Mass Disaster
Mass Disaster
Literature Review
The beginning of the legal medicine, when traced in history was With the fast-developing technology, methods used in identifying
found the use of technique such as autopsy, finger print identification disaster victims should also be modified. The various modified
and odontology. Markus Rothschild said that the very first cases techniques used in identification of the disaster victims, involves
involving forensic investigation in mass disaster and identification the use of anthropological techniques, radioactive isotopic dating
of mass disaster victims, was traced in the year 1881 in Austria, at methods, dental records for identification. The use of computer
the incident that took place in the fire in the ring at the theatre of tomography has also aided the process of identification. The use of
Vienna, having around 449 people as victims. The next example of forensic radar technology is also used now a days so as to enable
the beginning of DVI was traced in the fire incident that occurred in determination of the victim beneath.
the bazar de la charite in paris, 1897, having a victim count of 126. Defining a Mass Disaster
Professor Peter Ellis [2] defined disaster victim identification, as The very basic definition of mass disaster [3] constitutes of mass
the process of initiation of the related and concerned government disaster being an event, including airways, waterways, earthquakes
authorities in the area of the disaster, may that be criminal act or a and lots more, that results or ultimately as a consequence of which
natural disaster. The proper organization of the victims, dead or alive there leads to the production of such a large number of victims, that
and retrieving the information from the victims and knowing about needs to be spotted by the authorities and are relative of medico legal
the reason for their death, and then sending the deceased to their investigation.
family members for further rituals to be conducted. The major task The next definition of mass disaster comprises of the event as
of the DVI is to protect as many victims as possible and to retrieve being a catastrophic event in which the number of deceased are more
as much information as available and reduce any further chances of than the capacity that could be handled by the local jurisdiction of that
such events. particular area. Examples of mass disasters could be “Linate aircraft
Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol - Volume 7 Issue 1 - 2020 Citation: Chauhan I, Puri P, Shukla SK. Disaster Victim Identification: A Strand that Connects to Forensics. Austin
ISSN : 2380-0801 | www.austinpublishinggroup.com J Forensic Sci Criminol. 2020; 7(1): 1082.
Chauhan et al. © All rights are reserved
Isha Chauhan Austin Publishing Group
accident” that took place on October 8, 2001. The main victims of the
disaster included people from northern Europe and Italy.
Mass disasters, when taken into account can be divided into
“Open” and “Closed” systems respectively, depending the upon the
passengers or the victim information available in hand at the time
of the disaster. It is seen that a closed system is much more easier
to manage as compared to an open system, as in this case there is a
requirement for the authorities to wait for the missing victims and the
information collection could not be done pre- hand as in the case of a
closed system, where prior information relative of the event is known
by the authorities.
Importance of Identifying the Disaster Victims
A. Identification of disaster victims [4] is an important of aspect
as it even enables the investigators to know about the modus operandi
in case of man-made disasters.
B. Establishing the personal identity of victim by matching the
post and the peri mortem records enables us to know the true identity
of the individual and then to know about the probable reason for the
disaster to have had occurred in certain cases.
C. Reconstruction of the scene of occurrence could be done, by
knowing the identity of the victim, the injuries when identified as Figure 1: Aircraft Disaster Shown Using Grid Method [22].
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol 7(1): id1082 (2020) - Page - 02
Isha Chauhan Austin Publishing Group
Figure 2: External examination being done with the help of personal effects
such as tatoo marks [23].
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol 7(1): id1082 (2020) - Page - 03
Isha Chauhan Austin Publishing Group
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol 7(1): id1082 (2020) - Page - 04
Isha Chauhan Austin Publishing Group
property log book. The items not only encountered on the victim but
also on the crime scene are to be documented and photographed and
to be placed in “E” numbered bags, this responsibility is also of the
property section.
b) Identification centre medical section contains the
responsibility of comparison of physical features of the victim
based on the AM and PM records. The basic anatomical structure is
considered in case of re arrangement of the victim, when mutilated
victims are found. Once the general observations, the matching of
the body parts should be done as to their belongingness to the same
individual.
c) The next department includes the department of dental
section that basically involves the estimation of age, habits of the
individual, search for anomaly and aids in investigation. If an ante-
mortem x-ray or dental record is present both the records can be
matched and identification of the victim could be done easily.
d) The DNA analysis department plays a major role in
identifying of the individual as it can be searched for with the relatives
of the victim with his relatives and identification could be done.
Figure 7: Division of Command under Investigator in Charge [4]. Protective gloves should be worn so that contamination need not
be done. It should be of significant concern that the sample should
identification. be collected from the least affected area, so that investigation isn’t
Methods of identification of the victims: The methods by affected.
which the identification of the victim is done, is primarily divided e) Body release section is in accordance with mortuary
into two groups, namely the primary identification and secondary section. The work of the body release is not only related to just release
identification. the body but before the release victim’s family needs to answer certain
Primary identification in the most basic terms, involves the questions as per the guidelines of INTERPOL, such as, the place where
identification of victim based on the finding of the various disciples the body needs to be sent, if the body is to be cremated locally, should
involved and the finding are usually found as the effect of the the belonging be sent to the family and in cases where approval for
disaster on the victim. Primary evidences are factor governed, such local burial of the body is given, is there any of the belonging of the
as the time since incidence took place, the extent or level of damage victim to be buried along.
caused to the victim, the changes in the condition of corpse with the Summarizing the Phases of Identifying the
delay in investigation time. Mostly DNA fingerprinting, analysis of Disaster Victim
dental records and ridge analysis are found to be the most reliable
alternatives for identification. The basic procedure followed while identifying a victim of a mass
disaster could be explained as under:
Secondary identification basically involves the personal
effects and belongings, tattoo marks, scar marks, description of • The body of the victim when found on the scene of occurrence
the victim’s clothing and the jewellery worn, medical records. All is collected and sent to the mortuary branch for further examination.
these can corroborate with the information gathered from the • The body received is entered in the dead log book with a unique
primary identification of the victim but can’t stand alone as an serial number for each and every body in order to aid identification.
individual evidence for identifying the victim. Identification through
photographs although can serve the purpose but it can’t be that it is • The victim’s body is then stored under suitable conditions so as
errorless as cases with false information collected their means is seen. to aid it’s preservation for further examination.
Both the secondary [18] and the primary data of significant • The property officer mean while searches for the personal
value and concerned area of interest should be found. The quality of effects of the victim that constitutes to the secondary identification
the ante- mortem and the post-mortem data collected needs to be method, used to corroborate with the primary identification methods
scrutinized carefully so as to obtain a reliable result. available.
Identification centers: • The records from the dental examination, medical examination,
photography unit are collected along with the AM unit for comparison
a) The identification centre property section is concerned in the reconciliation center.
with the collection and recording of the property of the victim. They
basically document each and every item collected from the victim • Once the identification is done the body is sent to the body
in the form of photographs and registering them in the victim’s release unit for further procedure.
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol 7(1): id1082 (2020) - Page - 05
Isha Chauhan Austin Publishing Group
8. Article 11 tells about the involvement of ashes in the laws The rescue mission began in around 24 hours, with the help of
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol 7(1): id1082 (2020) - Page - 06
Isha Chauhan Austin Publishing Group
the authorities from the other states and with the help of NDMA as of the explosion. Anthropological analysis cannot only enable us to
per the guidelines of INTERPOL. The first list that was released of the know the age, sex, and community of the victim but also tells us about
victims included, a missing list of 4120 people that included around the living style of the victim so as to ease investigation. Thus, in order
92 foreigners, due to the intensity of the disaster all of the victims to make a speedy investigation and reduce the chances of further
were presumed to be dead. disasters in that area, pairing of the disaster victim identification
team and the forensic analysis team can be a golden standard mark
Help from army, navy and ITBP was also taken to intensify the
to enhance the investigating capacity and to provide justice to the
rescue response so as to enable fast identification. Rescue mission
deceased as well as the living victims of the disaster.
conducted by IAF saved around 18424 people till 30 June, 2013 and
around 33009 pilgrims in corresponding 15 days. References
1. Ginther C, Issel-Tarver L & King M. Identifying individuals by sequencing
The response team had the task of collection of DNA samples and mitochondrial DNA from teeth. Nat Genet. 1992; 2: 135-138.
the removal and cremation of the dead bodies found on the scene of
2. Kolude U, B F Adeyemi, J O Taiwo, O F Sigbeku, U O Eze. The Role of
crime and to reduce any further chances of future encounter of such Forensic Dentist Following Mass Disaster. 2010; 8: 111-117.
event. Each and every body encountered on the scene of occurrence
3. Jain N. Ante Mortem Dental Records and Forensic Significance. 2013; 7:
was given a specific identification number so as to aid management 42-44.
and ease identification.
4. Andi E. Disaster Victim Identification. 2006; 2: 203-207.
Case Study 3: Haiti Earthquake
5. Catnoe C, Angelis, D and Grandi M. Mass Disaster. 2010.
Date of incidence: 12 January 2010
6. Interpol.int. Disaster Victim Identification (DVI). 2020.
Time of incidence: 02:33 am 7. Taylor & Francis. The Role of Forensic Anthropology in Disaster Victim
Identification (DVI): Recent Developments and Future Prospects. 2020.
Estimated casualty: 220000
8. Anzpaa.org.au. Disaster Victim Identification - ANZPAA Website. 2020.
Earthquake having a measure of 7.0 hit the coast of Haiti east
9. Australian Federal Police. Explaining the Disaster Victim Identification
causing a major loss to assets both including life and property on 12
Process. 2020.
January 2010. The estimated loss of life is considered to be around
220000 people. The damage caused due to the earthquake that left 10. App.college.police.uk. Disaster Victim Identification. 2020.
around 1000000 people homeless. The UN facilities in Port-Au- 11. Icmp.int. ICMP Disaster Victim Identification. 2020.
Prince were also damaged. 12. Ellis P. Modern Advances in Disaster Victim Identification. 2020.
The rescue mission began in 24 hours after the incidence occurred. 13. Kenyoninternational.com. Disaster Victim Identification. 2020.
The deceased were transported to the refrigeration units within 2 days. 14. Interpol.int. Disaster Victim Identification (DVI). 2020.
Chain of custody was prepared involving all the evidences present on
15. Valk e & pol j. Mass disaster victim identification. 2020.
the scene of occurrence. The identification of the deceased was done
through comparison of dental records, DNA analysis and fingerprint 16. 25 yrs on, an earthquake still feels like clear & present danger in Latur
villages | India News - Times of India. 2020.
records. Personal effects were also collected to aid identification.
17. Kumar p. Recent Seismological Investigations in India. 2020.
Most of the deceased except 51 victims were identified. The rest of
the deceased were buried as per the guidelines given by INTERPOL. 18. Indian Ocean tsunami of 2004 | Facts & Death Toll. 2020.
Submit your Manuscript | www.austinpublishinggroup.com Austin J Forensic Sci Criminol 7(1): id1082 (2020) - Page - 07