Annex 4 Technical Guideline of FS
Annex 4 Technical Guideline of FS
Technical Guideline
1
Contents
4. Topographical survey
4.1 Collection of existing topographical maps
4.2 Topographical survey and mapping for preliminary design
4.3 Longitudinal river profile survey
4.4 River cross-section survey
7. Recommended Project
7.1 Project description
7.2 Preliminary Design
7.3 Construction Plan and Implementation Schedule
7.4 Project Cost
2
Technical Guideline on Feasibility Study
4. Topographical survey
4.1 Collection of existing topographical maps
The Project Developer shall collect existing topographical maps of 1/100,000 and 1/50,000-scale covering
the hydropower facilities of dam, waterways, powerhouse and transmission lines as well as drainage areas
and temporary facilities such as access roads, camp facilities, borrow areas, quarry sites and resettlement
areas. The above topographical maps of 1/100,000 and 1/50,000-scale are used only for identification of the
locations of project facilities including temporary facilities. Detailed topographical maps are required for
preparing preliminary designs as stated in 3.3.2.
・ 1/5,000 map to cover the project facilities including dam, waterways, and powerhouse, access
roads, and camp facilities, quarry sites, borrow areas and resettlement areas.
・ 1/10,000 map to cover inundated areas by dam and/or weir, and transmission line
・ 1/500-1/1,000 map to cover the above-ground structures of power facilities such as dam, weir,
open channel, head tank and powerhouse
The Project Developer shall also investigate and study the river profile, i.e. “river-bed slope”, with
topographical maps of more than 1/50,000 scale in order to verify that potential heads of the river are
effectively utilized by both existing and planned hydropower projects, and then shall prepare the river
profile of main river and its tributaries indicating locations of existing and planned hydropower
projects.
3
Developer shall conduct river cross section surveys for the downstream areas at appropriate intervals
in order to identify the inundated area due to the hydropower project.
Prior to the use of measured rainfall and runoff data for FS, the Project Developer shall validate the
consistency and reliability of the measured data through statistical approaches. If they are found to be
inappropriate, the Project Developer shall identify the reasons of inappropriateness and eliminate them
from the data series or correct them by reasonable methods.
4
sites for not less than 10 years, preferably 20-30 years, through the following methods and their
combinations of hydrological analysis.
(1) Ratio of catchment areas between dam and gauging station (s) in the same river basin on
condition that their drainage areas have similar rainfall patterns and amounts through a year
It is noted that the ratio of catchment area of dam site to that of gauging station is preferably
several times.
The Project Developer shall process the monthly, weekly or daily runoff data at the main dam site or
intake weir site and prepare a flow duration curve for run-of-river development project or a mass curve
for reservoir development project.
5
5.6 Flood analysis
Flood analysis is carried out to estimate flood flows at a proposed dam site. These flood estimates are
required for the design of dam/spillways and diversion facilities. The inflow design flood shall be
carefully determined through various approaches and considerations. Dam failure might cause
tremendous damage against downstream area such as loss of life and economic loss. “Inflow Design
Flood” for dam and spillway is specified in Article 17 of LEPTS as below taking care of hazard
potential against downstream area of the dam.
On the other hand, design flood at dam site during construction is determined by the Project Developer
based on probable flood discharge for T- year returns period in consideration of dam type,
construction plan and schedule, river diversion method and construction cost.
The Project Developer shall estimate “Probable Maximum Flood (PMF)” and “Probable Floods for
various return periods up to 10,000 year” by using available measured meteorological and hydrologic
data, and MEM shall determine “Inflow Design Flood” for dam and spillway according to the dam
classification specified in Article 17 of LEPTS.
Impact on economy,
Dam classification Loss of life Inflow design flood
society & environment
High Large increase Excessive increase PMF
Significant Some increase Substantial increase Between PMF & 1000-year flood
Low No increase Low increase Between PMF & 100-year flood
PMF Hydrograph
6
The Project Developer shall identify rainfall gauging stations in/around the concerned river basin and
select the stations of which records are used for Depth-Area analysis to obtain the area reduction factor
for estimating a mean rainfall over the river basin. In general, the relation between point rainfall depth
and basin mean rainfall depth is expressed by an exponential equation below, known as Horton’s
equation.
Pb = P0 * exp[-kAn]
The Project Developer shall carry out Depth-Duration analysis by collecting hourly rainfall records
during storms and estimating the hourly rainfall hyet-graph of heavy rainfall storm. When there are no
hourly rainfall records in/around the river basin, the Project Developer shall install a self-recording
rain gauge in the river basin and collect the hourly rainfall records.
The Project Developer shall estimate the PMP through appropriate methods by using available data.
The following methods are generally used for hydropower projects. It is advisable to estimate the PMP
by more than two (2) methods.
・ Theoretical approach in terms of the physically maximum moisture content by using temperature,
humidity, dew points and wind velocity/direction
・ Statistical approach which was developed by Hershfield and standardized by WMO in 1986
・ Historical approach by examining historical maximum rainfall storms ever occurred in the
concerned area
・ U.S. Weather Bureau method for the Lower Mekong River Basin to estimate “generalized PMP”
with little meteorological and hydrological data
The Project Developer shall construct unit hydrograph(s) by an appropriate methods including SCS1
dimensionless unit hydrograph method, construct the PMP hydrograph(s) and estimate the peak
discharge of PMF.
1 SCS: Soil Conservation Service (USA), now Natural Resources Conservation Center (NRCS)
7
5.7 Backwater analysis of the reservoir during flood time
The Project Developer shall carry out a backwater analysis of the reservoir during inflow design flood
in order to access impacts of the reservoir water level rising in the upstream area including local
villages, cultivated lands and existing structures like bridges and roads.
In case serious impacts are anticipated during inflow design flood, the Project Developer shall prepare
safe-guard plans to mitigate and alleviate those impacts.
Sediment phenomena progresses and it reduces effective storage capacity between HWL and LWL as
shown below. It is assumed that the sediment is deposited horizontally under the LWL. The LWL is
determined in consideration of sediment volume and the sedimentation level and required
water depth for the intake under the LWL. When the huge amount of reservoir sediment is
estimated and power generation might be effected in spite of appropriate countermeasures, the Project
Developer shall simulate a sediment configuration in the reservoir through mathematical analysis in
order to estimate an actual sediment profile.
8
The Project Developer shall estimate the sediment volume deposited during 100 years after the dam
completion through the two (2) different methods below.
Calculate annual
suspended load & bed load
Trap efficiency of
the reservoir
9
6. Geological, seismic and Construction Material Survey
The Project Developer shall collect data and information on geology, seismicity and construction
material covering the project area in order to 1) figure out geological conditions of the drainage area,
dam site and waterway route, 2) study the reservoir water-tightness, 3) to identify possible landslide
areas, 4) identify possibility of earthquakes and 5) study the availability of construction material such
as dam embankment, concrete and aggregates.
・ 1/5,000 geologic maps: the project area including dam, waterway, powerhouse, access roads for
construction, quarry sites, borrow areas, temporary facilities and resettlement areas.
・ 1/5,000-1/10,000 geologic plan: dam and reservoir area
・ 1/5,000-1/10,000 geologic profile: dam and reservoir area
・ 1/1,000-1/2,000 geologic plan and sections: dam and other power structures
・ 1/5,000 geologic sections: quarry sites and borrow areas
Geologic surface reconnaissance shall observe and identify geologic and morphologic features on
geological outcrops, overburdens and morphology as below;
Geological outcrops
・ Lithofacies including type of bedrocks, distribution of the stratum, joint pattern,
characteristics of bedding and schistose planes and geologic ages
・ Lithologic characters including hardness of bedrocks, conditions of weathering and alteration,
conditions of crack/joint and remarkable phenomena such as secondary deposit and cavity
・ Geologic structure including folding structure, faults, surface water and underground water
Overburden
・ Type of deposit, genesis, characteristics, distribution and vegetation
Morphology
・ Valley configuration
・ Flat surface configuration
・ Particular or unusual topography as karst, landslide and fault valley
10
6.1.4 Geophysical prospecting
The Project Developer shall conduct geophysical prospecting such as seismic prospecting, electric
prospecting, gravity prospecting and magnetic prospecting in order to identify the underground
geologic and hydrologic structures. Seismic prospecting is a most generally method used for
hydroelectric power projects.
The length of prospecting lines shall be at least five (5) times longer than the depth to be prospected.
Prospecting results shall be compared with drilled cores collected from drillholes located at
intersecting points of prospecting lines and/or along the lines.
The Project Developer shall keep utmost technical efforts for full core recovery and store the
recovered cores into specified core boxes. Through the drilled core observation, the Project Developer
shall prepare drillholes’ logs to describe the following items.
Depending on actual geologic and topographic conditions, the number of drillholes at dam site is
generally as below.
・ Dam height ≤ 50 m :
Total 5 drillholes including 3 holes at river bed & 2 holes at both river banks
The depth of drillholes at dam site is generally the same as dam height, depending on actual geological
condition.
The Project Developer will carry out permeability tests, seismic prospecting and horizontal loading
test by using drilled holes.
When seasonal ground water levels in dry and rainy seasons are key factors for the design of dam and
other structures, the Project Developer shall monitor groundwater levels in the drillholes through a
year.
11
・ Specific gravity/absorption test, ultra-sonic wave test
・ Unconfined compression test, Splitting tensile strength test, tri-axial compression test
The Project Developer shall confirm whether fly ash used for RCC dam and other concrete structures
will satisfy required qualities. If not, unsatisfied qualities of the fly ash shall be improved or modified
through appropriate measures.
The Project Developer shall investigate potential quantities at candidate quarry sites by geological
maps, geologic surface reconnaissance, seismic prospecting and drillholes in order to confirm whether
they have enough volumes of aggregates required for the project.
12
・ Pervious and semi-pervious material: specific gravity test, water absorption test, grain size
distribution test, uniaxial compression test
・ Impervious material: natural water content, specific gravity test, liquidity/inelastic limit, grain
size distribution test, compaction permeability test, triaxial compression test
7. Recommended Project
7.1 Project description
The Project Developer shall provide detail features and descriptions on a recommended project
scheme in accordance with the results of alternative study and optimization study. Required items of
project descriptions are listed below.
(1) Reservoir: catchment area (km2), annual basin rainfall (mm), annual mean runoff (million m3),
reservoir surface area (km2) at HWL, High Water Level (EL.m), Low Water Level (EL.m), gross
reservoir capacity (million m3), effective reservoir capacity (million m3), available draw-down depth
(m)
(2) Main dam: dam type, dam height (m), dam crest length (m), dam width (m), dam volume (m3)
(3) Auxiliary dam: dam type, dam height (m), dam crest length (m), dam width (m), dam volume (m3)
(4) Intake dam/weir: catchment area (km2), annual basin rainfall (mm), annual mean runoff (million
m3), intake water level (EL.m), dam type, dam height (m), dam crest length (m), dam width (m), dam
volume (m3)
(5) Spillway: inflow design flood (m3/sec), type of spillway gate, number and size of spillway gates
(6) Power intake: location and type of power intake, type of intake gate, number and size of intake
gate
(7) Headrace/Tailrace tunnel: number of tunnels, length and diameter of tunnels (m)
(8) Headrace/Tailrace channel: number of channels, length and size of channels (m)
(10) Penstock: number of penstocks, type of penstocks (tunnel or exposed), material of penstocks,
length and diameter of penstocks (m)
(11) Power plant: design power discharge (m3/sec), rated head (m), plant capacity (MW), power
supply for domestic use and/or export (MW), annual power generation (Gwh), type of powerhouse
(open or underground), size of power house (m)
(12) Turbine: type of turbines, number of turbines, rated output (MW)/rated head (m)/rated speed
(rpm) of turbines
(13) Generator: type of generators, number of generators, rated output (MVA)/rated speed (rpm) of
generators, power factor of generators
(14)Transformer: type of transformers, number of transformers, voltage ratio (kV), rated capacity
13
(MVA) of transformers
(17) Access road/bridge: length and width of permanent access road/bridges (m)
(19) Environmental/ecological flow: flow discharge (m3/sec), discharge method, length of recession
area of the river (km)
(20) Economy: total project cost (million USD), unit cost (USD/kw), EIRR, FIRR
When the hydropower project is planned to locate its dam at the Mekong mainstream in the Lower
Mekong Basin, this preliminary design shall be in compliance with the document “Preliminary Design
Guidance for proposed mainstream Dams in the Lower Mekong Basin (Mekong River Committee,
2009 August) in order to prevent any social and environmental impacts or other potential risks in the
four MRC member countries. The impacts and risks are particularly with respect to navigation,
fisheries, sediment transport and river morphology, water quality and aquatic ecology, and safety of
dams.
For the preliminary design the Project Developer shall study the following points for respective
facilities, but not limited to.
Main dam and auxiliary dams: its location in topographical and geological/geotechnical points of view,
alternatives of dam types, availability of dam body materials, foundation treatment including gallery
and grouting, method of river diversion, floods during construction, instrumentation during
construction and after completion
Intake dam/weir: its location for placing intake and settling basin, geological/geotechnical condition,
access for maintenance
14
Spillway: its location and types, cavitation during discharging, operation rule of spillway gates during
floods, downstream effects during discharging,
Intake: its location and alignment not to breathe air or flow in whirls, flow capacity and velocity,
structure types, geological and geotechnical conditions
Headrace/Tailrace: its alignment, flow capacity and velocity, structure types, geological and
geotechnical conditions for tunnel, lining pattern for tunnel, landslides and/or flush floods for headrace,
maintenance after completion
Head Tank/Surge Tank: its location, structure types, tank capacity, geological and geotechnical
conditions, access for maintenance
Penstock: its alignment, materials of penstock pipes, flow capacity and velocity, structure types,
geological and geotechnical conditions, installation method of penstock pipes, access for maintenance,
instrumentation after completion
Powerhouse: its location, geological and geotechnical conditions, safety against floods during
construction and after completion, cavern stability and supporting design of underground powerhouse,
installation method of turbine and generators, regulating pond/dam downstream, warning system at the
time of power discharging
Reservoir: flood management system including rainfall/inflow monitoring method, discharge process
and measures from spillway, warning system to downstream communities, environmental discharge,
reservoir operation rule, water sharing rules between power, irrigation, industrial water, navigation and
tourism
Others: capacities of disposal areas and its utilization after completion, utilization plan of temporary
facilities’ areas after completion, utilization and plantation plans of borrow areas and quarries,
resettlement plans, tree trimming plan in the reservoir area before impounding the reservoir
・ To select the type, shape, size and number of hydraulic gates and valves
・ To select the type of hoisting device of hydraulic gates
・ To determine operating conditions of hydraulic gates and valves in normal and emergency cases
According to Chapter 3 of LEPTS the Project Developer shall design turbines, generators, main
transformers and their auxiliary facilities, followed by the preparation of drawings presenting layout
plans of electrical facilities at power station and substation.
Environmental conditions shall be carefully studied and adequate countermeasure shall be provided.
Major items to be concerned are as follows;
15
・ Vibration and noise from turbine/generator and transformers.
・ Oil/water separation system for turbine/ generator and transformer.
・ Firefighting system for the necessary place,
・ Indoor type “Vacuum Circuit Breaker (VCB)” for medium voltage,
The Project Developer shall prepare general arrangement and single line diagram for the power station
in view of technical, economical, energy conservation and reliable points as below:
・ Applicable standard: IEC and/or LEPTS
・ Number and capacity of generators
・ Synchronous generator [kVA], [V], [SCR] with pf=0.8
・ Selection of transmission line voltage
・ Communication method of “Remote Terminal Unit (RTU) for SCADA” with Load Dispatching
Center (LDC)
・ Building code or standards of Lao PDR for powerhouse?
・ Safe and easy operation and maintenance?
16
・ Safe and easy operation and maintenance?
According to Section 3-5 “Transmission Lines” of LEPTS, the Project Developer shall select overhead
conductors, supporting structures, etc. considering design manual of transmission system of EDL.
In case the hydropower project will be linked to the national grid of Lao or neighboring countries, the
PD shall conduct the power system analysis in order to confirm reliability, power flow and short
circuit current.
17
・ Transportation conditions of roads and bridges near the project area
・ Electricity for construction including availability of existing power transmission lines near the
project area
・ Preparatory works including access roads, temporary bridges and distribution lines for the
construction
・ Temporary facilities including camps, concrete plant, turbid water treatment plant, steel
processing yard, parking lots for construction equipment, warehouses, and other facilities
・ Civil works of dam, waterway, powerhouse, etc.
・ Electro-mechanical works of turbines, generators, transformers and auxiliary equipment
・ Hydro-mechanical works of gates, valves and steel penstocks
・ Transmission line works
・ Resettlement works
・ Environmental mitigation works and safe-guard measures works
All main milestones and risks shall be clearly identified and addressed; in addition, the critical path
shall be indicated in the construction schedule. Main milestones are summarized below, but not
limited to.
The Project Developer shall describe clearly 1) how the above respective cost items are estimated and
2) how the unit costs are derived,.
The Project Developer shall also prepare the disbursement schedule of the project cost according to the
construction schedule stated in 7.3.2 Construction Plan and Schedule.
18
Cost Item Work Item
1. Base Cost
1.1 Development cost Feasibility study, Basic design & Detail design prior to
construction
1.2 Preparation works & temporary Access roads, temporary bridges, distribution lines for
facilities the construction, camps, concrete plant, turbid water
treatment plant, steel processing yard, parking lots for
construction equipment, warehouses, and other faciliti
1.3 Land acquisition & compensation Cost for land acquisition, land lease and compensation
for local villages and local people during construction
as well as during operation
1.4 Safeguarding works Environmental mitigation works to safeguard the
environment to be affected by the project
1.5 Civil works Main dam, auxiliary dam, spillway, intake weir/dam,
sediment settling basin, intake, headrace
tunnel/channel, surge tank/head tank, penstock,
powerhouse, tailrace tunnel/channel, outlet
1.6 Hydro-mechanical equipment Hydraulic gates, high pressure valves and trash-racks
such as spillway gate, intake gate, sediment flush gate,
draft gate, outlet gate, fish-way gate, navigation lock
gate, conduit valve, outlet valve, trash-racks, steel
penstocks
1.7 Electro-mechanical equipment Turbines, generators, transformers and auxiliary
equipment
1.8 Transmission and distribution line Transmission line, distribution line, steel tower
works structures, electricity concrete poles
1.9 Administration cost Administration cost for headquarter and site office
1.10 Engineering service cost Construction drawings and construction supervision
1.11 Physical Contingency Unexpected increase of work volume/quantities
19