BOM Performance Monitoring and Evaluation
BOM Performance Monitoring and Evaluation
June 2023
Dire Da wa District
Introduction
CBE has star te d te sti ng the Branc h Op e rati ng Mo d e l ( BOM) i n 1 0
sample branches since February 20, 2023.
Dire Da wa District
Introduction
Operation team - ensures speedy service delivery at all times
Estab lish c ad enc e f or p erf orm anc e m easurem ent and p erf orm anc e
dialogue
Dire Da wa District
Basic Conditions for the Test
Te s t b ra n c h e s - s h o u l d m a k e s u r e a l l r e l e v a n t p r e p a ra t o r y w o r k s a r e
performed and satisfied before starting the test exercise
5. Rehearse staff about the Bank's dressing code, core values and ethical
standards,
7. Ensure system access of staff are updated as per the new role.
Dire Da wa District
Basic Conditions for the Test
8. Call for m aintenanc e of any defec tive equipm ent and furniture in the
branch,
Dire Da wa District
Responsible Organs
1. Branch Manager -
I. Aware staff about this document and expectation of the Bank through
the test
III. Monitor the day-to-day test progress as per the criteria set herewith
VI. C o m p i l e re p o r t f o r w a rd e d b y re t a i l , w h o l e s a l e a n d I F B t e a m a n d
forward to District
Dire Da wa District
Responsible Organs
2. Branch Internal Control Team -
III. Com pile overall observation report and subm it to district and branch
team
I. Analyze eac h branc h perform anc e and determ ine sc oring on weekly
basis and provide feedback to test branch(s)
II. Identify key strength and weakness areas and provide enhancement or
corrective recommendations
III. Visit branch(s) at least once in a week (may not be performed all units
together)
Dire Da wa District
Responsible Organs
IV. Check customer suggestion book for confirmation of logged customer
feedback
VI. Send weekly performance monitoring report to RBD and RB & IFB TO
Dire Da wa District
Responsible Organs
5. Retail Business Development Department -
II. Collect and compile weekly performance monitoring report of the test
branches
III. D i s c u s s a n d m o n i t o r t h e p e r f o r m a n c e p ro g re s s w i t h R B & I F B T O
department and create ownership
VI. Submit weekly report to EVP for further decision and direction
Dire Da wa District
Responsible Organs
IV. Work with RBD to identify champion branch of the week
V I . A r ra n g e m e e t i n g s b e t w e e n R B D, R B & I F B T O a n d M e a s u re m e n t &
Tracking teams to deliberate the weekly progress
I. Perform the performance tracking and monitoring with RBD and RB& IF
-B TO
III. Advise RBD and RB&IFB TO how to scale the metric for rollout
- C V P i np ut s, a l t e rna t i v e p ro d uc t p ro m o t i o n o p t i o ns b a se d o n
customer feedback
- Redesign workflows
Dire Da wa District
High Level Branch KPIs
the m o ni to ri ng w i l l hav e at l e ast 5 m aj o r c ate g o ri e s f o r w e e kl y
compilation
T h e h i g h e st w e i g h t i s g i v e n to re sp o nsi v e ne ss a nd t h e l e a st i s
assigned to proactive customer engagement
much emphasis is given for responsiveness because the major change area of the
o pe rating mo d e l is to d e d ic ate te ams fo r an e nd - to - e nd d e live ry and to maintain
single point of contact for customers
1 Service excellence 20 %
3 Responsiveness 25 %
4 Sales 20 %
Total 105 %
Dire Da wa District
Breakdown of Major KPIs
The major criteria are detailed into 27 measures most of which needs
to be monitored manually by each team in the branch
The test branc h Control team shall independently take m easurem ent
and report to the branch & district Retail & Branch Banking team about
customer satisfaction and service delivery time independently
Fro m t h e 2 7 m e a s u re s l i s t e d b e l o w 1 2 ( 6 1 % ) o f t h e m a re t o b e
measured manually while the rest 15(39%) are to be downloaded from
system
Dire Da wa District
Breakdown of Major KPIs
The Operation team takes 43% of the performance
Dire Da wa District
Breakdown of Major KPIs
From strategic importance point of view :-
m o re t ha n 6 3 % ( 1 4 ) o f t he m e a sure s a re re l e v a nt f o r c re a t i ng
'customer centric' CBE branch
Dire Da wa District
Breakdown of KPIs with corresponding weight
1 Service excellence 20 %
10 % Oper & Ser Cust
1.1 CSAT Rate Centric
10% Oper & Ser Cus
1.2 SDT Centric
2.2 #of teller transactions < 10K* 5% Oper & Ser Cost Efficient
5% Operation Cost
2.3 Ratio of teller transaction <IOK Efficient
Dire Da wa District
Breakdown of KPIs with corresponding weight
3 Responsiveness 25%
5.4 #of visits at POS merchant site 3% Sales & RM Dig Lead
A l l s e r v i c e s a re d e l i v e re d a t l e a s t a s p e r t h e s t a n d a rd s e r v i c e
delivery time with courtesy and responsiveness
The daily number of samples should not be lower than 1Di0re Dawa District
Operationalization of KPIs
Timing Of Survey
The SDT start counting when customer f inish f illing relevant forms or taking queue
ticket (if available), and called and ends at the time of transaction advice receipt or
cash collection. Dire Da wa District
Operationalization of KPIs
For new custom er's account opening, the serv ice shall be reported to
be completed at the time of customer authorization by the HO team
T h e M e e t e r - G r e e t e r s h o u l d e n c o u ra g e c u s t o m e r s t o p r o v i d e t h e i r
feedback at all times
Dire Da wa District
SDT compilation summary
Dire Da wa District
Standard service delivery times
Dire Da wa District
Staff Productivity and effectiveness
B. Staff Productivity and effectiveness
balance confirmation
Troubleshooting
I. Transaction to teller ratio - this involves the ratio of all cash deposit,
cash withdrawal and custom er fund transfer transactions processed
under the Operation Team throughout the day to the number of tellers
available in the day.
- Tellers who worked for half day should be included in the teller count as
full-day
Dire Da wa District
Staff Productivity and effectiveness
Target for this ratio
Tellers who processed m ore than 100 transactions per day should be
celebrated at the branch.
Dire Da wa District
summary of teller transactions per day
Dire Da wa District
Number of teller cash withdrawal transactions less than ET B 10,000
II. Number of teller cash withdrawal transactions less than ET B 10,000 :
I n v o l v e s a c o u n t o f l o w v a l u e t e l l e r c a s h w i t h d ra w a l t ra n s a c t i o n s
am ounting to E T B 1 0 , 0 0 0 whic h c ould hav e b een p roc essed throug h
our ATM channel.
T h e M e e t e r G re e t e r s h o u l d b a l a n c e a l l o c a t i o n o f t h e s e l o w v a l u e
Dire Da wa District
Target for low value teller transactions
Dire Da wa District
Ratio of teller transaction less than ET B 10,000
III. Ratio of teller transaction less than ET B 10,000:
I s t h e ra t i o o f c a s h w i t h d ra w a l t ra n s a c t i o n s w i t h v a l u e l e s s t h a n E T B
10,000 to the total number of cash withdrawal transactions processed in
the branch
The branch should provide relevant justif ication for the number of cash
withdrawal transactions with value less than ETB 10,00D0ire.Dawa District
Number of fund transfer transactions less than ETB 200,000:
This is the ratio of fund transfer transactions in the branch (not by the
operation team only) with value less than ETB 200,000 to the total fund
transfer transaction processed by all teams.
Dire Da wa District
Responsiveness
C. Responsiveness
To b e c u s t o m e r c e n t r i c b y a d d r e s s i n g c u s t o m e r p a i n a r e a s a n d
increasing customer gains.
i. N u m b e r o f f e e d b a c k / i s s u e re c e i v e d i n v o l v e s a l l i s s u e s t h a t h a v e
been reported by customers of the branch orally or in writing
re c o rd t h e c u s t o m e r f e e d b a c k i n t h e c u s t o m e r s u g g e s t i o n re g i s t e r
including address of customers
Dire Da wa District
Number of feedback/ issue closed
i i . N u m b e r o f f e e d b a c k / i s s u e c l o s e d : a l l s e r v i c e i n c i d e n t s ra i s e d b y
customers should be closed by the branch within the same date .
S u c h c l o s u re s h o u l d b e re c o rd e d i n t h e re g i s t e r b o o k n e x t t o t h e
customer feedback by the Control Manager
Dire Da wa District
Number of issues escalated
i i i . N um b e r o f i ssue s e sc a l a t e d : i f t he c usto m e r i ssue i s b e yo nd t he
b ra n c h e s i n f lu e n c e , i t s h o u l d b e e s c a l a t e d t o t h e d i s t r i c t t e a m s f o r
resolution.
ATM
Lasrtedc
ato
encNiluiamtiboenr soufmi m
t ea
mrsy Days since last
ATM No. ATM Remark
reconciled adjusted per week reconciliation
Dire Da wa District
summary of sales and service dialogue
Dire Da wa District
Sales target
D. Sales target
Dire Da wa District
Additional deposit mobilized
ii. Additional deposit mobilized: this should align with the monthly deposit
target of the branch despite earlier achievement of same.
Retail 1%
Wholesale 1%
IFB 1%
Total 3%
Dire Da wa District
FCY mobilized:
i i i . FC Y m o b i l i z e d : t hi s sho ul d a l i g n w i t h t he m o nt hl y FC Y m o b i l i z a t i o n
target of the branch despite earlier achievement of same.
Dire Da wa District
Incremental deposit from cross-sell and upsell
iv. Incremental deposit from cross-sell and upsell: Should align with item (
I ) above but for amount of deposits mobilized from selected customers.
The list of inactive accounts which the branch sales team will contact
with a corresponding deposit target should be communicated with the
District team ahead of every week starting.
Dire Da wa District
Digital penetration
v. Digital penetration: this should align with the monthly digital target of
the branch despite earlier achievement of same.
Digital channel P lan Actual (B) Deviation Percentage Weight (E’) Score
(A) (C=B-A) (D=C/B)
Mobile Banking 2%
Mobi
le money 1%
Card banking 1%
Internet banking 1%
Total 5%
Dire Da wa District
Proactive customer engagement
E. Proactive customer engagement branch sales team are expected to
engage with customers proactively by building clear understanding about
the c usto m e r p ro f il e ( ac c o unt & transac ti o n hi sto ry, d e m o g rap hi c and
economic data).
the sales team at the branch should prioritize Retail (Middle and Mass)
and Wholesale (Micro) customers
Dire Da wa District
weekly customer contact plan
Customer Customer Segment Customer Call Call Expected Remark
ID Name Potential Agenda schedule Outcome
Dire Da wa District
weekly customer contact or call summary report
Customer ID Customer Segment Call Date Realized Remark
Name Agenda Called Outcome
Dire Da wa District
Number of cards delivered to customers
i i . N u m b e r o f c a rd s d e l i v e re d t o c u s t o m e r s : S a l e s a n d s e r v i c e t e a m
should work together to identify c ustom ers in whose nam e AT M c ard is
produced but not delivered
Dire Da wa District
Number of customer issues resolved
iii. Number of customer issues resolved: Sales team should engage with
the c ustom er to understand their p ain p oints, g ain areas and learn their
aspirations.
NO. Customer
SaleSsegtm
eaem
nt
or RPM customer issue register
hone Contact Feedback Resolution Staff
No. Date Name
Abebe Retail-Affluent
Kebede
Challa Gurmu Retail-Middle
Meaza Wholesale-
Gedeon SME
Dire Da wa District
Habru Kesete Wholesale-
Number of visits at POS Merchant location
i v. N um b e r o f v i si ts at P OS Me rc hant l o c ati o n: RM, se rv i c e and sal e s
t e a m s s h o u l d c o o rd i n a t e a n d s c h e d u l e t h e i r v i s i t s c h e d u l e w i t h P O S
merchants.
No. MeW
rceheaknlty PO
MSerm
chearncthanVtisliot catio
Vnisivtiinsgit plO
abnjective Remark
Name Site Date & staff
Hr
Dire Da wa District
District Team KPI
District Team KPI
Distric t Retail, Wholesale, I F-B and Digital Banking team s give strong
support
T h e v a r i a t i o n a m o n g b ra n c h e s i s b a s i c a l l y d r i v e n b y i n d i v i d u a l
difference of leadership not institutional clarity of what should be done.
The district Retail, IFB, Wholesale and Digital Teams should track their
performance and report same to RBD on weekly basis.
A c c o m p a n y i n g b ra n c h d u r i n g c u s t o m e r v i s i t s : T h e d i s t r i c t t e a m
(Wholesale, IFB and Retail) should visit impactful branch customers.
Countercheck customer calls: the district team (Wholesale, IFB and Retail)
should select sample customers and make telephone calls to confirm that
branches are actually doing the proactive engagement.
Dire Da wa District
District Team KPI
Branch customer call counter check summary
No. Segment Number of calls Number of Number of Number of
successful calls samples checked calls
selected
Retail
Whole sale
IF-B
Dire Da wa District
District Team KPI
Number of resolved and escalated issues: Is a measure of how effective
and ef ficient are the district teams in responding to issues escalated from
branches
Dire Da wa District
District Team KPI
Branch visit: State the date when the district team paid visit to test branch
including key observations and support provided.
A T M r e c o n c i l i a t i o n m o n i t o r i n g : p r o v i d e c o n f ir m a t i o n o n A T M
reconciliation record of the branch is up-to-date and assist to realize such
initiatives.
Dire Da wa District
Reporting Period and Reporting Hierarchy of the KP1s
Reporting Period and Reporting Hierarchy of the KP1s
T h e m a n u a l d a t a t ra c k i n g s h a l l b e p e r f o r m e d b y t h e r e s p o n s i b l e
branch staff
Dire Da wa District
Dire Dawa District