Bermudez Et Al 2012 Estimating Micronutrient Intakes From Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys Hces An
Bermudez Et Al 2012 Estimating Micronutrient Intakes From Household Consumption and Expenditures Surveys Hces An
S208 Food and Nutrition Bulletin, vol. 33, no. 3 (supplement) © 2012, The United Nations University.
Estimating micronutrient intakes from HCES in Bangladesh S209
was a national survey using a two-stage stratified these vegetables were listed together in one line and we
sampling design [2]. The HIES2005 examined 10,080 have no information about the frequency of consump-
households, of which 6,400 were rural and 3,680 were tion of those foods by the Bangladeshi population. For
urban [3]. The households contained a total of 48,969 mixed dishes eaten away from home, we developed
members. We obtained exempt status from the Insti- recipes based on published papers [7, 11, 12], consul-
tutional Review Board at Tufts Medical Center/Tufts tation with Bangladeshi colleagues, and descriptions
University, as this study consisted of secondary analysis found on the Internet.
of a publicly available dataset that was free of personal
identifiers. Intrahousehold food distribution
Food data The food acquisition data in the HIES2005 were col-
lected for households as the sampling unit. In order
As part of the HIES2005, a questionnaire with 134 to estimate nutrient intakes for individual household
lines or categories was employed to collect data on members and compare them with nutrient intake rec-
food acquisition that occurred during the previous ommendations, we divided the total household intake
14 days [4]. The food lines consisted of individual or by the number of household members.
multiple foods. Food lines included spices, alcoholic To perform the intrahousehold food allocation, we
and nonalcoholic beverages, and foods eaten away assumed that household members did not receive an
from home, some of which were mixed meals (e.g., equal share of the food available for consumption.
fish and vegetable dishes). Household food acquisition Therefore, instead of working with estimates of per
data were transformed into standard units of weight capita distribution, we calculated Adult Male Equiva-
(grams) or volume (milliliters) and then converted to lent units (AMEs) for each household member, fol-
daily amounts. lowing the steps outlined by Fiedler et al. [1]. In short,
AMEs were estimated as the ratio of the energy require-
Sources of foods ment of a household member of a particular age and
sex to the energy requirement of an adult male 18 to
Food reports from HIES2005 included the sources 30 years of age, with moderate physical activity, as rec-
of acquired foods: purchased foods, foods produced ommended by the Food and Agriculture Organization
by household members, or foods received as gifts or (FAO) [13]. The AMEs are listed in table 1. There are
donations (gifted) or as in-kind wages. A categorical two limitations to these estimations: the HIES2005 did
variable was created for food sources with four catego- not report the age of infants in months, and the iden-
ries: purchased, produced, wage in-kind, and gifted. tification of women as pregnant or lactating was not
available. Therefore, we assigned AMEs for all children
Nutrient database under 1 year of age as that of children 7 to 12 months
of age. For women, no adjustments were made, and all
As we were unable to find a current national (Bangla- women were treated as nonpregnant and nonlactating.
desh) nutrient database, we developed a nutrient data-
base for foods listed in the HIES2005 based on the US Estimation of nutrient intakes and requirements
Department of Agriculture nutrient database version
22 [5], plus information about regional foods obtained We performed the nutrient analysis with the estimates
from published reports [6–10]. Additional information of daily apparent food intakes. Correction factors were
was identified from a nutrient database developed by obtained from the US Department of Agriculture nutri-
HarvestPlus that was used for the analysis of a nutri- ent database [5] to account for nonedible portions and
tion survey conducted in one district of Bangladesh*. cooking losses. In addition to dietary energy, the nutri-
In addition, we consulted Bangladeshi colleagues and ents assessed were iron, zinc, and vitamin A.
others familiar with Bangladesh about the identifica- Household total intakes of energy, vitamin A, iron,
tion of local foods. and zinc were allocated to household members accord-
As indicated earlier, some food lines from the ing to their AMEs. Apparent individual intakes were
HIES2005 questionnaire included more than one compared with the requirements established for vita-
food. In those cases, we estimated the nutrient content min A, iron, and zinc. To assess adequacy of the
for those foods as the average of the foods included in apparent intakes of vitamin A, we used the Estimated
those food lines. For example, we estimated the aver- Average Requirements (EARs) promulgated by the
age nutrient content of spinach, amaranth, and basil, as Institute of Medicine (IOM)[14].
Although the Dietary Reference Intakes (DRIs)
* Arsenault J. Bangladesh food composition table. Docu- established by the IOM were defined using bioavail-
mentation manual. HarvestPlus (Internal report, unpub- ability as one of several factors taken into account for
lished). 2010. nutrients such as iron and zinc, those bioavailability
S210 O. I. Bermudez et al.
TABLE 1. Adult Male Equivalent (AME) consumption units TABLE 2. Intake of dietary energy according to division, from
applied to household members from the 2005 Bangladesh the 2005 Bangladesh Household Income and Expenditure
Household Income and Expenditure Survey Surveya
Males Females Population Energy intake
Age range Energy Energy (expanded sample) (kcal)
(yr) (kcal/day) AME (kcal/day) AME Households Individuals
< 1.0 661 0.22 661 0.22 Division (no.) (no.) Mean SE
1.0–1.9 950 0.31 850 0.28 National 28,644,938 138,817,749 2,151 3
2.0–2.9 1,125 0.37 1,050 0.34 Barisal 1,789,213 8,905,211 1,950 11
3.0–3.9 1,250 0.41 1,150 0.38 Chittagong 4,932,030 26,727,815 2,111 8
4.0–4.9 1,350 0.44 1,250 0.41 Dhaka 9,521,146 44,714,603 2,195 7
5.0–5.9 1,475 0.48 1,325 0.43 Khulna 3,456,250 16,292,108 2,126 9
6.0–6.9 1,575 0.52 1,425 0.47 Rajshahi 7,368,438 33,379,209 2,181 7
7.0–7.9 1,700 0.56 1,550 0.51 Sylhet 1,577,863 8,798,802 2,177 15
8.0–8.9 1,825 0.60 1,700 0.56 a. All analyses were performed with weighted data.
9.0–9.9 1,975 0.65 1,850 0.61
10.0–10.9 2,150 0.70 2,000 0.66 that reported four or fewer food items over the 14-day
11.0–11.9 2,350 0.77 2,150 0.70 period used for data collection or those in which
12.0–12.9 2,550 0.84 2,275 0.75 members had a mean intake of less than 500 kcal/day.
13.0–13.9 2,775 0.91 2,375 0.78 To further correct for stockpiling or for overreporting,
14.0–14.9 3,000 0.98 2,450 0.80 we identified households with mean individual intakes
15.0–15.9 3,175 1.04 2,500 0.82 above 6,000 kcal. After applying these steps, we identi-
16.0–16.9 3,325 1.09 2,500 0.82 fied only eight households with implausible data, which
17.0–17.9 3,400 1.11 2,500 0.82 were excluded from our analysis.
18.0–29.9 3,050 1.00 2,400 0.79 We applied the cutpoint method [14, 16] to evaluate
30.0–59.9 2,950 0.97 2,350 0.77 the adequacy of intakes of vitamin A and zinc. With
≥ 60.0 2,450 0.80 2,100 0.69 the use of this method, household members with
intakes below the recommendations for their age and
sex were classified as having inadequate intakes of that
factors were based on the “typical American” diet, micronutrient.
which is higher in animal sources of iron and zinc and For iron, the distribution of requirements is not
lower in phytates and other food components than normally distributed for women of reproductive years
those observed in countries like Bangladesh. There- and young children [14]. Therefore, the full probability
fore, we set different levels of bioavailability for those method [14] was required to estimate the percentage of
nutrients. For iron, an assumption of 5% bioavailabil- inadequate intakes for these subgroups, as well as for
ity was used to adjust intakes; values of physiological the other age and sex groups. Individuals were assigned
requirements were obtained from the IOM DRIs [14]. a probability of inadequacy based on which range their
The International Zinc Nutrition Consultative Group intakes fell into. The number and percentage of inad-
(IZiNCG) has estimated the bioavailability for differ- equate intakes for each subgroup were then determined
ent age and sex groups based on different diets with by summing the probabilities over that group.
varying amounts of phytate content [15]. We made our Estimates of the average apparent intakes of energy,
assumption of bioavailability based on an unrefined, vitamin A, iron, and zinc, as well as the percentages of
cereal-based diet reported by IZiNCG and used the individuals with inadequate intakes, were calculated
physiological requirements published by IZiNCG [15] according to age group, area of residence (urban or
as the standards with which to compare our adjusted rural), and country divisions. We used the statistical
intakes of zinc. package PASW-SPSS, version 18, for our analyses. For
all analyses, we weighted the data using the expansion
Statistical analysis factors provided in the HIES data sets. Here we present
only results aggregated by Bangladesh’s six geopo-
The plausibility of our apparent food and nutrient litical divisions: Barisal, Chittagong, Dhaka, Khulna,
intakes was assessed with exploratory analyses, includ- Rajshahi, and Sylhet.
ing simple counts of food items by household, fre-
quency tables, simple identification of extreme values,
plot charts, and others. Obvious stockpiled quantities Results
were also detected and labeled as outliers. We also
assessed issues of underreporting, flagging households Sixty-four percent of the Bangladeshi households
Estimating micronutrient intakes from HCES in Bangladesh S211
included in the HIES2005 were from TABLE 3. Intakes of vitamin A, iron, and zinc by household members, accord-
rural areas. The average household ing to division, from the 2005 Bangladesh Household Income and Expenditure
size was 4.8 members, and was higher Survey a
for rural (4.9) than for urban (4.7) Vitamin A (µg) Iron (mg)b Zinc (mg)b
households. Division Mean SE Mean SE Mean SE
National 286 1 0.72 0.002 2.06 0.005
Intake of dietary energy
Barisal 301 3 0.69 0.005 1.75 0.011
The population studied in the HIES2005 Chittagong 285 2 0.75 0.004 2.05 0.009
was distributed across the six divisions Dhaka 285 2 0.78 0.004 2.18 0.009
of Bangladesh, with the highest propor- Khulna 354 4 0.71 0.005 1.95 0.012
tion of households concentrated in the Rajshahi 266 2 0.62 0.003 2.04 0.010
division of Dhaka (table 2). As reflected Sylhet 235 3 0.68 0.006 1.98 0.018
in this table, the apparent daily intake a. All analyses were performed with weighted data.
of energy fluctuated from 1,950 kcal b. After adjustment for bioavailability: iron, 5%; zinc, physiological requirements based
among households in the Barisal divi- on an unrefined, cereal-based diet reported by IZiNCG [15].
sion to 2,195 kcal in Dhaka division,
with 2,151 kcal as the national average.
80
Intakes of vitamin A, iron, and zinc
70
50
lowest mean intake of vitamin A, 235 µg of retinol
40
activity equivalents (RAE), was observed among the
population from Sylhet division, while the highest 30
50
(51%), while residents of Khulna division appeared to
40
obtain 74% of their required vitamin A.
Apparent intakes of iron covered 67% of the require- 30
140
were consistent with previously reported research. Vita-
120 min A has been considered one of the most limiting
micronutrients in diets of the Bangladeshi population.
100
According to the national nutrition surveys of 1975/76
% adequacy
References
1. Fiedler JL, Lividini K, Bermudez OI, Smitz M-F. House- 19:562–571.
hold consumption and expenditures surveys (HCES): a 12. Roos N, Islamy MM, Shakuntala H, Thilsted SH. Small
primer for food and nutrition analysts. Food Nutr Bull indigenous fish species in Bangladesh: contribution
2012, 33:S170–84. to vitamin A, calcium and iron intakes. J Nutr 2003,
2. Asian Development Bank, Bangladesh Resident Mis- 133:4021S–4026S.
sion. Bangladesh Quarterly Economic Report. Sep- 13. FAO/WHO. Human energy requirements. Report of
tember 2006. URL: http://www.adb.org/Documents/ a Joint FAO/WHO/UNU Expert Consultation. Rome,
Economic_Updates/BAN/2006/sep-2006.pdf Accessed 17–24 October 2001. FAO Food and Nutrition Technical
April 20, 2010. Report series 1. Rome: FAO, 2004.; 2004.
3. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. Key findings of HIES 14. Food and Nutrition Board, Standing Committee of
2005. URL: http://www.bangladeshembassy.com.cn/em/ the Scientific Evaluation of Dietary Reference Intakes.
bbs/bbs.asp Accessed April 20, 2010. Dietary reference intakes: applications in dietary
4. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics. Household income assessment. A Report of the Subcommittees on Inter-
and expenditure survey (HIES); Survey questionnaire, pretation and Uses of Dietary Reference Intakes and
2005. URL: http://surveynetwork.org/home/index. Upper Reference Levels of Nutrients, and the Standing
php?q=activities/catalog/surveys/ihsn/050-2005-001 Committee on the Scientific Evaluation of Dietary Ref-
Accessed March 9, 2010. erence Intakes. Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine,
5. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research National Academy Press; 2001.
Service. USDA national nutrient database for standard 15. Brown KH, Rivera JA, Bhutta Z, Gibson RS, King JC,
reference, Release 22. Nutrient data laboratory home Lonnerdal B, Ruel MT, Sandtrom B, Wasantwisut E,
page, http://www.ars.usda.gov/ba/bhnrc/ndl. Accessed Hotz C. International zinc nutrition consultative group
February 11, 2010. (IZiNCG) technical document #1. Assessment of the
6. Ahmed F, Mahmuda I, Sattar A, Akhtaruzzaman M. risk of zinc deficiency in populations and options for
Anaemia and vitamin A deficiency in poor urban preg- its control. Food Nutr Bull 2004, 25:S99–203.
nant women of Bangladesh. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr 2003, 16. Food and Nutrition Board, Standing Committee of
12:460–466. the Scientific Evaluation of Dietary Reference Intakes.
7. Hels O, Larsen T, Christensen LP, Kidmose U, Hassan Dietary reference intakes for vitamin A, vitamin K,
N, Thilsted SH. Contents of iron, calcium, zinc and arsenic, boron, chromium, copper, iodine, iron, man-
β-carotene in commonly consumed vegetables in Bang- ganese, molybdenum, nickel, silicon, vanadium, and
ladesh. J Food Comp & Analysis 2004, 17:587–595. zinc. Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine, National
8. Hels O, Kidmose U, Larsen T, Hassan N, Tetens I, Academy Press; 2001.
Thilsted S. Estimated nutrient intakes and adequacies 17. World Food Program. Food security at a glance: Bang-
in Bangladesh change when newer values for vitamin ladesh. URL: http://foodsecurityatlas.org/bgd/country/
A, iron and calcium in commonly consumed foods are food-security-at-a-glance. Accessed September 5, 2011.
applied. Int J Food Sci Nutr 2003, 54:457–465. 18. Ahmed F. Vitamin A deficiency in Bangladesh: a review
9. Hels O, Hassan N, Tetens I, Thilsted S. Food consump- and recommendations for improvement. Public Health
tion, energy and nutrient intake and nutritional status in Nutr 1999, 2:1–14.
rural Bangladesh: changes from 1981–1982 to 1995–96. 19. Ahmed F, Azim A, Akhtaruzzaman M. Vitamin A defi-
Eur J Clin Nutr 2003, 57:586–594. ciency in poor, urban, lactating women in Bangladesh:
10. Alam N, Roy SK, Ahmed T, Ahmed AM. Nutritional factors influencing vitamin A status. Public Health Nutr
status, dietary intake, and relevant knowledge of ado- 2003, 6:447–452.
lescent girls in rural Bangladesh. J Health Popul Nutr, 20. Ahmed F. Anaemia in Bangladesh: a review of preva-
28:86–94. lence and aetiology. Public Health Nutr 2000, 3:385–393.
11. Kidmosea U, Yangb RY, Thilsted SH, Christensena 21. Claro RM, Bertazzi-Levy R, Bandoni DH, Mondini L. Per
LP, Brandtd K. Content of carotenoids in commonly capita versus adult-equivalent estimates of calorie avail-
consumed asian vegetables and stability and extract- ability in household budget surveys. Cad Saude Publica
ability during frying. J Food Comp & Analysis 2006, 2010, 26:2188–2195.