0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 74 views2 pagesReply and Appeal Reply
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
F.No. R 20011/60/2019-Ad1A, lianas cid
Government of Inia
Department of Revenue
‘Ad 1A Section
New Delhi, dated 9" April, 2019
ro Sim ot
Seeking information under Right to Information Act -2005- Regarding
With reference to your online RTI registration no. DOREV/R/2019/S0808 dated
31.03.2019 on the subject mentioned above and to say that so far as Ad 1 (A) Section Is
concerned, the information is as follows:
+= No such separate list for particular category is maintained by the
undersigned. Therefore, the requisite information is not available in the format
asked by him and the same are scattered in various files and other documents.
As per Clause (f) and (j) of Section 2 of the RTI Act, information may not be
Created and the applicant may access the information available with the public
authority in the form of data or analyzed data, with prior appointments and
2 select the required information from the documents and files available in record,
Point No.2 :- The caste and educational certificates of an employee are in the
nature of personal information about a third party. Hence, it may not be possible
to provide the certified copies of Caste Certificate.
Point No. 3 :- Requisite information is given below in para 2
2. Appeal, if any, against the above reply can be filed before the First Appellate
Authority within 30 days of receipt of this letter. The details of the First Appellate
Authority is as under:-
Shri Arvind Saran,
Deputy Secretary (Admn)
Room No. 48.A,
Department of Revenue, North Block
New Delhi-110001
Yours faithfully,
(Raghvendea Singh Rghutde)>
CPIO & Under Secretary to the Govt. of India
: Tele: 23095368
Copy to RTI Cell, Department of Revenue with reference to their
registration no
DOREV/R/2019/50808 dated 31.03.2019
ogo nc
Apa F.No. R-20011/60/2019-Ad.1A
Government of India
Ministry of Finance
Department of Revenue
North Block, New Delhi
Dated the june, 2019
ORDER
Subject: Appeal under Section 19(1) of Right to Information Act-2005 by ~ 27 Sthap —
regarding,
W. creas ow 3" 1 vide is letter dated 28.05.2019 (received by this
Department on 03.06.2019) has filed ari Appeal under section 19(1) of the RTI Act - 2003 with the
First Appellate Authority & Deputy Secretary (Admn, ), Department of Revenue,
2 sn ancitd whereas an Appeal has been raised on the contention that the applicant not satisfying
with the reply of his RTI application,
3. The APPEAL of ¢ 7
that the C°.9/Under Secretary (Adi
© crcteni® tls, Meiterated that as per the CIC Judgement in the appeal
NOCICISB/A/2016/00102S/CBECE-BI dated 03.03.2017, “at Outset the Commission
5. Moreover, as per the CIC’s decision dated 18" September 2013 and 19% July 2017, “the
Gate and educational certificates of an employee are in the nature of personal information about a
{hit Barty. The employee might have filed these documents betes appointing authority for
the purpose of seeking employment, but that is not reasos enough for this information to be
brought in to the public domain to which anybody could kane access. Apart from this, the
sppellant has not been able to demonstrate any public Purpose which the disclosure of this
information would serve. Hence, we concur withthe submitens sFtre CPIO’s representative that
the information is exempt from disclosure.”
However, the caste certificates of employees are in the nature of personal information
about a third party. Hence, it may not be provided under the provision of section 8(1) (e) and (j)
of RTI Act ~ 2005. Accordingly, the Appeal is disposed off, as CPIO’s reply was found in order
as per the provisions of RTI Act, 2005 and subsequent orders: of cic.
