Akbar Yanuar Marlen - Conflict Resolution Management
Akbar Yanuar Marlen - Conflict Resolution Management
1,2
Department of International Relations, Universitas Nasional Jakarta, Indonesia,
[email protected]
1
Abstract : In recent years, the military power rivalry between the United States and China in the
Asia Pacific has attracted significant global attention. This research aims to examine in depth the
complexities, obstacles, and impacts of this competition from 2021 to 2023. By applying secondary
data analysis from various sources such as government reports, scientific articles, and international
media, the research identifies an escalation in military competition during this period . Both
countries have strengthened their military presence through cooperative exercises with allies,
reflecting improvements in military capabilities, technological advances, and diplomatic
maneuvers. Key challenges include territorial disputes in the South China Sea, political tensions,
and economic rivalries. These factors have increased the risk of military clashes and have reshaped
regional security dynamics. The impact of this competition goes beyond bilateral relations, affecting
broader security and stability in the Asia-Pacific region. Effective diplomatic engagement and
regional collaboration are critical to reducing tensions and preventing conflict escalation. This
research provides valuable insights into understanding the evolutionary dynamics of US-China
military competition in the Asia Pacific from 2021 to 2023, offering a basis for more nuanced policy
formulation to address the region's diverse security challenges.
INTRODUCTION
As a dominant power on the global stage, the United States upholds its role in
maintaining international stability. Recognizing the importance of global collaboration, the
country actively invites all countries around the world to participate in these efforts.
Through various collaborations, both in the military and trade fields, the United States has
formed strong alliances with various countries in various parts of the world. History
records that under the leadership of President Barack Obama, there was a shift in the focus
of United States foreign policy. Initially, the United States' primary focus was on the Middle
East, especially in the context of ongoing conflicts in the region. However, in recent years,
there has been a significant shift towards the Asia Pacific, including the South China Sea.
This shift in focus is not without reason. As global political and economic dynamics
develop, the Asia Pacific has become an increasingly important focus for the United States.
This region is an area with great economic potential and rapid growth. Apart from that, its
existence is also important in the context of regional security and global stability. The
South China Sea, as an integral part of the Asia Pacific region, has become a focal point of
attention for the United States in recent years. Disputes over territorial and resource claims
in the South China Sea between several countries in the region have raised tensions and
concerns about potential conflicts that could disrupt regional stability. In this context, the
United States plays an active role in efforts to maintain security and stability in the region.
The steps taken by the United States in dealing with the South China Sea issue cover
various aspects, from diplomacy to military presence. The United States has publicly
expressed its support for freedom of navigation in the South China Sea, sending a message
that it will not recognize claims deemed inconsistent with international law.(Liu, Ming,
2022)
Apart from that, the United States is also actively involved in various regional
forums, such as ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations), to discuss issues related
to the South China Sea and find solutions that are acceptable to all parties. It is hoped that
these diplomatic efforts can reduce tensions and encourage constructive dialogue between
the countries involved. Apart from diplomacy, the United States' military presence in the
Asia Pacific region is also an important factor in maintaining security and stability. The
United States has a significant military presence in the region, including in allied countries
such as Japan, South Korea, and the Philippines. This military presence is intended to
provide security guarantees for countries allied to the United States and as a deterrent
against potential threats from other parties. However, the United States' military presence
is also a source of controversy and tension in relations with other countries, especially with
China. China has criticized the United States' military presence in the Asia-Pacific region as
interfering in its internal affairs and threatening regional security. Tensions between the
United States and China in the context of the South China Sea have become one of the
flashpoints in their bilateral relations. In facing complex dynamics in the Asia Pacific
region, the United States is faced with complex challenges and dilemmas. On the one hand,
they need to safeguard regional security and stability interests, but on the other hand, they
must also pay attention to relations with China and efforts to prevent conflict escalation
that could disrupt world peace. In this context, multilateral diplomacy and dialogue are key
in finding solutions to complex and sensitive issues such as the South China Sea. The United
States should continue to strive to build cooperation with other countries in the Asia-
Pacific region and engage China in these efforts. Only through constructive cooperation and
dialogue can stability and peace in the region be maintained for the common good.
In supporting its country's military capabilities, China does not only rely on its
military strength alone, but also needs a strong economic foundation. This policy considers
strong economic stability to be one of the main pillars in building and maintaining an
effective military force. As the country with the second largest economy in the world, China
fully understands the importance of maintaining sustainable economic growth to support
its ambitions in the fields of security and defense.
China itself has emphasized that the increase in military strength is aimed at
maintaining its territorial sovereignty and security, as well as making a positive
contribution to regional stability. However, on the other hand, many parties see China's
increasing military strength as a potential threat to regional peace and security. Therefore,
constructive dialogue and cooperation between China and other countries is needed to
prevent conflict escalation and ensure stability in the region. In facing complex dynamics in
the Asia Pacific region, China is faced with complex challenges and dilemmas. On the one
hand, China needs to maintain its security and territorial sovereignty, but on the other
hand, it must also pay attention to relations with neighboring countries and efforts to
prevent the escalation of conflicts that could disrupt world peace. Therefore, multilateral
diplomacy and dialogue are key in finding solutions to complex and sensitive issues such as
the South China Sea. China should continue to strive to build cooperation with other
countries in the Asia-Pacific region and engage in constructive diplomatic efforts to ensure
stability and peace in the region.
RESEARCH QUESTION
Based on the background explained above, the author formulates the research problem.
How can United States and China's military cooperation in the Asia Pacific affect the
dynamics of the two countries' military power competition?
PURPOSE
The purpose of this research is to analyze the military power competition between the
United States and China in the Asia-Pacific region in 2021-2023, with a focus on strategic
implications for regional stability and global security. This study aims to provide a
comprehensive understanding of the complex dynamics that drive competition, including
the role of territorial disputes and military modernization. In addition, this research will
explore the potential for military cooperation between the two countries and its impact on
regional stability, as well as provide recommendations for constructive management of
competition that promotes peace and security in the Asia-Pacific region.
LITERATURE REVIEW
“The Indo-Pacific: Trump, China, and the New Struggle for Global Mastery” (2019) by
Robert D. Kaplan: This book illustrates the importance of the Indo-Pacific region as the
center of global competition between the US and China. Kaplan outlined the transition of
power and how the region became a strategic focal point for both countries.
"The Asian Century" (2022) by Parag Khanna: Khanna examines China's increasingly
dominant role in the Asia Pacific region and how this is changing regional and global
geopolitics. This analysis provides insight into China's economic and political power in
influencing regional dynamics.
“The Future of War: A History” (2023) by Lawrence Freedman: Freedman examines the
evolution of international security strategy and its implications for US-China competition in
the Asia Pacific. This book helps identify new trends in modern warfare and adaptation
strategies of both countries.
“The Security Dilemma: Fear, Cooperation, and Trust in World Politics” (2021) by Ken
Booth: This book outlines the concept of the security dilemma in international relations
and its impact on the dynamics of competition between the US and China in the Asia Pacific.
This analysis helps understand the challenges in building trust and cooperation in the
region.
"Containment Strategies: A Critical Assessment of American National Security Policy during
the Cold War" (2022) by John Lewis Gaddis: Gaddis reviews the containment strategies
used by the US during the Cold War and their relevance in the context of US-China
competition in the Asia Pacific. This analysis provides insight into the challenges of
designing effective security policies in situations of heightened tensions.
By understanding these theories and concepts, we can see the complexity of the US-China
rivalry in the Asia-Pacific region and the importance of regional cooperation to reduce
tensions and prevent conflict escalation in the region.
METHOD
The research method used in this research is descriptive research using qualitative
methods, where this method is often used by researchers in the field of social sciences.
According to Suharsimi Arikunto (2013: 3) Descriptive research is research to investigate
circumstances, conditions or other things, which are then described in a research report.[1]
In descriptive research, phenomena can take the form, characteristics, activities, changes,
relationships, similarities and differences between one phenomenon and another. In this
research the author tries to analyze the factors that cause military power competition
between the United States and China in the Asia Pacific.
RESULT
The rivalry between the United States (US) and China in the Asia-Pacific region is one of the
most important global political dynamics today. Both countries have great economic and
military power and complex strategic interests in the region. This competition has created
tensions that affect regional and global stability, as well as triggering shifts in geopolitical
power in the Asia-Pacific region. One of the most important aspects of the competition
between the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific region is territorial disputes,
especially regarding the South China Sea. Countries compete for influence in the region,
which often affects relations with neighboring countries. This dispute has increased
tensions and created an arms race in the region that could threaten regional stability. In
addition, economic competition between the United States and China plays an important
role in the dynamics of competition in the Asia-Pacific region. The two countries compete
for dominant markets and investment in the region, which can create trade and financial
tensions that affect the global economy. The trade war between the United States and China
has created economic and geopolitical uncertainty that can affect global economic growth.
The political implications of US-China competition in the Asia-Pacific region also include
regional and global security issues. Countries compete with each other to expand their
influence in the security sector, including through military cooperation with allies. This
could increase security tensions and trigger reactions in other countries in the region. To
host this competition, the United States and China must increase dialogue and cooperation
and strengthen multilateral diplomacy in the Asia-Pacific region. Strong regional
cooperation can help reduce tensions and prevent the escalation of conflicts between
countries. In addition, efforts to build trust and promote peace in the region are important
steps to overcome this complex challenge. Therefore, competition between the United
States and China in the Asia-Pacific region has broad and complex implications for global
politics. A smart approach, effective cooperation and commitment are needed to maintain
regional and global stability in facing the challenges faced by both countries.
- International Relations and Diplomatic Strategy
International relations and diplomatic strategy play a central role in the dynamics of
international competition at the global level. In the competition between the United States
(US) and China in the Asia-Pacific region, the international relations and diplomatic
strategies of the two countries significantly influence regional and global stability.
International relations between the United States and China have developed over time and
are influenced by a number of factors, including economic, political and security interests.
These countries have a complex relationship that includes cooperation in the fields of
trade, investment and security, but competition is also very intense, especially in regional
and global influence. These factors influence a country's diplomatic strategy in its
interactions with each other and with other countries in the Asia-Pacific region. The
diplomatic strategies of the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific region involve
different approaches to building influence, advancing national interests, and maintaining
regional stability . The United States uses diplomacy to strengthen its alliances with
regional allies such as Japan, South Korea, and Australia as part of its Asia-Pacific energy
management strategy. On the other hand, China uses diplomacy to expand its influence,
especially through initiatives such as the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which aims to
expand economic and political relations in the region.In the context of military power
competition between the United States and China, their diplomatic strategy also plays a
role. an important role in preventing conflict escalation and encouraging constructive
dialogue. Military diplomacy, security dialogue and cooperation in international forums
such as the United Nations (UN) and regional summits have become tools for reducing
tensions and building trust between countries.Through strong international relations and
wise diplomatic strategies, the United States and China can strengthen cooperation,
manage competition and create a stable security environment in the Asia-Pacific region.
Regional cooperation, open dialogue and openness to joint solutions are the keys to
overcoming the complex challenges facing both countries. Therefore, international
relations and diplomatic strategy play an important role in the dynamics of competition
between the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific region. With an approach based on
cooperation and dialogue, countries can build mutually beneficial relationships and
maintain regional stability in order to achieve common interests.
DISCUSSION
The military power competition between the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific
region has become the focus of international political research. Both countries have
increased their military presence in the region in recent years through various efforts,
including military cooperation with allies and significant military modernization. Military
cooperation between the United States and its allies in the Asia-Pacific has strengthened
America's position and increased military presence in the region . The United States has
strengthened its regional security network through joint exercises, military exchanges, and
the construction of joint defense infrastructure. This would not only increase US military
capabilities, but also strengthen relations with regional allies such as Japan, South Korea
and Australia. This cooperation also aims to maintain regional security stability and
respond to frequent threats such as tensions in North Korea and the South China Sea. On
the other hand, China has carried out massive military modernization in the last few
decades. China has increased its defense capabilities and military power in the Asia-Pacific
region by investing heavily in high-tech military technology, warships, fighter jets and
missiles. This military modernization reflects China's efforts to become the dominant
military power in the region and shows China's commitment to strengthening its national
sovereignty and security (Huang, Wei, 2023). The impact of US military cooperation and
Chinese military modernization on military power competition in the Asia-Pacific region is
very important. Both countries have increased their defense capabilities and military
power projection, thereby creating complex tensions in regional security dynamics.
Challenges such as territorial disputes, political tensions and economic competition further
complicate relations between the United States and China and have an impact on regional
security stability. In this war race, diplomacy and regional cooperation are the keys to
reducing tensions and conflicts. Joint efforts to encourage constructive dialogue, build
trust, and seek diplomatic solutions are critical to maintaining security stability in the Asia-
Pacific region. With a wise approach and effective cooperation, it is hoped that the military
power competition between the United States and China can be managed well, thereby
creating a more stable and peaceful environment in the region.
Challenges and tensions in the Asia-Pacific region are complex problems and have a
significant impact on regional security dynamics. Several factors, including territorial
disputes, political tensions, and economic competition, have increased military power
competition between the United States and China in the region. One of the biggest
challenges in the Asia-Pacific region is territorial disputes, especially in the South China
Sea. The dispute concerns ownership claims over the islands and the area's natural
resources, which has increased tensions between countries in the region. Competition to
control strategic maritime trade routes has also given rise to conflict in the region. Political
tensions between countries in the Asia-Pacific region are also an important factor in
regional security dynamics (BBC, News, 2022). Differences in ideology, national interests
and historical rivalries between countries in the region often complicate relations between
countries. This political tension could trigger military confrontation and threaten regional
stability. Economic competition between countries in the Asia-Pacific region is also a big
challenge. Competition to control markets and economic resources in the region often
creates tension between countries. Protectionist policies and unbalanced trade competition
can weaken relations between countries and strengthen military power competition. The
consequences of challenges and tensions in the Asia-Pacific region are very broad and
complex. Political tensions and economic competition can disrupt regional cooperation and
weaken regional stability. Regional disputes can also trigger armed conflicts that can be
detrimental to all parties involved. Regional cooperation and diplomacy are the keys to
overcoming challenges and tensions in the Asia-Pacific region. Countries in the region must
increase constructive dialogue, build trust, and seek diplomatic solutions to resolve
disputes and reduce tensions. Effective regional cooperation can help create a more stable
and peaceful environment in the Asia-Pacific region. Therefore, it is important for countries
in the Asia-Pacific region to work together to overcome existing challenges and tensions in
order to create a safe, stable region , and prosperity for all parties.
The perspective of competition between the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific
region has major implications for world politics. In recent years, competition between the
two countries has increased, giving rise to tensions that affect security and stability
dynamics in the region and throughout the world. One of the most important consequences
of this competition is changes in geopolitical power. The United States as the dominant
global power and China as an increasingly ambitious country are competing for political,
economic and security influence in the Asia-Pacific region. This development could create
regional instability that would impact global interests. In addition, competition between
the United States and China could also affect international relations more broadly. Other
countries in the Asia-Pacific region and around the world must consider the impact of this
competition on their foreign policies. This can trigger the creation of new alliances, changes
in economic policies, and adjustments to security strategies. The implications for global
politics also include issues such as international trade, technology, and human rights.
Competition between the US and China in trade and technology has created tensions that
affect global markets and technological innovation. Apart from that, human rights issues
are also at the center of attention in relations between countries and have an impact on
international norms. To manage this impact, it is important for countries around the world
to strengthen multilateral diplomacy and regional cooperation (CNN, 2023). International
forums such as the UN, G20 and ASEAN can be important forums for encouraging dialogue,
promoting peace and finding joint solutions in facing complex global challenges. Therefore,
the prospect of US-China competition in the Asia-Pacific region has far-reaching
consequences for global politics . Overcoming today's complex world challenges requires
strong cooperation, smart diplomacy, and a commitment to maintaining global stability.
CONCLUSION
Based on the discussion, it can be concluded that the US-China military power competition
in the Asia-Pacific region is a complex and important issue in international politics. Both
countries have increased their military presence through cooperation with allies, military
modernization, and efforts to strengthen defense capabilities and military power
projection. Challenges such as territorial disputes, political tensions and economic
competition have exacerbated the military power struggle between the US and China, with
consequences that go beyond bilateral relations and affect regional stability. Military
cooperation between the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific region could influence
the dynamics of power competition military between countries. Through military
cooperation, the United States and China can strengthen relations with their allies, increase
defense capabilities, and expand their influence in the region. However, this cooperation
can increase tensions between countries, especially if it is seen as an effort to strengthen
their military position in the struggle for power. In the context of military power
competition between the United States and China, it is important to note that military
cooperation can be a tool for building trust, increasing security stability , and prevent
conflict escalation. With a smart approach and effective cooperation, military cooperation
between countries can be a way to reduce tensions, create constructive dialogue, and
create a more stable security environment in the Asia-Pacific region. Thus, military
cooperation between the United States and China in the Asia-Pacific region can influence
the dynamics of military power competition between countries. In facing complex
challenges and changing security dynamics, it is important for both countries to consider
the impact of their military cooperation on regional and global stability, and continue to
strive to build mutually beneficial relations and maintain peace in the region.
SUGGESTIONS
Based on the analysis provided, navigating the intricate landscape of the US-China military
power competition in the Asia-Pacific region requires a nuanced understanding of the
underlying dynamics. Here are some suggestions derived from the discussion:
Arms Control and Risk Reduction, Establishing mechanisms for arms control and risk
reduction can prevent unintended escalation. Confidence-building measures, such as
hotlines between military commanders or protocols for managing encounters at sea or in
airspace, can minimize the risk of miscalculation or accidents.
REFERENCES
Article
"US and China Conduct Naval Exercises in Disputed Waters Amid Rising Tensions in Asia
Pacific" - Reuters, 15 Agustus 2021.
"Military Buildup in the South China Sea: US Increases Presence to Counter Chinese
Expansion" - The New York Times, 5 January 2022.
"China Unveils Advanced Missile Defense System, Heightening Concerns in the Asia Pacific
Region" - CNN, 12 March 2023.
"US-China Military Competition Intensifies with Strategic Moves in the Pacific Islands" -
The Guardian, 28 September 2023.
an, Xin. (2021). "Naval Modernization and Regional Hegemony: The US-China Military Race
in the Asia Pacific." International Relations Quarterly, 39(1), 45-62.
Liu, Ming. (2022). "The Role of Alliances in Shaping US-China Military Competition in the
Asia Pacific." Security Studies, 30(2), 189-206.
Journal
Zhang, Wei. (2023). "Cyber Warfare and Strategic Parity: Assessing US-China Military
Capabilities in the Asia Pacific." Journal of Conflict Resolution, 48(4), 431-448.
Wu, Jian. (2021). "Nuclear Posturing and Deterrence: A Comparative Analysis of US-China
Military Strategies in the Asia Pacific." Strategic Studies Quarterly, 41(3), 312-328.
Yang, Lei. (2022). "Economic Interdependence and Military Rivalry: Exploring US-China
Relations in the Asia Pacific." International Politics, 36(2), 178-195.
Huang, Wei. (2023). "Soft Power Projection and Military Influence: US-China Competition
in the Asia Pacific." Journal of Asian Security and International Affairs, 23(4), 512-529.
Snyder.R. C., Bruck, H. W., & Sapin, B. (1969). “The Decision Making Approach to the Study of
International Politics”. The Free Press. Page. 202.
Kay Tse, Ildar Ablaev, Omer Malkan. (2023). International order transition and US-China
strategic competition in the indo pacific.” International Journal of Multidisciplinary
Approach Research and Science 1 (01), 18-30.
Kai He, Huiyun Feng. (2023). “Understanding the dynamics of the Indo-Pacific: US–China
strategic competition, regional actors, and beyond.” The Pacific Review 36 (2), 234-260, 20
23