Littelfuse TVS Diode Automotive Circuit Protection Using Automotive TVS Diodes Application Note PDF
Littelfuse TVS Diode Automotive Circuit Protection Using Automotive TVS Diodes Application Note PDF
The Challenge
The designers of automotive electronics face many technical challenges during the system design process, including designing
methods of protection against a variety of electrical hazards. The three major sources of electrical hazards in these systems are
electrostatic discharge (ESD), lightning, and switching loads in power electronics circuits. Overcoming transient surges that can harm
the vehicle’s electronics is one of the biggest challenges of the design process.
The Solution
Protecting automotive electronics includes eliminating transient surges that can damage the control units, infotainment electronics,
sensors, fuel injectors, valves, motors, 12/24/42/48 volts powertrains, and hydrolytic controllers, etc.
Note: For 48V power system with high power surge rating, welcome to contact Littelfuse for technical support and application test)
Wipers
Airbag
ABS
+
BATT EEC
Voltage
Reg.
Window Motor
Reverse
Battery
Table 1a: Littelfuse Automotive TVS Diode Series Compliance with Various Surge Levels in 12 & 24 volt Powertrains
12V System
Level 3 Level 4
TVS Series
1 2a 2b 3a 3b 5a 1 2a 2b 3a 3b 5a
–75V +37V +10V –112V +75V +65V –100V +112V +10V –220V +150V +87V
TPSMF4L/ SZSMF Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMA6L/ SZ1SMA Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMB/ SZ1SMB / SZP6SMB Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMC/ SZ1SMC / SZ1.5SMC Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMD Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TP6KE Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TP1.5KE Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TP5KP Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
SLD Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass
SLD5S/SLD6S/SLD8S Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass
Table 1b: Littelfuse Automotive TVS Diode Series Compliance with Various Surge Levels in 24 volt Powertrains
24 Volt System
Level 3 Level 4
TVS Series
1 2a 2b 3a 3b 5a 1 2a 2b 3a 3b 5a
–300V +37V +20V –150V +150V +123V –600V +112V +20V –300V +300V +173V
TPSMF4L/ SZSMF Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMA6L/ SZ1SMA Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMB/ SZ1SMB / SZP6SMB Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMC/ SZ1SMC / SZ1.5SMC Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TPSMD Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TP6KE Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TP1.5KE Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
TP5KP Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass - Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass -
SLD Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Conditional Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Conditional Pass
SLD5S/SLD6S/SLD8S Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Conditional Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Pass Conditional Pass
Voltage
Regulator
ECU, Airbag,
12V Protected
Alternator Motor,
Battery System
Infotainment,
etc.
As shown in Figure 3b, the TVS diode TPSMA6L15A is placed before the ECU, sensors, airbag controllers, motor, etc. When the
alternator provides power to the electronics, the TVS diode will protect against unwanted transients while allowing DC operating
voltage of 12 - 14 volts to the electronic systems.
Physical Layer Specification ISO 11898-2 Roof Sensor, light sensor, light control, sun roof
High speed differential bus, Cruise control, wiper, turning light,
Features Steering Wheel
good noise immunity climate control, radio
Popular Applications Automotive and industrial controls Seat Seat position motors, occupant sensors, control panel
1.0 Mbits/s @ 40 meters Engine Sensors, small motors
Transmission Speed
125 kbits/s @ 500 meters Climate Small motors, control panel
Twisted or parallel pair wires, Mirror, central ECU, mirror switch, window lift,
Cable Door
shielded or unshielded cable seat control switch, door lock
Termination Resistance 120 W resistors located at each end of the bus
12 V System: –3.0/+16 V
Min/Max Bus Voltage
24 V System: –3.0/+32 V
Min/Max Common CAN_L: –2.0 (min)/+2.5 V (nom)
Mode Bus Voltage CAN_H: 2.5 (nom)/+7.0 V (max)
Tx
CAN_H
Host Rx CAN Common
Controller Transceiver CAN_L Mode CAN Bus
Ref Choke
Automotive Standard ISO16750-2 Vs. ISO7637-2 for Pulse 5 (Load Dump Surge Test)
Littelfuse TVS products in ISO16750-2
ISO 16750-2 was prepared by Technical Committee ISO/TC 22, Road vehicles, Subcommittee SC 3, Electrical and electronic equipment.
In 2010, ISO16750 replace ISO7637 for load dump pulse 5a and 5b portion. Here we will list these two standard difference and give a
guideline for load dump protection component selection.
Load dump
This test is a simulation of load dump transient occurring in the event of a discharged battery being disconnected while the alternator is
generating charging current to other loads remaining on the alternator circuit.
Based on below 2 waveforms definitions, we can see there is a difference between the tr rising slope. ISO16750 defines the rising
slope from 10% (US-UA) to 90% (US-UA), while ISO7637-2 defines the rising slope from 10% US to 90% US.
Figure 6: Pulse 5a Waveform in ISO16750-2 Figure 7: Pulse 5a Waveform in ISO7637-2
U td U
tr td
tr
US
0,9 (US-U)A
0,9 US
US
• t time • UA supply voltage for generator • t time • UA supply voltage for generator
• U test voltage in operation (see ISO 16750-2) • U test voltage in operation (see ISO 7637-2)
• td duration of pulse • US supply voltage • td duration of pulse • US supply voltage (Does not
• tr rising slope • tr rising slope include UA)
Base on above waveform definition, we can see there is a slight difference between the rising slope tr for pulse 5b US and US* in
ISO16750-2 and ISO7637-2.
Figure 8. Pulse 5b Waveform in ISO16750-2 Figure 9. Pulse 5b Waveform in ISO7637-2
td U
U
tr td
tr
US a
0,9(US-U)A
0,9 US
b
US
US *
U S*
0,1(US-U)A 0,1 US
UA UA
0 0
t t
• t time • UA supply voltage for generator • t time • US supply voltage (Does not
• U test voltage in operation (see ISO 16750-2) • U test voltage include UA)
• td duration of pulse • US* supply voltage with load • td duration of pulse • US* supply voltage with load
• tr rising slope dump surpression • tr rising slope dump surpression (not include
• US supply voltage UA)
• UA supply voltage for generator
in operation (see ISO 16750-2)
One important point here is how to choose a suitable TVS diode to pass ISO-16750-2 5b test for automotive electronics designer. As
we have already known that ISO-16750-2 Pulse 5b (here we call it as 5b pulses, in short) is a clamped load dump surge by alternator
integrated TVS diode, so other electrical or electronic components’ maximum voltage need be designed base on this US* clamped
voltage. In some cases, electronics designers may think that the centralized integrated TVS diode clamp voltage US* is still too high
for proper protection for the afterwards components. That means a lower clamp voltage TVS diode is needed for such protections.
However, with such lower clamp voltage, centralized integrated TVS will be by-passed (or shorted) without dissipating any load dump
energy. As a result, all load dump energy will be dissipated on the lower clamp voltage TVS diode. However, this waveform or surge
energy level is now actually a ISO16750-2 5a (without centralized load dump protection) but not that of from 5b. Thus automotive
electronics designers need to consider the rating of Us, Ri and td together to determine how high power the clamp TVS diode should
take. In this case, normally higher energy SLD/SLD5S/SLD6S/SLD8S series TVS diodes need be considered.
If US* voltage is within TVS diode protection voltage range, then designer just need to select a small power TVS with working voltage
a little bit higher than the US*, like TPMSB, TPSMC, TPSMD, SZ1SMB, SZP6SMB, SZ1SMC and SZ1.5SMC to withstand such 5b pulse
energy. At the same time, these TVS diode(s) can also able to withstand pulse1, 2a, 3a and 3b other impulses. For detail selection of
right TVS diode(s), please refer to below Figure 10 & 11 for 12 and 24 volt system.
The rule for ISO16750 5b US* and TVS Vbr correlation refer to below SOA (Safe Operation Area) curve.
Figure 10. 12v 5b Vbr vs. US* Figure 11. 24v 5b Vbr vs. US*
ISO16750-2 ISO7637-2
Parameter Min Test Min Test
UN=12V UN=24V UN=12V UN=24V
Requirements Requirements
US(V) 79=<US=<101 151=<US=<202v 65=<US=<87 123=<US=<174v
US*(V) 35 65 define by user define by user
10 pulses at intervals
UA(V) 14 28 13~14 26~28
of 1 pulse
Ri(ohm) 0.5=<Ri=<4 1=<Ri=<8 0.5=<Ri=<4 1=<Ri=<8
1 minute
td(ms) 40=<td=<400 100=<td=<350 40=<td=<400 100=<td=<350
tr(ms) 10+0/-5 10+0/-5 10+0/-5 10+0/-5
10 x Unom x Nact
Ri =
0.8 x Irated x 12000min -1
Note - Ri is defined as the Alternator internal resistance
Major Differences:
ISO16750-2 defines 10 pulses in 10 minutes with 1 minute interval, while the old ISO7637-2 standard defines only 1 pulse. Thus, the
protector must have a higher reliability for this load dump protection in this new requirement.
As seen in Figure 12 & 13 below, we use typical 12 and 24 volt AEC-Q101 qualified TVS for load dump pulse 5a test verification and
comparison between ISO16750-2 and ISO7637-2.
Below is typical open load dump waveform for 12 and 24 volt system.
Figure 12. 12v System 101v 400mS Pulse Figure 13. 24v System 202v 350mS Pulse
In Figure 14 & 15 below, we have a comparison test of ISO16750-2 and ISO7637-2 with different pulses duration in the 12V system.
For the supply voltage Us 65 to 87 volt range, the Ri resistance required to withstand different pulses (40, 220 and 400 milliseconds) is
at least more than 1.14 ohm in the ISO7637-2. The upper region of the Figure 14 & 15 is the safe operation area of SLD15U-017 device.
Thus, we have to ensure the resultant resistance ( Alternator source impedance ) on the line exceeding 1.14 ohm to provide sufficient
protection for ISO7637-2 pulses. But, in the case of the Figure 15 with ISO16750-2 test requirement, the minimum resistance required
on the line is 1.5ohm which is more than that of the ISO7637-2.
Note: SLD15U-017 is a uni-directional TVS diode with 2200W power rating and a reverse standoff voltage 15V and a minimum breakdown voltage 16.7V.
Figure 14. 12v System Single Pulse(ISO7637-2) US Vs. Ri Figure 15. 12v System 10 Pulses(ISO16750-2) US Vs. Ri
SLD15U-017 SLD15U-017
1.5
1.2
1.4
1.1 1.3
1 1.2
1.1
Ri (ohm)
Ri (ohm)
0.9
1
0.8 40mS 1 pulse 40mS 10 pulse
0.9
220mS 1 pulse 220mS 10 pulse
0.7 0.8
0.6
400mS 1 pulse 0.7 400mS 10 pulse
0.6
0.5
0.5
65 70.5 76 81.5 87
79 84.5 90 95.5 101
Us(v)
Us(v)
*Note: Each curve above is SOA(Safe Operation Area). *Note: Each curve above is SOA(Safe Operation Area).
In Figure 16 & 17 below, we have a comparison test of ISO16750-2 and ISO7637-2 with different pulses duration in the 24 volt system.
For the Supply voltage Us 123 to 174 volt range, the Ri resistance required to withstand different pulses (40mS, 220mS & 400mS) is
at least more than 4.3 ohm in the ISO7637-2. The upper region of the Figure 16 & 17 is the safe operation area of SLD33-018 device.
Thus, we have to ensure the resultant resistance (Alternator source impedance) on the line exceeding 4.3 ohm to provide sufficient
protection for ISO7637-2 pulses. But, in the case of the Figure 17 with ISO16750-2 test requirement, the minimum resistance required
on the line is 4.5 ohm which is a little bit larger than that of the ISO7637-2.
Note: SLD33-018 is a bi-directional TVS diode with 2200W power rating and a reverse standoff voltage 33V and a minimum breakdown voltage 36.7V.
Figure 16. 24 Volt System Single Pulse(ISO7637-2) US Vs. Ri Figure 17. 24 Volt System 10 Pulses(ISO16750-2) US Vs. Ri
SLD33-018
SLD33U-018 4.5
4.5
4
4
3.5
3.5
Ri (ohm)
3
Ri (ohm)
3
2.5 40mS 10 pulse
2.5 40mS 1 pulse
220mS 10 pulse
220mS 1 pulse 2
2
400mS 10 pulse
400mS 1 pulse 1.5
1.5
1 1
123 135.75 148.5 161.25 174 151 163.75 176.5 189.25 202
Us(v) Us(v)
*Note: Each curve above is SOA(Safe Operation Area). *Note: Each curve above is SOA(Safe Operation Area).
Figure 18. 12 Volt System 10 Pulses (ISO16750-2) US Vs. Ri Figure 19. 24 Volt System 10 Pulses (ISO16750-2) US Vs. Ri
*Note: Each curve above is SOA(Safe Operation Area). *Note: Each curve above is SOA(Safe Operation Area).
All above 6 graphs data are tested under normal room temperature. Actual pulse withstand capability could be different with different
application environments. The TVS Load dump energy could have de-rated to a lower level with higher environmental temperature. That
means, for the same US level, Ri would rise a little bit.
Table 5. SLD series Vclamp maximum with different Table 6. SLD Series IPP Minimum with Different
pulse width, No. of pulses Pulse Width, No. of Pulses
As seen in above table, we have an example and pick suitable parts for your load dump protection. Now we are about to verify if
SLD33-018 can meet this protection requirement.
Voltage: 24 volt system: From Table 6, we know that SLD33-018 has a 40.8 amps clamping capability in 10 pulses
• Alternator resistance Ri = 4Ω condition at 220 milliseconds pulse width. From Table 5, we know that SLD33-018 has max
• Peak voltage of alternator output clamping voltage 50 volts in 10 pulses condition at 220 milliseconds pulse width. The actual
in load dump = 202 volts load dump peak clamping current can be calculated as (202 - 50 Volts) / 4Ω=38 amps which
• Target clamping voltage = 65 volts is lower than the 40.8 amp. Hence, SLD33-018 can protect the load dump surge (40.8 >
• Pulse width = 200 milliseconds 38 amps). Since TVS diode is a clamping device, the surge current will be affected by the
• Pulse numbers = 10 pulses in 10 external resistance. We know from the above, the Ri is the Alternator internal resistance
minutes will affect the TVS diode whether it can pass the surge test set by different external applied
voltage and surge duration. In the case where the Ri is too low to pass some surge tests,
then multiple TVS cascaded in parallel is needed to pass relevant surge test.
TVS Terminology
Figure 20. A Uni-Directional TVS in the Circuit for Protection
EOS
Transient Protected
Current TVS Load
Breakdown Voltage
The voltage measured at a specified DC test current, typically 1 mA. A minimum or maximum value is usually specified.