Promotion and Protection of Feminism Creativity Fo
Promotion and Protection of Feminism Creativity Fo
Research Article
Promotion and Protection of Feminism Creativity for Public
Environment: The Integration of Ecofeminism and
Public Environment
1,2 2
Wanjin Dong and Soonbae Kim
1
Nanyang Medical College, Nanyang 473000, China
2
Chungbuk National University, Chungbuk 28644, Republic of Korea
Received 15 June 2022; Revised 11 July 2022; Accepted 18 July 2022; Published 21 November 2022
Copyright © 2022 Wanjin Dong and Soonbae Kim. Tis is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons
Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Each of us leaves a trace of our consumption on the environment. Take a step back, though, and consider how much infuence
people have had on the Earth. Te Anthropocene, sometimes known as the era of humans, refers to how signifcantly we have
changed the Earth’s systems. Tis is the grand view of humanity’s impact on the Earth. In this article, we plan to introduce and
explain ecofeminism. Because of the natural connection with nature and the social role as housekeepers, women often have
empathetic power when expressing their demands for the public environment, thus becoming a vital force in public envi-
ronmental protection. Facing the public environmental forces spurting from ecofeminism, we study the dissemination of
ecofeminism with the help of mass media. However, in present-day China, as pointed out by ecofeminism, the predatory
exploitation of nature and the catastrophic killing of plants and animals make the fate of women challenging to control. Terefore,
we study the theory of multicultural ecofeminism and public environmental protection. Finally, based on the integration of
ecofeminism and the public environment, we interpret Lawrence’s famous work, Sons and Lovers, and analyze the relationship
between men and women and the public environment in this work from the perspective of ecofeminism. In human socialization,
ecofeminism has provided strong support for protecting the public environment, and at the same time, it has also improved.
own fate and called for the protection of animals’ survival Public Environmental Exploitation
rights. Afterwards, women’s concerns about the public
environment directly prompted their participation in urban
environmental reform activities. During this period, most of
the women tended to achieve environmental protection
through political channels. Tey were committed to pro-
moting environmental laws and administrative orders to
ensure healthy public environment for their families. Out of
maternal concern for the public environment and concern
for family life, women instinctively raised their voices for
improving the public environment by conducting investi-
gations, making speeches and seeking the help of govern-
ment departments by making use of their infuence,
mobilizing the participation of public people in improving
public environment from an individual perspective, and Gender Oppression
eventually pushing for government environmental policy Figure 2: Whole context for ecofeminism.
and laws. Tese kinds of women’s conscious behaviors di-
rectly popularized and spread the concept and knowledge of
protecting urban health. Using gender as a vantage point, events and information in a popular way, widely popular-
ecofeminism examines the conditions that cause and per- izing the concept of environmental protection. Tey pur-
petuate the subordination of both women and nature. It can posefully stimulate and guide public sentiment and public
be thought of as a lens for examining intersections of op- opinion, thus infuencing the progress of environmental
pression; harmful practices that exploit the environment and events and environmental movement. Under the infuence
social structures that oppress women among other groups of mass media, social resources have been highly mobilized
have an overlap, and that is what ecofeminism is all about, as and integrated, and civil environmental protection forces
shown in Figure 2. have efectively united and entered the environmental
Women’s protection of the public environment shows movement, thus forming a wave of social movement, which
their close connection with nature and strengthens their has a crucial impact on the formulation of government
social role as “family caregivers,” but at the same time, they public environmental policies and the implementation of
are satirized and attacked by the patriarchal civilization. environmental protection measures.
Tey believe that these women’s environmental behavior is Aware of the media’s communication advantages, eco-
purely out of personal emotions and concern for their in- feminists began to actively use the mass media to expand
dividual lives, lacking rationality and technology, and their infuence. Tey consciously seized the media’s right of
lacking sublime and applicability [26–28]. In the face of all speech, sought resource mobilization and support nation-
kinds of criticism and scrutiny, female public environmental wide, and infected other classes and groups of society with a
protection activists with ecofeminist consciousness began to positive attitude to protect the environment, resulting in
realize that women’s marginal status is the main reason universal linkage and imitation of social efects. In this
behind men despising and belittling women’s environmental process, driven by some women scholars and sportsmen, the
protection behavior. In a male-centered patriarchal society, expression of ecofeminism has become more and more
women’s true meaning and value are diminished or even mature, and the perspective of ecofeminism has begun to
totally denied. Tey are imprisoned in the private sphere of become familiar to ordinary people through the mass media,
family life for a long time, unable to participate in the and is gradually becoming known to the public through the
discussion and decision-making of public afairs, and mass media.
eventually become victims of male activities just like nature. For ecofeminists, the public environment communica-
Terefore, ecofeminism gradually shows a strong color of tion activities carried out by means of mass communication
publicity, which emphasizes that women must act against fnally expanded the activities with self-liberation signif-
the oppression of patriarchal social culture, change their cance to a broader public stage. With the reports and
position, seek equal social status and speech rights with men, propaganda of mass media, women show advanced envi-
and then gain a place in the public sphere. As there is a ronmental concepts, keen perception, and strong environ-
natural afnity between women and nature, public envi- mental protection power in the feld of social life, which also
ronmental problems can link family life and public society. makes the movement of women outside the private feld
Hence, ecofeminists consciously take the intervention of prominent enough to be recognized by the public [29, 30]. At
environmental issues as an important way for women to the same time, the success of these campaigns has also
resist male chauvinism and compete for public power. accumulated experience for women public environmental-
At the same time, as the disadvantages of industrial ists in developing feminist ecology. Tis is because women’s
civilization become more and more obvious and the de- involvement in public environmental issues, on the one
velopment of mass media becomes more and more mature, hand, enhances and amplifes their advantages and abilities
environmental problems begin to gain more attention in the in perceiving environmental hazards and achieves the initial
mass media. Media disseminates and reports environmental goal of public environmental protection. On the other hand,
4 Journal of Environmental and Public Health
it is also an essential way for women to participate in the fate of women has become challenging to master due to the
public sphere and compete with the male-centered social predatory development of nature and the catastrophic
structure and institutional culture. slaughter of animals and plants. Terefore, we urgently need
In all kinds of public environment communication ac- the rapid rise and development of ecofeminism and, more
tivities developed through the mass media, women have importantly, emphasize the essence and direction of eco-
actually experienced a tremendous change in environmental logical feminism, cultural ecology, and cultural environ-
perspective and motivation. From the very beginning, they mental protection. Cultural ecology and environmental
only concerned themselves and their families’ living envi- protection should not only overturn and adjust the binary
ronment, and then actively helped other people in society to opposition between men and women, but also between
solve the public environmental problems. In this process, culture and nature and between spirit and body, and achieve
women are no longer trapped in their private lives, but integration and perfection through humanistic revolution.
become important participants in the public sphere and have In thousands of years of human history, patriarchy has
a signifcant impact on social development. Te success of dominated the power of human culture, vigorously excluded
this activity also confrms the core concept of feminist the status of women in culture, completely denied the role of
ecology, that is, women construct a way to resist the gender women in cultural creation, and greatly persecuted the
oppression of patriarchal society in their campaign to cultural ecological balance of human society. Ecofeminism
protect the public environment. reveals the correlation between nature’s oppression and
Driven and motivated by mass media and women, more women’s oppression, and indicates men’s coerciveness and
and more ordinary people begin to pay attention to public hegemonic status in social culture. Tis kind of cultural
health and public environment and try to participate in the monopoly is the characteristic of patriarchy, which produces
process of public environment. With the continuous ex- a series of patriarchal value systems and patriarchal social
posure and development of mass media, the resources and structures. Men are dominant and superior, while women
forces of environmental protection in society have been are subordinate and inferior. Te “three obedience and four
highly mobilized and integrated to the maximum extent, virtues” of the Chinese feudal society denied the status and
thus forming a wave of social movement. Ecofeminism and identity of women as social and cultural subjects, and only
public environmental communication gradually break regarded women as a tool for bearing children and carrying
through the limitations of groups and go to the public arena, on the family line, depending on men.
becoming a common topic in the public feld. At this time, Ecofeminism is a multicultural ecological public envi-
the social movement initiated by the women’s public en- ronment protection theory, which points out the crisis and
vironmental protection movement and other groups trap that human beings are facing in public environment
resisting the oppression of social system began to have a [32]. Ecofeminism has made positive eforts in multicul-
theoretical and practical connection, and the feminist eco- turalism. It not only pays attention to women’s human and
logical trend of thought was ready to give theoretical support cultural ecological public environment, but also emphasizes
to the public environmental justice movement. the cultural ecological environmental protection of women’s
Originally, the patriarchal society oppressed not only spirit. Tere are three aspects of women’s spiritual and
women and nature, but also vulnerable groups such as cultural ecological protection. (1) the spirit of promotion, (2)
colored people and low-income people. Like women, they paying attention to the cultivation of inner nature, and (3)
are also excluded from the public sphere, lack the corre- having a conscious sense of regeneration. In essence, the
sponding science and technology and the opportunity to combination of spiritual and social dimensions is a con-
participate in public decision-making, and thus cannot enjoy scious act to protect the cultural ecological environment.
equal environmental welfare and become victims of the Harmonious cultural ecological environmental protec-
public environmental crisis. In addition, when faced with tion is a harmonious cooperative system of equal symbiosis
environmental problems, the cries for help from other formed by the internal and external elements and their
vulnerable groups like women are often not taken seriously. interaction of the humanistic interactive system consciously
Ordinary people’s accusations about chemical pollution or realized through humanism. Cultural ecology is a world
other public environmental problems are considered to be created for humans, more systematic than nature or con-
too emotional or ignorant. Teir beliefs and voices expressed ceptual natural ecology. It not only includes the transfor-
in public forums are often defned by government ofcials as mation of people’s ideological and moral quality, but also
unseemly or inappropriate. includes people’s scientifc and cultural quality. It has the
tradition of thousands of years of historical and cultural
3. Multicultural Ecofeminism Public accumulation, but also faces the impact of foreign culture,
Environmental Protection with the important task of cultural innovation.
In the process of China’s rapid modernization, the status of 4. Ecofeminist Interpretation of Sons
women has witnessed a downward trend. Although they and Lovers
have participated in a lot of work, the status and role of
women have not been recognized much, and women’s 4.1. Sons and Lovers Review. Author, poet, and essayist
employment and development are also faced with difculties David Herbert Lawrence was born in England. His works are
[31]. In present-day China, as ecofeminism points out, the primarily based on his early experiences in
Journal of Environmental and Public Health 5
Nottinghamshire, which had a signifcant impact on his life. Lawrence attempted to awaken human beings’ aware-
His work refects modernity’s and industrialization’s ness of ecofeminism by depicting the oppression of women
dehumanizing efects. Lawrence had spent his entire life and environment, demonstrating the specifc relationship
being concerned about human sexuality; emotional health; between both. Lawrence described the ideal relationship
and relationships between men, women, and nature (public between women and public environment as one of harmony,
environment). His novels and short stories have been peace, and love, and he encouraged humans to create this
reprinted in huge numbers and translated into a variety of kind of ideal relationship.
languages around the world. Sons and Lovers is still one of Men in Sons and Lovers desired to master public en-
the most popular works among the readers [33]. vironment, but men’s inner selves yearn for it as well. Pa-
Sons and Lovers, frst published in 1913, is today regarded triarchy refers to the male-dominated framework of modern
as Lawrence’s early masterpiece and semiautobiographical culture and political institutions. Women’s rights are
novel. Furthermore, it is usually regarded as the frst signif- thought to be jeopardized by such arrangements. However,
icant novel to depict the lives of English working-class people. it has been noted that patriarchal systems of government do
It came ninth on a list of the 100 best novels in English of the not beneft all men of all classes. Te exploiters’ desire for
20th century by the Modern Library in 1999. According to property outweighed their desire for a healthy environment.
Lawrence, the novel’s goal is to depict the tragedy of all British Te working class had no choice but to take whatever came
kids of his generation. Chinese critics and scholars have used a their way and labored to make a living.
variety of theoretical frameworks to understand Sons and Men and women should have common topics, and
Lovers, including postmodernism, Freudian psychoanalysis, should communicate with each other. Te status between
archetypal criticism, ethical critique, and feminist criticism. them should be equal, not be oppressed. In addition, they
Sons and Lovers is examined from an ecofeminist should have harmonious sexual life and spiritual commu-
viewpoint in this section. Public environment and women nication. Lawrence held the opinion that there was no need
are intrinsically intertwined, according to ecofeminism, and to yoke them with any bond at all. Te only morality is to
patriarchy is their common source of domination. Te most have man true to his manhood, woman to her womanhood,
important contribution of ecofeminism is the recognition of and let the relationship form by itself, in all honor. Terefore,
various socioeconomic injustices and oppressions caused by the ideal relationship between man and woman should be
patriarchal ideals. that “both are equal, two in one complete.” A couple should
With its descriptions of public environment, various be equal and love each other, they should depend on each
female characters, and the disharmonious relationship other, overcome the diferences of culture background and
between men and women, Lawrence convincingly con- the difculties in life together, raise children together, and
veys the permanent traumas of public environment, the spend life together.
suppressed helpless existence of women, and the asso- Troughout his life, Lawrence was concerned about the
ciated sorrow of men in Sons and Lovers. Lawrence’s links between women and public environment, men and
statements are all refective of his ecofeminist ideas and public environment, and women and men. He loved the
desire for peaceful and harmonious interactions between environment. Public environment was well described in
men and women, as well as people and the public en- Sons and Lovers. However, the Industrial Revolution had an
vironment. As a result, an ecofeminist reading of the text impact on his hometown. He saw the damaged landscapes
clarifes the book’s complicated public environment and and the vanishing woods. He was also witness to men-
gender concerns. women confrontations. As a result, he pushed for the
preservation of environment and the liberation of women.
He maintained that public environment, men, and women
4.2. Te Ideal Relationship from the Perspective of should all live in harmony. Tis subsection will discuss the
Ecofeminism. Tere were many vivid depictions of public ideal relationships from the perspective of ecofeminism, as
environments in Lawrence’s childhood, which may be ob- well as the origins of Lawrence’s ideas.
served in his novel. Public environment was destroyed as a Lawrence’s enthusiasm for the environment was pri-
result of the Industrial Revolution. Lawrence began to con- marily infuenced by his father, Arthur Lawrence, who was
demn men’s actions and called for preserving public envi- passionate about wildlife and knew a lot about it. He would
ronment after witnessing his beloved environment being occasionally bring fowers or animals home and tell his
destroyed. Lawrence was infuenced by several women during children their names. He would tell his children about the
his life. He admired them. However, women had no status plants and animals when they went on a walk outside.
during his age. Many women participated in women’s Lawrence had a natural passion for the public environment
movements to fght for their rights. Lawrence supported the since he was a youngster, due to his father’s infuence. Te
women’s movements after being infuenced by his female Chambers relocated to the Haggs Farm as teenagers, and
acquaintances. In Sons and Lovers, Lawrence combined Lawrence paid them regular visits. He was enamored by
themes of environmental protection with issues of women’s gardens, houses, trees, fowers, and the countryside.
rights protection. Lawrence’s concepts were in line with Lawrence embraced certain feminist ideals as a result of
ecofeminism’s principles, despite the fact that ecofeminism female infuence. Tese women’s images served as models
had not yet been proposed. His ecofeminist notion was por- for the heroines in his novels. He was a strong supporter of
trayed by his views in the novel. women’s rights movements. He did not like dominant
6 Journal of Environmental and Public Health
women who wanted to be in charge of everything. He ad- ecological nature, refecting their strong potential and power
vocated for women to have the same rights, position, and in public environmental protection. Women’s involvement
opportunities as males. On the other hand, he did not and participation in public environmental issues is their
support women discriminating against men. In his opinion, attempts and eforts to enter the public domain, resist pa-
men and women should depend on each other. Moreover, triarchy, and change social status. Tey show society a
Lawrence hopes for a harmonious relationship flled with unique perspective to solve public environmental issues by
love among the three—men, women, and public respecting diferences and diversity, which provides a new
environment. path for women to participate in public afairs and realize
Lawrence’s views on the interactions between men and their own liberation, and also provides a way for countries
environment, as well as men and women, are ecofeminist. around the world to deal with national and social issues.
Ecofeminists believe that women and public environments
have a direct relationship. Te patriarchal culture, which Data Availability
holds women and public environment to be inferior to
males, is the basis of the same oppressive condition. Tis All data used to support the fndings of the study are in-
system defends men’s dominance and women’s subjection to cluded within this paper.
public environment. Tus men are the masters of all things,
while women and public environment should obey the Conflicts of Interest
orders from men. Te same oppression makes women and
public environment unite together. All authors declare that there are no conficts of interest.
Ultimately, Sons and Lovers is a masterpiece in which
Lawrence expresses his concern for men’s, women’s, and References
natural connections. Lawrence hopes to raise public
[1] E. M. Arjona, “Ecofeminism and interculturality,” FEMI-
awareness about the need of protecting environment and NISMO-S, vol. 34, pp. 199–214, 2019.
women. Te current climate is peculiar, and the entire world [2] C. Mallory, “Environmental justice, ecofeminism, and power,
is constantly threatened by global economic and ecological linking ecology and ethics for a changing world: values,
crises. Terefore, rereading Sons and Lovers from an eco- philosophy,” Action, vol. 1, pp. 251–258, 2013.
feminist viewpoint is extremely important. Tis novel in- [3] G. A. T. Gonzalez, “Te critical ecofeminism of alicia puleo:
spires us to create a future in which men, women, and public weaving the thread of the “new ariadna”,” Investigaciones
environment all enjoy healthy and peaceful interactions. Feministas, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 267–282, 2017.
Tus, we can establish a nice public environment in this way. [4] X. X. Gao, “Critical analysis of “nature-women” metaphor
from ecofeminism,” in Proceedings of the 2012 International
Symposium—Women’s Human Resources Development &
5. Conclusion Management, pp. 7–11, Vienna, Austria, 2013.
[5] A. Gough and H. Whitehouse, “Challenging amnesias: re-
Taking the isomorphism between nature and women as a collecting feminist new materialism/ecofeminism/climate/
logical starting point, ecofeminists have profoundly education,” Environmental Education Research, vol. 26,
expounded that the root of ecological crisis is closely related pp. 1420–1434, 2020.
to patriarchal culture. Te emergence and meaning of [6] E. Ekinci, “Ecofeminism in the context of women and ecol-
ecofeminism are rights and promises, and its ultimate goal ogy,” in Proceedings of the 11th RSEP International Multi-
and ideal is to strive for the equality and harmonious de- disciplinary Conference, pp. 8–12, Vienna, Austria, 2019.
velopment of men and women. Ecofeminism has a unique [7] Z. R. Ding, “Comparative study of ecofeminism in Chinese
rational thinking and new insights, and its logical meth- and western feminist literature,” in Proceedings of the Sixth
odology is from heroic ethics to comprehensive ethics. As Northeast Asia International Symposium on Language, Lit-
erature and Translation, pp. 337–341, Datong, China, 2018.
the pioneer of public environmental protection, women
[8] Y. S. Zhao, Y. Xiong, and L. J. Li, “Appreciation of william and
have made great contributions to the common liberation of dorothy wordsworth from ecofeminism perspective, 3RD
public environment and women. As the practice pioneer of international conference on education and social develop-
public environmental protection, women have made great ment,” ICESD 2017), vol. 129, pp. 763–766, 2018.
contributions to the public environment and the common [9] Y. Qiu, “From androcentrism to ecofeminism: gary snyder’s
liberation of women. Public environmental protection af- goddess worship,” ORBIS Litterarum, vol. 77, 2021.
fected by ecological feminism was initially a conscious in- [10] D. Laplonge, “Exploring the distance between ecofeminism
dividual mobilization behavior caused by worrying about and women in mining (WIM),” Extractive Industries and
family life. After entering the middle of the 20th century, Society, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 843–849, 2016.
under the sustained reporting, shaping, and mobilization of [11] W. H. Wang, “Rereading jane eyre from the perspective of
the foreign mass media, public environment protection ecofeminism,” Foreign Literature Studies, vol. 30, no. 1,
pp. 119–124, 2008.
began to gradually move to the public stage, connect with the
[12] J. Devika and V. S. Caregiver, “Citizen? refections on eco-
issue of justice, promote a wave of social movement in- feminism from Kerala state, India,” Man in India, vol. 90,
volving the whole people, and ultimately exceed the limits of pp. 251–269, 2010.
the national framework. In the process of women’s public [13] C. Mallory, “Locating ecofeminism in encounters with food
environmental protection, their understanding of nature has and place,” Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics,
undergone a transformation from “housekeeping” nature to vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 171–189, 2013.
Journal of Environmental and Public Health 7
[14] Q. Q. Wei, “Toward a holistic ecofeminism: a Chinese per- [32] Y. Liu, M. K. Anser, and K. Zaman, “Ecofeminism and natural
spective,” Comparative Literature Studies, vol. 55, no. 4, resource management: justice delayed, justice denied,” Sus-
pp. 773–786, 2018. tainability, vol. 13, no. 13, p. 7319, 2021.
[15] F. A G Oliveira, “Te sexist diet: contributions from critical [33] M. Y. Wang, “An analysis of ideology in D. H. Lawrenc’s sons
ecofeminism for a decolonialization of the palate,” Question, and lovers,” in Proceedings of the Fourth Northeast Asia In-
vol. 1, no. 64, 2019. ternational Symposium on Language, Literature and Trans-
[16] A. J. Njoh and E. N. M. Ayuk-Etang, “Determinants of lation, pp. 295–289, Beijing, China, 2015.
ecofeminism in anglophone cameroon: a pestech analysis,”
Journal of Asian and African Studies, vol. 56, no. 7,
pp. 1538–1558, 2021.
[17] X. Y. Wang, “Women and construction of an ecological
civilization from the perspective of ecofeminism,” in Pro-
ceedings of the 2017 International Symposium—Female Sur-
vival and Development, pp. 102–107, Colombo, Sri Lanka,
2017.
[18] R. K. d. Rocha, A. K. T. Feldman, and M. C. Silva, “Ecocrı́tica e
ecofeminismo: uma leitura do conto “A porca”,” Revista
Ártemis, vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 30–45, 2020.
[19] I. Konik, “Ubuntu and ecofeminism: value-building with
african and womanist voices,” Environmental Values, vol. 27,
no. 3, pp. 269–288, 2018.
[20] X. Gu, “Challenges and public participation strategies on
coastal resources protection in China,” in Proceedings of the
2012 International Conference on Public Administration,
pp. 843–848, Bucharest, Romania, 2012.
[21] B. Bartniczak, “State Aid in Environment Protection in
Scandinavian Countries,” Hradec Economic Days, 2011.
[22] Y. X. Liu, “On universal design methods focusing on envi-
ronment resources protection,” in Proceedings of the 9th
International Conference on Computer-Aided Industrial De-
sign & Conceptual Design, pp. 153–156, Kunming, China,
2008.
[23] B. Kauder, N. Potrafke, and H. Ursprung, “Behavioral de-
terminants of proclaimed support for environment protection
policies,” European Journal of Political Economy, vol. 54,
pp. 26–41, 2018.
[24] Z. F. Yang and Q. L. Li, “Research on the construction of social
co-governance system of ecological environment protection,”
in Proceedings of the 2020 Asia Conference on Geological
Research and Environmental Technology, p. 632, Kamakura,
Japan, 2021.
[25] Q. F. Han, S. L. Ge, and J. L. Yu, “Te relationship between
ecological environment protection and social development to
Chinese resource-exhausted cities,” in Proceedings of the 2016
International Conference on Public Management (ICPM 2016),
Kumming, China, 2017.
[26] S. E. Kings, “Intersectionality and the changing face of eco-
feminism,” Ethics and the Environment, vol. 22, no. 1,
pp. 63–87, 2017.
[27] Q. Q. Wei, ““Staying female while knowing male”: a new
interpretation of ecofeminism in a cross-cultural context,”
Foreign Literature Studies, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 145–153, 2014.
[28] C. L. Klemmer and K. A. McNamara, “Deep ecology and
ecofeminism: social work to address global environmental
crisis,” Aflia, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 503–515, 2020.
[29] G. Gaard, “Ecofeminism and climate change,” Women’s
Studies International Forum, vol. 49, pp. 20–33, 2015.
[30] M. A. B. Bravo, “Ecofeminism: a new way to look at nature,”
Arbor-Ciencia Pensamiento y Cultura, vol. 192, no. 778, 2016.
[31] D. Li, “Ecofeminist literary criticism in mainland China: a
window into China’s academic globalization,” Asian Women,
vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 37–58, 2013.