Holocaust Changing Memory
Holocaust Changing Memory
REVIEW ARTICLE
Defining Memory
This article is addressing Holocaust memory belongs to a unique formative aspect of
ensconced in the discipline of history. The Jewish history as well as Judaic ideology.
concept of history as memory is a relatively The quasi-religious and certainly spiritual
new notion and was first introduced by notion of memory is an age-old practice
Halbwachs [1].The interpretation of history defined as Zakhor [5]. Thus the
as a form of collective memory was at first commemorative transmission of grieving for,
considered as both, outstanding and and remembering the departed, is part of
revolutionary, and received a tremendous weekly service in synagogues and its
amount of scrutiny. As it took traction, Pierre hallmark is the Yahrzeit-remembering the
Nora was refining the principle as a anniversary of the dead and saying Kaddish.
mechanism through which the transmission
The basis of Holocaust memory is an
of history is carried forward via the notion of
amalgamation of the age-old religious
collectivized memorization [2].
practices as well as the academic
Stepping into the fray of historical development of the notion of collective
controversy-as an almost a purposeful memory. In particular, the Holocaust as a
challenge to the conventional recording of tragic event cried out for commemorative
history-Hayden White labeled all historical practices that were readily developed. The
writings as "storytelling" and added a Holocaust museums are one of the products
measure of distortion that was soon emanating from the notion, as are annual
discarded by mainstream academia [3]. commemorative ceremonies such as Yom
Nonetheless, his concepts of metahistory Hashoah (Holocaust Remembrance Day) and
helped built the imaginative and Yom Haatzmaut (Israel Independence Day).
memorializing characteristics of historical
Formation of Holocaust Memory
reporting through academia at large [4]. The
basis of Holocaust Memory is partially As alluded to in the foregoing, the Holocaust
transmitted via these definitions but also casts an eternal shadow over the present and
future history of the Jewish people [6].It was 2010, there was a general consensus over the
a tragedy beyond description [7] and, in the definition and ideology connoted by
beginning, the only way to discuss it was to Holocaust Memory. At the same time, by
mourn and create commemorative 2008, Marianne Hirsch wrote about
memorialization processes. As early as 1942, postmemory as a way to address what was no
the vast proportion of the tragedy-the Shoah- longer survivor memory or direct archival
began to seep through the mindset of Jews historical research, but the proposition that
and Mordechai Shenhavi first proposed the such memory was now borne by a new set of
necessities of commemorative action individuals [16].
[8].After the end of WWII, the Jews were
scattered throughout Europe, in refugee For some time there was a belief system that
camps and some attempting to find life in held that first and second generation
their old communities [9]. survivors were the bearers of Holocaust
memory somehow transmitted via an
Common knowledge held that during these unexplained transmission route.
early post-war years the survivors were Researchers were demonstrating the
reluctant to talk about the afflictions. phenomenon by meticulous observation of the
However, this was prior to the formation of offspring [17] and what was labeled as
formal commemorative observations. Hasia superb psychosocial research [18]. However,
Diner's research showed that in the US and in retrospect, these are merely
Diaspora, every community, synagogues and lachrymose attempts of storytelling for
other Jewish venues were in constant states purposes of fame and publishing, or, at the
of mourning [10]. These were small and worst, highly suspicious attempts to
scattered efforts and did not have the mass manipulate data for academic gains.
exposure of future events and the influence of
the Holocaust museums to come. Similarly, The truth is that there was no truth to any of
in Israel, the earliest commemorative efforts these [19]. The terminology of generational
were in small clusters of communities [11]. transmission, however, is highly significant
when one looks at what really did happen
The earliest of established communal efforts [20]. The reality is that “For the vast
that would go on to become museums were in majority of contemporary Israelis the
the Ghetto Fighters' Kibbutz, which would go Holocaust is an acquired memory” [21].
on to become a well-known museum. In
Jerusalem, it was Martef Hashoah that was Such a stark statement is more in tune with
the central point of sorrow and the today’s realities and is in no way an
centerpiece of observation of Kiddush antithesis of previously formulated
Hashem [12]. Among the religious groups, definitions of Holocaust Memory. It is a
the mourning rituals took center stage [13]. naturally expected progression of social
In 1953, the Law of Yad Vashem [Martyrs’ evolution and memorialization maturity.
and Heroes] established an official and highly While the Holocaust museums are still
respected impetus for Commemoration of the authoritative depositories of historical
Holocaust [14]. accuracy and the maintenance of trace
memory [22] through artifacts exhibits, their
Yet there was still no Holocaust museum at service today is of the educational variety.
Yad Vashem; that would come years later.
Transitioning Holocaust Memory
However, the recognition that a great deal of
research was necessary for properly At some location in time, let’s say during the
organizing a history that would promulgate early years of the 21st century, the memory of
the project was evident in Ben-Zion Dinur’s the Holocaust [23] entered a comparative
article in the very first issue of “Yad Vashem stage Vis a Vis a multitude of genocides [24].
Studies” [15].Within the next decade or so, As the field of Genocidal Studies grew, the
the proper role of history, remembrance, “uniqueness” placement of the Holocaust
commemoration, as well as public sentiment, began to erode as efforts were being made to
would amalgamate into what would become internationalize its meanings and lessons
legitimate Holocaust Memory. As the "golden [25]. Such efforts inadvertently and
age" of Holocaust museums rose and unavoidably reached the mainstream of the
dominated the 1990's up till approximately political spectrum.
This took on a distinct course in Israel and further partition Jewish ideology [33].
an altogether different direction worldwide. However, not all is lost as regards the
support by the Diaspora of Israel as a nation
Enter Politics
of the Jews and much of this is due to
Inevitably, the forces of politics and power tourism directed toward memorial sites [34].
became dominant and Holocaust Memory In some ways, political controversies invite
was being relegated to convenient venues of visitors who, out of curiosity, want to see
ideology. A major share of this morphosis “what all the fuss is about.”
belongs to Prime Minister Netanyahu and his
Right-wing government coalition, as far as On the other hand, a series of opinion
Israel is concerned. While no one doubts the surveys by the Jewish People Policy Institute
existential threat nature of Israel's hostile indicates that the Diaspora population is well
neighbors [26.] The employment of Holocaust aware of the utilization of Holocaust Memory
Memory is an exploitation of the most by the state to curry favor and balances this
damaging variety. against the backdrop of settlement politics
[35]. The tensions between Left vs., Right
It feeds into the convenient politics of the politics is not lost on Diaspora Jews and they
Right and, not too surprising, provokes a are increasingly becoming wary of the
response from the Left [27]. As mentioned furthering of right-wing ideology in Israel
earlier, the notion of Holocaust Memory was [36].
being appropriated by a multitude of
academics and pseudo-historians for reasons Conclusion
beyond the scope of the present article It is a demonstrable factuality that Holocaust
[28].The cycling and recycling of concepts of Memory, at one time a binding spirit among
memory further feed political ideology. Jews, has veered off the horizon, enveloped
Reinforced via means of cultural motifs by the politics of the Right vs. the Left. The
ranging from literature to art and cinema, current Israeli government is not doing Jews
the public is overwhelmed [29]. any favor. It is a pathetic truth that the
current political leadership of the US and
Recently an increasingly political and right- Israel are marching in sync toward the
shifted public discourse by Prime Minister destruction of any remaining bonds between
Netanyahu succeeded in mobilizing Israeli Jews and the US Diaspora community
supporters for the most recent elections in [37-90].
April of 2019. However, it resulted in
exacerbating the diminishing of support The memory of the Holocaust is a distant
among diaspora Jews who tend to be left past, now reserved for use in the political
leaning [30]. The dividing of Jewry into Right arena and no longer a symbolic Jewish bond
and Left camp are a partial outcome of the based on the age-old traditions of shared
disturbing revisionism of memory and will suffering. It is as if Pesach (Passover) no
define sociopolitical norms for the future longer existed.
[31].These are lasting impressions [32] that
References
1 Maurice Halbwachs, On Collective Memory 5 Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi, Zakhor : Jewish
(Chicago: University of Chicago Press, History and Jewish Memory, The Samuel
1992). and Althea Stroum Lectures in Jewish
Studies (Seattle: University of Washington
2 Pierre Nora, "Between Memory and
Press, 1996).
History: Les Lieux De Mémoire,"
Representations (1989). 6 David Engel, Historians of the Jews and
the Holocaust (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford
3 Hayden White, "The Narrativization of
University Press, 2010).
Real Events," Critical Inquiry (1981).
7 Michael Bachmann, "Life, Writing, and
4 Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in
Problems of Genre in Elie Wiesel and Imre
Nineteenth-Century Europe (JHU Press,
Kertész," The Rocky Mountain Review
2014).
(2009).
17 Carol A. Kidron and " קדרו א קרולChildren of 25 Arlene Stein, "Whose Memories? Whose
Twilight : Deconstructing the Passage from Victimhood? Contests for the Holocaust
Silence to Voice of Second and Third Frame in Recent Social Movement
Generation Holocaust Descendants within Discourse," Sociological Perspectives 41, no.
the Private and Public Spheres in Israel" 3 (1998).
(Ph D, s.n. , 26 Daniel Levy and Natan Sznaider, "Memory
18 The Hebrew University, Jerusalem, 2005). Unbound the Holocaust and the Formation
of Cosmopolitan Memory," European
19 Hadas Wiseman, Einat Metzl, and Jacques Journal of Social Theory 5, no. 1 (2002);
P Barber, "Anger, Guilt, and "The Institutionalization of Cosmopolitan
Intergenerational Communication of Morality: The Holocaust and Human
Trauma in the Interpersonal Narratives of
Rights," Journal of Human Rights 3, no. 2 36 Jewish People Policy Institute, "Political
(2004). Views of Diaspora Jews Impact Their
Opinions Regarding Israel’s Use of Force,"
27 Klar, Schori‐Eyal, and Klar, "The “Never
JPPI,
Again” State of Israel: The Emergence of
http://jppi.org.il/new/en/article/english-
the Holocaust as a Core Feature of Israeli
jewish-values-and-israels-use-of-force-in-
Identity and Its Four Incongruent Voices."
armed-conflict-perspectives-from-world-
Gad Yair, "Israeli Existential Anxiety:
jewry/english-table-of-contents/english-
Cultural Trauma and the Constitution of
political-views-and-the-strength-of-the-
National Character," Social Identities 20,
israel-diaspora-relationship/#.XLRwCS-
no. 4-5 (2014).
B0_U.
28 Jamie Palmer, "The Holocaust, the Left,
37 Shmuel Rosner and Inbal Hakman, "The
and the Return of Hate," The Tower, no. 37
Challenge of Peoplehood: Strengthening the
(April 2016).
Attachment of Young American Jews to
29 Zygmunt Bauman, Modernity and the Israel in the Time of the Distancing
Holocaust (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Discourse," (Jerusalem: Jewish People
Press, 1989). Policy Institute, 2011). Jonathan Weisman,
30 Robert Cohen, "The Political Aesthetics of "American Jews and Israeli Jews Are
Holocaust Literature: Peter Weiss's the Headed for a Messy Breakup," (2019).
Investigation and Its Critics," History & 38 Mitchell Bard, "American Jews and the
Memory 10, no. 2 (1998); Annette Insdorf, International Arena (April 2017–July
Indelible Shadows: Film and the Holocaust 2018): The Gap between American and
(Cambridge University Press, 2003); Laura Israeli Jews Widens as the Gap between
Jockusch, "Historiography in Transit: Governments Narrows," in American
Survivor Historians and the Writing of Jewish Year Book 2018 (Springer, 2019).
Holocaust History in the Late 1940s," The
39 Bachmann, Michael (2009)"Life, Writing,
Leo Baeck Institute Yearbook (2013);
and Problems of Genre in Elie Wiesel and
Gabriel Mayer, "Haim Gouri and the
Imre Kertész." The Rocky Mountain
Ghetto Fighters’ House Holocaust Trilogy
Review,79-88.
Movies," Journal of Arts and Humanities 6,
no. 3 (2017). 40 Bar Doron (2005) "Holocaust
Commemoration in Israel During the
31 Christopher Browning, "A Lesson for
1950s: The Holocaust Cellar on Mount
Netanyahu from a Real Holocaust
Zion." Jewish social studies, 16-38.
Historian," Argument October (2015); NYT
Editorial Staff, "Mr. Netanyahu’s Holocaust 41 Bard Mitchell (2018) "American Jews and
Blunder," New York Times 2015. the International Arena (April 2017–July
2018): The Gap between American and
32 Danny Ben‐Moshe, "Elections 1996: The
Israeli Jews Widens as the Gap between
De‐Zionization of Israeli Politics," Israel
Governments Narrows." In American
Affairs 3, no. 3-4 (1997). Israeli Soldier
Jewish Year Book, 215-49: Springer,
Stuart A Cohen, "Towards a New Portrait
2019.
of the (New)," in From Rabin to Netanyahu
(Routledge, 2013). 42 Bauman Zygmunt (1989) Modernity and
the Holocaust. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell
33 Ian Buruma, "How to Talk About Israel,"
University Press.
New York Times (2003); Gideon Doron and
Rebecca Kook, "Religion and the Politics of 43 Baumel, Judith Tydor (1995) "“In
Inclusion," The Elections in Israel 1996 Everlasting Memory”: Individual and
(1999). Communal Holocaust Commemoration in
Israel." Israel Affairs, 1(3):146-70.
34 William D Rubinstein, The Left, the Right
and the Jews (Routledge, 2015). 44 In Perfect Faith" (2001) Jewish Religious
Commemoration of the Holocaust."
35 Steven Davidson, "Far-Left Diaspora Jews
Studies in Religion/Sciences Religieuses,
Increasingly Coming to Israel — and
30(1):5-21.
Sticking Around," THe Times of Israel
2019. 45 Ben‐Moshe Danny (1997) "Elections 1996:
The De‐Zionization of Israeli Politics."
Israel Affairs, 3 (3-4):66-76.
46 Brog Mooli (2002) "In Blessed Memory of 60 Hirsch Marianne (2008) "The Generation
a Dream: Mordechai Shenhavi and Initial of Postmemory." Poetics Today, 29(1):103-
Holocaust Commemoration Ideas in 28.
Palestine, 1942-1945." Yad Vashem
61 Insdorf, Annette. Indelible Shadows: Film
Studies, 30: 297-336.
and the Holocaust. Cambridge University
47 Browning Christopher (2015) "A Lesson Press, 2003.
for Netanyahu from a Real Holocaust
62 Institute, Jewish People Policy. "Political
Historian." Argument.
Views of Diaspora Jews Impact Their
48 Buruma Ian (2003) "How to Talk About Opinions Regarding Israel’s Use of
Israel." New York Times, 28. Force." JPPI,
http://jppi.org.il/new/en/article/english-
49 Cohen Israeli Soldier Stuart A (2013)
jewish-values-and-israels-use-of-force-in-
"Towards a New Portrait of the (New)." In
armed-conflict-perspectives-from-world-
From Rabin to Netanyahu, 93-103:
jewry/english-table-of-contents/english-
Routledge.
political-views-and-the-strength-of-the-
50 Cohen Robert (1998) "The Political israel-diaspora-relationship/ - .XLRwCS-
Aesthetics of Holocaust Literature: Peter B0_U.
Weiss's the Investigation and Its Critics."
63 Jockusch Laura (2013) "Historiography in
History & Memory 10(2):43-67.
Transit: Survivor Historians and the
51 Davidson Steve (2019) "Far-Left Diaspora Writing of Holocaust History in the Late
Jews Increasingly Coming to Israel- and 1940s." The Leo Baeck Institute
Sticking Around." THe Times of Israel. Yearbook, ybt001.
52 Diner, Hasia R (2010)We Remember with 64 Kansteiner Wolf (2002) "Finding Meaning
Reverence and Love: American Jews and in Memory: A Methodological Critique of
the Myth of Silence after the Holocaust, Collective Memory Studies." History and
1945-1962. nyu Press. theory, 41 (2):179-97.
53 Dinur Benzion (1957) "Problems 65 Kaplan Harold (1994) Conscience and
Confronting'yad Vashem'in Its Work of Memory : Meditations in a Museum of the
Research." Yad Vashem Studies,1:7-30. Holocaust. Chicago: University of Chicago
54 Doron Gideon, Rebecca Kook (1999) Press.
"Religion and the Politics of Inclusion." 66 Kidron Carol A (2005) קדרון א קרול.
The Elections in Israel 1996 : 67. "Children of Twilight : Deconstructing the
55 Engel David (2010) Historians of the Jews Passage from Silence to Voice of Second
and the Holocaust. Stanford, Calif.: and Third Generation Holocaust
Stanford University Press. Descendants within the Private and
Public Spheres in Israel." Ph D, s.n. , The
56 Farbstein Esther (2007) Hidden in Hebrew University, Jerusalem.
Thunder: Perspectives on Faith,
Halachah and Leadership During the 67 Klar Yechiel, Noa Schori‐Eyal, Yonat
Holocaust.1: Feldheim Publishers. Klar( 2013) "The “Never Again” State of
Israel: The Emergence of the Holocaust as
57 Friedlander Saul (1994) Trauma, a Core Feature of Israeli Identity and Its
Memory, and Transference. Holocaust Four Incongruent Voices." Journal of
Remembrance: The Shapes of Memory. Social, 69(1):125-43.
Edited by Geoffrey H. Hartman.
Cambridge: Blackwell. 68 Knesset "Martyrs' and Heroes
Remembrance (Yad Vashem) Law 5713-
58 Gil Idit (2012) "The Shoah in Israeli 1953."
Collective Memory: Changes in Meanings (https://www.yadvashem.org/yv/en/about/
and Protagonists." Modern Judaism, pdf/YV_law.pdf).
32(1):76-101.
69 Kochavi Arieh J (2003) Post-Holocaust
59 Halbwachs Maurice (1992) On Collective Politics: Britain, the United States, and
Memory. Chicago: University of Chicago Jewish Refugees, 1945-1948. Univ of
Press. North Carolina Press.