesis — that confronted theatre towards
the close of the nineteenth century, during the final phase of the inter-
lude when the short-lived proscenium arch defined the attitude and
practices of architecture, acting and scenography.
Perhaps, therefore, we should not think of the growth and devel-
‘opment of scenography during the twentieth century as solely repre-
senting attempts to reform theatre, Nor should we think of it as a
kind of rearguard action; a staving off of the rapid closure of theatre
buildings; a reframing and restructuring of practices necessitated by
reduced patronage and funding; a battling against perceived threats
from mediatised forms such as film, television and digital enter
ment; oF as attempts to maintain the traditional sense of a community
audience within an increasingly diverse, multicultural and globalised
world. Rather, we might, perhaps, think of the process of experiment
and change of the last century as a slow (and frequently painful) strug-
gle to rid theatre of the effects of this short interlude, or interruption in
its history, and to restore to theatre and performance something closer
to the attitudes and functions which it had maintained throughout the
greater part of its history.
The theatre of the ‘interlude’ may well be represented by Schechne-’s
‘string quartet’: a product of the humanism and capitalism of the
Renaissance that temporally displaced, disguised and hid, we might
argue, the true qualities and importance of the mainstream human
values and need for theatre and performance. The similarities between
contemporary understandings of performance, and the way they are‘manifesting themselves in the examples of new scenographic practices
that have been considered in this final chapter, and our understand-
ing of theatre history in non-Western cultures, in antiquity and in the
medieval period throughout Europe, would seem to support Craig in
his understanding of theatre history and his proposition that only
restoration is conceivable, It may well be the case, therefore, that
only with the rejection of the centrality of the ‘string quarter’, and
an acknowledgement of its place within an interlude in the history of
theatre, might there be a renaissance of belief in the communal values
and efficacy of performance and scenography: an attitude which might
ensure important and socially vital futures for theatre, performance
and technology.
Notes
Preface
1. Jacques Derrida, Archive Fever (1995), trans. Eric Prenowitz (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1998), p. 10. All quotations and references
are from this edition.
2. Ibid. p. 55.
3. John Donne, ‘A Valediction: of the booke” from Songs and Sonnets
{c.1593-1601), lines $3-4. Herbert Grierson (ed.), The Poems of Joh
Donne (London: Oxford University Press, 1933).
4, Derrida, Archive Fever (1998), p. 36.
5. I have adopted and modified this term from Bar Kershaw’s Theatre
Ecology: Environments and Performance Events (Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 2007).
Introduction
1. Lam thinking particularly of Steve Dixon's work with his company
Chameleons, and the telematic performance titled Unheimlich (2008)
that he made with Paul Serman, Andrea Zapp and Mathias Fuchs, which
linked audiences virtually with actors in both Salford, England, and
Rhode Island, USA.
Marvin Carlson, Places of Performance: The Semiotics of Theatre Arch-
tecture (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1989), p. 38.
3. Madame (Lucia) Vestris ran the Olympic Theatre in London from 1831
until 1839. Her refinement and good taste created a considerable fashion
for the extravaganzas, farces and burlesques that she produced.
4. For illustrations and discussion of these surviving theatres, see Simon
‘Tidworth, Theatres: An Architectural and Cultural History (New York:
Praeger, 1973), and Richard and Helen Leacroft, Theatre and Playbouse
(London: Methuen, 1984).
w
2458. Hans-Thies Lehmann, Postdramatic Theatre, cans, by Karen Jirs-Munby
(London and New York: Routledge, 2006), p. 17.
9. Tid. p. 86.
10, Michael Kirby, “The new theatre’, in Brooks McNamara and Jill Dolan
(eds.), The Drama Review: Thirty Years of the Avant-Garde (Ann Arbos,
‘ME University of Michigan Research Press, 1986), pp. 63-4
11, Christopher Balme, ‘Editorial’, in Theatre Research International,
vol. 29, no. 1 (March 2004), p. 1.
12, Ibid., p. 1.
13. Lehmann, Postdramatic Theatre, p. 85.
14, Mark Reaney in collaboration with the Kent Interactive Digital Design
Studio (KiDDS), at the University of Kent, July 2000.
15. Maaike Bleeker, ‘Look who's looking! Perspective and the paradox of
postdramatic subjectivity’, in Theatre Research International, vol. 29,
ro. 1 (March 2004), p. 40.
16. See Barry Smith, ‘Digital dancing and software developments’, in Steve
Dixon (ed.), Digital Performance (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2007),
pp. 183-208.
17, See Scott Palmer and Sita Popat, ‘Dancing in the streets: The sen-
suous manifold as a concept for designing experience’, in. Interna-
tional Journal of Performance Arts & Digital Media, vol. 2-3 (2007),
pp. 297-314.
18. Kershaw, The Radical in Performance, p. 6.
19. Richard Schechnes, ‘A new paradigm for theatre in the academy’, in
Drama Review, vol. 36, no. 4 (1992), p. 8.
20. Edward Gordon Craig, ‘The actor and the iiber-marionette’, p. 61.
21, Lehmann, Postdramatisches Theater, p. 288, cited in Bleeker, Look who's
looking!’ p. 31.
22. Nick Kaye, Postmodernism and Performance (London: Macmillan,
1994), p. 23.
11 Soenography as Dramaturgy of Performance
1, Richard Schechner, Performance Studies: An Introduction (New York
and London: Routledge, 2002), p. 269.
Baz Kershaw, The Radical in Performance, p. 6.
Christopher Balme, ‘Editorial’, p. 1.
Walter René Fuerst and Samuel J. Hume, Tiventieth-Century Stage Dec-
oration, 2 vols (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1929; Dover reprint, 1967),
pp. xii, xv.
5. Thave reported on some of these examples in ‘Scenography with purpose:
Activism and intervention’, in Arnold Aronson (ed.), The Disappearing
Stage: Reflections on the 2011, Prague Quadrennial (Prague: Arts &
Theatre Institure/PQ2011, 2012), pp. 36-49.
10.
1.
12.
13.
4.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
Mike Pearson, Site-Specific Performance (New York and Basingstoke:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2010), p. 13.
Stephen Di Benedetto, ‘Guiding somatic responses within performative
structures: Contemporary live art and sensorial perception’, in Sally
Banes and André Lepecki (eds.), The Senses in Performance (New York
& London: Routledge, 2007), p. 125.
Paul Ricoeur, Memory, History Forgetting, trans. by Kathleen Blarnet
and David Pellauer (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006), p. 131.
Patricio Villareal Avila, ‘Remembering ;NO®, Teatro Ojo (Prague
Quadrennial) PQ2011 exhibition leaflet.
Tleana Digguez, ‘Stages and dramas of memory’, Teatro Ojo (Prague
‘Quadrennial) PQ2011 exhibition leaflet,
Héctor Bourges Valles, ‘What I have thought about S.R-E VISITAS
GUIADAS,, Teatro OJO (Prague Quadrennial) PQ2011 exhibition
leaflet.
Ann Stoler, presentation at Johannesburg Workshop in Theory and
Criticism for 2011; see http:jhbwtc.blogspot.co.uk/2011/07/ann-stoler-
ruin-to-ruin-ruination.htm! (accessed 26 July 2012)
Quoted in Jonathan Pitches and Sita Popat (eds.), Performance
Perspectives: A Critical Introduction, (New York and Basingstoke:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2011), p. 65. In this, Scott Palmer conducts an
important interview with Louise Ann Wilson (pp. 63-74) that con-
‘tributes significantly to an appreciation of contemporary scenographic
dramacurgy.
Ibid., p. 66.
Di Benedetto, ‘Guiding somatic responses within performative struc-
tures’, p. 125.
hitpe/iwweblasttheory.co.uk/buiwork_sider_spoke.htinl (accessed 6 July
2012).
Kathleen Irwin, ‘The ambit of performativity: How site makes meaning in
site-specific performance’, PhD Dissertation, University of Art & Design,
Helsinki, 2007, pp. 10-1.
Ibid, p. 37.
Email correspondence with the author, 17 August 2011,
Marcel Duchamp (1887-1968) made a series of suitcase museums
from .1935 until shortly before his death. They contained and dis-
played miniature replicas, photographs and reproductions of works by
Duchamp, and usually one ‘original’ artwork.
Dwight Conquergood, ‘Of caravans and carnivals: Performance stud-
ies in motion’, The Drama Review vol. 39, no. 4 (Autumn 1995),
pp. 137-8.
Helen Nicholson, Applied Drama: The Gift of Theatre (New York and
Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2005), p. 56.
huepr//openarchitecturenetwork.org/projects/s2 (accessed 6 July 2012).24, Ibid.
25. Baz Kershaw, Theatre Ecology: Environments and Performance Events,
(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007), p. 28.
26. Edward Gordon Craig, The Actor and the Uber Marionette, (London:
Heinemann, 1911; Mercury Books 1962}, p. 61.
27. hetp:fen.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Monster_Ball_Tour (accessed 3 August
2012).
Further Reading
The role of scenography and the impact of technology within theatri-
cal production are referred to in many general histories of the theatre ~
although they are usually considered with a view, primarily, to gaining
a better understanding of the theatre’s contemporary dramatic litera-
ture. In addition, there are a few general histories of scenography and
a number of detailed studies of theatre architecture, There are a few
books of technical description and instruction that provide important
historical information, but there are very few books that consider the
application of specific technologies within theatre and performance.
‘The Selective Bibliography provides details of these, and specifically
includes works that have been useful to me in writing this book, and
it offers some guidance for those who wish to pursue further study
of individual artists and theatze practitioners, Since the first edition of
this book, there have appeared a number of books dealing with spe-
cific aspects of scenographic practice, for example, the intervention
of digital vechnologies in performance and site-specific performance.
In the Selective Bibliography I have indicated with an asterisk those
books to which readers may refer should they wish to pursue the
basic theme of this book ~ the fundamental synergy that lies between
theatre, scenography, technology and performance.
265