Estimation of Nusselt Number in Microchannels of A
Estimation of Nusselt Number in Microchannels of A
net/publication/232862173
CITATIONS READS
22 2,454
3 authors:
Ned Djilali
University of Victoria
317 PUBLICATIONS 13,948 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Majid Bahrami on 04 December 2014.
ICNMM2008-62198
Ned Djilali
Department of Mechanical Engineering
University of Victoria
ndjilai@uvic.ca
ABSTRACT
In many practical instances such as basic design, , ,, = Coefficients used in Eq. (10)
parametric study, and optimization analysis of thermal systems, = Hydraulic diameter, m
it is often very convenient to have closed form relations to · = Complete elliptic integral of the second kind
obtain the trends and a reasonable estimate of the Nusselt = Thermal convection coefficient, W/m2K
number. However, finding exact solutions for many practical = Polar moment of inertia, m4
singly-connected cross-sections, such as trapezoidal = Dimensionless polar moment of inertia
microchannels, is complex. = Side of a rhombic cross-section, m
In the present study, the square root of cross-sectional area is = Characteristic length scale, m
proposed as the characteristic length scale for Nusselt number. = Nusselt number
Using analytical solutions of rectangular, elliptical, and = Number of sides of a polygon
triangular ducts, a compact model for estimation of Nusselt
= Perimeter, m
number of fully-developed, laminar flow in microchannels of
" = Heat flux, W/m2
arbitrary cross-sections with “H1” boundary condition (constant
= Temperature, K
axial wall heat flux with constant peripheral wall temperature)
= Mean temperature, K
is developed. The proposed model is only a function of
= Wall temperature, K
geometrical parameters of the cross-section, i.e., area,
= Mean wall temperature, K
perimeter, and polar moment of inertia. The present model is
verified against analytical and numerical solutions for a wide = Velocity in z- direction, m/s
variety of cross-sections with a maximum difference on the = Mean axial velocity of the fluid , m/s
order of 9%.
Greek symbols
= Thermal diffusion coefficient, m2/s
NOMENCLATURE = Aspect ratio
= Dimensionless temperature
= Mean dimensionless temperature
= Cross-sectional area, m2
= Area of limiting rectangle of a cross-section, m2 Δ = Deviation from limiting rectangle
= Area of limiting triangle of a cross-section Δ = Deviation from limiting triangle
Dh
3 CHARACTERISTIC LENGTH SCALE
Nu
6
(5) 14
1.0578 0.1861 I 12
Nu√A
10
where, the Nusselt number is based on the hydraulic diameter
of the cross-section. It can be converted to the Nusselt number 8
based on the square root of area through:
6
P 4
√ (6)
4√ 2
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
ε= b/a
Tyagi [18] found an analytical solution for “H1” Nusselt
(b)
number of elliptical ducts.
FIGURE 2. COMPARSION BETWEEN ANALYTICAL
9π 1 ε 1 ε 6ε SOLUTIONS OF NU FOR ELLIPTICAL AND RECTANGULAR
√ (7)
1 ε √ 17 1 ε 98ε DUCTS USING: (a) HYDRAULIC DIAMETER AND (b)
SQUARE ROOT OF AREA AS CHARACHTERSITIC LENGTH.
where, · is the complete elliptic integral of the second kind.
As can be seen in Fig. 2, the square root of area √ , as the
characteristic length scale, leads to more consistent trends in 4 PROPOSED MODEL
the solutions of elliptical and rectangular ducts. These shapes Bahrami et al. [2, 19] developed a compact model for Poiseuille
cover a wide variety of cross-sections; thus, it can be concluded number, √ , which is only a function of geometrical
parameters of the cross-section, i.e., perimeter, area, and polar
that the square root of area √ is a more appropriate length
scale for Nusselt number as Muzychka et al. [10] proposed. moment of inertia. They started from the analytical solution of
elliptical channel and established their model. It was shown that
Bahrami et al. [2, 19] showed that the difference between the
their model is applicable to a wide range of cross-sections.
Poiseuille number, √ , of elliptical and rectangular ducts is Considering the analogy between the Poiseuille number and the
less than 8% over a wide range of aspect ratio. Considering the Nusselt number [20], the approach proposed by Bahrami et al.
analogy existing between the Poiseuille number and the Nusselt [2, 19] is followed to develop a general model for “H1” Nusselt
middle
18 Ellipse
Rectangle
2
Rhombus
16
Trapezoid
Circular Segment To apply the model, first we should find out which submodel is
14 Circular Sector
Right Triangle appropriate to use. Relative deviation of the channel cross-
Isosceles Triangle
I 12 sectional area from rectangular and triangular shapes is
Nu√A
Sinusoid
Rectangle with Semicircular Ends proposed as a measure to select the proper submodel. The
10
reference rectangular and triangular cross-section is defined
8 based on the limiting cases of geometry. These limiting cases
generally occur in bounds of aspect ratios or shape angles. For
6 instance, as shown in Table 2, the trapezoid yields rectangle
4
when the aspect ratio goes to zero and/or goes to 90 and
approaches the triangle when the aspect ratio becomes higher
2
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 and the upper base goes to zero. Figure 4 illustrates the
ε procedure to apply the model.
18 data [3]
model
16 model - 10 %
model +10 %
14
lower
I 12
Nu√A
10
6
Start
4
2
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
ε= b/a
∆ 1 (a)
∆ 1 20
18 data [3]
model
model - 10%
16
model + 10%
∆ 0.2 ∆ 0.2
∆ ∆ ∆ 14
I 12
Nu√A
10
0.2 ∆ 0.2
8
6
upper model middle model lower model
4
2
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
ε= b/a
(b)
√
√
P FIGURE 5. COMPARSION OF PRESENT MODEL AND
NUMERICAL VALUES [9] FOR: (a) ELLIPTICAL CHANNEL,
FIGURE 4. FLOWCHART FOR APPLYING THE PROPOSED (b) RECTANGULAR CHANNEL.
MODEL.
√ 1
4 1 4
√ 1
2 1 12
√2 1
1 9 12
2 1
√2 1 7
2 1 √1 9 9
1 2 3 3
1 1
φ 2 √ 36
1
φ 4 6
1 1 3
tan /
1 2 n tan / 6 tan /
4 1
2 2 2 4 1
√2 1 12 9
2 5
2 12 32
2
(1)
1 (2)
2 1
6
60 0.577 3.618 3.398 -6.48
70 0.700 3.610 3.314 -8.93
80 0.839 3.609 3.511 -2.78
4 90 1 3.608 3.489 -3.41
16
18
data, φ = 85 data
data, φ = 60 model
14 data, φ = 45 16 model - 10%
data, φ = 30 model + 10%
model
12 model ± 10% 14
12
Nu√A (model)
I
Nu√A
10
φ 10
8
I
8
6
6
4
4
2
2
0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 ε= b/a
Nu√A (data)
I