Research Paper

Aryan Verma
David LeBlanc

Impact of E-commerce on retail and local businesses

Abstract:

The exponential growth of e-commerce has significantly transformed the retail sector and
carries substantial ramifications for neighborhood enterprises. This research paper
investigates the diverse effects that e-commerce has on conventional retail establishments and
regional businesses. By analyzing shifts in consumer behavior, competitive pricing strategies,
and supply chain adaptations, this report underscores the opportunities and challenges that
retailers face. Even though local enterprises encounter distinct obstacles, viable approaches to
thrive and endure in the digital era are discerned. Case studies and government regulations
and support are examined to illustrate the practical implications. Through this analysis, this
paper offers significant perspectives on the changing dynamics of the impact that e-
commerce has on the retail and local business sectors.

Keywords: e-commerce, retail industry, local business, digital transformation,

competitive pricing, supply chain management, SMEs, retail innovation, retail future

Problem Statement:

E-commerce has given birth to a new era in the retail sector, fundamentally bringing shift in
the nature of how customers purchase. This occurrence raises a crucial inquiry: To what
extent does e-commerce influence conventional physical retail establishments and
neighborhood enterprises? Established retail practices have been disrupted by the
introduction of online retail, which has posed a challenge to conventional business models
and necessitated swift adjustments. Local businesses are particularly vulnerable to the
existential risk of losing market share to digital behemoths. In order to tackle this urgent
matter, the objective of this research is to conduct an analysis of the obstacles and prospects
that electronic commerce offers to retail and local enterprises, thereby illuminating
approaches for enduring and expanding in the era of digitalization.

Purpose:

The primary objective of this research paper is to offer a thorough comprehension of the
significant ramifications that e-commerce has on conventional retail establishments as well as
local enterprises. Through an in-depth exploration of this commercial environment, this
article aims to analyse the diverse aftermath of electronic commerce, showing light on both
obstacles and prospects. The comprehensive objective is to provide retailers and local
businesses with valuable insights that will aid them in successfully adjusting to and
prospering in the era of digitalization.
Objective:

The purpose of this research study is to examine how the growing e-commerce sector affects
conventional retail and local companies. First, it evaluates how the internet commerce boom
has changed customer behavior and preferences. Second, the research analyses retail
competition, pricing tactics, and supply chain management changes. Finally, it will provide
practical advice for merchants and local businesses to succeed in this fast-changing digital
retail market.

Introduction:

E-commerce is the integration of digital technologies into the operational processes of an

organization and involves the interchange of digital media in exchange for purchases and
sales. The advent of innovative software and other technological developments during the
early 1990s caused a paradigm shift in the worldwide business environment, which was
radically altered by the Internet. The increasing inclination of individuals to optimize their
daily routines is met with e-commerce. (Ferrera, 2019)

Literature Review:

While the term "e-commerce" did not gain widespread usage until the 1990s, its rudimentary
applications can be traced back to the early 1970s, when electronic data exchange between
industrial entities first emerged. Electronic Data Interchange (EDI) brought e-commerce into
sharp focus. As a consequence, joint-stock companies, from financial institutions to retailers
and factories, increased in number. Furthermore, applications for telecommunications,
including the purchase and sale of shares, surfaced. The phrase "e-commerce" surged in
prominence in tandem with the widespread adoption of the internet. Subsequently, its
applications have grown substantially and progressed considerably due to the swift
developments in sophisticated computer systems and information and communication
technology. (Mohamad, 2022)
According to the PWC Report (2015), referenced in the text, the global number of internet
consumers in 2014 exceeded three billion [Figure 1]. Additionally, in relation to the studies,
emerging economies in Asia and Africa will be the main factors of the expansion of e-
commerce and acceptance in the future, surpassing established economies, and B2C digital
commerce is projected to grow at a more rapid growth rate when compared with B2B digital
commerce. India and China will probably emerge as the leading nations in the expansion of
digital commerce globally. (Goyal, 2019)

Figure 1
According to a statistical analysis performed by eMarketer, worldwide e-commerce
transactions are projected to increase from nearly $3.5 trillion in 2019 to $4.9 trillion by
2021. This signifies a substantial surge in electronic commerce transactions occurring within
a comparatively brief time span.
In addition, the source highlights the significance of implementing diverse digital
technologies to enhance the efficiency of supply and delivery, knowledge pertaining to
security, processes for payment, and e-commerce while experimenting with novel techniques.
Because of a growing acceptance of cutting-edge technology and business approaches or
strategies by both corporations and consumers, it is incontrovertible that e-commerce will
continuously develop and expand in the years ahead. This will result in globally expanding e-
commerce. (Beyari, 2021)
On the basis of statistical data and prevailing trends, it is possible to conclude that the e-
commerce sector is experiencing a significant growth spurt and has substantial potential for
future growth, and it is a good sign. Theories for analyzing e-commerce's influence on retail
and local enterprises include:
1. The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) investigates the determinants that impact
the acceptance and utilization of novel technologies. This framework may be employed
to examine how enterprises and consumers embrace electronic commerce, as well as
the determinants that propel or impede this trend. (Beyari, 2021)

2. Additionally, the theory of Diffusion of Innovation can be applied to examine how e-

commerce affects local and retail businesses. This theory analyses the diffusion and
adoption of new technologies within a society; it can be applied to studying the spread
of e-commerce and the components that influence its adoption. (Beyari, 2021)

3. An industry-shaping competitive analysis is conducted using Porter's Five Forces

model, which considers the threat of new participants, the negotiating power of
suppliers and consumers, the threat of substitute products or services, and the intensity
of competitive rivalry. By employing this framework, one can examine how e-
commerce is transforming the retail industry's competitive landscape and devise
strategies for conventional retailers to adapt. (Beyari, 2021)

4. The law of one price states that identical products should sell for the same price in
various locations under a perfectly competitive market condition. This uniform pricing
can be promoted with the assistance of e-commerce, which enables customers to
compare prices across retailers and locations with ease. (Jo, 2022)

5. A novel economic geography framework that places significant emphasis on the

influence of transport costs and other trade barriers on the distribution of economic
activity across space. E-commerce enables consumers to purchase products from any
location in the world, thereby aiding in the elimination of these obstacles. (Jo, 2022)

6. A novel framework for trade theory that places significant emphasis on the influence of
product differentiation and economies of scale in influencing international trade
patterns. These economies of scale can be aided by e-commerce, which permits
retailers to expand their consumer base and decrease their fixed expenses. (Jo, 2022)

7. When applied to e-commerce, Transaction Cost Theory (TCT) examines the expenses
linked to digital interactions and transactions. It provides guidance for decision-making
 processes pertaining to supplier management, outsourcing, platform selection, and
market entry strategies, with the objective of reducing transaction expenses. The
significance of minimizing uncertainty, upholding contractual obligations, and
optimizing market mechanism utilization is underscored by TCT. These factors are
indispensable within the intricate realm of electronic commerce operations. (Qi, 2020)

8. The Uppsala model delineates the progressive escalation of internationalization

endeavors by corporations, commencing with domestic markets that are culturally and
geographically intimate to their own. (Qi, 2020)

E-commerce offers retailers and local enterprises the following benefits:

1. One significant advantage is that it empowers organizations to expand their market

influence beyond the limitations imposed by their physical foundation. (Taher, 2021)

2. Through the utilization of electronic commerce, businesses can expand their clientele
to domestic and global markets with negligible financial outlay. This facilitates the
development of a company's customer base and revenue stream without requiring the
establishment of supplementary physical locations or branches. (Taher, 2021)

3. E-commerce has the potential to enhance business efficiency while concurrently

mitigating operational costs, including labor and rent. Moreover, online trading
powers enterprises to collect and evaluate consumer information, thus facilitating the
strategic focus on the most appropriate target market for their products or services.
(Taher, 2021)

4. By facilitating e-commerce, local retailers and businesses can increase sales, reduce
expenses, and improve operational efficiency. (Taher, 2021)

5. By eliminating the need for physical locations, e-commerce facilitates retailers' access
to a larger consumer base, thereby potentially contributing to the reduction of
operating expenses. This could be particularly useful for small enterprises or small
local businesses that have restricted capital or funds, as it may allow the cost
reduction of fixed expenditures such as utility costs, rent, and human resources. (Jo,
2022)

6. E-commerce enables retailers or vendors to distribute a wider range of products to a

larger number of customers, thus promoting economies of scale. This could
potentially result in increased revenue and reduced unit payments. This will then
profit them. (Jo, 2022)

7. The implementation of e-commerce can facilitate the expansion of new businesses'

customer reach and reduce the need for a physical storefront, thereby aiding in the
reduction of entry barriers. This phenomenon possesses the capacity to stimulate
creativity and rivalry in the retail sector. (Jo, 2022)

8. The implementation of e-commerce systems could potentially promote price

transparency and reduce price discrepancies across different geographic regions. This
 has the potential to improve consumer welfare through the introduction of
comparisons of costs and the identification of discounts. (Jo, 2022)

Disadvantages of e-commerce for retailers and local businesses:

1. The advent of e-commerce has the potential to intensify competition and diminish
profit margins for conventional physical retailers. This can pose a particular difficulty
for small enterprises that have restricted resources and brand awareness. (Jo, 2022)

2. The complexity and expense of logistics and supply chain management may escalate
in tandem with the expansion of e-commerce, posing a significant challenge for
organizations ill-equipped to confront these obstacles. (Jo, 2022)

3. Particularly detrimental are cyber-attacks and fraud that are facilitated by e-

commerce, which can be particularly costly for small businesses that lack the capital
to implement robust cybersecurity measures. (Jo, 2022)

4. The diminishing significance of physical storefronts and local communities due to e-

commerce may result in adverse social and cultural consequences for the surrounding
neighborhoods. (Jo, 2022)

5. By favoring large, established retailers with the financial means to invest in e-

commerce infrastructure and marketing, e-commerce may exacerbate income
inequality. (Jo, 2022)

6. Insufficient personal engagement with clientele, potentially resulting in

discontentment and product returns. (Taher, 2021)

7. Significant infrastructure and technology expenditures, including the development of

websites and secure payment systems. (Taher, 2021)

8. Fraud and cyber-attacks have the potential to cause financial losses and reputational
harm to an organization. (Taher, 2021)

Methodology:

The sample frame comprised online B2C retail companies from twenty European nations,
and the research was carried out utilizing a quantitative, questionnaire-based methodology.
Using the Web Extractor System (2015) software, the researchers extracted URLs of e-stores
from reputable national e-commerce associations, price comparison websites, and trust-mark
websites. The researchers compiled a list of e-stores using publicly available uniform
resource locators (URLs). In two phases, they subsequently distributed to 7865 e-retailers
their structured questionnaire accompanied by a cover letter that elucidated the study's
objectives. A November 2016 initial wave was followed by a subsequent surge in April 2017.
A total of 446 observations remained after excluding responses from e-retailers that did not
offer products or services in foreign markets or failed to meet the criteria for a small to
medium-sized enterprise (less than 250 employees) as defined by the European Union.
Positive responses were obtained from 948 e-retailers, representing a response rate of 12%.
Active participants in B2C cross-border e-commerce, each e-retailer in the sample was
headquartered in one of the twenty European markets. (Goldman, 2021)

The effects of e-commerce on Japanese retailers and small enterprises are examined in this
case study. The authors calculate the component parts of the Japanese consumer price index
(CPI) using a distinct Japanese dataset comprising household expenditure shares according to
retail channel (catalog, e-commerce, and physical store). An increase in the price differential
between products primarily sold in physical stores and those sold extensively online is
observed as a consequence of the entrance of e-commerce firms, the researchers discovered.
In contrast, goods sold primarily offline experienced no change in the rate of price
convergence, whereas the rate of intercity price convergence for goods sold extensively
online increased considerably after e-commerce sales became prevalent in Japan. (Jo, 2022)

Various sectors of Malaysian SMEs (small and medium-sized businesses) have witnessed a
significant increase in e-commerce adoption digitally in most sectors of business and small
and medium-sized enterprises (SMBs); specifically, those operating in the food and beverage
sector reduced their online revenue because they were unable to take advantage of the bigger
profit margins generated through the sale of desserts and refreshments through e-commerce
On the other hand, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) that operated in multiple
industries observed positive consequences stemming from their enhanced online visibility,
culminating in augmented revenue. ( Beyari, 2021)

To endure the difficulties presented by the COVID-19 pandemic, entrepreneurs operating in

various service and retail sectors in Brazil adopted e-commerce as one of several business
strategies. These sectors included education, culinary service, retail, and business-to-business.
Additionally, e-commerce was reportedly expanding, especially in the grocery and food
sectors. The PDF file, however, lacks particulars concerning the survey that was conducted in
Brazil. (Beyari, 2021)

The influence of electronic commerce on the Chinese market was profound. The total of the
online investments or expenses of Chinese consumers in 2016 amounted to seven hundred
fifty dollars billion, exceeding the combined expenditures of the United States and the United
Kingdom, and this shows the advancement of e-commerce in China at a global level. With
that amount of money, China has become the foremost e-commerce market on a global scale
or at an international level. Popular within Chinese e-commerce companies, cross-border e-
commerce (CBEC) is considered a potential market entry strategy for brands pursuing initial
market entry in China. CBEC in China entered a phase of exponential development in 2016,
with a trade volume of RMB6.7 trillion (somewhere around $1 trillion), representing a 31.6%
increase compared to the previous year. It is expected that trade will amount to RMB8.8
trillion, and one-third of a trillion Chinese Renminbi, by 2018. Market leaders operating on
prominent cross-border e-commerce platforms (e.g., wish.com, vip.com, mia.com) have
successfully established robust ecosystems with the aid of a variety of service providers
seeking to broaden their enterprises in collaboration with online platforms. (Qi, 2020)

Impact of e-commerce on retailers:

Prominent impacts have been observed in the retail sector due to the advent of electronic
commerce. The emergence of electronic commerce has prompted a fundamental change in
consumer purchasing patterns, necessitating retailers to adapt their approaches to sustain a
competitive advantage. The Chinese e-commerce market has already showcased its
capabilities and resourcefulness by introducing social commerce, mobile e-commerce, and
online-to-offline (O2O) transactions. (Qi, 2020)

In addition, cross-border electronic commerce (CBEC) has become a notable phenomenon

among Chinese e-commerce organizations and is considered an alternative strategy for
companies seeking to penetrate the Chinese market. CBEC platforms serve as electronic
marketplaces by facilitating connections between global consumers and purveyors,
establishing trade policies and regulations, and fostering confidence among market
participants. (Qi, 2020) Sharma (2020) asserts that the transformations that have taken place
in the economy and society in 2020 have significantly undermined the confidence and trust of
consumers in retailers. Retailers ought to sustain communication with their clientele through
social media and other digital channels to ensure customer retention through the provision of
aid and the exhibition of care for their welfare. These actions have the potential to evoke
feelings of optimism, attachment, and delight in customers. Regarding the transportation of
online purchases, retailers must also strictly adhere to all relevant safety and security
protocols. (Beyari, 2021)

The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly transformed supply and demand, in addition to
the approaches taken in conducting business and providing services. In light of this new
reality, it is now undeniable that e-commerce can function as an indispensable tool for
consumers and buyers. Electronic commerce has the potential to stimulate both domestic and
global trade while bolstering small businesses' competitiveness in the market. Consumers
assert that they will adhere to their recently adopted routines following the crisis. This
phenomenon gives rise to novel opportunities for global commerce through electronic means.
(Beyari, 2021)
E-commerce-related activities have yielded a plethora of favorable outcomes, both immediate
and long-term, as determined by researchers. These positive results include increased
revenue, decreased expenses, improved client relations, and market penetration on a broader
scale. Furthermore, the incorporation of advertising and review forums into online stores has
the potential to benefit retailers. Nevertheless, it is important to acknowledge that the advent
of e-commerce has brought about increased competition among businesses, which may pose
difficulties for small-scale enterprises in terms of determining cycle stock and returned
merchandise. (Ferrera, 2019)

Impact of e-commerce on local business:

Local businesses may face potential negative consequences when mall retailers engage in e-
commerce and face difficulties associated with return management and cycle stock
forecasting. Furthermore, it has been observed that the implementation of electronic
commerce has the potential to expand market penetration across all industries. This could
provide local enterprises with benefits, including access to a more diverse consumer base and
potential profits in other business domains. Yet, it is critical to acknowledge or to
remember that the effects of electronic commerce on local businesses can differ considerably
due to several factors, such as the nature of the business, its financial resources, it is physical
or geographic positioning, and the level of rivalries or compactions in the area in question or
the market culture. (Ferrera, 2019)

It is demonstrated that e-commerce has a positive impact on the marketing performance

attributes of small businesses or small enterprises, although this effect lacks statistical
importance. There will be an evident correlation between the degree of success small
businesses attain when integrating e-commerce into their marketing strategy and their overall
performance in this field. The efficacy of e-commerce in improving marketing is constrained
by the scarcity of educational resources accessible to businesses regarding the optimal
implementation of e-commerce in their activities. The previously mentioned element impedes
the substantial impact that e-commerce could have on enhancing marketing performance. An
additional factor to contemplate is the significant hesitancy exhibited by a considerable
proportion of business organizations to embrace e-commerce because of their aversion to
inconvenience; they would rather offer the conceptual framework for sale. Therefore, it is
advisable that the government or affiliated entrepreneurs offer educational initiatives and
training programs focused on e-commerce and technological utilization. These programs
would empower small enterprises to improve their marketing capabilities, thereby enabling
them to contend more effectively with comparable or emerging competitors. The objective is
to empower smaller enterprises to augment the marketing efficacy of their larger
counterparts. Already scholastic in nature, the text provided by the client does not require
rewriting. (Hardilawati, 2019)

The implementation of electronic commerce has generated a range of responses from regional
enterprises. The advent of electronic commerce has granted locally owned enterprises
unprecedented opportunities, allowing them to broaden their customer base and access a
more extensive spectrum of prospective clients. On the other hand, the emergence of
electronic commerce has presented significant new obstacles for regional businesses, such as
increased rivalry from online merchants and the requirement to adapt to a digital setting. No
text was provided by the user for rewriting. (Qi, 2020)

Business enterprises operating in the local community that have successfully implemented e-
commerce strategies have observed an increase in their customer base and a more substantial
pool of potential buyers. However, regional enterprises that have demonstrated a hesitancy to
adopt contemporary technologies, such as e-commerce, have faced substantial obstacles in
sustaining their competitive edge. Local businesses face novel challenges with the advent of
e-commerce, including the efficient conveyance and management of products, the protection
of online transaction security, and the provision of exceptional customer service in a digital
environment. No text was provided by the user for rewriting. (Qi, 2020)

Although the impact of e-commerce on local businesses has been diverse, some have
benefited. Local businesses that have adeptly adjusted to the perpetually evolving e-
commerce environment are thriving in the contemporary era.

Future Predictions & Recommendations:

In order to attain a fresh competitive advantage, organizations of all scales must diligently
consider the development of viable business models that integrate interactive user
engagement, multichannel digital distribution of products and services, and an emphasis on
enhancing the customer experience. Furthermore, regulatory bodies, customers, and
organizations must exercise caution in order to mitigate the negative consequences associated
with e-commerce. These consequences encompass credit card fraud, identity theft, data
breaches, impulsive purchasing, and societal transformations due to the obsolescence of
products and changes in lifestyle. Regardless of the absence of specific predictions regarding
the future of e-commerce and retail from the source, it is indisputable that businesses must
persistently adjust to the dynamic landscape of e-commerce and retail to sustain their
competitive advantage. This may involve the integration of novel technological
advancements, an increase in market penetration, and an increased concentration on data
security and customer privacy. (Ferrera, 2019)

In their study, Bakalis et al. (2020) examined the scope of diverse e-commerce scenarios in
2020 and identified online ordering and delivery as the areas undergoing the most substantial
transformations. It is conceivable that these alterations could persist for an extended period of
time beyond the current epidemic. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has unequivocally
demonstrated that consumers ought to regard e-commerce as an indispensable resource.
Consumers assert that they intend to sustain their newly established routines even in the
aftermath of the crisis. As a direct result of this, new and fresh prospects have emerged for
commerce via the Internet in the realm of global commerce. E-commerce can serve as a
catalyst or as an amplifier for economic expansion on both the domestic and international
levels or for retailers and small local businesses, boosting economies' competitiveness and
bolstering the operations of small- and medium-sized enterprises.
Nevertheless, the degree to which businesses will revert to their pre-pandemic levels and the
behavior of consumers once the nervousness surrounding the pandemic dissipates are both
undetermined. Overall, it is evident that electronic commerce will persist in exerting a
substantial influence on the retail sector. Organizations that can effectively adapt to this
evolving landscape will have a competitive edge in the coming years and will have more and
more advancement in their respective fields. (Beyari, 2021)

There is an expectation that the forthcoming landscape of e-commerce and retail will be
marked by an integrated blend of brick-and-mortar or traditional and digital platforms. By
utilizing technology, retailers will offer consumers a customized and immersive purchasing
experience. Future projections indicate that this will be the case. In the digital age, retailers
that are adaptable to this new reality and willing to adopt technology will have a significant
competitive advantage. (Qi, 2020)

Conclusion:

A paradigm shift in the way consumers conduct transactions and organizations operate has
occurred as a result of the indisputable impact of electronic commerce on the retail sector and
local businesses. The complexities and challenges that traditional retailers and local
enterprises face in an increasingly digital landscape have been highlighted by this study.
Nonetheless, the potential for expansion and adaptation has been underscored as well.
Electronic commerce has precipitated a paradigm shift in consumer behavior. Consumers
have rapidly developed a favorable perception of online purchasing due to its practicality,
accessibility, and customized experiences. Responding to the dynamic demands of the digital
consumer has consequently compelled retailers to modify their strategies. In addition, the
dynamics of competition have been transformed by electronic commerce. Online marketplace
entrants present conventional retailers with innovative pricing strategies, dynamic
promotional activities, and personalized marketing techniques. The importance of effective
inventory management and dependable delivery services has elevated supply chain
management to a critical success factor. Local organizations, recognized for their positive
impact on the community, face a unique set of challenges when competing with e-commerce
powerhouses. Individuals often find themselves faced with the predicament of how to
simultaneously embrace the digital revolution and preserve their distinct identity. Critical is
the impact that government assistance and regulations have on the e-commerce ecosystem.
Ensuring market fairness, innovation, competition, and consumer protection coexist in a
precarious equilibrium. Adaptability and innovation are critical qualities in the current
dynamic environment. Successfully integrating electronic commerce (e-commerce) into their
operational strategies, actively engaging consumers through technological advancements, and
actively participating in local communities are all elements that contribute to the likelihood of
positive outcomes for organizations. Retail and local businesses will face an uncertain future
characterized by constant change; those who can recognize and adeptly maneuver through
these changes will be at the vanguard of a paradigm shift in the industry.

References:

 Ferrera, C., & Kessedjian, E. (2019). Evolution of E-commerce and Global

Marketing. International Journal of Technology for Business (IJTB), 1(1), 33-38.
 Mohamad, A. H., Hassan, G. F., & Abd Elrahman, A. S. (2022). Impacts of e-
commerce on planning and designing commercial activities centers: A developed
approach. Ain Shams Engineering Journal, 13(4), 101634.
 Goyal, S., Sergi, B. S., & Esposito, M. (2019). Literature review of emerging trends
and future e-commerce directions in the global business landscape. World Review of
Entrepreneurship, Management and Sustainable Development, 15(1-2), 226-255.
 Beyari, H. (2021). RECENT E-COMMERCE TRENDS AND LEARNINGS FOR E-
COMMERCE SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT FROM A QUALITY
PERSPECTIVE. International Journal for Quality Research, 15(3).
 Jo, Y., Matsumura, M., & Weinstein, D. E. (2022). The Impact of Retail E-commerce
on Relative Prices and Consumer Welfare. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1-45.
 Qi, X., Chan, J. H., Hu, J., & Li, Y. (2020). Motivations for selecting cross-border e-
commerce as a foreign market entry mode. Industrial Marketing Management, 89, 50-
60.
 Taher, G. (2021). E-commerce: advantages and limitations. International Journal of
Academic Research in Accounting Finance and Management Sciences, 11(1), 153-
165.
 Goldman, S. P., van Herk, H., Verhagen, T., & Weltevreden, J. W. (2021). Strategic
orientations and digital marketing tactics in cross-border e-commerce: Comparing
developed and emerging markets. International small business journal, 39(4), 350-
371.
 Hardilawati, W. L., Sandri, S. H., & Binangkit, I. D. (2019, December). The Role of
Innovation and E-Commerce in Small Business. In International Conference of
CELSciTech 2019-Social Sciences and Humanities track (ICCELST-SS 2019) (pp. 18-
22). Atlantis Press.
 Chava, S., Oettl, A., Singh, M., & Zeng, L. (2023). Creative destruction? Impact of e-
commerce on the retail sector. Management Science.