Ch01 L2 Actionresearch
Ch01 L2 Actionresearch
Lesson 2
Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
1|Page
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
Discover
Read more about action research and answer the activity provided.
Explore
The following are selected concepts that describe, redefine and support the essence of action
research in the context of classroom application and school operations. This discussion was compiled
from Action Research for Beginners in Classroom-based Contexts, Elmer de Leon, (2019).
1. Action research is characterized as research that is done by teachers, for which they examine
their own classrooms, instructional strategies, assessment procedures, and interaction with
student-learners in order to improve their quality and effectiveness (Mertler, 2009; cited in
Thorson & Beliveau, 2012).
2. Action research is a process, in which participants examine their own educational practice
systematically and carefully using the techniques of research (Watts, 1985).
3. Teacher-initiated and school-based research is used to improve the practitioner’s practice by
doing or changing something where the teacher is the researcher and the teacher’s practice is
the focus of the research. The main reason for teachers to engage in action research is to learn
from and improve their own teaching activities (Dr. Suman Saggu, Khalsa College of
Education).
4. Action research refers to a disciplined inquiry done by a teacher with the intent that the
research will inform and change his or her practices in the future.
5. According to Good, (1972) action research is a research used by teachers, supervisors and
administrators to improve the quality of their decisions and actions.
6. For J.W. Best, (1995) action research is focused on the immediate application, not on the
development of theory. It places its emphasis on real problem- here and now in a local setting.
7. Action research is the process of systematically testing new ideas in the classroom or school,
analysing the results, and deciding to implement the new idea or begin the process again with
another idea.
2|Page
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
10 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
There are common myths and misbeliefs about action research, such as:
1. Action research is not what usually comes to mind when we hear the word “research”
2. Action research is not a library project in which one learns more about a topic of interest.
3. It is not problem-solving in the sense of trying to find out what is wrong, but rather a quest for
knowledge about how to improve.
4. Action research is not about doing research on or about people, or finding all available
information on a topic looking for the correct answer. Instead, it involves people working to
improve their skills, techniques, and strategies.
5. Action research is not about learning why one does certain things, but rather how he/she can
do things better. It is about how a teacher can change his/her instruction to impact students.
1. Teachers and principals work best on problems they have identified for themselves.
2. Teachers and principals become more effective when encourage to examine and assess
their own work and then, consider ways of working differently.
3. Teachers and principals help each other by working collaboratively.
4. Working with colleagues helps teachers and principals in their professional
development.
11 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
As the landscape of K-12 school changes, expectation for teachers to engage in school reform
and be accountable for student achievement increases. Although, not all schools currently offer
teacher’s opportunities for professional development through action research, some, at least are
realizing the professional and political implications of this type of sustained systematic inquiry
(Seider & Lemma, 2004).
The teacher will then, actively seek out ways to study how deliberate implementation of
instructional strategies will enhance student learning. As methods of teaching have evolved,
particularly influenced by theories of constructivism, interdisciplinary connections, reflective
practices and cooperative structures (Schon, 1987; Adler, 1991; Ross, 1992; Johnson & Johnson,
1994), new pattern of effective teaching have become necessary. Changing how teachers construct
learning for students means altering how they define what good teaching looks like and how it gets
done.
Classroom action research begins with a question or questions about classroom experiences,
issues, or challenges. It is a reflective process, which helps teachers to explore and examine aspects of
teaching and learning and to take action to change and improve.
Thus, it is a method of finding out what works best in one’s own classroom to improve
students learning amidst the so many ways to improve knowledge about teaching. Many teachers
practice personal reflection on teaching, while others conduct formal empirical studies on teaching
and learning. Action research, therefore, considered more systematic than personal reflection
although, it is more informal and personal than formal educational research.
More so, it is one type of applied research conducted by a teacher to aid in decision- making
in the school. It focuses on the solution of day-to-day problems at the classroom level, which is less
rigorous in terms of design and methodology, that other educational research. Actually, this research
is carried out within the context of the teacher’s environment, with the students and in school, in
which the teacher works on problems that deal with educational matters at hand.
Watts (1985) as cited by Ferrance (2000) elucidated that teachers should be constantly
researching and educating themselves about their area of expertise. This is different from the study of
more educational questions that arise from the practice of teaching. Implicit in term of action research
is the idea that teachers will begin a cycle of posing questions, gathering data, reflection, and deciding
on a course of action. When these decisions begin to change the school environment, a different set of
circumstances appears with different problems posed that require new look.
Many action research projects start with a particular problem to solve, whose solution leads
into other areas of study. While a teacher may work alone on these studies, it is also common for a
number of teachers to collaborate on a problem, as well as enlist support and guidance from
administrators, university scholars, and others. At times, the whole school may
12 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
decide to tackle a school-wide study to address a common issue, or join with others to look at district-
wide issues.
Education problems and issues are best identified and investigated where the action is (i.e. at
the classroom and school level). As such, through action research, findings can be applied
immediately and thereby, problems can be solved more quickly.
According to Schmuck (1997) in ATA (2000), action research is a valuable form of inquiry
for educators because it is practical, participative, empowering, interpretative, tentative and critical.
Research Possibilities
Action research can be as simple as testing a new teaching method, or it can answer more
complex questions about curriculum, school management, or other issues.
1. When a teacher knows whether and why teaching is effective (or understand why it is
not), the teacher will be happier.
2. Teachers face new challenges without previous model to guide them (e.g. the use of
technology as a pedagogical tool.
3. Teachers must adapt to new streams (e.g. flipped classroom, new technology
introduction, etc.)
Taking the time to reflect critically on the things done in classrooms is perhaps the most
effective thing to do to ensure desired outcomes. (Wenmoth, 2007).
13 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
The following are identified purposes of action research based on experiences, experiments
and research studies.
The National Council of Teachers of English (2016) likewise, presents purposes of action research
such as:
The British Educational Research Association, (BERA) cites the role of action research in
teacher education, such as, to:
14 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
There are challenges in doing research that everyone may consider or take in order to overcome
them, as follows:
Although action research brings about positive impact and good implications on teachers,
teaching and learning, at some point, however, there are drawbacks which include:
1. Few respondents or informants are allowed for the research in a limited time of processing
that at times, entails no more statistical applications, result may turn to be biased.
2. Due to contextual scope of the research, which is in the individual classroom, results are
generalizable. Although in a way, other teachers may test and expedite the same investigation
in their own contexts.
3. Hectic schedules in teaching and other related tasks confronting teacher-researchers may
impede the whim to follow through the designed action plan for implementation.
4. Due to lack of required validation process, validity of the instrument to be used, so as with the
results can be an issue.
15 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
The following are the identified characteristics of action research that every teacher- researcher
may consider:
1. Action research in schools investigates human actions and social situations that are
experienced by teachers as: (1) unacceptable in some respects (problematic); (2) susceptible
to change (contingent); and (3) requiring a practical response (prescriptive). Action research
is concerned with the everyday practical problems experienced by teachers, rather than the
“theoretical problems” defined by pure researchers within a discipline of knowledge. It may
be carried out by teachers, themselves or by someone they commission to carry it out for
them.
2. The aim action research is to deepen the teacher’s understanding (diagnosis) of his/her
problem. It therefore, adopts an exploratory stance towards any initial definitions of his/her
situation he/she may hold. This understanding does not indicate any specific response but it
does indicate more generally what sort of response is appropriate. Understanding does not
determine appropriate action but appropriate action must be grounded on understanding.
3. Action research adopts a theoretical stance. Action intended to change the situation is
temporarily suspended until deeper understanding of the practical problem has been achieved.
4. In explaining what is going on, action research tells a story about the event by relating it to a
context of mutually interdependent contingencies, i.e. events that hang together because they
depend on each other for their occurrence. This “story” is sometimes called a case study. The
mode of explanation is case study that is naturalistic rather than formalistic. Relationships are
illuminated by concrete description rather than by formal statements of casual laws and
statistical correlations. Case study provides a theory of the situation but it is a naturalistic
theory embodied in narrative form, rather than a formal theory stated in propositional form.
5. Action research interprets what is going on from the point of view of those acting and
interacting in the problem situation, e.g. teachers and pupils, teacher and head teacher. Events
are interpreted as human actions and transactions rather than natural
16 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
processes subject to the laws of natural science. Actions and transactions are interpreted in
terms of the conditions they postulate, i.e. as expressions of a person’s:
- Understanding of and beliefs about his/her situation
- Intentions and goals
- Choices and decisions
- Acknowledgement of certain norms, principles and values in diagnosing, setting
goals, and choosing courses of action.
What is going on is made intelligible by reference to the subjective meanings ascribed to it by
the participants. This is why interviewing and participant observation are important research tools in
an action research.
6. Since action research looks at a situation from participants’ point of view, it describes and
explains “what is going on” in the time language as they used, such as the common sense
language people use to describe and explain human actions and social situations in everyday
life. It is by virtue of this fact that the accounts of action research can be validated in dialog
with participants. A research report couched in the language of abstract disciplines is never a
product of genuine action research.
7. Since action research looks at a problem from the point of view of those involved, it can only
be validated in unconstrained dialog with them. Action research necessarily involves
participants in self-reflection about their situation, as active partners in the research. Accounts
of dialog with participants about the interpretations and explanations emerging from the
research should be an integral part of any action research report.
8. Since action research involves unconstrained dialog between the researcher (whether he/she
be an outsider or teacher-researcher) and participants, there must be free information flow
between them. The participants must have free access to the researcher’s data, interpretations,
accounts, etc. and the researcher must have free access to “what is going on” and their
interpretations and accounts of it. This is why action research cannot be undertaken properly
in the absence of trust established by fidelity to a mutually agreed ethical framework
governing the collection, use and release of data.
Action research can involve a single teacher investigating as issue in his/her classroom, a
group of teachers working on a common problem, or a team of teachers and others focusing on a
school-or district-wide issue. (Based on the researcher/s doing the research work)
17 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
journal, newsletter, info graphics, monograph, web page, online journal or any electronic
platforms. More so it is possible for several teachers to be working concurrently on the same
problem with no knowledge of the work of others.
2. Collaborative Action Research. It may include as few as two teachers or a group of
several teachers and others interested in addressing a classroom or department issue. The
issue may involve one classroom or a common problem shared by many classrooms. As such,
the teacher doing the research may be supported by individuals outside school, like
community, agency, organization or institutional partner.
(Based on scope)
18 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
Hence, Ferrance (2000) identified differences among various types of action research
presented in the table below.
19 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
There are four varieties of action research and each variety has some values and own limitations.
Self-reflection question:
20 | P a g e
Chapter 1, Embracing the Teaching Profession
Lesson 2. –Embedding Action Research for Reflective Teaching
Deepen
Activity 01_Ch1_L2
Directions: Prepare a Summary Paper about your understanding of action research. Include the
following in your Summary Paper:
a. Definition
b. Characteristics
c. Challenges
d. Importance
e. Steps
Activity 02_Ch1_L2
Directions: Apply your understanding of concepts about Action Research. Identify 3 prevailing
problems inside classroom situation that teachers are encountering which maybe solved
through action research. Complete the matrix below.
21 | P a g e