Modules 123 Reviewer in Pricing Strategy
Modules 123 Reviewer in Pricing Strategy
Customer Value Modeling relies on In this step, you examine where you have
customers’ subjective judgments about price and operational advantages. Which value drivers can
product attribute performances. It assumes that you deliver more efficiently and at lower cost than
customers seek to purchase the products that others? Also, which drivers are constrained by
give them the greatest perceived benefit your resources and operations? Experience,
capital spending plans, personnel capabilities,
VALUE-BASED MARKET SEGMENTATION and overall company strategy are among the
inputs to this step. Those factors contribute to
Market segmentation is one of the most customer profitability, value delivery, and the
important tasks in marketing. Identifying and price you can charge for bundled and unbundled
describing market subgroups in a way that guides offering features. You should also examine
marketing and sales decision-making makes the competitive strengths and weaknesses on key
marketing and pricing process much more drivers as closely as you can. With these data,
efficient and effective. you can cross-reference and compare lists of
Significant differences between value- customer needs served and unserved, the seller’s
based segmentation and other methods are advantages and resource limitations, and
especially critical for pricing. First, most competitors’ abilities.
segmentation criteria correlate poorly with Step 4: Create Primary and Secondary
different buyers’ motivations to pay higher or Segments
lower prices. Second, even needs-based
segmentations give priority only to those
This step combines what you’ve learned so far Price Structure
about how customer values differ and about your Tactics for Pricing Differently Across
costs and constraints in serving different Segments
customers. In theory, your primary segmentation A segmented price structure is one that causes
is based on the most important criterion revenues to vary with differences in the two key
differentiating your customers. Your secondary elements that drive potential profitability: the
segmentation divides primary segments into economic value that customers receive and the
distinct subgroups according to your second most incremental cost to serve them. There are three
important criterion. Your tertiary segmentation mechanisms that one can use to maintain
divides second segments based on the third most such a segmented structure: price-offer
important criterion, and so on. configuration, price metrics, and price fences.
Each is appropriate for addressing different
Step 5: Create Detailed Segment Descriptions reasons for the existence of value-based
segments.
Value-based segmentation variables can look fine
to the price strategist, but segments should be PRICE-OFFER CONFIGURATION
described in everyday business terms so that
sales people and marketing communications When differences in the value of an offer across
planners know what kinds of customers each segments is caused by differences in the value
segment represents. Exhibit 2-12 lists the needs associated with features, services, or both, a
and typical firmographics of the customer- seller can segment the market by configuring
controlled scheduling segment’s three sub- different offers for different segments. Using offer
segments. It also lists specific catalog publishers design to implement segmented pricing requires
within each segment. minimal enforcement of the segments because
customers self-select the offers that determine
Step 6: Develop Segment Metrics and Fences their prices.
This is the next logical step in pricing strategy and To create an effective price structure, one must
management, a step we cover in greater detail in first determine which features and services the
Chapter 3. Here, it’s important to recognize that firm should price à la carte, leaving customers to
segmentation isn’t truly useful until you develop customize their own offers and which features
the metrics of value delivery to market segments and services to bundle into packages. There are
and devise fences that encourage customers to multiple arguments against pricing all individual
accept price policies for their segments. features and services separately. A single price
for a bundle of features and services reduces
Metrics are the basis for tracking the value
transactions costs for both customers and sellers.
customers receive and how they pay for it. For
The costs to make and deliver most products and
example, car rental companies once used a
services increase with the number of variations
distance-based value metric and charged
allowed, although technology is reducing the cost
customers for the mileage traveled, in addition to
of mass customization. Lastly, research has
the time used.
shown that people are less sensitive to the cost of
Fences are those policies, rules, value-added features and services when bundled
programs, and structures that customers must as a single expenditure.
follow to qualify for price discounts or rewards.
Optimizing an Offer Bundle
For example, minimum volume requirements,
time-based membership requirements, bundled By creating more than one bundled option
purchase requirements, and so on keep prices designed to appeal to different segments, a
paid and the value delivered to customers in line. marketer can get most of the benefits described
above along with the financial rewards of
segmentation.
CHAPTER 3
Adding to the benefits of bundling, sellers
MODULE 3 can often earn more profit by pricing a bundle
than they could by pricing the individual elements
when a particular relationship exists among the Unbundling Strategically
features included in the bundle. Bundling is profit
enhancing when it is possible to bundle features While bundling can be a profit-enhancing strategy
and services that create high value for some for segmentation, it often has the opposite effect
significant customer segments but more when variable cost services are bundled simply to
moderate value for another. A simple à la carte differentiate an offering.
price for one feature or service that optimized Unless the cost to deliver a service is trivial
profitability from one segment would necessarily relative to the overall value of the offer, bundling
over or under price other segments. Bundling, optional services “free” will undermine profitability.
however, can facilitate more profitable, value- Unbundling them with per use fees or limiting the
based pricing to each segment. The following use of them, as many airlines are doing for
example illustrates the principle when the same baggage handling or for using an agent to make
features can be priced profitably for more than reservations, is in
one segment, but the most profitable price level
for different segments is not the same.
Designing Segment Specific Bundles fact strategically essential when facing intense
competition. Where customers have come to
Bundling can also facilitate segmented pricing, expect the service to be included, companies can
thus increasing profitability, when different unbundle the price structure without upsetting
customer segments have different price sensitivity
customers by offering rebates for forgoing use.
for a “core” product or service (for example, For example, one company whose customers had
lodging at a popular vacation spot). When it is become accustomed to placing orders on short
possible to find features or services that one notice for “free” raised its prices but, at the same
segment values highly and another does not (for time, offered a discount of more than the price
example, access to a pro-quality golf course or a increase for orders to be shipped within seven
“kids’ club” where children can be left safely and days. That enabled it to avoid disrupting
entertained), it is easy to design segment-specific relationships with customers already paying a
pricing by bundling. premium for its quick service while enabling it to
As rewarding but often overlooked is the potential match competitive prices when necessary.
for bundling value-added features and services to PRICE METRICS
attract customer segments that require a lower
price to win their patronage. Although they pay a Not all differences in value across segments
lower price, their purchase volume may, reflect differences in the features or services
nevertheless, be profitable, especially during off- desired. Value received is sometimes not even
peak periods or economic downturns when related to differences in the quantity of the
excess capacity would otherwise remain unused. product consumed, necessitating a price metric
Simply cutting prices to win their business would, unrelated to quantity of product or service
however, make it difficult to continue charging provide. Price metrics are the units to which the
other customer segments a higher price and price is applied. They define the terms of
could “cheapen” the image of the brand. Bundling exchange—what exactly will the buyer receive per
a “free” or low-cost service or feature specifically unit of price paid.
preferred by this segment, however, can improve
the value proposition for that segment without Creating Good Price Metrics
having to cut the offer price explicitly.
There are five criteria for determining the most
There is an alternative to adding a feature that profitable price metrics for an offering (Exhibit 3-
raises the value of the discounted offer to only the 4). The first criterion for a good price metric is that
low-price segment. That is to add a feature to the it tracks with differences in value across
lower cost offer that kills value for the higher- segments. While offer design facilitates different
priced segment without affecting the value to the pricing differently based upon what people chose
discount segment. to buy, a price metric not based upon units of
purchase can facilitate different pricing for the
same offer. Second, a good metric tracks with designed with proprietary technology to fit
differences in the cost to serve across customer uniquely with the asset and carried a remarkable
segments. A third criterion for a good metric is wholesale margin of 60 percent. The key to HP’s
that it is easy to implement without any ambiguity pricing success is that its pricing allowed it to earn
about what charge the customer has incurred. some profit from its superior printers from the
Profit-sharing or performance-based pricing are many light users who bought them and its high-
theoretically ideal ways to achieve the first two priced ink. But HP could earn much more from
criteria for a good metric—tracking with value and heavy users who need to replace their printer
cost. The fourth criterion for evaluating a price cartridges more frequently. This tie-in strategy
metric is how the metric makes your pricing enables HP’s inkjet division to maintain a 50
appear in comparison with competitors’ pricing, percent market share and profit per dollar sales
and the impact of that on the perceived ratio that is twice that of the company in general.
attractiveness of your offer. The fifth and final In service-based companies, tie-in contracts are
criterion for evaluating a price metric is how the frequently used to reduce the cost for new buyers
metric aligns with how buyers experience the to try their services. Wireless phone providers
value in use of the product or service. The better offer a digital telephone for a nominal fee, and
the alignment—how a price metric fits the timing sometimes free, if the buyer agrees to purchase a
and magnitude of the customers’ expenditure— long-term service contract to use the company’s
the more attractive the offer. wireless network for 12 or 24 months. Satellite
entertainment companies offer households a
Performance-Based Metrics satellite dish and receiver unit for a greatly
reduced price when buyers agree to subscribe to
An ideal price metric would tie what the customer
a higher-priced entertainment package of
pays for a product or service directly to the
channels for a minimum of 12 or 24 months.
economic value received and the incremental
These packages can be particularly effective for
cost to serve. In a few cases, called
low knowledge buyers, who perceive significant
“performance-based” pricing, price structures can
risk in investing in a new and little-known
actually work that way. Also, performance-based
technology—and then developing them into loyal
pricing has the effect of shifting the performance
buyers who become accustomed to the firm’s
risk from the buyer to the seller.
technology and programming.
Tie-Ins as Metrics
PRICE FENCES
A very common challenge for a company that
Sometimes value differs between customer
sells capital goods is that the value of owning
segments even when all the features and
them can vary widely across segments based
measurable benefits are the same. Value can
upon how intensely they are used.
differ between customer segments and uses
“Tie-in” sales like those that tied purchase simply because they involve different “formulas”
of cans contractually to purchase of the machine for converting features and benefits into economic
were quite common until 1949, when the federal values. The difference may be tied to differences
courts decided that such contracts were not in income, in alternatives available, or in
enforceable under U.S. antitrust law because of psychological benefits that are difficult to measure
their impact on the otherwise freely competitive objectively. Unless there is a good “proxy” metric
market for the tied commodity. 5 But although that just happens to correlate with the resulting
contractual tie-ins are no longer enforceable, differences in value, the seller needs to find a
companies still frequently use technological price fence: a means to charge different
design to tie a unique consumable to an asset. customers different price levels for the same
For example, Hewlett-Packard (HP) led the products and services using the same metrics.
industry in the development and manufacture of Price fences are fixed criteria that customers
inkjet printers. HP strategically priced the printer must meet to qualify for a lower price. At theaters,
—the asset—low to make the up-front cost museums, and similar venues, price fences
competitive with much lower-quality printers. The
replacement ink cartridge—the consumable—was
are usually based on age (with discounts for by purchase location. This is common practice for
children under 12 years of age and for seniors) a wide range of products.
but are sometimes also based on educational
status (full-time students get discounts), or A clever segmented pricing tactic common for
possession of a coupon from a local paper pricing bulky industrial products such as steel and
(benefiting “locals” who know more alternatives). coal is freight absorption. Freight absorption is the
All three types of customers have the same agreement by the seller to bear part of the
needs and cost to serve them, but perceive a shipping costs of the product, the amount of
different value from the purchase. Price fences which depends upon the buyer’s location. The
are the least complicated way to charge different purpose is to segment buyers according to the
prices to reflect different levels of value. attractiveness of their alternatives.
Unfortunately, while simple to administer, the Trade barriers between countries once made
obvious price fences sometimes create segmentation by location viable even for products
resentment and are often too easy for customers that were inexpensive to ship. As trade barriers
to get over whenever there is an economic have declined around the world, and especially
incentive to do so. Thus, finding a fence that will within the European Union, the tactic has become
work in your market usually requires some less effective.
creativity.
Time of Purchase Fences
Buyer Identification Fences
When customers in different market segments
Occasionally pricing goods and services at purchase at different times, one can segment
different levels across segments is easy because them for pricing by time of purchase.
customers have obvious characteristics that
sellers can use to identify them. Priority pricing is one example of segmenting by
time of purchase. New products in a retail store
Rarely is identification of customers in different are offered at full price, or sometimes premium
segments straightforward. Yet, management can surcharges over full price in the case of extreme
sometimes structure price discounts that induce excess demand. Over time, as product appeal
the most price-sensitive buyers to volunteer the fades in comparison to newer competitive
information necessary to identify them alternatives, buyers discount the product’s value
Deal proneness is another form of self-induced until they are willing to pay only a fraction of its
buyer identification— especially through the use original price for leftover models.
of coupons and sales promotions, a frequent tool Predictable, periodic sales offering the same
of consumer marketers. Coupons provided by the merchandise at discounted prices can also
seller give deal-prone shoppers a way to identify segment markets. This tactic is most successful in
themselves. markets with a combination of occasional buyers
Often a buyer’s relative price sensitivity does not who are relatively unfamiliar with the market, and
depend on anything immediately observable or on with more regular buyers who know when the
factors a customer freely reveals. It depends sales are and plan their purchases accordingly.
instead on how well informed about alternatives a Time is also a useful fence when demand varies
customer is and on the personal values the significantly with the time of purchase but the
customer places on the differentiating attributes of product or service is not storable.
the seller’s offer. In such cases, the classification
of buyers by segment usually requires an expert Purchase Quantity Fences
salesperson trained in soliciting and evaluating
the information necessary for segmented pricing. When customers in different segments buy
different quantities, one can sometimes segment
Purchase Location Fences them for pricing with quantity discounts.
When customers who perceive different values There are four types of quantity discount tactics:
buy at different locations, they can be segmented volume discounts, order discounts, step
discounts, and two-part prices. All are common
when dealing with differences in price sensitivity,
costs, and competition.