2020 The Routledge Handbook of The Bioar
2020 The Routledge Handbook of The Bioar
T H E R O U T L E D G E HA N D B O O K
O F T H E B I OA R C HA E O L O G Y
O F C L I M AT E A N D
E N V I R O N M E N TA L C HA N G E
This handbook examines human responses to climatic and environmental changes in the past,
and their impacts on disease patterns, nutritional status, migration, and interpersonal violence.
Bioarchaeology—the study of archaeological human skeletons—provides direct evidence of the
human experience of past climate and environmental changes and serves as an important com-
plement to paleoclimate, historical, and archaeological approaches to changes we may expect
with global warming.
Comprising 27 chapters from experts across a broad range of time periods and geograph-
ical regions, this book addresses hypotheses about how climate and environmental changes
impact human health and well-being, factors that promote resilience, and circumstances that
make migration or interpersonal violence a more likely outcome. The volume highlights the
potential relevance of bioarchaeological analysis to contemporary challenges by organizing the
chapters into a framework outlined by the United Nation’s Sustainable Development Goals for
2030. Planning for a warmer world requires knowledge about humans as biological organisms
with a deep connection to Earth’s ecosystems balanced by an appreciation of how historical
and socio-cultural circumstances, socioeconomic inequality, degrees of urbanization, commu-
nity mobility, and social institutions play a role in shaping long-term outcomes for human
communities.
Containing a wealth of nuanced perspectives about human-environmental relations, the book
is key reading for students of environmental archaeology, bioarchaeology, and the history of
disease. By providing a longer view of contemporary challenges, it may also interest readers in
public health, public policy, and planning.
THE ROUTLEDGE
HA N D B O O K O F T H E
B I OA R C HA E O L O G Y
O F C L I M AT E A N D
E N V I R O N M E N TA L
C HA N G E
Edited by
Gwen Robbins Schug
To my family and friends.You make life brighter.Thank you for your inspiration, patience, and love.
CONTENTS
List of figures xi
List of tables xv
Notes on contributors xviii
Acknowledgements xxvii
PART I
Good health and well-being 17
vii
Contents
PART II
Socioeconomic and gender equality, no poverty or hunger 157
PART III
Peace, justice, and strong institutions 277
viii
Contents
PART IV
Life on land 377
25 Stable carbon and oxygen isotope evidence for late third millennium
BCE environmental and social change at Titriş Höyük, an Early Bronze
Age urban center in the Lower Turkish Euphrates watershed 453
Adam W. Schneider, Andrew D. Somerville, Ö. Dilek Erdal,Yilmaz S. Erdal,
and Guillermo Algaze
ix
Contents
Index 511
FIGURES
xi
List of figures
6.3 A bar chart showing the distribution of age categories in the Keldudalur
and Keflavík populations 110
7.1 Example of bony changes (spicules) within the maxillary sinus related
to sinusitis, viewed through the damaged medial wall 126
7.2 Top: Map of the Middle Nile Valley depicting the location of sites
analyzed (circular marker) and other sites mentioned in the text
(square marker). Bottom: Inset of the Fourth Cataract region with
the location of analyzed sites 131
7.3 Prevalence of maxillary sinusitis at Sudanese sites according to their
likely subsistence practice, geographic location, and time period 133
8.1 Map of Switzerland showing the location of Aventicum 145
8.2 Aventicum and the surrounding environment 146
8.3 Age-at-death distribution of non-adults (<17.0 years) at the Roman
cemeteries of Aventicum 148
9.1 Depiction of the three primary pathways through which climate
change will impact health: direct environmental impacts, ecosystem
mediated, and human institution mediated 160
9.2 The global multi-dimensional poverty index 161
9.3 The effect of multi-dimensional poverty on children worldwide 162
11.1 Himera and the Mediterranean 207
11.2 Positive correlation between stress index and number of grave goods
(corredo), by burial type 213
12.1 Comparison of colonization and migration models of population
movement 223
12.2 Map of Cyprus with sites used in the present analysis 228
13.1 Map showing the Belqa’ Ottoman administrative region and sites
mentioned in the text 238
13.2 Frequency of pathology observations at Hisban, Khirbat al-Mudayna,
and regional pre-19th-century sites combined 249
14.1 Map of the Veneto region (right) and images of San Servolo (top left)
and Sant’Anna Ospedale (bottom left) 262
14.2 Ventral view of Ferrara 494 (left) demonstrating dental pathology
at the lower end of the scale for this collection and 485 (right)
demonstrating more severe dental conditions 268
14.3 View of the cranial base from the inside of the cranium for individual
479, demonstrating lytic changes to the hypophyseal fossa of the
sphenoid 269
14.4 Individual 477 had an interesting case of pneumosinus dilatans 270
14.5 Individual 413 died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head 270
15.1 Examples of perimortem injuries in Neolithic skeletal remains from
Germany 284
15.2 Images of the Bronze Age Palace complex at Knossos (Crete) 286
15.3 Witchcraft: witches and devils dancing in a circle. Woodcut, 1720 291
xii
List of figures
xiii
List of figures
24.2 Strontium isotope ratios and oxygen isotope values from human
dental enamel from tombs Unar 1, Shimal 95, and Shimal 103 446
25.1 The site of Titriş Höyük. Rectangle is the rough area extent of the
Karababa Basin 457
25.2 All δ13Capa and δ18Oapa values obtained from the analysis of the Titriş
Höyük skeletal samples 464
26.1 Comparative average human δ13C values for each site location and
associated terrestrial biome (left) and annual average precipitation
and average human δ15N values for each site location (right) 476
26.2 Comparison of stable carbon (δ13C) and nitrogen (δ15N) isotopic
results for human and faunal remains from each location 486
27.1 Map of the Pacific showing Near and Remote Oceania 495
27.2 Distribution of carbon and nitrogen isotopes over time at Hanamiai
(Marquesas Islands), Aitutaki (Cook Islands), and Uripiv ( Vanuatu) 499
27.3 Model of species vulnerability relative to environmental change 506
xiv
TABLES
xv
List of tables
17.1 Total number of blunt force cranial trauma over time 322
17.2 Total number of sharp force trauma over time 323
17.3 Total number of individuals with porotic hyperostosis over time 324
17.4 Total number of individuals with cribra orbitalia over time 325
17.5 Total number of individuals with periostitis over time 326
18.1 Presence of traumatic injury by cemetery for the San Pedro de
Atacama Oases sample 336
18.2 Presence of traumatic injury in San Pedro de Atacama Oases
cemeteries compared to upper Loa River cemeteries 339
19.1 Chronology of the lake basin and associated cultural phases 347
19.2 Age distribution of sample 352
19.3 Sex distribution of sample 353
19.4 Trauma by time period 354
20.1 Koyama’s (1984) population estimation 366
20.2 Estimates of mortality attributable to violence over the
Jōmon period 368
20.3 Estimates of mortality attributable to violence over the
Yayoi period 369
20.4 Numbers of sites on the Atsumi Peninsula used in the
Jōmon period 371
21.1 Neolithicities in Jōmon Japan 384
22.1 Demographic profile of the Nepal study samples 402
22.2 Frequency of fractures among the samples 405
22.3 Cases of fractures in the major long bones of the limbs 406
22.4 Description of traumatic injuries in the study samples 407
22.5 Comparison of cranial fractures in Nepal sites with Andean
highland sites of approximately similar elevation 408
24.1 Radiogenic strontium isotope ratios and stable oxygen and carbon
isotope values for Bronze Age human enamel samples from the
Shimal Necropolis 443
24.2 Descriptive statistics for strontium and carbon isotope
values for Bronze Age faunal enamel samples from the
United Arab Emirates 444
25.1 δ13Capa and δ18Oapa results for all Titriş Höyük human
bioapatite samples 462
25.2 Summary statistics for δ13Capa and δ18Oapa isotopic results by period 464
26.1 Locations and time frame discussed throughout text 475
26.2 Sample composition of adult human and faunal remains from
each location 480
26.3 Summary results of stable carbon (δ13C) isotopic analysis from
each site location 482
26.4 Summary results of stable nitrogen (δ15N) isotopic analysis from
each site location 483
xvi
List of tables
26.5 (MANOVA) post hoc Tukey HSD tests for significance in mean
differences for adult human δ13C results 484
26.6 (MANOVA) post hoc Tukey HSD tests for significance in mean
differences for adult human δ15N results 485
27.1 Stable isotope analyses (including sample sizes) undertaken in Remote
Oceania and neighboring regions using humans and other species 497
27.2 Changes in hypoplasia defect frequency over time in pigs from the
Marquesas Islands 504
xvii
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
Mark Aldenderfer is the Edward A. Dickson Emeriti Endowed Chair and Distinguished
Professor Emeritus of Anthropology at the University of California, Merced, USA. His research
focuses on the comparative analysis of high-altitude cultural and biological adaptations from an
archaeological perspective. He has worked on the three high-elevation plateaus of the planet—
Ethiopian, Andean, and Tibetan—and currently works in the High Himalayas of Nepal. He has
edited or written numerous books, articles, and book chapters. His research has been featured
widely in the media, including the 2017 documentary film Secrets of the Sky Tombs, which was
produced by PBS/NOVA.
Daniel Antoine is the British Museum’s Curator of Bioarchaeology, with responsibility for
the Museum’s collection of human remains. Before joining the Museum in 2009, Daniel was
at the Institute of Archaeology, University College London, where he gained his PhD in 2001.
He has published widely on dental anthropology, bioarchaeology, and paleopathology, including
Regarding the Dead: Human Remains in the British Museum (2014) with Alexandra Fletcher and JD
Hill. He is the President of the Dental Anthropology Association (2019–2021) and an Honorary
Senior Research Fellow at the Institute of Archaeology, University College London.
xviii
Notes on contributors
Bernardo T. Arriaza is Full Professor at the Instituto de Alta Investigación of the Universidad
de Tarapacá, Arica, Chile. His research focuses on the study of health conditions and cultural
change in pre-Columbian populations through the analysis of cemeteries, mummies, and
skeletons. He has worked extensively on Chinchorro mummies’ bioarchaeology. Bernardo’s
current research focuses on the study of natural pollutants in prehistory, Bioarchaeology of the
Invisible: Unraveling the History of Endemic Natural Pollutants that may have Affected Ancient Chilean
Populations, Fondecyt 1170120 (2017–2020). He has published numerous scientific papers, in
addition to books and book chapters on Andean paleopathology and bioarchaeology. He has
actively engaged in the dissemination of scientific knowledge, participating in television docu-
mentaries for the Discovery Channel and National Geographic, among others.
Kristen A. Broehl is a doctoral student at the University of Nevada, Reno, USA, and she
holds a master’s degree in anthropology from California State University, Chico, USA. She has
archaeological experience in California, Indiana, Tennessee, Georgia, Mississippi, and Poland.
Her research focuses on the bioarchaeology of California, particularly regarding the biological
structure, relationships, and social roles of prehistoric societies. She also researches commingling
and alternative methods for estimating the biological profile in forensic anthropology.
Nicola Carrara is Curator of the Museum of Anthropology of the University of Padua, Italy, a
position he has held since 2000. He is trained as a biologist and works in physical anthropology
for the Museum, in many archaeological excavations, and in the forensic field. As the Museum
curator, he reorganizes, studies, catalogues, and valorizes the anthropological collections.
xix
Notes on contributors
frailty and resilience in the Mississippi State Asylum. Her interests include paleopathology,
paleoepidemiology, non-infectious and chronic diseases, the Developmental Origins of Health
and Disease, ecosocial theory, and the biocultural approach. She earned her BA in Anthropology
from the University of Wyoming, USA.
Emily Edwards received her MA in Anthropology from East Carolina University, USA, and
her BA in Anthropology at the University of Texas, Austin, USA.
xx
Notes on contributors
Siân E. Halcrow is Associate Professor at the University of Otago, New Zealand, with a
research focus on infant and child stress and disease in the past and social aspects of childhood.
She manages the skeletal analyses on several international archaeological projects in Thailand,
Laos, Cambodia, China, and Chile. Siân’s research is funded through sources including the
NZ Royal Society Marsden Fund, Fulbright NZ, and National Geographic. She has published
extensively on infant and child bioarchaeology and teaches undergraduate and postgraduate
science and biological anthropology courses.
Michelle Hrivnyak is Faculty Specialist at the Institute for Intercultural and Anthropological
Studies, Western Michigan University, USA. Her research focuses broadly on human-
environment interactions, and more specifically on reconstructing diet, health, and mobility
patterns through isotopic and bioarchaeological analyses. She has worked on a variety of field-
work and analytical projects in south-west Siberia, the central Eurasian steppe region, and
North America.
Mark James Hudson is a researcher in the Eurasia3angle Research Group, Max Planck
Institute for the Science of Human History, Jena, Germany. He previously taught archaeology
and anthropology in Japan for more than 20 years. His current research focuses on long-term
social change in Northeast Asia from the Late Neolithic to the Bronze Age. His publications
include Ruins of Identity: Ethnogenesis in the Japanese Islands (1999) and, as co-editor,Volume 1 of
the Cambridge World History of Violence (2020).
xxi
Notes on contributors
Britney Kyle is Associate Professor and Chair of the Department of Anthropology at the
University of Northern Colorado, USA. She is a bioarchaeologist whose research uses human
skeletal remains from archaeological contexts to identify how past peoples respond biologic-
ally and culturally to major social transitions. She directs the Bioarchaeology of Mediterranean
Colonies Project (BMCP) with Laurie Reitsema. The BMCP explores interactions between
Mediterranean peoples and Greek colonizers in the eighth through fourth centuries BCE and
has implications for understanding culture contact in a variety of contexts.
Takehiko Matsugi is Professor at the National Museum of Japanese History, Japan. He received
his PhD (2005) from Osaka University, Japan. He specializes in weapons, Kofun, and warfare of
the Yayoi and Kofun period in Japan.
Naoko Matsumoto is Professor in the Graduate school of Humanities and Social Sciences at
Okayama University, Japan. She received her PhD (1998) from Kyushu University, Japan. She is
one of the pioneers of cognitive and gender archaeology in Japan. Her recent articles include
Changing relationship between the dead and the living in Japanese prehistory (2018) and Subsistence,
sedentism, and social complexity among Jomon hunter-gatherers of the Japanese archipelago (with Junko
Habu and Akira Matsui, 2017).
xxii
Notes on contributors
xxiii
Notes on contributors
Megan A. Perry is Professor of Anthropology at East Carolina University, USA. Her primary
research interests involve investigating human skeletal remains to assess ancient disease, diet, and
mobility patterns, in addition to mortuary practices of ancient populations in first- to sixth-
century AD Jordan. Professor Perry has been working on archaeological projects in Jordan for
over 25 years, and she is on the Board of the American Center of Oriental Research (ACOR)
in Amman, Jordan.
Rebecca Redfern is Curator of Human Osteology at the Museum of London, UK, and
a Research Fellow at Newcastle University, UK. Her current research focuses on violence
and ancestry, using a web of violence approach to explore these bioarchaeological data. She
is currently researching migration, enslavement, and injury patterns in Iron Age, Roman, and
Medieval populations. These themes were brought together in her book, Injury and Trauma in
Bioarchaeology: Interpreting Violence in Past Lives (2017). She has also published widely in peer-
reviewed journals on ethics, museum curation, diet, and origins using stable isotopes and ancient
DNA data, evidence for disease, and culture change
xxiv
Notes on contributors
Kohei Tamura is Assistant Professor at the Frontier Research Institute for Interdisciplinary
Sciences,Tohoku University, Japan. He received his BA (2008) from Nagoya University and MA
xxv
Notes on contributors
(2010) and PhD (2013) from the University of Tokyo. His research topics include mathematical
models and quantitative analysis of cultural dynamics, with a particular focus on cultural evolu-
tion. He has recently published Quantifying cultural macro-evolution: A case study of the Hinoeuma
fertility drop (with Yasuo Ihara, 2017) and Modelling the emergence of an egalitarian society in the n-
player game framework (with Hiroki Takikawa, 2019).
Dr. Hui Wang is a researcher at Fudan University, China, with affiliations in the Department
of Cultural Heritage and Museology, the Institute of Archaeological Science, and the Research
Center for “One Belt One Road” Archaeology and Ancient Civilizations. He received his PhD
from the Department of Cultural Studies, Kobe University, Japan, and previously served as the
Director of the Gansu Provincial Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology. He has long been
engaged in archaeological research on the Neolithic and Bronze Age periods, early Qin and
Xirong cultures, and the early Silk Road in Northwest China.
Guðný Zoëga is Assistant Lecturer at the Department of Rural Tourism, Hólar University, Iceland.
She holds a PhD in archaeology from Oslo University, Norway. She has worked extensively in Iceland
on a variety of archaeological sites, in both an archaeological and osteological capacity. Recently her
focus has been on settlement history, mortuary archaeology, early Christian households, and house-
hold cemeteries. She is a co-PI on the NSF-funded project Skagafjörður Church and Settlement
Survey (SCASS), a multi-year regional project examining the relationship between settlement his-
tory and the development of early Christianity in North Iceland AD 870–1300.
xxvi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I would like to thank all of the authors for their time, energy, and patience.This volume obviously
would not be possible without their efforts and I appreciate their dedication. Many of the
authors are also friends, who have provided support and encouragement over the years. I also
want to thank all of my other colleagues who have supported my scholarship, spent time
exchanging ideas, or even just provided general encouragement, including Jane Buikstra, who
might not realize that the idea for this volume came from her work and conversations with her
over the years. I particularly want to thank my colleagues and collaborators in India, Oman, and
Italy for allowing me to access collections but, more importantly, for helping me to learn about
the past and provide some interpretations, even if they might be incomplete or incorrect. Finally,
I want to thank all of the agencies who have funded my research: Wenner Gren, Fulbright,
American Institute of Indian Studies, and the George Franklin Dales Foundation. I appreciate
and am deeply grateful for all of you.
xxvii