ETHICS Principles of Ethical Behavior in Modern Society
ETHICS Principles of Ethical Behavior in Modern Society
Jens Micah De G
; .11u.1rJE!J
Edna C. Aquino
Rodrigo DP. Tomas
Jeremiah B. Pacer
I
loysius T. Madriaga
Gherold C. Benitez
Lou S. Hualda
estie Allan A. Puno
Anthony B. Banzon
berto M. Bamba, Jr.
Authors
Ethics is. the branch of philosophy that studies_morality or the rightness or
wrongness of human conduct. Morality speaks of'a code or,system of behavior in
regards to standards of right or wrong behavior. In this book, the two terms (ethics
· a·nd morality), especially their adjective form (ethical and moral), are oftentimes used
interchangeably.
As a branch of philosophy, ethics stands .to queries about what there is reason
to do. Dealing with human actio_ns and reasons for action, ethics is also concerned
with character. In f~ct, the word 'ethics' is derived from the Greek ethos, ·which means
'character', or,·in plural, 'manners'.
Some questions that are et.hical in nature are'.·What is the gopd? Who is a moral
person? What are the virtues of a human bt::ing? What makes an act right? What
' I • ,
Clearly, ethics and morality necessarily carry the concept of moral standards or
·rules with .regard ·to behavior. So as a way of introducing moral rules, let us discuss
why rules are important to social beings. _
c. Rules produ_
ce a sense of justice among social beings. Rules are needed in order
to keep the strong .from dominating the_weak, that is, to prevent exploitation
and domination. Without rules, schemes in which those with the power control
the system, would take over. In effect, rules g~nerate a stable system that
'
·provides justice, in which even·the ~ichest and most powerful have limitations
. on what .they can do: If they transgress rules such as laws and ordinances and
take advantage of P,eople, there are consequences_both socially and criminally.
d. Rules are essential for a healthy economic system. Without rule~ regulating
business, power would centralize around monopolies and threaten the strer:igth
and competitiveness·-ot the system.:Rules a~e needed to ensure product safety,
employee safety, and product ·quality: Copyright and patents help protect
people's intellectual property. ~ules and regulations also keep the banking
. .· '. '
In short, soci~ty coulsf not soundly function without rules and regulations.
Rules are necessary to protect the gr~ater good. Even the freest socjeties ought to
have rules in order fo avoid exploitations and tyranny while upholding the common
welfare.
Not all rules are moral rules. ,:hat is, not all standards a~e moral standards.
Morality may refer to the standards that a person or a group has about what is
right and wrong, or good and evil. Accordingly, moral standards are th,ose concerne_d
with or .relating to human beha.vior, especially the distinction between good and bad ,
(or right and wrong) behavior. .
II
Moral standa'rds involve the rules people have about the kinds of actions. try,ey
believ~ are morally right and wrong, as well as the values they place on the kinds ,of
objects they believe are morally good and morally bad. Some ethicists·equate m~ral
stand~rds with moral values and moral principles.
a. Moral standards
1
l
involve serrous ll._
,
wrongs
' l'-. 1 . ,
or significant benefits. Moral
•· i'
1
.:, .- 1 • • l , ,
1
standards deal with matters which can seriQlisly impact, that is, injure or benefit
• • • .•· .,f ! ) - • • ' . . . :
human beings. It is not the case .with many non-moral st_ andards. For instance,
\. t ! .', ' \ '• • , ' • , •'' ,:, l 4 •.
do that even if it conflicts with other non-moral standards, and even with self-
,. ' ' . • 1 • • •
interest.
. .
Moral standards are not the only rules or principles in society, but they take
"prec:edence over other c_o~ nsideraii'ons, indudin_
g aesthetic, prudential, and even
' legal .ones. Aperson ri,~y be aesthetic.ally justified in leaving behi~d his family
in order to devote his life ·to painting, but m~rally, ali things considered, he/she
probably was not justified. It may be prudent to lie to save one's dignity,·but it
probably is morally wrong to do SO; When a particular law becomes seriously
immoral, it may be people's moraLduty .to ,exercise,icivil disobe~l,ierice: There
is a general mpral duty. to .ob~y the :law, b1,1t. there r,nay .co.me a time .when
the injustice -~f an evil law .is unbearabl~ and thu;.
I '
csills far 1Uegat bu_
.
t moral . . I '' t
L
· ,,..3...- •
, 11 ""
c. MQral'standards are not estabUshed by authority figures. Moral standards are
not invented, formed,.or gene.rated by authoritative bodies.or persons such as
nations' legislative bodies. Ideally instead, these values ought to be considered ·
in the process of making laws. In pri.ncipte·therefore, moral standards cannot be
changed nor nullified by the decisions of particular authoritative body: One thing
about these standards; rionethe/ess, is that its validity lies on th.e soundness or
adequacy of the reasons that are considered to support and justify them. -
This characteristic is. exemplified in the Gold Rule, "Do unto others-what
you would them q_o unto you (if you were .in the,ir shoes)" and in the formal
A
Principle of Justice, '"It cannot De right f~r to treat B i~ a. m~nne~ ,n which
it ~ould be wrorig for B to treat A, .me;~ly on the ground that they are two
different 'individuals, and without ther~'· being any difference -between the
natures or circumstances tif the.two which dn be stated ~s reasonable ground
. for difference of treatment." U~i~~rsalizability i~ an extension of the principle of
_. consistency, that is, Qne ought to be consistent about one's value judgments . .
The term 'dilemma' refers to.a situation.in which a tough choic~ has to be made
between two or mor~ options, especially more or les~ equally unde~irable ones. Not
all dilemmas are mor~~ dilemmas. ·
·:.. Cephalus, define; 'justic~' as spe~king the truth and paying one's
debts. S~cra~es -quickly. refutes .this account by suggesting that it would
be wrong to repay certai~ debts-for example, to return a borrowed ·
weapor;i to a friend who is no.t in his right mind. Socrates' point is not that ·
· repaying debts is without mora_ l import; rather, he wants to show that it
is not aiways right to repay one's debts, at least not exactly when the one
to whom the debt is owed demands repayment What we have here is a
, ,
conflict between two moral norm~: repaying one's debts and protecting .
oth.ers from harm ..." ("Moral Dilemmas," n.d.)
The key features of a moral dilemma are these: (a) the agent is required to do
each of two (or more) actions; (b) the agent can do each of the ·actions; but the agent
cannot,'do both (or all) -of the action~. In a moral di.lemma, the agent thus seems
conqemned -to morai failure; n.o matter what he does, he will do somett:iing wrong,
·or fail to do something that he ought to do.
Some ethicists propose that when one of the conflicting moral requirements
overrides .the other, the case is not·a 'genuine rnoral dilemma.' Thus, in ~dditicm to
the features 'mentione·d 'above; in·order. to have a genuine moral' dilemma, some add
that it must also .be the case that (c) neither of the conflicting morai requirements is
overriqden.
Moral dilemmas can ~e categorized according to these levels: (a) pers<?nal, (b).
organizational, and (c) structural. .
on the personal
'
leve,t. Sine~ many
.
ethical decisions
' . .
are personally
.
made, many,
· if not most of, moral dilemmas fall ·under, or boil down to, this level.
. '
6 '""''-J
;_..___,.,
., · ETHICS: PRINCIPLES OF ETH ICAL BEHAVIOR IN MODERN SOCIETY
-
b. Organizati~nal -Dilemmas. Organizational moral dilemmas refer to ethical
cases encountered and resolved by social organizations. This -category includes
moral dilemmas in·b~siness, medical field, and public sector. ·
ETHICS: PRINCIPLES er- ErnicAL er;;ww 10R iN Mot,rnN s.-JC1 H·f ...,.
. __,...,Z,..._,_ _
~ -"""'"'"·'"'1
·.· Case in point is the prices of medicine in the Phmppines which are higher
~bmpared to other countries in Asia and in countrres of similar economic
status·. ·Factors affecting medicine prices include the cost of research, presence
df competition in the market, government regulations, and patent protection .
. Institutions concerned may want to lower the costs of medicine, thereby
· benefiting the Filipino public, but such a move may ruin t~e interests or legal
· · rights of the involved researchers, inventors or discoverers, and pharmaceutical
•companies which own the patent of the medicines or h~althcare technologies.
·· _'..Concerning this
.
program,
.
health
.
financing
..
is
. .
first a,:id foremost
.
a big issue.
· Government could set aside bigger: budget for health for the implementation .
of this provision, But ttien; this·would mean -cutting down allocations on other
sectors (such as education or public works.). · '"
. ·. . .
5. 'Onlyituman beings can be ethical'
Another .basic tenet in ethics is the belief that only human beings can be truly
ethicaL Most philosopher_s hold that unlik~ animals, human beings possess some
traits that make it possible for them to be.moral:
Moreover, the-values of appreciating art, literature, and the goods that come ·
with deep personal relationships all require a being to be rational, autonomous,
and self-:-conscious. These
·-.
values, and
.
others like them, are th~ highest
. '(alues to
us humans; they compri~e t_hose which m~ke our lives worth living.
b. Only human b~ings can act morally or immorally. Strictly speaking, ar animal
which _devours another animal cannot be said to be immoral. In th~ same
manner, no matter how 'good' an animal's action seems to be, it cannot be
technically said to be moral.
, • ', •' • .~ -;_• • • • I ")
their good
l • <' •
c, O~Ly lfuman beings are part of the moral community. The so--;:alled moral
com·m unity is not defined in terms of the ir1trinsic properties that beings have,
• I - • •
but rather in ter.ms of the essenti~l social relations that exist between or amon~
beings. Distinctively, only human beings can possess or practicevalues such as
love, honor,
. .,
social relationships,
- .
forgiveness: compassion~ and-altruism.
- .
·. Moreover, only human -b~ings can communicate with each other in truly
meaningful ways, c~nengage ·in economic, ·political,: and -familial relationships
with each ,other,~and can also form deep -personal relationships with each
other. These kinds of relationships require .t he mernbers of such relationships
to extend real c-0ncern to 9ther members of th~s~.relationships in order for the
relationships to continue. _These relations~ip~ are what constitute our lives and
the values ~dntained in them.
Another thing human beings have that no animal has is th~ ability to
participate in a collective cognition. That is, we, as individuals, are able to draw
on the collective knowledge of humanity in a way no animal can.
As ~xplair:ied above, one ofthe r~asons animals cannot be.truly ethical is that
they are not really autonomous or free. Likewise, a robot, no matter how beneficial I
I
its functions may be, cannot be said to be moral, _for it has no fre~dom or choice but
to work according to what is commanded based on its built-in progr~m.
Morality requires and allows choice, which means the right to choose even
differently from our fellows. In their daily lives, people make the choice to give to
charities, donate time
.-
and money to schools~ mentor
,
children, open businesses, or
protest against animal cruelty.
The late Philosophy professor James · Rachels (1941-2003) holds that moral
judgments must be backed by sound reasoning and that morality requires the
impartial consideration of all parties inv~lved (Racheis, 1999). It is thus submitted that
reason and impartiality compose the "minimum conception" of morality or, as some
put it, the minimum. requirement for morality.
•.1.i!a
'. - - 10""""'.., ETHICS:
- ___ PRINCIPLES OF ETHICAL BEHAVIOR IN MODERN SOCIETY
lmpartia_
lity, on the other hand, involves the idea that each individual's
interests and point of view are equ/illy impo_rtant. Also called evenhandedness or
fair-mindedness, impartiality is a principle of justice holding that decisions ought to
be based on objective criteria, rather than on the basis of bias, prejudice, or preferring
the benefit to one person over another for improper reasons. (Detailed discussions
on reason and impartiality can be found in a later section of this book. For other
introductory topics about Ethics, you may read _the Appendix A: "Ethics: A Primer" of
this book.)
1. Recall ·some rules you have to follow in school 13nd community. What
rules do you find constricting? Explain why people ~ave to.follow r_ules. .
2. Differentiate oetween moral and non-moral standards. Cite two to three
differences between moral and non-morat,standards.
3. · When do you say something is a mor~l expetience?
·4_ What are moral dilemmas? Give some exampl~s..
Go online to www.OurHappySchool.com.
.
Through its search engine.
(upper right section), look for the article, "Cultural Relativism: A chalienge in
2. In the Facebook (FB) comment ~ection below the· article, answer these
questions in not more than three . (3) sentences: Is Cultural Relativism
sound? Why or why not? Use. hashtags: #CulturalRelativism #Ethics
#JensEnismo
3. Ask at least three friends (preferably not from your school) to write a short
comment on your post.
....,,. . ,- 1 • l
_ 2. Rule,s generate a stable system that provides justice, ·in which even the ..
.· richest and most powerful liave limitations on whatthey can do.
_ 3. Non-moral standards ar_e not the only rules or principles in society; but
the'9 take ·precedence over other 'considerations, includi~g aesthetic,
prudential, and even legal ones.
·~ 4. Morality requires and allows choice, which means the right to choose
even differently from our ·fellows. .
5. Most philosophers hold that unlike animals, human beings possess some
traits-that make it possible for them to be moral.
6. Dealing with human actions and reasons for action, ethics is 'also
cohcerned with character.
7. The wor~-'et_b_i¥s' is.der1yed from the L~tin ~thos, which means 'character',
or, in plural/manners'.
__:___; 10. Basic examples of moral standards includ~ rules of 'etiquette, fashion
standar~s, rules in games, .and various house rules.