The 6 C in Speech Therapy
The 6 C in Speech Therapy
While living in south Florida since the beginning of the pandemic was fun, I have
FOUR grandchildren now, 3 who were born in the years I was away. This grandmother
just can't stand living 15 hours away from them anymore... so I'm going home where I
can be a part of their everyday lives. I know those of you who have grandchildren will
certainly understand, and so will those of you who are moms and dads fortunate
enough to have help from your own mother, your mother-in-law, or a grandmother
stand-in. This "LaLa" is very excited about this next season of my life!
But back to business...
Today I want to begin talking about The 6 C's of Communication which are really the
foundational pieces of early language development. It's an easy way to help parents
understand that communication is much more than talking. Here's a summary with a
direct cut and paste from one of the handouts in The Late Talker Workbook. If you
want to know 'how the book sounds' or 'what's in the book,' here's an example:
3. Comprehending:
Comprehending means that a child assigns meaning to the words he hears regularly.
Examples of early receptive language skills include identifying familiar people and
objects, consistently responding to their own name, pointing to body parts and familiar
pictures in favorite books on request, and most importantly, following routine
commands like ―Come here‖ and ―Sit down.‖ Routine commands also include tasks
such as, ―Put your arm in,‖ during dressing, ―Open your mouth,‖ as you feed them or
brush their teeth, along with requests to retrieve items, such as, ―Go get your ____.‖
These commands, and assessing a child‘s response to them, are a good place to begin
when determining a child‘s ability to understand what he hears.
Toddlers with typically developing language skills, and many late talkers, understand
much more than they can say. That‘s why lots of people miss it when a toddler doesn‘t
understand very many words. We expect young children to pick up language and begin
to learn what words mean as we go about our everyday routines.
Therapists refer to comprehension as receptive language skills. If we were dividing
language into two big categories, receptive language would be the input piece and
expressive language, or talking, would be the output piece. Sometimes I explain the
connection between receptive and expressive language to parents by saying, ―You‘ve
got to have good input before you get good output.‖ That‘s what this whole section is
about…making sure a child receives good input.
Here‘s the reason receptive language is so important:
When there are receptive language delays, we can expect expressive language delays
too. This is not a real word, but I tell parents that late ―comprehenders‖ are always late
talkers.
I don‘t want to alarm you, but I‘d be seriously neglecting my responsibility if I didn‘t
tell you that receptive language delays are much more serious than a delay in
expressive language only.
Like most other problems in life, the earlier we address it, the better our outcome will
be. When we don‘t, even a mild receptive language delay can spiral out of control so
that it will be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for a child to catch up. For this
reason, and for the best possible trajectory for that child, we must identify and treat
receptive language issues early, even before we would think about talking. Here‘s how
I describe it to parents:
If a 1½-year-old isn‘t following very familiar commands, it‘s a real concern. This issue
is more significant when a child is over the age of 2 and does not consistently complete
simple requests. When a child reaches the age of 3 and doesn‘t follow directions, there
is unquestionably a serious language and/or developmental disorder.
If the late talker you‘re working with does not consistently respond to verbal
directions, helping him improve his ability to comprehend words should be one of your
top priorities.
The bottom line for Comprehending is this:
Now I know what some of you are thinking... what about presuming competence?
That's a real buzz phrase in our field. Many SLPs are now not working on receptive
language at all.
Respectfully, I disagree with that position.
I think ignoring receptive language can be dangerous for toddlers with language
delays. Over the years, I've seen so many soooo many EI therapists completely miss
receptive language delays and focus so much on talking that the child never makes any
real progress in either area.
While this may be a controversial position in this day and age, this is what I believe in
my head and in my heart after 30+ years of working with toddlers and their families.
When we ignore receptive language, it's as if a parent doesn't get the full scope of
what's happening with their child's language development. To me that's like teaching a
child multiplication when they haven't demonstrated understanding of adding and
subtracting. We're putting the cart before the horse...
If I worked mostly with preschoolers and school age children, I might have a different
opinion.
If I worked exclusively with older children with autism, I might have a different
opinion.
And if we're talking about one specific child, I certainly might have a different
opinion.
But I don't and we're not!
I work with babies and toddlers with language delays and disorders.
The truth is ALL babies and toddlers -- our population in early intervention -- are
learning what words mean. To ignore receptive language in a child who rarely
demonstrates understanding of words, concepts, and following directions is a real
disservice to a child who is not yet talking.
Even when a parent reports, he understands everything, I want to get a sense of that
myself before I completely rule out targeting language comprehension.
Let's agree to respectfully disagree if you have a different opinion : )
If after reading this you realize that your child needs to work on Comprehending,
please check out the plan in The Late Talker Workbook. It will help you work on this
third foundational C and get language moving in your little one!
More info in case you've missed it...
I can help you plan therapy for a late talker based on what works
for YOU and your priorities.
Each of the three plans in The Late Talker Workbook contains:
4. COPYING:
If your late talker occasionally imitates words, you may be tempted to skip this area
and move on to the next area. Do not do that! Until a child can quickly, even
automatically, copy your words, learning to talk will be a slow, laborious, and tedious
process. We know that when a child can‘t imitate words easily, his skills are probably
weaker at an earlier level. When we go back and target those earlier levels, imitating
words will become easier. I‘ve seen this happen with many, many, many late talkers
who had a handful of words when a therapist or parent wisely ―backed up‖ and worked
on strengthening the previous levels. Once they did that, a child was able to begin
imitating words much more consistently, and finally, they began to talk on their own.
Over the next several pages, I‘ll teach you how to do that too! Be sure to add any idea
that you want to incorporate into your Weekly Plan.
Continuum for Copying
Like every skill we learn, there‘s a continuum for learning to copy what a child hears.
I‘ve written a couple of examples so that you can take a look and find the one that may
resonate with you for the late talker you‘re working with to give you some ideas for
starting points.
Example 1: When discussing imitation with a late talker’s mom during his first
meeting with his SLP, she can’t come up with any examples of when her son
copies actions or sounds. However, his therapist notes his mature play skills as he
operates a Hot Wheels race track by putting three cars in their individual lanes and
then pushing the correct button on a remote control. When the therapist marvels at his
ability, his mother says, ―Oh, he learned that from his brother.‖ Slowly, the mother
begins to smile as she realizes, yes, my child understands how to imitate!
Focus for Therapy: Since this child understands how to imitate complex actions,
move on to helping him learn to imitate sounds. Since he demonstrated interest and
advanced proficiency in operating that Hot Wheels race track, model vehicle noises
and exclamatory words as you play with the race track as you entice him to copy you.
As you play, excitedly copy any play sounds the race track makes and see if the late
talker will join in. Listen for any sounds (or words!) he says or imitates during play.
Many times, parents of late talkers underestimate their ability to use these kinds of
early "words" and a child may already be using a few of them. So instead of starting
with "real" words, try play sounds with the car like "Vroom!" or "Wow!" or "Whee!"
or "Beep beep!" This is a wonderful starting point for therapy for many late talkers.
Example 2: A late talker’s mom reported that her little girl likes music and is
trying to copy hand motions for her favorite songs like ―If You‘re Happy and You
Know It‖ and ―The Wheels on the Bus.‖ Her mom knows music should be a good way
to help her child develop speech, but she‘s not sure how to proceed.
Focus for Therapy: That should be music to our ears! Anytime a child is interested in
music and trying to copy hand motions, we know they are primed to learn to copy and
imitate. Begin with a child‘s favorite songs to ―meet them where they are‖ and get
success going right away. Add a new motion or verse with a new round of hand
motions to an existing song if you can. Move on to new songs with new hand motions.
If a child has difficulty, select songs with similar hand movements. For example, you
clap in ―Patty Cake‖ and ―If You‘re Happy and You Know It," as well as at the end of
songs. Remember that repetition is the key to teaching songs and motions. Kids have to
hear it over and over before they are able to join in with the motions or words.
Anytime a child is learning words to songs, go ahead and introduce verbal routines.
Songs are just that—verbal routines. By learning words to a song, a child is practically
telling you, ―If there‘s a pattern, I can learn it!‖ So, get repetitive and help a child
develop some verbal routines. I‘ll list several ideas to get you started in the next
section.
Example 3: A therapist begins seeing a child for therapy and quickly identifies
that he repeats a few holistic phrases he’s picked up from his favorite YouTube
videos. She tells his parents that since he ―obviously knows how to talk,‖ they should
have him request items before giving in. She begins therapy by having him request
items before she will give him a toy. This results in frequent crying throughout the
session, which upsets the child and his mother, but the therapist encourages Mom and
Dad to continue since they know this child can talk. After several weeks, she gets a
phone call from the service coordinator telling her the family has requested another
therapist.
Focus for Therapy: Although it might seem like this child is ready to copy the
therapist‘s words since he can say a few phrases, something is missing. This child is
likely a gestalt language processor and may need to learn more holistic phrases or
gestalts as you play together, rather than focusing on using single words to make
requests.
Another way to approach treatment with a child like this is to use the imitation
hierarchy to determine the lowest level where a child begins to have difficulty
imitating. Strengthen that area first, moving up the levels so that the child begins to
copy all kinds of things—from actions with toys, to hand motions in songs, to play
sounds, to words in verbal routines—easily and consistently before you solely focus on
Copying words. Look at these levels and examples again in the next section.
To summarize...
Until a child learns to easily and effortlessly copy what you say, he's not going to
learn to talk.
In case no one has reminded you of this, most late-talking children do learn to talk,
including those who have a medical diagnosis that predisposes them to communication
delays such as Down syndrome or cerebral palsy, a developmental diagnosis like
autism, a speech-language diagnosis like apraxia, and especially plain ole‘ late talkers.
That is a very positive reality that I want you to hold onto throughout this process.
However, no child learns to talk until they establish the foundational pieces. No matter
what you hear from the neighbor down the street or the cashier at the grocery store or
even your pediatrician, children don‘t just wake up one day and talk. They all go
through predictable stages, even when their language development is delayed or
atypical.
The broad stages are just what you‘ve learned in this manual…Connecting,
Conveying, and Comprehending, Copying, and finally, Communicating with Words,
and then Combining Words. These overall skills are the ones that will determine if and,
to a lesser degree, when a child will begin to talk. Nothing else.
As we‘re discussing a child‘s ability to communicate with words, we must make sure
we‘ve set the stage for success by shoring up any weakness in the first 4 C‘s we‘ve
reviewed. I know you‘re doing that (or are on your way to doing that!) by your
commitment to get this far in this therapy manual!
There are a few special circumstances about communicating with words that warrant
additional discussion, so let‘s talk about those now.
Listen carefully for early word attempts.
Occasionally when I meet a new child and their family, I identify word attempts that a
parent misses. For those families, I focus on helping parents recognize when their child
is trying to talk. Most of the time, this happens when a child‘s speech sound system is
significantly delayed or disordered and his vocalizations are highly unintelligible. A
child may be missing many or most sounds in the word or substituting sounds to the
degree that his parents haven‘t discerned any recognizable patterns, especially when a
child is not trying to immediately imitate the word.
One little girl I worked with like this years ago had only vowels and they weren‘t even
close to what she should have used. No wonder her parents had a hard time deciding if
she was really talking, but she was trying from time to time, and those sweet little first
attempts needed to be reinforced. If you think this might be the case for your child,
follow the specific recommendations coming up for you in the Practical Strategies
section.
Increase the frequency of the words a child already uses before you teach new
words.
When we discussed communicating with words in the introduction, I focused on
vocabulary size because that‘s the most common way that we begin to separate
children who need further assistance in learning to talk from those who don‘t.
Vocabulary size matters, but maybe not as much as you think for a late talker.
Frequency, or how often a child says the words she can, is a much better gauge, in my
opinion. A child who uses only 10 different words but says each of them 10+ different
times all day long is much different than a child who says 10 different words once or
twice each over the course of a whole week!
For some late talkers, I don‘t focus on teaching them any new words at the beginning
of therapy. Instead, we target how often and how appropriately (meaning in context)
they use their words. If your child says only a few words, but you don‘t hear them very
often, you should focus on increasing the frequency of those words before trying to
teach new words. Do that for a couple of weeks to try to solidify those words. Your
child will be in a much better position to move forward, and I bet you‘ll begin to
breathe a sigh of relief when you hear his or her first words more often.
Combining Words:
Before a child can combine words on his own, he or she usually needs to:
• Possess a large core vocabulary of at least 35–50 words.
• Understand and use words from a variety of categories including nouns, verbs,
prepositions, modifiers/descriptive words.
• Sequence two syllables.
• Include a variety of syllable shapes.
• Imitate two-word phrases.
Always try to model phrases using words from a child’s existing vocabulary.
Don‘t include new words when you‘re trying to help a toddler learn to use phrases.
Choose high-frequency words (words a child hears and says all the time) along with
words a child can already pronounce (words that are easily understood). Model those
combinations and encourage a child to imitate and then use them himself.
This is a little more difficult when a child‘s vocabulary is mostly nouns, but it can be
done. Immediately, you may think about possession as in ―Mommy(‘s) brush,‖ but
most of the time, toddlers‘ two-word phrases represent many ideas as they can‘t
include all the words just yet. Let‘s take the example we just used with ―Mommy
brush.‖ A child may mean, ―That‘s Mommy‘s brush,‖ or ―Mommy, brush my hair,‖ ―I
want Mommy‘s brush‖ or any other meaning you may imply.
Practice expansion.
When a child says a single word, add a relevant word, then model the new phrase for a
child to imitate. For example, when a child says, ―Go!‖ say, ―Go car!‖ If she says,
―Book,‖ say, ―Read book.‖ If you want more information about expansion, it‘s
included as the 11th strategy in Plan B. Take a look at that section for more ideas to
implement in everyday routines.
Pick a high-frequency word a child says easily and then combine it with words she can
already say. This will be easier for a child since she‘ll only need to change one word of
the phrase. This strategy works well for mass practice, meaning an activity set up for a
child to produce the same kind of target many times. For example, if you‘re cleaning
up toys, you could use ―Bye‖ as your anchor word and cue a new phrase each time you
toss a toy into the basket, such as, ―Bye car, bye truck, bye boat, bye plane, bye choo-
choo, etc.‖
Sometimes late talkers can imitate or ―pop out‖ a holistic phrase and then it becomes
part of their core vocabulary. Gestalt language learners who have used jargon seem
especially prone to imitating these kinds of phrases first, too. Good ones to try are: