Systems Analysis
Systems Analysis
Introduction
System development involves identifying business requirements and developing information
systems that will effectively help to support the day-to-day operations & decision-making
processes in an organization.
Definition of a System
A System is a set of organized components which interact in a given environment and within
a specified boundary to achieve collective goals & objectives that are emerging.
A System is a set of items, equipments, procedures, processes, techniques, programs &
people working jointly with an aim of achieving common goals.
Examples of systems are:
Education (school) system.
Transport system.
Bicycle system.
Banking system, etc.
A system is made of various components. Once the components come together, they become
interrelated to each other and generate new goals and objectives, and as such, a system breaks
down when any of its components is removed.
E.g., a Bicycle system has all the components working together to provide motion when
ridden. The individual components cannot provide these services to a rider when on their
own.
A system does some useful job; hence, it should be active & efficient, e.g., a Banking system
deals with money.
Description of a System
A system can be described as either being Soft or Hard.
Soft systems:
These are usually the human activity systems.
They are described as soft because of 3 main reasons;
1. Their boundaries keep on changing.
2. Their goals & objectives usually conflict, and may not be captured clearly at any one given
time. This is because; they are based on human factors such as attitudes & preferences.
3. It is difficult to clearly define their exact measures of performance.
Examples of soft systems:
i). A Political system: - it is very difficult to come up with a system that will predict the
political mood in a country over a given period of time.
ii). A sales tracking & prediction system in an organization: - sales in an organization depend
on human factors such as attitude in the market place.
Hard systems:
These are systems whose goals & objectives are clearly defined, and the outcomes from their
processes are predictable and can be mode led accurately.
Hard systems are based on proven scientific laws such as mathematical formulas or Engineering
solutions.
-1-
Example of a hard system:
i). Stock management system in a supermarket: - it is possible to know exactly the stock
levels, cost, selling price, and to predict accurately the profit if all the stock is sold.
Note. A good system should have features of both soft & hard systems, e.g., a stock
management system should be able to show when the demand for a certain item rises so that a
decision can be made on when to buy more stock. Similarly, new demand is driven by soft
aspects in people’s lives such as attitude & seasons.
2). Purpose
A system must be designed to achieve a specific predetermined objective, e.g., one main
objective of a school system is to enable the students to excel in national examinations.
The objectives that a system is supposed to achieve will enable the system developers
measure the performance of the system during its operation.
4). Sub-systems
Each system is made up of different components (or other systems) that communicate with
each other. These systems are described as Sub-systems.
This means that, a system does not exist alone, but it is composed of subsystems, which are
also made up of other subsystems.
Example;
The Classroom system is part of a School system, which is a subsystem of the Ministry of
Education. The Ministry of Education is part of the Government, while the Government is
part of the Global system.
Therefore, every system is a component of a larger system.
-2-
5). Inputs & outputs
A system communicates with its environment by receiving inputs & giving outputs.
Example;
A manufacturing firm can be considered as a system that gets inputs in form of raw
materials from the environment and transforms them into finished products (outputs), which
are released into the environment.
6). Process
A system will usually transform data from one state to another.
Usually, after the raw data is collected & prepared into a form suitable for input, it is then
manipulated into information using the given procedures or instructions. The processing
may be manual, clerical, electro-mechanical or automatic to obtain the information.
Example;
A motor vehicle manufacturing company is expected to produce several vehicles per day. If
the demand increases, the feedback will show that the company is underperforming.
Control signals can then be issued to speed up the movement of units on the Assembly line
so as to increase production.
-3-
Open and Closed systems
A system can be described as being open or closed.
Open systems:
An Open system is that which interacts and communicates with its environment constantly. It
receives inputs from & gives output to the environment.
Examples of open systems;
Business organizations.
Information systems.
Open systems normally adapt to changes in the environment, e.g., for any business
organization to exist, it must be able to adapt to the changing market prices, competition, etc.
An open system has an unlimited scope when providing the services of the organization.
In an open system, relevant variables keep on interacting.
An open system is generally flexible & abstract.
Closed systems:
A Closed system is that which does not interact or communicate with its environment. It does
not communicate to or receive communication from its environment.
Closed systems do not receive inputs or give output to their environment.
A closed system can correct or control itself; hence, it does not obtain modification from its
environment.
A closed system has a limited scope when providing the services of the organization.
The variables in a closed system are self-contained.
A closed system is rigid & mathematical.
Example of a closed system;
A computer Program. It accepts previously defined inputs, processes them & gives
previously defined outputs.
Revision Questions.
1. What do you mean by a System?
2. Differentiate between soft systems and hard systems.
3. List five characteristics of a system.
4. Explain the term system boundary.
5. a). What is system Control?
b). Why do we need feedback in a system?
c). Draw a well-labelled diagram that shows a system that is controlled through feedback.
6. Distinguish between open and closed systems.
-4-
INFORMATION SYSTEMS
System Design:
System design is the activity that involves identifying possible solutions to a problem, and then
deciding on the most appropriate system to solve the problem.
System design is concerned with the design of a computerized application based on the facts
disclosed during the Analysis stage.
-5-
In system design, the nature & contents of inputs, files & outputs are formulated and described in
order to show how they are connected by processing procedures, and for the purpose of
developing a new (or, an improved) system.
Revision Questions.
1. Define the following terms:
i). Information system.
ii). Online analytical processing.
2. State and explain three purposes of Information systems in organizations.
3. Highlight three circumstances that necessitate the development of new information systems.
4. List down four roles of an Information system analyst.
Traditional approach.
In the Traditional approach, there is no formal documented methodology to be followed by all
system developers in the organization.
The method relies mostly on the skills & experience of the individual members carrying out the
project development.
Disadvantage of traditional approach.
i). The structure of the old system is not changed in anyway; hence, the weaknesses of the old
system are not corrected, and are carried forward to the new system.
Example;
In a Bank, a manual system is characterized by long queues & poor controls. If the
Traditional approach is used, each Cashier will simply be given a computer. The long
queues might remain and lack of controls increase because no value was added to the old
information system.
-6-
Rapid Application Development (RAD).
This method heavily relies on Information Technology (computers). This is because; there is
need for businesses or organizations to develop & implement information systems quickly
enough for them to maintain a competitive advantage in the market.
Advantage of RAD.
Ensures faster development of information systems, and as a result, increase production of an
organization.
Disadvantage of RAD.
The working system may be weak due to quick development, i.e., a system may be working
well but may not have the necessary inbuilt security mechanisms.
Structured approach
In structured approach, there is a defined set of stages that should be followed when developing a
system. Each stage is well documented and specifies the activities to be carried out by the
system analyst and his team while developing a system.
Revision Questions.
1. Explain three system development theories and methods.
2. (a) State one disadvantage of the Traditional approach in system development.
(b) State the main advantage of Rapid Application Development method.
-7-
SYSTEM DEVELOPMENT LIFE CYCLE
The stages of developing a system are called the System development life cycle (SDLC).
The 7 main stages in system development include:
1. Problem recognition and definition.
2. Information gathering.
3. Requirements specification.
4. System design.
5. System construction (coding).
6. System testing and implementation.
7. System review and maintenance.
The following diagram represents the 7 stages, which must be followed in the system
development life cycle: -
Information gathering.
System Design.
Problem recognition
Problem recognition is done during the Preliminary investigation. A preliminary investigation
is carried to find out if really there is need for change.
During the problem recognition stage, the system analyst seeks to answer two questions:
1. Is the proposed project worth looking at?
2. Is the project worth pursuing?
After this, the system analyst then defines the scope of the project and tries to establish the
limitations (risks involved), the budget (i.e., cost, resources/manpower involved) & time
involved.
Some of the most common limitations are:
Lack of finance, and lack of appropriate technology (expertise) to develop the system.
-8-
Problem definition (Problem analysis)
Problem definition is the process of identifying & understanding the problem, and finding out
any limitations that may limit the solution.
At this stage, the system analyst is required to find out much about the existing system (whether
manual or computerised) in order to come up with a good & relevant proposal for the new
system.
A special study called a feasibility study is carried out. A Feasibility study is a study carried out
to establish the costs & benefits of the proposed new system.
The study tries to;
1. Justify the new system in terms of the capital to be employed, equipments required,
personnel, and the procedures necessary for the new system.
2. Determine whether the existing system, be it manual, mechanical or computerized, is
adequate, or it should be modified, updated or replaced.
The feasibility of a system is accessed in 4 ways: -
1). Technical feasibility.
This tries to establish whether the existing technology can be developed (upgraded) or is
sufficient to support the new system.
It also tries to find out whether the staff has relevant technical skills to develop & use the
new system.
2). Economic feasibility.
Economic feasibility study tries to establish whether developing the new system is cost
effective by comparing all the costs & benefits of the proposed system.
I.e., it tries to find out whether the expected benefits will exceed the costs of developing &
operating the proposed system.
3). Operational feasibility.
Operational feasibility is concerned with the operation of the office. It establishes whether
the management, employees, customers, suppliers & other users are happy, willing and able
to operate, use and support the proposed new system.
For example;
When carrying out operational feasibility study, the analyst tries to:
Ask the users whether they accept the new system?
Find out whether the staff has the necessary skills or manpower? If they don’t have the
necessary skills, how are they going to acquire them? Do they require training or not?
Look at the kind of job assignments that will be affected.
Look at how the firm will be reorganized to accommodate the new system, e.g., office
space, comfort, etc.
4). Schedule feasibility.
It establishes whether developing of the proposed system will be accomplished within the
available time.
Note. This cost-benefit analysis study will then indicate whether the proposed system is viable
or not. Otherwise, a new system should only be developed if its benefits are more than its costs.
After the feasibility study, a feasibility study report is produced, which outlines the following:
1. Recommendations on whether to continue or abandon the project.
2. The performance of the new system in relation to the existing system.
3. Limitations & benefits expected.
4. The development plan for the new system, etc.
-9-
The recommendations contained in the report are carefully evaluated by the personnel involved
in the system study, i.e., the management, user departments, steering committee, finance
department, etc who will then decide on whether to commence a detailed investigation or not.
Revision Questions.
1. Define the term System development life cycle.
2. Outline the seven steps followed in structured system development.
3. What is ‘Problem definition’ in the context of system development?
4. Define the term Feasibility study as used in system development.
Revision Questions.
1. What do you mean by fact-finding?
2. State the objectives of fact-finding?
Fact-finding techniques
The following are some of the common methods/techniques used to collect data:
1. Document review (study of available documents or records).
2. Use of questionnaires.
3. Interviewing.
4. Automated methods.
5. Use of workshops.
Note. Before the system analyst chooses the most appropriate technique, he/she should compare
the merits & demerits of each technique. This will ensure that the technique chosen will be able
to meet all the requirements, which will assist the management in achieving its goals.
- 10 -
Document review (study of available documents):
This involves going through all the existing documents/records, which relate to the system being
investigated in order to find out information that describe the data & procedures of the current
system.
Examples of such documents are: -
a). Organizational charts – they illustrate or describes the formal structure of the parts of the
organization relevant to the investigation.
b). Reports, e.g., financial reports, review & evaluation reports.
c). Procedure manuals, formal job descriptions & job specifications – they describe how tasks
should be carried out.
d). Standard & technical manuals.
e). Strategy & policy documents.
f). Forms used within the system.
g). Backup files that the system maintains.
h). Card catalogues.
i). Receipts.
Records inspection involves studying all the manuals maintained in connection to the system
being studies. This helps the analyst understand the structure of the organization, its operation,
and history.
Advantages of documents review
1. It helps the analyst to gather basic background information about the system.
2. It assists the analyst in designing interview questions & questionnaires.
3. It helps the analyst in deciding whom to interview.
Disadvantages of documents review
1. The documents may not have been modified to reflect the current status of the system, i.e.,
they may be obsolete. This is because; documents such as organizational charts & procedure
manuals may have been documented when the information systems were set up.
2. Human systems are dynamic. This implies that, after sometime, the real system will have
changed greatly from the documented one. Therefore, reading such documents will give the
analyst a false picture of the system.
3. Documents relating to a system are usually bulky. Therefore, reading all the documents will
be time-consuming.
4. The documentation may be poor or incomplete, thus the analyst may not obtain all the
information he would require.
Observation:
This method requires the analyst to participate in or watch closely as a person performs some
activities for a period of time in order to see for oneself what exactly happens in the system.
In Observation, the analyst asks no questions. Instead, he observes the actions in which he is
interested, and records the desired information. This method gives the analyst first hand
experience about the problems and exposes him/her to the system requirements.
Advantages of observation
1. Data collected is highly reliable, since the method gives the real picture of the system.
2. Concepts or tasks that are too difficult for non-technical staff to explain in words can be
clearly observed.
The analyst is able to see clearly what is being done. He can also identify tasks, which have
been omitted or inaccurately described by other fact-finding techniques.
- 11 -
3. Allows the analyst to do some measurements.
4. It is relatively cheap compared to other techniques.
Disadvantages of observation
1. The presence of the analyst may make the person being observed perform differently (or
change behaviour) leading to wrong requirements being observed.
2. The work being observed may not involve the level of difficulty or volume normally
experienced during that time period.
3. The need to be on the site where the activities are taking place consumes a lot of time.
4. Tasks being observed are subject to various types of interruptions.
5. Some system activities may take place at odd times causing a scheduling inconveniences for
the analyst.
Use of Questionnaires:
A Questionnaire is a special-purpose document that allows a person to collect information &
opinions from respondents.
The method involves sending out forms containing questions with spaces for response to a group
of people, and collecting the forms back after they are completed. This method allows the
analyst to collect facts from a large number of people while maintaining uniform responses.
Circumstances in which a questionnaire is used for gathering information.
The questionnaires method is used in situations where:
The information to be gathered is located over widely spread geographical areas.
A large number of people are to be questioned, and the questions to be asked require short
answers, or are limited to Yes/No.
100% coverage is not essential.
Privacy (anonymity) of the respondents is to be maintained.
Note. In a situation where a large population is to be questioned, the analyst may spend a lot of
time analyzing the questionnaires. In such cases, a sample of people (who are assumed to
represent the overall population), can be given the questionnaires.
Advantages of questionnaires
1. Questions can be answered quickly, since respondents can complete & return the
questionnaires at their convenient time.
2. Use of questionnaires gives the respondents privacy; hence, there is likelihood that the
information given is sincere & real.
3. Questionnaires provide a relatively cheap means for data being collected from a large number
of individuals.
4. Responses can easily be tabulated & analysed quickly.
Disadvantages of questionnaires
1. Good questionnaires are difficult to prepare.
2. Number of respondents is usually low.
3. The respondent may not fully understand the questions because of ambiguity of language;
hence, he/she may end up giving wrong responses.
4. No guarantee that an individual will answer or explain on all the questions.
5. No immediate opportunity to clarify an unclear or incomplete answer to any question.
6. Not possible for the analyst to observe & analyse the body language of the respondents.
- 12 -
7. Questionnaires are inflexible, i.e., no opportunity for the analyst to obtain voluntary
information from a respondent.
Procedure for developing a questionnaire
1). Determine the facts & opinions, which must be collected and from whom you should get
them. If a large number of people is involved, then select a sample.
2). Depending on the facts required, decide whether to use free-format or fixed-format
questions.
3). Write the questions & edit them such that they do not offer your personal bias or opinions.
4). Test the questions on a sample of respondents, then edit if necessary.
5). Duplicate & distribute the questionnaires.
Interviewing:
Interviewing is the process of obtaining information from another party by means of
conversation.
Interviews enable the system analyst (who is the Interviewer) to collect information from the
affected individual (Interviewee) through face-to-face communication. The Interviewer asks
questions and the Interviewee responds with answers.
The analyst should carry out interviews with the relevant stakeholders in order to get views about
the current system, and gather information about the requirements for the proposed system.
Interviewing provides facts and also enables the analyst to verify the facts. It also provides an
opportunity to meet & overcome any possible user resistance.
A good interview should be planned, and should be carried out at the most appropriate time for
the parties involved.
When executing an interview, the following guidelines should be followed:
1. The interviewee must be informed in good time, and the topic of discussion communicated
accordingly to allow for adequate preparation.
2. Avoid personal biasness in your questions and perspectives.
3. Be careful about body proxemics. Proxemics refers to issues related to physical contact such
as sitting arrangement or body closeness during an interview.
At the end of the interview, the analyst should read what he/she has recorded to the interviewee
for further clarification before the final notes can be taken.
Advantages of interviews
1. An interview provides the analyst with an opportunity to motivate Interviewees to respond
freely & openly to questions. This removes the rigidity that exists in questionnaires.
2. It allows the analyst to rephrase/frame questions for each person.
3. It allows the analyst to prompt/urge for more feedback from the Interviewee.
4. It gives the analyst an opportunity to observe the verbal & non-verbal communication such as
facial expressions of the interviewee.
Disadvantages of interviews
1. It is difficult to organize interviews. This makes the method time-consuming & costly.
2. Many system analysts are poor interviewers, thus there is a possibility of failure.
3. The interviewee may not fully open up on some issues that may be personal or sensitive.
4. Interviewing may not be practical due to the location of the interviewees.
- 13 -
Automated methods:
Automated data collection is mostly used when actual data is required but difficult to get through
interviews, observation, or questionnaires.
Such data may be collected using devices that automatically capture data from the source such as
Video cameras, Tape recorders, etc.
Revision Questions.
1. State and explain four methods that can be used to gather information during system
development.
2. Identify three disadvantages of the observation method used in fact-finding.
3. Outline three disadvantages of Questionnaires
4. State two advantages and two disadvantages of the interview method when used for
information gathering.
5. Explain the concept of proxemics in interviews.
6. (a) Explain the importance of using automated methods in fact finding.
(b) Give one example of automated information gathering technique.
Fact recording:
Fact recording takes place at the same time the analyst is gathering the facts. Facts relating to
staff, operations, and processing tasks are recorded.
Fact recording is necessary because; the subsequent stage of system development shall depend
on the facts recorded, i.e., the facts recorded will form reference material for the analyst during
system design.
The various methods of fact recording are:
Procedure descriptions (narrative).
Clerical procedure charts.
Flow process charts.
Decision tables.
Grid charts.
Output requirements.
In system development, the output requirements of the new system are considered first. This is
because; the main interest from a system is information (output), e.g., the main concern of a
library management system is whether the system can generate reports on overdue books,
charges of late return, inventory reports, etc.
The output is usually in the form of reports either in the form of hardcopy or softcopy.
The following factors should be considered when designing the output:
i). Target audience: - a user report may show only the transactions to be carried out, while the
management would require a summary of the overall performance in the organization.
ii). Frequency of report generation (i.e., the time at which the output is required): - some
reports are required daily, others weekly, monthly or annually.
iii). Quality and format of information to be generated.
iv). Cost of producing the output: - the output should be at reasonable cost.
v). Mode of output & devices used for output, e.g., softcopy mode of output is produced
through the screen.
After designing the output, it should be approved by the users, the management, and other staff
within the organization who are affected by the change.
Input specifications.
Once the system analyst has identified the output requirements for the new computerised system,
he/she then identifies the input needed to obtain the relevant information from the system.
The input to the system is necessary because the contents input are used to maintain the master
files.
The system analyst should therefore decide on:
1. The contents & volume of input, and whether these contents can grow.
2. The mode of input, the devices of input selected and their suitability.
3. The format & sequence of input.
4. The nature of the system, which determines the frequency of input, e.g., for Batch processing,
the frequency would be periodical, and for Real-time systems, it would be on-demand.
After identifying all the inputs, the analyst designs the user interface by designing data entry
forms or screens.
When designing the user interface, the following guidelines should be observed:
a). Objects such as Textboxes, Labels, and Command buttons placed on the forms must be
neatly aligned & balanced on the form.
b). The size of the form should not be too small for the user to read or too big to fit on the
screen.
c). The colour of the interface should not be too bright to avoid hurting the eye.
- 15 -
File requirements specification.
This involves identifying the files required to store data & information in the system.
The system analyst should:
a). Identify the number of files that will be needed by the system.
b). Determine the structure of each of the files, e.g., will the files allow direct access? Will they
be sequential files stored on a magnetic tape?
c). Identify the attributes of the records in a file.
An Attribute is a unique characteristic of a record for which a data value can be stored in
the system database.
Note. These attributes are used when designing tables in a database, and each attribute
becomes a field in the table.
For example;
A Books table will have the following attributes/fields: Book ID, ISBN number, Title,
Author’s name, Year of publication, Date of issue and Date of return.
Book ID ISBN No. Title Author’s Name Year of Date issued Date of return
publication
- 16 -
Revision Questions.
1. Outline the four areas that are considered during the requirements specification stage.
2. Explain at least three factors that should be put into consideration during output design.
3. (a) State four factors that may be considered in order to design a good file.
(b) Define the term ‘Attribute’.
(c) Explain why it is important to consider the file backup and recovery strategies during file
design.
4. Outline the factors that should be considered when sourcing for hardware and software
resources required for a new system.
System Design
In the design stage, the analyst must come up with ways of solving the problem.
The following are some of the tools used for designing an information system:
i). System flowcharts.
ii). Data flow diagrams.
iii). Entity relationship models.
iv). Structured charts.
System flowcharts.
A system flowchart is a tool that can be used for analysing processes. It allows one to break a
process down into individual events/activities, and also display these events in a short form
showing the sequential or logical relationships between them.
A system flowchart has its own set of symbols. The following are some of the common system
flowchart symbols:
- Telecommunication link
- 17 -
Designing a system flowchart.
A system flowchart gives a summary of how particular processes are done within the business
organization.
The following are some of the important guidelines when designing a system flowchart:
1. Start by writing the title of the flowchart.
2. If possible, start drawing the flowchart with the trigger event.
3. List down the actions taken in their logical order until the process is concluded. Use few
words to describe the actions.
4. In case there are many alternatives at the decision stage, follow the most important and
continue with it. The less important alternatives can be drawn elsewhere and reference made
to them using the On-page or Off-page connectors.
After drawing the system flowchart, other design tools such as pseudocodes and program
flowcharts can be used to extract the processing logic for each module in the system before
system construction.
Revision Questions.
1. State two methods that a system analyst may use to design a system.
2. (a) Differentiate between a system flowchart and a program flowchart.
(b) Draw four system flowchart symbols and explain their functions.
System construction
System construction refers to the coding, installation and testing of the modules and their
components such as outputs, inputs & files.
The purpose of the construction stage is to develop & test a functional system that fulfils the
design requirements of a particular organization.
System construction is done by programmers.
System construction methods
To construct a system, the programmer can use the following programming techniques:
1). Use the high-level structured languages, e.g., Pascal, COBOL, etc
2). Use the 4th generation languages, e.g., Visual Basic, Visual COBOL, Delphi Pascal, etc
3). Customise & use a ready-made standard package such as a database software, financial
package or enterprise management system.
System testing
After constructing the system, it is tested by entering some test data to find out whether its
outputs are as expected.
When the system is newly developed, it can be first tested using dummy (assumed) data, while
real/live test data can be used for normal circumstances to find whether the system can detect &
report errors.
System testing is carried out in order to achieve the following aims:
To test the programs further to detect any errors. This is because; after testing the programs,
some errors might have gone unnoticed.
To find out whether the system meets all requirements specified.
To establish whether the programs work interactively as a suite of programs.
To find out whether there is a link between the clerical & computer procedures.
- 18 -
During system testing, the following details should be checked:
Files maintained in connection to the information requirements of the system.
Input to the system, for the maintenance of the existing files.
Processing tasks.
Reports generated by the system.
Controls incorporated within the system.
NB: System testing is an iterative process, and it ends only when the analyst & the other
personnel involved are satisfied that when operational, the system will meet the objectives and
the growing demands of the organization.
Revision Questions.
1. (a) Explain system testing.
(b) State the importance of system testing.
(c) Name three groups of people who are involved in system testing.
System implementation
System implementation is the process of putting the new system in day-to-day operating
environment for the users to start using it.
A system is put into use after it has been fully tested, well documented, and after training the
staff who will be involved in the running of the new system.
In most cases, the implementation phase is faced with various problems. They include:
Staff problems in the user department, e.g., in case the confidence levels are low, ignorance,
etc
Security aspects, e.g., inadequate controls, are there any standby arrangements in case of
failure, etc
Administrative problems.
The areas to be addressed during system implementation include:
1. File creation & conversion.
2. Staff training.
3. Changeover strategies.
- 19 -
Staff training
After designing a new system, all the staff affected by the change should be trained properly on
how to use/run the system.
The aims of the training are:
a). To remove the fear of change in them.
b). To convince the staff of the user department on the effectiveness & efficiency of the new
system.
c). To enable the staff to cope with the processing tasks of the new system.
The following methods of training can be used depending on the requirements:
Demonstrations.
Film shows.
Group discussions.
Lectures or seminars.
Visits.
Reference from the available documents such as User manuals, etc.
NB: The training should be well planned & the most suitable method that can meet the needs for
all the stakeholders selected. Otherwise, if the staffs are not trained properly, the system
implementation can fail leading to great loss of company resources.
Changeover strategies:
Changeover is simply how to move from the old system and start using the new system.
The changeover should be planned & effected at the most suitable time for a smooth transition to
the new system.
The following are some of the common methods/ways of system changeover:
1. Direct (straight) changeover.
2. Parallel running.
3. Phased changeover.
4. Pilot running.
Direct (straight) changeover:
Straight changeover is a complete replacement of the old system with the new system in one
bold move.
In this approach, the old system is stopped & abandoned and the new system starts operating
immediately.
This sudden change from old to new can be very inconveniencing in case the new system fails,
faces problems, or in a situation where the users have not gained enough confidence to run the
new system.
Direct changeover is likely to be used in situations where:
The users have a very high level of confidence with the system.
The new system bears little resemblance to the old.
The system is relatively small.
Personal resources are unavailable for any other method.
Advantage of Direct changeover.
1. It is usually cheap because; two systems are not run in parallel.
- 20 -
Parallel running:
Both the old & the new systems are run side by side (parallel) to each other for some time until
users have gained confidence in the new system.
Data is processed on systems in order to compare their performance, and the results are cross-
checked. The old system is only abandoned if the new system proves to be satisfactory.
Advantages of parallel running.
1. It promotes user confidence since it allows the results of the old & new system to be
compiled side-by-side.
2. It is reliable because it enables thorough testing.
3. The users are given time to familiarize themselves with the new system.
Disadvantages of parallel running.
1. The cost of operating & maintaining the two systems would be high.
2. Resources are duplicated over the two systems, i.e., extra resources have to be engaged to run
the two systems in parallel.
3. It is difficult for the staff to carry out clerical operations for two systems during the time
available, which is just enough for one system.
Phased changeover:
In phased changeover, the new system is implemented in stages, e.g., one department after the
other, while the other departments are still being processed by the old system. When each new
phase is proved satisfactory, another one is brought in.
For example;
Changing of the education system from the old curriculum to the new curriculum. Each year, at
least one class level changes over to the new syllabus.
Advantage of phased changeover.
1. It ensures slow but sure changeover, and also tends to prolong the implementation period. In
this case, users/analysts are able to learn from their mistakes.
Disadvantage of phased changeover.
1. The various elements (i.e., hardware & software) of the same system may be incompatible.
Pilot running:
In pilot running, the overall system is put into use bit-by-bit, e.g., on department basis.
Usually, data from a previous period is first run on the old system and then on the new system.
The results from the new system are then compared with the results from the old. When the new
system is considered as correct, a double sequence in one processing run may be tried to convert
the pilot run into a parallel run.
Advantage of pilot running.
1. Pilot running offers gradual change to the overall new system. During this time, the staff
gains enough experience & confidence.
Disadvantage of pilot running.
1. It is difficult for the staff to carry out clerical operations for two systems.
- 21 -
Security control measures
The data & information in an information system must be kept secure. This is because; if not
well protected, the information can be illegally accessed or disclosed to unauthorized parties.
Therefore, the system implementers must make sure that the security features built in the system
are properly configured during the implementation stage.
Revision Questions.
1. Define the term ‘system implementation’.
2. Explain three tasks that are carried out during system implementation.
3. List two main aims of staff training.
4. Define the following terms:
i). File conversion.
ii). Changeover.
5. Give an advantage of Straight changeover over Parallel running.
System review
System review is a formal process of going through the specifications, and testing the system
after implementation to find out (establish) whether the system meets the original objectives, or
whether it performs as predicted in the designed framework.
If the system does not meet/achieve the stated objectives, system development might start all
over again.
System review is conducted by the Data processing team of users & auditors. After the review, a
post implementation review report is produced, which contains recommendations on how to
overcome the problems identified during the review.
System maintenance
Once the system becomes operational, it should be maintained throughout its life.
System maintenance is the process of adjusting & enhancing of requirements, or correcting of
errors that may be detected after the system has been implemented in order to keep the system
functioning at an acceptable level.
Maintenance functions mainly involve: -
1). Correcting errors due to program bugs.
2). Changing the procedures & algorithms used to develop the original programs.
3). Adding new routines & removing the obsolete routines.
4). Hardware & software maintenance.
5). Adjusting the existing routines so that the system may adapt to enhanced functional
environments.
Reasons for system maintenance.
System maintenance is carried out to ensure that: -
i). System efficiency is maintained for the changing functional environment & requirements.
ii). User expectations are satisfied.
iii). The system caters for growth in application requirements.
iv). The system adapts to new changes in the company’s organization.
v). System operation is based on the facilities of the current technological development.
vi). External influences beyond the organization’s control are adhered to by the system, e.g.,
Government policies on taxation, allowances, etc.
- 22 -
NB: System maintenance runs parallel to the maintenance of the system documentation, i.e., any
time maintenance is carried out on the system, the documentation should also be updated to
convey the right image of the system.
Revision Questions.
1. (a) What is ‘system maintenance?’
(b) Why is system maintenance necessary?
System documentation
Documentation is the process of describing all what the analyst was doing during the system
development stages.
Documentation is done by the analyst who developed the system, and is used as a means of
communication between the system analyst & the end-users of the system.
NB: System documentation takes place throughout the system development life cycle. After a
system has been implemented, any maintenance work must be documented & the analyst
modifies or updates the system documents (manuals) so as to reflect the current image of the
system.
A comprehensive system documentation consists of the following:
1. Report on fact-finding.
2. Requirement specification.
3. System flowchart and module flowcharts.
4. Table/file structures description.
5. Sample test data & expected output.
6. Output reports.
Report on fact-finding.
At the end of the fact-finding stage, the system analyst should prepare a well detailed report that
mainly outlines:
The methods used to collect data.
The weaknesses of the current system as indicated by the collected data.
Recommendations, i.e., why there is need to replace or upgrade the current system.
Requirement specification
The report on requirement specification mainly outlines the:
Output requirements for the new system, e.g., reports.
Input requirements.
Hardware & software required to develop the new system, and also support the processing of
an existing system.
System flowchart
The system flowchart shows the overall functionality of the proposed information system.
Therefore, at the end of the system design stage, the analyst should write a report that contains:
The system flowchart or data flow diagrams that shows the processing logic of the information
system.
Any module flowchart that may help programmers in constructing the required subsystem or
modules.
- 23 -
Table/file structures description
Depending on the approach used in system construction, the report should contain file or table
structure definitions, e.g., if you customised a standard package to construct a system, details on
table structures should be well documented.
Output reports
To prove that the system is working & giving the desired result, a number of sample outputs
from various system modules should be provided.
User manual
User manuals are used to help a person use the system with little or no guidance.
The manual must contain information such as:
1. How to install, start and run the system.
2. How the system appears when running (interface).
3. How to carry out various tasks, e.g., how to include a new entry, data entry, how to modify a
record, etc
4. A troubleshooting guide, which describes error correction & how to get help when faced with
problems.
Revision Questions.
1. What is ‘system documentation?’
2. Outline some of the contents of a user manual.
- 24 -