Scribd
Upload
27 views3 pages

ORacle and MongoDB TCO Comparison

Uploaded by

Duvan Mejia
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
27 views3 pages

ORacle and MongoDB TCO Comparison

Uploaded by

Duvan Mejia
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

Year 1 Year 2

Oracle MongoDB Oracle MongoDB


Development Effort 120 60 120 60
Administrative 60 30 60 30
Sw maintenance and support 93 36 93 36
Server maintenance and supprt 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2
Storage Maintenance and support 12.5 2.4 12.5 2.4
Migration effort 75
286.7 204.6 286.7 129.6

3 yr TCO
Oracle MongoDB
Development Effort 360 180
Administrative 180 90
Sw maintenance and support 279 108
Server maintenance and supprt 3.6 3.6
Storage Maintenance and support 37.5 7.2
Migration effort 0 75
Overall 3 yr TCO 860.1 463.8

1000
900 860.1
800
700
600
500 463.8
400 360
300 279

200 180 180


90 108
100 75
37.5
3.6 3.6 7.2 0
0
rt ve rt rt rt or
t
CO
ffo ti po pp po eff T
t E tra su
p su su
p yr
en is d on l3
in
an
d an an
d
ati al
pm m ce gr er
lo Ad ce an ce i v
ve an n an M O
De e n
in
te e n
nt a nt
ai m ai
m r M
Sw ve ge
er a
S or
St

Oracle MongoDB
Year 3 3 yr TCO
Oracle MongoDB Oracle MongoDB
120 60 360 180
60 30 180 90
93 36 279 108
1.2 1.2 3.6 3.6
12.5 2.4 37.5 7.2
0 75
286.7 129.6 860.1 463.8

Savings 46%

554710 388710 0.700745

860.1

463.8

75

T CO
yr
l3
al
ver
O
The TCO model assumes the same server hardware for MongoDB and Oracle. For the smaller project, we assume 3 servers, ea
RAM, at $4,000 per server. For the larger project, assumed 30 servers, each with 8 cores and 32 GB RAM, at $4,000 per server

For MongoDB, the TCO model accounts for two 1 TB SSDs (1 TB mirrored) per server ($8,000), which translates to $24,000 in t
$240,000 in the larger project. For Oracle, assumed a 3 TB SAN ($125,000 for 3 TB usable) for the smaller project and a 30 TB S
($500,000 for 30 TB usable).

Oracle configurations as analogous as possible to the MongoDB configurations, we use Oracle Database Enterprise Edition ($4
RAC pricing ($23,000 per core), for a total of $70,500 per core. Discounts on Oracle pricing can range from 0% for small deploy
deployments. We assume a conservative 50% discount on the list price for the smaller and larger projects. Additionally, we ap
on top of that to account for Oracle's core processor licensing factor.2 This amounts to $17,625 per core for both projects.

1. While one can reduce software costs by using only Oracle Database Enterprise Edition and forgoing Oracle RAC, this entails
scale-out) architecture, requiring the customer to purchase a more powerful and expensive server. For the sake of keeping the
comparable as possible across the configurations, we use Oracle RAC in this example. See Server Hardware and the associated
2. To account for differences in CPU core architecture, Oracle multiplies the number of cores by a core processor licensing fact
for older Sun SPARC processors, to 0.5 for most AMD and Intel processors, to 1.0 for IBM Power and others.

In the smaller scenario, we assume that MongoDB requires 50% less ongoing developer effort (6 man-months) than Oracle (12
scenario, we apply the same logic, assuming 18 man-months of ongoing developer effort for MongoDB and 36 man-months fo
loaded developer salary of $120,000 per year.

For MongoDB, the TCO model assumes software maintenance and support costs of $11,990 per server, per year for the smalle
server, per year for the larger project (a 10% discount). The TCO model assumes 22% of license costs for Oracle. The model als
maintenance and support costs of 10% of the hardware purchase price for both MongoDB and Oracle.

You might also like