MG + WO3 MG+ H0.23WO3
MG + WO3 MG+ H0.23WO3
Available at www.sciencedirect.com
Article history: The H sorption properties of mixtures Mg þ WO3 (having various structures) and
Received 22 December 2008 Mg þ H0.23WO3 are reported. First, the higher conversion of Mg into MgH2 during reactive
Received in revised form mechanical grinding (under 1.1 MPa of H2) for higher WO3 content is due to the improve-
6 February 2009 ment of the milling efficiency. Then, it is shown that the hydrogen absorption properties
Accepted 9 February 2009 are almost independent of the crystal structure of the catalyst and that only the particles’
Available online 17 March 2009 size and the specific surface play a major role. Finally, for the desorption process, it appears
that the chemical composition and structure of the catalyst, together with the particle size
Keywords: and specific surface have an effect.
Hydrogen storage ª 2009 International Association for Hydrogen Energy. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights
Magnesium hydride reserved.
Kinetics
Mechanical alloying
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ33 54000 2653; fax: þ33 54000 2761.
E-mail address: [email protected] (J.-L. Bobet).
0360-3199/$ – see front matter ª 2009 International Association for Hydrogen Energy. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2009.02.030
international journal of hydrogen energy 34 (2009) 3404–3409 3405
8000
10 h
60
Intensity (a.u.)
6000 5h
4000 2h 40
Mg + 10wt% WO3 hexa
2000
20 Mg + 10wt% WO3 monoclinic
1h
0
0
20 30 40 50 60 70 0 2 4 6 8 10
2θ (°) Milling time (hour)
Fig. 1 – X-ray diffraction patterns for the mixture Mg D 10% Fig. 3 – Wt.% of b-MgH2 formed as a function of reactive
monoclinic WO3 ball milled under hydrogen for different mechanical grinding for different additives (monoclinic
milling times (1, 2, 5 and 10 h). WO3, hexagonal WO3, and tetragonal H0.23WO3).
3406 international journal of hydrogen energy 34 (2009) 3404–3409
60
50% WO3 m 200°C
40
25% WO3 m 200°C
20
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800
Time (s)
Fig. 4 – Relative fraction of H absorbed as a function of time at two different temperatures (200 and 300 8C) for Mg D x% mWO3
(stands for monoclinic) with x [ 10, 25 and 50.
device (47 kHz, 125 W, 30 min). Surface area measurements that the formation of MgH2 during milling depends on the
were performed using a Quantachrome Autosorb 1 milling conditions (temperature [20] and ball/powder weight
equipment. ratio [21]). The XRD patterns obtained after different milling
The mixture Mg þ WO3 was introduced in a volumetric time are presented in Fig. 1. After 1 h of milling, the Bragg
apparatus (Hera) and was evacuated for 2 h at room temper- peaks of tetragonal b-MgH2 (JCPDS card no. 12-0697) start to
ature under primary vacuum. The first absorption was done at appear on the XRD pattern. As expected, increasing the
300 C under 1 MPa. As the mixture consists of both Mg and milling time leads to an increase of the Bragg peaks intensity
MgH2, we wait for the complete absorption (between 2 and 8 h) of MgH2 and to a decrease of the Bragg peaks intensity of Mg.
before recording the first desorption at 330 C and 0.03 MPa. The Moreover, it has to be pointed out that the crystallinity of the
following absorption–desorption cycles were done at 300 C – MgH2 formed during milling is lower than that of the initial
1 MPa and 330 C – 0.03 MPa, respectively. The results presented magnesium. This is in agreement with previous results [19,20].
in this paper correspond to the third cycle (second and third are After 5 h of milling, a very small amount of orthorhombic g-
similar). After these first 3 cycles, the absorption and desorption MgH2 (JCPDS card no. 35-1184) is also formed, but according to
were performed at lower temperatures (250 and 200 C for the very small intensity of the Bragg peaks, it has not been
absorption, and 300 and 280 C for desorption) at the same taken into account in the calculation of the relative amount of
pressure (1 MPa and 0.03 MPa, respectively). MgH2 formed. Moreover, the amount of g-MgH2 does not
increase as milling proceeds, and it does not play a significant
role during sorption (it disappears after the first cycle).
3. Results and discussion Rietveld refinements allow-us to determine the relative
amount of MgH2 formed as a function of milling time (Figs. 2
3.1. Conversion of Mg into MgH2 during reactive ball and 3). As already mentioned, no correction was performed
milling due to the difference between the absorption coefficients of
Mg and MgH2 due to their close similarity. Nevertheless, the
It has already been shown that ball milling under a reactive calculated hydride amount should be considered carefully,
media could lead to the formation of nitrides [18], oxides or taking into account an accuracy of at most 95%, mainly
hydrides [19]. In the case of magnesium, it has been reported because WO3 and g-MgH2 were not taken into account in the
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 750 800
Time (s)
Fig. 5 – Wt. % of H absorbed as a function of time at two different temperatures (200 and 300 8C) for Mg D 50 wt.% of different
additives (monoclinic WO3, hexagonal WO3, and tetragonal H0.23WO3).
international journal of hydrogen energy 34 (2009) 3404–3409 3407
Particle Size Distribution by (i) a higher H2/Mg ratio, as the total amount of magnesium
10 decreases and the H2 pressure is constant, (ii) a higher milling
WO3 monoclinic efficiency; as more WO3 is added, more fresh surface is
9
created, and as the amount of H2 is also more important, this
8 leads to an increase of the conversion rate.
In Fig. 3, the effect of different additives is examined.
7 Almost the same results were obtained with the addition of
H0.23 WO3 tetragonal
(milled monoC) monoclinic or hexagonal WO3. This result is surprising
Volume (%)
6
because the hexagonal structure is less compact and should
5 offer some hydrogen trap sites which should play a role during
milling. On the other side, the use of the bronze H0.23WO3
4 leads to a significant improvement of the conversion degree.
We assumed, and it will be justified in the second part, that
3
the difference on the specific surface of the additives (3 m2/g
2 for monoclinic WO3 and 20 m2/g for the bronze) is the origin of
WO3 hexagonal
the distinct conversion rates of Mg into MgH2 during milling.
1 It is finally worth pointing out that the catalysts remain in
their initial crystal structure during milling and that no
0
0.01 0.1 1 10 100 1000 chemical change (H content in the bronze) has been observed.
Particle Size (µm)
3.2. Hydriding and dehydriding properties
Fig. 6 – Particle size distribution of monoclinic WO3,
hexagonal WO3 and tetragonal H0.23WO3 (obtained by
In a first step, the influence of the WO3 content was studied.
milling monoclinic WO3).
The goal was to verify that the use of a large quantity of WO3
(useful to be able to check the evolution of WO3 structure
during milling and subsequent hydruration) produces the
refinement, and also due to the possible disappearance of Mg same effect on the sorption properties (except the maximum
reflections due to reduction of crystallite size. The following capacity) than a small quantity. As clearly seen in Fig. 4, no
general trends are observed in the curves (Figs. 2 and 3): (i) significant difference can be found in the kinetic behaviour
during the first hour of milling only a small quantity of MgH2 is when varying the amount of monoclinic WO3 from 10 to
formed; (ii) from 1 to 5 h the formation of MgH2 is rather rapid 50 wt.%. This is in good agreement with previous results (but
and two thirds of the initial Mg is transformed into MgH2; (iii) with lower catalyst content) [7–10]. It is worth pointing out
from 5 to 10 h, the remaining Mg is transformed into MgH2 but that 10 wt.% of WO3 represents only 1.15 molar % and 50 wt.%
in some cases a complete transformation is not reached after only 9.49 molar %. It can be rather surprising that an increase
10 h. The reported behaviour is similar to the one observed for in the amount of WO3 during milling improves the trans-
Mg þ Cr2O3 mixtures in the same milling conditions [6]. By formation of Mg into MgH2, whereas it does not have any
optimizing the milling conditions (increasing the ball to appreciable effect on the sorption properties of the milled
powder weight ratio [21] or the milling temperature [20]) it material. But both facts are not contradictory as, the use of
should be easy to reach the full transformation in a few hours. different amounts of additives has an impact on the milling
The effects of different amounts of monoclinic WO3 are efficiency (i.e. by adding more brittle component in the
presented in Fig. 2. An increase in the WO3 content leads to powder mixture), but it does not have any effect on the kinetic
a higher conversion rate (e.g. almost 80% of the Mg is trans- properties of the milled material. It is therefore worth
formed after 5 h). Such improved conversion can be explained concluding that the higher transformation rate during milling
Fig. 7 – SEM (backscattered electrons) images of Mg D WO3 monoclinic (left) and Mg D H0.23WO3 tetragonal (right). Both
mixtures were ball milled for 5 h.
3408 international journal of hydrogen energy 34 (2009) 3404–3409
Mg+H0.23 WO3 tetra 300°C small particles (around 0.8 mm) exist compared with mono-
3 Mg+WO3 monoC HSS 300°C
clinic WO3. The BET measurements confirm the granulo-
metric measurements as the specific surface of the bronze
was 20 m2/g and that of the monoclinic and hexagonal WO3
only 3 and 3.6 m2/g, respectively. Moreover, the SEM obser-
2
Wt% H abs
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Time (s)
Fig. 9 – Wt. % of H desorbed as a function of time at 300 8C for different additives: Mg D 50% low specific surface monoclinic
WO3, Mg D 50% HSS monoclinic WO3, and Mg D 50% H0.23WO3.
international journal of hydrogen energy 34 (2009) 3404–3409 3409
86) is due to the chemical composition of the catalyst and or to [4] Barkhordarian G, Klassen T, Bormann R. Effect of Nb2O5
the structure. The XRD analysis after the sorption process content on hydrogen reaction kinetics of Mg. J Alloys Compd
does not reveal any changes on the chemical composition or 2004;364:242–6.
[5] Dehouche Z, Klassen T, Oelerich W, Goyette J, Bose TK,
the crystal structure of the catalyst. Therefore, at the present
Schulz R. Cycling and thermal stability of nanostructured
time, we can conclude that the specific surface of the catalyst MgH2–Cr2O3 composite for hydrogen storage. J Alloys Compd
is the major factor to take into account considering hydrogen 2002;347:319–23.
absorption kinetics, but it is not the only factor for desorption. [6] Bobet J-L, Desmoulins-Krawiec S, Grigorova E, Cansell F,
For desorption, the chemical composition of the catalyst (WO3 Chevalier B. Addition of nanosized Cr2O3 to magnesium for
or H0.23WO3) as well as the structure (monoclinic and tetrag- improvement of the hydrogen sorption properties. J Alloys
onal) may also play an important role. Maybe the presence of Compd 2003;351(1–2):217–21.
[7] Barkhordarian G, Klassen T, Bormann R. Fast hydrogen
protons in the catalyst can help during the recombination
sorption kinetics of nanocrystalline Mg using Nb2O5 as
process, a step that has been considered as the rate limiting catalyst. Scripta Mater 2003;49:213–7.
step in the desorption [10]. [8] Dornheim M, Doppiu S, Barkhordarian G, Boesenberg U,
Klassen T, Gutfleisch O, et al. Hydrogen storage in
magnesium-based hydrides and hydride composites. Scripta
4. Conclusion Mater 2007;56:841–6.
[9] Barkhordarian G, Klassen T, Bormann R. Catalytic
mechanism of transition-metal compounds on Mg hydrogen
First, it is shown that a higher transformation of Mg into
sorption reaction. J Phys Chem B 2006;110(22):11020–4.
MgH2 during reactive milling could be obtained by adding [10] Barkhordarian G, Klassen T, Bormann R. Kinetic
more catalyst to the mixture. This is directly linked with investigation of the effect of milling time on the hydrogen
a higher milling efficiency. Then, this preliminary study also sorption reaction of magnesium catalyzed with different
allows-us to highlight the low influence of the nature of the Nb2O5 contents. J Alloys Compd 2006;407:249–55.
catalyst on the hydriding properties of Mg based mixtures. [11] Glemser O, Naumann C. Kristallisierte
Wolframblauverbindungen; Wasserstoffanaloga der
It can be assumed that if the additive is hexagonal WO3,
Wolframbronzen HxWO3. Z Anorg Allg Chem 1951;265(4–6):
monoclinic WO3 or H0.23WO3 all of them with similar 288–302.
particle size distribution and specific surface, then, there [12] Wells AF. Structural inorganic chemistry. 3rd ed. Clarendon
will be no significant differences on the hydrogen absorp- Press; 1962.
tion behaviour of the mixtures. The specific surface of the [13] Gerand B, Nowogrocki G, Guenot J, Figlarz M. Structural study
additive seems to be the important factor that should be of a new hexagonal form of tungsten trioxide. J Solid State
taken into account when looking for improvements in the Chem 1979;29:429–34.
[14] Han W, Hibino M, Kudo T. Synthesis of the hexagonal form of
kinetic absorption properties of magnesium based mate-
tungsten trioxide from peroxopolytungstate via ammonium
rials. Interestingly, this independence of the nature of the paratungstate decahydrate. Bull Chem Soc Jpn 1998;71:933–7.
catalyst (composition and or structure) has not been [15] Solonin YM, Khyzhun OY, Graivoronskaya EA.
observed during hydrogen desorption. In this case, both the Nonstoichiometric tungsten oxide based on hexagonal WO3.
microstructure (particle size and specific surface) and the Cryst Growth Des 2001;1:473–7.
nature of the catalyst (H0.23WO3, HSS monoclinic WO3 and [16] Urretavizcaya G, Tonus F, Gaudin E, Bobet J-L, Castro FJ.
Formation of tetragonal hydrogen tungsten bronze by
low specific surface monoclinic WO3) play a role during
reactive mechanical alloying. J Solid State Chem 2007;180:
hydrogen desorption.
2785–9.
[17] Castro F, Tonus F, Bobet J-L, Urretavizcaya G. Synthesis of
hydrogen tungsten bronzes HxWO3 by reactive mechanical
milling of hexagonal WO3. J Alloys Compd, submitted for
Acknowledgments
publication (JALCOM-D-08-02310).
[18] Sherif El-Eskandarany M. Solid state nitrization reaction of
Partial financial support from the SECYT-ECOS Cooperation amorphous tantalum aluminium nitride alloy powders: the
Program (A05-E04 Project) is gratefully acknowledged. role of amorphization by reactive ball milling. J Alloys Compd
1994;203:117–26.
[19] Bobet J-L, Akiba E, Nakamura Y, Darriet B. Study of Mg–M
references (M ¼ Co, Ni and Fe) mixture elaborated by reactive
mechanical alloying. Hydrogen sorption properties. Int J
Hydrogen Energy 2000;25:987–96.
[1] Züttel A. Materials for hydrogen storage. Materials Today [20] Huot J, Tremblay M-L, Schulz R. Synthesis of nanocrystalline
2003;6(9):24–33. hydrogen storage materials. J Alloys Compd 2003;356–357:
[2] Schlapbach L, Züttel A. Hydrogen-storage materials for 603–7.
mobile applications. Nature 2001;414:353–8. [21] Bobet J-L, Chevalier B, Song MY, Darriet B. Improvements of
[3] Aguey-Zinsou K-F, Ares-Fernández J-R. Synthesis of colloidal hydrogen storage properties of Mg-based mixtures
magnesium: a near room temperature store for hydrogen. elaborated by reactive mechanical milling. J Alloys Compd
Chem Mater 2008;20:376–8. 2003;356–357:570–4.