Module Propulsion and Steering
Module Propulsion and Steering
Essential competency: characterize a type of propulsion system focusing on its design peculiars
and principle of operation.
Part 1
Marine Propulsion System
"...If the wheelhouse is the brain of the ship, the engine room may be called the heart of the
ship".
W. Somerset Maugham "Mister Know-All"
Vocabulary
1 Match the words to get word combinations and enquire a monolingual dictionary for their
meaning.
marine characteristics
propulsive a ship
to propel propulsion
2 Read the definition of the word “propulsion”. Which of them are applicable to marine sphere?
a) force that creates thrust which pushes the vehicle;
b) force that propels (drives) a vehicle;
c) process of making a body to move against natural forces;
d) process of driving something into operation;
e) ability to propel.
- Watching movies
- Travelling
- Moving vehicles
- Machinery repair
- Filling of fuel tanks
- Swimming
- Taking readings
- Braking a car
- Maneuvering a ship
- Delivering pilot on board
- Carrying cargoes
- Fishing
- Transportation of passengers
4 Label the pictures of some objects. Discuss in pairs the possibility to use them for marine
propulsion.
Motor, sail, paddle wheel, propeller, thruster, pedal, oar,
controllable pitch propeller (CPP)
After the motor of our boat had failed we started to row with ____________.
When we need to maneuver the ship in port, we usually start a _______________.
A ____________is a type of fan that transmits power by converting rotational motion into thrust.
That sailing vessel was moving with grandeur in full ________.
The __________ of his bike had broken and he couldn’t ride it more.
I must dismantle the ____________ of my car and look what makes it knocking.
Reading
6 Look at the scheme of a marine propulsion system and share ideas about the function of each
its part.
Energy needed for propulsion may come from an external source (e.g. solar radiation,
air), or from a storage on board (e.g. batteries, diesel fuel, heavy fuel). Besides the energy
source, two propulsion subsystems are usually involved: an engine that transforms the energy
source (e.g. chemical, solar) into mechanical energy (e.g. to a shaft), and a thruster (or propeller)
that transforms the mechanical energy to propulsion energy.
Energy conversion devices may be classified
according to the energy source (e.g. chemical propulsion,
electrical propulsion); according to the type of engine
(e.g. internal combustion engine or electric motor);
according to the end of actuator (e.g. wheeled screw-
propelled, jet-propelled); according to the application
(e.g. railroad systems, maritime systems). But it’s clear
that the engine is the key element of any propulsion
plant.
Marine propulsion engines, located usually in the
engine room, are used to turn the ship’s propeller and move
the ship through the water, while burning diesel or heavy
fuel oil. Thrusters, located in thruster room, are operated by
electric or hydraulic motors and normally used only during
maneuvering the ship.
9 Read the text and carry out jig saw filling in the chart: student A fills in with Examples, student
B – Functions, student C – Layout.
Parts of Marine
Examples Functions Layout
Propulsion Plant
Energy sources
Engine/ Motor
Thruster/ Actuator
10 Exchange the information in pairs with your partner for filling in the chart with missing
information.
Models:
St.1: What examples of … do you know?
St.2: I know… And what is the function of …?
St.1: …
Watching/Listening
11 Label the layout of 1/ engine room, 2/ steering room and 3/ thruster room on the drawing of
the vessel given below.
13 Check your understanding of some words by matching them with synonymous structures.
giant to increase three times as much
unrivalled oversized
unique plenty of something
to triple unequal to anybody
redundancy recommendations
credentials the only in the whole world
15 Watch/ Listen the video “North Sea Giant” again. Tick the correct sentence in each line.
Writing
Grammar Spot
Passive vs. Active Voice in Present Simple
In the sentences with Present Simple Active In the sentences with Present Simple
Voice, the Subject (Noun) of a sentence usually Passive Voice, the Action (Verb) is
(often, always, sometimes, seldom…) performs usually (often, always, sometimes,
an Action (Verb) on an Object (Noun). seldom…) performed on an Object (Noun)
S + V0(s/es) + O. by the Subject (Noun).
Do/does + S + V0+O? O + is/am/are + Ved(V3) by S.
Wh + do/does + S + V0+O? Is/am/are + O + Ved(V3) by S?
Wh + is/am/are + O + Ved(V3) by S?
The ship proposes new levels of advanced New levels of advanced marine operations
marine operations. are proposed by the ship.
Does the ship propose new levels of advanced Are new levels of advanced marine
marine operations? operations proposed by the ship?
What does the ship propose new levels of What levels of advanced marine operations
advanced marine operations? are proposed by the ship?
17 Make questions to the words in italics. Pay attention to the Voice (Active or Passive).
1. Onboard facilities of the vessel include two recreation rooms, a cinema hall, online / offline
room and conference room. ___________________________________________________.
2. The vessel is equipped with two large offshore cranes. _____________________________
_____________________________________?
3. The manoeuvring system comprises two Voith Schneider forward thrusters, each of 3,800kW,
and a Rolls-Royce tunnel thruster of 2,000kW capacity. ______________________________
_________________________________________?
4. «North Sea Giant»is furnished with diesel electric propulsion systems with six General
Electric (GE) main engines, and six Leroy Somer main generators.
___________________________________________________________________________
_______________________________________________?
5. The vessel is provided with Kongsberg’s DPC21 dynamic positioning (DP) Class-3 control
system for automatic positioning. ________________________________________________
______________________________________?
Speaking
18 Use the introductory phrases to make chain story about unique propulsion system of North
Sea Giant.
19 Role play the situation in pairs: student A is the Chief Engineer of North Sea Giant, student B
– a journalist from magazine Marine Propulsion. The last interviews the Chief Engineer about
the unique propulsion system of this vessel.
Starter
a) Label the pictures of ships with names of propulsion systems types.
- human propulsion;
- wind propulsion;
- mechanical propulsion
1 2 3
b) Tick the propulsion system type, which is applicable to modern merchant ships.
Vocabulary
2 Match the paragraphs in previous activity with their main ideas. Which is odd?
a) Propulsion system design.
b) Variety of propulsion systems.
c) Fundamental provision for propulsion.
d) Energy generation.
3 Put the words on their correct places in sentences.
4 Identify three components of an ordinary mechanical propulsion system and explain their
functions.
5 Tick the pictures with energy conversion devices for mechanical propulsion systems.
Reading
8 Check your ideas while highlighting the actual requirements to marine propulsion plants.
9 Give suppositions about the best energy conversion device for a marine propulsion plant.
I think that …
has the most number of
advantages, because … But as for me, I
suppose that … has
more advantages,
because …
10 Scan the text to check your reasoning.
If to compare the weight and cost of different propulsion plants, gas turbines and multi-
machined units with middle-speed diesel engines may seem more appropriate. So, gas turbine
weights 60% less than ssslow-speed diesel engine which directly drives the propeller. Gas
turbines have other advantages like: very few maintenance costs, possibility of urgent (in 4 – 6
hours) renewal, quick readiness for operation and high capacity against very little volume.
Despite numerous advantages gas turbines have some weak sides. They burn only fine
(light) and expensive (diesel) fuel, but slow- or middle-speed diesel engine can work on heavy
fuel (it’s 60% cheaper).
Thus only on fast-speed ships (as hydrofoils and air cushions) where the use of gas turbine
is reasonable they may be applied. On the majority of ships diesel engines with greater than in gas
turbines capacity are mostly used.
Pollution is one of the biggest drawbacks of diesel engines: they’re noisy, produce a lot of
unburned soot particles, emissions of CO2, and contribute to global warming. Though their lower
running costs and longer operating life generally offsets that.
11 Read the text and in pairs fill in the chart: student A fills the information about gas turbines
and students B – about diesel engine.
Gas turbine
Diesel
engine
12 Interview your partner about missing information and complete filling in the chart. Use the
models for speaking:
- What do you know about … ?
- What is … of …?
- What’s about … of …?
- What can you say about disadvantages of … ?
13 Group work. Prepare a project in groups: group A - about Gas Turbines, group B – about
Diesel Engine. Enlighten the questions:
- Size/ weight;
- Fuel consumption;
- Capacity;
- Service and maintenance;
- Disadvantages.
Part 2
Auxiliary Machinery For Ship Propulsion
Starter
Look at the pictures of different propulsion systems, find the difference in gas and diesel engine
connection to the propeller and answer the questions:
The ______________________ is located between the prime mover (diesel engine, gas or
steam turbine, electric motor) and the propulsor (propeller, waterjet or vertical axis propeller). Its
main function is to convert or transmit mechanical energy. The ___________________ transmits
the torque (a twisting force that causes rotation) generated by the prime mover to the propulsor,
and the thrust generated by the propulsor to the ship’s hull. The _______________ _________
includes shafts, gearboxes, bearings, couplings and finally the propeller itself. There are two
types of ___________________________ used onboard:
• Direct, when the prime mover is coupled directly, through a shaft to the propulsor (this is
the case with low speed diesel engines)
• Geared: the prime mover delivers its energy through a gearbox and a shaft to the propulsor.
The function of the gearbox is to reduce the rotational speed of the engine to match the desired
rotational speed of the propulsor.
3 Match the pictures with words and definitions.
8 Make sentences, which should start with the words given below. Use the model:
The transmission system includes the thrust shaft, one or more intermediate shafts and the tail
shaft.
a) transmission system
b) thrust shaft
c) intermediate shaft
d) tail shaft
e) thrust block
f) stern tube bearing
g) intermediate shafting
h) propeller
1) The transmission system on a ship transmits power from the engine to the shaft.
2) The thrust from the propeller is transferred to the thrust block through the transmission
system.
3) The system includes the thrust shaft, only one intermediate shaft and the tail shaft.
4) The thrust block transfers the thrust from the propeller to the hold of the ship.
5) The stern tube bearing acts as a gland to prevent draining of sea water.
6) The intermediate shafting has flanges at one end only and may be increased in diameter.
Writing
Grammar Spot
Preposition at the End vs. Preposition at the Beginning
A question with an interrogative pronoun Some speakers prefer to keep the
(who(m), where, when, why, how) may have prepositional phrase together at the beginning
the preposition at the end of the clause, that is of the clause. While this placement is formal
preferred for informal, personal sphere and is good for business and academic usage.
What kind of hobbies are you interested in? In what kind of hobbies are you interested?
Where do you come from? From where do you come?
Who(m) did you give your number to? To whom did you give your number?
Which card did you pay with? With which card did you pay?
10 Practice in making questions of both types to the verbs with prepositions in italics.
12 Compare the pictures different for students A and B, using the questions of both types.
Student A
Student B
Operation and Troubles of Propulsors and Sterntube
Starter
1. 2.
Reading
1 Match the words in columns. Which of the compounds formed by you may refer to the pictures
1 and 2 from previous activity?
electric hole
ship’s the vessel
remotely gland
narrow driven
maneuvering stability
sealing controlled
Group A Group B
__________________ ______________________
Both the diesel engine and propeller are Thrusters are type of propellers. They are
very heavy: locating them both at the same generally used for maneuvering the vessel
place inside the ship would disturb the ship’s near the coastal waters at lower speeds or
stability. It is for this reason a stern tube while entering or leaving a port. Bow
along with a propeller shaft is used. The stern thrusters help in assisting tug boats in
tube is a narrow hole in the hull structure at berthing the ship without wasting time.
the rear end (aft peak) of the ship, through Generally, bow thrusters are transverse
which the propeller shaft passes and connects thrusters placed at the forward and aft end of
the engine and propeller. the ship.
The weight of the overall stern tube Bow thruster consists of an electric
arrangement, along with the stern tube motor which is mounted directly over the
bearings is carried by the stern frame and the thruster using a worm gear arrangement. If
internal framing of the ship’s hull structure at there is a change in the thrust or direction
the aft peak area. Apart from stern bearings, required, the controllable pitch blades are
the stern tube also houses water and oil adjusted. The pitch is changed with the help
sealing glands known as the stern glands. The of hydraulic oil which moves the hub on
glands prevent passing of sea water into the which the blades are mounted to change the
ship and leaking of oil from the stern bearings pitch when it is necessary to maneuver the
into the sea. ship.
A return to seawater lubricated stern The thruster is controlled from the bridge
tube bearing system is widely used on ships. and the directions are given remotely. The
The seawater is taken from the sea, pumped bow and the stern thrusters can be electric
through non-metallic shaft bearings and driven or hydraulic driven, but the most often
returns to the sea. No stern tube oil is needed. used is environmentally friendly electric
drive.
3 Scan the text and answer the questions in groups.
1. What are the functions of the device?
2. Where is it located?
3. What does it consist of?
4. What principle of operation does it have?
5 Name the main part of propeller embedding into the hull and discuss its arrangement.
6 Join the parts of words and discuss what they have in common.
delami…
…ring
…ment
misalign…
sco… …nation
7 Fill gaps with the words from previous activity.
1) ___________________ (1) takes place when surface of bearing splits apart into layers under
the tension of different stresses and in case of fatigue.
2) _______________ (2) is the damage which may happen due to accumulated small seizures
caused by wrong sliding in case of improper lubrication or severe operating conditions.
3) A condition where the propeller shaft centerlines are not parallel and intersect at an angle is
known as ____________________ (3).
8 Skim two cases and substitute the words in italics with those in a frame.
1st
2nd
11 Role play the situation with kinds of stern tube bearing damage analyzed in previous activity.
The Third Engineer will speak about the first signs of problem and reasons of damage and the
Second Engineer will speak about kinds of damage and remedies to be taken.
12 Project. Design a poster “Sterntube damage prevention” and introduce it to your groupmates.
Part 3
Combined Propulsion Systems
1 2
3 4
Vocabulary
synonyms antonyms
____________________ ____________________
_____________________ _____________________
_____________________ _____________________
_____________________ _____________________
____________________ _____________________
_______________________ ________________________
2 Use the words from previous activity to make your own definition.
3 Join capital letters in right column definitions to get abbreviations in left column and match
them.
CODAD COmbined Diesel engine Or Gas turbine
COGOG COmbined Diesel engine And Gas turbine
CONAS COmbined Steam turbine And Gas turbine
COGAS COmbined Diesel-eLectric Motor And Gas turbine
CODLOD COmbined Diesel engine And Diesel engine
COSAG COmbined Gas turbine Or Gas turbine
CODOG COmbined Diesel-eLectric motor Or Diesel engine
CODAG COmbined Nuclear plant And Steam turbine
CODLAG COmbined Gas turbine And Gas turbine
COGAG COmbined Gas turbine And Steam turbine
4 Look at the pictures and label the names of propulsion systems. Explain your choice.
3. ____________________________ 4. __________________________
5. ___________________________ 6. __________________________
5 Fill the gaps in sentences with proper abbreviations from previous activity.
1/ Two independent plants (port and starboard) diesel engines and gas turbines that are operated
alternatively according to the required propulsion power are combined in
________________-Systems. 2/ The name of diesel engine with a gas turbine combination is
________________-System. 3/ Two gas turbines for individual or common propulsion
constitute combined _______________-System. 4/ A parallel hybrid propulsion system,
which consists of a gas turbine and an electric motor, is known as _________________-
System.
6 Highlight 3-5 important characteristics of combined marine propulsion systems to prove their
necessity.
Speaking
7 Draw the draught of your combined propulsion system which satisfies to some of the following
requirements:
- high capacity;
- ecofriendly enough;
- long service life;
- low fuel consumption;
- easiness for its automation…
Speak about its principle of operation to your mates.
Hybrid Propulsion
Starter
Look at the picture below and find common to this system among those in Ex. 4. Can you
explain why this system is named a hybrid propulsion system?
A “hybrid” drive means there is more than one power source that can turn the shaft through an
electrical interconnection. There might be a combination of batteries and diesel generators, all of
which can feed their power into an electric propulsion motor.
In an ideal hybrid drive system the system automatically chooses the most efficient source of
power for a given load demand. Usually the domestic needs load and propulsion load are
connected together electrically and powered by a combination of power sources including
generators, batteries and alternative power sources.
The engine in the system runs at a constant load, which suits the vessel’s propulsion needs,
and power is sent to the propellers. But during those times when this power is not needed –
during slow-speed maneuvers, for example – the engine still produces the power, but it is banked
in an accumulator array. Then, when required, the accumulator array is drawn upon and its
power is added to the still-continuous output of the engine.
A hybrid drive is of modular design. It may have one or more diesel generators, a battery bank
and a propulsion motor. You can change out a major component of the system without disturbing
the rest.
This modular or “component architecture” nature of a hybrid drive also brings some
potentially important design flexibility. It is possible to put the components nearly anywhere on a
ship. In a hybrid drive there is no need for all the generators to be the same size.
Due to its property to combine abilities to maintain the diesel engine while running on
batteries by the diesel engine when the craft is on the surface the hybrid drive is used for
submarines.
4 Read the text and decide are the statements true or false.
1/ In hybrid drive any of components may be changed out without disturbing the rest.
2/ Modular “component architecture” of hybrid drive allows design rigidity.
3/ Domestic needs and propulsion load in hybrid drive are fully separated.
4/ When submerged the hybrid drive of submarine is run by diesel engine.
5/ The motor speed of submarine driven by hybrid drive entirely depends on the diesel engine’s
speed.
Speaking
6 Label the principal elements of hybrid drive propulsion and explain how it works.
Starter
Look at the picture and answer the questions.
Vocabulary
1 Join the words to get word compounds you see in the picture.
rudder wheel
tiller arm head
ship’s rope
rudder arm
tiller stock
2 Fill the gaps with proper word compounds from previous activity.
1. The top of the rudderpost, to which the steering apparatus may be fixed, is normally
named as ______________________.
2. ______________________ is the vertical member at the forward edge of a rudder, hinged
at the sternpost and attached to the helm or steering gear.
3. The helm, which together with the rest of the steering mechanism, is used to change the
angle of the rudder to change the direction of the ship we name also
_________________________.
4. ____________________ is a handle, which is fixed to the top of a rudderpost to serve as
a lever in steering it.
5. ___________________ is a rope, which connects the fore end of the tiller to the steering
wheel an turns it.
3 Complete the sentences about connection of the rudder to the wheel using the picture below.
a)
The total system contains such parts: a telemotor,
a control equipment, a power unit and a
transmission to the rudder stock.
The first part integrates two elements, the
transmitter and the receiver. The transmitter in a
form of wheel sends order to the receiver located in
the steering gear section through revolving the
steering wheel. The receiver sends the order to the
control unit about the desired rudder angle and
activates the power unit. The power unit provides
the force, when required, to move the rudder to that
1.______________________________ angle. The transmission in its turn accomplishes
the movement of the rudder.
b)
The main control of the steering operations is
given from the helm of any ship. The ‘control
force’ for turning is triggered off from the wheel at
the helm, which reaches the steering gear system.
The steering gear system generates a torsional
force at a certain scale which is then transmitted to
2. ____________________________ the rudder stock that turns the rudder.
c)
According to the way of operation, the steering
gear may be divided into three kinds: hand-
steering, follow-up steering and automatic steering.
Today ships or vessels have been equipped more
advanced steering gear system types: fully
hydraulic, electro-hydraulic and telemotor types.
Among them electro-hydraulic gear is the most
3. ___________________________ widely applied.
1- 2- 3-
5 Match two columns and explain your choice.
A B C D
7 Look at the pictures and use one word only to fill in gaps of the one only paragraph:
- hydraulic - telemotor
- electro-hydraulic
3. The ________________________system has the advantage that the signal from the
wheelhouse to steering flat is transmitted by electrical wires. Further, the
____________________system uses a uni-directional pump.
The pump supplies oil at a constant rate to a directional control valve, which is usually
positioned in the steering flat.
The valve has three positions, and depending on the position, will supply oil to either side
of the double acting ram. When in the neutral position, oil is locked in the ram, thus
maintaining the given rudder angle, whilst the pump flow is circulated back to the tank. In
_______________- system the valve is operated by solenoids controlled from the
wheelhouse via the control box.
In ________________________ system there is a by-pass and relief valve fitted between
the left and right sides of the ram. Emergency steering can be carried out by operating the
emergency steering lever located in the steering flat.
8 While scanning each text find the words to be filled into the columns.
10 Project. Each of three groups make sketches for presentation one of Hydraulic/ Telemotor/
Electro-Hydraulic steering gear systems, using the plan below:
- Steering gear system components;
- Principle of operation;
- Information about its reliability.
Steering Gear Operation and Troubleshooting
Starter
1. An arrangement used to convert the straight line motion of the rams into an
angular movement of the tiller is a _______________________________.
2. A pulley block that is pivoted to control linear movement of the rams to the rotary
movement to the tiller arms and rudder stocks_________________________.
3. A mechanism used to stop the engine when rudder has been turned through an
angle that corresponds to angle indicated at wheel is a __________________.
4. A vertical member of rudder, to which rudder blade is attached, is a
_________________.
Reading
c/
2 Scan the text and match its parts to the pictures explaining your choice.
1- 2- 3- 4-
3 Are the sentences below true or false? Correct the false ones.
1. The two-ram electro-hydraulic gear outer sides are linked to the tiller arm by a
crosshead only.
True False
2. The rams inside their own hydraulic cylinders are connected to a hydraulic pump with
stock.
True False
1. The pump of special axial or radial design runs continuously in the same direction
driven by an electric motor.
True False
1. The position of a movable plate or a floating ring inside the pump controls the suction
and discharge of the fuel oil.
True False
2. The plate or ring is actuated by a hunting gear which is attached at its outer end to the
control rod.
True False
3. The pump control is moved by the telemotor through a floating lever.
True False
4. The linkage through the floating lever of telemotor, pump and rudder stock forms the
swivel block.
True False
5. The rudder stock returns the pump operating rod to mid position as soon as the
helmsman stops turning the wheel.
True False
Speaking
5 Discuss the purposes of everyday checking items in steering gear. Which of these procedures
should be confirmed by the Chief Engineer or reported to the Master?
Poor maintenance led to steering failure and grounding of the Bow Singapore
On August 19, 2016, a Port Phillip Sea Pilot boarded the vessel. The pilot was to conduct
the ship through The Rip and the South Channel to an anchorage in the northern part of Port
Phillip.
As the ship neared the eastern end of the South Channel, the rudder ceased responding to
helm inputs and remained at 5° to port. The ship started swinging towards the edge of the
channel. Steering was regained a short time later but, despite the efforts of the pilot, the ship
grounded. The ship was re-floated the next day and did not sustain any hull damage.
20 Highlight the actual reason of this accident and compare with your former guesses. Discuss
the mistakes made by both Bridge and Engine departments.
A telemotor solenoid, controlling the rudder’s movement to starboard, had stopped
responding to electrical signals. The company’s procedures for a steering gear failure required a
change in operation from the bridge to local emergency operation from the steering gear room,
but no steps were taken on the bridge. Besides, planned maintenance system for the steering
gear did not include any schedules for detailed inspections or scheduled parts replacement. In
addition, the hydraulic system port and starboard solenoids were painted green and red
respectively, to match the side of the ship that each is on when mounted on the shuttle valve.
However, this was opposite to the direction the rudder would move when they were operated.
8 Be familiarized with actions of Odfjell Management to investigate this accident and offer your
plan of preventive actions to avoid it.
9 Compare you plan of preventive actions with those remedial measures provided by Odfjell
Management.
The ship managers have included a six-monthly job entry into their planned maintenance
system for the opening and inspection of the steering gear’s solenoids. In addition, the telemotor
solenoids have been repainted so that the colors now match the direction of rudder movement,
rather than the side of the ship on which they are mounted. The safety management system
procedures for steering gear change over in case of failure has been amended to ship specific
emergency.
Check Your Competency
Module 1
Marine Propulsion and Steering
The Calypso departed Tilbury Passenger Terminal at 1838 on 5 May 2006 carrying 462
passengers.
At 0330, the third engineer officer was writing up his logbook when he saw flames through the
window of the ECR. The flames appeared to be coming from between units 5 and 6 of the starboard main
engine. He immediately phoned the bridge, informed them of the fire, and asked for the engine control to
be passed to the engine room.
The third engineer brought the pitch of both controllable pitch propellers to zero, de-clutched
both engines, and then stopped them. He entered the engine room with a damp cloth over his face.
Through the increasingly smoke-filled engine room, he went down one deck and stopped the fuel oil feed
and booster pumps and closed the pump valves on the port forward side. He located his two assistants, a
motorman and engine room wiper, and they evacuated the engine room and woke the chief engineer.
Soon after the third engineer’s telephone call, the second officer, who was the OOW, called the
master, staff captain and the safety officer to inform them. The master arrived on the bridge at 0334,
followed by the staff captain and safety officer, and went to the safety room.
When they arrived in the safety room, located two decks above the ECR, they found the chief
engineer had already arrived. They all looked into the starboard engine casing from the access door.
They saw flames, which they assessed to be between two to three decks high, and reported this to the
master. The chief engineer operated the remote quick closing valves for the fuel and lube oil systems, and
the stops for the engine room ventilation fans.
At 0336, the master announced “Code Bravo” over the public address system. This was the
signal for the crew to assemble at their fire response muster stations. A number of crew mustered in the
safety room, including three fire entry teams with BA sets. Soon after this, the air conditioning engineer
was ordered to close all the ventilation flaps to the engine room. At about the same time, an attempt was
made to fight the fire with hoses. A fire entry team entered the starboard casing from the safety room.
They found it very hot and withdrew after a few minutes.
At 0341, the chief engineer made a recommendation to the master that the fixed fire-fighting CO 2
system should be used to extinguish the fire. The master agreed to this proposal after receiving
confirmation that the engine room had been evacuated.
The chief engineer instructed the chief electrician, who was in the safety room, to release the
CO2 into the engine room. The CO 2 compartment hatch was opened by the chief electrician and safety
officer, but only the chief electrician entered and climbed down a vertical ladder below the hatch
entrance where the CO2 bottles were located.
At 0347, the chief electrician opened the valves on two small bottles which he believed were the
pilot cylinders. He then operated the control levers for the engine and boiler room gas supply lines, as
directed by the posted instructions, and manually opened the distribution valves to the engine room and
boiler room. He left the CO2 room within a few minutes and informed the chief engineer that the CO 2
system had been operated. At 0350, the safety officer contacted the bridge and confirmed that the CO 2
had been released.
About 10 minutes after the operation of the CO 2 system, the chief engineer and chief electrician
donned BA sets and entered the engine room from the safety room to undertake an assessment. They
found that the fire had depleted and advised the master. At 0416, The Calypso reported to MRCC Dover
that the fire was under control, and that there were no injuries to the passengers or crew.
After the fire, an inspection of the starboard main engine quickly established that the cause of the
fire was due to a loose flange connection on the LP fuel return line from the inboard cylinder bank.
The flanges had separated because the two, 10mm, socket headed flange bolts had failed. Their
failure allowed the flanges to separate slightly, thus causing the “O” ring seal to become dislodged, and
fuel, at a pressure of up to 10 bar, to spray through the gap in the flanges.
The fuel, in both droplet and mist concentrations, would have found a number of hotspots in the
vicinity of the failed flange, such as the exhaust manifold at the inlet to the turbo charger and the turbo
charger itself. Ignition of the fuel would have occurred when a sufficient quantity of fuel to sustain
combustion had come into contact with one of these hot spots. The continuing supply of fuel from the
failed flange would have fed the fire until the third engineer stopped the fuel oil booster pump and closed
the valves in the line.
The analysis indicated that the fracture surfaces were very fine. Nevertheless, one bolt showed
some evidence of failure by fatigue.
The Wartsila technical bulletins provided relevant advice including the replacement of two bolt
flanges with four bolt flanges and other modifications aimed at dampening pressure pulses and
vibrations in the fuel supply system. The recommended modifications were not carried on The Calypso.
It is concluded that a combination of factors, primarily the fatigue failure of the securing bolts on
an LP fuel pipe flange and including a poorly fitting or loose sprayguard and the close proximity of hot
spots to cause ignition, caused the fire. If the advice contained within the Wartsila technical bulletins
had been followed, it is likely that this fire would have been avoided.
_____________________________________________________________________________
TASKS