Project Management
Project Management
Management
By
Dr Jane Handal
Unit 02: Designing a Project
Who is the project team?
The RIBA Outline Plan of Work 2013
Types of Procurement
An integrated process
All parties MUST work together for successful project outcomes,
including quality
The Project Roles Table has been designed to assist with determining the roles that are
required on a project at each stage and then deciding on the party that should undertake
them.
The first step in the preparation of the Project Roles Table is to consider the roles that are
required on a project. Unless the project is limited in its nature and scope - for example,
undertaking work up to the application for planning consent only - all the core project roles
will be required.
Good design produces better value
Cost control
How did the control slip?
1- Cost Control:
Cost control is part of the normal process of keeping a careful check to see that money is not
wasted and targets can be met. Financial and project management expertise is needed.
Although some of the tasks involved are the responsibility of the project manager during the
construction project, the client’s financial team must stay involved and keep the business case
updated. A quantity surveyor – a cost consultant who checks design against budget – or
someone with appropriate knowledge should control the cost throughout.
Cost control requires you to:
• plan required resources: people, equipment, materials and time
• estimate the cost of each resource
• record the cost plan
• evaluate costs against whole-life value
• monitor expenditure to check it matches expected costs
• monitor project changes to check they do not invalidate the cost plan
• update the cost plan as needed and co-ordinate this with the budget
and cash flow
Building budgets are usually quoted in GBP/SAR/USD per square metre. . The areas referred to
may or may not include walls, service areas, WCs, stairs and other spaces that serve the
building. To avoid confusion, all terms must be
defined clearly and used consistently and all assumptions explained. The difference
between net and gross areas, for example, must be clear in any information provided by the
design team
Building costs and other associated costs
A large part of the budget is spent on things that
are not part of the visible finished building
Typical cost per sqm of different project types and qualities
Building costs per square metre vary according to the building type. A
theatre building, with its specialised equipment and spatial
requirements, is many times more expensive per square metre than a
school or an office.
2- Value Management
This is a name for a process in which discussions or workshops held at key points provide an
opportunity to ‘brainstorm’ and see if better results can be achieved within the budget, or the
same quality provided at a reduced cost. It should not be seen as inventing ways of reducing
costs.
These discussions need to involve the whole team, including the users, and be formalised,
minuted and the opinions considered and shared to ensure any suggested new approaches
really are better than the old ones. The discussion format is a way of tapping into lateral
thinking and ideas that may develop spontaneously out of conversation. It lets the client focus
on practical issues in running the completed building and call for imaginative solutions.
Risk assessment asks ‘what if?’ questions to identify which risks are
serious and which can be reduced. It must begin early and be continuously updated as the
project progresses. In the UK, the Construction Design and Management Regulations (CDM)
make provisions for reducing some of the risks, especially to the health and safety of site
workers and the eventual occupants of the building.
Risk assessment methods are formal processes for using common sense and creative thinking
to visualise possible problems and work out ways to reduce the likelihood of them happening.
They depend on good communication, good documentation of ideas and decisions and
agreement between all concerned about how the whole process will be handled. Workshops
similar to those for the value management process can help.
Confrontation between the client and the contractor or other team members, differing
objectives, hidden agendas and unstated differences of aims in the client body or among
stakeholders can all present risks. In complex funding or shared-use situations, where a project
is part of a larger development, the objectives of the funding or partner organisations may not
be fully compatible or able to be resolved in the same time frame and this risk needs to be
managed.
Management
Risks must be carefully assessed and a management plan to deal with them should be put in
place. An appropriate sum, which will vary depending on the size and complexity of the project
and the degree of uncertainty, must be set aside to cover any associated costs. The basis for
authorisation to spend any sum set aside must be agreed. Clients and contractors will have
different objectives and need to carry out independent risk assessments.
However, each should have input into the other’s assessments and good communication
channels make this easier. Good team relationships are themselves an important way of
reducing risk.
Unit 03: Contracts
The relationships between the client and members of the external teams are defined in legal
contracts. It is of paramount importance that such contracts are simple, clear and
unambiguous. To support an integrated process, contracts should enable team-working,
motivate all parties to work together with a common aim and have the flexibility to deal
with the inevitable changes that
arise from uncertainties inherent in building projects.
Contracts define a financial relationship and they should set a framework for fair dealing
between parties. The contracts should deal with all key issues – time, cost and quality –
and determine the distribution of risk.
The following box indicates the range of issues contracts should cover but specialist advice
is essential. The selection of forms of contract should be made with the help of an
experienced person. Depending on the scale of the project, and whether non-standard
requirements are anticipated, this advice could be given by an experienced consultant or
a specialist lawyer.
.
Wherever possible, contracts should be standard, not tailored to particular projects, and the only
changes should be striking out clauses that are designed for specific either/or situations. Where
specially adapted or bespoke contracts are unavoidable, legal advice from a specialist lawyer shou
always be obtained.
In all cases clients should ensure they are familiar with and understand the terms they are
signing. Scrutinise the 'small print’!
• The Contract Documents describe, in detail, the Works that the Client wants the Contractor to
carry out, including any restrictions/limitations that apply.
• The choice of what constitutes Contract Documents depends on the complexity of the project.
Complex projects will require considerably more detailed information. Further advice on the
extent of the requirements to be incorporated within Contract Documents should be sought
from the Architect/Contract Administrator.
• If the Contract Documents include more than one document, the documents must all be
consistent with each other in terms of the extent of requirements. Having to resolve
discrepancies within Contract Documents can result in disputes and potential changes to the
Contract Price and/or the Date for Completion.
• All documents to be included in the Contract Documents are to be listed in special clause, in
RIBA building contract can be listed in item D and form part of the Contract between the Client
and the Contractor. It is very important that they are clearly identified and kept together with
the rest of the Contract.
• BOQ, Specifications and drawings, all calculation sheets and any other reports must be
essential part of the Contract documents for construction works .
Completing the Contract Details
• The Contract Details describe the specific features of the Works and are divided into two
sections:
– Main Items: general information required for most projects.
– Optional Items: additional provisions that allow for more flexibility in control of the
Works, which might be required in more complex projects. If any of these are selected, the
corresponding ‘Optional Clauses’ in the Contract Conditions will apply.
Main Items For building Contract
1-The Client and the Contractor:
2- Description of the Works and Site Address:
3- Contract Documents:
4- Contract Period:
5- Facilities:
6- Architect/Contract Administrator and other Appointments by the
Client:
7- Consents, Fees and Charges:
8- Insurance:
The following are examples of insurances that typically should be included in a contract for
building work:
– ‘all risks’ insurance, in joint names (Client and Contractor), to cover liability for damage to the
Works, products and equipment
– public liability insurance, covering the Contractor’s liability for damage to third party property
and people. This includes personal injury to third parties other than the insured’s own
employees and for damage to property belonging to third parties
– employers’ liability insurance, covering the Contractor’s liability for personal injury to or the
death of its employees. This includes employee illness or injury sustained as a result of their
employment
– professional indemnity insurance, covering the Contractor’s liability for failure to provide
advice or services of a professional standard, including design services (only required if item P
of the Contract Details is selected)
– other insurance, such as buildings and/or contents insurance, which the Parties may agree
upon that may be required for the Works.
Insurance is a highly technical subject and the wordings of policies can vary significantly
between insurers, so the Parties are advised to consult with insurance brokers in making
decisions on the insurance requirements.
13- Programme:
14- Contractor Design:
15- Required Specialists:
16-Compltion in Sections:
17- Milestone Payments:
18- Payment on Practical Completion of the Works: Select this item
if the Works will last for less than 45 days and it is appropriate to make payment
only when Practical Completion has been certified.
19- Client Acting as Contract Administrator:
20- Insurance Backed Guarantee: It is recommended that this guarantee
should cover the whole of the Works as well as defective materials and
workmanship in the event that the Contractor ceases to trade. The duration of the
guarantee should be a minimum of one year after Practical Completion has been
certified.
21- New Building Warranty: Select this item only if the Works are a new residential
building. A New Building Warranty provides insurance for some defects, inferior materials
or poor workmanship discovered after the Defects Fixing Period. The New Building
Warranty cover must satisfy the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) requirements and
should commence no later than the expiry of the Defects Fixing Period.
22- Evidence of Ability to Pay the Contract Price: This option can provide
assurance to a Contractor working with a new Client. However, it is advised that this option
is used sparingly. Evidence may be a bank reference or some form of guarantee.
Contract Conditions
• The clauses within the Contract Conditions allocate the risks of the Works between
the Parties and set out the Parties’ rights and obligations.
• The Contract Conditions support the items in the Contract Details and so are divided
into two sections: ‘Main Clauses’ and ‘Optional Clauses’.
• The Main Clauses always apply. The Optional Clauses will only apply if the
corresponding optional item is selected in the Contract Details.
Contract: the Agreement, Contract Details, Contract Conditions and all documents listed as
Contract Documents in item D of the Contract Details.
Contract Price: the amount that the Client shall pay to the Contractor for carrying out and
completing the Works, calculated in accordance with its clause of the Contract. Note: The
Contract Price may increase (or decrease) as a result of instructions given by the
Architect/Contract Administrator.
Date for Completion: the date stated in the Contract Details by which the Contractor is
required to achieve Practical Completion of the Works or a Section of the Works.
Defects Fixing Period: the period specified in its clause of the Contract Details.
Force Majeure: an exceptional event or circumstance (see its clause in the contract )
which:
• is beyond the control of the Parties
• is not caused by either Party
• neither Party could have reasonably foreseen when entering the Contract.
Practical Completion: when the Works or a Section of the Works is certified complete in
accordance with its clause of the contract.
Retention: a percentage of the amount included in a Payment Certificate that is deducted
from a payment in accordance with its clause of the contract.
Payment Certificate: a certificate that the Architect/Contract Administrator issues, in
accordance with its clause of the contract, showing the amount to be paid, how it was
calculated and the period in which the payment is due.
Confidential Information: all information relating to the Project and the Client and Architect/
Consultant’s business and affairs which either Party directly or indirectly receives or acquires
from the other Party or any representative of the other Party whether in writing, by electronic
mail or verbally and which is not otherwise already in the public domain.
Construction Cost: the Client’s target cost for the building works as specified in the Project
Brief, as set out in its clause of the Contract Details (being the Client’s initial budget), and
subsequently the latest estimate approved by the Client or, where applicable, the actual cost of
constructing the Project upon agreement or determination of the final account for the Project.
The Construction Cost includes the cost of any equipment and/or materials provided or to be
provided by the Client to the Contractor for installation as part of the Project, and any direct
works carried out by or on behalf of the Client. The Construction Cost excludes VAT,
professional fees, the cost of resolution of any dispute, the Client’s legal and in-house
expenses and any loss and/or expense payments made to the Contractor or any adjustment
for any liquidated damages deducted by the Client.
CDM Regulations 2015: the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 and any
guidance as issued, amended or replaced from time to time by the Health & Safety Executive,
which govern the management of health, safety and welfare for construction projects.
Health and Safety File: the file required by the CDM Regulations 2015, which contains relevant
health and safety information needed to allow future construction works, including cleaning,
maintenance, alterations, refurbishment and demolition, to be carried out safely.
Novation: a procedure whereby the original client and a new client transfer the Architect/
Consultant’s appointment from the original client to the new client, so that after the
Novation the Architect/Consultant carries out its duties for the benefit of the new client and
is paid by the new client.
Schedule of Services: the schedule specifying the role specifications, Services and additional
services to be undertaken by the Architect/Consultant in connection with the Project, which
is incorporated into the Contract.
Unit 04: Contract Administration
1- Pre-Construction Phase
1.1 Construction Contract Documents:
Check and review all construction contract documents and report to Client problem
areas( deficiencies, missing information …etc) prior to start of construction
activities.
2- Site Management
2.1 Mobilization Plan
Review and approve Contractor’s mobilization plan. Coordinate location of all
temporary facilities; offices; storage areas; parking; fencing; temporary signs; delivery
routes, etc.
Monitor the Contractor submittal schedules to prevent delays of the Works. Prepare
and maintain a Submittal Log.
Review and approve all samples and mock ups to ensure they conform to the required
level of finish and aesthetics and are in compliance with the Contract Documents.
Review and approve all technical data per submitted cut sheets and/or
manufacturer’s specifications to meet the performance criteria per the standards
required by the Contract Documents.
2.9 Testing
Review and approve Contractor’s proposal for provision of facilities, equipment and
procedures for testing of materials, equipment and systems in compliance with the
requirements of the Contract Documents. Review and approve the qualifications and
experience of the Third Party Materials Testing Laboratory/ Agency.
2.10 Site Cleanliness
Require that the site be maintained in a reasonably clean and orderly fashion during the
course of the Works and that site and buildings are delivered in a ready for occupancy
condition. Issue notices of non-compliance.
2.12 Close-out
Review and approve as - built drawings; O&M Manuals and all warranties and
guarantees to be in compliance with the Contract Documents.
3- Cost Control and Financial Management
3.1 Pay Application
Receive, review and verify the Contractor’s claim for completed works. Report to Client’s
Representative and advise on deductions, hold backs or back charges.
Monitor and update monthly the cumulative expenditure curve. Evaluate final accounts
and advise Client on final payments.
4- Coordination, Planning, Scheduling and Time
Management
4.1 Site Meetings
Schedule and conduct regular site meetings among all members of the construction team to
review project progress, coordination of trades, look ahead schedules and site issues. Issue
Minutes of Meeting to Client’s Representative.
Monitor that materials and equipment are approved; ordered; purchased and delivered
as required to meet the Construction Schedule Dates.
Resolve and advise Contractor on the resolution of any site related conflict or issue
recommending alternative solutions when design details or site considerations impact
cost or scheduling.
5- Site Supervision and Quality Control
5.1 Base Documentation
Verify Contractor’s site office has a set of drawings as per the Contract requirements
including all addenda issued. During the course of the project maintain contractor aware
of all revisions or changes.
Inspect the work for compliance with the Contract Documents, approved shop drawings
and specifications. Issue notices of deficiency. Check and approve corrected work.
6.2 Assist Client in enforcing the guarantees of the Contractor and in causing the
Contractor to perform any work in connection with repairs, replacement or correction of
defective work or materials.
6.3 Assist Client in closing out all contracts; give advice and recommendations to the
resolution of claims; prepare and certify final accounts and the terms and conditions of
any settlement agreement.
6.4 Obtain and review all close out documentation as required by the Contract
Documents. As built drawings, O&M manuals; warranties and guarantees, etc.
6.5 Monitor for compliance with all required training of operator’s engineering staff in the
maintenance and servicing of all systems and equipment as required by the Contract
Documents.
6.6 Monitor review and approve the commissioning and testing of all equipment and
systems in compliance with the requirements of the Contract Documents.
Provide Client with a compliance / variation report with recommendations for corrective
action on non-compliant items.
6.7 Prepare final punch lists and follow up to Contractor’s satisfactory completion.
6.8 Issue preliminary and final completion certificates. Assist Client in the handing over of
the project from Contractor to Operator.
6.9 Prepare a final report summarizing all outstanding contractual and technical issues of
the project.
Close out all files, packaging all data which should be retained and deliver same to Client
as Consultant’s archives.
7- Final Completion
7.1 Thirty (30) days prior to the end of the Contractor’s warranty period the contract
administrator schedules with the Client/client Representative and Contractor a final
project inspection (walk through) of the buildings and site.
7.2 Prepare a final punch list outlining all deficiencies to be corrected by Contractor.
Advise Client on the issuance of the Final Completion Certificate.
Variation: The term “variation” as may used in the Construction contract conditions
means the alteration or modification of the design, quality of the works as shown upon
the contract drawings and described by or referred to in the BOQ and includes the
addition, omission or substitution of any work, the alteration of the kind or standard of
any of the materials or goods to be used in the Works, and the removal from the site of
any work materials or gods executed or brought thereon by the contractor for the
purposes of the works other than work materials or goods which are not in accordance wit
the said contract.
a. An appraisal of any consultants or specialists who may have been engaged. This appraisal
should be made against the terms of reference when the latter’s work have been
completed;
a. The comments in (b) would also apply to any contractor that may have been engaged or
recommenced by the Practice;
a. A review of client’s complaints which should address how corrective action was applied e.g.
timely and effectively and if any action was taken, or could be taken to reduce or eliminate
problems;
e. A review of the quality system audits that have been carried out. This should cover an
appraisal of the audits against the planned schedule and the opportunity should be taken for a
critical look at how the Quality System operates to see where improvements can be made to
the service offered to clients. Results from project quality audits are useful in this context;
f. The identification of any pending statutory requirements which members of the
Practice need to be aware of, and that may effect the business e.g. health and safety,
environmental etc;
g. Any information derived from any project, identified as being of benefit to the
Practice.
Notes of these reviews will include actions and agreed dates for completion of actions. It is the
responsibility of the quality manager to follow up these actions to ensure they are discharged
properly.
The reviews are run by a member of the top management of the Practice, and will include the
quality manager and senior partners, associates etc. and any other personnel who have a
relevant input to the meeting.
It is emphasized that the quality management system is for all personnel and that top
management will demonstrate its commitment to the on-going success of the quality system.
1- Project Management
This procedure defines the practice adopted on receipt of verbal or written instruction from a
client to provide professional services. The procedures include review and amendment to the
commission.
The term ‘brief’ is frequently used but has two connotations. It is commonly used to signify the
statement of requirements for a project. It also applies to the terms and extent of the
commission. Both aspects of the brief are considered.
In response to a potential client's enquiry, either written or oral, the Principal confirms the
enquiry in writing.
The Principal nominates an appropriate staff member to be responsible for the project. The
nominee arranges for a commission file to be opened.
The administrator opens the file as requested with the following information recorded:
a) unique project name;
b) a unique project number;
c) date of enquiry;
d) client's name, address and contact details
The project number commences with the last two digits of the year followed by a sequential
number of 3 digits (07/012). A list of project numbers is maintained by administration.
COMMISSION REVIEW
a) The extent of the duties and scope of work are clearly defined and acceptable. The
Conditions of Appointment and terms for payment of fees are agreed with the client based
on those from the RIBA or agreed mutually with the client;
b) The statement of requirements is adequately defined and/or there exists a means for
clarifying them as the design proceeds;
c) There are no obvious ambiguities, contradictions or inadequacies in the documentation;
d) The program for the project is acceptable;
e) The Practice has adequate resources and expertise to complete the project to
program, additional resources/expertise needed to be brought in;
f) The Practice has adequate equipment available (including computer hard/software);
g) The Practices PI insurance is adequate and manner consulted over any reserved matters (eg
collateral warrantees)
h) There are no other reasons for rejecting the commission;
The Principal or nominee carries out an additional review if/ when significant changes are made
to the brief or other conditions in order to assess whether any changes to, or clarifications of
the brief during its development have affected the agreement.
CLIENT AGREEMENT
Unless the client determines the form of agreement, the Principal establishes the agreement
under the following headings:
a) Terms of reference - comprising the terms set down in the client's initial enquiry or letter of
invitation, together with any relevant comments, clarifications of results of negotiation;
c) the clients’ brief - having been checked for adequacy and completeness;
d) program - showing the extent and nature of the project, dates of all key activities,
including obligations of the client, and approval periods;
Where the agreement has been drawn up by the client, the Principal checks the details and
identifies conditions at variance with those recommended by the RIBA, taking legal/PII advice as
necessary, before signing and returning the agreement to the client. A copy of the agreement
signed by all parties is kept on the commission file.
The Principal checks the agreement for contractual completeness and definition of duties, signs
and dispatches it to the client for signature and return.
AMENDMENTS TO THE COMMISSION
During the course of the work, minor amendments and clarifications to the brief, particularly
the schedule of requirements, frequently occur. Minor changes and clarifications are discussed
with the client at regular meetings. The changes are recorded in the minutes of the meeting
and a copy of the minutes sent to the client.
Any changes agreed verbally are confirmed in writing to the client and entered into the project
quality plan.
Where these changes constitute an amendment to the terms of the commission by way of
change in scope, program or cost limits, the Principal agrees the changes with the client and a
signed record is held in the commission’s file.
SPECULATIVE WORK
When the Practice is invited to bid for work or undertakes speculative work it may not be
possible to satisfy all the requirements of normal commission review. Ambiguities or omissions
in the documentation are recorded and all effort made to obtain clarification.
Before submitting a tender, the most senior member of staff involved undertakes a commission
review, recording unresolved ambiguities and noting the potential consequences.
SIGNIFICANT CHANGES
Significant changes are those which may affect the ability of the Practice to comply with the
client’s brief in terms specified requirements, programme, capital cost or professional fees. All
such changes from the client’s original brief including those stemming from proposals by the
client, the Practice and the consultants, are agreed with the client by Principal or project
architect and signed.
The quality plan records the forms raised and the date submitted to the client together with the
date and reference of any confirmation.
All changes after completion of Plan of Work stage E, Final Proposals, are treated as significant.
RELATED DOCUMENTS
The documents referred to in this section are those which constitute the output of the Practice
.
in response to the client's brief. They are usually in the form of drawings and project
specifications. They may sometimes be reports and studies. Project documents may also be
prepared and transmitted by electronic means.
All project documents show the unique project number allotted when the commission was
accepted. Individual drawings are numbered in accordance with the recommendations in The
Co-ordination of Project Information (CPI) Code: Production Information: a code of procedure
for the construction industry.
ISSUE OF DOCUMENTS
Documents are only issued after the appropriate approval has been recorded. All documents
are issued with an issue sheet. It records the number of document and its amendment mark,
the number of copies and to whom issued. A copy of the issue sheet is filed.
INCOMING PROJECT DOCUMENTS
All incoming project documents from members of the design team (including the client, where
appropriate) not accompanied by an issue sheet are recorded including number, revision mark
and date. Each drawing/document is date stamped on receipt.
RELATED DOCUMENTS
CPI document - Production Information: A code of procedures for the construction industry;
Unified classification for the Construction Industry (UNICLASS)
VERIFICATION
Verification generally implies checking that the product satisfies the specified requirements.
In the building design process the ‘specification’ is seldom sufficiently precise and the
‘product’ so variable that the verification is somewhat subjective. However certain
safeguards are performed to ensure client satisfaction.
Design reviews - to ensure that the project satisfies the brief, the Practice standards and
statutory requirements.
Verifying data - ascertaining that the source of data is reliable. With proprietary products,
that their use has been proven and that test data is checked as satisfactory.
Project audits - to ascertain that the appropriate procedures have been used, not necessarily
that the outcome is correct.
DESIGN REVIEW, VERIFYING DATA and PROJECT AUDITS
These procedure shall be described in Design control.
The technical content of consultants’ work is the responsibility of the individual consultants.
Where a consultant is listed as generally providing good service they will follow their own
checking procedures. Where the consultant is not so listed they are asked to confirm that the
technical content of their work has been adequately checked.
The project architect ensures that the documents received are complete and appropriate to the
requirements of the consultants brief and the project.
DRAWING AND SCHEDULE CHECKING
Drawings and schedules are checked at two levels, each with a different bias:
Level a) checking by the draftsperson before the drawing is issued that the content is correct
within itself and covers the subject specified. The completion of this check is recorded on the
drawing.
Level b) checking that a set of drawings and/of schedules is complete, coherent and has
been checked against relevant drawings of other disciplines. The completion of this check is
recorded on the drawing/schedule. It makes references to other drawing schedules and the
specifications.
All drawings and schedules are to be signed as checked by the draftsperson (level a) before
they leave the office. Drawings issued before level b checks are marked ‘PRELIMINARY’.
All calculations are recorded on standard calculation sheets. Input data to the calculations is
also recorded on the calculation sheets. All sets of calculation sheets are signed by the person
performing the calculations and by the checker
CONTROL OF REVISIONS
Consultants may be nominated and employed by the client, nominated by the Practice and
approved by the client or commissioned by the Practice. In any case, where the commission
contains the requirement for project management or incorporation of consultants work into
the Practice’s work, procedures are established to ensure that the Practice can satisfy its
professional responsibilities.
LIST OF CONSULTANTS
The Practice maintains a list of consultants (with whom there is a good track record of
previous working). The consultants are vetted in accordance with the procedure described
below (see APPOINTMENT OF CONSULTANT).
The list is reviewed each year taking into account the performance of the consultants. Where
a consultant has not been used within the preceding five years, the name is removed from the
list (alternative – this is indicated on the list).
Where the use of a consultant is imposed by the client, steps are taken to evaluate their
management system. Additional safeguards in reviewing the information provided by the
consultant will be defined in the quality plan.
LIST OF CONTRACTORS
Principal Contractors are normally appointed by the client. The Practice maintains a list of
contractors in order to be able to make recommendations to the client. They are vetted in
accordance with the procedure described below (see APPOINTMENT OF A CONTRACTOR).
The firms are annotated according to the size and type of contract for which they are approved.
APPOINTMENT OF A CONSULTANT
When a consultant is required to assist the Practice in the performance of a commission, the
client is notified. The client may make a nomination or request a nomination from the Practice.
In either case the list is consulted. A short list is drawn up from appropriate firms on the list to
suit the project. Where the client nominates a consultant, that consultant is assessed and
entered on the list.
PERFORMANCE REVIEW
At the completion of each commission, the performance of each consultant is assessed as
objectively as possible and the results filed on the consultants’ file in the administration
series. The factors to be reviewed are:
a) quality and presentation of information provided;
b) co-operation with the design team;
c) ability to meet programme;
d) ability to meet cost targets;
e) ability to appreciate design intentions.
The consultant is graded from 1 to 3 according to the team’s wish to work with the
consultant in future, the highest grade is 1. This grade is noted in the database for ease of
reference.
REVIEW OF LIST
Each year the Quality manager will review the list and transfer to a reserve list (by coding in the
appropriate database field) those which consistently receive poor reports or who have not been
used for more than five years. Before they are recommended again they will be reassessed.
APPOINTMENT OF A CONTRACTOR
Principal Contractors are normally appointed by the client. The Practice maintains a list of
contractors in order to be able to make recommendations to the client. They are vetted on the
following basis:
ASSESSMENT PROCEDURE
The contractors are vetted by the Principal or their nominee on one or more of the following
bases:
a) satisfactory completion of previous project;
b) performance reports;
c) independent quality assessment
D) recommendation from other Practices;
e) inspection of ongoing projects;
RELATED DOCUMENTS
Architects are very often expected to advise on the choice of procurement method for a
client’s project. It is important that this advise be impartial from the architects own interest
in the contract and it is therefore advisable to use an authoritative source of reference as
well as experience when discussing this with the client.
The following table “Procurement – Identifying Priorities” has the advantage of providing
information that was compiled from thorough and independent research of the subject
including assessing the process and actual outcomes of samples of projects. It has the
disadvantage of being quite old and now no longer published (though originals will be
available from sources such as the RIBA Library). It therefore does not cover PFI and its
derivatives.
If more contemporary guidance is used check on its impartiality and the rigour of the
research backing the assertions made and be prepared to explain this to the client.
Also included for reference is a diagram to illustrate the principles of the likely effect on the
sequence of the of the Plan of Work stages of various procurement methods.
3- Design and production Management
RIBA PLAN OF WORK
Had been discussed in Unit 02
The consultants appointed to the project are fully integrated members of the design team
whether appointed by the client or commissioned by the Practice. The project architect
convenes a project team meeting as soon as practical after the commencement of the
project.
4. Design input that is specific to the project is recorded in the quality plan. The
source of this information is reviewed and assessed to ensure that it
adequate for the purpose.
VERIFICATION OF TECHNICAL DATA
1. All design methods and sources of design data are evaluated by one or more of
the following processes:
a) usage - regular and satisfactory use; regular reviews are carried out so that
new design methods can be accommodated;
b) status of source - for example a profession institution, recognised research
body, technical publications; this is used when incorporating new materials,
construction methods or data and is backed up with evidence of testing or the
derivation of data;
c) testing - this may be necessary when a design method or detail is applied in an
unfamiliar situation or where there is a high risk associated with the design.
CALCULATIONS
The lead sheet gives the subject and brief description of the purpose of the
calculation and records the input data and its source. Diagrams and sketches are
drawn on the sheets where possible or attached where not.
Calculation sheets and printout are checked in accordance with the checking
strategy described in Drawing and document checking.
DRAWING PRODUCTION
1. Where drawings have been revised after the first issue, precise details of the
amendment, revision letter, person making the amendment and the date are
recorded on the drawing.
1. Standard drawings for tried and tested details are to be used directly, or
used to set principles for project specific situations, where appropriate. A
list of drawings is maintained in the technical library and …..fill in title …. is
responsible for their maintenance and review based on project feedback.
PROJECT SPECIFICATION
1. NBS is a proprietary product and all procedures and recommendations for its
use applied as recommended by NBS and as in the CPIC “Production
Information; a code or procedure for the construction industry”.
1. When NBS is not used (e.g. when the type of work is not covered by the
NBS) bespoke sections are prepared from validated technical sources in the
style of the NBS and in sections as published in the CPIC Arrangement of
work sections (CAWS)
1. Where the specification has been revised after the first issue, precise
details of the amendment, revision letter, person making the amendment
and the date are recorded.
TENDER INVITATION
If requested by the client, the project architect is responsible for preparing a list of
prospective tenderers from the list of approved contractors taking into
consideration feedback from previous projects . The list is submitted to the client for
approval.
1. Some clients have their own tender procedures – adopt them where appropriate.
Possible procedures for use in the absence of client or reference to other published
procedures are the now obsolete NJCC procedures that are still followed by many
clients.
2. When tenders are returned they are held until the final date for their return in a
secure location. They are opened by the principal (in the presence of the client if
requested).
3. The project architect checks the tenders to ensure that there are no errors,
conditions or other qualifications. Should any be found they are referred back to
the contractor for correction or withdrawal.
4. The project architect schedules the tenders in reverse order of price and records
relevant comments on each. He passes them to the Principal for onward
submission to the client with a recommendation to accept.
5. Once the client has approved the successful tenderer and instructions to proceed
have been received, the project architect prepares two sets of tender documents
for signature. A meeting is arranged with the contractor and the client for signing.
First : the terms and are represented by the letters ( ) ك ب سand these include the
minimum limit of engineering standards required in design, construction, operation
and maintenance which are derived and drafted in a manner complying with the
requirements and regulations applicable in the Kingdom.
Second: the requirements and are represented by the letters (SBC) and includes
details of design and methods of construction.
1-Administrative and legal terms:
This deals with the scope of code and classification of facilities according to
occupancy and shows responsibilities of the parties concerned in the building and
application of the code. Some of these are:
• definitions
• duties and responsibilities
• use and occupancy
• qualification
• disputes
• others
1- Hourly rates
This is pretty straightforward: Architects will bill for the hours worked on the project.
Prices will differ depending on the project and the location you’re working on, but can
come in around 200 GBP per hour or higher to work with a firm’s principal.
The hourly fee can be problematic, "While we’re excited to be paid for the work we’ve
done, we always have to back down on what we charge, because the client wouldn’t
believe how many hours we spent on a project.”
A client can control the number of hours worked on a project by adding a "not-to-exceed
this amount" in their contract with the firm. Almost nobody gets away with charging
hourly without a cap.
2- Fixed-fee
A fixed-fee contract with the architect will state the set amount that they will charge.
But usually, architects will not settle for a fixed-price contract until they know exactly
what the project entails—thus, they need to charge hourly for work in the beginning
stages.
The fixed fee is typically used for smaller-scale projects. Think removing a wall or
adding a bathroom. "It’s cut and dry. Architects need to be already aware of the
scope of the project.
As for the percentage charged by the architect? It’s a sliding scale affected by how
big the firm is and the size of the project. It could range anywhere from 8 to 20
percent of the construction cost (if it is less than 5%, the architect will not be able to
deliver his task as per RIBA plan of work).
Business Planning: Business planning enables the principles in an architecture
firm to chart its course instead of reacting to situations and opportunities as they arise.
Planning begins with strategic thinking and positioning. Goals and strategies are then
translated into a business plan – a set of financial projections and operational plans
that guide the principals in managing the firm.
2- A staffing plan that defines the size and cost of the staff required to provide the
services outlined in the revenue projection;
3- An overhead expense budget that identifies the indirect costs of supporting the staff
as it provides the services outlined in the revenue projection;
4- A profit plan that establishes and budgets the profit required to sustain the firm
and allow it to meet its goals.
Revenue Projection
• Existing projects to be completed;
• Proposals that are outstanding;
• Unidentified future work.
Staffing Expenses
• Direct labour cost (hourly salary);
• Benefits;
• General and administrative
expenses (Indirect expenses
included Tax);
• Target profit.
Overhead Expenses
• Anticipated cost increase in rent
or insurance;
• Indirect labour;
• Utilities, Office Supplies, Printing,
Marketing tools, Professional
Development, legal and
accounting expenses