Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)

Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022

Venue: Through Video Conferencing

In view of pandemic situation of COVID-19 , Maharashtra SEIAA directed SEAC-1 to

appraise the proposals by using information technology facilities. Hence, SEAC-1
initiated to appraise the proposals received by the SEIAA through Video-conferencing
technology on Cisco Webex platform.

Following members of SEAC-I were present for videoconference meeting.

Dr. Rakesh Kumar Chairman

Shri. Jeevan Patgaonkar Vice Chairman
Shri. Kundan Deshmukh Expert Member
Ms. Kavita Takale Expert Member
Dr. Chandrashekhar Marathe Expert Member
Shri. Abhay Pimparkar Secretary

Meeting of 229th meeting were confirmed. Due to pandemic the Minutes of meeting are
approved through emails hence signature is not required.

1
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No. 1: SIA/MH/IND/81886 Type: EC

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 81886 for prior
Environmental Clearance for manufacturing of aroma chemicals under category 5(f)
Synthesis of Organic Chemicals as per provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006 amended
from time to time and appraised in the SEAC-1 committee.
PROJECT DETAILS:
Environmental Clearance for Proposed Establishment of Synthetic organic
Chemicals (Aroma chemicals) manufacturing facility at Plot No- B-7/2,
MIDC Mahad Tal. Mahad, Dist. Raigad, Maharashtra by Prigiv Specialties
Private Limited

Details of earlier EC if any: No

DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
After deliberations SEAC observed:-
The project proponent along with their accredited consultant M/s Aditya Environmental
Services Pvt. Ltd were present for the meeting.

The proposal was considered under category 5(f) B1 as per Notification EIA Notification,
2006 as amended form time to time.
The proposal was appraised based on the documents submitted and presented by the PP and their
accredited Environmental Consultant.
PP was granted online ToR vide No. SIA/MH/IND3/81886/2022 dated 06.08.2022 for
the preparation of EIA/EMP report.
Now, PP submitted EIA/EMP report for appraisal.
During deliberations following deficiencies were observed,

1. PP is having adequate space to provide mandatory 33% green belt within the plot
area, but PP proposes to provide only 24% within the plot and deficit out side the
plot area. PP asked to rearrange the layout and submit revised layout providing
green belt within the plot area preferably on the periphery.
2. PP to carryout soil sampling analysis based on the identification of control site
outside the premises and collect soil samples in and around the proposed site. PP
to choose parameters to be analysed based on the use of raw materials and finished
products by the earlier owner of the site and all other chemical parameters
including heavy metals. PP to compare these results with the control site result

2
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
and prepare and implement appropriate mitigation plan to address soil
contamination issue.
3. PP to prepare wild life conservation plan and get it approved from the Competent
Authority of the Forest Department as there are two scheduled species were
observed during EIA study.
4. PP to carry out risk assessment study of steam line proposed to be taken from the
adjacent sister unit of the PP; PP to include safety risks as well as operational ,
legal liability and other related risk in the assessment study.
5. PP to submit structural stability certificate of buildings exists on site w.r.t its load
bearing capacity of additional equipment, manpower etc. and it can safely
accommodate proposed manufacturing activity in in the existing building.
6. PP to submit copy of MoU executed with the sister unit of PP to obtain steam from
them. PP to submit copies of NOC/permissions obtained for the same from
Competent Authority.
7. PP to submit details of gas leak detection system proposed in the storage and
operation areas so as to avoid any unforeseen incident as most of the impact of
incident seen affecting the areas outside the factory limit.
8. PP to submit plan for VOCs control and monitoring on site w.r.t emissions during
loading/unloading, process activities etc.

RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:
After detailed deliberations with the PP and their accredited consultant, SEAC-1 decided to defer
the proposal till submission of compliance of above points.

CONCLUSION:
Deferred

3
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No.: 2 SIA/MH/IND/77209 Type: EC

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 77209 for prior Environmental
Clearance for expansion project for Sugar (4000 TCD to 7500 TCD of sugar), Proposed Distillery
(45 KLPD) and Expansion of Cogen plant (15 MW to 28 MW) under category 1(d) Thermal
Power Plant, 5(j) Sugar Industry and 5 (g) Distillery B1 as per provisions of the EIA Notification,
2006 amended from time to time and appraised in the SEAC-1 committee.

PROJECT DETAILS:
Environmental Clearance For Proposed Modernization cum expansion project for Sugar
(4000 TCD to 7500 TCD of sugar), Proposed Distillery (45 KLPD) and Expansion of Cogen
plant (15 MW to 28 MW) At Mohannagar, At/ Post- Arag, Tal- Miraj, Dist- Sangli,
Maharashtra by M/S. Mohanrao Shinde Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd.
Details of earlier EC if any: No.
DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
After deliberations SEAC observed:-
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Accredited Environmental
consultant M/s. Sneha Hi- Tech Products Ltd.
The proposal was appraised based on the documents submitted and presented by the PP and their
accredited Environmental Consultant.

The proposal is for Environmental Clearance For Proposed Modernization cum expansion
project for Sugar (4000 TCD to 7500 TCD of sugar), Proposed Distillery (45 KLPD) and
Expansion of Cogen plant (15 MW to 28 MW) At Mohannagar, At/ Post- Arag, Tal- Miraj, Dist-
Sangli, Maharashtra by M/S. Mohanrao Shinde Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd.

During deliberations , PP submitted that, they applied for the grant of Term of References (ToR)
to MoEF&CC on 19.10.2018 as per requirement of EIA Notification, 2006 dated 14.09.2006,
wherein it was mentioned that, all distillery projects having capacity more than 30 KLPD shall
be considered as Category “A” and be dealt at MoEF&&CC level. Accordingly, PP obtained ToR
vide letter No. IA-J-11011/341/2018-IA-II(I) dated 29.11.2018.

In the mean time, MoEF&CC issued amended Notifiation dated 13.06.2019 mentioning the
molasses based distillery having capacity less than 100 KLPD shallbe dealt by respective State
SEIAA.

4
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
MoEF&CC issued an O.M. dated 18.01.2022 which reads as below,
“..Notwithstanding anything contained above, the period from 1st April, 2020 to the 31st March
2021 shall not be considered for the purpose of calculation of the period of the validity of Term
of Reference granted under te provisions of this Notification in view of outbreak of Coron Virus
(COVID 19) and subsequent lockdowns (total or partial) declared for its control, however, all
activities undertaken during this period in respect of the said ToR shall be treated as valid.”

Hence, the validity of ToR issued to the PP was up to 28.11.2022. Accordingly, as per ToR
obtained, PP prepared draft EIA/EMP report and Maharashtra Pollution Control Board conducted
the Public Hearing on 31.12.2021.

After completion of Public Hearing, while uploading final EIA/EMP report on State portal of
PARIVESH, PP observed that, there is no provision to upload EIA/EMP report on the State Portal
for which ToR was granted by the MoEF&CC. Hence, PP applied on State SEIAA Portal for
ToR and obtained online standard ToR on 25.05.2022 and uploaded final EIA/EMP report for
the grant of prior Environmental Clearance.

With above facts and records, PP requested SEAC-1 to consider the proposal as per ToR obtained
on 29.11.2018 and subsequent submission of EIA/EMP report.

After deliberations with the PP and their accredited consultant and looking at the facts submitted
by the PP, SEAC-1 noted that, PP was not able to upload final EIA/EMP report on PARIVESH
portal of the SEIAA directly as per ToR issued on 29.11.2018, hence, PP applied for fresh ToR
and uploaded the EIA/EMP report.

In view of above facts, SEAC-1 was of the considerate view to apprise the proposal as requested
by the PP.

The brief information of the project as submitted by the PP is as below,

Sr. NO. Particulars Details

1. Name of the project & Address along Proposed Modernization cum expansion project
with all corner latitude and longitude for Sugar (4000 TCD to 7500 TCD of sugar),
Proposed Distillery (45 KLPD) and Expansion
of Cogen plant (15 MW to 28 MW)

Latitude– 16o81’98.47” N,
Longitude – 74o78’24.58” E
2. Type of Organization (Private Co- Operative
/Government/Semi Government etc.)
3. Correspondence Address and contact Shri. Suryakant Bhimrao Patil (Managing
details of Project Proponent Director)

5
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
M/S Mohanrao Shinde Sahakari Sakhar
Karkhana Ltd.
At: Mohannagar, Post: Arag, Tal: Miraj, Dist:
Sangli,
State: Maharashtra, Pin: 416401, India
Phone No. 0233-2264852, 8600025901 / 902 /
903
Email Id: md@mohansugar.com,
contact@mohansugar.com

4. Type of project (TOR/EC/Amendment in EC

TOR/Amendment in EC/ Revalidation/
Expansion/Process change etc.)
5. Category of project as per EIA Category ‘B’ project as per the EIA
Notification 2006 amended from time to Notification 2006 and amendments made there
time (Pl. mention category A,B,B1,B2 on.
etc. whichever is applicable)
6. If earlier ToR is obtained pl. mention Auto Generated ToR received by MoEF,CC
details (ToR letter No. & Date, Delhi vide Letter No: IA-J-11011/341/2018-IA-
SEAC/EAC Meeting No.) II(I), Dtd:- 29.11.2018

As per MoEFCC notification dtd13.06.2019

distillery projects up to 100 KLD transferred to
SEAC/SEIAA

7. If earlier EC is obtained pl. mention EC Not applicable, as project is a green field

Number &Date project.
8. Whether the proposal is a violation case No.
(yes/no)
9. Applicability of CRZ clearance (yes/no) No
10. Whether General Specific Conditions are No
applicable to the project (Yes/No) If yes
pl. give details
11. Whether Scrutiny fees paid as per SEIAA No
guidelines (Yes/No): If yes pl give
payment details
12. Name of accredited Environmental Sneha Hi-Tech Products, Bangalore
Consultant & address along with QCI-NABET vide Certificate no.
Accreditation No. & Validity Old : NABET/EIA/1619/IA0028
New : NABET/EIA/2124/RA 0235.
Validity : 15.02.2024

13. Name of layout plan approving Authority Town Planning Authority

14. Estimated cost of Project (in Rs. Lakhs) 24000 (17716 Sugar & CoGen , 6284-
Distillery Unit )
15. Area of project (in Sqm.) 250905.00
16. Whether 33% green belt is provided Yes
(Yes/No)
6
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
17. Area of Green Belt & No. of trees in the 80937.1
proposed project in Sqm. (Pl. provide No. Of Trees : 17,000 Plants
2000 trees per hectare of green belt area)
18. Width of internal roads and turning radius Internal Road: 6 Mt
Turning Radius: 9 Mt
19. Details of proposed construction Total Built-up Area (in Sq.m)
80937.1
No. of Buildings – 7 ( Shed )
Height in mtrs. 25 mtr
20. List of Raw materials & Storage Details (Pl. add on in the list if necessary)

Sr. Particular Quantity Total Source

No.
Existing Expansion
Sugar unit
1 Sugarcane (TCD) 4000 3500 7500 Nearby farms
2 Lime Tonnes/ d 8.0 7.0 15.00 From outside venders
3 Sulpher tonnes/d 2.0 1.75 3.75 From outside venders
Co-generation unit
1 Bagasse (TPD) 1333 1167 2500 From sugar unit
Distillery
1 Molasses (MT/M) 5100 5100 From sugar unit
2 Nutrients (kg/D) … …. From outside venders
4 Press mud (TPD) 140 300 From sugar unit
5 Boiler ash (12 8.87TPD 28.40 From sugar unit
TPD) TPD

21. Production Details

Sr. Product Production Unit

No
1 Sugar Expansion from 4000 to TCD
7500
2 Co-gen power 15 to 28 MW
3. Fuel Ethanol/ Extra Neutral 45 KLPD
Alcohol (ENA)/ Rectified spirit
22. Water Consumption & Effluent generation (All units in CMD)
i)Source & Qty of water requirement (in CMD):

Fresh water requirement for the sugar & Cogen unit is 1768 KLD.
Fresh water requirement for the Distillery unit is 463 KLD.
7
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

Details are attached -Annexure I

ii)Water supply permission obtained (Yes/No) & approving Authority : Irrigation Dept

23. Quantity of sewage generation (in CMD) 48

24. Details of Sewage Treatment and Disposal of MSSSKL will construct a Sewage
treated sewage: Treatment Plant of 48 KLD capacity
with latest technology for treatment of
domestic sewage from the sugar mill
and Distillery plant. Treated sewage
will be used for Gardening and
plantation
purpose.

25. Detail of Effluent Generation (unit CMD),

Particulars Existin Proposed Total
g
a) Qty. of Effluent generation: 350 830 1180
(CMD)
b) Qty of high COD Effluent (CMD) 00 3500-4000 3500-4000
c) Qty of low TDS effluent (CMD) 00 50-100 50-100

Sr. Particulars Water Effluent

No. Intake Generation
1. Domestic requirement 55 48
2. Process In Sugar Mill 1175 565
3. Heating In Sugar Mill 1358 42
4. Heating In Cogen Unit 3300 200
5. Cooling for Cogen Unit 560 243
6. Washing 60 60
7. Miscellaneous 70 70
Green Belt Development 190 0
26. Whether Zero liquid Discharge Effluent Treatment Yes
is proposed (Yes/No)
27. Brief Description of Effluent Treatment scheme i. 350 KLD ETP will be upgraded to
1200 KLD. Effluent from sugar
and cogen unit will be treated in
this ETP.
ii. The Spent wash will be treated
Incinarator followed by MEE
iii. The spent wash evaporation
condensate, spent lees and other
waste will be treated in
Condensate Polishing Unit (CPU)
and treated water will be reused for
distillery cooling tower make up or

8
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
for fermentation process and for
greenbelt. In this way, Zero Liquid
Discharge (ZLD) will be achieved
as per CREP norms prescribed by
CPCB.
28. Qty of treated effluent proposed to be sent to Not Applicable, Proposed project will
CEIP (pl. mention Name of CETP and its be ZLD
membership Details)
29 Please mention parameters of treated effluent to be achieved as per EP Rule, 1986 and or
stipulated by the SPCB
Parameter Inlet concentration (Mg/L) Outlet concentration
(mg/L)
PH 4-9 6- 8.5
TSS 900 75-90
TDS 26500 1500-1800
CoD 5500 170-200
BOD 3000 65 -795
Oil & Grease 30 10
30 Brief Note on proposed Rainwater harvesting scheme along with budget allocation:
31 Solid Waste management
Sr. Type of Qty Source of Disposal methods Pl. mention
No waste MT/M Generation plan to
reduce solid
waste
generation if
any
1 Fly/ Boiler 586 Process Brick Manufacturer --
Ash MT/M
2 ETP Sludge 300 MT/A Process Manure --
3 Paper waste 0.01 Other sold to scrap vendors --
MT/M
4 Plastic waste 0.01 Other sold to scrap vendors --
MT/M
5 Non- Municipal sold to scrap vendors --
Biodegradabl 7 MT/M Solid waste
e
6 Bio- Municipal sold to scrap vendors --
10 MT/M
degradable Solid waste
32 Hazardous Waste Generation & Disposal (As per HW Rule 2016)
Sr. Categor Particula Source of Existing proposed Total Method & Disposal
No y rs Generati Qty of Qty & Qty & as per
. on generatio generatio generatio HW Rules 2016
(please n MT/M n MT/M n MT/M
include
Name of
Product)
1. 5.1 Used / 00 00 0.084 0.084 Sent to authorized
Spent re
Oil
9
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
processors/CHWTS
DF

33 Fuel Consumption
Sr. Type of Consumption Qty (TPD) Used Ash % So2% Air Pollution
No Fuel for control /
(Boiler/ equipment
DG Set provided
etc.) (Yes/ No)
Existi Propose Tota Existi Propo T Exi Pro Total
ng d l ng sed ot stin pos
al g ed
1. Bagasse 00 605 605 Boiler 00 1-2 1- 00 0.0 0.02 Yes
55 TPH 2 2
2. Biogas 00 67 67 00 00 0 00 00 00 Yes
0
3. Diesel 00 2*1010 0 00 Yes
KVA
34 Brief Note on Air Pollution Control equipment’s :

The air pollution caused by this industry is mainly from dust as SPM from fuel. The dust is
not predominantly due to the composition and handling of raw materials because those are
largely controlled. The efforts taken by the Industry in this respect, are also indicated. Stack
with 65-meter height provided as per guideline with Dust catcher ESP. The CO2 from
fermentation will be converted to liquid CO2. The effluent treatment will be fully aerobic.
35 Stack Details (Also include process vent details)
Sr. No. Section/ Source Stac Stack Height Internal Temperature
Unit Polluti k height form Diameter of exhaust gas
on No. ground (inch)
1. 1* Proces 1 60 m 62m 2.0 160
Boiler- s
55 TPH
2. 1* 110 Proces 1 60m 62m 2.0 160
TPH s
3. 1* 20 Proces 1 58 m 60 m 2.0 160
TPH s
36 Energy
a) Source of Power Supply: from existing
b) Maximum Demand : 10.27 MW/Hr.
c) Whether DG sets will be provided (Yes/No): Yes
If Yes:
Two D.G. sets of capacity 625 kVA & 320 kVA are present at the site.
New two DG set will be installed of capacity 1010 kVA after expansion

d) Please Mention if high tension line is passing through the plot: No

10
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
If yes, pl, give details of safety measures adopted: Not Applicable
37 Details of use of renewable energy with budget allocation
i) Total Energy Demand 10.27 MW/hr (Source- own CCP)
i) Proposed renewable energy source capacity- 1.027 MW/hr
ii) Proposed Budget (in Rs. Lakhs): 5 lakhs
iii) Timeline for implementation: before operation of unit
Project proponent is in planning to proposed the renewable energy like solar
light, LED light etc. Details will be incorporated in EIA report.

38 Details of public hearing (if applicable)

i) i)Place of public hearing: at Site M/S. Mohanrao Shinde Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd.
At Village Mohannagar, Post: Arag, Tal: Miraj, Dist: Sangli, Pin: 416401

ii)Date of public hearing:30-12-2021

Sr. Details of the Question/Suggesti Response from Project Proponent EMP Cost Timefram
No. Participants on e
1 Shri Santaji He asked the Project Environment Consultant Capital before
Ramchandra question that informed that as shown in the Cost of operation
Gaikwad, A/ P whether there will presentation the proposed project CPU – Rs.
Belanki, Tal- be pollution & to will be zero liquid discharge 5 Cr.
Miraj, Dist- what extent due to (ZLD). Not a drop of treated O&M
Sangli project expansion effluent will be discharged outside Cost – Rs.
& commission of the factory premises. Hence, there 0.30 Cr.
new distillery will not be any water pollution.
plant?
2. Shri He asked Due to The Environment Consultant said Capital before
Babasaheb this project that there would be no loss of Cost of operation
Krishanarao whether there will farmers water. As informed in the CPU – Rs.
Patil be any loss presentation, this project is zero 5 Cr.
A/P Erandoli, farmers water? liquid discharge (ZLD) project. O&M
Ta- Miraj, Not a drop of treated effluent will Cost – Rs.
Dist- Sangli be discharged outside the factory 0.30 Cr.
premises. The most advanced
technology R. O. (Reverse
Osmosis) system will be
commissioned in the plant. Due to
which the treated effluent will be
recycled & reused in the process.
There will not be any water
pollution in the area. Therefore
there will be no loss of water to the
farmers.

11
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

3 Shri Tanaji He asked that The Project Environment Capital within 3

Rajaram while developing Consultant answered that there Cost – years
the expansion of would be no tree
Dalvi. the project & new cutting/deforestation. In the 0.65 Cr.
distillery plant, presentation the outline & the plan
A/P O&M
will there be any of the project is shown. There are
Vyankochiwad Cost – 0.07
tree cutting/ small shrubs on the project site. It
i Ta- Miraj, Cr,
deforestation? cannot be called as trees. They will
Dist- Sangli.
have to removed in the very small
quantities. There will be no tree
cuttings/ deforestation
4 Shri Tanaji He asked the Environment Consultant further Capital before
Rajaram question & said informed that in the new expanded Cost –2.20 operation
that details about project 110.0 TPH boiler will be
Dalvi. air pollution installed. The stack to the tune of Cr.
control system 62 meters height will be provided
A/P O&M
should be to it. The ESP system will be
Vyankochiwad Cost – 0.25
explained. provided to it. The dust particles
i Ta- Miraj, Cr,
will arrest in the ESP system. The
Dist- Sangli
ESP gives 99.99%. Hence there is
no possibility of dust particles
coming out. Similarly, there will be
no generation of any gas in the
atmosphere.
5. Shri Avinash He asked that Due to expansion of project & new -- --
Raosaheb How many people distillery plant, it will provide
will get job Employee opportunities to 117
Kerimane opportunities due new people. Total 567 people will
to this project get employment opportunities,
A/P Malgaon,
expansion?. both old & new projects.
Ta- Miraj,
Dist- Sangli

6 Shri He asked I am a The managing Director of the -- --

Babasaheb farmer. Will the project said that the power
Bhausaheb electricity & produced in the project will be
fertilizers sold to Maharashtra State power
Nargachhe,
produced in the Distribution Company Limited,
A/P Bolvad, project be a power generation company of
available to the Government of Maharashtra
Ta- Miraj,
local farmers? as per the agreement. Therefore
Dist- Sangli Maharashtra State Electricity
Distribution Company will
provide electricity to the
surrounding villages as per their
distribution, Similarly, the
fertilizers produced in the
project is of excellent quality &
12
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

will be made available to the

members & beneficiaries.

7 Shri Shivaji He asked How The managing Director of project

Shrikant the farmers willsaid that the plant consisting of
Mahadik be benefitted modern devices would be
due to this operational and there would be no
At post project pollution. So, there will be no
Shipur, Ta- expansion & water, air & noise pollution. Due to
setting up of expansion of sugarcane crushing
Miraj, Dist-
new distillery capacity, more sugarcane crop will
Sangli project? How isbe procured from local farmers.
it going to The loss of weight of sugarcane
benefit crop will be crushed without delay
.
Due to the timely crushing of
sugarcane, the sugar yield of the
factory will increase. This will
also increase the income of the
factory. In addition, the ethanol
project will provide additional
revenue to the factory. It will
help to pay less interest on
capital amount. Therefore, it
will be possible for the factory
to give extra price to the local
farmers
39 EMP (Please mention specific items proposed in EMP along with specific timeline for its
implementation)
Construction Phase
Cost
Sr. No. Attributes Parameters Management Measures (Rs. in
Lakh)

Dust & Particulate

Dust suppression measures such as regular water
matters due to
Air sprinkling, covering the stock piles, Providing PPE’s viz.
1 material hauling & 1.25
Pollution Dust masks, Safety Goggles to construction workers,
construction
Site barricading
activity

13
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

Construction activity wastes:

Solid recyclable inert wastes:

--
The inert solid recyclable waste viz. left over iron rods,
wooden flanks, cardboards, wooden boxes will be stored
in separately in dedicated area & sold to recycler.

Solid non-recyclable inert wastes:

Construction The inert non-recyclable wastes viz. left over concrete --

activity waste viz. debris, stones, aggregates will used as filling material for
solid recyclable internal roads.
Land/Soil &
wastes, non-
2 Water Excavated soil:
recyclable wastes,
pollution --
excavated soil & The excavated soil will be stored & used for green belt
surface runoff development activity.
water & sewage
Surface run off:

Surface runoff generated due to water sprinkling activity 0.50

will be appropriately routed to nallah by temporary
constructed channels.

Domestic sewage:

Mobile sanitation (toilet) facility will be provided to 1.50

construction workers & will be periodically cleaned by
Night soil tankers

Noise generation
due to construction PPE viz. Ear plugs will be provided workers & it will be
Noise
3 activities & use of ensured construction activity will be limited between 9. 0.05
pollution
machineries/equip AM to 5 PM only.
ment’s

Total 3.3

14
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

Operation Phase
Capital Estimated
Investment Recurring
SN Component Mitigation/Management measures
(INR, in Expenditure/Year
Cr) (INR, in Cr)

Boiler Provision of ESP attached to common

emissions stack of 62 m height.
1 Air 2.20 0.25
Process
Provision of CO2 Bottling Plant
gases
Construction of CPU of 300 m3/day capacity with
2 Water primary secondary & tertiary treatment scheme; 5.0 0.30
Installation of MEE - Incinator
Ear plugs/muffs for workers,
3 Noise acoustic enclosures to noise generating 0.25 0.02
equipment's
Quarterly Environment Monitoring (Per year)
Ambient Air
PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOx, CO
Monitoring
Environment Boilers, &
4 Monitoring DG stack TPM, SOR2, NOx 0.60 0.10
monitoring
Effluent
pH, COD, BOD, TSS, TDS, Oil &
(Treated
Grease
&Untreated)
Glares, Gloves,
Occupational Safety shoes, Helmets, Ear Plugs etc. & 6 monthly
5 0.25 0.04
Health health-medical check-up of all employees
(Recurring).
6 Green Belt Green belt development activity 0.65 --
Estimated annual expenditure for maintenance of
-- 0.07
green belt
Development of dedicated area for solid waste
Solid waste
7 storage & Provision of waste storage 0.35 0.10
Management
drums(Recurring)
Rain Water Installation of roof top RWH, Construction of
9 Harvesting RWH pond. Annual Cleaning up and maintenance 0.50 0.05
Measures of RWH pond & system (Recurring).
Installation of solar street lights within premises for
10 Energy illumination internal roads & open places within 0.55 0.02
plant premises.
Disaster Provision of Lightning arrestor, Implementation of
11 Management & safety measures identified in Quantitative Risk 0.75 0.02
Safety Assessment studies.
Storm Water Development & Maintenance of internal storm
12 0.25 0.02
Management water drains (Recurring).
Environment Provision of Environment Monitoring &
13 -- 0.21
Management Cell Management Department
Total 11.35 1.20

40 Other Relevant Information :(Pl. provide brief note on proposed project)

15
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
41 Details of skill development program within Organization

Employees will be sponsor for further education if needed in their existing field. Employees
shall be sponsored for various conferences, workshops and training in the related field by
reputed institutes. SOP’s shall be prepared and activities will be carried out in line with
SOP.
42 Details of environmental Monitoring Cell (Pl. provide organogram with educated
Qualification and experience)

Director

Plant Manager

Production in charge

EHS Manager

Operator and Workmen

Sr. Designation of officer Qualification and experience Degree and Responsibility

No.
1. Director Degree in the respective field Total responsibility for EMP
2. Plant Manager Diploma or degree in the respective Day to day feedback from
field and minimum ex. Of 10 years production executive team and
Consistent effort on control of
emission in Line with SOP
and predefined limits
3. Production in charge Min. Post-graduation with chemistry Maintaining records of waste
as principal subject with 5 years’ disposal water analysis, Legal
experience aspects of Environmental
Monitoring
4. EHS Manager Graduation in Env. Science with 2 To run STP and ETP in line
years of experience with predefined SOP’s
5. Operator and workman B.Sc. and experience in relevant field To run ETP, STP plant as per
standard Operating procedure
43 Details of court cases if pending in any Hon'ble court

Nil

16
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:

After detailed deliberations with the PP and their accredited consultant, SEAC-1 decided to
recommend the proposal to the SEIAA for the grant of prior Environmental Clearance subject to
following specific conditions,

Sr. No. Condition

1. PP to submit an undertaking for CPU installation as identified in the certified
compliance report of the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board.

2. PP to submit point wise compliance of issues raised during Public Hearing along with
financial provisions and time lines for its compliance.
3. PP to complete development of mandatory green belt immediately with the provision
of drip irrigation and submit photographs. PP to plant tree sampling of 5-6 feet height.
4. PP to prepare plan for conservation of all natural water streams exists on site; PP shall
not diver any natural water stream without permission of competent authority.
5. PP to provide Zero Liquid Discharge Effluent Treatment for distillery unit. PP to
explore possibility to assess techno-economic feasibility of using technology for MEE
such as low temperature/mechanical vapour compressor etc. so as to reduce operation
cost and use of natural resources.
PP to get ZLD design vetted by the reputed Govt. Institution like IIT/NIT.
6. PP to ensure enclosed storage with impervious flooring of all raw materials and
chemicals, no open storage be practiced so as to avoid odour nuisance and its impact
on the soil in case of spillage.
7. PP to provide RCC platform for composting area with proper leak proof lining of 250
micron HDPE sheet followed by local soil & finally brick-on-edge with filled cement
solution in between bricks to stop percolation from yard.
8. PP to provide dig trench (cut off trench) with black cotton soil & plastic sheet around
the boundary of composting site to avoid the percolation/lateral capillary movement of
liquid
9. PP to provide display board at piezometric hole and monitor ground water
10. PP to provide appropriate measure to remove the issue related with odour I flies within
and surrounding of the compost plant by spraying (Glue Trap, Bromodialon 0.005%
cake, Bromodialon 0.005% powder, Fifronil 0.03%) at different points of Bio-
Compositing site and provide Sugar beds for flies at Biocomposting site to reduce fly
nuisance.
11. PP should regularly monitor the poly sheds, brick-on edge area and HDPE lining area
and immediately replace if found damaged
12. PP should maintain record regarding daily receipt of spent wash, compost dispose each
day.
13. PP to submit copies of MoU executed with the brick manufacturer for disposal of boiler
ash along with their quantities.
14. PP to provide asphalting on all internal roads so as to reduce particulate matter
pollution during plying of vehicles within the premises.
15. PP to provide nature based treatment for Sewage Treatment for treatment of domestic
sewage ( in place of septic Tank) and ensure all standard parameters are met as per
requirements of CPCB/MPCB.
17
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
16. PP to carry out physiochemical analysis report of the ETP/CPU sludge proposed to be
used as manure and obtain approval from the competent Authority so as to ensure its
safe use on agricultural land
17. PP to ensure to reduce spent wash generation within 6-8 KL/KL of alcohol produced
18. PP to ensure to utilize CER fund before the commissioning of the manufacturing
activity in consultation with the District Collector.
19. PP to ensure to restrict fresh water consumption within 10 KL/KL of alcohol
production
20. PP to complete rain water harvesting facility before the commissioning of the
manufacturing activity.

CONCLUSION:
Recommended

18
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No. 3: SIA/MH/IND/62118 Type: EC

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 62118 submitted along with copies
of documents seeking prior Environmental Clearance under the provisions of the EIA Notification,
2006. The proposed project activity is listed at Sr. No. 5(g), Distillery under category B1 as per EIA
Notification 2006 amended from time to time and the proposal is appraised in the SEAC-1
committee.
PROJECT DETAILS:
Environmental Clearance for Establishment of 30 KLPD Distillery at Gat No. 165, 168A,
168CVasant Nagar, Pargaon, Tal.: Washi, Dist.: Osmanabad, By Bhimashankar Sugar Mills
Ltd., (BSML)..

Details of earlier EC if any:

No
DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Accredited Environmental consultant
M/s. Ultra Tech Environmental Consultancy and Laboratory.
The proposal was appraised based on the documents submitted and presented by the PP and their
accredited Environmental Consultant.
The ToR was granted to the PP vide letter dated 06.05.2021. The Public Hearing was carried out on
18.11.2021; the public hearing report submitted along with EIA/EMP report.
PP submitted EIA report on 01.12.2022.
The proposal was earlier considered in the 224th meeting of SEAC-1 wherein the proposal was deferred
for following reasons,
I. PP proposes composting of spent wash the Regional Officer, MPCB noted in the Public Hearing
that, the process generates the odour nuisance in the surrounding of the industry area. PP to submit
their management plan indicating use of new and recent technologies for the complete treatment
of spent wash without creating any nuisance in the surrounding.
II. PP to submit point wise compliance of all issues raised during public hearing along with specific
time lines for completion, responsibility for compliance and adequate budgetary provisions.
III. It was noticed from the proceedings of the Public Hearing and information shared by the PP and
their consultant that, the NOC given by the Grampanchayt vide letter dated 16.02.2021 was
revoked in the monthly meeting of Grampanchayat held on 16.11.2021. PP replied that the same
has been later on cancelled. PP asked to submit revised proceeding soft e Grampanchayat meeting
indicating they do not have any objection for the establishment of proposed distillery in the area.

19
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
IV. PP to submit copy of certified compliance to be obtained from MPCB for existing Consent to
operate.
V. PP to submit copy of permission/ agreement executed with the Water Resource Department for
supply of water for the proposed Distillery unit as per prevailing rules of Water Resource
Department.
VI. PP informed that, they have submitted application for withdrawal of ground water but yet not
obtained the same. PP to submit copy of permission obtained from the Competent Authority.
VII. PP to carry out HAZOP of the distillation process and submit an undertaking indicating all
recommendation will be implemented on site.

Now, PP submitted additional information.

During deliberations it was noted that, PP has not complied with the observations of last meeting.
Following deficiencies were observed,
1. PP proposes composting of spent wash the Regional Officer, MPCB noted in the Public Hearing
that, the process generates the odour nuisance in the surrounding of the industry area. PP to submit
a comprehensive and technically sound odour management plan indicating use of new and recent
technologies for the complete treatment of spent wash without creating any nuisance in the
surrounding.
2. PP has not obtained water lifting permission from the Competent Authority of water resource
department. PP proposes to use ETP recycled water, water stored from rains and ground water for
which NOC has been obtained. PP to submit detailed water requirement calculations to establish
sustainability of project in absence water supply from other sources.
3. PP to submit design details of ETP and STP.

RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:
After detailed deliberations with the PP and their accredited consultant, SEAC-1 decided to defer
the proposal till submission of compliance of above points.
CONCLUSION:
Defer

20
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No. 4 : SIA/MH/IND/248631 Type: EC

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 248631 submitted along with copies
of documents seeking prior Environmental Clearance under the provisions of the EIA Notification,
2006. The proposed project activity is listed at Sr. No. 5(f), Synthesis of Organic Chemicals category
B2 as per Office Memorandum issued by MoEF&CC dated 28.01.2021 and the proposal is appraised
in the SEAC-1 committee.

PROJECT DETAILS:
Environment Clearance for Proposed Establishment of API Manufacturing Facility at Gat
No.1065, 1066, 1069 Golegaon Road, Off Alandi Markal Road, Markal, Khed, Pune by
M/S Deccan Nutraceuticals Pvt.Ltd.

Details of earlier EC if any: No

DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
After deliberations SEAC observed:-
Representative of PP was present during the meeting along with Accredited Environmental consultant
M/s. Aditya Environmental Services Pvt. Ltd.
The proposal was earlier considered in the 224th meeting of SEAC-1 wherein PP remained absent.
The proposal was appraised based on the documents submitted and presented by the PP and their
accredited Environmental Consultant.
The brief information of the project as given by the PP is as below,

S. Particulars Required Details

N
.
1. Name of the project & Address along with Name of Project: Proposed API
all corner latitude and longitude manufacturing Industry by M/s Deccan
Nutraceuticals Pvt. Ltd.
Address: GAT 1065, 1066, 1069,
GOLEGAON ROAD, OFF ALANDI
MARKAL ROAD, MARKAL, KHED,
PUNE, MAHARASHTRA

Latitude and Longitude:

Poin Longitud
Latitude
t e

21
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

18 °39’45’’ N 73°57’25’
1
’E
2 18 73°57’21’
3 °39’46’
18 °39’40’’ N ’73°57’20’
E
’N ’73°57’23’
E
4 18 °39’39’’ N
’E

2. Type of Organization (Private Private Limited company registered under

Government/Semi Government etc.) Companies Act 1956
3. Correspondence Address and contact details Mr. Navin Karnani
of (Director)
Project Proponent Deccan Nutraceuticals Pvt. Ltd.
Gat 1065, 1066, 1069, Golegaon Road, Off
Alandi Markal Road, Markal, Khed, Pune,
Maharashtra
Phone: 9822641298
Email: nutrapharma.pune@gmail.com
4. Type of project (ToR/EC/Amendment in Fresh EC
ToR/Amendment in EC/ Revalidation/
Expansion/ Process change etc.)
5. Category of project as per EIA Notification 5 (f) (API), B2
2006 amended from time to time (Pl.
mention category A,B,B1,B2 etc. whichever
is applicable)
6. If earlier ToR is obtained pl. mention details NA
(ToR letter No. & Date, SEAC/EAC
Meeting No.)
7. If earlier EC is obtained pl. mention EC NA
Number & Date
8. Whether the proposal is a violation case No, NA
(yes/no)
9. Applicability of CRZ clearance (yes /no) No, NA
10. Whether General /Specific Conditions are No, NA
applicable to the project (Yes/No) If yes pl.
give details
11. aWhether Scrutiny fees paid as per SEIAA Yes, Rs. 1 Lakh Scrutiny fee is paid on 14-09-
guidelines (Yes/No); If yes pl give payment 2022. See Annexure below for more details.
details
12. Name of accredited Environmental Aditya Environmental Services Pvt. Ltd.
Consultant & address along with NABET/EIA/1922/SA 0129 valid till 19th
Accreditation No. & Validity October 2022.
13. Name of layout plan approving Authority MIDC
14. Estimated cost of Project (in Rs. Lakhs) Rs. 550 lakhs
15. Area of project (in Sq.m.) 22,000 sq. m.

22
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
16. Whether 33% green belt is provided Yes
(Yes/No)
17. Area of Green Belt & No. of trees in the GB area: 7260.13 sq. m.
proposed project in Sq.m. (Pl. provide 2000 No. of Trees: 1453
trees per hectare of green belt area)
18. Width of internal roads and turning radius 6 meter
19. Details of proposed construction Total Built-up Area (in 5010.39
Sq.m)
No. of Buildings & its  1 floors
height in mtrs.  Utility
buildings Gr +
1 floor
 Maximum
height of
buildings 14m
20. List of Raw materials & Storage Details (Pl. add on in the list if necessary)
S. Name of Raw consumptio No of Hazard Proposed Remar
N Material n (MTPA) days Category Precautio k
. storage (NFPA) n to
planne Prevent
d at site Accident
1.Cyanocobalamin 3.3 15 -- Use of --
2.Methanol* 271.9 15 Flammable PPE’s shall --
3.Methylene 102.1 15 Toxic be ensured --
Dichloride** while
4.Hydrochloric Acid 4.53 15 Corrosive handling --
Acetone
5. 41.4 15 Flammable above --
6.Diethyl Ether 3.7 15 Flammable chemicals --
, Toxic such as
7.Triethylamine 6.1 15 Flammable safety --
, Toxic helmet,
8.Hyflo 1.24 15 -- splash --
9.Tetrahydrofuran 37.2 15 Flammable proof --
Methyl tert-butyl 1.5
10. 15 Flammable goggles, --
ether safety
Tertiary
11. Butyl 1.83 15 -- shoes, --
Dimethyl Silyl apron,
Chloride rubber
N,N-
12. 15 15 --- hand --
Dimethylformamid gloves as
e applicable
Minitroleum
13. 2.9 15 Flammable --
(Hexane)
Toluene
14. 15.5 15 Flammable --
Isopropyl alcohol
15. 53.83 15 Flammable --
Cyclohexane
16. 14.1 15 Flammable --
Dimethyl Sulphate 1.1
17. 15 -- --
23
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

Ethanolamine
18. 1.02 15 -- --
Ethyl acetate
19. 82.5 15 -- --
Raney Nickel
20. 3.8 15 -- --
Formamide
21. 2.1 15 --- --
Sodium methoxide
22. 12.7 15 -- --
solution
4-methoxyaniline
23. 2.1 15 -- --
Ethyl-2-chloro
24. 2.9 15 -- --
aceto acetate
Sodium acetate
25. 3.3 15 -- --
21. Production Details

Exis
ting
Pharma
(TP Tot
Therapeut copoeia
Sr. M) Proposed al
ic Products Referenc
No As (Kg/Annum) (TP
Categories e / Page
per M)
No.
CT
O
Herbal Taxus Baccata Extract (10- 750 750
Extrats DAB III)
(Used as
1 --
API Key
Starting
Material) --
Cardiovasc Digitalis Lannata Extract 750 750
2 --
ular agent --
Herbal Artemisia Extract (as 5000 500
Extrat Artesunate and Artemether) 0
3 --
(Antimalar
ial) --
Miscellane Other Herbal Product 33 33
4 --
ous ---
Herbal Kaladan Extracts (Lysergol) 250 250
Extrats
(Used as
5 --
API Key
Starting
Material) --
Herbal Horsechetnut Extracts 2000 200
Extract 0
6 (Anti- --
inflammat
ory) --
Herbal Coleus Forskohill Extracts 2000 200
7 --
Extract 0 --

24
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

(Nutraceuti
cals)
Miscellane Fermented herbal product 1650 165
8 --
ous 0 --
Herbal Lycopene Extract 100 100
Extract
9 --
(antioxidan
t) --
Herbal Lutein Extract 100 100
Extract
10 --
(Antioxida
nt) --
Herbal Piperine Extract 100 100
Extract
11 --
(Antioxida
nt) --
Herbal Yohimbine Extract 100 100
Extract
12 --
(Antagonis
t) --
API Cabergoline
13 (Parkinson -- 20 20
treatment) --
Vitamin B Hydroxocobalamin Sulphate
14 12 -- 5 5
Deficiency --
Vitamin B Hydroxocobalamin Acetate
15 12 -- 200 200
Deficiency --
Vitamin B Hydroxocobalamin Chloride
16 12 -- 5 5
Deficiency --
Vitamin B Methylcobalamin
300
17 12 -- 3000
0
Deficiency --
Vitamin B Adenosylcobalamin
18 12 -- 20 20
Deficiency --
API Naltroxone Hydrochloride
(Opioid
19 -- 200 200
antagonists
) --
API Naloxone Hydrochloride
(Opioid
20 -- 50 50
antagonists
) --
API Nalbuphine Hydrochloride
21 -- 50 50
(Opioid --
25
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

antagonists
)
API Dexmedetomidine
22 -- 20 20
(Sedative) Hydrochloride --
API Neostigmine Methylsulfate
(Cholinest
23 -- 250 250
erase
inhibitors) --
API Nepafenac
(Nonsteroi
dal
24 -- 250 250
anti-
inflammat
ory) --
API(Antic Apixaban 100
25 -- 1000
oagulant) 0 --
Total 1283 179 --
5070
3 03
22. Water Consumption & Effluent generation (All units in CMD)
i)Source & Qty of water requirement (in CMD) : Tankers 56 cmd
ii) Water supply permission obtained (Yes/No) & approving Authority : Yes, CGWB/ Tanker
Particular Requirement (CMD) Loss (CMD) Effluent (CMD)
Water Existi Propose Tot ExistingPropose Tot Existin Propose Tot
requireme ng d al d al g d al
nt
Domestic 5 3 8 1 1 2 4 2 6
Cooling
and boiler 15 5 20 12 3 15 3 2 5
feed
Industrial
10 3 13 5 1 6 5 2 7
Processing
Green belt 0 15 15 0 15 15 0 0 0
Total 30 16 56 18 20 38 12 6 18
23. Quantity of sewage generation (in CMD) 6
24. Details of Sewage Treatment and Disposal Domestic sewage will be treated in ETP along
of treated sewage: with trade effluent. Trade effluent will be
treated in ETP/ Evaporation Plant and treated
effluent will be recycled for cooling tower
makeup.
25. Detail of Effluent Generation (unit CMD)
Particular Existing Proposed Total

26
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

a)Qty. of Effluent generation: 12 6 18

(CMD)
b)Qty. of high TDS/COD effluent: 0 2 2
(CMD)
c)Qty. of low TDS/COD effluent: 16 16
(CMD)
26. Whether Zero liquid Discharge Effluent Yes
Treatment is proposed (Yes/No)
27. Brief Description of Effluent Treatment Existing: Industrial effluent is treated in ETP
scheme and used for gardening.
Proposed: The effluent generated from API
project will be collected in separate tank and
will be evaporated -The condensate will be
collected and treated in ETP and treated water
will be tested and used into cooling towers.
The Industry will maintain ZLD after
proposal.
28. Qty of treated effluent proposed to be sent to No, since proposal is ZLD.
CETP (pl. mention Name of CETP and its
membership Details)
29. Please mention parameters of treated effluent to be achieved as per EP Rule,1986 and or
stipulated by the SPCB
Parameter Inlet concentration (mg/l) Outlet concentration
(mg/l)
PH 4 to 6 6 to 8.5
TSS 400-500 <100
TDS 1800-2000 <2100
COD 4000-5000 <250
BOD 2500-3000 <30
Oil and Grease -- --
Chlorides as Cl -- --
Sulphates as SO4 -- --
Heavy metals -- --
Benzene -- --
other if any -- --
30. Brief Note on proposed Rainwater Roof Top Rain water will be collected and sent
harvesting scheme along with budget to Water Treatment and will be used within the
allocation: plant
31. Solid Waste management
S.N. Type of Waste Quantity Source of Disposal Pl. mention plan
Generation Method waste
Minimization
methods to reduce
solid
waste generation
if any

27
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

1 Industrial As Manure --
Botanical waste 10 Kg/day
Activity
2 CHWTSDF --
ETP sludge 400 Kg/M
3 Sale to Brick --
Boiler Ash 1.8 TPD
Manufacturer
32. Hazardous Waste Generation & Disposal (As per HW Rule 2016)
S. Categ Particular Source Existin Propose Total Method of
N. ory of g Qty & d Qty & Qty & disposal as
generat Genera Genera Genera per HW
ion tion tion tion Rules 2016
(please MT/M
include
name
of
produc
t)
1 20.3 Distillation Industri 0 10 10 CHWTSDF/S
residue al MT/Yea MT/Yea ale to
Activiti r r authorized
es party
2 33.3 Discarded 0 Barrels Barrels Sale to
barrels, – 1000 – 1000 authorized
containers, nos/year nos/year recycler/CHW
liners Contain Contain TSDF
ers 250 ers 250
no/year no/year
3 28.6 Spent Solvent 0 10 10 Reuse/ sale to
MT/Yea MT/Yea authorized
r r vendors /
CHWTSDF
4 28.3 Waste 0 2 MT/A 2 MT/A CHWTSDF
charcoal/hyflo
w/sod
sulfate/al
oxide
5 28.2 Spent Catalyst 0 0.5 MT 0.5 MT CHWTSDF
per Year per Year
5 Other Battery waste 0 10 10 Sent back to
nos/year nos/year manufacturer
6 Other Plastic waste 0 1 1 Sale to Auth.
mt/year mt/year Party/
Recycler
7 Other E waste --IT/ 0 0.5 0.5 Sale to Auth.
Telecom, mt/year mt/year E waste
Electrical, handler/
Electronic Recycler
wastes
28
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

BIO MEDICAL WASTE

Solid Yellow Waste HC 0 2 Kg/m 2 Kg/m CBMWTSDF
waste
Waste White HC 0 1 Kg/m 1 Kg/m CBMWTSDF
sharps (Translucent)
includi
ng
Metals
33. Fuel Consumption
S. Ty Consumption (Qty) Use Ash % SO2 % Air
N. pe d pollut
of for ion
fu (boi contr
el ler/ ol/
DG equip
set ment
etc.) provi
Exist Prop Tota Exis Prop To Exis Prop To ded
ing osed l ting osed tal ting osed tal (yes/
No)
1 Co 3 3 6 Boil 10 10 10 0 0 0 Adequ
al TPD TPD TPD er ate
stack
height
/Bag
filter
3 HS 125 -- 125 DG 0 0 0 0 0.5 0.5 Stack
D Kg/ Kg/ set height
D D
34. Brief Note on Air Pollution Control Bag filter reduce particulates in flue gas.
equipment
35. Stack Details (Also include process vent details)
S. Section/ Source Stack Stack Height Internal Temperature
N. Unit Pollution No. Height from Diameter of exhaust
Ground (inch) gas
1 1 x 2TPH Coal 1 30 m 30 m 0.4 m 140 0C
capacity
Boilers
2 1 x 2TPH Coal 2 30 m 30 m 0.4 m 140 0C
capacity
Boilers
5 DG (160, HSD 3,4,5 4m 2.5m, 0.2 130 0C
62.5 & 500 1.5m
KVA) and
2.5m
above
roof
36. Energy
29
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
a) Source of power Supply : MSEDCL
b) Maximum Demand (KVA) : 440 KVA (Existing: 241 KVA & Proposed: 199 KVA)
c) whether DG sets will be provided (Yes/No): Yes

if yes :
S.N. No. of DG Sets Capacity
Existing Proposed
1. 3 -- 62.5 KVA, 160 KVA
& 500 KVA
respectively.

d) Please Mention if high tension line is passing through the plot : No

If yes, pl. give details of safety measures adopted: NA
37. Details of use of renewable energy with budget allocation

i) Total Energy Demand 440KVA

ii) Proposed renewable energy source: Solar panel 30 KW
iii) Proposed Budget (in Rs. Lakhs): 5 (Capital), 1 (OM)
iv) Timeline for implementation: 1 year
38. Details of public hearing (if applicable)

i) Place of public hearing: NA, since it is under B2 category.

ii) Date of public hearing: NA

Please fill following details

S.N. Issue raised during Applicant plan Budget Specific time
public hearing for its allocation for line of
compliance/ implementation compliance
implementation

NA NA NA NA NA
39. EMP (Please mention specific items proposed in EMP along with specific timeline for its
implementation)
Construction Phase
Cost Rs in Lakhs
SN Description Capital O &
Individual M per
Total year
break up
A Construction management
Provision of barricading sheets, water sprinkling, top --
5
soil preservation, Material storage precaution
Construction and demolition waste safe disposal 3 13
Safe shelter for worker, Drinking water and sanitary
3
facility
PPE for construction worker 2

30
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
40. Operation Phase
Cost (in lakhs)
Sr No Component Description O&M
Capital
per year
Cyclone + Bag filter for coal
1 Air Pollution Control fired stack + scrubber for 2.0 0.2
Process vent
In house Lab + External NABL
Environmental
2 approved lab for Routine 0.5 0.5
Monitoring (*)
Monitoring
Water Pollution ETP upgradation (Evaporation
3 30 5
Control plant for HPS + ETP for LPS)
Hazardous Waste & Storage shed and Disposal cost
4 Solid waste of Hazardous waste and Non- 10 2
management hazardous waste
Green Belt Development and Maintenance
5 0.5 0.5
Development of Green Belt
Occupational Health
6 PPE, Safety Training 0.5 0.5
and Safety
Solar Panel (30 KW over admin
Power Conservation 5 1
building)
Total 48.5 9.7
41. Other Relevant Information : (Pl. provide Nutraceuticals Pvt. Ltd. is proposing to
brief note on proposed project) establish API Manufacturing at Deccan Gat
1065, 1066, 1069, Golegaon Road, Off
Alandi Markal Road, Markal, Khed, Pune,
Maharashtra.
The proposed activity falls under 5(f) (API)
B2 category as per MOEFCC Notification: F.
No. 22-25/ 2020-IA.II dated 13th April 2020
and needs prior Environmental Clearance
from SEIAA.
42. Details of skill development program within 1. Annual Product Quality Review
Organization 2. Quality Assurance
3. Environment Health and Safety
43. Details of environmental Monitoring Cell (
Pl. provide organogram with educated
Qualification and experience )

44. Details of court cases if pending in any NA

Hon’ble court

31
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:
After detailed deliberations with the PP and their accredited consultant, SEAC-1 decided to
recommend the proposal for prior Environmental Clearance to the SEIAA subject to following
conditions,
Sr. Condition
No.
1. PP to submit lay out plan showing internal roads with minimum six meter width and nine
meter turning radius, entry/exit gates (preferably sliding gates) , provision of cul-de-sac at
dead ends of the internal roads if any, location of pollution control equipment, parking areas,
33% green belt with its dimensions preferably on the periphery of the plot with the provision
of drip irrigation, rain water harvesting structures (locations with dimensions), storm water
drain lines etc.
2. PP to provide Zero Liquid Discharge Effluent Treatment Plant. PP to explore and submit the
feasibility of using technology for MEE such as low temperature/mechanical vapour
compressor/improved membrane with low energy footprint etc. so as to reduce operation cost
and use of natural resources.
PP to get ZLD design vetted by the reputed Govt. Institution like IIT/NIT.
3. PP to ensure to deploy well trained regular employees on all critical/hazardous operations
and storages of hazardous chemicals instead of contract workers. Regular safety training to
be provided to all such employees.
4. PP to prepare chemical compatibility chart of all chemicals and finished products handled,
stored on site and ensure its storage/handling as per compatibility.
5. PP to provide Continuous Online Monitoring System connected to the servers of CPCB and
MPCB. PP to include VOCs monitoring in the scheduled ambient air monitoring plan.
6. PP to submit VOCs emission control and its management plan.

7. PP ensure to provide adequate space for parking of all types of vehicles including external
vehicles carrying raw material and finished products. No vehicle shall be parked on the public
road.
8. PP to ensure to prepare and implement On-site and Off-site emergency handling plan. The
plan shall be prepared based on the HAZOP and Risk Assessment. Required training to all
employees be provided on the emergency handling plans.
9. PP to complete rain water harvesting facility before the commissioning of the manufacturing
activity.
10. PP to utilize CER funds for the development of public infrastructure in the vicinity of the
project area in consultation with District Administration.
11. PP to provide solar energy for the illumination of common areas like administrative building,
parking areas, streetlight etc.

CONCLUSION:

Recommended

32
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No. 5: SIA/MH/IND/73808 Type: EC

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 73808 for prior
Environmental Clearance for manufacturing of resins under category 5(f) B Synthesis of
Organic Chemicals as per provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006 amended from time
to time and appraised in the SEAC-1 committee.
PROJECT DETAILS:
Environmental Clearance For Expansion Of Resin Manufacturing Unit At Plot No.F-
38,Ranjangaon Midc, Teshil - Shirur, Dist – Pune By M/S Reichhold India Pvt.Ltd.

Details of earlier EC if any: No

DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
After deliberations SEAC observed:-
PP remained absent.

RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:
PP remained absent. Hence deferred

CONCLUSION:
Deferred

33
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No. 6: SIA/MH/IND/61703 Type: EC

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 61703 for prior
Environmental Clearance for Development of a Scientific Landfill under category 7(i) B
Common Municipal Solid Waste Management Faciltiy as per provisions of the EIA
Notification, 2006 amended from time to time and appraised in the SEAC-1 committee.
PROJECT DETAILS:
Environmental Clearance For Proposed Development of a Scientific Landfill At
Bheemwadi Village Tuppa, Nanded- Waghala by Guru Ramdas Constructions,
Nanded

Details of earlier EC if any: No

DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
After deliberations SEAC observed:-
PP remained absent.

RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:
PP remained absent. Hence deferred

CONCLUSION:
Deferred

34
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Proposal No. 7 SIA/MH/MIN/76489 Type: ToR (Violation SOP)

INTRODUCTION:
This has reference to your online application vide proposal No. 76489 submitted along with copies
of documents seeking prior Environmental Clearance under the provisions of the EIA Notification,
2006. The proposed project activity is listed at Sr. No. 1(a), Mining of Minerals category B of the
EIA Notification, 2006 and the proposal is appraised in the SEAC-1 committee.
PROJECT DETAILS:
Environmental Clearance for Stone Quarry(Area 4.85 Ha) ( Mine lease area : 3.50 Ha), at
Gut No. 137 & 140/1, Village Umbrale Bk, Taluka- Dindori , Dist.- Nashik By M/S.
Bholeshankar Metal Partners By Khanderao Chakor & Narayan Kashiyani

Details of earlier EC if any: No

DELIBERATIONS IN SEAC:
PP along with their accredited consultant M/s Manusrushti were present for the meeting.

The proposal was earlier considered in the 206th meeting of SEAC-1 wherein the proposal was
deferred for following reasons,

“During deliberation an excavation/quarrying was observed on the site from the KML files and
Google map.
In view of above observation, SEAC directed to carry out a joint inspection by the District Mining
Officer, Environmental Consultant and Project Proponent to ascertain the extent of
excavation/quarrying exists on site and permission / approvals obtained from the Competent
Authority for such excavation
The District Mining Officer shall submit an inspection report through Collector/Addl. Collector
mentioning that, no excavation/ quarrying is carried out on site in violation of EIA Notification 2006
amended from time to time.
In case any illegal excavation observed the District Mining Officer shall initiate appropriate legal
action against the defaulter.”
There after the proposal was again considered in the 215th meeting of SEAC-1 wherein the proposal
was referred to the SEIAA for guidance on violation. The details are as below,
“The proposal was appraised based on the information presented by the PP and DMO, Nashik.
During deliberation, it was observed that, quarrying was carried out on site and Environmental
Clearance was not taken by the PP.
A joint inspection report submitted by the Additional Collector, Nashik vide letter dated
13.08.2021indicating there is no excavation/quarrying carried out in violation of EIA Notification,
35
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
2006 as amended from time to time. But no copy of earlier Environmental Clearance was attached
with their letter.
The committee also observed that, PP was continuing the excavation under Temporary Permit even
the application for prior Environmental Clearance was under examination by SEAC. The details of
Temporary Permits issued to the PP are as below,

SR. NO NAME OF THE APPLICANT OFFICE ORDER BRASS ROYALTY

1 BHAGWAN GOTAN PATIL 1582/2020 dt-20-11-2020 4500 18,00,000

BHAGWAN GOTAN PATIL

2 55/2021 dt -20-01-2021 4500 18,00,000

BHAGWAN GOTAN PATIL

3 148/2021 dt -03-02-2021 4500 18,00,000

BHAGWAN GOTAN PATIL

4 351/2020 dt -16-03-2021 4500 18,00,000

BHAGWAN GOTAN PATIL

5 544/2021 dt -05-05-2021 4500 18,00,000

BHAGWAN GOTAN PATIL

6 494/2021 dt -07-06-2021 2100 8,40,000

TOTAL 24600 98,40,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
7 DHATRAK 863/2021 dt -22-11-2021 2100 8,40,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
8 DHATRAK 96/2021 dt -28-01-2021 2100 8,40,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
9 DHATRAK 641/2021 dt -14-07-2021 2100 8,40,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
10 DHATRAK 775/2021 dt -20-09-2021 5000 30,00,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
11 DHATRAK 863/2021 dt -22-11-2021 5000 30,00,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
12 DHATRAK 3/2021 dt -06-01-2022 1000 6,00,000

SHASHIKANT RAMNATH
13 DHATRAK 32/2021 dt 17-01-2022 4000 2,40,0000

TOTAL 21300 1,15,20,000

In view of above facts and figures, SEAC-1 is of the opinion that, it is the case of violation but the
Additional Collector in his report mentioned that, there is not violation of EIA Notification, 2006.

36
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
Hence SEAC-1 decided to refer the proposal to SEIAA for further guidance and decision in the
matter.”
The SEIAA considered the proposal in their 238th meeting and directed PP to apply a fresh under
violation SOP.
Now, PP submitted their application for ToR under violation category as per SOP issued by the
MoEF&CC vide Office Memorandum No. 22-21/2020-IA-III dated 07.07.2021.
As per para B (vii) which reads as below,

“…..may insist upon the Public Hearing to be conducted for such categories of projects for which
the EIA Notification 2006, as amended from time to time, requires the Public Hearing to be
conducted. “

As the proposed project is falls under category 1(a) B2 which does not attract Public Hearing as per
the EIA Notification, 2006, as amended from time to time. Hence the Public Hearing is exempted.

In the meanwhile the SEIAA, Maharashtra issued guidelines on the Terms of Reference for EIA and
preparation of Environment Management Plan (EMP) for Violation Cases in August 2022 which is
to be followed by the PP for the preparation EIA report and EMP.(Atatched as Annexure –I).
The brief details of the project are as below,
Total Area – 4.85 Ha.
Minable Area – 3.50 Ha.
Production Capacity – 1,98,796 Brasss/Year
Life of mine – 10 years
Latitude - 20°12'36.12"N, 20°12'27.73"N, 20°12'35.74"N, 20°12'26.14"N,
Longitude - 73°44'42.60"E 73°44'44.72"E, 73°44'39.82"E 73°44'37
The image shows minable and non minable area of the proposed project.

.25"E
37
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

RECOMMENDATIONS OF SEAC:
The SEIAA shall initiate action against the PP under section 15 read with section 19 as per para 10(i)
of the SOP issued by MoEF&CC on 07.07.2021.
After detailed deliberations with the PP and their accredited consultant, SEAC- decided to grant
violation ToR subject to the following conditions and as per SOP issued by the MoEF&CC dated
07.07.2021 and Annexure – I attached here with for the preparation of EIA/EMP report.
CONCLUSION:
ToR Granted with following terms

1. PP to submit detail of ownership of the area in the EIA report.

2. PP to submit their plan to utilize CER (Corporate Environment Responsibility) along
with timelines as per OM issued by MoEF&CC dated 01.05.2018.
3. PP to submit approved District Survey Report, Mining Plan, Mine Closure Plan obtained
from the Competent Authority.
4. All documents including Form I/II, approved mine plan, District Survey Report, EIA /
EMP should be compatible with each other in terms of the mine lease area, production
levels, waste generation and its management, mining technology etc. and should be in
the name of the lessee.
5. All corner coordinates of the mine lease area, superimposed on a High Resolution
Imagery/ topo sheet, topographic sheet, geomorphology and geology of the area should
be provided. Such an Imagery of the proposed area should clearly show the land use and
other ecological features of the study area (core and buffer zone).
6. Details about the land proposed for mining activities should be given with information
as to whether mining conforms to the land use policy of the State; land diversion for
mining should have approval from State land use board or the concerned authority.
7. It should be clearly stated whether the proponents/ Company has a well laid down
Environment Policy approved by its Board of Directors? If so, it may be spelt out in the
EIA Report with description of the prescribed operating process/procedures to bring into
focus any infringement/deviation/ violation of the environmental or forest norms/
conditions? The hierarchical system or administrative order of the Company to deal with
the environmental issues and for ensuring compliance with the EC conditions may also
be given. The system of reporting of non-compliances / violations of environmental
norms to the Board of Directors of the Company and/or shareholders or stakeholders at
large, may also be detailed in the EIA Report.
8. Issues relating to Mine Safety, including subsidence study in case of underground
mining and slope study in case of open cast mining, blasting study etc. should be
detailed. The proposed safeguard measures in each case should also be provided.
9. The study area will comprise of 10 km zone around the mine lease from lease periphery
and the data contained in the EIA such as waste generation etc. should be for the life of
the mine / lease period.
10. Land use of the study rea delineating forest area, agricultural land, grazing land, wildlife
sanctuary, national park, migratory routes of fauna, water bodies, human settlements
38
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
and other ecological features should be indicated. Land use plan of the mine lease area
should be prepared to encompass preoperational, operational and post operational
phases and submitted. Impact, if any, of change of land use should be given.
11. Details of the land for any Over Burden Dumps outside the mine lease, such as extent
of land area, distance from mine lease, its land use, R&R issues, if any, should be given
12. A study shall be got done to ascertain the impact of the Mining Project on wildlife of
the study area and details furnished. Impact of the project on the wildlife in the
surrounding and any other protected area and accordingly, detailed mitigation measures
required, should be worked out with cost implications and submitted.
13. Location of National Parks, Sanctuaries, Biosphere Reserves, Wildlife Corridors,
Ramsar site Tiger/Elephant Reserves/(existing as well as proposed), if any, within 10
km of the mine lease should be clearly indicated, supported by a location map duly
authenticated by Chief Wildlife Warden. Necessary clearance, as may be applicable to
such projects due to proximity of the ecologically sensitive areas as mentioned above,
should be obtained from the Standing Committee of National Board of Wildlife and
copy furnished.
14. One season (non-monsoon) [i.e. March-May (Summer Season); October-December
(post monsoon season) ; December-February (winter season)]primary baseline data on
ambient air quality as per CPCB guidelines, water quality, noise level, soil and flora and
fauna shall be collected and the AAQ and other data so compiled presented date-wise in
the EIA and EMP Report. Site specific meteorological data should also be collected.
The location of the monitoring stations should be such as to represent whole of the study
area and justified keeping in view the pre-dominant down wind direction and location
of sensitive receptors. There should be at least one monitoring station within500 m of
the mine lease in the pre-dominant downwind direction. The mineralogical composition
of PM10, particularly for free silica, should be given.
15. Air quality modeling should be carried out for prediction of impact of the project on the
air quality of the area. It should also take into account the impact of movement of
vehicles for transportation of mineral. The details of the model used and input
parameters used for modeling should be provided. The air quality contours may be
shown on a location map clearly indicating the location of the site, location of sensitive
receptors, if any, and the habitation. The wind roses showing predominant wind
direction may also be indicated on the map.
16. The water requirement for the Project, its availability and source should be furnished. A
detailed water balance should also be provided. Fresh water requirement for the Project
should be indicated.
17. Necessary clearance from the Competent Authority for drawl of requisite quantity of
water for the Project should be provided.
18. Description of water conservation measures proposed to be adopted in the Project should
be given. Details of rainwater harvesting proposed in the Project, should be provided.
19. Impact of the Project on the water quality, both surface and groundwater, should be
assessed and necessary safeguard measures, if any required, should be provided.
20. Based on actual monitored data, it may clearly be shown whether working will intersect
groundwater. Necessary data and documentation in this regard may be provided. In case
the working will intersect groundwater table, a detailed Hydro Geological Study should
be undertaken and Report furnished. The Report inter-alia, shall include details of the
aquifers present and impact of mining activities on these aquifers. Necessary permission

39
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
from Central Ground Water Authority for working below ground water and for pumping
of ground water should also be obtained and copy furnished.
21. Details of any stream, seasonal or otherwise, passing through the lease area and
modification /diversion proposed, if any, and the impact of the same on the hydrology
should be brought out.
22. Information on site elevation, working depth, groundwater table etc. Should be provided
both in AMSL and bgl. A schematic diagram may also be provided for the same.
23. A time bound Progressive Greenbelt Development Plan shall be prepared in a tabular
form (indicating the linear and quantitative coverage, plant species and time frame) and
submitted, keeping in mind, the same will have to be executed up front on
commencement of the Project. Phase-wise plan of plantation and compensatory
afforestation should be charted clearly indicating the area to be covered under plantation
and the species to be planted. The details of plantation already done should be given.
The plant species selected for green belt should have greater ecological value and should
be of good utility value to the local population with emphasis on local and native species
and the species which are tolerant to pollution.
24. Impact on local transport infrastructure due to the Project should be indicated. Projected
increase in truck traffic as a result of the Project in the present road network (including
those outside the Project area) should be worked out, indicating whether it is capable of
handling the incremental load. Arrangement for improving the infrastructure, if
contemplated (including action to be taken by other agencies such as State Government)
should be covered. Project Proponent shall conduct Impact of Transportation study as
per Indian Road Congress Guidelines.
25. Details of the onsite shelter and facilities to be provided to the mine workers should be
included in the EIA Report.
26. Conceptual post mining land use and Reclamation and Restoration of mined out areas
(with plans and with adequate number of sections) should be given in the EIA report.
27. Occupational Health impacts of the Project should be anticipated and the proposed
preventive measures spelt out in detail. Details of pre-placement medical examination
and periodical medical examination schedules should be incorporated in the EMP. The
project specific occupational health mitigation measures with required facilities
proposed in the mining area may be detailed.
28. Measures of socio economic significance and influence to the local community
proposed to be provided by the Project Proponent should be indicated. As far as possible,
quantitative dimensions may be given with time frames for implementation.
29. Detailed environmental management plan (EMP) to mitigate the environmental impacts
which, should inter-alia include the impacts of change of land use, loss of agricultural
and grazing land, if any, occupational health impacts besides other impacts specific to
the proposed Project.
30. Public Hearing points raised and commitment of the Project Proponent on the same
along with time bound Action Plan with budgetary provisions to implement the same
should be provided and also incorporated in the final EIA/EMP Report of the Project.
31. Details of litigation pending against the project, if any, with direction /order passed by
any Court of Law against the Project should be given.
32. A Disaster management Plan shall be prepared and included in the EIA/EMP Report.

40
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
33. Besides the above, the below mentioned general points are also to be followed:-

Executive Summary of the EIA/EMP Report.

All documents to be properly referenced with index and continuous page numbering.
Where data are presented in the Report especially in Tables, the period in which the
data were collected and the sources should be indicated.

Project Proponent shall enclose all the analysis/testing reports of water, air, soil, noise
etc. using the MoEF & CC/NABL accredited laboratories. All the original
analysis/testing reports should be available during appraisal of the Project.

Where the documents provided are in a language other than English, an English
translation should be provided.

While preparing the EIA report, the instructions for the Proponents and instructions
for the Consultants issued by MoEF & CC which are available on the website of this
Ministry, should be followed.

The EIA report should also include (i) surface plan of the area indicating contours of
main topographic features, drainage and mining area, (ii) geological maps and
sections and (iii) sections of the mine pit and external dumps, if any, clearly showing
the land features of the adjoining area.

41
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing

Annexure -I
Terms of Reference for EIA and preparation of Environment Management Plan (EMP) for
Violation Cases
August 2022

The following Terms of Reference (TOR) for violation cases shall be read along with Ministry of
Environment Forest and Climate Change orders no F.No.22-21/2020-IA.III Dated 7th July 2021 and
F No. 22-21/2020-IA.III (E 138949) dated 28th January 2022 and Approach for Assessment for
Environment Damage and Estimation of Remediation Costs for Building Construction Projects
Initiated Without Mandatory Environment Clearance” 2018
The following TOR are drafted with reference to Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate
Change impact assessment division TORs for Violation Case a) For Construction Sector vide
Notification S.O.804 (E) dated 14th March 2017 in the matter of IA/HR/NCP/63612/2017 and b) For
Mining Sector dated 12th November 2018 in the proposal No IA/MH/MIN/68113/2017.

A) Project Description
1. Project description, its importance and benefits.
2. Project site details (location, topo-sheet of the study area of 10 Km, Coordinates, google map, layout
map, land use, geological features and geo-hydrological status of the study area, drainage). hydro geological
survey report with graphs & data.
3. Land use as per the approved Master Plan of the area, Permission/approvals required from the land
owning agencies, Planning / Development Authorities, Local Body, Water supply & Sewerage Board, etc.
4. Land acquisition status, R & R details.
5. Forest and Wildlife and eco-sensitive zones, if any in the study area of 10 km. Any sensitive areas in
impact zone such as archaeological structures, reserved forest, noise sensitive zones etc. Clearances required
under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 and/or the Environment
(Protection) Act, 1986.
6. High Tension lines or Hazard lines if any on the plot.
7. Plan showing HFL/CRZ lines.
8. Permissions granted by State Government in tabular and chronological form. Comparative statement
of components approved and components constructed including tis configuration as per earlier EC (if
applicable) and proposed development.
9. PP to submit the detailed master plan indicating already completed construction and proposed
construction. PP to submit the certificate from registered architect for completed work, built up area and
configuration.

42
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
10. Project cost shall be based on government notified stamp duty ready reckoner at time of application
including cost of land and construction including civil, MEP works, environment services, site/land
development, horticulture/landscape works etc complete

B) Base Line Data

11. Baseline environmental study for ambient air (PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOx & CO),water (both surface and
ground), noise and soil for one month (except monsoon period) as per MoEF&CC/CPCB guidelines at
minimum 5 locations in the study area of 10 km, The collection and analysis of data shall be done by an
environmental laboratory duly notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, or an environmental
laboratory duly notified under the Environment (Protection) Act,1986, or an environmental laboratory
accredited by NABL, or a laboratory of a Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) institution
working in the field of environment.
12. Detail on flora and fauna and socio-economic aspects in the study area. Details of tree cutting, tree
transplantation and survival report of existing trees including conformity to prevailing Tree Act.
13. Likely impact of the project on the environmental parameters (ambient air surface and ground water,
land, flora and fauna and socio-economic, etc.)
14. Source of water for different identified purposes with the permissions required from the concerned
authorities, both for surface water and the ground water (by CGWA) as the case may be, Rain water
harvesting, etc.
15. Socio-economic infrastructure details including public transport arrangements on the site; PP to
mention details of socio-economic in EIA.
16. PP to submit contour map with slopes, drainage pattern of the site and surrounding area. Layout
showing natural water courses on site; total runoff calculation before and after development.
17. PP to submit details of existing trees, proposed to be cut, proposed to be transplanted along with tree
survival report conforming to prevailing Tree Act.
18. Land use of the study area delineating forest area, agricultural land, grazing land, wildlife sanctuary,
national park, migratory routes of fauna, water bodies, human settlements and other ecological features should
be indicated.
19. Proximity to Areas declared as ’Critically Polluted’ should also be indicated and where so required,
clearance certifications from the prescribed Authorities, such as the SPCB should be secured and furnished
to the effect that the proposed Activities could be considered.
20. Similarly, for Coastal Projects, A CRZ map duly authenticated by one of the authorized agencies
demarcating LTL. HTL, CRZ area, location of the mine lease w.r.t. CRZ, coastal features such as mangroves,
if any, should be furnished. (Note: The Projects falling under CRZ would also need to obtain Approval of the
concerned Coastal Zone Management Authority).
21. The water requirement for the Project, its availability and source should be furnished. A detailed
water balance should also be provided. Fresh water requirement for the Project should be indicated.
22. Necessary clearance from the Competent Authority for drawl of requisite quantity of water for the
Project should be provided.

43
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
23. Description of water conservation measures proposed to be adopted in the Project should be given.
Details of rainwater harvesting proposed in the Project, if any, should be provided.
24. Impact of the Project on the water quality, both surface and groundwater, should be assessed and
necessary safeguard measures, if any required, should be provided.
25. Based on actual monitored data, it may clearly be shown whether working will intersect groundwater.
Necessary data and documentation in this regard may be provided. In case the working will intersect
groundwater table, a detailed Hydro Geological Study should be undertaken and Report furnished. The Report
inter-alia, shall include details of the aquifers present and impact of mining activities on these aquifers.
Necessary permission from Central Ground Water Authority for working below ground water and for
pumping of ground water should also be obtained and copy furnished.
26. Details of any stream, seasonal or otherwise, passing through the lease area and modification /
diversion proposed, if any, and the impact of the same on the hydrology should be examined.
27. Information on site elevation, working depth, groundwater table etc. should be provided both in
AMSL and BGL. A schematic diagram may also be provided for the same.

C) Traffic Impact Study in detail including:

28. Traffic Management Plan for the development – Internal circulation indicating road width and turning
radius. Cross section of roads at four places showing clear road width, distance left from building line, spaces
left for plantation, footpath, service lines etc.
29. Traffic Volume Counts and Turning Movement Counts on all the external surrounding roads of the
proposed project showing the time period taken.
30. Topographic details of roads and intersection of the surrounding roads where counts are taken, actual
geometry on ground to be shown with dimensions.
31. Traffic generation values of similar development to be given by actual count by actual count as
support data for assumption made to the particular project.
32. Impact on local transport infrastructure due to the Project should be indicated. Projected increase in
truck traffic as a result of the Project in the present road network (including those outside the Project area)
should be worked out, indicating whether it is capable of handling the incremental load. Arrangement for
improving the infrastructure, if contemplated (including action to be taken by other agencies such as State
Government) should be covered. Project Proponent shall conduct Impact of Transportation study as per Indian
Road Congress Guidelines.
33. Parking statement mentioning parking as per DCR & parking provided actually.
34. Basement ventilation plan: Fire Tender Movement Plan showing clear road and turning radius. Cross
section of roads at four places including UGT, OWC and DG set location showing clear road width and
distance left from building line & spaces left for plantation, parking, service lines, foot paths, etc.

D) Environmental Impact and Management Plan:

35. Identify sources of air pollution, indicate mitigation measures to reduce Air pollution/Noise pollution.

44
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
36. Debris management plan including (a) debris required for refilling, (b) contour plan, (c) details of
site where excess debris will be disposed, capacity of the site and NOC of plot owner. PP shall also ensure
that debris disposed on other plot shall not be disposed on another plot. If to be disposed on another plot, the
same shall be carried out as per prevailing environmental laws.
37. Management of solid waste and the construction & demolition waste for the project vis-a-vis the
Solid Waste Management Rules 2016 and the Construction & Demolition Rules, 2016. Transport, collection,
storage and disposal for all types of wastes like hazardous waste, non-hazardous waste, solid waste, E– waste,
and debris/excess earth etc. PP to provide the detailed solid waste management plan along with marked
locations on the master plan. Design details of waste processing equipment such as OWC/biogas plants
confirming to the technical requirements to meet the quality products.
38. Waste water management (treatment, reuse and disposal) for the project and also the study area.
Design of all STP’s along with BOD load, oxygen requirement calculations and sizing of the tanks with
respect to the design criteria. PP to submit detailed calculation for the disinfection of the treated STP water;
PP to submit cross sectional drawing of STP’s showing dimensions and ground level; PP to provide ozonation
for tertiary treatment. PP to mark the area required for all STP’s on master layout with dimensions
39. PP to show internal storm water drain and sewer line arrangements up to final disposal point.
40. Provision of mandatory RG area on virgin land and submit the drawing with calculations, ensuring
entire mandatory RG is provided on the plot where residential buildings are proposed.
41. A detailed phase wise development plan with safety planning where occupancy has been given.
42. If any site specific structures such as creation of water body, alteration of natural storm water, large
alteration of slopes, creation of green areas abutting to water bodies / natural storm water drain / river etc, is
involved, detailed environmental protection approach for the same shall be provided.
43. Separate chapter on Renewable energy in EIA report. PP to submit terrace plan for installing solar
panels& calculations of energy saving; Energy efficient measures (LED lights, solar power, etc.) during
construction as well as during operational phase of the project. Report on ECBC compliance.
44. Provide details of Solar PV and Solar water heater in the specific format. PP to carryout shadow
analysis for identifying the roof-top area for providing solar panels Minimum 5% of the total connected load
shall be provided with Solar PV.
45. Environmental status report including analysis reports of all environmental pollution reduction
facilities if any commissioned.
46. PP to submit Disaster management plan.
47. Preparation of site specific, executable and auditable environment management plan (EMP)
48. A time bound Progressive Greenbelt Development Plan shall be prepared in a tabular form (indicating
the linear and quantitative coverage, plant species and time frame) and submitted, keeping in mind, the same
will have to be executed up front on commencement of the Project. Phase-wise plan of plantation and
compensatory afforestation should be charted clearly indicating the area to be covered under plantation and
the species to be planted. The details of plantation already done should be given. The plant species selected
for green belt should have greater ecological value and should be of good utility value to the local population
with emphasis on local and native species and the species which are tolerant to pollution.

45
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
49. Benefits of the Project if the Project is implemented should be spelt out. The benefits of the Project
shall clearly indicate environmental, social, economic, employment potential, etc

E) Environmental Modelling and additional Studies:

50. Fugitive dust modelling by using local meteorological data.
51. Ecological footprint calculation using LCA approach.
52. Estimation of Carbon footprint of the project and its analysis to be included.
53. Assessment of ecological damage with respect to air, water, land and other environmental attributes.
The collection of data and sample analysis shall be done by an environmental laboratory duly notified under
the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 or Environmental Laboratory accredited by NABL, or a laboratory
of council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) institution working in the field of environment.
54. Gate mass balance analysis for environmental parameters related to solid/liquid waste material
coming to site, waste generated and its treatment and disposal from site.
55. Public health implications of the Project and related activities for the population in the impact zone
should be systematically evaluated and the proposed remedial measures should be detailed along with
budgetary allocations.
56. Measures of socio economic significance and influence to the local community proposed to be
provided by the Project Proponent should be indicated. As far as possible, quantitative dimensions may be
given with time frames for implementation.
57. Detailed environmental management plan (EMP) to mitigate the environmental impacts which,
should inter-alia include the impacts of change of land use, loss of agricultural and grazing land, if any,
occupational health impacts besides other impacts specific to the proposed Project.
58. Public Hearing points raised and commitment of the Project Proponent on the same along with time
bound Action Plan with budgetary provisions to implement the same should be provided and also incorporated
in the final EIA/EMP Report of the Project.
59. PP to refer “approach paper for assessment for environmental damage and estimation of remediation
costs for building construction projects initiated with obtaining mandatory environmental clearance”
available on the portal : “ecmpcb.in”.

F) NOCs, Undertakings, CER and Litigations:

60. NOC’s required: a) CFO, b)Water supply with quantity, c) Drainage, d) Non-biodegradable waste
disposal, e) Aviation f) HRC, G) PESO , H ) Defence/NAD etc
61. Undertaking to provide DG set backup to all Pollution Control Devices, Water Supply, Emergency
Services including emergency lifts, etc.
62. Include condition of “maintenance of all Pollution Control Equipment’s and functioning of
Environment Monitoring Cell in PP’s MoU with society /maintenance agencies /vendors

46
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
63. PP to submit details of CER activities in consultation with the affected people in the project area as
per MoEF&CC circular dt. 01.05.2018, along with details of fund utilization & agreement or consent of
executor.
64. PP to submit Roles and Responsibilities of developer etc for compliance of environmental regulations
under the provisions of EP act.
65. Details of litigation pending against the project, if any, with direction /order passed by any Court of
Law against the Project should be given.

G) Specific Term of Reference

66. The State Government/SPCB shall take action against the project proponent under the provisions of
section 15 read in conjunction with Section 19 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, and further no
consent to operate to be issued till the project is granted EC.
67. As per extant regulations at the time of scoping, if it is viewed that the project activity is otherwise
permissible, Terms of Reference (TOR) shall be issued with directions to complete impact assessment studies
and submit Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) report and Environment Management Plan (EMP) in a
time bound manner.
68. Such cases shall be subject to appropriate
(a) Damage Assessment
(b) Remedial Plan and
(c) Community Augmentation Plan.
69. Assessment of ecological damage with respect to air, water, land and other environmental attributes
shall be done before arriving at quantum environment remediation and natural and community resource
augmentation.
70. The methodology of calculating this quantum shall be as specified in format for Assessment of
Environmental damages in the paper titled “Approach for Assessment for Environment Damage and
Estimation of Remediation Costs for Building Construction Projects Initiated Without Mandatory
Environment Clearance” 2018
71. Preparation of EMP comprising remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation
plan corresponding to the ecological damage assessed and economic benefits derived, which shall be based
on cost of project derived from prevailing rates of construction and land of government approved ready
reckoner, due to violation. The cost of the Project (capital cost and recurring cost) as prevailing in Annual
Statement of Rates / District Schedule of Rates/ Government Ready Reckoner Rates as well as the cost
towards implementation of EMP should be clearly spelt out.
72. The project proponent shall be required to submit a bank guarantee equivalent to the amount of
remediation plan and natural and community resource augmentation plan with the SPCB prior to the grant of
EC. The quantum shall be recommended by the EAC and finalized by the regulatory authority. The bank
guarantee shall be released after successful implementation of the EMP in a period of one year, followed by
recommendations of the EAC and approval of the regulatory authority.

47
 Minutes of 230th meeting of SEAC-1 (Day-2)
Date: 27th to 28th October, 2022
Venue: Through Video Conferencing
73. The collection and analysis of data shall be done by an environmental laboratory duly notified under
the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, or an environmental laboratory accredited by NABL, or a laboratory
of a Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR) institution working in the field of environment.
74. The remediation plan and the natural and community resource augmentation plan shall be prepared
as an independent chapter in the EIA report by the accredited consultants.
75. It should be clearly stated whether the proponent if it is a Company has a well laid down Environment
Policy approved by its Board of Directors? If so, it may be spelt out in the EIA Report with description of the
prescribed operating process/procedures to bring into focus any infringement/deviation/violation of the
environmental or forest norms/ conditions? The hierarchical system or administrative order of the Company
to deal with the environmental issues and for ensuring compliance with the EC conditions may also be given.
The system of reporting of non-compliances / violations of environmental norms to the Board of Directors of
the Company and/or shareholders or stakeholders at large, may also be detailed in the proposed safeguard
measures in each case should also be provided.
76. Besides the above, the below mentioned general points are also to be followed:
a) All documents to be properly referenced with index and continuous page numbering.
b) Where data are presented in the Report especially in Tables, the period in which the data were
collected and the sources should be indicated.
c) Project Proponent shall enclose all the analysis/testing reports of water, air, soil, noise etc. using the
MoEF&CC/NABL accredited laboratories. All the original analysis/testing reports should be
available during appraisal of the Project.
d) Where the documents provided are in a language other than English, an English translation should be
provided.
In case of continued violation after issue of TOR, the ToR/Environmental Clearance shall be
terminated forthwith.

48