Neuroimaging in Investigation of Patients With.11
Neuroimaging in Investigation of Patients With.11
Neuroimaging in
Address correspondence to
Dr Fernando Cendes,
Departamento de Neurologia,
FCM, UNICAMP, Campinas,
KEY POINTS
h CT scans are indicated more important for the diagnosis of In addition, the logistics of CT make it
in emergent situations the etiology of epilepsies than the easier for unstable patients to be
but are of limited emergence of MRI. imaged as compared to MRI. There-
usefulness for limited fore, this is the ideal imaging exami-
or small lesions, particularly INDICATIONS nation for emergencies. CT can detect
in regions of orbitofrontal All patients with epilepsy should un- most tumors (except for some low-
or medial temporal dergo an MRI except possibly those grade tumors), large arteriovenous
cortex. Focal lesions are with very typical forms of primary and extensive brain malformations,
only seen in 30%. generalized epilepsy (eg, juvenile stroke, and infectious lesions, and is
h A proper MRI investigation myoclonic epilepsy, childhood ab- sensitive for detection of calcified le-
of patients with focal sence) or benign focal epilepsies of sions and bone lesions. CT has low
epilepsies requires the childhood with characteristic clinical sensitivity for detecting small cortical
use of specific protocols and EEG features (eg, benign epilepsy lesions in general and particularly le-
selected based on with centrotemporal spikes, early- sions in the base of the skull, as in the
identification of the
onset childhood epilepsy with occipital orbitofrontal and medial temporal re-
region of onset by
spikes [Panayiotopoulos type]) and gions. Small, low-grade gliomas usually
clinical and EEG findings.
adequate response to antiepileptic drugs are not detected by CT. The overall per-
(AEDs).1,2 centage of success of CT in detecting
There are two basic situations in lesions in focal epilepsies is low, ap-
which to perform neuroimaging in pa- proximately 30%.3
tients with epilepsy. The first applies
to newly diagnosed patients and those MRI
with long-standing epilepsy that has The extraordinary ability of showing
not been properly investigated. The clear differences between gray and
second applies to patients with intrac- white matter and other tissues in the
table epilepsy who are therefore can- brain in MRI is the main difference
didates for surgery.2 Even patients between this technique and x-ray imag-
with long-term focal epilepsy of un- ing modalities, such as CT. MRI has
known etiology should undergo MRI. fundamental importance in the diagno-
Low-grade tumors may be found in sis and treatment of patients with
patients with a history of epilepsy with epilepsy. The introduction of MRI led
more than 20 years’ duration. to major improvement in the diagnosis
Priority should be given to patients and understanding of different epileptic
with focal changes in the neurologic syndromes. MRI allows the characteri-
examination. Emergent imaging (CT or zation of the nature of the lesion and its
MRI) should be performed in patients behavior over timeVthat is, whether
who have new onset of seizures with the lesion is progressive (eg, cancer,
focal neurologic deficits, fever, persis- Rasmussen encephalitis) or static (eg,
tent headache, cognitive changes, and a ischemic lesions, congenital malforma-
recent history of head trauma. Focal tions). Within the context of investiga-
seizures with onset after the age of 40 tion for surgical treatment, identification
years should be considered as a possi- of a lesion closely associated with the
ble indication for an emergency neuro- ictal and interictal EEG abnormalities is
imaging examination. associated with a better prognosis of
postoperative seizure control.4Y6
CT A proper MRI investigation of pa-
CT has the advantages of being avail- tients with focal epilepsies requires
able in most hospitals worldwide and the use of specific protocols selected
having a relatively low operating cost. based on identification of the region
624 www.ContinuumJournal.com June 2013
FIGURE 3-1 Coronal T1 inversion recovery (A, C) and fluid-attenuated inversion recovery
(FLAIR) (B, D) MRIs showing left hippocampal atrophy associated with change
in morphology and internal structure and hyperintense FLAIR signal (arrows),
all classic signs of hippocampal sclerosis on MRI that were confirmed on postoperative
histopathology. Patient with left mesial temporal lobe epilepsy was seizure free after left
amygdalohippocampectomy.
Feature Description
Hippocampal The most specific and reliable feature, hippocampal atrophy, is defined
atrophy by comparing the hippocampal circumference on each side on all available
coronal slices. Small asymmetries can be present because of normal variation
or a tilted position in the scanner, and should not be considered abnormal.
It is important to evaluate the shape of the hippocampus as well. A normal
hippocampus is oval. In the presence of hippocampal sclerosis it becomes
flattened and usually inclined.
Increased T2 signal In isolation, increased T2 signal may be insufficient to diagnose hippocampal sclerosis.
T2 mapping (relaxometry) is an objective method for measuring abnormal T2 signal,
which may be difficult to detect visually.
Loss of internal This is usually associated with atrophy and hyperintense T2 signal. The loss of normal
structure internal hippocampal structure is a consequence of neuronal loss and gliosis with
a collapse of pyramidal cell layers that is characteristic of hippocampal sclerosis.
Other features Asymmetry of the horns of the lateral ventricles (which is variable and may lead to
false lateralization) and atrophy of the anterior temporal lobe (which is nonspecific)
may be present.
Atrophy of the fornix and mammillary body ipsilateral to the hippocampal sclerosis
may also be present.
Case 3-1
A 40-year-old, right-handed man presented with focal seizures since 2 years of age. Seizures were
controlled with antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) until he was 10 years old, when he began having at
least 3 focal seizures per week despite several adequate trials with AEDs; his longest period free of
seizures was 3 months. He described his seizures as rising epigastric sensations (sometimes with fear)
followed by loss of contact with surroundings, staring, oroalimentary automatisms, and sometimes
more complex automatisms such as walking around or taking off his clothes. Rarely, these seizures
evolved to secondary generalization. The patient had no history of head trauma, encephalitis, or
status epilepticus and no family history of seizures. He complained that his memory had been getting
worse over the years.
Routine EEGs showed frequent slow waves and epileptiform sharp waves over both
anterior-midtemporal regions with left-side predominance. Five of his habitual seizures were
recorded on video-EEG monitoring. All had EEG onset over the left anterior-midtemporal region
(maximum at T3) and the first clinical manifestations were coincident with first EEG changes. The
patient’s neuropsychological evaluation showed a significant deficit of verbal and nonverbal memory
and impairment of verbal fluency tests. His MRI showed signs of left hippocampal sclerosis (Figure 3-1).
He underwent a left anterior temporal lobe resection and had a brief focal seizure on the second
day after surgery, after which he remained seizure free on carbamazepine over the next 2 years
until it was discontinued; a few months later he had a generalized seizure and a few focal seizures. He was
put back on medication and remained seizure free at the last follow-up visit 5 years after surgery.
Comment. This patient had a typical history, semiology, EEG changes, and MRI signs of
hippocampal sclerosis. Unfortunately, he spent 30 years with frequent, disabling seizures and was
referred for evaluation for surgical treatment only at age 40. Patients with this clinical picture and
clear-cut MRI findings of unilateral hippocampal sclerosis should be considered for evaluation for
surgery as soon as refractoriness to AEDs is defined.
epilepsies, subtle structural lesions can be fast and able to provide excellent
be missed unless MRI is performed differentiation of gray and white mat-
with optimal technical quality and ex- ter and spatial resolution. Unfortunately,
pertly interpreted. Correlation with these goals are mutually exclusive
semiology, EEG, and structural and because of limitations imposed by
functional imaging data is essential. basic physical principles of MRI. The
The ideal protocol for MRI investi- sequences should include T1- and T2-
gation in patients with epilepsy should weighted images covering the entire
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2013;19(3):623–642 www.ContinuumJournal.com 629
KEY POINTS
h MRI sequences should
include T1- and
T2-weighted images
covering the entire brain
in the three orthogonal
planes, with minimum
slice thickness allowed
by the scanner. The
injection of contrast is
usually unnecessary;
however, it may be
important in situations
when the images
without contrast are not
sufficient for diagnosis
or when a tumoral or
inflammatory lesion is
suspected.
h The use of appropriate
MRI protocols targeted
for the study of patients
with epilepsy allows
the diagnosis of the
majority of patients with
lesional epilepsies.
However, in a
considerable number FIGURE 3-4 MRI curvilinear reconstruction (A, C, and E) in a patient with frontal lobe seizures
and previous MRIs considered as normal. Panel D shows an axial T1-weighted
of patients with image at the level of the abnormality. Note the area with abnormal gyri (H, I, red
epilepsy, the MRI is arrows), a deep sulcus, and a depression on the overlying surface of the brain
considered normal. (G-I, blue arrows) with increased CSF space that is better observed in the curvilinear reconstructions
in the right frontal lobe (A-C, E, F). These abnormalities and the focal cortical-subcortical
Although the etiology blurring become obvious in the curvilinear reconstructions in layers going from 4 mm (A) to
remains unclear in these 12 mm (F) below the surface of the brain. The T2-weighted and fluid-attenuated inversion
cases, the disorders of recovery (FLAIR) images (not shown) did not show abnormal signal. The patient, a 36-year-old
woman, underwent a right frontal resection under electrocorticography and has been seizure
cortical development, free for 4 years. Histopathology showed focal cortical dysplasia type IIA.
mainly focal cortical
dysplasia, have been
identified as the most brain in the three orthogonal planes, that more methods of image recon-
likely pathologic with minimum slice thickness al- struction from 3D acquisitions allow
substrates. lowed by the scanner. The injection of a better evaluation of patients with
contrast (eg, gadolinium) is usually discrete structural lesions, especially
unnecessary; however, it may be im- focal cortical dysplasias (Figure 3-3 and
portant in situations when the images Figure 3-4).
without contrast are not sufficient The use of appropriate MRI pro-
for diagnosis or when a tumoral or tocols targeted for the study of patients
inflammatory lesion is suspected. with epilepsy allows the diagnosis of
The ideal MRI in patients with focal the majority of patients with lesional
epilepsy should include a 3D volumet- epilepsies. However, in a considerable
ric acquisition with thin sections (ie, number of patients with epilepsy, the
less than 2 mm) in order to enable the MRI is considered normal. Although the
reconstruction of images in any plane etiology remains unclear in these cases,
(Table 3-2).8,9,11 Studies have shown the disorders of cortical development,
630 www.ContinuumJournal.com June 2013
mainly focal cortical dysplasia, have been examinations as areas of cortical thick-
identified as the most likely pathologic ening, loss of the interface between
substrates. The effort involved in try- white and gray matter, focal atrophy,
ing to increase the detection of these and hyperintense signal in T2/FLAIR
‘‘invisible’’ lesions involves the im- sequences (Figure 3-3, Figure 3-4,
provement of the signal-to-noise ratio and Figure 3-5).
and contrast resolution between dif- In the current classification, focal
ferent tissue types, structural imaging cortical dysplasias are subdivided into
techniques, and imaging postprocessing.8 three types: type I (no dysmorphic
Among the techniques used to imple- neurons or balloon cells), type II (pres-
ment the image quality, two methods ence of dysmorphic neurons with or
are highlighted: the use of higher mag- without balloon cells), and type III
netic fields (eg, 3 Tesla or higher) and (focal cortical dysplasia associated with
surface coils.19,20 another lesion)9; these in turn have
subdivisions (Table 3-4).
Malformations of Cortical Focal cortical dysplasia type I may
Development present with mild hyperintensity of
Focal cortical dysplasias. Refractory the white matter in T2/FLAIR with loss
epilepsy, particularly in childhood, is of gray/white matter differentiation,
often associated with malformations but in many patients MRI does not
of cortical development, especially show abnormalities in the white matter.
focal cortical dysplasia. Many patients It may present with mild focal increase
have seizures refractory to medication in cortical thickness and abnormal gyrus
and are candidates for surgical treat- in shape and deep sulci, but it may also
ment. However, not all patients with be associated with focal volume loss
malformations of cortical develop- and thin cortex, in particular when the
ment present with refractory epilepsy. temporal lobe is affected.
Focal cortical dysplasia is character- Focal cortical dysplasia type IIB, or
ized by disorganization of the cortical focal cortical dysplasia with balloon
lamination associated with bizarre (ie, cells (which was previously defined as
dysplastic) neurons or cells with eosin- Taylor type dysplasia), is characterized
ophilic cytoplasm and increased vol- by areas of thickening of the cortex,
ume (ie, balloon cells).21 Focal cortical with the blurring of the differentiation
dysplasia may be observed in MRI between the gray/white matter interface,
FIGURE 3-5 Coronal T1-inversion recovery (A, B) and coronal (E, F) and axial fluid-attenuated
inversion recovery (FLAIR) images showing typical changes of focal cortical dysplasia
type IIB (arrows). Diagnosis was confirmed in the postoperative histopathology in a
patient with refractory focal seizures with temporal-insular semiology. Note area of cortical
thickening and loss of sharpness of the cortical-subcortical transition (A, B, D-F, blue arrows) and
cortical-subcortical signal changes (increased FLAIR signal and decreased T1 signal) below the area of
cortical thickening that extends toward the ventricle (transmantle sign) (A-C, F, red arrows).
Type of
Focal Cortical
Dysplasia Histologic Characteristics MRI Features
Ia Abnormal radial cortical lamination & Mild hemispheric hypoplasia
Ib Abnormal tangential cortical lamination & Areas with thin cortex
Ic Abnormal radial and tangential & Blurring of the gray/white matter junction
cortical lamination
& Abnormally shaped sulci and sometimes
deep sulci
& MRI results are often negative
& MRI cannot differentiate these subtypes
IIa Dysmorphic neurons without & Gradient of morphologic changes: from
balloon cells dysplastic lesions that can be easily
identified by conventional MRI techniques
to minor structural abnormalities, including
small areas of discrete cortical thickening or
blurring of the gray/white matter interface
that often go unrecognized
& Sometimes subtle hyperintense T2 signal
in the subcortical and deep white matter
IIb Dysmorphic neurons with & Increased T2 or fluid-attenuated inversion
balloon cells recovery (FLAIR) signal in the subcortical
white matter underneath the focal cortical
dysplasia
& Transmantle sign (tapering of abnormal
white matter signal from cortex to
ventricle surface)
& Blurring of the gray/white matter junction
& Increased cortical thickness
& Deep sulci
& Abnormal cortical gyration and sulcation
IIIa Architectural abnormalities & Variable combination of MRI features of
associated with hippocampal focal cortical dysplasia described above
sclerosis and the associated lesion, which is most
IIIb Architectural abnormalities frequently in the same lobe/region
adjacent to tumors
IIIc Architectural abnormalities
adjacent to vascular malformation
IIId Architectural abnormalities adjacent
to lesions acquired early in life
(ie, trauma, ischemic injury, encephalitis)
a
Adapted from Blümcke I, et al, Epilepsia.9 With permission from Wiley Periodicals, Inc. B 2010 International League Against Epilepsy.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1528-1167.2010.02777.x/full.
FIGURE 3-6 MRI of four different patients illustrating schizencephaly and polymicrogyria. Axial T2- and T1-weighted and
coronal T1-weighted MRIs from a patient with open-lip schizencephaly (AYC) and axial T1-weighted images from
a patient with closed-lip schizencephaly (DYF); axial T1-weighted image from a patient with bilateral polymicrogyria
(G) and coronal and sagittal T1-weighted image from a patient with left unilateral polymicrogyria (H, I).
edges are juxtaposed, and open-lip neurons reach the cerebral cortex
schizencephaly when the edges are during development but are distrib-
separated (Figure 3-6).22 uted abnormally, resulting in abnor-
Polymicrogyria is characterized by mal small gyri that may appear as
developmental abnormalities where thickened cortex if the MRI is acquired
634 www.ContinuumJournal.com June 2013
with low resolution and thick cuts promising the adjacent neocortex.23
(Figure 3-6).22 Subcortical laminar heterotopia (double
Periventricular nodular heterotopia cortex) is characterized by a continu-
is characterized by clusters of ectopic ous or semicontinuous ectopic band of
neurons and can be located at the gray matter below the cortical mantle
periventricular areas (subependymal). (Figure 3-7).9
These nodules consist of mature neu- Lissencephaly-agyria-pachygyria and
rons and glia cells without well-defined subcortical laminar heterotopia repre-
lamellar organization (Figure 3-7). Sub- sent extremes in the spectrum of the
cortical nodular heterotopia is charac- same entity. In lissencephaly-agyria-
terized by nodules of ectopic gray pachygyria the brain has a limited num-
matter that vary in number and size, ber of gyri and sulci, resulting in shallow
sometimes in the posterior peritrigonal sulci and large gyri with thickened
region (vascular border zone), and may cortex or an almost complete absence
extend toward the white matter, com- of sulci in lissencephaly (Figure 3-7).22
FIGURE 3-8 Two patients with left (A, B) and one patient with right (C, D)
hemimegalencephaly. Note the abnormal signal in the white matter, which is
brighter on T2 (A) and darker on T1-weighted images (BYD) of the affected
hemisphere in all patients and variable degrees of pachygyria and hemispheric enlargement.
Periventricular nodular heterotopia is present in panel D.
FIGURE 3-10 Coronal MRIs showing ganglioglioma in three patients with temporal lobe epilepsy and seizures not
responding to antiepileptic drugs who became seizure free after surgical resection of the lesion. A,
T2-weighted image showing a ganglioglioma in the left amygdala. B, T1-inversion recovery image showing
a small ganglioglioma in the right collateral sulcus (arrow) that was previously missed in an MRI without thin coronal cuts.
C, T2-weighted image showing a ganglioglioma in the left uncal region with a cystic component (arrow). Gangliogliomas
usually have clear limits and are hypointense on T1 (not shown in this figure) and hyperintense on T2-weighted images.
The contrast enhancement is variable from absent to intense, and may present with an annular (ring-enhancing) pattern.
Gangliogliomas should be considered when a poorly defined, slightly enhancing mass is present in the temporal lobes.
FIGURE 3-11 Two patients with temporal lobe epilepsy due to oligodendroglioma, one in the right temporal horn of the
ventricle adjacent to the hippocampus (AYC) and the other (DYF) in the right inferior temporal gyrus.
Oligodendrogliomas are nonspecifically hypointense on T1-weighted (D) and hyperintense on
T2-weighted or fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) images (A, E). Occasionally, foci of increased signal on
T1-weighted images (B) reflect intratumoral hemorrhage. Enhancement on CT or MRI is variable (C, F, arrows). On CT,
calcifications are expected and may be shell-like, ringlike, or nodular.
KEY POINTS
h N-acetylaspartate or subtle lesions of white matter, nology may allow multislice or 3D proton-
appears to be a dynamic which have research applications.26 MRS acquisitions with whole-brain cov-
marker of epileptogenic DTI clinical applications for epilepsy, erage, with good spatial resolutions.
activity as well as a although promising, are still limited.
marker of neuronal POSITRON EMISSION
density; therefore, MAGNETIC RESONANCE TOMOGRAPHY
N-acetylaspartate SPECTROSCOPY PET images using 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose
abnormalities should be ProtonYmagnetic resonance spectros- (18F-FDG) may demonstrate a focal or
interpreted with caution. copy (proton-MRS) assesses neuronal regional hypometabolism within the ep-
h The major limitation of integrity by quantifying the peak of ileptogenic area, especially in MTLE.26,29
magnetic resonance N-acetylaspartate (NAA), a marker of This hypometabolic area can extend be-
spectroscopy is its neuronal integrity, usually by compar- yond the epileptogenic zone defined by
limited coverage area, ing its concentrations with choline or EEG, or beyond the area of structural
which in current creatine peaks. Unlike MRI, single- damage. This hypometabolism may
practice undermines the
photon emission computed tomogra- represent deafferentation or neuronal
evaluation of patients
phy (SPECT), and positron emission dysfunction, and can ‘‘recover’’ after a
with neocortical epilepsy
without a strong
tomography (PET) techniques, the successful surgery.29,30
suspicion of the location entire brain is not covered by MRS In clinical practice, the additional
of the epileptogenic examinations and usually only a few yield of 18F-FDG-PET in patients with
focus or lesion on MRI. large voxels are included in proton- MTLE and clear video-EEG and MRI
h PET images using MRS.26Y28 The poor signal-to-noise findings is modest, and in most of these
18F-fluorodeoxyglucose ratio of proton-MRS is a technical cases it may be considered unnec-
may demonstrate a limitation for acquisitions including essary.29 However, for patients with
focal or regional small volumes of tissue. In addition, inconclusive video-EEG and MRI re-
hypometabolism within the relatively long time for spectra sults, 18F-FDG-PET is extremely help-
the epileptogenic area, acquisitions makes the quantification ful for presurgical evaluation; it
especially in mesial of spectra in many voxels impractical. provides a correct detection of tempo-
temporal lobe epilepsy. Comparisons with the EEG localiza- ral lobe foci in 66% of these cases, as
This hypometabolic area tion and surgical results have demon- confirmed by depth-EEG studies.30,31
can extend beyond the strated that the reduced signal intensity The focal hypometabolism has been
epileptogenic zone
of NAA can lateralize and localize the useful in predicting seizure control after
defined by EEG, or
epileptogenic focus in patients with surgery for MTLE, as the greater severity
beyond the area of
structural damage.
focal epilepsies, especially MTLE. How- of the hypometabolism (defined either
ever, these changes are often bilateral by quantitative or qualitative methods)
h In clinical practice, the in patients with MTLE.26Y28 Moreover, correlates with better postoperative
additional yield of
the relative concentration of NAA can seizure outcome.32,33
fluorodeoxyglucose-PET
in patients with mesial
normalize after successful surgery for An extratemporal epileptogenic fo-
temporal lobe epilepsy MTLE.27 NAA appears to be a dynamic cus presents a hypometabolism by
and clear video-EEG and marker of epileptogenic activity as well 18F-FDG-PET less frequently.26 How-
MRI findings is modest, as a marker of neuronal density; there- ever, some patients with infantile spasms
and in most of these fore, NAA abnormalities should be may have a regional hypometabolism
cases it may be interpreted with caution.27 that can help in the decision for a sur-
considered unnecessary. The major limitation of MRS is its gical treatment.29
However, for patients limited coverage area, which in current A cost-comparison study showed
with inconclusive practice undermines the evaluation of that the combination of EEG and MRI
video-EEG and MRI results, patients with neocortical epilepsy with- as screening tests, without addition of
18F-fluorodeoxyglucose-
out a strong suspicion of the location of PET, is the most cost-effective screen-
PET is extremely helpful.
the epileptogenic focus or lesion on ing approach for presurgical investiga-
MRI.27,28 Future improvements in tech- tion of epilepsies.34
640 www.ContinuumJournal.com June 2013
for seizures less than 15 seconds in 10. Colombo N, Salamon N, Raybaud C, et al.
Imaging of malformations of cortical
duration. development. Epileptic Disord 2009;11(3):
To improve the spatial resolution, 194Y205.
functional images can be subtracted 11. Barkovich AJ, Rowley HA, Andermann F. MR
(eg, ictal SPECT minus interictal SPECT) in partial epilepsy: value of high-resolution
and coregistered (eg, the subtracted volumetric techniques. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol
1995;16(2):339Y343.
ictal-interictal SPECT, or a PET image)
with a high-resolution anatomical 12. Kuzniecky RI, Bilir E, Gilliam F, et al.
Multimodality MRI in mesial temporal
MRI.26,35 All functional images must sclerosis: relative sensitivity and specificity.
be interpreted in the context of all Neurology 1997;49(3):774Y778.
clinical and laboratory data. 13. Arruda F, Cendes F, Andermann F, et al.
Mesial atrophy and outcome after
REFERENCES amygdalohippocampectomy or temporal
1. Berg AT, Berkovic SF, Brodie MJ, et al. lobe removal. Ann Neurol 1996;40(3):
Revised terminology and concepts for 446Y450.