We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 15
‘THE ‘DRESS REHEARSAL)
‘Om a sunny Sunday morning the long columns of protestors marched
across the ice towards the centre of St Petersburg, Church bells rang
and their golden domes sparked in the sun. In the font ranks were the
‘women and children, deste in ther Sunday best, who had been placed
these to deter the soldiers from shooting At the head ofthe largest col-
‘umn was the bearded figure of Father Gapon in a long white cassock
catrying a crucifix. Gapon had made a name for himself asa preacher in
the workers’ districts ofthe capital, Hetold his fllowersin simple terms,
‘with arguments drawn from the sible that the Tsar was obliged efore
God to satisty their demands if tohim in supplication
The petition head drawn up forthe marches to presento the Tsar began:
SieWe, the woskers and inhabitants of St Peterburg, of varlous
come to THEE, OSIRE
estates, ou wives, our children, and ou
to see justice and protection, Weare impoverished we are oppressed
‘overburdened with excesive tol contemptuous tated... We are
sufcating in despotism and lawlesnes
Behind Gapon was a portrait of the Tsar anda large white banner with
the words: "Soldiers donot shoot atthe people!” Red fags, the banner of
the revolutionaties,had been banned by th organizers ofthe march
As the column ng
ton of cavalry Si
advance towards the]
at them, Two warnin
range a third volley
and fell o the grou
continued to fire se
killed and hundreds
down inthe rush, Be
around him, was he
no Teac”
There were blood
Square a huge body ¢
front of the Winter 1
‘The guards tried to ¢
sabres. But when this
Seeing the efes poin
took of their caps a
firing began. When
a the dead and wot
moment, the turning
‘changed from disbe
recalled Bolshevik
No, the reverend and
tility and even hatre
literally every face”
Ta few seconds
(ained the regime the
moments after the st
fourteen and said to
remember and sweat
spilled, did you seo?vestors marcied
burch bells rang
vt ranks were the
hud been placed
sf the largest cal
vg white cassocke
fasa preacher in
in simple terms,
2s obliged before
i supplication,
othe Tsar began
rp of various
CHEB, O SIRE
are oppressed,
ted. Weare
bite banner with
the banner of
of the march,
‘As the column neared the Narva Gates it was charged by a squad:
‘ton of cavalry. Some ofthe marchers ran away but most continued to
advance towards the line of infantry, whos rifles were pointing directly
st them. Two warning salvoes were fred into the ae, and then a close
range third volley was aimed at the unarmed crowd, People screamed
And fell tothe ground but the soldiers, now panicking themselves,
continued to fire steadily into the mass of people. Forty people were
[ulled and hundreds wounded as they tried to le. Gapon was knocked
own in the rush But he got up and, staring in disbelief atthe carnage
round him, was heard to say: "There is no God any longer. Thee i
no Tse”
‘There were Bloody incidents in other parts of the ity. On Palace
‘Square a huge body of cavalry and several cannons had been posted in
{ont ofthe Winter Palace to stop another group of 60,000 protestors.
‘The guards tried to clear the crowds using whips and the fats of their
sabres. But when this proved unsuccessful they took up Sing positions
‘Seeing the ries pointed at them, the demonstrators fell to their knees,
took off their caps and crossed themsclves. A bugle sounded and the
firing began. When it was al over and the survivors looked around
atthe dead and wounded bodies on the ground there was one vital
‘moment, the turning: point of the whole evolution, when their mood
‘changed from disbelief to anger. T observed the faces around me;
recalled a Bolshevik in the rowed ‘and I detected neither fear nor panic
'No,the reverend and almost prayerful expressions were replaced by hos
tility and even hatred. I saw these looks of hatred and vengeance on
literally every face?
Ina few seconds the popular myth ofa Good Tsar—wwhich had sus
tained the regime through the centuies~—vwas suddenly destroyed. Only
‘moments after the shooting had ceased an old man turned to a boy of
fourteen and sud to him, with his voice fll of anger:'Remember, som,
remember and swear to repay the Tsar. You saw how much blood he
spilled, dd you see? Then swear, son, swear!”There was awave of strikes and demonstrations aginst the massacres of
“Bloody Sunday, asthe events of9 January 1905 became known. In that
‘month alone, more than 400,000 workers downed tols across the cou
try. Ie was the largest ever labour protest fn Russian history. But the
strikes were not really organizes thelr demands were formulated as they
‘went along; and the socialist parties were tll much too weak, too closely
watched by the police, their main leaders in eile in Europe to play a
leading role, The workers could not bring about revolution on thelr own.
eral middle classes and nobility that
turned the events of Bloody Sunday into a revolutionary crisis of author
Te was the response of the li
ity forthe tarst government Since 1903 liberal professionals and 2
otal reforms, inclding &
demand fora national assembly, Together they had formed a Union of
Liberation, whose petitions to the Tsar had influenced Gapon.
‘Bloody Sunday was not the frst blow tothe Tsar's authority. Russias
military humiliation in a war against Japan had turned a broad section
‘of the public agnint him and added strength tothe Union's campsign
tis hard to overestimate the shock caused in Russia as the news of,
reported defeats y the Japanese came in—the first timea modern Euro-
pean power had been beaten by an Asian people In January 1904, the
‘war had begun when the tarst let in Manchuria was ravaged by a
Japanese surprise attack. ‘Ie fapanese had been angered by Russias
stvo activists had been campaigning f
aggressive economic expansion in the Fat East and by the implications
ofthe Trans-Siberian Railway asi approached completion. Despite this
initial setback the Russians were confident of an easy victory. Govern
‘ment posters portrayed the Japanese as puny little monkeys, slit-eyed
and yellow-skinned, running in panic from the giant white fst of «
robust Russian soldier. Swept along bythe patriotic mood, liberals con
tended that Russia was defending European civilization against the
‘yellow danger, the new hordes of Mongols armed by modern technology
yeaa whch tie
‘ays behind the Gregorian (Nem Se) calendar ne Wester Europe Dts relting
selon enh yep ony tee
The zemstvos spran
Manchurian Fron.
Head the war bee
Political capital ron
sian military to figh
the sheer incompete
themilitary doctrin
of Russian lives by
entrenched artillery
As the war went
fvernment, using
ment for political
had in the past reli
criticism as they su
So unpopular had
Viacheslav von Plehy
to pieces by a terror
In Warsave,Pleve’s
shocked by Pl
with another hard
ofthe opposition a
Prince Mirsky, whe
-Mirsky’s appoint:
fn St Petersburg ane
including a legisla
the congress was it
tory, People at the
189, Civie bodies «
lutions. The Union
‘hose in France in |
toasts were drunk
Mirsky presente.
stvo assembly’s res
gramme of moderatown’ In that
dssthe coun:
‘ory. But the
sated a they
k, too closely
spe to play a
onthe own
nobility that
sis ofauthor:
alsand 2em-
including 3
{da Union of
orty, Russia's
road section
campaign
the news of
ary 1904, the
ravaged bya
by Russia's
implications
Despite this,
‘ory. Govern:
ps, aiv-eyed
‘hite fst of 3
liberals con
a against the
technology
“The zemstvos sprang back ino action and sent medical brigades to the
Manchurian Front
Had the war been won, the regime might have been able to: make
pelitical capital from this patriotic upsurge. Bu it was hard forthe Rus:
san military to fight a war 6,000 miles awa: The biggest problem was
the sheer incompetence ofthe High Command, which stuck rigidly to
the military doctrines ofthe nineteenth century and wasted thousands
of Russian lives by ordering hopeless bayonet charges against well
entrenched artillery position a mistake it would repeat in 1914-17.
‘As the war went from bad to worse, the liberals turned against the
‘government, using is bungled military campaign as a pateotl argu:
rent for politi
Jha in the past relied on the sat for protection, joined the chorus of
criticism as they sulered trom the economic dislocations ofthe war.
So unpopular had the government become that in July 1904, when
\Viacheslav von Pleve, its reactionary Minister ofthe Interior, was Blown
to pieces by a terrorist bomber, there was hardly 2 word of public regret.
In Warsaw, Plehive's murder was celebrated by crowds inthe street.
Shocked by Plehves murder, the Tsar had intended to replace him
‘with another hardliner, but bad news from the Front and the strength
‘ofthe opposition at home finally persuaded him to appoint a liberal,
Prince Missky, who called himself ‘zemstvo man. Encouraged by
Mirsky’s appointment, 103 zemstvo representatives met ata congress
Petersburg and passed a ten pon resolution for politcal reform,
Snchding a legislative parliament. Convene illegally in various palaces,
the cangress ws, in effect, the frst national assembly in Russian his
tory, People atthe time compared itt the French Estates-General of
1789, Civic bodies and associations held meeting to suppor its reso
lutions. The Union of Liberation organized a series of banguets (like
‘those in France in 1847-8) attended by the zemstvos’ supporters where
toasts were drunk to freedom and a constitution
‘Mirsky presented the Tsar with a carefully worded digest ofthe zem-
stvo assembly resolution in the hope of winning him over toa pro-
gramme of moderate reform. It asked only fr a consultative pasiament
form, Bven the country’s main industrialists, who(eather than a legislative one) and for zematvo delegates to sit in the
State Council an advisor lepisative body appointed by the Tsar. But ever
this was to much for Nichola, who ruled out any tlk of political efoem
as ‘harmflto the people whom God has entrusted to melOn 12 Decem-
ber, the Tar issued an Imperial Manifesto promising to strengthen the
rule oflaw, to ease restrictions onthe pres, and to expand the authority
‘of the zemstvos. But it said nothing on the controversial subject of a
parliamentary body. Hearing of its contents, Mirsky fel into despair.
“Berything has failed he sai to his colleagues ‘Let ws build jails
there isa single, repetitive theme in the history of Russia during
the last decades ofthe old regime, it is that ofthe need for reform and
the flue of successive governments to achiev it inthe face ofthe Tsar’
‘opposition, Mirsky’ initiative was probably the main chance the gov
cexnment would have to avert a revolution. In a crisis of authority a
regime's best hope of survival is to make concessions soon enough to
satisty and split ff the oppositions moderate wing
Bloody Sunday ended the Tsar's chance of keeping the political in
tiative. It drove the liberals to the lef, creating & more radical, united
opposition to the government. Educated society was outraged by the
massacre. Sudents went on strike an turned ther campuses into cee
tres of politcal agitation. By the end of February, the government had
been forced to close down virtually all institutions of higher learning
until the end of the academic year. Profesional unions organized them:
‘elves ata national level into a Union of Unions, later joined by a Wom
en's Union for Equality and similar unions for semi-professional groups
(ea. railway workers and employees), which gave the intelligentsia direct
link to the masses
“The protest movement quickly spread tothe non-Russian bordriands
twas particuatlystrongin Poland, Finland, the Baltic provinces andthe
‘Caucasus, where social and political tensions were reinforced by a wide
spread hatred of Russian rule. In the ten Polish provinces there were more
strikes in the spring and summer of 195 than in the rest of the empire
combined. In Wat
with the police. N
brated in Poland, 1
bring doven the gor
The mood oft
government's we:
ized ren strikes
try’ land, felled t
they begun to laun
and setting fire to
spoke of the night.
of horse-drawn ce
property. Nearly 3
f Russa during
ar reform and
face ofthe Tsar's
chance the gov
Sof authority a
900 enough to
he political ini
ical, united
‘outraged by the
puss into cen-
government had
higher learning
organized them
ined by a Wom:
fessional groups
gents direct
tan bordetands
rovinces and the
orced by a wide
there were more
sst of the empire
combined. In Warsaw and Lodz strikers put up barricades and cashed
With the police. News of Rusis humiliating defeat by Fapan was cele
bated in Poland, Finland and the Baltic lands in the belief that it would
bring down the government and pave the way forthe own autonomy.
‘The mood of rebellion spread tothe countryside as wel. Seeing the
government’ weakness, the peasants took their chance and orga
nized ret strikes against the landowners. They trespassed on the gen
try’ land, fled their trees and cut thee hay. From the ealy summer,
‘they began to launch full-scale attacks on their estates, seizing property
and setting fre to the manors, forcing the landowners to fle, Witnesses,
spoke of the night sky litup bythe blaze of burning manors an the lines
of horse-drawn carts moving along the roads, loaded with plundered
property. Nearly 3,000 manors were destrayed (5 percent ofthe total)
‘during the jacquerie of 1905-6. Most ofthe violence was concentrated
in the central agricultural zone south of Moscow, where the largest
estates were located and peasant poverty wis most acute.
‘The local gentry appealed for help against the peasant, and the gov
ernment sent in the troops. Prom January to October 1905 the atmy
was deployed no fewer than 2,700 times to
accelerating the breakdown of army discipline which had begun with
the despatch ofthe troops to Manchuria. It was the growing threat of
‘ mtinous revolution at home combined with the prospect of defeat
abroad which forced the Tsar to sue for peace with Japan. It proved
impossible—a it would again in 1917—to conduct foreign war in the
‘midst of a domestic socal revolution. The vast majority of the infantry
‘were peasant, and resented being used to suppres agrarian discontent
Whole units refused to carry ot orders and mutiniesspreed through
the ranks. Even the Cossack cavalry—known to be among the Tsar's
‘mot loyal soldiers—succumbed to the mood of rebellion. And then, on
1 June the unrest spread tothe Black Se Fleet,
The mutiny began with apiece of maggoty meat. The ship's doctor
on the battleship Potemkin declared it was ft to eat, When the sailors,
complined to the captain he had thle spokesman, Vakulenchuk, sho.
“The crew rebelled, killed seven offers and raised the red flag on the
jown peasant uprisingship. The mutineers took the Potemkin to Odessa, where steking work
crs had bosn ina state of virtual war withthe ity government fr the
past two weeks Surrounded by a guard of honour, Vakulenchuk’'sbody
‘was placed atthe foot ofa set of marble steps (ater immortalized by
Eisenstein lm) leading from the harbour to the city Huge crows gah
ered on the harbour front, placing wreaths around the bier of the mae
tyred revolutionary. Troops were sent in to disperse the crowd. Moving
down the steps, they fired indiscriminately into the hemmed-in civil
Jans below: 2,000 people were killed and 3,000 wounded before the i
ing stopped. The mutiners sled to Constanza in Romani, where they
give up the Potemkin for safe refuge In itself the mutiny had been &
minor threat Bu it was a major embarrassment to the goverment for
itshowed the word that the revolution had spread tothe hear ofits own
military machine,
‘With the Russian Empiceon the verge of collapse, the regime responded
to the crisis with its usual incompetence and obstinacy: Nicholas seemed.
oblivious to the dangers of the situation: while the country sank into
chaos he filled his diary with trivial notes on the weather and the com-
pny at tea. His advisers told him that foreign agents had been respon:
sible for the demonstration on bloody Sunday. 4 carefully selected
delegation of ‘liable’ workers was simmoned to his palace and lined
uplike children to hear lecture from the Tsar in which he blamed the
workers fr allowing themselves to be deceived by foreign revolution
aries’ but promised to “forgive them their sins’ because he believed in
‘heir ‘unshakeable devotion’. When advised by his new Minister ofthe
Interior, A. G. Bulygin, that political concessions might be needed to
‘calm the country, Nicholas was astounded. He told the Minister: ‘One
‘would think that you are afraid a revolution will break out! "Your May
‘sty Bulygin replied, the revolution has already begun.*
(On 18 February 1905, Nichols isued an Imperial Manifesto calling
‘onthe people to unite behind the throne and send in ideas for improve
ments inthe government’ Bulygin was instructed to deaw up proposals.
fora national assemb
reform petitions were
regiments, towns and
during the French Rey
ing language of deme
foc Nicholas. Mosteal
legislation, efetive
the only sort of assem
Bulygi Duma, prese
sulative one (wha
chive to ensure the do
‘The Bulygin Dum,
cadlie it would have
fexament to regain th
moderate reformers f
Petersburg’ adult res
provincial cites the n
chose to boycott the
ment of mass evil die
ing further concession
During 1905 the work
organized ond militar
ties growing infence
more clas-conscious
police became more bi
The general strike
ciplined uprising by t
walk-out by the Mo
better pay and conditi
(the printing works we
which came under atte
police and erected batriking work
tment for the
chuk’s body
rortalized by
crowds gah
+ ofthe mar
wd, Moving
smed-in civik
defore the fi
a where they
yhad been a
ernment, for
artofitsown,
vneresponded
thos seemed
try sank into
and the com:
been
fully selected
ace and lined
re blamed the
sa revolution
te believed in
Sinister of the
be needed to
Jinister ‘One
28 "Your Maj
aifesto calling
for ‘improve
‘up proposals
for a national assembly. For the next four months tens of thousands of
refoem petitions were sent in tothe Tsar from village assembles, amy
regimens, towns and factories Like the eaiers, the letters of grievance
luring the French Revolution of 178, they gave expression tothe evov
ing language of democracy. But their demands were much too radical
for Nicholas, Mos called for a national parliament with sovereign rights,
of legisation, effectively establishing a constitutional monarchy, whereas
the only sort of assembly which the Tsar was prepared to concede (the
Bulygin Duma, presented for his signature on 6 August was a purely
consultative one (what Mirsky had propose) elected ona limited fran
chise to ensure the domination of the aristocracy
The Bulygin Duma (parliament) was to little too late: six months
calier it would have been welcomed, and might have enabled the gov
ernment to regain the political initiative. But now all but the most
moderate reformers found it unsatisfactory, Less than 1 percent of St
Petersburg’s adult residents would qualify for the vot, while in many
provincial cities the number would be even tine. The socialist partes
chose t boycott the elections and support the aleady growing move-
ment of mass civil disobedience to pressure the government into mak
ng further concessions.
Dring 1905 the workers’ strikes and protests had become increasingly
‘onganized and militant. This was partly the result ofthe socialist par
ties growing influence, but mainly ofthe workers themselves becoming
‘ore elas-conscious and violent a their confliets with employers and
police became more biter and intense.
“The general strike was a classic example ofa spontancous yet dis