Joe Carr Receiving Antenna Handbook
Joe Carr Receiving Antenna Handbook
RECEIVING ANTENNA
HANDBOOK
by
Chapter 2 : 13 Chapter 4: 35
ANTENNA AND LIGHTNING TRANSMISSION LINES
PROTECTION GROUNDS Single-W ire "Downleads" 35
Why Ground an Antenna? 13 Transmission Lines 35
Ground W ires 14 Standing Wave Ratio (SWR) 40
Basic Antenna Ground System 14 Velocity Factor 40
Switched Ground System 16 Types of Transmission Lin e 41
Grounds for Vertical Antennas Installing Coaxial Connectors 44
and Towers 17 H andling and Installing
Conclusion 18 Transmission Linf'.s 47
iv .a. Receiving Antenna Handbook
Chapter 5 : 51 Chapter 7: 75
SIMPLE LONGWIRE ANTENNAS
"QUICK AND DIRTY" Single Wires, Vee Beams,
ANTENNAS Rhombics, and Beverages
Chapter 70: 13 7
DIRECTIONAL Chapter 12: 77 7
ANTENNAS LOW FREQUENCY
ANTENNAS
Rotatable Dipoles 131
Parasitic Beam Antennas 132 Obvious Solutions 172
Double Dedication
This book is dedicated to two people who helped me learn to
appreciate antennas. One is the late Johnnie Harper Throne,
K4N FU/5: a dude what knew some smoke about antennas-and
had the integrity and interest to teach others. The other is the late
Hugh T. Collins, a Voice of America radio engineer, next door
neighbor, surrogate father, and man of wisdom. H e taught me a
lot about transmitter and receiver antennas, the latter derived
from showing U.S. embassy and military personnel how to re-
ceive VOA broadcasts in posts that were truly hardship locations.
Besides his technical mentoring, Hugh also changed my life by
kicking my butt into college back in 1966-67.
ix
Erecting antennas can be a dangerous affair. is at all times. It can easily become entangled in
Every year the radio co mmunity is saddened by your feet or ladder support, and cause a serious
stories of people who were killed or seriously fall. Always work with another person so that
injured by antennas that they were erecting. The help is near at hand; if yo u're a yo ung reader,
m ost serious threat comes fro m foolish ly work with a knowledgeable adult until you are
attempting to erect a wire antenna by tossing it experienced in the antenna erection p rocess. W ire
over the AC power lines coming into the house. antennas are notoriously easy, or so it seems, to
While it may be tempting to do so, especially erect . . . but that's a fool's game from a safety
when the most convenient suppo rt structures perspecuve.
are on op posite sides of the p owe r line, this feat You also need to be careful when soldering
MUST NEVER BE ATTEMPTED! The argu- connections, particularly if yo u're using a high-
m ent that both antenna and power w ires are wattage iron. Such irons (and the molten solder)
insulated d oes not help, fo r insulation can and can cause painful burns if you're n ot careful.
does deteriorate or cu t thro ugh (and with Allow plenty of time for soldered connections to
remarkably little force). Ir is NEVER safe to do cool before touching them.
this trick, so DON'T DO IT! Please??? H ere's som e legal-type stuff High Text is
Also, keep in mind where the antenna will making me put in here:
go if it breaks and plan your installation accord-
ingly. Look aro und the yard and determin e " This book contains information that
involves electricity and requires the use
whether or not it will be capable of wind-
of tools and the possession of certain •
whipping into a power line, or if it will becom e physical abilities. Neither the publisher
a hazard on a fo ot path or sidewalk, or if it will nor the author can accept responsibility
crash into a window or vehicle (and those insu- for your use of this information or for
lators and balun coils WILL break glass when your safety. Although all information is
believed to be correct, and efforts were
wind-whipped).
made to ensure correctness, no warranty
Use properly designed factory-made insula- is made explicitly or implicitly as to its
tors, not ad hoc substitutes, for the end and completeness, correctness, or fitness for
center insulators. The rope should be sufficiently any particular application. 11
strong to h old the antenna (plus ice load if you
live in a colder climate) under all wind condi- Are you H ighText people n ow satisfied???
tions, and should be strain-relieved with a spri ng I can't possibly fo resee all possible situations,
or counterweigh t. Use good quality wire in #12 so please exercise some basic good sense when
or # 14 size. A steel core, copperclad wire-like planning, erecting, or repairing antennas. T he
that available un der the brand name of Copper- secret to successfully building and installing any
weld-intended especiall y for antennas is antenna- and having fun doing ir- is to plan
reco mmended. your efforts, take your time, watch what you're
W hen erecting the antenna, especially if doing, and double-check your work. Try it and
standing on a ladder, be aware of where the wire see for yourseln
- Joe Carr, Falls Church, VA
CHAPTER 1
Some Preliminaries
efore we can get into the nuts and bolts of using the VHF and UHF frequencies, the an-
B antenna design and construction, we need
to review some important points about radio
tenna polarization is important for maximizing
the received signal. The principal length of the
waves and signal propagation you'll need to receiver antenna is ideally oriented to match the
know to understand the material in the rest of polarization of the incoming radio wave. Cross-
this book. Some of the following may be a re- polarization-a horizontal antenna picking up a
view for you, so please feel free to skip ahead as vertically polarized wave (or vice versa)-causes
appropriate ... I won't be offended (I promise). a reduction of signal strength on the order of
about 3 dB . Since we're interested in antennas
Wavelength and Frequency for frequencies below 30 MHz, however, we
Sure, we're all fami liar with the relationship have less need to consider polarization issues
between the frequency and wavelength of a radio than VHF/UHF listeners. This is because sky
signal. But just in case you've forgotten ... wave signals below 30 MHz have scrambled
polarization due to refraction off the ionosphere.
Although there are general guidelines concern-
wavelength = 300 J ing "best" polarizations for given VHF/UHF
( frequency in MHz
frequencies, the situation over long, international
... gives the wavelength in meters for a signal of shortwave paths is not so easily defined because
a given frequency. By the way, wavelength is
often denoted by the symbol A in various radio
Antenna Rad iator
books and articles. We'll also use it in this book. Element ~
C:: : : ================
Radio Wave Polarization
Earth
T he polarization of a radio wave is defined as
the direction of the electric field (E-field). The
E-field vector has a positive and negative end,
which is measured by the effect the field has on
®
any electrons that are within the E-field. The
polarization of a wave sent from a transmitting
antenna can be deduced by looking at the con-
struction of the antenna. If the principal length
Antenna Rad iator
of the antenna is horizontal (Figure 1- l A), as it Element ~
is with many wire antennas, then the wave is
horizontally polarized. Similarly, if the principal
Earth
length is vertical (Figure 1-lB), as it is on AM
broadcasting antenna rowers, then the emitted
electromagnetic wave is vertically polarized.
®
For some receiver owners, especially those Figure 1 - 1
2 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
there are polarity shifts over the transm1ss1on Earth. Since the Earth is round, a great circle
path. Indeed, there may be multiple transmis- path is a curved line instead of a true straight
sion paths between a transmitter and receiver, line. To determine the great circle bearing from
and the two waves may arrive out of phase with your location to another, sit down with a globe
each other. . . and with differing polarities. and some string. The results can be surprising.
For example, th e shortest path from much of
Angle of Arrival the United States to Asia is not to the west; it's
A critical concept for antenna d esigners is to the north, over the North Pole.)
the angle ofarrival (AOA) of the desired signals. Figure 1-2 shows two ways that angle of
Gro und wave sign als are of little concern in this arrival can change. In Figure l-2A, we see that
respect because the only angle of arrival that the angles of arrival of three signals, from three
we must consider is the azimuth-from which different locations, are different just by virtue of
direction does ir come. Point the antenna in rhe the respective skip distances. In Figure l -2B, a
right direction, or use an azimuthal omnidirec- different situation is seen. H ere the ionosphere
tional antenna, and the signal is received. But will change during reception of a signal, and the
sky wave signals refracted back to Earth in the effective height will vary so the angle of arrival
ionosphere are different. They have nor only an at the receiver also changes. When this occurs
azimuthal angle of arrival, which is the "great fast enough, a flutter is heard. It is com mon for
circle" bearing between receiver and transmitter, ionospheric changes to occur over a period of
but also an elevation angle of arrival. (A great several minutes, especially as the band fades for
circle is the shortest path between two points on the evening.
Figure 1-2A
'
'
'
'
'
'
Figure 1-28
Some Preliminaries ... 3
to talk about a value like "6 dB " unless we know 3 dB = gain or loss of 2
the signal levels being compared. The decibel 6 dB = gain or loss of 4
can be used to express gains or losses berween 10 dB= gain or loss of 10
signal levels. 20 dB = gain or loss of 100
The decibel is based on the response of the 30 dB = gain or loss of 1000
h uman ear to changes in the loudness of a sound. 40 dB = gain or loss of 10,000
T his m eans it is a logarith mic rather than linear 50 dB =gain or loss of 100,000
term. For example, suppose the power of a trans- 60 dB =gain or loss of 1,000,000
mitter was increased from 100 watts to 200
watts. How much louder would the signal from Thus, if an antenna is said to have a 20 dB
th e transmitter sound? Common sense (and gain over another, it means that the antenna
"linear" thinking) might suggest that the signal makes the transmitted (or received) signal sound
would so und twice as loud. But that's wrong- 100 times more powerful than the antenna it is
in fact, there would be only a slight, barely being compared to.
noticeable increase in the loudness of the signal. Decibel measurements can be extremely mis-
The transmitter power would have to be in- leading if the reference antenna or p ower level
creased ten times-from 100 watts to 1000 that is being used for comparison is not clearly
watts-before the signal would so und rwice as stated. Some manufactu rers often misstate the
loud. This is how a logarithmic response works. gain claims for their antenna by using a non-
One decibel is abo ut equal to the smallest isocrop ic (or non-existent???) antenna for com-
audible change in signal level-in other wo rds, parison. T hat's why any claims fo r antenna gain
a difference that's just enough to be noticed. in an advertisement should be taken with large
Since decibels are logarithmic, seemingly minor grains of salt unless the referen ce antenna is
ch anges in the n umber of decibels used to m eas- clearly stated.
ure gain or loss can express big differences in
power levels. For example, a 10 dB gain in a Traveling Waves and Standing
signal is equivalent to increasing the power ten Waves
times. A 60 dB gain in a signal is not equal to Let's consider what happens when a wave is
increasing the power 60 times; instead, it is applied to an antenna. It doesn't matter much
equal to increasing the power 1,000,000 times! whether the antenna current is excited by a radio
You can calculate the difference between rwo transmitter or a passing electromagnetic wave;
power levels in decibels by using the following the result is pretty much the same. Take a look
fo rmula: at Figure 1-3. In Figure 1-3A, a wave is launched
onto the antenna wi re. It travels from the source
towards the other end . T his wave, called the
incident wave or fo rward wave, is an example of
a traveling wave. That is, th e wave travels from
one point to another on rhe antenna wire. When
However, m ost people just memorize some the wave hits the open opposite end of the con-
commonly used decibel levels and their equiva- ductor, it cannot go anywhere so it reverses
lent gain or loss in power. H ere are some of the direction (turning upside down, or "reversing
most com1non ones: polarity," in the process) and travels back towards
Some Prelimin aries ... 5
the source (Figure 1-3 B). This reflected wave is "standing wave" designs. A standing wave antenna
also a traveling wave but is traveling in the is n ot terminated at the far ends, away from the
opposite direction of the incident wave. receiver, so has incident and reflected compo-
The incident and reflected waves interfere n ents. A traveling wave antenna is terminated in
with each other, as do all waves that try ro a res istance so that the forward wave is absorbed
occupy the same space. The signal level at any rather than reflected. These con cepts will be
given point on the wire is the algebraic sum dealt with further later.
(added taking into consideration the polarities
of the waves) of the incident and reflected waves. Directivity, Gain,
When the waves add constructively, they reinforce and Aperture
each other, producing a maxima. Conversely, A directional antenna is one that prefers
when they add destructively they produce a min- signals from a specified direction while exclud-
ima (Figure l -3C). The location of the minima ing or severely attenuating th ose from oth er
("nodes") and maxima ("aminodes" or "loops") directions. For omnidirectional (all direction)
tends to be stationary, so the envelope of the transmitting antennas, an analogy is a spherical
combined traveling waves forms a standing wave. light bulb (Figure l-4A) that emits light in all
In the other chapters of this book, you will directions; the illumination envelope p rovided
find antennas described as "traveling wave" or is a large sphere radiating in all directions. Such
a source is called omnidirectional because it radi-
ates all directions . Bur when th e spherical lamp
_ ___~
Q_,_ _/\ __,__I_n_c_id_e_
nt_W_av~e is placed at the focal point of a parabolic reflec-
\::J . v A I
tor mirror, its rays are redirected in a single
direction (Figure l-4B) . Such a source is direc-
tional, in this case unidirectional.
A receiving antenna analogy might be a
ph otocell-an electrical component that
responds to light levels-at the focal p oint of a
Reflected parabol ic mi rror. By itself, the photoce ll
Wave ~[\ responds to light from many directions, and as a
8~========~\J==i==-
' ~·========~ result may nor have rh e sensitivity or dynamic
range to detect weak light sources in specific
B directions. But if the photocell is placed at the
focal point of a parabolic mirror, then its direc-
tion of maximum response will be as shown in
Figure l -4C.
For any given antenna the law of reciprocity
tells us that the performan ce of the antenna on
transmit and receive is the same. In our mirror
analogy, lamps and photocells placed at the focal
~ --
point of the parabolic mirror work opposite
each other as "transmitter" and "receiver,"
Figure 1-3 respectively. A transmit antenna that directs all
6 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
Preferred
Direction
© Figure 1 -4
Some Preliminaries ... 7
a very small physical area), or less as in the case Antenna Response Patterns
of a parabolic reflector used in microwave recep- One way to characterize the performance of
tion. Figure 1-7 shows the capture area of a half- an antenna is to plot its response pattern. We
wavelength (0.5 A) dipole. It consists of an ellipse can use either of two systems to plot the antenna
with major axes of0.51A and 0.34A.. pattern: polar plot or rectangular plot. Let's
consider a flashlight analogy. In Figure 1-8, a
A B unidirectional light beam emerges from the flash-
~
1 !,~-----------~
-- -------- ---- - light in a reference direction (which we label
zero degrees) . The light is brightest at 0°, and
falls off in intensity at angles greater than zero
051' Di ole
0.3'-tf-1========"'==== ====1 until total darkness is reached. This same data,
L__ _ _ _ _ _ -~-_
D_ _ __ __
- ____________ , c
----=-=-=
0.511------~
plotted in polar method in Figure 1-8, can be
plotted using rectangular coordinates as in Figure
1-9. Light intensity is plotted along the vertical
axis, while the angle is plotted along the hori-
zontal axis.
Figure 1-7
The next few figures show some representa-
tive antenna polar plots. These plots represent
the horizontal extent-that is, an azimuthal
pattern as viewed from above. (Don't forget that
each antenna also has a vertical extent, an
elevation pattern.) An omnidirectional antenna
pattern is shown in Figure 1- 10. Such an
0
- 900 _ ,.. ..-+90 antenna receives equally well from all directions.
Signals arriving with equal strength from any
point on the compass will evoke equal responses
in the receiver. An advantage of the omnidirec-
tional pattern is that stations from many loca-
t tions can be accomm odated without manually
2:1 80°
Figure 1-8
turning the antenna. A disadvantage is that
interfering signals cannot be discriminated if
they share the same operating frequen cy. Omni-
directional patterns are commonly associated
Brightest with single radiator vertical antennas.
A figure-8 antenna polar pattern in shown in
Figure 1- 11. This pattern is the type of pattern
expected from half-wavelength dipoles, certain
other horizontal antennas, some loops, and cer-
Dark Dark tain multiple radiator vertical antennas. This
- 90° +90° type of antenna has two preferred directions in
which reception is maximized. T here are also
Figure 1-9 two rej ection or "null" directions in which little
Some Preliminaries ... 9
j
A
•
1
Ma ximum
Direction
A unidirectional beam antenna pattern is We can also use the pattern to recognize
shown in Figure 1- 13. This pattern is the opposite another facet of antenna design . Note that there
of the cardioid because it has only one maxima is a main lobe in the direction of maximum
direction and all other directions are nulls. T his reception, but there are also other minor lobes
type of pattern is common ly associated with (bacl<lobe and sidelobes) . These lobes are natural
m ulti-element Yagi or quad beam anten nas, as responses of th e antenna and represent direc-
well as certain m ulti-radiator vertical antennas . tions fro m which atten uated (but non-zero)
response is possible. All antennas have these
lobes, and the job of the antenna design er is to
Direction of reduce them as far as theoretically possible.
Maximum Reception An elevation antenna pattern is shown in
Figure 1- 14; this one most nearly matches the
1 beam antenna pattern of Figure 1-13 in that it
receives in only one direction. The pattern does
not lay parallel to the ground, but rather is
elevated by an angle of radiation (a) . The angle
Main of radiation is often important wh en designing
Lobe an antenna for reception fro m particular areas of
the world, although in some cases it m ight not
be practical for receiver owners to accomplish
such a goal (it is n ot impossible, h owever) . The
reason for taking care with the elevation pattern
is that shortwave signals arrive at the receiver
site from the ionosphere at some angle. Ideally,
the response pattern of the an tenna is oriented
A co place its high est gain section dead center on
Figure 1 - 13 L Backlobe the incoming radio signal. For receiver anten-
nas, it might be prudent to call angle of radia-
tion the angle ofmaximum response (AMR).
protection. Also, your homeowners insurance (RG-8/U or RG- 11 /U) . The outer insulation,
may require such protection in order to keep the inner insulation, and center conductor are
policy in effect, especially if local codes require stripped away from the shield. Whatever type of
it. You should use a lightning protection ground wire is used it should a) be legal under local
even if your local codes and insurance regula- electrical codes and b) be a large, heavy duty
tions are silent on the matter. size.
Electrical protection is necessary because ra-
dio receivers sometimes short out internally, and Basic Antenna Ground System
that can put 110 volt AC on the chassis. If that Figure 2-1 shows the basic (and most
happens, then the radio chassis becomes electri- common) antenna ground system for lightning
cally "hot, " and very dangerous (perhaps fatally protection. A lightning arrestor is connected into
so). A good ground carries the current to Earth, the antenna downlead (or transmission line) at
blowing the fuse. some point outside of the building. A h eavy
A "good ground" also makes radios work ground wire is connected from the "ground"
better under the right circumstances, especially (GND or G) terminal on the lightning arrestor
with long wire or random length wire antennas to a ground rod driven into the ground.
(in fact, all so-called "Marconi" style antennas). T he "innards" of a typical lightning arrestor
Antenna and radio performance is improved if are shown in Figure 2-2A. The antenna lead is
the antenna system is provided with a good RF represented by a center conductor (''A") that is
ground. separated from a pointed ground lug by a small
Lightning grounds, electrical safety grounds, air gap. The air gap is an insulator at low voltages,
and RF grounds are not n ecessarily the same but when a high voltage lightning strike comes
thing. For example, a lightning ground that along, the air in the gap ionizes and creates a low
works through a lightning arresto r may be a resistance path to ground (Figure 2-2B).
reasonably good protector for lightning, but is
totally ineffective for RF or electrical protection
purposes. The idea is to design a ground system
W indow
that will work for all three functions. / ...__ Antenna downleod
Antenna
Downleod
B
Grourd Rod
To Receive r
/
Old -Fashioned
Knife Switch
Earth
Figure 2 -4
Antenna a nd Lig htning Prot ection Grounds ..- 17
246 ) Conclusion
Lfeec = ( F For an antenna to work properly and yet still
MHz
provide at least reasonable protection against
W here: L is rhe length of the radial in feet, and lightnin g strikes and electrical failures in the
Fis the frequency of resonance in megaH en z. receiver, a proper ground system is needed. No
H ere's an example: what is rhe length of a form of protection is totally foolproof, or gives
radial cut fo r a frequency of 9750 kHz (9.75 absolu te protection, but a good ground is better
MHz)? than no protection- by a long shot!
CHAPTER 3
mechanical licensing and inspection is required. Others I know (both listeners and ham operators)
People who live in townhouses have a d iffer- live in either suburban townhouses or urban
ent situation. Besides having lots that are too row houses, and for both classes their op tions
small fo r any fo rm of full size antenna in the are tighter than mine. Your own personal situa-
lower shortwave ban ds, many of these people tion will have to be assessed before any antenna
have to contend with homeowners' association selection is possible.
rules. Generally regarded as a legally binding If you own your home, then you should
covenant- th us nearly unbreakable-most such have received a copy of th e surveyor's plan e
rule books have a provision against any form of when you settled, or sho rtly thereafter. You can
outdoor anten na. Unless you can make the make a copy of the actual plane (you don't really
antenna nearly invisible to the prying eyes of the want to d raw on the original) for purposes of
homeowners' association toads, then opt for one making antenna plans fo r the sire. A ruler and a
of the indoor designs even though they are less bit of knowledge will help you plan an antenna
effective than other designs. installation that makes sense for you.
Generally speaking, the possibility of outdoor
antennas fo r apartment dwellers or o ther rental How Much Antenna Gain?
property residents is limited to nearly, but not Gain is a highly desirable attribute of any
exactly, zero. Most of these people will wan t to antenna. Gain makes the signal seem stronger
op t fo r an indoor antenna of some sort. However, th an it really is. And it's not by magic, either, fo r
all is not lost fo r many people who live in apart- a higher gain antenna will actually deliver to the
m ents. It is not unusual fo r apartment owners or receiver antenna inpu t more RF power picked
managers t0 grant permission tO erect a random up from th e airwaves than a lower gain antenna.
length wi re t0 a tree, or a dipole or oth er antenna But the matter of gain needs some consider-
on the roof. If you are on good terms with the ation, for gain costs m oney.
manager, an d can give that person reasonable O n the positive sid e: gain m eans more signal
assurances that they will not assum e any un- pick- up an d less noise (or unwanted signal) pick-
reasonable liability for grantin g you permission , up, so a better sign al-to-noise ratio is achieved .
then they might just grant it. Can't h urt t0 ask! Dollar fo r dollar, up to some unspecified but
We'll cover some approaches for apartment and flexible limit, a dollar spent on the antenna
con do dwellers later in this book. system provides better results than a dollar spent
on p reselectors and fancy receiver features. For
Site Survey ham operators, a $3000 antenna does a lot more
In the sections above we talked a bit about overall good than a $3000 linear amplifier. Thus,
the d ifferent choices for an antenna based on it might seem that antenna gain is everything.
the lot size. For the vast majority of readers, the But consider gain in another light. A gain of
installation site is a primary decision d river, and +3 dB means doubling the received power level.
cannot be overlooked. A friend of mine owned a Sounds like a lot of increase, huh? Nah , not
43 acre farmette in Texas, and was able to erect really-remember our discussion of d ecibels
just about anything he wanted (includ ing a 1250 back in C hapter 1? On some receivers 3 dB is a
foo t longwire) . My own lot is a 10,000+ square single S-unit on the S-meter, while on o ther
foot suburban mortgage trap, so my cho ices are receivers 6 dB (quadrupling the power level) is
considerably more constrained than my fri end's. required to regis ter a 1 S- un it increase. Ir's also
Real World Antennas ~ 21
true that human operators h ave difficulty distin- motors produce a "whirring" sound wh en they
guishing two reasonably strong signals that are a run. A "frying eggs" hash-like noise is produced
single S-unit apart. For example, the difference by those infernal light dimmer controls used to
in perception of two signals, one S-6 and the replace switches in houses. Some of those
other S-7, is in the decimal dust category. The dimmers are so noisy that replacing them with
3 dB, a fa 1 S-unit, difference only makes a real regular switches is the best solution. A scratchy
difference when you are searching for the really arcing noise is sometimes produced by the local
weak ones, where a signal that is 1 S-unit (3 dB) power lines if th ey are not in good repair.
above the noise floor is hearable and a weaker Perhaps th e worst offenders in the neighbor-
one is not. For listeners chasing weak DX, the hood are television receivers and video cassette
difference may be worth it, but for others it is a recorders. There are three basic problems seen.
marginal ben efit in the trade-off equation. Ir is First, if you have cable, then there is a wideband
generally held (that is, people I agree with say) coaxial cable entering your home carrying sco res
that a 20 dB difference (about 6 S-units) is of signals that raise intermodulation possibilities
required for comfortable listening if two signals to new heights of glory (or ignominy) . The cable
are present at the same time. must become "leaky" to RF befo re the problem
can occur in any large degree. You might want
Noise Considerations to get the cable company to repair the cable as a
One of the factors that can make you wonder solution. Second, th e 15734 Hz mis-shapened
why you p aid so much money for such a poorly squarish wave used in the TV horizontal deflec-
performing radio is local noise pick-up. One of tion system produces "birdies" that appear every
the most important controlling factors in radio 15.734 kHz up through the spectrum . . . even
reception is signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), the rela- into the low-band VHF region. Finally, there is
tive strength of the signal versus the "noise floor. " th e 3.58 MHz co lor oscillator used on color
Some noise is inherent in the receiver, while televisions.
other noise is inherent in the atmosphere. The Listen at that frequency on a good TV night
on-board noise created by the receiver cannot be and you may hear severe birdies at 3.58 MHz
h elped, while atmospheric noise is attenuated at and they splash a few dozen kiloHertz either
least somewhat by using a direcrional antenna side of 3.58 MHz .. .which wouldn't be so bad
with gain. T he noise problem can be quite were it not for th e fact that they appear on
complex, and is beyond the scope of this book harmonics of 3.58 MHz as well. In my neigh-
(especially since many noise problems are not borhood, I can tell from the 15.734 kHz and
helped by antenna design). But what is a matter 3.58 MHz noise in my receiver when a popular
of concern, and what you can do something TV show is on ... and if lots of p eople are taping
about, is man-made interference. That type of a movie then some freq uencies in the lower
noise can be helped by proper design and instal- shortwave bands become almost useless to me.
lation of the antenna. Antenna design and installation can make a
Man-made noise comes in a lot of different difference in suppressing these n oise sources,
forms. Sparking electrical contacts, which are especially if the antenna is directional. The null
foun d in switches and motors, will produce a in the directional antenna pattern can be aimed
static-like noise or an abrupt "pop!" (if a single at the offending noise source, reducing its over-
operation type of device, like a switch). Some all amplitude at the input of the receiver. While
22 & Receiving Antenna H andbook
that position may also attenuate desired signals received against every homeowner in the area.
from that direction, it may be a reasonable rrade- T he county board repealed the law during the
off for a specific SNR problem. next meenng.
W here you locate your antenna is a factor in Fortunately, yo u won't have to worry about
noise pick-up. For example, power line noise building permits or other legalities for most wire
tends to fall off dramatically with distance, so anten nas unless you are erecting masts or towers
placing an antenna as far away as possible will to support them. H owever, you should ch eck on
help tremendously. Keep in mind that a "safe" any local regulations pertaining to antennas just
distance from a hazards point of view might be in case. Ifyour property is covered by any restric-
too close for the SNR point of view. Avoid tive covenants dealing with antennas, these can
locating any antenna near either power lines o r usually be found in the prospectus, sales contract,
cable television wires even when hazards are not or deed for the property.
the primary concern. Save all paperwork regarding any building
permit or other written authorization you m ight
Permits and Legal Stuff need, including inspection decals or papers, and
One necessary reminder is that your local the original drawings (with the local building
government might have so m e inrerest ing inspector's stamps) . If a casualty occurs, then
ideas-legal requirements, actually-concerning your insurance company may elect to not pay
your antenn a installation. Their electrical, off if you have violated an electrical, mechanical,
mechanical, and zoning codes must be observed. building, or zon ing code. T hat clause may be
There is a great deal of similarity between local overlooked by an enthusiastic antenna builder,
codes because most of them are adaptations from but it could prove to be a costly oversight if
certain n ation al standards. Bur there are enough something happens.
differences that one needs to cons ult local
authorities. Indeed, you may need a license or Installing Antenna Masts
building permit to install the antenna in the In the absence of the side of a building, or a
first place, and it may be illegal for you to install natural antenna support such as a tree, it becomes
any antenna! Before you decide on a final design necessary to provide a support. There are three
or purchase the materials for it, make sure that ways this can be done: grow a tree; erect a tower;
you are p ermitted to install it. or erect a mast. The first alternative isn't terribly
Abou t thirty years ago, a fri end of mine in a p ractical because one would have to wait for a
radio club fo und out that his county had an decade or two before the tree was tall enough to
ordinance that said an outdoor antenna must be do you any good. T he second alternative is so
double its own height plus SO feet from the costly that only a few can afford it. T h e third
nearest property line. He received a summons alternative is wh at this section is all about.
after a complaint from a neighbor. In a county Mas ts are typically shorter than towers.
full of quarter-acre home lots, however, that was Although SO-foot telescoping masts are avail-
a ridiculous law. Very few outdoor TV antennas able, they are also a bit rare. For purposes of this
met that strict requirement! So H al went to the discussion, we will assume a maximum height
court house and asked for S0,000 complaint ofless than 30 feet. Such masts can be bought or
forms . Using a local county directory, he pro- built from a number of different m aterials.
ceeded to fill out the sam e complaint as he'd One source of metal masts is stores that sell
Real World Antennas .,.. 23
television receiver antenna parts, such as home mast sections for this type of mast, avoid the
supply d ealers and many local electronic parts cheap thin wall steel or aluminum varieties, and
distributors. Although getting rarer in this age opt instead for the thick walled steel versions.
of nearly universal cable TV wiring, TV antenna Even thin wall steel will collapse when loaded
parts are still sold in electronics catalogs. Masts too much.
and hardware are also sold by ham radio equip- Wooden masts can be built, and in the follow-
ment dealers. ing sections one such design will be discussed .
There are two basic forms of TV antenna These masts can be made to 25 or 30 feet with
mast. The most elegant (and costly) are the tele- good stability, especially if a good grade of pres-
scoping slip-up masts. T hese masts consist of sure treated lumber is used.
two, th ree, or four sections, each smaller diameter Figure 3-1 shows one method fo r installing
than the next, so that they fit inside one another. shorter masts, say up to about 15 feet high. The
When the assembly is collapsed, they will be no mast is fastened to a chain link fence post by
more than six to eight feet long, depending on U-bolts buffered wi th short pieces of "2x4"
the d esign and the final erected height. To in- lumber. The bottom end ofthe mast is anchored
stall, each mast section is raised to a certain in a concrete filled cinder block (large size pre-
heigh t, wh ere some alignment holes line up, and ferred). You can buy repair or patching cement
a steel pin is placed thro ugh both diameters to in small bags at Harry and Harriet H omeowner
help stabilize the assembly. If the mast is more hardware stores, in case you don't want to buy
than 15 to 18 feet high, then it is common an entire seven cubic yard truckful.
practice to use guy wires,
which means a guy ring
is needed to hold the
W ireS. -<~--- Woo den Mast
A less expensive TV
mast consists of several
five or ten foo t sections ~--- 2X LJ- Block
that can be joined end
to end. These mast sec-
tions are built with one French Post----'>-
end tapere d and the
other flared so that sec-
tions can be joined to-
gether. If a guy ring and
wires are used, these
'---- - - 2 XLJ- Block
masts are successful to
about 30 feet high, al-
.. ,. •'
though I am not happy :.-: .-. . .-. . .-. -<~- Co n cr ete Fil led
with them over 20 feet :': · ::::::/:::/:: Cinder BIo ck
because they tend to :'.: -.......-............
Figure 3 - 13
30 • Receiving Antenna H andbook
The final step is to solder the connections. 3-14 is not recommended because it is m echan-
The purpose of the solder is not to add mechan- ically weak and open to the weather. It is
ical strength, but to ensure the electrical connec- common to find water infiltration inro the co-
tion in the face of potential corrosion and axial cable, which deteriorates its performance.
oxidation. Use either 50/50 or 60/40 lead/tin It is better to use a regular center insulator or
resin core solder. balun transformer.
Connecting to the center insulator depends Figures 3-15 and 3-16 show both forms of
on the type of center insulator that is used. center insulators; Figure 3- 16 also represents
Figure 3- 14 shows the use of an ordinary end typical balun transformer connections. In both
insulator as a center insulator for a dipole or forms, the antenna transmission line to the
other balanced antenna. The two wire radiato rs receiver is made through th e S0-239 on the
are spliced onto the insulator in the normal center insulator, and its mating PL-259 coaxial
manner for end insulators. The coaxial cable is connector on the coax cable.
stripped such that its center insulator and con- The type of center insulato r shown in Figure
ductor are routed t0 one of the antenna radia- 3-15 uses a heavy, solid copper wire pigtails
rors, while the braid (outer conductor) is routed protruding from inside the insularor. Before be-
tO the other. Both are spliced to their respective ginning the splice, "tin" the pigtail. T hat is, heat
radiator elements. One popular method is to it with the soldering iron and spread a thin
use the pigtails left over from making the two coating of 50/50 or 60/40 lead/tin resin core
support splices as electrical connections for the solder all over each pigtail. It should look "silver
coaxial cable. plated" after it is tinned wi thout lumps of solder
In some cases, the body of the coaxial cable on the wire.
is wrapped around the center insularor and tied The antenna wire is laid alongside the copper
off with string, cord, or fishing line in order t0 pigtail, in contact with it, and is then passed
provide m echanical support for the connections. through the hole in the insulator, doubled back
If you use the "split coax" m ethod, then strain on itself, and finally wrapped around both the
relief is essential. pigtail and its own main body six to eight times.
The method of connection sh own in Figure It thus resembles an ordinary end insularor sup-
Figure 3 - 14
Real W orld Antennas T 31
Antenna
Down lead
®
Jumper
Transmission
Lines
T he subject of transmission lines can be easy
or hard, depending on how we wam to
make it. The reason is that a transmission line
Transmission Lines
Perhaps the simplest true transmission line
that we'll consider is the parallel line. Several of
can be a very complex circuit. Indeed, it is a lot the types of transmission line that are discussed
more than a simple electrical conductor to con- below are basically parallel conductor lines.
nect a load (antenna) to a source (receiver or Figure 4-1 shows the basic transmission line
transmitter). In this chapter, we will cake a prac- circuit based on a parallel conductor line. This
tical descriptive approach. If you wam a slightly type of transmission line consists of two identi-
m ore technical (read "mathematical") approach, cal conductors, parallel to each other, separated
see my other antenna book, Practical Antenna by a "dielectric" ("insulator" to us comm oners)
Handbook publish ed by TAB Books/McGraw- between the signal source and the load. In a
Hill. In this book, you will find the various transmitter, the "source" is the transmitter, while
types of transmission line described, along with the "load" is the antenna.
some inform ation on connecting th em to There are three impedances in the circuit of
receivers. Figure 4-1. First, th ere is always an internal
impedance on any device, and this is repre-
Single-Wire "Downleads" sented by resistance R5 in Figure 4-1. Second,
Certain types of antennas (Marcon i, ran- there is the load impedance, represented by RL'
dom wire, Tee, Windom, etc.) require a single which is the impedance of the antenna. Finally,
conductor "downlead" from the antenna feed- th ere is a characteristic impedance (Z0 ), also
point to the receiver. T hese antennas are the sometimes called surge impedan ce, that is an
simplest, and on some the "downlead" is not a attribute of the transmission line itself. For prac-
true transmission line. Even so, the installation tical purposes, we n eed only know a few things
advice given here also applies to those simple about characteristic impedance. First of all, we
downleads.
Transmission Line
Rs
~·c======~========~~
Signal
Source
Figure 4 - 1
36 ..t. Receiving Antenna Handbook
can rely on the so-called "naive" (because it's (see Figures 4-2D and 4-2E) .
non-mathematical) definition. T his definition is T he reflected signal is a loss to th e system. In
based on the fact that in all electrical circuits, receiver systems, the signal "source" is the anten-
antennas and transmission lines included, the na, which is excited by a passing electromagnetic
maximum power transfer between a source and wave. The signal set up in the antenna acts as if
a load occurs when the impedances are marched. it were a signal gen erator with an internal im-
That is, Z 0 is that impedance that, when the pedance equal to th e antenna's feedpoint imped-
transmission line is terminated in it, will allow ance. The load is the receiver input impedance
the maximum power transfer between the line seen across the antenna terminals. If the anten-
and the load. A proper transmission line is one na impedance, transmission line impedance, and
that has a characteristic impedance, Z 0 , that is receiver inpu t impedance are mismatched, then
equal to both the source and load impedances. there will be a loss situation where less signal
Remember: characteristic impedan ce, which is than is possible reaches the receiver.
used to o rder or make transmission line, is mere- The situation actually found in radio receiver
ly an attribute of the line. Nothing at all mysti- and transmitter antennas is shown by th e rope
cal about it! analogy in Figure 4-3. Real signals, except in
In the discussion above, I alluded to a situa- esoteric applications like radar, are continuous
tion where not all of the power is transferred to sine waves, which can be simulated by connect-
the load. Where does it go? After all, the Law of ing a rope to a hard, immovable wall, and then
Conservation of Energy is inviolable in any moving the free end up and down in an oscilla-
frame of reference no t created by a sick mind. tory manner. T h e sinusoidal incident (or for-
Figure 4-2 sh ows what happens by a li ttle gedan- ward)wave thus imparted to the rope propagates
kenexperiment (mind experiment). Figure 4-2A towards the wall, where it reflects and propa-
shows the same sort of circuit as in Figure 4-1 , gates in the opposite direction (reflected wave) .
although fo r simplicity's sake only the load end If the oscillation continues, when the forward
is shown in derail. and reflected waves combine they form a system
Suppose that the signal generator at the left of standing waves, with nodes (minima) and
end of Figure 4-2A blurts out a single pulse of anrin odes (maxima) . (You remem ber these
electrical signal energy (Figure 4-2B). Ir will be terms, don't you?) T he nodes are spaced a half-
launched onto the transm ission line and travel wavelength apart, as are the antinodes; the dis-
from the source end to the load end. W h en it tan ce b etween a node an d eith er adjacent
comes to load, different things happen under antinode is a quarter-wavelength.
different circumstances. If the load impedance, But antenna systems are not ropes on walls,
Ru happens to equal the characteristic imped- so we have to transform the analogy to the real
ance Z 0 of the line, then all of the signal is wo rld. In the case of the antenna system, the
absorbed by the load (Figure 4-2C) . In the case "rope" is the transmission line, while the oscilla-
where the load is an antenna, some of it is tion is in the form of a sine wave electrical
radiated into space as a radio signal, while some signal. Figure 4-4 shows the voltage situation as
of it is used ro make heat. But if there is an a fun ction of line length (expressed in wave-
impedance mismatch , such that ZL =F Z 0 , then lengths) for several situations. T h e current wave-
only some of the signal is absorbed by the load; form could just as easily been measured, and the
the rest of it is reflected back towards the source results would be the same. In this scheme, the
Trans mission
. L.mes • 37
Incident
Signal
Absorbed
(or radiated}
, - ------,)____- :I
I
I
I
I
Figure 4-2 I
Reflected
Wave
, Immovab le
5Surface
"
Node
Figure 4-3
38 ...,. Receiving Antenna Handbook
zero point of measurement is the load end of the along the line; no matter where you m easure it
transmission line. The length along the line is the value is the same. Such a line is said to be
measured in wavelengths, so the physical length "fl at. ))
will vary with frequency. Figures 4-4B and 4-4C show the situations
The situation in Figure 4-4A is fo r a perfect- where the line is sh orted at the load end (ZL = 0,
ly matched system in which the load and trans- Figure 4-4B) and open-circuited (ZL = 00 , Figure
mission line impedances are equal to each other 4-4C) . In both cases, the voltage varies along the
(ZL = Z 0 ) . All of th e energy senc down th e line line from zero to a maximum value, V max' but
from the generator is absorbed by the load, so th e nodes are displaced in the two cases. In the
there is no reflected wave to interfere with the case of the shorted load (Figure 4-4B) , the first
forward wave. The voltage (Vma.·) is the sam e all node is found at the 'A.J2 point, and others at
® ZL= Zo
0
0
I
Load
End Wavelength Along Line
Vmax
Z=O
(Shorted)
0
0
I
Load
End Wavelength Along Line
Figure 4-4
Transmission Lines "' 39
integer multiples of /.../2 (N/.../2) thereafter. In voltage along the line will vary from an antinode
the case where the line is open-circuited (Figure maxima (VmaJ tO a node minima (Vmin) at
4-4C), the first node occurs at the /.../4 point, half-wavelength intervals along the line. The
and others are spaced half-wavelength apart first minima occurs at the load end, while the
down the line from there. T he location of the subsequem minima (nodes) are spaced half-
nodes is often used in troubleshooting faulty wavelength apart from there. The first thing to
antenna transmission lines to determine whether note is that the minima voltages are not zero,
they are open or shorted. but have som e non-zero value. This situation
In most healthy antennas, if the line isn't flat indicates a line that is mismatched, but is n either
it will resemble Figure 4-4D. In this case, the open nor shorted.
Ymax
© z =00
L
(open)
0 1--~~~~--+~~~~~+-~~~~~-1--~~~~-t-~
0
I
Load
End Wavelength Along Line
v
Ymox - - --- - .....
-:::.;-,...___- -:....::- - - - -- -- - --- -- -- -_;.
-~~:....::- -- ---- - - -- - --.
0
I
Load
End Wavelength Along Line
Figure 4 -4
40 • Receiving A ntenna H a ndbook
VSWR =(Vm~)
vmm
The o ther legitimate way is to use an antenna
tuning unit, or matching network, that trans-
forms a complex impedance to a resis tive
impedance equal to the feedline impedance.
The VSWR (or SWR) can also be deter-
Some people- who don't know any better but
mined by looking at the ratio of load and char-
acteristic impedances, a rranging th em to should-erroneously th ink that you can adjust
produce a positive n umber of one or greater the SWR by adj us ting the transmission line
length. This error derives from two false pre-
(1 .2: 1 is valid, 0.8: 1 is no t):
mises: fi rst, the fact that it appears so because of
faults in the simplest forms of VSWR meter
+ Parallel Conductor
Transmission Line
Z 0 = 276 log (2:J
Parallel conductor transmission lines consist Where:
of two wires, run parallel to each other, and Z 0 is the characteristic imp edance in ohms
separated by air (which serves as the dielectric) Sis the center-to-center spacing between
as in Figure 4-5. As a result of having an air conductors
dielectric, the velocity factor of the parallel line d is the diameter of th e conductors (assum-
is typically close enough to 1.0 that it is rated at ing both conductors are identical)
0 .999 or 1.0. Wire sizes typically used are # 12 [Both Sand d are in th e same units.]
down to #22, and much of the time the
wire is uninsulated (however, enamel or
formvar insulation is probably a goo d
idea). In practice, the wires are held ap art a
constant distance S by plastic, ceramic or
Spacer
other insulators; these insulators are often (Insulator)
called spacers in honor of the fact that their
main function is to maintain a cons tant
separation between the two wires.
The characteristic impedan ce of the
parallel wire transmission line is set by the
center-to-center spacing between the con-
ductors (S), and the diameter of the wire
used for the conductors. Typical values of
impedance for parallel line run from about
250 Q to 1200 Q , with 400 , 450, 500,
600, and 800 Q being the most commonly
encountered (you can match these values
with antenna feed requirements). I am
going to give you the equation for figuring
out the impedance because it's a facto r Figure 4 -5
42 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
T he diameters of common AWG wire sizes, this type of spacer is to maintain the center-to-
n eeded for "d " in the equation above, are as center spacing while increasing the electrical
follows: pathway taken by leakage currents that flow on
Wire Size d the surface of the spacer. Both conraminants
10 0.101 9 and rain water can seriously reduce the normally
12 0.0808 very high electrical resistance, and this effect is
14 0.06408 lessened by using the U-shaped spacer design.
16 0.05082
18 0.04030 + Twin-Lead Transmission Line
20 0.03196 Twin-lead transm ission line (Figure 4-6) is a
22 0.02535 special variety of parallel line that uses a plastic
material as the dielectric separating the conduc-
Parallel line is typically made using solid tors rather than air. Because the plastic is dielec-
wire conductors, although som e is seen using trically different from air, the velocity factor
stranded wires. Care must always be taken in of twin-lead is lower than for parallel line.
handling parallel line to avoid kinking it, for the Typically, twin-lead has a velocity factor around
kinks become permanent immediately on occur- 0.82.
rence. The problem is that these discontinuities Twin-lead comes in two main varieties. The
mess up the impedance and create a glitch in the 300 .Q twin-lead (Figure 4-6A) is designed for
SWR exhibited by the line. televisio n antenna installations. Early TV anten-
In some cases, yo u may build yo ur own par- nas used folded dipole driven elements and re-
allel line from a spool of wire and a collection of quired an impedance close to 300 .Q for proper
spacer insulators. While the store-bought vari- matching. As a result, the low cost transmission
ety has spacers molded onto the
wire, the homebrew variety typi-
cally uses spacers that are a slip fit @
at bes t. In order to secure the spac-
er along the line, a jumper arrange- 300.n TV -Type
m ent as show n in inset "A" to
Figure 4-5 is used . The two main
conductors are passed through the
holes in th e spacer, and a short @
piece of wire is spliced such that it
mechanically bridges the spacer.
The purpose is not electrical con- Lf-50.n
n ection , but rath er mechanical
stren gth.
T he spacers used in parallel line
~Hollow
will be either straight, as in the
main illustration of Figure 4-5, or ©
will be U-shaped as shown in insert
"B" to Figure 4-5. The purpose of Figure 4-6
Transmission Lines ...,. 43
Alchough che large diameter types are some- connector is another matter- it is relacively easy
whac lower loss cables than the small diameters, to install besides not being readily available al-
the principal advantage of the larger cable is in ready mounted.
power handling capability. While this is an Figure 4-9 shows the PL-259 coaxial con-
important factor for ham radio operators, it is nector disassembled. Also shown in Figure 4-9
totally unimportant to SWLs. Unless there is a is the diameter reducing adapter that makes the
long run (well over 100 feet) where cumulative connector suitable for use with smaller cables.
losses become important, then it is usually more Without the adapter, the PL-259 connector is
practical on receiver antennas to opt for the used for RG-8/U and RG-11 /U coaxial cable.
small di amece r (RG-58/U and RG -59/U ) With the correct adapter, it will be used with
cables-they are a lot easier to handle. The tiny smaller RG-58/U or RG-59/ U cables (different
diameter RG- 17 4 is sometimes used on receiver adapters are needed for each type).
antennas, buc its principal use seems to be con- The first step is to slip the adapter and
n eccion becween devices (such as the receiver threaded outer sh ell of the PL-259 over the end
and either a preselector or antenna tuning unic),
in balun and coaxial phase shifcers, and in instru-
mentacion applications.
of the cable. (You will be surprised at how many terribly cost effective for anyone wh o doesn't do
times the connector is installed, only to find this stuff for a living. You can do just as effective
that one of these components is still sitting on a job with a scalpel or hobby knife (like the kind
the workbench ... requiring the whole job to be sold under the "X-acto" name), either of which
redone.) If the cable is short enough that these can be bought at hobby stores and some elec-
components are likely to fall off the other end, tronics parts stores. Follow these steps in prepar-
or if the cable is dangling particularly long dis- ing the cable:
tance, then it might be wise to trap the adapter
and outer shell in a knotted loop of wire (note: 1. Make a circumscribed cut around the
the knot should not be so tight as to kink the body of th e cable %-inch from the end,
cable) . and then make a longitudinal cut from
The second step is to prepare the coaxial the first cut to the end (Figure 4-1 OA).
cable. There are a number of tools for stripping
coaxial cable, but they are expensive and not 2. Now strip the outer insulation from th e
coax, exposing the shield-
ed outer conductor, as
shown in Figure 4-lOB.
S---- X- acto knife or scalpel 3. Using a small pointed
tool, carefully unbraid
th e shield. Be sure to
separate th e strands
making up the shield.
®
r- f----1"--
Lay it back over the out-
er insulation, out of th e
circumscr ibed cul way.
r- s5"
I ~
I conductor and 3/s-inch
of inner insulation ex-
posed, and the outer
© shield "de-stranded" and
laid back over th e outer
insulation.
Figure 4-10
46 .&. Receiving Antenna Handbook
Handling and Installing the roof (use overhanging portions). Getting the
Transmission Lines transmission line inside the house is a bit of a
Transmission lines are relatively simple to trick. If you have brick or masonry walls, then a
use, but do require some care in handling. Some hole can be drilled in th e wall at an appropriate
general rules or guidelines are: place. A h amm er and star bit can be used (for
those who like hard manual labor). Most people
1. For all types of transmission line, you would prefer to use a tungsten carbide masonry
want to avo id extremely sharp bends and kinks. bit on a slow-speed electric drill to make the
Those kinks will inevitably cause a VSWR dis- hole. Be sure to wear goggles when doing this
continuity, and reduce the performance of the job, for dust and chips fly about and are danger-
antenna. ous to your eyes.
On brick walls, make th e entrance hole in
2. If it is necessary to route the mortar line between bricks, for it's a
transmission line around a corner, lot easier than drilling through brick.
then make the turn over a gentle arc Note that old brick and mortar
with about one foot radius or more. which has been weathered for
:·:> many years becomes extremely
3. Avoid, wherever possible, .-::·1'---11--- Wa 11 hard-so hard, in fact, that
running transmission lines close to ~-::- you might wan t to consider
m etallic objects such as gutter an alternate route into the
1 ~..111(--- Cable
downspouts. Of course, don't even building. I've worn out
~Standoff
THINK of running them close to several carbide mason-
power lines! ......
ry bits on a single in-
:.'· Insu lators st allation whe re
4. Run the rransm1ss1on line
along a wall, floor, or roof using
stand-off insulators (Figure 4- 14).
These insulators consist of a screw-
eye end with a plastic center insula-
tor plug. There are several types, all
originally made for the TV antenna
and cable TV industries, and they
differ in the manner of fastening:
machine screw, wood screw, and
case hardened masonry nail types
are all readily available. Most peo-
ple will use the wood screw or ma-
sonry nail types for outside walls or
roofs. Care should be taken on roof
installations to not penetrate inside
the roof; otherwise, a water wicking
situation will exist and it could rot Figure 4-14
48 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
100-year old reused brick was used to build the block. Once the center line is marked, split the
house, and the mortar line was too th in to cut distance to either edge and drill at that point (it
into effectively. should be right in the center of the block, if the
Cinder block walls are used on a lot of houses, block was built normally). Keep in mind that an
and even brick houses frequently have cinder extra long bit is needed for drillin g through
blocks in the basement and for a few feet above most cinder blocks (eight to 14 inches thick,
the surface. Cinder block is usually built with depending on the block) .
two hollow chambers (see Figure 4-15), one on There is a right way and a wrong way to
either side of the center line. The best place to install cable at the wall entrance site. Figure
drill the hole is in these chambers. To find an 4-15 shows both ways. The wrong way is to
appropriate spot, first find the center line of the bring the cable in from above, and then pass it
._
o. · .· .· . ·. . o·
. · . ·. ·. ·. :.· through the wall. T he problem is that water
runs down the cable and into the hole .
Even if the hole was waterproofed
Wood frame and siding houses (like mine) "I rent my house, and the landlady is a real
are even easier to install a transmission line in. {expletive deleted} and won't let me drill a %-inch
My h ouse is like millions of other h ouses built hole in the side of h er {expletive deleted} house."
in the post-war period (that's World War II, for There is a way our, other than just doing and
you kids who don't remember it). It has a cinder paying the consequences. Figure 4- 17 shows a
block basement that extends about two feet method that I used on several occasions. You
above grade. A 2x4 heel plate supports the sys- can fashion a flat piece of wood planking (l x6
tem of 2x4 studs that frames the house. The works nicely, as do narrower widths) to fit under
inside of rhe frame is covered with dry wall, rhe moving part of rhe window. Ar least one
while the outside is covered with plywood friend of mine used a 4-inch high metal panel
sheathing and aluminum siding (some houses intended for a rack mount for this purpose.
use vinyl siding). This method of construction is Coaxial barrel connectors, stand-off feedrhrough
shown in cross section in Figure 4-16. insulators and other connectors can be mounted
In some houses, like mine, there is a ten inch on the wood panel to pass antenna wires into
space between the top of the cinder block, which the house. The connectors and the top, bo ttom
is two fee t above grade, and the heel plate, and and side edges of the panel should be caulked
this space is occupied by the floor joists fo r the against the weather. In addition, some means
first floor above the basem ent. I am able to drill must be found to secure the window to prevent
holes in this sp ace to the outside, and that is DSBGs (dirty, sm elly, bad guys) from burglariz-
where my antenna transmission lines pass into ing the place via an open window (besides steal-
the h ouse. Alternatively, as shown in Figure ing the family silver, your pistol, hunting rifle
4- 16, a fist sized (or smaller) square hole can be and yo ur kilobuck radio , they will likely also
cut in th e dry wall in an unobtrusive spot to damage the antenna wire).
accommodate locating the cable. In either
case, you can either pass the cable
directly into the h ouse, or use ..... ... ..... . .
...
...... ··::.(
a double ended female co- .
. . ..
)
.. . .
axial "barrel" connecto r, as .... ..... ·.
.. ,• :. :::.,...· r----Plywood Sheathing
shown. These connecto rs ) ·.:·
are threaded over their en-
) ....
tire cylindrical body so ' ·.·..
:• ..:·
that a pair of h ex nuts can Hole in
~ Coax Barrel
be used to secure the con- Wall~ Connector
n ector to the wall. I've
) ·.'·
found ir wise to caulk or ) ....
...... ........ ) -.: . ,
silicone seal the hex nut . . .. .
. .. .. ~ Siding
against water wicking. Of .·-.....·...... ) ·"
course, a drip loop is es- Drywa l1 - ---- : :. : : :_.: : ;.' .:·.
:· .·.
sential. . .. .. ·.'·
.. .. . ..
)
Insulated
Down lead ~
Lightning
EI= End Insulator Arrestor
R=Rope Support Ground /
Wire
Receiver
Ground ~
Connection
Figure 5 - 1
52 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
all localities. The antenna wire should be well Nature does what it must so no guarantees) .
clear of the support structure, so use at least five Even if the house does catch fire, your insurance
feet of rope an d more if needed. For well filled- is m ore likely to pay off if an app roved lightning
out trees, the antenna wire should be entirely arrestor is used in the circuit. Another factor is
clear of the leafy crown of the tree so that no that local electrical codes migh t require a ligh t-
physical interference (and therefore potential ning arrestor, so use it!
damage) or signal loss occurs. T he ground con nection is n ecessary fo r the
The signal is carried to the radio receiver by antenna to reach its bes t performance. Som e
a downlead. T he downlead consists of a length shortwave receiver manuals recommend a cold
of insulated wire of # 14 to #22 size. It must be water pipe as the ground . I don't think th ey
insulated, even though the antenna wire need make very good gro unds today now that cold
not be insulated, fo r both safety reasons and to water pipes are typically made of polyvinylchlo-
prevent signal loss by accidental grounding. Make ride (PVC) or som e other plastic m aterial. Even
sure that the downlead doesn't touch anything if you have metal pipes, it is usually p referable to
metallic or the gro und even if it is insulated. use an eigh t-foo t copperclad steel ground rod
The rando m length antenna can be erected driven into the Earth so that only a few inches
at alm ost any angle, from sloping downward to show. T he ground wire from the receiver and
straight up in the air (in which case it is a the lightning arrestor should be as heavy as
vertical). The best perfo rmance will be seen if possible (but for different reasons).
the antenna wire is horizontal to the ground and T he random length antenna is a good basic
is as high as practical. 20 to 30 feet seems to be a antenn a, but doesn't perform as well as some of
p ractical height for many SWLs, and it works the other antennas foun d in this book. Use it if
just fine . .. 100 feet is better, but isn't terribly you please, but realize that other alternatives
practical. After all, if you can afford a 100-foo t exist.
tower, you can afford a better antenna!
The random length antenna wo rks best if The "Tee" or
the wire is run in a single direction so there are "Top Hat" Antenna
no bends in the wire as it runs fro m one support T he Tee antenna shown in Figure 5-2 is a
to another. If you m ust bend the wire, however, reason ably pop ular version that is related to the
this can be don e with minimum violence to its random length antenna of Figure 5- 1. Like the
performance. Don't overdo it, however. Keep at random length anten na, it is untuned and non-
least 50% of the length in one direction and reson ant. It differs from the random length
have no more than two bends. antenna in that a portion of the downlead is
Many people simply run the downlead into used as a vertical antenna section. T he vertical
the house, directly to the radio receiver, without section should be ten to 30 feet long, and runs
going through a lightning arrestor. T hat may be at a right angle dow n from the antenna wire.
quick 'n' dirty, but it's also dumb. Lightning The rest of the downlead can be routed as con-
strikes are not very likely, but if they com e the venient for your particular case.
arrestor will divert a large portion of it to One popular way to make a Tee antenna is
groun d. The lightning arrestor may save the to place the downlead connection directly over
receiver (no guarantees, however), and is likely the point on the house where the receiver is
to prevent the house from catching fire (again, located (or where the wire goes in to the h ouse) .
Simple "Q uick and Dirty" Antennas .... 53
EI Radiator Element
W indow
Down lead
. . _ _ _. D
0[]
Solder
Copper
Foil
To
RCVR
Figure 5-4
A problem sometimes seen on longwire sistor across the lightning arrestor because the
antennas is static electricity build-up. The arrestor makes a decent mounting support for
electricity comes from local fields, including the resistor. Use a value of resistance between
distant lightning, and other physical phenom- 200 kilohms and 2 megohms. However, in
enon. It can reach scores of dozens of kilo- consuucting the resistor use at least ten 2-watt
volts, and can seriously damage the input resisto rs in series; i.e., for a 1 megohm resistor
circuitry of the receiver (even though not use ten 100 kilohm, 2-watt resistors conn ected
generally harmful to humans, unless you're in series. The reason for this is to prevent the
startled by the shock and fall off your ladder). static electricity from arcing over the resis-
The solution to this problem is to place a tor ... we want to drain it off, not zap it to
resistor (Rl in Figure 5-4) between the ground ground (Yes, Virginia, resistors have voltage
and the downlead. Many people place the re- ratings).
56 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
A more conventional means of passing a The window doesn't quite close all the way
single wire downlead through the window is when the flat strap is used (despite what the
shown in Figure 5-5. The conductor through installation instructions say) . If you live in a
the window is an insulated flat strap (available cold region of the country, then you might
where antenna supplies are sold) that fits be- want to either use a different approach or be
neath the movable part of the window and the sure to seal the window. I found that the adhe-
window sill. Ir will mold into the channel that sive-backed foam weather strippin g sold at Har-
receives the moving part. T he window is then ry and Harriet Homeowner do-it-yourself
dropped down onto th e flat strap. stores works well. One type is round, and will
mold directly to the window sill and sash (see
inset in Figure 5-5) .
Downleod ~
Wo ll
Ground Wire ~
Adhesive Bocked
/ Weather Strip
Figure 5 - 5
CHAPTER 6
ular rece1v1ng I
antennas is their
utter simplicity.
Just take a bit of
Maximum
Reception
'
. . Direction
wu e, some insu-
lators, a 1:1 balun
coil (if you want
to do it right),
a nd you' re in I
business! ' Z
I C
'=
Fi gure 6 - 1
58 .-. Receiving Antenna Handbook
effects." In free space (that is, many wavelengths T he radiator element is broken into two
above the Earth's surface) the factor "468" be- portions, each of which are half the length found
comes 492. by the equation above, or a quarter-wavelength
Let's look at a real-world example. Suppose long. The ends of the wires are tied off to a rope
we want a dipole cut to a frequency of 11 750 mechanical support via ceramic, glass, or plastic
kHz with an overall length of L and the length end insulators (EI in Figure 6-2) . The feedpoint,
of each element A. The solution is found by: where the line to the receiver is connected, is the
center of the antenna where the two quarter-
468 wavelength radiator elements are supported by a
Lfeet = = 39. 83 feet center insulator or 1: 1 balun transformer.
11. 750
Dipole
Length "A" is one-half of Lfeer or
Radiation Patterns
39 83 Figure 6-1 shows the conventional "figure-8"
· = 19.92 feet pattern normally associated with dipole anten-
2
nas. This pattern is azimuthal- that is, as viewed
from above. It consists of two main lobes along
The fac tor ".92" feet can be converted to the same maxima axis, with low-reception nulls
inches by multiplying it by 12, that is: 0.92 inch along an axis at right angles to the main lobes.
x 12 = 11.04 inches "" 11 inches. Thus, the The main lobes represent the directions of maxi-
antenna is made of two wire elements, each mum reception signal stren gth (when pointed at
being 19 feet and 11 inches long. a transmitting station), while the nulls represent
L
1-- 1: 1 --1
BALUN
75ohm
Coaxial
Cable 2.
EI= End Insu lat or
Coax To R= Rope Support
RCVR L FT =Lj. 68 I FMHZ
Figure 6-2
A=~LFT
The Dipole and Its Relatives ..,. 59
points of minimum signal strength. the pattern from the ideal of Figure 6-3C is
The pattern of Figure 6- 1 is actually only a due to reflections from the Earth's surface
partial view. It represents only the horizontal immediately below the antenna combining
cut. Real antenn as have a three dimensional with the radiated signal.
radiation p attern with both vertical and hori-
zontal extents. Figure 6-3 shows the three di-
mensional pattern (Figure 6-3A) relative to the Azimuthal Pattern
antenna axis. The horizontal figure-8 pattern is (seen from above)
shown at Figure 6-3B, while the vertical
extent for a perfect dipole in free space is
shown in Figure 6-3C.
The vertical extent radiation pattern
is a function of the distance of the anten- Antenna
Axis
na above ground. The version shown in
Figure 6-3C is for a perfect, free space
dipole. If th e antenna is less than a quar-
ter-wavelength above groun d, the pattern
will be highly distorted. The variation of
~-,--~~
----- --- - --------~-----
I
I @
Vert ical
Elevation Antenna Axis
Pattern
(Side View)
Many
Wave lengths
© ®
Ground Su rfoce
Figure 6 - 3
60 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
Dipole
Feedpoint Impedance
Earth Dipole
When a dipole is electrically excited,
either by a transmitter at the feedpoint or
by an intercepted radio wave, an electricai
current flows in th e radiator. This current
oscillates back and forth at the transmitted
Figure 6 -4
frequency. Neither the current (I) nor the
voltage (V) are constant over
th e entire length of the radi-
ator element. Figure 6-5
- 2500ohms shows the distribution of
(end)
voltage (dotted line) and
current (thin so lid line)
along the len gth of the half-
wavelengrh radiator. These
Feed point two elements (V an d I) are
related to the impedance by
v - - --- the ratio V/I. Note that the
voltage crosses a minimum
and current rises to a maxi-
~_._=---~~~~~---=""-=-- 75ohms
(cente r ) mum at the feedpoint. Be-
ca use the feedpoi n t is
located in the middle of the
half-wavelength dipole, we
can conclude that the dipole
is a current fed, rather than
Figure 6-5 voltage fed, antenna.
The D ip ole and Its Relatives T 61
110
100
90
[jJ 80
E
....c
_Q
CJ
70
u
c
.s 60
(/)
-i]j
CJ
er: 50
c
0
+:3
0
'+0
-0
0
er: 30
20
10
0
0
Height of Dipole Above Ground
Figure 6-6 (Wavelengths)
We can also note that the impedance drops ter operators, they are also important for you if
to a minimum at the feedpoint, and rises to you want to maximize the effectiveness of your
about 2500 Q at the ends. In an ideal dipole in antenna system.
free space-or so far above the ground and away Coaxial cable is used as the transmission line
from other objects as to simulate free space- between the dipole and the receiver; one end of
the feedpoint impedance is close to 73 Q. As a the antenna is connected to the center conduc-
result, such a dipole makes a good match to 75 tor of the coax, while the other end of the anten-
Q coaxial cable. Unfortunately, the situation is na is connected to the outer shield of the coax.
not so simple in real life. Figure 6-6 shows that T h e coaxial cable makes a good impedance
the actual impedance is a function of the dis- match for most practical dipoles. In general,
tance of the antenna above the Earth's surface. RG-59/U, RG- 11/U, or some other 75 Q coax-
The impedance is close to the ideal 73 Q only at ial cable is used for the transmission line. For
intervals of a quarter-wavelength until the an- receiver antennas, the smaller sized RG-59/U
tenna is so far above ground that the impedance cable is suitable (hams sometimes have to use
variations converge to the ideal point. While th e larger size cable because of the high power
these facts are of more importance to transmit- level of th eir transmitters) .
62 ..t.. Receiving An tenna H andbook
I
Rope & 1----,,---rrll----..11-~-"IF~~t-rr.:::.......::-~-,-,lrr-1-~I~ Rope
11
~
Radiato~r nsu lat<x
Line
Figure 6 -8 A B c
The 300 Q feedline to the receiver is not a toothbrushes (don't laugh, it worked!). Each
good match to the 50 Q output impedance used insulator is secured in place by a tie wire made
by most equipment sold today. In addition, this of the same wire stock as the antenn a radiator
transmission line is balanced, while the standard (Inset A in Figure 6-8). The tie wires are twisted
receiver antenna input is unbalanced (designed and then soldered.
for coaxial cable). T he folded dipole made with Th e feedpoint of the wire folded dipole
either twin-lead or parallel transmission line (Inset B in Figure 6-8) is insulated with a stan-
sh ould be connected to the receiver through an dard antenna center insulator (which are easily
antenna tuner (usually a good idea for any an- available everywhere). The feedline is 300 Q
tenna) that is eq uipped with a balanced output parallel transmission line, and it is connected to
in addition to the normal unbalanced or coaxial the radiator between the center insulator and
cable output. These tuners have an internal 4: 1 the strain relief winding. T he latter winding is
impedance ratio balun ("balanced unbalanced") made by looping a "tail" through the insulator,
transformer. and around the radiator wire (back on itself),
The folded dipole shown in Figure 6-8 uses wrapping it around the radiator four or five
a more traditional method of construction ("pre- times. Both the electrical connection from the
twin-lead") . Many experienced people prefer this transmission line and strain relief wrapping are
method to the twin-lead method. The radiator soldered.
element is made from # 12 or # 14 stranded cop- The end insulator is sim ilarly handled (Inset
p er wire. The wires are spread four to six inches C in Figure 6-8) . A spreader insulator at each
by using spreader insulators ("I" in Figure 6-8) end is wired in the n ormal way (Figure 6-8,
every five feet or so. The best insulators are the Inset A), but the ends of th e radiator are twisted
ceramic types that are made for the purpose, but together in a normal insulator for support by a
these are hard to come by these days except at rope. If yo u use regular parallel wire antenna
hamfests. Alternatives include segm ents of PVC insulators, then it is possible to buy a type with a
plumbing pipe, plastic, plexiglass, or even old hole in the center. If these are used, then the
64 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
support insulator can be eliminated, and the feedpoint impedance, this antenna can be fed
rope attached to the center hole. As with all from 75 Q. coaxial cable.
antenna connections, the end connections and Using a balun transformer at the feedpoint
tie wires should be twisted tightly together and also helps the an tenna pattern by balancing the
then soldered. currents in the two halves of the radiator. That
W hen the antenna radiator elements are nice pattern in Figure 6-1 is idealized for a per-
identical sizes, and the spacing is fo ur to six fect antenna. In practical antennas, it can get
inch es, then the impedance transfo rmation is quite ragged, but with a balun at the feedpoin t
4:1, as for antenna folded dipole. O ther values it comes much closer to the ideal.
(from 0. 1: 1 to 16: 1) can be achieved by varying
the spacing and respective conducto r diameters.
(See The ARRI Antenna Book for design graphs Solving THE BIG PROBLEM on
and equations if you're interested. If yo u use the Twin-Lead Folded Dipoles
15th edition, look on p age 2-33 .) As early as 1960, I learned the hard way that
th ere is a major p roblem with rwin-lead folded
d ipoles. Because twin-lead uses # 16 or # 18 wire,
Alternate Feed and it is typically soft-drawn copper rather than
Using a Balun copper clad steel, these antenn as break a lot. A
An alternate method of feeding a folded di- little wind, or a bit of ice, and piooop.'The an-
pole is shown in Figure 6-9. In this system , a 4: 1 ten na breaks and falls to the gro und . Sometimes
balun transformer is connected directly to the old fas hioned metal fatigue causes these anten-
feedpoint, transforming the impedance to a value nas to simply drop to rhe ground. Regardless of
fo ur times lower than the natural impedance the mechan ism, however, the result is the same:
(:::::: 300 Q./75 Q.). As a result of transforming the you're out of business until repairs are made.
~ stLGN
75 IL
Coaxial ' - _ PL-259 ''UHF''
Cable Coo xia I Connector
4
Figure 6 -9
The Dipole and Its Relatives ,, 65
Support
~,,Hole Rope
11
Radiator 5"
x8
1
A A A A
~
Figure 6 - 1 0
As a sad-faced teenager I told my m entor, at one end for the support rope (both ends for
the late "Mac" Parker (W4II), of the problem. a feedpoint insulator) . In order to prevent
He ch uckled, and then drew out a little cracking, the %-inch hole should be at leas t its
drawing .. . which was somewhat like Figure own diameter away from any edge.
6-10. The end insulators (shown here) and the The twin-lead is prepared by using a drill,
center insulator are made from 1.4-inch plexi- leather punch , or ordinary paper hole punch
glass, Lucite, or other form of strong, noncon- to cut holes into the twin-lead. Pass th e end of
ductive plastic material. A pair of 'A-inch slots, the twin-lead across the from side of the insu-
about two inches apart, are cut into the center. lator, through the first slot, across the back
It is easy to make these slots by starting with a side of the insulator to the other slot, and
'A-inch drill, making a hole at either end of the through this slot back to the front side. The
slot-to-be, and then removing the material be- twin-lead is fasten ed to the insulator block
t\.veen them with a rat tail file. A series of five using nylon (NOT metal) machine screws and
screw holes are made at the points indicated. If hex nuts. It might be useful to use a second
#6 screws are anticipated, then drill 5/32-inch nut on each screw, tighten it, and then super-
holes ('A- inch for #8) . A %-inch h ole is drilled glue it in place.
66 ...,. Receiving Antenna Handboo k
"
,(Coax To
RCVR
_.s-Mast
Stake Stake
Earth
Figure 6 - 11
The Dipole and Its Relatives ,.. 67
Figure 6- 14 shows three possible methods insulators work best. In Figure 6- l 4A the coil is
fo r connecting the loading inductor to the an- a standard cylindrical "solenoid wound" coil
tenna. In each case, the coil is supported by an (meaning it has a length greater than its dia-
insulator of the sort used for the end and center mete r). The co il is sometimes connected exactly
insulators. Usually, the shorter versions of the as shown, while in other cases (where the coil is
larger diameter) the insulator passes coaxially
through the center of the coil. Figure 6- I 4B
Co il shows the same type of mounting for a coil
wound on a toroidal core; Figure 6- I 4C is
similar bur uses a larger size toroid that can be
slipped over the insulator.
A pair of commercial dipole loading coils are
A shown in Figure 6- 15. These coils appear to be
made from PVC pipe stock with a PVC cap on
either end. The coil is made from insulated wire
wound in the space between the end caps. These
are available from a variety of ham radio and
electronics parts sources.
r D- 9.8
-FNHz
one foot . T hus, the overall
p hysical length, counting the
two element length s and h alf of
b o th spread er len gths, is
[2 x 23.4 feet - (2 x 0. 5)] foot,
or 45.8 feet. If the angle of
6'
6' mounting is 30°, then the an-
tenna fo rms the hypotenuse of
Figure 6 - 16
a 60/30 righ t triangle. If we al-
low six feet for the lower sup-
port, then the upper support is:
The spread (D ) of the antenna wire elements
is fo und from: H eight = 6 + L C os 8
9 .8 = 6 + (45.8 C os 30) = 45.7 feet
D feet = F
MHz
T his anten na has a low angle of radiation, and at
T he spreaders are preferably ceramic, strong a tilt angle of 30° (considered ideal) it is n early
p lastic, or thick-walled PVC pipe. T he spreaders omnidirectional.
can be made of wood (lx2 stock or 1-inch dowels) T he termination resistor can be mounted on
for receive antennas if the wood is properly var- a small piece of plastic, or alternatively as shown
nished against the weather. in Figure 6- 17, it can be stretched across the end
T he overall length of the antenna is calculat- insulator in the manner of th e inductors in the
ed a little differently from most antennas. We previous section. Use a 390 Q , 2-watt resistor
need to calculate the lengths from the feedp oint fo r this application.
to the middle of the spreaders, which is also the
length from the m iddle of th e sp readers and the
terminating resistor. These lengths (A l -B, A2-B,
C l -D and C2- D) are fo und fro m: Resist or
L _ 164, 000
feet - F
kHz
Wideband and Multiband Hertz. For example, if the one dipole (Al/A2) is
Dipole Antennas cut for 25 MHz, and the other for 26 MHz, the
T he dipole is reasonably wideband for re- length difference is only about 8.6 inches.
ceiving applications, but "wideband" normally Keep in mind that all dipoles are already
means scores of kiloHertz above and below the "multiband" antennas, provided that the other
resonant frequency. At frequencies removed bands are odd h armonics of the half-wavelength
from this range, however, the antenna is less natural frequency. Thus, an antenna cut for a
effective and acts much like a random wire an- half-wavelength on 4500 kHz, is also a 3_4-wave-
tenna. Let's look at two methods of "wideband- length resonant antenna for 3 x 45 00 kHz, or
ing" a dipole. 13500 kHz. The two-lobe "figure-8" pattern of
First, the method of Figure 6-18 is basically the half-wavelength dipole splits into four dis-
two dipoles connected to the same feedline, but tin ct lobes, so the antenna is not as directional
tuned to slightly different frequencies. At th e on the higher frequency.
higher end of the HF spectrum , only a few The simplest, most straightforward method of
inches difference in physical length are needed multibanding a dipole is to connect several dipoles
to wideband the antenna several hundred kilo- to the same feedline, as shown in Figure 6-19.
I: I
Al BALUN A2 EI R
Bl B2
Coaxial Cable
ToRCVR 2. Figure 6-18
Coaxial Cable
ToRCVR
4
Figure 6 - 19
The Dipole and Its Relatives ... 71
Each dipole has a low impedance near its half- parallel LC tuned circuit is that it offers a high
wavelength resonant frequen cy, and a h igh impedance at its resonant frequency bur a very
impedance at other frequencies. T he antennas low impedance to all other frequencies. Such a
can be harmonically related to each other only if trap might offer an impedance of 20,000 nor
th e even harmonics are used (third harmonics so to the resonant frequency and a low imped-
are already resonant-see above) . ance ( < 100 .Q) at all other frequencies. Thus,
Use the usual formula for a standard dipole for a high frequency, the sections marked "A" in
to determine the physical length of each antenna. Figure 6-20 are used; the trap isolates th e rest of
Like any dipole, the formulas are only approxi- the antenna length for those frequencies. Each
mate, and some means for tuning the antenna ''A" section represents a quarter-wavelength ele-
are necessary for maximum efficiency. Each an- ment of a half-wavelength antenna.
tenna is independent, so make the calculation At a lower frequency, the trap is not a factor
for each band of interest. so the resonant frequency is determined by the
Some people use a single multiconductor lengths consisting of A+ B for each quarter-wave-
cable to form the dipole sections. For example, length section. The resonant frequency is also
electric cord (two conductors), antenna rotor affected by the inductor of the trap, and follows
wire (four or five conductors), and computer rules approximating those of the loaded trap
flat cable (up to 100 conductors!) have all been dipole in the previous section. Typically, for any
used for multiband dipoles. These wires are, given resonant frequency, the antenna will be
however, weaker than regular antenna wire and 68 to 75% of the non-trap physical length given
antennas built with chem will most likely have a earlier by the standard dipole equation.
greater failure rate than regular antennas. A little "cur and try" experimentation will
result in a resonant antenna. In gen eral, the best
advice is co adjust the length of the highest
Trap Dipoles frequency sections ("A") first, and then work
One approach to building a multiband di- out m sequence.
pole antenn a is to use resonant traps in a single Figure 6-21 shows a commercially available
wire dipole, as shown in Figure 6-20. Each crap trap for shortwave antennas. Although it is rela-
is a parallel resonant inductor (L)-capaciror (C) tively easy to design and build antenna traps fo r
tuned circuit. One of the properties of the receiving antennas, they are also relatively low in
72 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
Balun
Transformers
As we noted earlier, the word balun is
actually an acronym made from the first sylla-
bles of balanced and unbalanced. A true balun
transformer will convert a balanced load into
an unbalanced load, such as from a balanced
dipole to an unbalanced coaxial cable trans-
mission line. The balun may, or may not, pro-
vide impedance transformation depending on
the design. Two common impedance ratios are
1: 1 and 4: 1. The 1: 1 balun transformer is
typically used with conventional single-wire
dipoles fed with 75 Q coaxial cable, while the
4: 1 are used with folded dipoles or elsewhere
if a 4: 1 or 1:4 impedance transformation is
Figure 6-21 needed (they are bidirectional and can be used
"backwards").
The typical balun today is wound on a
cost and readily available from suppliers of ferrite toroidal core, although air core and fer-
radio antenna goods. rite rod solenoid wound (cylindrical) are also
Figure 6-22 shows a long multiband trap possible. Figure 6-23A shows the basic toroi-
antenna that is usable for a large number of dal balun, Figure 6-23B shows th e solenoid
bands. Each trap (Tl, T2, T3) is resonant on version, and Figure 6-23C the "bazooka'' style.
successively lower frequencies. Otherwise, the For receiving antennas, the FT-37 and FT-50
antenna is very similar to the trap dipole of sizes are adequate. Typically, for the 3 to 30
Figure 6-20. MHz high frequency (a.k.a. HF) range, use
Coaxia l Cable)
To RCVR ~
Figure 6-22
The Dipole and Its Relatives .... 7 3
® ®
Figure 6 - 23
©
six turns on the CF- 123 or ten turns on the trifilar wound, on a single core. This type of
FT 200-6 1 (they have different permeability transformer is used on ordinary dipoles which
values), of # 12 or # 14 enameled or formvar provide a 75 Q load, and are fed with 75 Q
coated solid wire. coaxial cable (such as RG-59/U or RG-11/U) .
Each transformer is either bifilar or uifilar W hy would anyone want a 1: 1 balun trans-
wound. T hat is, each turn consists of two or former? The reason is simple, especially wh en
three wires wound close together, dep ending on one looks at the antenna patterns produced by
the design. Some builders twist the wires conventional dipoles with and without a balun
together in a drill mandrel, but I don't transformer at the feedpoint. The idealized
recommend this practice because it is both dan- figure-8 pattern that is normal fo r a dipole is
gerous and does not work as well as the flat distorted by radiation caused by currents flowing
winding schemes. o n the outside con ductor of the coaxial cable.
The pattern of windin gs is shown in Fig- Ideally, this current is geometrically balanced by
ure 6-24 fo r three differen t cases: 111 , 4/ 1, and currents flowing in the opposite direction in the
50 Q /75 Q. T h e balu n co il shown in inner conductor, but that ideal is rarely achieved.
Figure 6-24A provides balanced to unbalanced T he problem is alleviated by the 1: 1 balun
transformation, but the impedance transfor- transfo rmer, and the pattern res tored to very
mation is 1: 1. Note th at it uses three windings, near the ideal.
74 .a.. Receiving Antenna Handbook
R
Unbalanced
_c--(9) • •
R
Unbalanced
~
LtR
Balanced Balanced
Figure 6 - 24 ®
A 4: I balun transformer is shown in Figure
6-24B. This transformer uses two bifilar wound
windings ever a single core. T his is the type of
balun that will convert the 300 Q impedance of
the folded dipole to the 75 Q impedance of
coaxial cable.
Both of the balun transformers shown in
• Figure 6-24A and Figure 6-24B are broadband
RF transformers, and will cover a wide range of
impedan ces. For example, the I: I transformer
can also work with 52 Q coax, while the 4: I
• transformer will convert the 200 Q impedance
(_,_. .
o_2 of certain loop antennas to 50 Q for coax input.
~-~8(/) T he balun transformer of Figure 6-24C is a
f----1J1 little different. It will match 75 Q loads to 50 Q
transmission line. It uses two silvered mica
capacitors for frequency compensation. Note
that the number of turns for coil L l is one-half
the number of turns for L2 and L3 (3 turns and
6 turns fo r C F- 123 forms, and 5 turns/ I 0 tu rns
for FT-200-6 1 fo rms). This winding protocol
differs from the other baluns where all windings
have the same number of turns.
CHAPTER 7
Longwire Antennas
Single Wires, Vee Beams, Rhombics,
and Beverages
popularity with receiver owners is due to several addition, there is a related class of antennas
different factors. One factor is that it provides called Beverage or wave antennas. We will
gain and directivity at certain harmonically re- discuss all of these antennas in this chapter.
lated frequencies (and in one version on non-
h armonic frequencies). With the possible
exception of odd multiples of a quarter-wave- Resonant Single Wire
length, at other frequencies the antenna acts like Longwire Antennas
a very long random length wire antenna. Another Let's first take a look at the simple untermi-
receiver advantage is that its very long length nated resonant (a.k.a. "p eriodic") longwire an-
provides a very large aperture, so the amount of tenna made from a single wire radiato r.
signal energy captured is also large. Interestingly enough, although the longwire an-
There is also the matter of the angle of radia- tenna looks terribly Marconian-like an anten-
tion and reception (ARR or a ). DX antennas na that is tuned against ground-it is actually
need low, horizon-kissing angles. A longwire that Hertzian when the physical length is more than
is installed ~ /..,/2 from the ground will exhibit two wavelengths (~ 2/..,).
values of a of 10 to 15°. A fundamental form of longwire antenna is
Finally, there is a diversity effect sometimes shown in Figure 7-2. It consists of a wire radia-
seen on longwires. When the ionosphere is un- tor element that is at least two wavelengths
settled, an incoming signal's arrival angle may (2'. 2A) long. One can visualize the longwire an-
change (see Figure 7- 1) over the course of a few tenna as a se t of series-connected half-wave-
seconds, resulting in the fading phenomenon. length dipoles strung end to end . Unlike certain
Because of its length, the fading signal can other long wire (but not "longwire") antennas,
change, yet remain within the antenna's aper- the "dipoles" are our of phase with each other, as
ture, thus reducing fading under the right cir- indicated in Figure 7-2 by the"+" and"-" signs
cumstances. along the antenna length. It is the interaction of
There are several "flavors" on the longwire the waves on the various sections that forms the
antenna menu: resonant single wire longwires, pattern for reception.
nonresonam single wire longwires, Vee beam
longwires, and rhombic beam longwires. In
Signal Angle
Changes
l Figure 7 - 1
Longwire Antennas ... 77
Full Wavelength Full Wavelength Full Wavelength Full Wavelength Ful l Wavelength
1+---~-1v~~--J--~-1v~~---~~1v~~_.~~1v ~~_.~~1v~~+
Iv Iv Iv Iv Iv Iv Iv Iv Iv Iv
2 2-----2--- z--2 2 ---2-----2 - -2 - - 2 ---- EI
-0
© 8 0 8 0 8 0 8 0 8
LFeedpoint N=5 Wire EI =End Insulator
R=Rope Support
Figure 7 -2
The resonant longwire antenna mentioned The radiation pattern for the terminated
above is a standing wave antenna because it is longwire is a unidirectional version of the
unterminated at the far end. A signal p ropagat- multi-lobed pattern fo und on the untermi-
ing from the feedpoint, or any point along the nated longwires (Figure 7-4). The angles of the
length as happens in receive antennas, towards lobes vary with frequency, even though th e
the open end will be reflected back towards the pattern remains unidirectional. The directivity
source. The interference between the forward of the antenna is partially specified by the
and reflected waves sets up stationary standing an gles of the main lobes. Figure 7-SA shows
waves of current and voltage along the wire. how angles of the main lobes change with
A nonresonant longwire is terminated at the respect to anten na length in wavelen gths. For
far end in a resistan ce equal to its characteristic the sake of comparison, the gain over a dipole
impedance. T hus, the incident waves are ab- is shown in Figure 7 -5 B. It is interesting to
sorbed by the resistor rather than being reflected. note that gain rises almost linearly with NA.,
Figure 7-3 shows a terminated longwire anten- while the directivity function changes rapidly
na. The receiver end is like the feed system for at shorter lengths (above three or fo ur wave-
other longwire antennas, but the far end is lengths the rate of change diminishes consider-
grounded through a terminating resistor, Rl, ably) . Thus, when an antenn a is cut for a
that has a resistance (R) equal to the character- certain low frequency, it will wo rk at high er
istic impedance (Z0 ) of the antenna (R = Z 0 ) . frequencies, bur the directivity characteristic
W hen the wire is 20 to 30 feet above the will be somewhat different at each end of the
ground, zo is about 500 to 600 n. spectrum of interest.
RI
Antenna Wire (> 2;\) Terminating
Resistor
20' to LfO'
Receiver
Figure 7 - 3
Longwire Antennas ... 79
Main Lobes
Figure 7-4
10
90 9
(/) 00 ~ 8
..0
"'"''- u
CT> 70
8 7
0"'
-6 bO -3
0...
6
"' 50
~
0
'- 5
~ g:
l.j() 0 1+
~ c
>
'.i3 30 ~ 3
u
0
"'
'- 20 2
10
0
0 Ill 2A 311 411 511 611 711 811 911 1011 2 3 '+ 5 6 7 8 9 10
Length (inWavelength5,ll) Antenna Length (in Wavelength5, 11)
+ On each side of the antenna, there is selected. Unfortunately, these very simple an-
at least one lobe, minor or major, for tennas grow terribly comp lex (in theory of oper-
each half-wavelength of the wire ele- ation, if not construction) once the frequency
ment. For the overall element, there for which any given feed point in a current loop
is one lobe for every quarter-wave- changes. Sliding to another received frequency
length. changes the location of the maximum current
spots because the physical definition of "half-
+ If there is an even number of lobes wavelength" also changes. For multi-frequency
on either side of the antenna wire, operation the best solution is to end-feed the
then half of the total number oflobes antenna.
are tilted backwards and half are tilted The "ideal" feed system is shown in Figure
forwards; symmetry is maintained. 7-7. It uses an antenna tuning unit right at the
antenna feedpo int. The impedance to be
+ If there is an odd number of lobes on matched is typically 500 Q. An argument for
either side of the wire, then one lobe this system is that any practical untuned parallel
on either side will be perpendicular transmission line will re-radiate some signal,
to the wire, with the other lobes dis- contributing an unwanted vertically polarized
tributed either side of the perpendic- element to the antenna pattern. By placing the
ular lobe. ATU at the feedpoint, the problem is greatly
reduced-coax, prop erly termina ted, is less
Longwire Feed Systems likely to re-radiate than open feeders. (Or at
A longwire antenna can be fed either at the least that's the popular myth about coax ... which
end, or at any current maxima ("loop") along its may or may not be true-makes a good story,
length. The current loops occur in the middle of anyway.) Although some people have success-
half-wavelength segments. If a longwire is to be fully used this system by motorizing the tuning
for single frequency operation, then an appro- elements in an ATU, remote mast mounted
priate low imped ance current loop can be ATUs are still a bit rare.
ATU
~Coaxial Cable
...---- To RCVR
Figure 7-7
82 .a. Receiving Antenna Handbook
A popular alternative is shown in Figure num siding than the other, can distort the
7-8. This feed system is the old fashioned current flow and thus the antenna receive
"Zepp" method. The antenna tuning unit is pattern.
co-located with the receiver, and is co nnected The use of a quarter-wavelength match-
to the longwire antenna line thorough 500 .Q ing section to feed the longwire is shown in
parallel conductor transmission line. Al- Figures 7-9A and 7-9B. Both versions use
though the correct line is 500 .Q "open" par- 600 .Q parallel transmission line. You can
allel line, a good substitute is 450 .Q insulated ei ther purchase such line ready-made or make
twin-lead. It will substitute nicely fo r the open it yourself The 600 .Q characteristic imped-
parallel line, causing only a small VSWR in- ance can be realized by spacing # 16 solid wire
crease. It is quite suitable for n early all SWL at four inches, or # 14 wire at five inches. The
applications and is less of a hassle than open physical len gth of the quarter-wavelength
line. stub is 246/FMHz (the velocity factor being
A disadvantage of the simple Zepp feed negligible here) . The m ethod of Figure 7-9A
method is that the integrity of the antenna uses a matching nonresonant (untuned) par-
pattern depends on currents in both parallel allel transmission line to the receiver that is
conductors being equal. This situation occurs tapped at a point that will make the required
naturally only when the physical length of impedance transformation. This matching
the antenna is an integer multiple of a half- system only works on a single band. The
wavelength for the frequency being received. oth er method, shown in Figure 7-9 B, con-
At other frequencies, the currents are unequal nects untuned parallel 600 .Q line to the
and that increases the pattern distortion. Also, open-circuited bottom of the stub. This feed
installation problems, like one conductor system will wo rk on only on e band as non-
being closer (too close) to a gutter or alumi- tuned feeders, but if an an tenna tuning unit
- ~Pa ralle l
....--- Transmission
Line
EI =End Insulator
R =Rope Support
ATU
Receiver
Figure 7 -8
Lo ngwire Antennas "" 83
l /
/ 600- ohm Line
To RCVR
coaxial cable.
A way to improve the situation is to
use a quarter-wavelength radial connected
Figure 7 -9A
to the "cold " side of the parallel transmis-
sion line (see Figure 7-10). The purpose
of the radial is to provide a counterpoise
ground (as opposed to a real Earth
ground) connection for the longwire an-
A Antennal
If Radial tenna. T he radial is a wire that is cut to a
- -- - ---'--------- - --- · quarter-wavelength in the center of the
band of interest. The length is:
A.
If
246
l /
/ 600-ohm Line
To RCVR or, in 1neters:
Lfeet =F
MHz
75
Figure 7 - 98 Lmerers = F
MHz
EI =End Insulator
CI= Center or End Insulator
R =Rope Support
Figure 7-10
84 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
The antenna shown in Figure 7-10 is fed mation can be done, in order to better march a
with 500 Q parallel transmission line, as were standard coaxial cable impedance, th e resultant
the others, even though it has a counterpoise 125 Q impedance results in only a 1.67 : 1
radial ground. Although considered "best" fo r VSWR when connected to 75 Q coax like
ideal installations, practical installation prob- RG -59/U or RG- 11/U. While that VSWR
lems usually militate against parallel line. A might concern ham operators (b ecause of
method for using coaxial cable transmission line VSWR shut-down circuits in transmitters), it
is shown in Figure 7-11. In this version , a 4: 1 doesn't seriously affect receiver owners.
balun transformer (Tl) is inserted at the feed- Radials are a key component to resonant
point. The balun converts the feedpoint imped- longwires-indeed, for nonresonant longwires
ance to a value that is one-fourth as large, or too. Unfortunately, the radial is also relatively
125 Q. Although further impedance transfer- long and may consume a bit of valuable lawn
space n eede d for the
longwire. For example, a
~ Radial two-wavelength longwire
Wire ~2.A. Long ~ design ed to receive 6000
\ EI R
~---;-----------~ kHz and up has a length
of 324 feet, and the radi-
al for 6000 kHz is 4 1 feet
- 75 .n_ long, for an overall length
Coaxial Coble
Ta RCVR end-to-en d of 324 + 41,
EI =E nd I nsulator or 365 feet. It is possible
R=Rope Support to shorten th e rad ial
length by inserting an
Figure 7 - 11 inductor in series with
the radial (Figure 7-12).
A general rule is to use a
ILoading coil that has an inductive
t Coil
reactance of 900 Q at a
LI frequency in the center of
R
-----t-----------t---8--8- the band of interest. For
example, in the 5950 to
6200 kHz international
shortwave broadcast band,
the center frequ ency is
6075 kH z. The coil makes
the an tenna tuning a
little sharper, but this is a
reasonable trade-off for
Receiver most users lacking proper
Figure 7 - 12 space.
Lo ngwire Antennas ... 8 5
Antenna Wire l RI
~ Radiall
EI
Figure 7 - 13
86 ..... Receiving Antenna Handbook
The other solution is to use a system such when buried (and made with bare wires) con-
as shown in Figure 7- 14. This method places siderably shorter wires will do. There should
the resisto r at the top of a six to eight foo t be at least fo ur radials p er band, although one
copperclad steel ground rod (driven into the or two are better than none. As always, the
ground so that only a few inches sh ow). A radials should be buried for safety reasons-
long, h eavy duty machine screw or bolt con- pedestrians can trip over radials on the surface,
nects the box to the ground rod; U-bolt clamps and receive serious injury for which you might
make both the electrical connection and the be liable.
mechanical fastening. A stand-off insulator con nects the other
No te that a series of radials are also end of the resistor to the antenna wire. T he
connected to the ground rod. These wire can be either a vertical downlead, at
radials are ideally a quarter-wave- the cost of some distortion to the
length lon g (length in feet Wire receive pattern, or sloped over a
eq ua ls 492/FM Hz), but relatively long distance to the
resistor housing.
Ceramic
Stand-Off ...,
Insulator
1....
.,...
_ _ Waterproof
Resistor Box
Spade Lugs
Ground Rod
Eart h
~
Radials
Figure 7 - 14
Longwire Antennas ..,. 87
Vee Beams and summing together the patterns of the two indi-
Rhombic Beams vidual wires. Proper alignment of the main lobes
Longwire antennas can be combined in sev- of the two wires requires an included angle be-
eral ways to increase gain and sharpen directivi- tween the wires of twice the radiation angle of
ty. Two of the most popular of these are the Vee each wire. If the radiation angle of the wire is ~,
beam and the rhombic antennas. Both forms then the appropriate included angle is 2 ~. The
can be made in either resonant (unterminated) list below shows the optimum included angles
or nonresonant (terminated) versions. for various wavelength Vee beam antennas. For
antennas with included angles given below, the
+ Vee Beams radiation pattern elevation angle is close to 0°
The Vee beam (Figure 7-15) consists of two (i.e. h orizontal). To raise the pattern a few de-
equal length longwire elements (Wire-1 and grees, the 2~ angle should be slightly less than
Wire-2), fed 180° out of phase with each other, these values.
and spaced to produce an acme angle between
them. The 180° phase difference is inherent in ~ ~
connecting the two wires of the Vee to opposite 1 90
conductors of the same parallel conductor feed- 2 73
line. 3 58
The unterminated Vee beam of Figure 7 -15 4 50
has a bidirectional pattern that is created by 5 44
6 40
7 36
8 35
wavelength from the ground. At low frequen- beam is connected to each conductor of the
cies, such heights may not be practical, and one transmission line. Some books state that the two
must expect a certain distortion of the pattern wires to the receiver are mere downleads, and
due to ground reflection effects. need not be parallel to each other. I doubt that
Gain on a Vee beam antenna is about 3 dB advice, and recommend against it. While open
higher than the gain of the single-wire longwire wire transmission line is a tad difficult to work
antenna of the same size, and is considerably with, it is usually worth it. Besides, there are
higher than the gain of a dipole (see Figure other ways to do the job ("there's more than one
7-16). At three wavelengths, for example, the way to kill a cat, ya don't gotta ch oke him to
gain is 7 dB over a dipole. In addition, there death on bacon fat" as a supposedly wise man
may be som e extra gain due to mutual imped- once said). For example, using insulated 450 Q
ance effects, which can be about 1 dB at 51... and twin-lead results in a slight impedance mis-
2 dB at 81.... match, but is entirely satisfactory for receiver
Feeding a Vee beam is similar to feeding a use. Some people report that using 300 Q TV-
longwire antenna in that 600 Q parallel wire rype twin lead, with an antenna tuner, as tuned
transmission line is used. One wire of the Vee feeders also works well. A 9: 1 balun transformer
reduces the 600 Q impedance to
about 67 Q, so will match the feed-
15 point impedance to either 52 or
75 Q coaxial cable.
IL+
An additional 3 dB gain can be
13
0"
<:()Q.,o achieved by stacking two or more
i/' Vee beams together, either horizon-
0"'
o._
12 ~'\-o<".
i:5 tally (Figure 7- 17) or ve rtically
...c II
.,J
CJ>
(Figure 7- 18) .
c 10 0"
~ <:()Q.,o The horizontal stacking method
"'
>
..::,.Q.,q, was popular on low-cost TV anten-
~ 9
'-
8 nas for the VHF low-band channels
0
I (54 to 88 MHz) . T he two Vee
0
7
0
~ beams are positioned approximately
...0 6
<( a quarter-wavelength apart and are
d)
-0 5 connected by a quarter-wavelength
_<;;; section of transmission line that
0 i+
0 serves to cause a 90° phase shift
3
between them. T he bidirectional
2 radiation and reception characteris-
tic of normal Vee beams is replaced
0 with a unidirectional pattern. The
0 11 21 31 i.+l 51 61 71 81 91 101 I 11 121 actual direction is a function of
Antenna Leg Length in Wavelengths wheth er the feedline is connected
across Al/A2 or B l/B2 (see arrows
Figure 7 - 16 in Figure 7- 17).
Long wire Antennas .,. 8 9
Al Di re cti on if
A20::-1--'--'--'-_J__j__J__J_j_j_~L-J_-L...J-J....(l ~ Al/AZ used
Di rection if
Bl/BZ used
Figure 7 - 18
Vertical stacking also produces a 3 dB gain, The two Vee beams of Figure 7-18 are fed
but h as the additional charm of taking less space 90° out of phase with each ocher. If a single
than the h orizontal method. The vertically transmission line is desired (case shown), then
stacked Vee shown in Figure 7- 18 uses two Vee space the Vees 'A/4 and use a 'A/ 4 phasing harness
beams, an upper and a lower. The upper Vee is (made of parallel transmission line) between
'A.J2 longer on each leg than the lower. T he them. Alternatively, either use two lines, with
stacking distance between them is an odd multi- the upper being 'A/ 4 longer than the lower, or
p le of a quarter-wavelength. use a 90° phase shift network in on e line.
90 .... Receiving Antenna Handboo k
~ ~
traveling wave antenna and is th us uni-
directional.
The same problems with practical
terminated longwires also affect termi-
nated Vee beams. As a result, some peo-
ple prefer to terminate the wire in a
resistor and a quarter-wavelength radial.
O thers prefer to use a Vee-Sloper anten-
na such as Figure 7-20. The supporting
R mast height should be abo ut half to
three-fourths of the length of either an-
tenna leg. The legs are sloped down-
Fi gure 7 - 19 ward to terminating resistors at ground
level. Each wire should be longer than
lA at the lowest operating frequency.
ATU
To
RCVR R
Figure 7-20
Lo ngwire Antennas T 97
ATU
~ = Til t Angle
8 =Apex Angle
RCVR
R
Figure 7-21
ATU
RCVR
Figure 7 -22
92 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
A variation on the theme is the vertically Beverage was used by RCA at its Riverhead,
polarized rhombic of Figure 7-23. Although Long Island (New York) station in 1922, and a
sometimes called an inverted- Vee-not to be technical description by D r. H .H . Beverage (for
confused with the dipole variant of the same whom it is named) appeared in QST magazine
name-this antenna is half a rhombic, with the for November 1922, in an article tid ed "The
m issing half being "mirrored" in the ground Wave Antenna fo r 200-Meter Reception." In
(similar to a vertical). The angle at the top of the 1984, an edited and updated version of th e
mast (<I>) is typically 2:: 90°, while 120° to 145° is 1922 article appeared in the same magazine. In
more common. Each leg should be 2:: A, with the 1921, Paul Godley, under sponsorship of the
longer being somewhat higher in gain. American Radio Relay League (ARRL, 225
Main Street, Newington, CT 06111) journeyed
to Sco tland to erect a receiving station at An-
Beverage or d rossan. His mission was to listen for amateur
"Wave" Antennas radio signals from N orth America. As a result of
T he Beverage or W{zve anrenna is considered politicking in the post-World War I era, hams
by some people to be the best receiving antenna were consigned to the supposedly useless short-
available fo r very low frequency (VLF), AM waves (A< 200 meters), and it was not clear that
broadcast band (BCB), medium wave (MW), or reliable international communications were pos-
tropical band (low H F region) DXing. The sible (remember, the "200-meter an d down"
Direction of
Max imum Reception
~ Mast
600n
Line to Rece iver
~--~r--~~~~~-L-L-~~~~~-r-~~~~
Figure 7 - 2 3
Longwire Anten nas .,. 93
region is what we now call the MW and HF the period of the experiment. The experimental
shortwave bands!) . Godley went to Scotland to results are probably valid, but are misinterpreted.
see if that could happen ... he reportedly used The issue can be easily resolved by a properly
a wave antenna for the task (today called the contrived, statistically valid, theoretically com-
Beverage) . petent, side-by-side comparison experiment.
The Beverage antenna is a longwire of special T he Beverage antenn a works on vertically
design, more than o ne-wavelength (IA) long, polarized waves arriving at low angles of inci-
although some authorities maintain that > 0.5A dence. T hese conditions are normal in th e AM
is minimally sufficient. The Beverage provides BCB, where nearly all transmitting antennas are
good directivity and good gain, but is not very vertically polarized . In addition , the ground and
efficient. As a result, it is preferred for receiving sky wave propagation foun d in th e VLF, AM
but sh unned for transmitting. This is an exam - BC B, and low MW ("tropical") bands are rela-
ple of how different attributes of various anten- tively consistent. As the frequency increases,
nas make the Law of Reciprocity an unreliable however, two factors become increasin gly domi-
sole guide to antenna selection. Unlike th e regu- nant. First, the likelihood of horizontal polariza-
lar longwire, which is of a different design, the tion increases because of the size of a wavelength
Beverage is intended to be mounted close to the at those frequencies. Second, shortwave propa-
Earth's surface (typically< O. l A); heights of eigh t gation becom es less consistent at higher fre-
to ten feet is the usual prescription. quencies. The p olarization of the received signal
The Beverage works best in th e low fre- not only changes in those bands, but does so
quency bands, VLF through Mw, although at constantly when conditions are unsettled . It is
least som e results are reportedly relatively easy the strong dependen ce of the Beverage on rela-
to obtain up to the 2 5-meter (11. 5 M Hz) band . tively constant vertical p olarization that makes
Some attempts have been m ade at m akin g me suspect the claims of Beverage-like perfor-
Beverage antennas work as high as the 11-meter mance above the 25- or even 3 1-meter bands.
citizens ban d or th e 10-m eter h am ban d Figure 7-24 shows the basic single wire Bev-
(29. 7 MHz) . T here is a sometimes snide d ebate erage antenna. It consists of a single conductor
going on between those who claim good Bever- (# 16 to #8 wire, with # 14 being most common)
age performance at h igher frequencies and those erected about eight to ten feet above ground.
who say "it t'aint so. " At the risk of joining the Some Beverages are unterminated (and bidirec-
debate- which I don't wish to do- I'll recog- tional), but most are terminated at the far end in
nize that there are sound theoretical reasons to a resistance (R) equal to the antenna's character-
support the low frequen cy argument, although istic impedance (Z0 ) . The receiver end is also
the h igh frequency adherents seem to have some terminated in its characteristic impedance, but
impressive experimental results to show. I sus- gen erally requires an impedance matching trans-
pect that both sides of the argument are right, or former to reduce the antenna impedance to the
think they are. The HF performance of Bev- 50 Q standard impedance used by most modern
erages to nearly 30 MHz may well be the result receivers (Figure 7-2 5).
of regular longwire performan ce arising at fre- T he Beverage depends on being erected over
quencies above som e unrecognized limit around poorly conductive soil, even though the termi-
7 MHz. Either that, or particular propagation nating resistor needs a good ground . Thus, one
conditions made the antenna wo rk well durin g source claimed that sand beaches adj acent to
94 .... Receiving Antenna Ha ndbook
Primary
1 Ground-To-
vertical. Bur over imper-
fectly conducting soil the
field lines tend to bend
To Receiver <§;- (Winding Ground Wi re
close to the point of con-
1 ~ s'To 10'
Secondory-=;--=b--~==-....-.~----~~=:;:zt;~~
tac t w ith th e gro und .
As shown in the inset to
Winding
Figure 7-26, the bending
of the wave provides a
Figure 7 - 25
horizontal component of
the E-field vector, and this
provides the means of gen-
era ting an RF current in
the conductor wire.
.------1"-... Direction of Beverage directivity is
~ Propagation
an interesting phenom-
enon. When sign als arrive
E-lield--..
from either side (p erpen-
Wire dicular to the wire), all
sections of the wire are ex-
cited in-phase with each
Rx other. When these signals
propagate along the wire,
they reach the receiver end
Good Medium
Conductivity Conductivity essentially out of phase
Ground Ground with each other, so they
cancel. Thus, the Beverage
exhibits very deep nulls off
the sides ar right angles to
Figure 7 - 26 the wire.
Longwire Antennas T 95
Signals arriving from either end of the wire circuits. If an electrical signal is launched onto a
produce electrical situations that are similar to transmission line that is terminated at its far end
each other, but with opposite results. Signals by a resistance (R) equal to Z 0 , then all of the
from either direction set up in-phase reinfo rcing forward signal power is either radiated as an
waves at the ends. Signals arriving from the electromagnetic wave or absorbed by the termi-
fo rward direction propagate along the wire ro- nating resisror; no signal is reflected back down
wards the receiver end, and build up a strong the line towards the source. But if R # Z0 , a
resultant that is heard by the receiver. Signals reflected signal will arise, and its amplitude is
arriving from the rear direction also build up in- proportional to the mismatch between Z 0 and
phase reinfo rcing electrical signals, bur these R. On receive antennas, a component of the
propagate towards the termination resistor end, signal set up in the wire by the electromagnetic
where they are absorbed by the resistor and wave travels rowards the receiver, while another
therefore lost. If the termination resisror is component travels towards the termination . The
matched to the characteristic impedance of the signal heading towards the termination is ab-
antenna (R = Z 0 ) then there will be no reflec- sorbed by the resisror. The value of Z0 for the
tion s back down the wire (which could redu ce single wire Beverage is:
the depth of the rear null).
A good "thought model" for th e Beverage is
4
to regard it as a parallel wire transmission line Z 0 = 138 log ( dh J
w ith one good conductor (the wire) and one
lossy, poor conducror (the soil underneath). As Where:
with any transmission line, the electrical wave in
the wire has a lower velocity of propagation than Z0 is the characteristic impedan ce in .Q
the electromagnetic (EM) wave in free space. h is the antenna height
The free space EM wave travels at the speed of d is the wire d iam eter
light (denoted by th e letter c), while the electri- [h and d must be in t he sam e units -
cal signal in the wire set up by the passing EM inches, fee t, meters, etc.]
wave travels at a velocity of 0. 85c ro 0. 98c,
depending on the design and installation of the Let's look at an example. Find the character-
antenna. The velocity factor (V) is the ratio of istic impedance (Z0 ) of a Beverage mounted
the actual velocity (v) tO th e free space velocity eight fee t fro m the ground, and made of # 14
(c) : V = vi c. T he velocity facro r is sometimes wire (diameter is 0.064 inches).
expressed as a decimal (such as 0.90) and some-
times as a percent (like 90%) . T he velocity fac-
tor increases with antenna height, although the Z 0 =1 38 log(
4 3
( )( fr )
(O. 064 in. )(l fr I 12in. )
J
rate of increase slows down above h eights of ten
feet or so.
As n oted earlier, all transm ission lines have 32
Z 0 = 138 log ( )
an attribute called characteristic imp edance, 0 .00 53
symbolized by Z 0 . Although the rigorous defini-
tion is a bit more complex, it is possible tO Z 0 = 138 log (6037) = (138)(3.78)
defin e Z 0 in terms of what happens in practical = 52 1 .Q
96 ..... Receiving Antenna Handbook
This equation is used to determine the im- position or metal film are suitable [note: many
pedance of the antenna so that a terminating potentiometers are wirewound]. H ere are the
resistor can be selected. Figure 7-27 shows curves diameters (d) of several popular U.S. wire gauges:
of impedance vs. height for several pop ular wire
sizes. If the calculated value of Z 0 does not fall A WG WIRE DIAMETERS
on a standard resistor value, then you can do AWG Outside
Wire Size Diameter (in .)
one of three things: make a network of standard
8 0.1285
value resistors that does match Z 0 , use a potenti-
10 0.1019
ometer (variable resistor) and set it to a value 12 0.0808
equal to Z 0 , or use a compromise value fixed 14 0.0640
resistor; 600 Q is a popular value. In any event, 16 0.0508
only noninductive resistors such as carbon com- 18 0.0403
Like the longwire antenna, the Beverage Installation of the Beverage antenna is not
needs a termination resistor that is connected to overly critical if certain rules are followed. The
a good ground. This requirement may be harder antenna should be installed at a height of six to
to meet on Beverage antennas because they work ten feet off the gro und, and should be level
best over lossy ground, which doesn't make a with the ground over its entire length. If the
very good ground connection. On Beverage in- ground is not flat enough to make a level instal-
stallations, follow the same principles given ear- lation possible, then try to use a height that is
lier for grounding of nonresonant longwire six to ten feet above the average terrain eleva-
terminations. As in the longwire case, insulated tion along irs run.
or bare wire a quarter-wavelength long makes A popular installation method is to erect
the best radials. However, a substantial improve- 16-foot 4x4 lumber such that three to four feet
m ent in the ground is possible using just bare are buried in a concrete filled posthole. Use
wires from 15 to 20 feet long (which is much lumber that is treated for outdoor use, such as
less than A/4), buried in the soil just below the lumber sold for add-on decks and porches.
surface far enough to prevent erosion from The wire can be fastened to the 4x4 posts
bringing it to the surface. Many articles and using either ceramic stand-off ("beehive") insu-
books on Beverages show ground rods of two or lators or electric livestock control fence insula-
three feet long, which borders on the ridiculous. tors (which some people deem preferable). Try
Poor soil requires longer ground rods, on the to use one contiguous length of wire for the
order of six to eight feet. As before, copperclad antenna, if possible, in order to avoid soldered
steel makes the best rods. splices and joints.
In addition to the radials and ground rod, One of the Beverage installation difficulties
Misek also recommends using a wire connection shared with the longwire is the need to slope
betwee n the ground connection at th e down to a point where a termination resistor
termination resistor and the ground connection can be easily installed close to the ground.
at the receiver transformer (see again Figure While the longwire can be sloped over a large
7-25). According to Misek, this wire helps portion of its length, the Beverage should only
stabilize the impedance variations at higher be sloped downwards over the last 60 feet or so
frequencies. (Figure 7-28).
;..____
To
RCVR
R
Figure 7 - 28
98 ""- Receiving A n tenna H andbook
NP - /50
35 turns ~SOO
Jack91~
50-43 core, and then wind the
primary turns of #26 enam-
eled wire, and the secondary
with 11 turns of the same wire.
Other cores are also useful, and
indeed may be better for the
BCB. These would require Toroida l ~
different turns ratios from the Forradoy Core ~
example given above. Shielded
The "" 500 n impedance Secondary
of the Beverage makes a rea- Primary
sonable match to the "Hi-Z" Winding
(high impedance) inputs of Jock
some receivers (as well as the (to RCVR) ~
normal imp edance of older
receivers), but direct connec- Center
tion is not recomm ended Conductor Shield
because of safety reasons. The Soldered to Not Connected
Outer Shield
Beverage is a huge static elec- Figure 7 - 30
tricity generator. Static build-
up on the wire can p roduce
discharges that will destroy the RF input circuit- to allow 114-in ch of inner conductor to be
ry of solid-state receivers. As a result, even when exposed, along with V2-inch of inner insulator
no impedance transformation is needed, a 1: 1 and 1/2-inch of the shielding outer conductor;
transformer is recommended because of the dis- solder the inner conductor of the other end to
charge path to ground through the secondary the outer conductor of this end (be sure to not
winding. use too much heat, or the inner insulator will
Better performance, especially noise perfor- melt).
mance, is achieved if the transformer is wound The transformer can be mounted in either a
using a Faraday shield technique recommended shielded metal box, or a non-shielded box, but it
by Misek and others. This method is shown in must be mounted at the feed end of the wire,
Figure 7-30. The primary winding is wound in with no downlead (other than the coax) . The
the normal m anner with enameled hook-up chief requirement is that the box be weather-
wire. T he secondary, h owever, is made with a proofed.
length of coaxial cable for the wire. Small sizes, Avoid mounting the transformer on the pole
such as RG-1 74/U or even RG-58/U, will suf- is possible if the Beverage wire is sloped gently
fice for m edium to large size cores. One end of from the normal height (six to ten feet) to the
the wire is stripped back and the shield removed, ground level (Figure 7-3 1). As in the case of the
exposing the inner insulator and conductor; termination resistor m entioned earlier, the slope
remove about 114-inch of the inner insularor to should be over about 60 feet, but not signifi-
expose the conductor. The oth er end is trimmed cantly more.
100 ...._ Receiving Antenna Handbook
Coaxia l Cable
~
To RCVR
Figure 7 -3 1
Also shown in Figure 7-31 is an alternate wire over a suitable core (like the FT-50-43).
transformer scheme (see inset) that can be used T he center tap is at 18 turns and is grounded.
with any Beverage, not just the sloping feed The center condu ctor of the coaxial cable to the
type. This transformer is called an autotrans- receiver is connected to a tap on the "cold" end
former because the same winding is used for that matches the impedan ce. For 50 Q , tap the
both primary and secondary. T he secondary coil six turns from the ground connection.
is merely tapped down on the
p rim ary at the correct imped-
ance level. Some people use a
series of taps on the primary Rope
and a switch to select one tap
from the many in order to ac-
commod ate several different
impedance levels.
Figure 7-32 shows a Zepp-
1
fed Beverage antenna. A paral- 6 to 10 ' Wood or Plastic
Spreaders (12" separation )
lel transmission line is made by
spacing two # 14 lengths of wire,
each long enough to reach the
feed end of the Beverage, 12
inch es apart. Use either plastic
or wooden dowels to keep the
wires spread apart (as many '------Autotransformer
son..
dowels as needed may be used). Coax To
T he feed transformer is a bal- RCVR
anced autotransformer consist-
Figure 7-32
ing of 36 turns of #26 enameled
Longwire An tennas ..,. 70 7
[4hd ~i +(2h)2J
propagates to the right side end, an d reflects
z =69 lo 100% back towards the receiver. In Wire-A,
0
g s however, the reflected signal reverses phase with
respect to the incident forward signal, while in
Wire-B the open-circuit load causes an in-phase
reflection. Whether these signals can cel or add
depends on the nature of th e load circuit.
Wire B If the load is resistive (see "Alternate Load"
JI
PortA
rl
y
in Figure 7-33) the antenna is unidirectional. If
the second transformer is used as the load for
W ire A (Grounded T 1, however, the reception is bidirectional,
bur only one direction at a time. A two-
anten na coaxial switch can be used to select
~
Port-A or Port-B, depen ding on the desired
J2
PortB y direction of reception.
If null steering behavior is desired, then a
phase control circuit (abbreviated PCC-see
inset to Figure 7-33) is used. Ir consists of a
The other variation on the theme is shown longwire and ground. Each NE-51 takes more
in Figure 7-34. This antenna is the same as the than 65 volts to ignite so there was at least 195
previous case on the receiver end (except for the volts on that line- and probably several kilo-
PCC being hard-wired, rather than movable; volts!
both designs are acceptable) . On the termina- Everyone is familiar with static electricity
tion end, however, a trifilar transfo rmer (three problems from ordinary experience. Wearing
interleaved windings) is used to terminate the certain fabrics, scuffling across certain types of
two wires. rugs, or sliding across a car seat can build up a
very high-many kilovolts-static ch arge that
can cause the "bite" yo u receive when touching
Electrostatic Discharge (ESD} another (especially a gro unded) object.
Damage Control All electronic circu itry is sensitive to ESD,
During my 1984 visit to Texas to see friend but the problem became more acute with the
and antenna guru Johnnie Harper Thorne, I advent of solid-state circuits . These circuits are
learned first-hand about a problem that affects zapped into oblivion by high voltage ESD tran-
all large antennas, but is especially severe on sients. While vacuum tube receivers were not
longwires of all types: electrostatic discharge immune to ESD damage, they were a lot more
(ES D) damage. Because of their very large size, tolerant of ESD voltage spikes.
longwire antennas pick up immense static elec- There are several mechanisms by which static
tricity charges. John demonstrated to me that ch arges build up. First, lightning storms many
three series-connected NE-51 neon lamps would miles away, far out of sight, can produce electri-
flash (indicating a high voltage present) when cal fields near you r antenna that are intense
connected between the feedline of a resonant enough to build up static charges on a long
Tl
To
KCVRJ
t---1
r !: T3
- I
I
1
LI
300uH
Cl
lf50
pf
Figure 7-34
Longwire Antennas ~ 103
x
x
Ten 1- meg _n_ Ten 1-meg _n_
2 - watt Resistors 2- watt Resistors
M
0
v NE-2
Neon Glow Lamp
-= -=
Figure 7 - 36 A B c
CHAPTER 8
B
A= 722 feet
i B=
FMHZ
480V feet
FMHZ
Figure 8 - 1
7 0 6 .... Receiving Antenna H andb ook
I :I BALUN
~ 75D Coax
Figure 8-3
108 .&. Receiving Antenna Handbo o k
~Radial
~
Wire Antenna Element
JiV (>~at lowest frequency)
Coax to Direction of ~
Receiver Reception ~
~ Support
Mast RI
270 n.. / _ Ground
Ground 2- watt ~ jll( Connect ion
I
_ I
1:] 1:1
BALUN EI R EI BALUN R
75 _n_ Coax
A
Phase
Box
Figure 8-5
RCVR
I Ii
R EI ... , ... ,EI R
~ ~
Figure 8 -6
110 .a. Recei ving A ntenna Handbook
A/Lt
i_ ~
Lf:I BALUN
A/Lt
i_
. - 75ohm
Coax To
RCVR
Figure 8-7
Other Wire Antennas ... 111
L3
l
L3
l
x3
To RCVR via
Figure 8-8 BALUNand Coax
The phase reversal harness connecting the Large Wire Loop Antennas
elements is made fro m either 45 0 Q parallel Antennas can be built using half- or full-
transmission line, or 450 Q twin-lead. No te wavelength pieces of wire arranged in a loop.
that it is twisted over on itself in order to make There are two basic fo rms of loop antenna: small
the ph ase reversal happen (lack of this phase and large. These two types have different char-
reversal is one reason why this antenna seems to acteristics, work according to different princi-
"fail" when built!) . The matching section is also ples, and have different purposes. Small loops
made of 4 50 Q line, and is a quarter-wave- are those in which the current flowing in the
length: wire has the same phase and amplitude at every
point in the loop (which fact implies a very
246
L3feet = -- - short wire length, such as < O. lA). Such loops
FMH z respond to the magnetic field compon ent of the
electromagnetic radio wave. We'll discuss small
T he 75 Q coaxial cable transmission line is loops in an upcoming chapter.
connected to points "X l " and "X2 " through a A large loop antenna has a wire length
1: 1 balun transformer. T hese points are found > O. lA, with most being either A./2, lA, or A.
experimentally by m oving the balun connection The current in a large loop varies along the
points up and down along the stub until a 1: 1 length of the wire in a manner similar to other
impedance match is achieved . wHe antennas.
112 "" Receiving Antenna Handbook
..I
l_ l_
8 Xz
· ------- SI 8
l_ ..,
8
-------~ y y y ''------ -- - - - - - - - - ,
I) XI
x2
Maximum 1)
Reception
1 A Large Loops
If size is not forcing you ro a 'A/2 loop, then a
l A loop may be just the ticket. It produces a
gain of about +2 dB over a dipole in the direc-
tions that are perpendicular to the plane of the
loop. The azim uth patterns formed by these
antennas are similar to the "figure-8" pattern of
th e dipole. T hree versions are shown: the square
loop in Figure 8-11, the diamond loop in Figure
8- 12, and the delta loop (a.k.a. D-loop and tri-
angle loop) in Figure 8-13. T he square and dia-
mond loops are built with 'A/4 on each side,
while the delta loop is 'A/3 on each side. T he
overall length of wire n eeded to build these
antennas is:
L _ 1005
feet - F
MHz Figure 8-11
T he polarization of the three loop antennas moving the feedpoinr to either of the two adja-
is horizontal because of the location of the feed- cenc apexes. On the delta loop, placing the feed-
points. On the square loop, moving the feed- point at either of the two other apexes produces
point to the middle of either vertical side will a diagonal polarization that offers approximately
provide vertical polarization. Similarly, on the equal vertical and horizontal polarization com-
diamond loop vertical polarization is realized by ponents.
XI XZ
Figure 8-12 Figure 8 - 13
Other Wire Antennas ... 115
To XI t X2
I
Figure 8-14
~ 52 ohm
Coax To
RCVR
The feedpoint impedance of the lA loop is (any length )
around 100 Q , so it provides a slight mism atch
to 7 5 Q coax, and a 2: 1 mismatch to 52 Q coax.
A very good m atch to 52 Q coax can be pro-
duced using the scheme of Figure 8- 14. H ere we Where:
see a quarter-wavelength coaxial cable matching Z 0 is the characteristic impedance of the
stub made of 75 Q coaxial cable. The length of coax used in the matching section in Q
this cable sh ould be: ZL is the feedpoint impedance of the
antenna in Q
L _ 246V
feet - F Zs is the source impedance (the 52 Q
MHz characteristic impedance of the line to
Where: the receiver in standard systems)
Lfee t is the length in feet (ft)
V is the velocity factor of the coax For example, where Zs = 52 Q and ZL =
FMHz is the frequency in megaHertz (MHz) 100 Q:
Half-Delta Sloper (HDS) feet is needed. T he lengths for any frequen cy are
The half-delta sloper (HDS) shown in Figure found from:
8-15 is similar ro the fu ll delta loop, except that
(like the quarter-wavelength verrical) half of the
antenna is in the fo rm of an "image" in the
ground. Gains of 1. 5 to 2 dB are achievable. and
The HDS antenna consists of two elements:
a /..../3 wavelength sloping wire and a 'A/6 vertical
wire (on an insulated mast) or a /..../6 m etal mast.
Because the ground currents are very important,
much like the venical antenna, either an exten- T he HDS is fed at one corne r, close to the
sive radial system at both ends is needed or a ground. If only the fundamental freq uency is
base ground return wire (buried) must be pro- desired, then you can feed it with 52 Q coaxial
vided. cable. But at harmonics the feedpoint imped-
The HDS will work on its design frequency ance changes to as high as 1000 Q. If harmonic
plus harmonics of the design frequency. For a operation is intended , then an antenna tuning
fundamental frequency of 5 MHz, a vertical unit is needed at point ''A" tO match these im-
segment of 33 fee t and a sloping section of 66 pedances.
Good Electrical
and Mechanical
Connection
\
\/3
\ /6
.._s-- M etal Mast
or Wire
52Jl
Earth Coax
~ ~
Buried Ground Return Wire (Bare)
Figure 8 - 15
Other Wire Antennas • 7 77
Bi-Square
Loop Antenna
The bi-square antenna, shown in
Figure 8-16, is similar rn the other large
loops except that it is 'A-/2 on each side,
making a total wire length of two wave-
Each side is ~
lengths. This antenna is built like the
diamond loop shown earlier, in that it is L side-- -F--
i+BO
a large square loop fed at an apex that is MHZ
set at the bottom of the assembly. In
this case, the loop is fed either with an
antenna tuning unit (to match a 1000 n
impedance) or a q uarter-wavelength
matching section made of 300 n or
450 n twin-lead transmission lin e.
A 1: 1 balun transformer connects the
~Matching Section
75 Q coaxial cable to the matching sec- i+
uon.
The bi-square antenn a offers as
much as 4 dB gain broadside to the I :I BALUN
plane of the antenna (in and out of the Transformer
book page) , in a figure-8 pattern, on the
design frequen cy. It is horizontally po-
larized. When th e frequency drops to
one-half the design frequen cy, the gain
drops to about 2 dB and the antenna
52ohm
works sim ilarly to the diamond loop Coax To
discussed above. RCVR Figure 8 - 16
CHAPTER 9
Vertical
Antennas
he vertical antenna has long been popular sistent with th e "free space" idea, let's use the
T with hams and SWLs because of its many
positive attributes. It is omnidirectional (not
concept of "far above rhe Earth's surface" for our
present discussion. This idea allows us to over-
always a positive factor, by the way), usually look the effects of a bounced signal from the
quite simple to erect, is low cost, and requires ground recombining with rhe principal antenna
only a small amount of real estate under most pattern. So, for the sake of our argument, this
circumstances. The straight quarter-wavelength antenna is many, many wavelengths up in the
vertical antenna is of manageable size down ro air.
frequencies of about 5 MHz (height:::::: 50 feet), When the physical axis of the antenna is
although at lower frequencies the height be- vertical with respect to the ground, the electro-
comes prohibitive for most shortwave listeners. magn etic wave that it transmits is vertically
Ar lower frequencies (< 5 MHz), or even at polarized, meaning the electrical field is vertical
higher frequencies, a vertical can be constructed with respect to the Earth's surface. On receive,
with a loading coil to compensate for missing
length . While nor ideal (all co mp ensation
m ethods involve trade-offs), it is often a viable A.
approach to making a decent antenna that is
otherwise impossible. AM radio broadcasting Ve rtica lj J
stations and most VLF stations use vertical an- Antenna
tennas, and there is ample evidence that they are
frequently, bur not always, the best engineering
~ A.
choice for those frequencies. Lt
Vertical antennas can be m ade fro m either
wire or piping (aluminum tubing is most often
J
selected). In this chapter we'll take a look at
antennas made from both types of construction
material.
the antenna responds best to signals that are all directions (which-surprise!-is what "omni-
vertically polarized. In the middle and upper directional" means). The side view (Figure 9-2C)
shortwave spectrum, the polarity of the incom- is a "figure-8" pattern with nulls projecting from
ing signal is messed up by ionospheric propaga- the top and bottom along the antenna's physical
tion problems. But on the lower shortwave, axis. This pattern, which in practical terms is the
medium wave, and VLF bands, the polarity is elevation pattern, is less than omnidirectional
more likely to remain consistent. because of the nulls. Its strongest point is per-
Now remember that antenna patterns are pendicular to the axis of the antenna.
three-dimensional. They describe a solid hunk Now let's get back down to Earth. Real verti-
of the universe .. . not just vertical and horizontal cal antennas are planted either on the ground or
planes. Figure 9-2 shows the space occupied by mounted a short distance above the ground, as
the antenna pattern for antennas such as Figure in Figure 9-3. In this configuration, we don't
9- 1. The overall pattern is what the math whiz- need the full half-wavelength (although it could
zes call a "torus," but we less than brilliant types be used). When the antenna is mounted on the
call doughnut-shaped (Figure 9-2A). When ground, the radiator element is a quarter-wave-
viewed from above (Figure 9-2B), and sliced length long and the other half of the antenna
horizontally, the pattern is a circle. The "omni- circuit is essentially the ground. Some books use
directional" property of a vertical is based on the concept of a quarter-wavelength radiator
this pattern; a circular pattern hears signals from coupled with its "image" in the ground. I've
Horizonta l
Polar
Patter n
(seen from above)
Antenna
1
Horizontal
Plane
Vertical
Antenna Pattern Patter n
(side view)
1 Antenna Lobe
Antenna Nu ll
: (i nside) Axis
Lobe
A Sol id
Pattern
Antenna
Figure 9 - 2 Ax is
c
Vertical Antennas .,. 121
r Xz
@
Figure 9-5 shows three popular coil loading end of the loading coil is gro unded, fo rming a
schemes. The antenna in Figure 9-5A is base path to ground for currents. The antenna is
loaded because the series inductor is placed at tuned by adjusting tap ''A," while the imped-
the base right at the antenna feedpoint. A center ance of the coaxial cable to the rece iver is
loaded version is shown in Figure 9-5 B, while a matched by adjusting tap "B." These taps can be
top loaded version is in Figure 9-SC. Many top adjusted with a VSWR bridge, noise bridge, or
loaded verticals also have a small telescoping other antenna instrumentation.
extension above the coil to tune the antenna. A delta fed vertical is shown in Figure 9-6B.
Some also have a cap acitive decoupling " hat," as The basis for impedance matching in this an-
in Figure 9-5D. tenna is the fact that the impedance varies along
The verticals presented thus far have been the height of the antenna, with the lowest point
insulated from ground, m eaning the feedpoint being the current n ode. In this type of antenna,
is not connected to ground. Some people prefer the radiator element itself is directly gro unded,
grounded verticals for various reasons, not the as is one side of the coaxial cable (the shield).
least of which is possibly improved lightning T he center conductor of the coax is connected
protection. Figure 9-6 shows two fo rms of to a po int above ground that has an impedance
grounded vertical antenna. The version in Fig- equal to its characteristic impedance (50 Q ,
ure 9-6A is a base loaded vertical in which one usually).
Vertical Antennas ... 123
Counterpoise Grounds,
or "Radials"
There are two problems with grounding on
vertical antennas. First, the Earth ground may
not be all that good .. . and verticals require a
good, low resistance ground to work properly.
Second, when you elevate the vertical, which is
done sometimes to adjust the elevation of the
Radiator
Element - - ARR, then there is no ground to connect to.
Both of these situations are improved im mensely
by the use of quarter-wavelength radials (Figure
9-7) connected to the shield side of the coaxial
cable. The radials form an artificial ground, also
called a counterpoise ground. Antennas that use a
LI
co unterpoise ground sys tem are sometimes
called ground plane antennas.
Each radial can be a half-wavelength long,
but is at least a quarter-wavelength lon g. Its
length is found from:
Figure 9-6A
246
Length feer = .
Frequency m MHz
Coaxial
To RCVR
Figure 9 - 7
Vertical Antennas ,,. 125
Coax! EI
Figure 9-9, the pipe is sh own bolted to the
wooden support with U-bolts. An alternative
scheme is to use stand-off "beehive" insulators.
~R These components, however, are becoming in-
~ Stake creasingly difficult to locate and actually have
only a slight advantage over dry wood. (Of
Figure 9-8 course, if the wood gets soaked there may be
a considerable difference!)
I used a scheme such as
The vertical half-wavelength dipole is built Figure 9-9 for many
in exactly the same manner as th e horizontal years and n ever
variety. The center insulator (CI) can be found it to be
either a regular center insulator, designed a problem.
for this purpose, or a 1: 1 balun trans-
'-+X'-+ or 2X'-+ \
former. The coaxial cable is routed con - 1- - Pipe
veniently to the inside of the structure.
Where possible, the coax should come
away from the antenna wire at a right
> U- Bolts
angle, and continue that way for a
considerable distance. However,
don't go overboard trying to ....- Ground Stake
make this ideal situation hap- ~ -- 1--1r- ...
------1 j : :
pen if it is just plain difficult. ,,
A ground mounted vertical made from alu- ,,,,
--r---'-L---- ----""-- Bu ri ed Rad ia Is
minum tubing is shown in Figure 9-9. The sup- I 11
,,,,,,
1. _ _ I I1
wave traps separating the sections. Most crap The wave traps can be treated in several
verticals designed for the ham bands can be ways . If you want to modify the trap to change
tuned as much as 5% or 6% ou tside the ham its frequency, then connect a small value capaci-
bands, so they will work nicely for some SWL tor in parallel with the coil (the regular capacitor
bands. is inside and can usually be accessed). The capa-
citor will lower the resonant frequency. The
values of capacitor vary m arkedly, bur good trial
values are 10 pF from 13 MHz and up, 33 pF
from 7 to 13 M H z, and 100 pF at lower fre-
quencies. Use a "trial and error" approach to
home in on the actual capacitance.
Electrical Installation
Figure 9-1 4 shows the usual fo rm of multi-
band trap vertical antenna. Each trap (TR1 -
TR3) is a parallel resonant LC tank circuit that
blocks a certain frequency but passes all others.
Figure 9- 12 In Figure 9-1 4, TRl is the 10-meter trap, TR2
is the 15-meter trap, and TR3 is the 20-meter
trap. No 40-meter trap is needed because the
antenna resonates the entire length of the tubing
on 40-meters. Each section (except perhaps the
10-meter section) is actually a little shorter than
might be expected from the standard quarter-
wavelength formulas. That is because the traps
tend to act inductively and lessen the length
required to resonate on any given band.
The vertical manufacturer may give suggested
lengths fo r the various segments between traps.
Do not make the mistake ofassuming that these are
absolute numbers! They are only recommended
starting points, even though the literature
packed with the antenna may suggest otherwise.
Loosely (meaning don't tighten the clamps too
much) but safely install the antenna and then
adjust each segment for resonance. Start with
the 10-meter band, and then work each lower
frequency band in succession: 10-1 5-20-40, etc.
After each lower band is adjusted, recheck the
higher bands to make sure nothing shifted be-
cause there might be a little interaction between
Figure 9 - 13
Vertical Antennas ... 129
_____,..,..___ .._s Capacity Hat two radials per band and preferably four
arranged so that they are equally spaced
around the antenna. If you can't space
them correctly, never fear-they' ll work any-
way. O n a four-band antenna, that means 16
radials, which really isn't a lot.
, 1 111 I ,,,,
11
Figure 9-16 ,,
11
11
//
II,
I
I
,,
,,,,
,1 - 1'...,,,, ''...i--......
//
,,
,,
,,
CHAPTER 10
Directional
Antennas
irecrional antennas are those in which the
D reception pattern can be directed or steered
to a specific region of the universe. The reason
decent center mount for smaller antennas (such
as for the 13-meter band) while the matching
pipe serves as a mast.
that we want to be able to direct the pattern is Rotation of the antenna can be by either of
two-fold. In the main beam (o r "lobe") of the two methods. The ''Armstrong" rotor consists of
antenna p attern, signals will be louder. This is a good gripping wrench or pliers and some el-
because there is a gain associated with the anten- bow grease. Don't laugh- I've lmown both hams
na. The other reason is that a null-a point of and SWLs who would open an upstairs window
minimum pick-up-exists in the pattern and it and use a vise grip wrench to turn the antenna
can be positioned towards an interfering station. mast to point the antenna in th e right direction.
In this chapter we'll take a look at several popu- T he other method is t~ buy a regular antenna
lar directional antennas. ro tator. For ligh tweight an tennas (above
20 MHz), an ordinary television antenna rotator
Rotatable Dipoles will suffice, but for larger antennas a heavy duty
The h alf-wavelength dipole is probably the ham radio rotator is required.
most popular single type of directional antenna
in th e sh ortwave bands. It has a "figure-8" direc-
tional pattern (azimuthal) consisting of two
Antenna
AaPipe
maxima at right angles to the wire, and two
minima (nulls) off the ends of the wire. If the
Elements
dipole can be rotated, then the nulls and the C lamps
maxima can be positioned for
best signal reception .
Figure 10-1 shows a rotat-
able half-wavelength d ipole that
' - Pipe Flange
can be built at frequencies as
low as abou t 13 MHz, although IX2 Lumber )
it is probably easier to construct
the antenna at the 18 MHz
band and up. (At lower frequencies, the elements ........1---- - Pipe Mast
get too long for simple construction practices.)
The antenna elements are made from %-inch to
l 1A.-inch aluminum tubing. Each element is a
quarter-wavelength long. The aluminum tubing
is mounted on a piece of l x2 pressure treated
lumber. A pipe floo r or ceiling flange makes a Figure 10-1
1 32 ... Receiving Antenna Handbook
The direction of the maximum receive sensi- arcing of the Yagi beam antenna elements at
tivity, and maximum radiation on transmit, is in their ends in the rarified high altitude atmo-
the direction away fro m the reflector and sphere of Quito. By making a current mode
towards the director. The elem ents are spaced loop antenna, the high voltages at the tips were
approximately 0 .151.. apart. In this case, the gain avoided (there are no tips in a loop). The loop
of the Yagi will be optimized at 5.8 dB for a two lengths (i. e., entire perimeter) can be found by:
element model and 7 dB for a three elem ent
model. Additional elements add gain, as does D riven Element:
"stacking" two or more beams (about 3 dB per
L _ 1005
stack if done correctly). Yagi beam antennas can feet - F
~MHz
be either horizontally or vertically polarized,
although the horizontal version is the most pop-
ular (except on the 11-meter citizens band). Director Element:
Yagi beams can be operated on multiple
975
bands using tuned traps, similarly to the trap Lfeet = F
dipoles discussed earlier. Amateur radio opera- MHz
tors often use multiband, multi-element Yagi
beam antennas fo r their op erations. Yagi beam Reflector Element:
antennas can also be shortened by inserting in-
1030
ducto rs in the elements. Similarly, the induc- Lfeer = - --
tance can be provided by helically winding the FMHz
wire along the length of an insulating elem ent.
By using this method, low frequencies can be
accommodated, although at the cost of lost Driven Element
bandwidth.
The impedance at the feedpoinr of the Yagi Paras it ic Element
beam antenna is lower than th e 75 Q one nor-
mally expects of dipole antennas. Values of feed-
point impedance of 12 to 60 Q are fo und,
depending on the number of elements and their
relative spacing. This impedance can be mea-
sured , an d an impedance transformer or balun
provided to match it to 50 Q coaxial cable.
X1 X2
There are other matching methods-such as the
gamma match , omega match, and h air pin
stub-but these ten d to get a bit dicey to build.
Quad beam antennas are full wave loops
(Figure 10-3) rather than half-wavelength di-
i
A
s-Op t ional
Tu ning Stub
poles. The quad antenna was invented in the _l_
late 1940s by engineers for the missionary sh ort-
wave radio broadcasting station H CJB in Quito,
~ Shorting Bar
Ecuador. H CJB was troubled by RF corona Fig ure 10- 3
134 .._ Receiving Antenn a H andboo k
These lengths are the entire loop length, cable at the feedpoint, and then 52 Q coaxial
rather than each side. The length of the indi- cable from the open end of the 75 Q section to
vidual sides are one-fourth of the lengths calcu- the receiver. T he length of the 75 Q portion is
lated by the equations above. T he antenna can reduced by the velocity factor of the coaxial
be tuned by adding a quarter-wavele ngth cable:
tunable stub (''A") to one side of the reflector L _ 246V
element , although this stub is cons idered teer - F
MHz
optional by some experts.
The feedpoi nt impedance of the quad M ulriband quad antennas can be built from
antenna will vary from about 40 Q to around a common mounting scheme (Figure 10-4). T he
90 Q , depending on the spacing of the elements. wires of each band's antenna can be connected
These antennas are therefore reasonable m arch- in parallel to the transmission line (points "Xl"
es to either 52 Q or 75 Q coaxial cable. In some and "X2") . The spreaders are made of fiberglass,
cases, however, an impedance transformer or although at one time bamboo poles (used in the
matching stub is used to imp rove the situation. carpet trade) were quite popular. Un fortunately,
A popular impedance matching method is to bamboo poles are a bit hard to find these days
use a quarter-wavelength piece of 75 Q coaxial and the cardboard rolls now used by carpet mal(ers
are no t suitable . The
mounting plate can be a
thick piece of plywood or
a fiberglass or metal plate.
Check the amateur radio
or SWL magazin es for
current suppliers of these
items.
H ardwa re to make
either Yagi or quad an-
tennas can be ob tained by
salvagin g parts from used
amateur radio antennas.
Spreaders I've seen a large amount
of such hardware at ham-
fests and other "flea
market" get togethers,
and the stuff is generally
low cost. T h e elements
can be either cut to SWL
freque ncies, or the basic
hardware used to support
newly constructed ele-
ments cut to SWL fre-
Figure 10-4 quenc1es.
Directional Antennas "" 135
Phased
Vertical Arrays
Can a vertical antenna own- Null
er get the benefit of directivity
without a huge investment in a t
• pl
tower mounted with a Yagi
beam or quad? The usual ___ .,..
so luti on is to u se phased
Maxima
verticals. AM broadcast stations
• p2
with more than one tower are
using this type of system. The
idea is to place two or more
t
Null
antennas in close proximity and
feed them with currents at
specific phase angles to produce
a desired radiation pattern. A lot of material is
available in the literature on phased vertical an-
tenna systems, and it is far too much to be
•
Max ima
covered here. There are "standard patterns" dating
from before World War II that are created with
different spacings and different phase angles of
feed current. In this chapter, we will consider
only one sys tem.
Figure 10-5 shows the patterns for a pair of
quarter-wavelength vertical antennas spaced a
half-wavelength (180°) apart. Without getting
into complex phase shifting networks, there are
basically two phasings that are easily obtained:
0° (antennas in-phase) and 180° (antennas out
of phase w ith each other). When the two anten-
nas (Pl and P2) are fed in-phase with equal
currents, the radiation pattern (shown some-
what idealized in Figurel 0-5A) is a bidirectional
"figure-8 " that is directional perpendicular to
the line of centers between the two antennas. A
sharp null exists along the line of centers (Pl-P2).
When the antennas are fed out of phase with
'
Maxima
It should be apparent that we can select our upon the type of coax used. Unfortunately, the
directivity by selecting the phase angle of the physical spacing between P 1 and P2 is a real half-
feed currents in the two antennas. Figure 10-6 wavelength (A= 492/F), while the cable length
shows the two feeding systems usually cited in is shorter by the velocity factor (~ = ((VF) X
books for in-phase (Figure 10-6A) and out-of- 492)/F). Consider an example. A 13-meter band
phase (Figure 10-6B) systems. In Figure 10-6A, (21. 6 5 MHz) phased vertical antenna system
we have the coax from the trans-
mitter coming to a coax Tee-con-
nector. From the connector to Quarter Wavelength
the antenna feedpoints are two Verticals
lengths of coax (Al andA2) that
are equal to each other and iden-
tical. Given the variation be-
tween coaxial cables, I suspect
that it would work better if the
two cables were not m erely the
same length (Al = A2) but also
came from the same roll!
The second variation, shown
in Figure 10-6B, supposedly pro-
duces a 180° phase shift between
Al = A2
antenna Pl and antenna P2, Coax To
when the length is an electrical RCVR
half-wavelength. According to
much-publicized theory, the sys-
Figure 10-6 A
tem of Figure 10-6B ought to
produce the pattern of Figure
Quarter Wavelength
10-6B-yet experience shows Verticals
''t'ain't always so." It seems that
there are a couple of problems
with the system in Figure 10-6B.
First, remember that coax h as a 1----------- A=~ - - -- -- -- - -1
velocity factor (VF) which is the
fraction of th e
speed of light at
which signals in
the cable prop- --- - - -- - - A
Coax To
agate. T he VF is RCVR
a decimal frac- ''Tee''
tion on the or- Coax
der of 0.66 to Connector
0.82, depending B
Directional Antennas ..,. 137
will have two 11.4 foot radiators spaced 22.8 Figure 10-6B is less than the power available to
feet apart (approximately, d epending upon antenna P 1. Thus, the pattern will be distorted
exact frequency). If we use foam coax, with VF because the current produced in P2 is less than
= 0.80, the cable length is (0.8) x (22.8 feet), the current in Pl, where they should be equal.
or 18.25 feet. In other words, despite lots of The first problem is sometimes fixed by using
publicity, the darn cable won't fit between the unequal lengths for cables Al and A2 (Figure
towers. 10-7), and using it for the out of phase case. For
Second, the patterns shown in Figure 10-5 example, if we make Al a quarter-wavelength,
are dependent upon one principal condition: and A2 a %-wavelength, antenna P 1 is fed with
the antenna currents are equal. If both of them a 90° phase lag (relative to the Tee connector
are the same impedance, and are fed from the signal), while antenna P2 is fed with a 270°
same transmitter, then it is reasonable to as- phase shift. The result is still a 180° phase differ-
sume that the currents are equal-right? ence. Unfortunately, we have not only not solved
Wrong!What about coax loss? Because of nor- the current level problem, we have actually made
mal coax loss, which is worse at higher fre- it worse by adding still more lossy cable to the
quencies, the power available to antenna P2 in system.
Quarter Wavelength
Pl Verticals P2
........- --Al .. ,- - - -- - - A2 - - -- - -
AI =\ /4
A2=3\/4
Coax To
RCVR
Figure 10-7
138 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
There is still another problem that is generic Adjustable phase control is obtained by select-
to the wh ole class of phased verticals. O nce ing how many segments are switched into the
installed, the pattern is fixed. T his problem circuit at any one rime.
doesn't bother most point-to-point commercial
radio stations or broadcasters because they rend Bobtail Curtains
to tran smit in only one direction. Bur we are The Bobtail curtain, also called th e broad-
most likely to n eed a rotatable antenna pattern. side array, is shown in Figure 10-9. It is a verti-
N either Figure 10-5A nor Figure 10-5B is ratable cally polarized array that can be mad e either of
without a lot of effort- like changing coax feeds wire or tubing. Ir is blessed with a low angle of
around (or physically digging up the verticals radiation and works very well for long distance
and repositioning them ?) . DX work (over 2500 miles). The Bobtail cur-
The pattern of a pair of phased vertical can tain offers about 5 dB gain in a figure-8 pattern
be steered considerably (20 to 70°) by inserting at right angles to the line connecting the three
a phase shift network in series with either anten- antennas (when seen from above).
n a's coaxial cable before it inputs to the phase The Bobtail curtain antenna consists of three
control box. Various RLC n etworks can be used quarter-wavelen gth ve rt ical radiators ("A")
for phase shifting, bur the coaxial cable version spaced a half-wavelength apart. T he center radi-
of Figure 10-8 is quite simple. Cut up a half- ato r element is fed between its base and ground
wavelength piece of coax and fit the ends with through an antenna tuning unit (Figure 10-10).
coaxial connectors. Connect the coax junctions, T he horizontal sections ("B") act as phasing
via Tee connectors, to a coaxial switch (S l ). harnesses to excite the two outer radiators.
Coax Sections ~
Tee ~ Tee ~ Tee
B E
F
A SI
Go---oITo
Antenna
J2
~
To
RCVR
JI
Figure 10-8
Directional Antennas T 139
E
lr - B
·I~ B
___,EI
iA
iA
iA
EI
1 Coax To
RCVR
1 1 EI
R R
A= 225 feet
FMHZ
Fig u re 10- 9
475
B= feet
Flv1HZ
Cl
T he antenna tuning unit is shown in ILJ-Opf JI
Figure 10-10, and consists of a 140 pF To RCVR
capacitor and 18 µH adjustable induc-
tor in parallel. In practice, the inducto r
may be set to one inductance that tunes
the band when the capacitor (C l ) 1s
adjusted through its entire range. Fi g ure 10-1 O
74 0 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
T TA T
A A
52ohm A = \/ Lf
Coax To
RCVR B = \/2
Figure 10- 11
Directional Antennas ... 141
A3
Al
CT
Figure 10- 12
Figure 10-12 shows a multidirectional Thorne "Y," close 52 and 53 and leave 51 open. For direc-
array using a center element ("CT'') and three tion "Z," close 51 and 52 and leave 53 open.
outer elements spaced at 120° intervals in a The switches 5 1 through 53 can be either
circle- with a 'A/2 radius- around the center mechanical switches, or electromechanical relays.
element. A set of switches (S 1 through 53) allows If you opt for relays, then make sure to use low
the antenna to receive in any of three directions. current, low voltage (5 volt DC or 6 volt DC)
For direction "X", close 51 and 53 and open 52 types that are operated from a battery. Do not use
(that is, use elements Al and A3). For direction 110 voft AC relays!
CHAPTER 11
Small Loop
Receiving Antennas
I f you are fond of DXing the AM broadcast-
ing band (BCB), VLF, medium wave, or low
tion of the loop plane), and the nulls are broad-
side to the loop plane (see Figure 11- lA). Don't
frequency HF "tropical" bands, then this chapter confuse small loop behavior with the behavior
was written with you in mind. In this chapter of the loopstick antenna. Loopstick antennas
yo u will learn some smoke about small loop are made of coils of wire wound on a ferrite or
receiving antennas. These antennas are funda- powdered iron rod. The direction of maximum
mentally different from the large loop typ es pre- response for the loopstick antenna is broadside
viously discussed and are very often the antenna to the rod with deep nulls off the ends (Figure
of choice for low frequency work. Large loop 11-1 B). Both loops ticks and small wire loops
antennas are 0.5A or larger and respond to the are used for radio direction-finding and for
electrical field component of the electromagnetic shortwave, low freq uency medium wave, AM
wave. Small loop antennas, on the other hand, broadcast band, and VLF DXing.
are< O. lA (some sources say 0.17/... and <0.22A) The nulls of a loop antenna are very sharp
and respond to the magnetic field component of and very deep. Small changes of pointing direc-
the electromagnetic wave. One principal differ- tion can make a profound difference in the re-
ence between the large loop and the small loop sponse of the antenna. If you point a loop
is found when examining the radio frequency antenna so that its null is aimed at a strong
current induced in the loop when a radio signal station , the signal strength of the station appears
intersects it. In a large loop, the dimensions in to drop dramatically at the center of the notch.
each section are an appreciable portion of one But turn the antenna only a few degrees one way
wavelength, so the current will vary from one or the other, and the signal strength increases
point in the conductor to another. But in a sharply. The depth of the null can reach 10 to
small loop, the current is the same throughout 15 dB on sloppy loops and 30 to 40 dB on well-
the entire loop. built loops (20 dB is a very common value). I've
The differences between small loops and seen claims of 60 dB nulls for some commer-
large loops show up in some interesting ways, cially available loop antennas, but until they are
but perhaps the most striking is the directions of properly tested I discount such claims as adver-
maximum response-the main lobes-and the tising hyperbole. I would, however, like to see
directions of the nulls. Both types of loop pro- some scientifically valid evidence of 60 dB nulls
duce figure-8 patterns, but in directions at right if anyone has it available. The construction and
angles with respect to each other. The large loop uniformity of th e loop are primary factors in the
antenna produces main lobes orthogonal at right sharpness and depth of the null.
angles or "broadside" to, the plane of the loop. At one time, the principal use of the small
Nulls are off the sides of the loop. The small loop antenna was radio direction-finding, espe-
loop, however, is exactly the opposite: the main cially i.n the lower frequency bands. The RDF
lobes are off the sides of the loop (in the direc- loop is mounted with a compass rose to allow
144 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
Loop~
location.
Today, th ese small loops are still used for
(Top View) radio direction-finding, but their use has been
extended into the general receiving arena,
especially on the low frequencies. One of the
characteristics of those bands is the possi-
t
Maximum
bility of strong local interference smoth ering
weaker ground wave and sky wave stations.
As a result, you can't hear co-channel signals
when one of them is very strong and the other
Response
is weak. Sim ilarly, if a co-channel station has
Figure 11-lA
Null
Maximum
Response ----~~
' ____
......,... Max imum
Response
Null
Figure 11 - 1 B
Small Loop Receiving Antennas .,.. 145
/
of potential between segments of the conductor /
A
/
/
I
B
"'<
I
Minimum
4~-4~ * see t ext
Response
Cl*
A>5B
Vo
Figure 11 - 2
To RCVR
Fi g ure 11 - 3
Small Loop Receiving Antennas ..,. 747
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
Figure 11 -4
The actual voltage across the output termi- put voltage of a small loop with a vertical piece
nals of an untuned loop is a fu nction of the of che same kind of wire chat has a height of:
angle of arrival of the signal a (see Figure 11-4),
as well as the strength of the signal and the H _ 2nN A
design of the loop. The voltage V0 is given by: eff - 'A
Tuning of a remote loop can be a bother if Figure 11-7 shows h ow a remote tuning
done by hand, so some means must be found to scheme can work with loop antennas. The tun-
do it from the receiver location (unless you enjoy ing capacitor is a combination of a varactor
climbing into the attic or onto the roof). Tradi- diode and two optional capacitors: a fixed ca-
tional m eans of tuning called for using a low pacitor (C l ) and a trimmer (C2). The DC tun-
RPM D C motor, or stepper motor, to turn the ing voltage (Vr) is provided from the receiver
tuning capacitor. A very popular comb ination end from a fixed DC power supply (V+). A
was the little 1 to 12 RPM m otors used to drive potentiometer (R I) is used to set the voltage to
rotating displays in retail store show windows. the varactor, hence also to tune th e loop. A DC
But that approach is not really needed today. We blocking capacitor (C3) keeps the DC tuning
can use varactor voltage variable capacitance voltage from being shorted out by the receiver
diodes to tune the circuit. input circuitry.
A varactor works because the junction
capacitance of the diode is a function of the The "Embroiderloop"
applied reverse bias voltage. A high voltage (such Fashioning the loop is usually a bit of a
as 30 volts) drops the capacitance while a low chore, and winding even a dozen or so turns on
voltage increases it. Varactors are available with a large form can be daunting-especially since
maximum capacitances of 22, 33, 60, 100, and the turns keep falling off the form. I hit upon an
400 pF. The latter are of most interest ro us idea that allowed me to make a multi-turn trans-
because they have the same range as the tuning forme r loop in which the tuned loop (Ll) has
capacitors normally used with loops. Look for 14 turns, and the receiver coupling loop is two
service shop replacement diodes intended for turns. The loop is made of 16-conductor color-
use in AM broadcast band radios. A good selec- coded ribbon cable of the sort used by comput-
tion, wh ich I have used, is the NTE-618 device. erniks. Two wires in the center of the bundle
It produces a high capacitance > 400 pF, and a (grey and white) are used for L2, while all the
low of only a few picofarads over a range of 0 to rest are used for LI. The form is a 14-inch
15 volts.
V+
RI
/OK
Tune
Loop
Antenna
R2
DI lf7K
NTE-Lf IB
C3
Coax to Receiver 01 Jvtf
·=--------1 f-----+ To
Receiver
~-~--• Antenna
Input
Termina ls
Figure 11-7
Small Loop Receiving Antennas "" 151
BRN BRN
RED RED
OR OR
EL YEL
GRN GRN
BLU BLU
VIO VIO
GRY GRY
WHT WHT
BLK BLK
BRN BRN
RED RED
OR OR
YEL YEL
GRN GRN
BLU BLU
AZ
The inner loop is connected to a length of Ysx3x24-inch Bass wood "hobby board" stock
coaxial cable, which carries signal to the radio acquired from a local hobby shop. Model build-
receiver. The outer loop is connected to a ers use this wood as a stronger alternative to
variable tuning capacitor. I found that a 365 pF balsa wood.
"broadcas t band variable" capacitor was suffi- The electrical circuit of the Hobby Board
cient to tune the loop in all sections of th e AM Loop shown in Figure 11 - 11 is a transformer
band. But two or three 365 pF sections may be loop design . The main tuned loop is on the
n eeded in some cases where fewer turns are used. outside and consists of ten turns of #26 enam-
Figure 11-10 sh ows the completed loop antenna. eled wire. It is tuned by a 365 pF capacitor. The
inner loop is used for coupling to the receiver
The Square Hobby Board Loop and consists of a single turn of #22 insulated
A very common way to build a square loop solid h ook-up wire.
antenna is to take two pieces of thin lumber, The mechanical fit between the vertical and
place them in a cross shape, and then wind the horizontal wooden pieces is shown in Figure
wire around the ends of the wooden arms. T his 11-1 2 . Note that four Y2-inch wooden blocks
type of antenna is shown in Figure 11 - 11. T he (also obtained at the hobby shop) are glued to
wooden supports can be made of lx2 lumber, the junction of the two cross pieces in order to
or some other stock. A test loop made while stiffen the joint. Details for the boards are
researching thi s book was made with two shown in Figure 11-1 3. Each board is 24 inches
long. At the mid-point (1 2 "), there is alls-inch
wide, l 1/2-inch long slot cut. T hese slots are
used to mate the two boards together.
At each end there are ten tiny slits made by
a jeweler's saw (also called a "jig saw" in h obby-
ist circles) with a thin blade. These slits are just
wide enough to allow a single #26 wire to be
inse rted without slipping. T he slits are IA -inch
long, start 1/2-inch from one edge, and are
Vs-inch apart. There are ten slits on both ends
of the horizontal piece while the vertical piece
has ten slits on the top end and 11 slits on the
bottom end. The reason for offsetting the wire
slits is to allow room on the other side of the
3-inch width of the vertical member for a
mounting stick.
When assembling the antenna, use wood
glue on the mating surfaces, square them to be
at right angles to each other, and clamp the two
pieces in a vice or with C -clamps for 30 min-
utes (or longer if the glue maker specifies) .
Next, glue the support blocks into place and
clamp them for a similar period.
Small Loop Receiving Antennas ..- 753
Cl
365pF
Figure 11-11
Figure 11-12
Coupling
® Loop W ire
• A2
Cl
16 Turns 365pF
-
1--~ - Zlf" _ ____
_., ,
Figure 11-17
Figurell -1 6
•
Susan
wound over a section of %-inch
I
L3
L2 LLf
cf*
/ 90° Elbo~Tee"
LlA LlB
90° Elbow J
52fL Coaxia l
To RCVR
Coil L5 acts as a transformer secondary to the Before assembling th e Tee piece segment, it
main loop, and it supplies the output signal is necessary to wind the couplin g loop (L5).
from the loop. It worked well directly to a re- This coil is wo und directly on the ferrite rod
ceiver through 52 Q coaxial cable, but a pre- and not on the PVC pipe (Figure 11-23) . It
amplifier is nonetheless highly recommended. consists of four turns of #24 wire in the center
of the ferrite rod. Before winding L5, place a
Construction of the Ferriloop single layer of electrical tape at the point on the
The construction of three of the arms of the rod where the coil will be wound and for a
FerriLoop an tenna is shown in Figure 11 -22. An distance about one inch either side. Anchor one
81/2-inch long section of %-inch PVC plumbing end of the wire (with a second piece of tape) at
pipe is cut and the burrs trimmed off the ends. the point where the coil will start, and then
The ferrite rod will not fit snugly inside the wind four turns. The turns are wound so that
pipe, so the ends must be built up with masking each w ire touches its neighbor. ~en the fo ur
or electrical tape to form a tape plug. How turns are wound, anchor the oth er end of the
many turns of tape are required depends on the wire with another piece of electrical tape.
thickness of the tape you use. W ith the 3M Next, prepare a length ofRG-174/U coaxial
brand black electrical tape that I used, 13 turns cable. This cable is 52 Q coax, but is about half
were sufficient to allow a snug slip-fit that held the size of RG-58/U so is easy to use in applica-
the rod but did not require excess force to insert tions such as this antenna. Strip off the outer
it. You might find it advisable to plug the ends insulation and unbraid th e shield. Then twist
of the PVC pip e with wood glue or some other the unbraided shield rightly, and tin with solder
substance to furth er improve the stability of the to keep the strands from straying. Strip off about
rod inside the loop. a ~-inch of the in ner insulator to expose the
The section containing the Tee piece (refer inner conductor. Tin the inner conductor and
again to Figure 11 -2 1) is broken into two seg- then solder it to one end of coil L5; solder the
ments of PVC pipe, each 31/2 inches long, placed other end of L5 to the shield of the coaxial
on either side of th e Tee piece. Four small holes cable. After the entire assembly is finish ed, place
(I used a 3/ 16-inch bit) are drilled into the Tee a single turn of electrical tape over all connec-
at the points shown in Figure 11 -21 (holes A, B tions to further secure th em. Be careful not to
and C are shown; D is at the same point as C on build up the layer so much that it won't slip into
the opposite side of the Tee) . the Tee junction.
158 ..... Receiving Antenna Handbook
.
Fe rrite Rod -i LSI .
11
05
Solder Solder
To assemble the bottom portion of the an- The loop will tend to flex and become mis-
tenna, gather together che two 3Y2-inch sections shapen unless the pieces are glued together. After
of PVC pipe, the Tee junction, and the ferrite you assemble the unit to make sure all sizes are
rod. Insert one end of the ferrite rod into one of correct and it will actually fie together properly,
the PVC pipe pieces until it is about Y2-inch disassemble each joint and coat the %-inch PVC
from the far end. Next, insert the coaxial cable pipe ends with wood glue. You should use a glue
through hole "D " in the Tee junction and then that takes a few minutes to set up (I used Elmer's
pull some cable th rough to the outside (gently.0. wood glue) so chat th e antenna can be adjusted.
As you do this operation, slide the Tee over the Lay the glued assembly on a flat surface and
ferrite rod until LS is centered inside che Tee. square the corners in all planes. Leave it sitting
Pull all of the excess coax out so that only there undiscurbed uncil the glue is cured.
enough is left to prevent strain on the electrical Now it's time to add the main loop. For this
connections. Finally, place che ocher piece of operation we need about ten feet of #24 wire. I
PVC pipe over the ferrite rod and secure both used regular solid insulated hook-up wire, but
ends of the assembly with wood glue or oth er you might wane to use enameled magnet wire
"potting" substance. instead. Pass one end of the wire through hole
At this point, you should have three arms ''A" from th e outside towards the inside, and
containing rods 2, 3, and 4 plus a bottom sec- then pass it our the bottom of the Tee so that
tion containing rod 1 and che Tee section. These there is about eight inches of free wire. Anchor
sections are assembled into a square by using this wire temporarily with electrical tape. Next,
90° PVC elbow junctions at the corners (refer wind coil Ll A, securing it on either end with
again to Figure 11 -21). Each elbow is scored electrical cape. Pass the far end of the wire over
from one end to the other on the outer surface, che first elbow joint (so that che wire lays in the
with a triangle or flat file to form a "Vee" shaped vee groove), an choring either end with tape, and
wire groove. chen wind L2. Similarly, pass it over each elbow
Small Loop Receiving Antennas .,. 159
Shie~
I
I
I
I ' I
I
I
I
I I
I I
I
Loop .._ ~
® I
I
I I
-----
Loop
I I
Connect center
conductors
Sh ielded Box
Coax
Connectors
Coax To
Figure 11 - 28 RCVR
or RG-11 /U coaxial cable. T he cable is n ormally biliry an d may cause overload of th e receiver
supported by wooden cross arms, as in the other front-end circuitry.
forms of loop, but they are not shown here for Another problem with shortwave reception,
sake of simplicity. Note that, at the upper end, whether using a portable radio or a AC powered
the coaxial cable shields are not connected . radio, is due to the nature of ion osph eric short-
wave propagation. When signals are refracted in
Shortwave Performance the ionosphere, their components tend to spread
Enhancer Loop Antennas out, causing the signal to arrive at different
Small portable shortwave radios are not al- angles of arrival at d ifferent times . As the dy-
ways the best performers, although they work namic ionosphere changes , the angle of arrival
better today than ever in the past . Neverth eless, changes. These changes can occur over th e
they are severely "antenna limited." In most cas- course of a few minutes. C omm on loop anten-
es, the only antenna is a small telescoping whip nas aimed at th e desired station are reasonably
extending from the case of the radio. Attempts insensitive to changes of elevation angle of arriv-
to put up random length wire antennas of large al, but their null is essentially a point-source
size will help, but will destroy all of the porta- notch . T he solution to th e p roblem is to build
162 """ Receiving Antenna Handbook
antennas with a fan-shaped, adjustable null with A clever and simple-to-build antenna of this
reasonable insensitivity to the vertical angle. This class is shown in Figure 11-29. This loop anten-
class of antenna, popularized by Villard, includes na calls for a 30-inch single turn square loop
the single- turn, low-inductance wide loop. This antenna made from three-inch wide sheet metal
trick is seen in a lot of antenna books and maga- stock. The metal can be copper, aluminum, or
zine articles, and was also told to me by a mis- brass as available (not aluminum if you want to
sionary who worked in Sudan. This guy was a solder to it). A gap is left at one end to accom-
Swedish national and a ham radio operator, and modate the tuning capacitor, Cl. This capacitor
in the course of a three hour evening at Wheaton must be relatively large, on the order of 750 to
College taught me a lot of smoke about "anten- 1200 pF. This capacitance can be accommo-
naing" under bad circumstances and at low bud- dated by two-section and three-section AM
get. Some of his antennas are found in the broadcast band variable capacitors of 365 pF per
emergency antennas chapter of my other anders section (some capacitors, intended for superhet-
book, Radio Antenna Handbook published by erodyne radios, have two sections that are differ-
TAB/McGraw-Hill. (Buy two copies please, I ent capacitances) . On the same side of the loop
need the money.) as the gap there are four 5/32-inch holes (A, B,
C, and D) drilled to accommodate
mounting the loop to a lx2 wood-
en piece or other suitable support.
A wire that is equipped with an
alligator clip is attached to the loop,
and this clip will be connected to
the telescopic antenna on the por-
table radio. In operation, the loop
SheetMetal ~ can be oriented for best reception.
Cl (Each side is 30 '' X3 '')
~ 750pF Another example is the anten-
na designed by Villard as shown in
0
c Figure 11 -30. This antenna is made
ofwide metal conductors. Examples
include th e same type of hobbyist's
brass stock as used above. It can
also be copper foil or som e other
stock that can be soldered. Some
electronic parts stores sell adhesive
backed foil stock used for making
printed circuit boards. The foil can
Portable be glued to some flat insulating
HF Radio surface. Although 3/s-inch plywood
0 0
0
gQ springs to mind immediately, another
alternative is found in artists' supplies
stores. Ordinary poster board is too
Figure 11-29 floppy to stand up, bur poster board
Small Loop Receiving Antennas ... 163
A---.i~1
(four inches), then the induc-
1~ tance increases and only 28 pF
are needed at 15 MHz. The larger
size loop can be used at lower
frequencies as well. For example,
the 91 cm loop will resonate at
I
I
6 MHz with 177 pF.
Antenna ~: To use this antenna, position
(see text) the radio's telescopic antenna
Cl RI close and adjacent to the loop
365 SOK
pF but not touching it. The loop an -
tenna can be rotated to find the
B
best position to either null or
-0--------
enhance a particular station. T he
Radio --'..-~:
Position ' "Lazy Susan" idea will work well
in this case.
Table ~
A traditional method is
shown in Figure 11-31. These
Figure 11 - 30 antennas consist of two small
loops spaced d < Al 4 apart, but
not too close. The version in
glued to a Styrofoam backing can be used. It is Figure l l -32A consists of two
extremely easy to work with using X-acto knives
and other common household tools.
Two controls are used on this antenna. Capa-
citor C l tunes the loop to the resonant frequency
of the desired station. Potentiometer Rl is used Small Loop
as a phasing control. The dimensions of the
Whip Antenna ----.
antenna are not terribly
critical, although some
guidelines are in order. In
the Villard article, he
recommended a 40 cm
(15. 75-inch) square loop
("A") . If the loop is 7.62 149 97
Paper Sheet
cm (three inches) wide, ===o
the antenna will resonate Metal Plate 0
at 15 MHz with around
33 pF of capacitance. If rC-----~
~ "Lazy Susan''
the dimensions are in-
creased to A = 9 1 cm (36
inches) and B = 10.16 cm Figure 11 - 31
164 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
vertical coaxial loops (the loops are on the same Testing Your Loop Antenna
axis, not that they are made of coaxial cable) . W hen each loop prototype was completed,
This antenna is less sensitive to skywave error I tested it on th e AM broadcast band over
than sin gle lo ops, but at the expen se of several evenings. T he same procedure can be
changing the pattern. This style of antenna has used with any loop. A strong local signal at
a four lobe "cloverleaf" pattern. T he second 1310 kHz served to check the pattern. The
class of antenna is the horizontal coplanar loops station and my home were located on U.S.
of Figure l l -32B. This antenna retains the Geological Survey 7.5-minute quadrangle maps
figure-8 pattern fo r d < A/4, and produces a of my area. The maps had adjacen t coverage, so
minimal elevation skywave erro r. Both of these the compass bearing from my location to the
antennas can be mechanically rotated in either station co uld be determin ed. Checkin g the an-
azimuth or elevation in order to find the best tenna showed an 57 /S8 signal when the loop
reception conditions. was endwise to the station-that is, the station
was in one of its lobes. Rotating the loop so
that its broadside faced the direction of the
station dropped the signal strength to less than
S 1, and frequently bottomed out the meter.
Because my receiver has a 3-dB/S-un it calibra-
tion on the S-meter, I figured the null to be
more than 20 dB, although it will take a bit
more exp erimentation to find the actual depth.
This test is best done d uring day-
ligh t hours, I fo und out, because
there is always a residual sky wave
cacophony on the AM band that
raises the S-meter "floor" in th e null.
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
/
Figure 11-33
60°- 90°
L/
I
The other use is illustrated by the case of a also null the desired station in the opposite
friend of mine. H e regularly tunes in clear direction.
channel W SM (65 0 kH z, Nashville) in the wee One method is to use a sense antenna to
hours between Saturday evening ("Grand O le spoil the pattern of the loop to a cardioid
Opry" time) and dawn. H owever, that "clear" shape. Another method is to use a spoiler loop
channel of WSM isn't really so clear, especially to null the undesired signal. The spoiler loop is
without a narrow filter in the receiver. H e uses a large box loop placed one to three feet (found
a loop antenna to null out a nearby 630 kHz experimentally) behind the recep tion loop in
signal that made listening a bit dicey, and can the direction of th e offending signal. T his
now tap e his 1940s/ 1950s vintage country method was first described by Levintow and is
music. detailed in Figure 11-33. T h e small loopstick
It isn't n ecessary to place the desired station may be the anten na inside th e receiver, while
directly in the main lobes off the ends of the che large loop is a box loop such as th e Sports
antenna, but rather place the nulls (broadside) Fan's Loop. The large box loop is placed about
in the direction of the offending station chat one to three fee t behind the loopstick and in
you want to eliminate. So what happens if the the direction of the offending station. The
offending station and the d esired station are in an gle with respect to the line of centers should
a direct line with each other with your receiv- be 60° to 90°, which is also found experimen-
ing location in the middle between chem ? Boch tally. It's also possible to use two air core loops,
nulls and lobes on a loop antenna are bidirec- such as those in Figures 11-8 and 11 -1 4, to
tional, so a null on the offending station will produce an asymmetrical receiving pattern.
166 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
Tl
+ 12
VDC C:::V ires Twisted
Together
Tl J2
C2
,------ $ 50.fl.
Output
0.33},\J 1
I
I
101: Si licon NPN
1 High Frequency
Cl Transistor (2N5179
JI I 0.33Jvl.f ECG - 316,NTE - 316,
EC G- 108,NTE -108, etc)
50.fl. ~----<I 1--- --e-- - - -- -r
Input 1
Figure 11 - 34
Small Loop Receiving Antennas .,,. 167
+12VDC
C6 RIO RI/ C7
0.1_µ,f 47 47 0.1_µ,f
_[)_ _[)_
_rl +
ri
C2
RFCI
lmH
-1 l_µf
C5
RFC2
lmH
0. 1_µ,f 0.1_µ,f
R5
3.3K C9
R6 0.1_µ,f 50
Cl
RI
240
_[)_
R5
3.3K
C4
0.1}.{J
2Lf0
.n. fou-Pput
0.1_µ,f
o----1 ,_____ ------+--<
From
R7
IK
Loop
R2
J_ IK
cs
0.1_µ,f
Figure 11 - 35
ings of Tl are twisted together, about eight stages can be cascaded for 40 dB of gain,
twists to the inch, and then wo und over the although one must be cautious to observe good
form as if they were a single wire. I make twist- layout practices in such a case (inadvertent feed-
ed enameled wire for baluns by taking a length back can cause oscillation wh en gains are high) .
of #26 enamel insulated wire, folding it back The amplifier of Figure 11 -35 is useful at
on itself, and then chucking it up in a hand full sp ecifica tion gain from about 1 MHz
drill. Anchor the far end in a vise, and then thro ugh out the shortwave bands. At lower fre-
turn the crank on the drill to twist the wire . quen cies, gain will drop off somewhat, but that
T his operation can be done on an electrical doesn't necessarily mean that it becomes useless.
drill, if the drill has a gentle trigger and speed Besides, you can make certain modifications that
control, but can be DANGEROUS. If you do will coax (that's "coax," not "co-ax" like the
this operation, then wear safety goggles or glass- transmission line!) a little more gain out of the
es to protect your eyesight. If that wire comes circuit at VLF frequencies. For example, all of
loose and starts whipping around, it could dam- the coupling and deco upling capacitors (that is,
age your eyes. every one but C2 and C5) can be increased in
A related amplifier circuit is shown in Figure value to accommodate lower frequencies. I no-
11 -35. This circuit also uses the 2N51 79 tran- ticed a bit more gain by using 0.47 µF instead of
sistor, or its service grade replacements. The 0. 1 µF fo r those capacitors. You can also in-
amplifier consists of two identical stages, each crease the values of the RF chokes (RFC 1 and
of which provides 10 dB of gain. Up to four RFC2) from 1 mH to 2.5 mH.
168 • Receivi n g A ntenn a Handbook
D
56
.n. J2
th at works well into
the VHF region .
Suitab le replace- =
Cq Output f
ments from the service sh op lines of IIOOpF
devices include the ECG-312 and the
Figure 11 - 36
N TE-312. Because the application is
not terribly critical, and the devices are
not expensive, it is reasonable to exp eri-
ment with other JFET devices if they
+
are more readily available than those
+9VDC_l
selected here.
All of the preamplifier circuits in R2
th is section can be used w ith either 100
.n. C4
tuned or unruned loops, although
o. 1µf
neither the loop nor the tuning capaci-
tor are shown in all cases.
C2
200µf
~--<l---+
-'--1 I--__,,_ _ __ ... 01
MPF-102
Loop Cl RI
IOOK
C3
1----ITo J I
-
Receiver
o.1µf -
= RFCI
2.5mH
Figure 11-37
Small Loop Receiving Antennas -.. 769
To Receiver
or Preamplifier +9VDC
L2 Coupling
Loop
C2
200}M
01
+ MPF-102
Q-Multiplier
Loop
Antenna
LI
Cl IOOk
L3
0
Multiplier
Feedback
Figure 11 - 38
CHAPTER 12
Low Frequency
Antennas
he low frequency (below 6 MHz) antenna
T is a Particularly Perplexing Problem (dare
we call it a "p3''???) for most people. There is a
support the dipole (properly connected to a herd
of cows to supply the methane needed for the
burner, of course). And a vertical antenna is no
large amount of interesting DX on the low fre- less problematic. Quarter-wavelength vertical
quencies (which we'll define as near DC to about antennas wo uld rapidly become too high for
6 MHz or so). Unfortunately, many of the easy or economical construction, and would be
wonderful antennas that I've discussed in this illegal under existing zoning and engineering
book are "as useless as teats on a boar hog... " (to regulations in most locations. And while the
coin a phrase) on low frequencies because of on e Beverage is always a good bet if you own a farm
little problem: they're too darn big. The size of or have some mighty tolerant neighbors, its 600
resonant antennas varies inversely with frequen- to 1500 foot length reduces its appeal and practi-
cy, so we can expect low frequency anders to be cality fo r most p eople.
a mighty assemblies indeed. Consider the ubiq- There are any numb er of other reasons why
uitous (that's a fancy word for "seen every- conventional half- and quarter-wavelength an-
where") half-wavelength dipole. A 6 MHz dipole tennas become less and less practical as the oper-
is a reasonable 78 feet long. But in the marine ating frequency decreases, bu t those given above
radiotelephone band (e.g., 2182 kHz), the di- are probably sufficiently depressing to render
pole antenna becomes 215 feet long, and in the yo u senseless. Let's press on and prevent a gener-
m iddle of the AM broadcast band ( 1 MHz or alized weltschmertz from setting in. It is, after all,
1000 kHz) it becomes 468 feet long. On 1600 somewhat more rewarding to dwell on possi-
kHz, at the top end of the AM broadcast band, bilities than on what can't be done.
the dipole is 293 feet long and wants to be at Low frequency receiving systems depend in
least as high. On the low end of the AM band- part on the propagation phenomena applicable
550 kHz-the dipole becomes 850 feet long to those frequencies and also to the practices of
and its ideal A/2 mounting height wo uld look radio stations operating there. As the frequency
down on the Washington Monument (555 feet drops, there is an increased tendency to see both a
tall, provided it has stopped sinking like the ground wave and a sky wave. In some situations,
dollar) from a height of nearly 300 feet. both may arrive at a distant receive site (although
T he dipole antenna should be installed half- that is rare) and interfere with each other. When
wavelength above the ground, or about as high DXing the AM broadcast band, signals, espe-
as it is long. An AM broadcast band dipole, cut cially on ground wave, tend to be vertically polar-
for midband, would require two Washington ized. This is in co ntrast to higher frequencies
Monuments, spaced their own height apart, to where the polarization may be skewed by propa-
support the optimal half-wavelength dipole. Or gation conditions even though the signal started
maybe two hot air balloons could be used to out as either horizontal or vertical.
172 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
Obvious Solutions
T here are, fo rtunately, several obvious solu-
tions that lend themselves well to the low fre-
quency antenna problem. For SWLs, there are
more solutions than for ham operators because
some antennas, such as the small loop, are very
good on receive but work poorly on transmit. Tap ~ L2
Indeed, some ham operators operating on the
80- and 160-meter bands will use a sm all loop
antenna on their receiver, m ostly to null out
T8'
interfe ring signals, and a dipole or other full
sized antenna on transmit. l
You might be well advised to consider a loop
antenna because they work very well fo r low
~ LI
frequency reception while offering very deep l-=
nulls (for removing interferen ce) that wo uld
otherwise require large-very large at low fre- Figure 12- 1 -=
quencies- arrays to otherwise achieve.
Another approach is to use a loaded antenna
of one sort or another. T hese antennas are phys- Figure 12-1 shows a rypical low frequency
ically shorter than the full sized quarter-wave or antenna made from either a single 16-fo ot long
half-wave antenna, and perform well en ough to thickwall section of PVC pipe, or two eight-foo t
be quite useful. D o they perform as well as the sections coupled at the middle. There are two
full sized antennas? In a word: heckno. But when coils used in this antenna. Inductor Ll is used to
the decision is optimum perfo rmance ve rsus any impedance match the feedpoint of the an tenna
performance at all, th en you might be enticed to to the 50 Q system impedance used by th e
try one of these compensation antennas. Besides, receiver; a length of 52 Q coaxial cable is used to
the co rrect comparison is between the com pen- connect the tap on this coil to the receiver. The
sation antenna and a random length wire of other coil in Figure 12-1 , L2, is a loading coil.
convenient size rather than an optimal antenna. Its use is to increase the effective len gth of the
The random length wire is, after all, the option antenn a. All antennas that are used on frequen-
that most people will otherwise select. cies lower than their natural resonant frequency
exhibit a capacitance, and this capacitance has a
capacitive reactance. Inductive reactance will
Loaded "Plumber's Delight" cancel capacitive reactance, so coil L2 is needed
Vertical to "rune" the antenna to the operating frequency.
We've seen in a previous ch apter how vertical Fo r p ractical use in the 2 to 7 MHz band-
antennas can be constructed using PVC pipe to assuming a two to three inch PVC pipe and two
support the antenna wiring. T he same technique vertical runs of wire (# 12, # 14, or # 16), each
can be used when building a low frequency eight feet long- we can make L2 of 30 turns of
antenna. #16 enameled wire closely wound . Tap the coil
Low Frequency Antennas ,. 173
every five turns or so in order to find the exact Using a CB Whip On The Low
inductance needed, and to accommodate differ- Frequencies
ent bands. A tap is made by scraping the enam- Figure 12-2 shows two ways to use a nine
eled insulation off the wire at the correct point, foot CB whip antenna on low frequencies. One
and soldering the tap wire to it. Some authori- method is to treat it as a very short random
ties actually made a little loop of the wire used length wire antenna, albeit in the vertical posi-
for the coil at that point to facilitate tapping. tion, and use a reverse L-section antenna tuner
Tuning the loaded vertical can be a little to match the impedance to the 50 Q used by the
tricky if you are not equipped with proper in- receiver. Typical values for the components will
strumentation. The best way is to use a VSWR be 140 pF for the capacitor (Cl) and 28 µH for
meter, dipper, a noise bridge, or some other the inductor (Ll ). These values can be increased
instrument that is legal for SWLs to use (that is, or decreased if it is found that they are
it doesn't require a ham transmitter for RF exci- insufficient for any particular installation. If you
tation). Another way that's a little flaky but buy an antenna tuner for this application, then
often works is to pick a strong station at a dis- select one that will match a high impedance to a
tance, on a frequency where you want to listen, low impedance, rather than a mere "line flat-
and then find the correct tap by looking at tener'' (typical of coax-to-coax tuners).
the S-meter of the receiver. The maximum The m ethod of Figure 12-2 does
signal strength is theoretically found wh en not actually resonate the antenna,
the tap is correctly set. T he reason this but rather it matches the high
method is a bit flaky is that the changes are impedance to the receiver sys-
going to be very subtle-so subtle, in fact, tem impedance. An alter-
that ordinary fading (and oth er variation) native is to use a loading
in the signal strength may easily be mis- 9' coil (see inset for Figure
taken for the correct setting (or obscure the 12-2) to bring the an-
correct setting). For this reason, I recom- tenna to resonance.
m end using an instrumentation approach.
After all, if you're going to be active in the Antenna Tuner
shortwave h obby, the price
of the instrument will
be justified over
time.
Load ing
Co il
T he value of the loading coil requi red varies All-Band (More or Less)
somewhat depending on th e details of the local Shortwave/Low Frequency
environment where the antenna is installed, Antenna
but a reasonable approximation is found from Figure 12-4 sh ows a vertical antenna that
th e curves in Figure 12-3 . Two curves are can be used for n early the entire sh ortwave
sh own , one each for base mounting and center sp ectrum from 2 to 30 MHz depending on the
mounting of the loading coil. components selected. The 16-foot to 18-foot
One of the nice features of this antenna is radiator element is either aluminum tubing, or
that it can be an indoor antenna, even in the PVC pipe fitted with wire (as described above).
attic of some h ouses, fo r those SWLs who live The entire length of the antenna should be
in neighborhoods with restrictions on building vertical, although a single conductor "down-
antennas. lead" to an antenna tuning unit close to the
receiver can become part of its overall length.
1000
T he versatility of this antenna is derived
900
800
from the tuning network at the base. This
700 tuner can be placed at the receiver location,
600 if a single wire feedline is used, but that is
not the best solution "antenna wise"
500
(even though it might be as a practical
~
'100 consideration) .
~c T h e inductor should have a
::r 300 ~,.....
~ maximum value of 25 to 40 µH,
(i)
u 200 dbO'~ <oOQ< and is tapped twice. One tap
c
0
+)
<oOo.< ~O" provides an impedan ce match to
u 100
the receiver (50 Q), while the
::J ~O"
-0 90 other provides the correct load-
c 80
f---1 ing ind uc tan ce to m ake th e
70
antenna reso nant on a low fre-
60
50
quen cy. At these low frequencies,
the switch is closed so the "cold"
'10
end of the coil is grounded. At
30 higher frequencies, where the an-
tenna length is close to or more
20 than a quarter-wavelength, the
switch is opened and the capaci-
10 tor used to counteract some of
2 3 'I 5 6 7
the inductive reactance of the an-
Frequency (MHz) tenna and loading coil, effec-
tively shortening the anten na. In
Loading Co i I I nductance (jvtH) for 8' Whip those cases, th e loadin g coil tap
and the impedance matching tap
Figure 12- 3 may nearly or actually coincide.
Low Frequency Antennas T 175
at 5 M H z. A half-wavelength of wire at this antennas for same) o r from car radio antennas.
frequency is about 100 feet. To make the heli- Adjustment of the helically wound antenna
cally wound vertical, then, 100 feet of insulated is done similarly to any other antenna. The
wire (any type) is wound so that it is evenly correct wire len gth is found experimentally by
spaced over the entire 16 feet oflength. using a grid dip m eter, impedance m eter, SWR
The helically wound antenna simulates a meter, or noise bridge. The feedpoint imped-
quarter-wavelength vertical, bur typically is much ance tends to be very low, about 4 Q , so either a
higher "Q'' than a full-sized vertical. As a result, b roadb and imp edance transfo rm er or an
th e h elically wound antenna is much narrower antenna tuning unit is needed.
in bandwidth than the full-sized version. In order
to alleviate that problem, it is common to use a Ground Systems for
capacity hat made from fo ur to six rods measur- Low Frequency Antennas
ing eight to 12 inches (brazing rods or hobby A good ground is important for all antennas,
brass rod stock are popular) arranged evenly especially unbalanced typ es, but it is even more
spaced around the anten na at th e top end. Some critical in the low frequen cy bands. Whenever
people report that a ten to 12 inch aluminum yo u see the ground symbol in the illustrations in
pie p an works just as well, although it tends to this chapter, assume that it refers to a very good
look a bit tacky. Earrh ground or to at least a multiple radial
T he actual length required of the antenna is counterpoise ground. Such a counterp oise need
found experimentally. The interaction of the not have straigh t radials, but they at least should
turns of wire change the physical length required be resonant. Keep in mind that the efficiency of
to achieve an electrical half-wavelength. Some a compensation antenn a is poorer than full-
p eople use a telescoping whip antenna at the top sized antennas at best, so we don't want to burn
fo r tuning to resonance. These whips are sal- up any more signal in losses than is absolutely
vaged from portable radios (or new replacement necessary. Get a good ground!
CHAPTER 13
MFJ AN TE N NA TUNER
111!1 . . .
.
.
. .
M O<h· I M f J lhllll'
..
.
in earlier chapters.
Pream plifiers 111 / llllf l\H Hll \ \ I II \Ill /'~I 1111~ IHI R
lhtk,C. TOA fttcT(M lA
• f ••
restricted to powerful, well-heard stations, or if signals. In fact, they can't receive signals that
you're using a "full size" antenna, odds are that aren't present. An active antenna used inside a
you will seldom need to use a preamplifier. metal frame structure, such as a high rise apart-
ment building, or one with aluminum siding
Active Antennas such as my house, will not pick up signals that
Active antennas are very short (two to six are shielded by the metal building ... and most
feet) antennas that include a built-in preamplifi- will be. If some signal is present, and the electri-
er. They are used to replace longer antennas in cal n oise is not too high, then the active antenn a
places where a longer antenna is not viable, such will work reasonably well if the signal's strength
as when you're an apartment dweller, townhouse is not too low.
or rowhouse dweller, or live in a single family Ir is also possible to build your own active
h ouse with a lot too small to support even a antenna by using a preamplifier with a physically
limited space antenn a. You m ight also be a shortened antenna, a len gth of aluminum
listener who lives in a rented house owned by a tubing, or random length of wire. This can be a
landlord with no sympathy for the shortwave versatile solution and less expensive than many
listening hobby. active antennas.
Unfortunately, the active antenna has been
touted perhaps a little too much by advertisers Indoor Antennas
in the shortvvave industry. I don't believe that, Indoor antennas are relatively easy to install,
when all factors are considered, an active anten- and except for certain circumstances wo rk quite
na will actually work as well overall as a 50 to well. Indoor antennas typically don't work as
100 foot random length wire antenna. However, well as the same antenna outdoors, bur in so me
there are situations where they are very useful, cases the differen ces aren't profound.
especially when living under some of the con- Several problems insinuate themselves into
straints noted above. Don't expect a miracle, the indoor antenna installation. Perhaps the
however. Try an active antenna, if you must, but most important is the matter of safety. You don't
expect to h ave to live with the defects. want to install the wire where humans or pets
Some of the defects are those that also afflict can tangle with it. It can be quite dangerous to
a preamplifier: strong signals will overload some be trotting towards what the British call the
active antennas. If there is no filtering in the "loo" and get decapitated by a wire antenna.
front-end , then you will find that local AM Place the wire where it can't be a hazard.
stations rend to "swamp" an active antenna badly. The attic o r loft probably represents the best
Also, the electrical noise inside a building te nds alternative for indoor antennas. In the attic or
to become worse when an active antenna is used loft, the antenna is well hidden. Besides, it is
because the antenna amplifies noise as much as also above most of the effects of siding, wiring,
it does real signals. Various electrical noises are and plumbing so it will probably work better
all seen as valid signals by the active antenna- than most other indoor antennas. To support
and are amplified. The noise also afflicts regular antennas in the attic, you can use television
wire antennas (they are real signals, after all) but antenna wire stand-off insulators screwed into a
the wire antennas don't amplify the mess. roof rafter or truss. Don't screw these into the
A false premise h eld by many fa ns of active roof itself, especially if it penetrates to the out-
antennas is that they will magically pick up side-the screw threads can serve as a "wick" to
Odds and Ends "' 181
draw water into the attic, rotting the wood attic, then a route th rough the ceiling of a closet
around the screw. is an unobtrusive way to run th e coax or down-
The random length wire is probably the lead.
most common attic antenna. It can be installed Another popular form of attic antenna is th e
out of the way to p revent interference from mobile antenna. For years, hams have done this
people trying to stuff stuff into the attic, or trick. A pair of loaded whips, fed back to back,
balancing precariously on the rafters trying become a decent replacement for a short, loaded
desperately not to get fiberglass on your skin. dipole. Adjusting the coil values will make such
Be careful in the attic, by the way. Most antennas work on the shortwave broadcastin g
attics are not finished, and the only thing be- bands as well.
tween you and the floor below is a bit of half-
inch dry wall and a coating of paint. If there is Clandestine, Stealth, and
no floo r in the attic, then stay on the wooden Disguised Antennas
joists .. .or you might accidentally drop into the Some people are in a seemingly intractable
loo while someone ... errr .. . looses, so to speak. situation regarding receiving antennas. The home-
Attic antenna feed lines can b e routed owners association, the landlord, or some other
through the walls to your receiver if the correct Person of High er Authority just simply won't
path can be found . Avoid paths that also include (won't won't won't) let you put up an antenna.
the electrical wires. Not only is there a potential There are several approaches that can be taken:
electrical hazard, but the power wires sometimes 1. H ire a witch doctor to stick pins in a
carry loads of noise signals, and they can couple little doll that has a photo print of the offender's
into the receiver th ro ugh the antenna line. In face pasted on it.
cases where the receiver is on the floor below the 2. Wish fervently (the ferventer the better)
that they be visited by a thousan d cockroaches,
all of them the size of ducks .
3 . Ch eat. Put up an antenna that n o on e
Flog Pole2_____.
knows is an an tenna.
Of these, option num ber three seems to be
the most viable. It is quite possible to make an
antenna that either doesn't look like an antenna,
isn't easily seen, or is only used intermittently
and is retracted at oth er times.
One method for making a clandestine-sorta-
stealthy antenna is the old flagpole trick as
W ire shown in Figure 13-3. A flagpole is a deligh tful
vertical and can even be tuned at the base if the
tuning unit is unobtrusive. In some cases, the
flag pole is metal, so yo u can either shunt feed
the pole or insulate it from ground and feed it
the regular way. If the flagpole is fiberglass (or
other insulating m aterial), then pass a wire up
Figure 13- 3
through the center of it (see Figure 13-3 inset).
182 .... Receiving Antenna Handbook
Antenna
Receiver
S- Meter
Noise Bridge
R X 11758 IAI
I====~ Ant Tune
Antenna
Connection 00
______ RCVR
.._ _, 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
Figure 13-5
,,
'
Figure 13-6
Figure 13-6 shows the "R-X Noise Bridge" An "SWL-Legal" VSWR Analyzer
from Palomar Engineers. This is a low cost Measuring VSWR is relatively easy for ama-
noise bridge that I've used for several years teur radio operators: they excite th e antenna with
and have found quite competent for its in- their transmitters and then measure the forward
tended applications. Other manufacturers of- and reflected power levels. They can either calcu-
fer noise bridges as well. If antenna building late the VSWR from a standard formula (or look
becomes your thing and you want to know it up on a nonomograph), or they can use a RF
just what the impedance of an antenna is, power meter calibrated for VSWR as well as in
then you'll need to add a noise bridge to your watts. But SWLs have a problem. They are not
set of tools. allowed to use transmitters, and most signal gen-
184 .._ Receiving Antenna Handbook
Bibliography and
Further Reading
American Radio Relay League, ARRL Antenna Misek, Victor, The Beverage Antenna Handbook.
Handbook. American Radio Relay League Published by the author; 142 Wason Road,
(multiple editions) . Hudson, N H , 03051.
Bryant, John, "Beverage Antennas" in Fine Tun- National Radio Club, Beverage and Longwire
ing Proceedings 1989 (available from Fine Antennas: Design and Theory. Available from
Tuning Special Publications, c/o John Bry- National Radio Club Publications Center, P
ant, Route 5, Box 14, Stillwater, OK, 0 . Box 164, Mannsville, NY, 13661.
74074).
National Radio Club, Loop Antennas: Design and
Carr, Joseph J. , Practical A ntenna Handbook. Theory. Available from National Radio Club
TAB/McGraw-Hill, 1991. Publications Center, P 0 . Box 164, Manns-
ville, NY, 13661.
Eldridge, Bob, "The Wave (Beverage) Antenna:
D esign and Operation," in Fine Tuning Pro- Orr, William I., Radio Handbook. Howard W
ceedings 1991 (available from Fine Tuning Sams & Co., Inc. (multiple editions) .
Special Publications, c/o John Bryant, Route Wire Antennas for Radio Amateurs. Radio
5, Box 14, Stillwater, OK, 74074) . Publications, Inc., 1972.
Levintow, Mike, "Using Two Loop Antennas to Villard, 0. G., "Indoor Interference-Reducin g
Generate Asymmetrical Receiving Patterns," Antennas for Sh ortwave Listening" in News-
National Radio Club reprint # 13. Available letter of the Association of North American
from National Radio C lub Publications Radio Clubs, January, 1990.
Center, P 0. Box 164, Man nsville, NY, "Miniature Indoor Directional An tennas
1366 1. fo r Reducin g Sky-Wave and Gro und-Wave
Interferen ce in the Shortwave Bands" in
Marris, Richard Q., "Experimental Quadraform Newsletter of the Association ofNorth Ameri-
Ferrite Transmit/Receive Antenna" in Elek- can Radio Clubs, March, 1990.
tor Electronics USA, November, 1991. "Combating Interference in Shortwave
"Imp rovin g Portable Radio Pe rfor- Reception with Compact Indoor Directive
mance" in Elektor Electronics USA, February, Antennas" in World Radio-Television Hand-
1992. book, 1990.
187
Index
formula for determining length, 57-58
impedance of, 60-61
Active antennas, 180
inverted-Vee, 66
Air core loops, 145-147 loaded, 66-68
Angle of arrival, 2 mulriband, 70-7 1
Angle of maximum response, 10 radiation patterns, 58-60
Angle of radiation and reception, 76, 121 rotatable, 131
tilted center-fed terminated folded, 68-69
Antenna patterns, 3, 8-10
trap, 7 1-72
Azimuth pattern, 3
Directional antennas, 5-8
Discone antenna, 176
D Diversity effect, 76
Beamwidth, 11
Double extended Zepp antenna, 109
Baluns, 64, 72-7 4
Double (stacked) dipole, 108
Base loaded antennas, 122
Beverage antennas, 92-1 01
Bobtail curtain arrays, 138-1 39 DI
Electrostatic discharge con uol, 102-103
Elevation pattern, 3
D
Capture area, 7
Cardioid pattern, 9 D
Ferrite core loops, 156-1 59
Center loaded antennas, 122
Folded dipole, 62-64
Characteristic impedance, 35
Coaxial cable, 43-46
Coaxial "Tee" antenna, 17 6 B
Gain, 3
Collinear "Franklin" array antenna, 11 O
Ground plane antenna, 123-1 24
Counterpoises, 123- 124
Ground systems, 14-16, 178
Ground wires, 14
El GSRV doublet, 105- 106
Decibels, 3-4
Delta fed antennas, 122
Dipole antennas: III
Half-delta sloper, 116
double (stacked), 108
folded, 62-64 Helically wound antenna, 177-178
188 • Receiving Antenna Handbook
1111 El
Impedance, 11 Marconi antenna, 53-56
Incident wave, 4-5 Multiband dipoles, 70-71
Indoor antennas, 180- 181
Installing antenna masts, 22-27
Insulators, 28-3 1
El
Noise bridges, 182- 183
Inverted-Vee antenna, 66 Noise considerations in antenna selection ,
Isotrop ic source, 3 21-22
When installing ground wires for antennas, it is critical to ensure they are legal under local electrical codes. The ground wire should be made of aluminum or copper and be as large as possible for optimal performance and safety . Additionally, grounding systems must be properly designed to provide protection against lightning and electrical failures, with a heavy ground wire connected from a lightning arrestor to a ground rod . Local codes might require eight-foot copperclad steel ground rods for proper lightning protection, and these requirements may also be stipulated by homeowners insurance policies . Furthermore, incorrect grounding, like connecting to a gas pipe, can be illegal and dangerous . Another legal consideration is the requirement for permits for antenna installation, which might apply depending on local regulations .
The design of random length antennas impacts their installation and performance due to their non-resonant nature, meaning they are not naturally tuned to any specific frequency range. As such, they exhibit varying impedance across different frequencies, which can lead to poor impedance matching and affect performance unless an antenna tuning unit (ATU) is used . Using variable inductors and capacitors with an ATU allows the antenna to simulate longer or shorter physical lengths, aiding in frequency tuning . Installation considerations include proper support, such as trees or masts, ensuring antennas are clear of physical obstructions . Additionally, proper grounding and lightning protection, such as connecting to an eight-foot ground rod and using a lightning arrestor, are vital for safety and optimal performance . The inclusion of ground radials can also enhance performance significantly for the bands they are cut for .
Shielded loop antennas mitigate interference by reducing interaction with ground and nearby structures, which can distort the antenna pattern. The shield blocks voltage signals and electrostatic interactions while leaving the magnetic component, responsible for picking up signals, unaffected. This is typically achieved by wrapping the loop in conductive foil or embedding it in a conductive frame, with a gap left in the shield to avoid affecting the magnetic field .
Antenna patterns, such as lobes, significantly influence the performance of antennas. Main lobes are the primary direction of radiation or reception, while minor lobes and nulls affect signal strength and quality. The directivity and gain of an antenna are partially determined by the angles of the main lobes, with closer main lobe angles suggesting higher directivity and improved gain over a dipole . As the length of an antenna changes, the angles of lobes shift, affecting the directivity and gain characteristics . For longwire antennas, the number of lobes and their positions also depend on the wire length, impacting how signals are received or transmitted . Interlobes or nulls in the pattern represent areas with weak or no signal reception, which are crucial for targeting specific signals while minimizing interference from other directions .
A folded dipole antenna offers several advantages over a traditional dipole. It typically has a higher impedance, at about 300 ohms, compared to the traditional dipole which is near 73 ohms, resulting in better impedance matching with certain transmission lines . The folded dipole has a broader bandwidth, allowing it to receive a wider range of frequencies effectively, acting almost like a multiband antenna . Additionally, the folded dipole has a more even radiation pattern, potentially providing a more consistent signal reception from various directions due to its nearly omnidirectional low-angle radiation when mounted properly , whereas the traditional dipole is more directional with its characteristic "figure-8" pattern . In terms of construction, folded dipoles can be more complex due to the additional elements and connections required, but they can be advantageous in reducing interference and achieving better overall performance in certain setups .
The Tee antenna and the random length antenna both have similar performance characteristics for shortwave reception, as neither provides a significant advantage over the other in typical setups . Both types are untuned and non-resonant, meaning they do not naturally match the impedance of the receiver across a wide frequency range, which can result in inefficient power transfer and weakened signal reception . This impedance mismatch can be mitigated with an antenna tuning unit, which can help optimize performance by adjusting inductance and capacitance, effectively altering the perceived electrical length of the antenna . Additionally, both antennas benefit from a proper ground connection, which enhances performance and provides safety through a lightning arrestor . A Tee antenna distinguishes itself by employing a vertical section for its downlead, helping to position the antenna wire at a convenient right angle . This setup can be useful when natural supports are available to maintain the wire's orientation over a building . Overall, neither antenna provides significantly better performance over the other without additional tuning devices, and choice between them can often depend on available installation options rather than performance metrics .
Impedance matching is crucial for optimal antenna signal reception because it ensures maximum power transfer between the antenna and the receiver. This occurs when the antenna's impedance, the transmission line's characteristic impedance, and the receiver's input impedance are equal . If the impedances are not matched, part of the signal reflects back towards the source, causing a loss in the received signal strength . This mismatch also affects the voltage standing wave ratio (VSWR), where a VSWR close to 1:1 indicates minimal signal loss and optimal power transfer. An ideal matched system minimizes signal reflection and maximizes reception quality . Proper impedance matching can be achieved either by adjusting the antenna to resonance or using an antenna tuning unit to transform mismatched impedances to the desired value ."}
The capture area of a receiver antenna, also called aperture, is a crucial factor determining its effectiveness because it relates directly to how much power can be collected from the radio waves incident upon the antenna. A larger capture area allows the antenna to intercept more power from the radio signal, which is then delivered to the receiver, improving Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) and potentially enhancing reception quality . The capture area is sometimes more substantial than the physical area of the antenna itself; for example, a half-wavelength dipole can have a larger capture area due to its design . This characteristic is important in choosing and designing antennas for specific frequencies and reception contexts, as it affects the amount of signal power available to the receiver for processing . Therefore, the effectiveness of a receiver antenna is partially determined by its capture area, as it dictates the proportion of radiated signal energy that the antenna can capture and deliver to the receiver system.
Elevation patterns are crucial in the design and use of receiving antennas as they determine the angle of maximum reception (AMR), which affects the range and quality of received signals. A dipole antenna placed about a quarter-wavelength high will have a main elevation lobe nearly vertical, not suitable for distant stations arriving at low angles . For DX (distance listening) purposes, antennas are designed for low AMR to capture low-angle incoming waves typical for long-distance signals. Conversely, antennas designed for regional reception require higher AMR . The performance of antennas such as the Beverage, installed close to the ground, can be influenced by the elevation angle, as they are effective for low-angle vertically polarized waves . Thus, understanding and optimizing elevation patterns are key for effective antenna design and signal reception.
The G5RV antenna offers several advantages and limitations when used across a wide frequency range. Advantages include its ability to operate over the entire HF spectrum and its good performance at specific frequencies like 16.5 MHz and 26 MHz. The center-fed design allows it to be more versatile than a simple dipole, and it can be adapted to different band frequencies by adjusting the feedline length and employing an antenna tuning unit (ATU) to manage impedance mismatches . Additionally, it can be conveniently set up using standard coaxial cable and twin-lead . However, the G5RV also exhibits limitations. The design results in variable and often high SWR values across the band, with sharp spikes in VSWR at certain frequencies such as 11 MHz and 23 MHz, which reduce performance to that of a random length wire . This necessitates the use of an ATU to adjust for these mismatches, making the setup more complex . Additionally, the gain and impedance characteristics of the G5RV antenna vary significantly across different frequencies, further complicating its use . Therefore, while capable of being used across wide frequency ranges, these limitations require careful tuning and setup to achieve optimal performance.