Microprocessors and Microsystems: L. Senthil Murugan, P. Maruthupandi
Microprocessors and Microsystems: L. Senthil Murugan, P. Maruthupandi
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Switched Reluctance Motor (SRM) are widely used in drives market because of its elegant features such as
Received 25 November 2019 simple arrangement, manufacturing cost, minimal maintenance and wide speed range. Significant inves-
Revised 30 January 2020
tigation has been conducted to lengthen the feasibility of SRM drive technologies in various aspects such
Accepted 24 March 2020
as control strategy, torque ripple minimization, an optimal winding arrangement, etc. Even though it has
Available online 3 May 2020
numerous virtues, there are few noticeable issues that occur in SRM. In this paper, the issues like phase
Keywords: open circuit fault, phase-phase short circuit fault, power switch failure, dc link capacitor failure, and en-
Multi processor chip coder faults are discussed using Wavelet Transform (WT) with their experimental results. A multi-phase
Embedded (10/8 pole) SRM motor is considered to investigate the fault tolerance proficiency and other performance
Communication parameters. Initially, a healthy condition of multi-phase SRM is simulated then faults are injected at dif-
Circuits ferent phases which are analyzed and validated using MATLAB simulink tool and the same is validated
Gates
through experimental results. The performance parameters of SRM drive during various faults conditions
Drives
Fault-tolerance
are analyzed and the impacts of speed and torque are illustrated.
MATLAB simulink © 2020 Published by Elsevier B.V.
Power converter faults
Wavelet transform
SRM
1. Introduction noise and vibration of motor during operation are prime causes to
discard of the SR motor in the industrial areas. The torque ripple
In the recent past, the research in the Switched Reluctance Mo- production makes fast switching in the excitation of phase wind-
tor (SRM) plays a key measure to find an alternative to the Induc- ings and forced commutation thus fault occurs in the motor.
tion Motor (IM) drive in the industrial applications as well as in To mitigate, the torque ripple content at the output, the new
the variable speed drive market. The SRM has numerous advan- methods are proposed in the paper [6–8]. The power convert-
tages over the IM and Permanent Magnet Brush Less DC (PMBLDC) ers play a vital role in the SRM operation, the new topologies
motor due to its minimal maintenance, wide speed range, and op- are proposed to nullify the drawbacks in [9–11]. The conventional
erates in high temperature environment [1]. The adjustable speed controller and vector control techniques are used to control SRM
of single phase IM drive with reduced number of switches requires in [12,13]. The advanced controller designs and techniques such
frequent maintenance and faces power quality issues is explained as Fuzzy Logic Controller (FLC), open loop control, Artificial Neu-
in [2]. The scholars has chosen SRM with integration of charging ral Network (ANN) controllersare introduced to control the motor
capacity for hybrid electric vehicle to reducing CO2 emission in the drive in [14]. The electromagnetic energy efficient conversion of
atmosphere [3], and numerical analysis experiment in the inven- SRM motor is presented in [15].
tion of new double layer SRM drive system [4]. The fault existence possibilities in SRM drives are more than the
The drawbacks of SRM drive in the hybrid electric vehicles are other drives. Because the SR drives operation consists of high num-
noise and vibration produced by the motor. The prediction of noise ber of stages from input supply to the output. The fault detection
and control measures and vibration control of switched reluctance methods using K-means clustering algorithm that are explained in
motor are discussed in [5,6]. The torque ripple production, acoustic [16]. A new method to diagnosis the power converter faults and
flexible fault tolerance topologies are proposed to diagnosis the
fault occurrence in the system are discussed in [17,18] respectively.
∗
Corresponding author. The other fault investigation methods using rotor structure [19],
E-mail addresses: senthil2010@gmail.com (L. Senthil Murugan), pandi@gct.ac.in inter turn faults diagnosis using Space Vector Modulation (SVM)
(P. Maruthupandi).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.micpro.2020.103104
0141-9331/© 2020 Published by Elsevier B.V.
2 L. Senthil Murugan and P. Maruthupandi / Microprocessors and Microsystems 76 (2020) 103104
state response [22]. The faults in the electronic circuit system as- where Ni, represents the detail coefficients
sociated with the sensors, detects the change at circuit parameter. i represents higher frequency components
The fault from the circuit or system component can be identified An stands for approximation coefficients
using the frequency range of response. In WT, circuit parameters The signal, k, in the normal operation condition is composed
like voltage/current are decomposed into several levels and based with the average value of the DC link capacitor voltage, phase
on fault signal frequency, faults conditions will be observed. volages of SRM drive, current through diode and IGBTs with gate
L. Senthil Murugan and P. Maruthupandi / Microprocessors and Microsystems 76 (2020) 103104 3
Where, t=t1 -t0 is the conducting time The harmonics from the rectifier circuit is eliminated by the fil-
Iav is the mean value of the current ter circuit. The supreme choice of the filter circuit is capacitive fil-
Irms is the rms current through the semiconductor. ter; Cf . The lagging power factor due to the inductance property of
It is assumed that always one diode and one switch are con- the phase winding that can be compensated by the capacitive filter
ducts at the same time. Then, the conducting losses produced in (Cf ) circuit.
all n-phases of the converter are given as follows;
1
Pd (Conv) = n.(Pdiode + PSwitch ) (5) Vdc = i dt (9)
Cf
4 L. Senthil Murugan and P. Maruthupandi / Microprocessors and Microsystems 76 (2020) 103104
Table 1
Specification of proposed SRM drive.
Power Supply
Parameters Values
SR Motor Parameters
Parameters Values
Number of Phases 5
Number of Stator poles 10
Number of Rotor Poles 8
Input Voltage, Vdc 230 V
Number of switches 10
Number of diodes 10
Unaligned Inductance 0.67 mH
Aligned Inductance 23.6 mH
Reference Speed 5500 rpm
Table 2
Compared values of current, speed and torque from various fault detection using WT.
Parameter Healthycondition Freewheeling Phase-phase Short Filter faultcondition IGBT fault condition
faultcondition (phase e) condition (phase b (phase b)
&phase c)
iph (A) 12.86 A ie = −1.86 to 12.86 A ib = 15.14 A &ic = −50 Non uniform ib = 0 A
A
tav ( Nm) 12.6 Nm 12.5 Nm 11.25 Nm 9.25 Nm 8 Nm
ipeak (A) 12.86 A 12.86 A 15.14 A 16 A 13.86 A
Speed (rpm) 5500 rpm 5400 rpm 5069 rpm 4704 rpm 5084 rpm
Torque ripple(%) 37% 40% 65% 82% 40%
In a healthy condition, the phase current, iph is 12.86 A is re- SRM drive under healthy condition is NS =5500 rpm. Due to elec-
quired to attain the reference speed. In freewheeling diode fault tromagnetic torque, average T is slightly reduced by 0.1 Nm, there-
condition, diode failure occurs in the phase E. The peak of the fore the speed is also decreased by 100 rpm in freewheeling fault
phase current is almost equal to that of the healthy condition. condition.
Due to the absence of freewheeling diode, and to maintainthe In presence of some negative phase current, speed is also re-
minimum current above zero level which is not accomplished. So duced to NS =5069 rpm in phase to phase fault condition. The dc
the negative phase current in the phase E, ie = −1.86 A. link filter failure produces oscillations in the speed and reduces the
In phase to phase short circuit fault, phase B & C windings are output speed by 15%. The rotor speed in the filter fault condition
shorted. The phase current ib = 15.14 A is 17.7% increases from the is NS = 4704 rpm. The oscillatory motion of rotor produces irri-
nominal value and ic = −50 A, which is nearly 89% decrease from tating sound. Hence, this indicates the filter fault. The switching
its nominal value. fault reduces 8% of speed output and NS is measured as 5084 rpm
In dc link filter fault is the major fault, because of the rip- (Table 1).
ple content input which is not suitable for power semiconductor The output rotor speed analysis in Freewheeling Diode Fault
switches. So the phase current is non-linear and peak value ipeak is Condition, Phase - Phase Short Circuit Condition, DC Link Filter
18A. The IGBT switch fault or phase open circuit is almost identi- Fault Condition, IGBT Switching fault condition and Healthy Con-
cal. Consequently phase B switch is fault, so ib is equal to zero. The dition are shown, in the Fig. 8a–e respectively.
phase current analysis is shown, in the Figs. 6a–e respectively. The measured values of Phase Current average torque, Peak Cur-
rent and Speed for Freewheeling Diode Fault Condition, Phase -
4.6. Electromagnetic torque analysis Phase Short Circuit Condition, DC Link Filter Fault Condition, IGBT
Switching Fault Condition and Healthy Condition are presented, in
The electromagnetic torque is produced from the twisting force the Table 2.
of the rotor. The output torque also contains ripple due to fast
switching of excitation of stator phase windings. The average elec- 5. Conclusion
tromagnetic torque of one phase can be formulated as,
The fault and high temperature tolerance are the major con-
Nr v 2 θ1 − θ 1 θo f f − θ1
Tav = . dc2 θo f f − θ1 − (15) cern to choose a drive for the industrial purpose. The proposed
2π wr Lmin 2 Lmax − Lmin technique can early detect fault occurrences and to identify not
Where, Nr =Number of rotor poles. only the affected motor phase but also the faulty element. In the
The instantaneous average torque (Tav ) produced in the SRM phase current analysis, under fault condition is relatively equal to
drive under healthy condition is 12.6 Nm. Even though it is a 12.84A. From the analysis of results, phase to phase short fault
healthy system, it also produce ripple in the output torque wave- leads to more deviation in iph current. Other faults are accept-
form. In freewheeling fault, electromagnetic torque average is able to run the SRM without much loss. In the average electro-
slightly reduced to 12.5 Nm. magnetic torque analysis, all the above mentioned faults are pro-
In the presence of negative phase current, torque is reduced duced and the slight torque decreases from the healthy condition
nearer to zero periodically. In phase to phase fault condition, tav 12.6 Nm. The switching fault leads to tav of 8 Nm that decrease
torque ripple is high compared to freewheeling fault. It is because speed by 400 rpm from the reference speed. Thus, from the rotor
of the two phases malfunctions and so the average torque value speed analysis, the motor should not stop at any fault. Though, it
(Tav ) is 11.25 Nm. runs with minor reduction of speed level compared to reference
The DC link filter failure produces very high torque ripple in the speed of 5500 rpm. The overall conclusion is that, the SRM works
output and Tav is 9.25 Nm. It is very high compared to other faults with less output losses at any fault occurrence. Thereupon it is
that include the production of acoustic noise in the surrounding concluded that SRM has fault tolerance capability compared with
environment. This causes the main reason for less usage of SRM in other drives.
industrial applications. The switching fault produces 40% of torque
ripple and Tav is calculated as 8 Nm. The output electromagnetic Declaration of Competing Interest
torque analysis is shown, in the Fig. 7a–e respectively.
This paper has not communicated anywhere till this moment,
4.7. Rotor speed analysis now only it is communicated to your esteemed journal for the
publication with the knowledge of all co-authors.
The output speed of the motor is measured from the tachome-
ter in the shaft connected with the rotor. The actual speed is taken Ethical approval
from rotor position sensor and speed reference is also given as in-
put to the controller circuit. Based on speed error, motor runs con- This article does not contain any studies with human partici-
stantly in closed loop operation. The rotor speed produced in the pants or animals performed by any of the authors.
L. Senthil Murugan and P. Maruthupandi / Microprocessors and Microsystems 76 (2020) 103104 7
References [17] Y. Hu, C. Gan, W. Cao, J. Zhang, W. Li, et al., Flexible Fault-Tolerant Topology
for Switched Reluctance Motor Drives, IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 3 (6) (2016)
[1] R. Krishnan, Switched Reluctance Motor Drives: Modelling, Simulation, Analy- 4654–4668, doi:10.1109/TPEL.2015.2477165.
sis, Design and Applications.Boca Raton, CRC Press LLC, Florida, 2001. [18] N.S. Gameiro, A.J.M. Cardoso, A New Method for Power Converter Fault Diag-
[2] M. Chomat, T.A. Lipo, Adjustable-speed single-phase IM drive with reduced nosis in SRM Drives, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl. 48 (2) (2012) 653–662, doi:10.1109/
number of switches, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl. 39 (3) (2003) 819–825, doi:10.1109/ TIA.2011.2180876.
TIA.2003.811778. [19] H. Torkaman, N. Faraji, M.S. Toulabi, Influence of rotor structure on fault di-
[3] Y. Hu, X. Song, W. Cao, B. Ji, New SR drive with integrated charging capacity agnosis indices in two-phase switched reluctance motors, IEEE Trans Magn 50
for Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEVs), IEEE Trans. Indust. Electron. 61 (3) (2014), doi:10.1109/TMAG.2013.2285882.
(10) (2014) 5722–5731, doi:10.1109/TIE.2014.2304699. [20] V.S. Chandrika, A. EbenezerJeyakumar, A novel method to detect Inter turn
[4] H. Torkaman, E. Afjei, M.S. Toulabi, New double-layer-per-phase isolated shorts in SRM stator using K means Clustering and SVM classification, Int. J.
switched reluctance motor: concept, numerical analysis, and experimental Sci. Res. Publ. 4 (2) (2014) 1–6.
confirmation, IEEE Trans. Indust. Electron. 59 (2) (2012) 830–838, doi:10.1109/ [21] M.D. Hennen, M. Boesing, R.W. De Doncker, Analysis of the Fault Tolerance of a
TIE.2011.2158049. Switched Reluctance Machine with Distributed Inverter, World Electr. Vehicle
[5] W. SUN, Y. LI, G. XU, N. ZHANG, Vibration control of in-wheel SRM for elec- J. 5 (2) (2012) 482–493, doi:10.3390/wevj5020482.
tric vehicle applications, in: 43rd International Congress on Noise Control En- [22] Jianbo Gao, Fault detection of power electronic circuit using wavelet analysis
gineering, Melbourne, Australia, 2014, pp. 1–9. in modelica, in: Proceedings of the 9th International Modelica Conference, Mu-
[6] C. Lin, B. Fahimi, Prediction of acoustic noise in switched reluctance motor nich, Germany, 2012, pp. 513–522, doi:10.3384/ecp12076513.
drives, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 29 (1) (2014) 250–258, doi:10.1109/TEC.
2013.2291702. L. Senthil Murugan received the B.E degree in Electrical
[7] Suvarnasudarsanan, G. Muthuram, Torque ripple minimization in switched re- and Electronics Engineering from Park College of Engi-
luctance motor, Int. J. Adv. Sci. Tech. Res. 4 (2) (2014) 677–684. neering and Technology, Coimbatore, India, in 2006, and
[8] M.R. Tavakoli, F. Faradjizadeh, H. Torkaman, E. Afjei, Unbalanced magnetic force the M.E degree in Embedded System Technologies from
mitigation and torque ripple minimization in eccentric SRMs, in: The 5th Anna University, Coimbatore, India, in 2009. He is pursu-
Power Electronics, Drive Systems and Technologies Conference, Tehran, Iran, ing his PhD degree at Anna University Chennai, India. He
2014, pp. 591–598. is currently working as an Assistant Professor with De-
[9] S.M. Mahmoud, M.Z. El-Sherif, E.S. Abdel-Aliem, M.N.F. Nashed, Studying differ- partment of Electrical and Electronics Engineering. He is
ent types of power converters fed switched reluctance motor, Int. J. Electron. pursuing his PhD degree at Anna University Chennai, In-
Electr. Eng. 1 (4) (2013) 281–290, doi:10.12720/ijeee.1.4.281-290. dia. His current interest include Embedded Systems, Elec-
[10] H. Wang, J. Liu, J. Bao, B. Xue, A novel bearing less switched reluctance mo- tric Drives and Control.
tor with biased permanent magnet, IEEE Trans. Indust. Electron. 62 (7) (2015)
4298–4306, doi:10.1109/TIE.2014.2387799.
[11] P. Srinivas, P.V.N. Prasad, PWM control of asymmetrical converter fed switched
reluctance motor drive, in: Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering
and Computer Science, San Francisco, USA, 2013, pp. 283–288. Dr. P. Maruthupandi received the B.E degree in Electrical
[12] J. Uma, A. Jeevanandham, Conventional controller design for switched reluc- and Electronics Engineering from Government College of
tance motor drives, Int. J. Comput. Appl. 134 (7) (2013) 38–42. Engineering, Tirunelveli, India, in 1995, and the M.E de-
[13] M.R. Ab Ghani, N. Farah, M.R. Tamjis, Vector control of switched reluctance gree from College of Engineering, Guindy, Chennai, India,
motor using fuzzy logic and artificial neutral network controllers, Interna- in 2002, and Ph.D. degree from Faculty of Engineering,
tional Conference on Electrical, Electronics, and Optimization Techniques, 2016, Anna University Chennai. He has twenty four years of ex-
doi:10.1109/ICEEOT.2016.7755553. perience in teaching and research. He is currently work-
[14] S. Kurian, G.K. Nisha, Open loop control of switched reluctance motor using ing as an Assistant Professor with Department of Electri-
theta position sensing, Int. J, Innov. Sci. Eng. Technol. 1 (10) (2014) 64–68. cal Engineering, Government College of Technology, Coim-
[15] W.U. Nuwantha Fernando, M. Barnes, Electromagnetic energy conversion ef- batore, India. He has published more than forty papers in
ficiency enhancement of switched reluctance motors with zero-voltage loop national and international journals. He has attended more
current commutation, IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. 28 (3) (2013) 482–492, than thirty national and international conferences. He is
doi:10.1109/TEC.2013.2272638. a reviewer of many International reputed journals. He is
[16] V.S. Chandrika, A. Ebenezer Jeyakumar, Fault detection in switched reluctance an active member of many professional societies. His current interest include Power
motor drives using discrete wavelet transform and K-means clustering, Am. J. Electronics, Power Quality, Renewable Energy, Embedded system, Electric Drives and
Appl. Sci. 11 (3) (2014) 362–370. Control.