Yusuph
Yusuph
RESEARCH PROPOSAL
by
YUSUPH R. YUSUPH
BSc/GB/T.22/042
NOV 2024
ABSTRACT...............................................................................................................................................iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT..............................................................................................................................v
DEDICATION............................................................................................................................................vi
CERTIFICATION......................................................................................................................................viii
CHAPTER ONE..........................................................................................................................................1
INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................................................................1
CHAPTER TWO.........................................................................................................................................7
LITERATURE REVIEW................................................................................................................................7
ii
CHAPTER THREE.....................................................................................................................................13
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY...................................................................................................................13
3.1Research Approach...........................................................................................................................13
3.4.1 Population....................................................................................................................................14
APPENDICES...........................................................................................................................................18
BUDGET.................................................................................................................................................18
REFERENCES..........................................................................................................................................20
iii
ABSTRACT
This proposal aims to investigate the impact of the Competence Based Curriculum on students’
academic performance at secondary schools in Bagamoyo, Tanzania. The study will be
conducted at Hassanali Damji memorial trust Secondary School and Kingani Secondary School,
with a focus on understanding how the new curriculum has influenced students’ learning
outcomes. The findings of this research will provide valuable insights for educators,
policymakers, and other stakeholders in the education sector.
This research proposal aims to investigate the role of competence-based curriculum on students’
academic performance at secondary schools in Bagamoyo, Tanzania. The study will employ a
mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative and qualitative data to analyze the relationship
between the implementation of a competence-based curriculum and students’ academic
outcomes. The findings of this study will provide valuable insights into the effectiveness of the
competence-based curriculum in improving students’ academic performance and will contribute
to the ongoing debate on curriculum reform in Tanzania.
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude to Marian University College, Hassanali Damji
memorial trust Secondary School, and Kingani Secondary School for granting me permission to
conduct this research. I am also thankful to my supervisor for their guidance and support
throughout this project.
Mostly I would like to thanks much the following individuals and organizations for their support
and assistance in conducting this research proposal;
Rev. ELIAS RUVAHOFI - Coordinator
Mr. FRANCE P. MDOE - supervisor or mentor
My PARENTS – for financial services
Mr. SIXBETH KASUNZU - Hassanali Damji memorial trust Secondary School headmaster
MAADAM KANYEMA – Kingani Secondary School academic master
v
DEDICATION
I dedicate this proposal to my family, friends, and mentors who have supported and encouraged
me throughout this research journey. Their unwavering belief in me has been a constant source
of inspiration.
This research is dedicated to the students, teachers, and administrators of Hassanali Damji
memorial trust Secondary School and Kingani Secondary School, as well as the staff of Marian
University College, for their support and cooperation throughout the research process.
vi
DECLARATION AND COPYRIGHT:
I hereby declare that all the information presented in this proposal is true and accurate to the best
of my knowledge. I also declare that I have obtained all necessary permissions and licenses for
the use of any copyrighted material included in this proposal.
Copyright
Copyright © 2024 yusuph yusuph
[email protected]
0787132568
vii
CERTIFICATION
I certify that this proposal entitled “The Role of Competence Based Curriculum on Students’
Academic Performance at Secondary Schools in Bagamoyo, Tanzania” is my original work and
has not been submitted for any other degree or qualification. All sources of information used in
this proposal have been duly acknowledged.
This research proposal has been conducted under the supervision of Marian University College
and has been carried out at Hassanali Damji memorial trust Secondary School and Kingani
Secondary School in Bagamoyo, Tanzania. The research has been conducted in accordance with
the ethical standards and guidelines provided by the relevant authorities.
viii
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Study conducted in Norway by (Germeten, 2011) aimed to explore the New National Curriculum
in Norway and it focused on the role of school principals. The findings specified that although
they were assigned the responsibility of implementing the competence based curriculum, they
were not part of any decisions taken. This finding further suggested that the principals were not
involved in the process of competence based curriculum development though they were
implementers. This remained a challenge if curriculum implementers are not involved in the
process of development, the implementation of competency-based curriculum would not be
effective.
Study conducted conducted in Israel by (Benavot andResh 2003), showed that in recent years,
the predominance of the nation-state as the sole mediator of curricular matters has eroded. New
actors and organizations, especially local schools, have acquired greater discretion over the
definition of school subjects and curricular emphases. The study investigated whether and how
different patterns of educational governance influence the actual curriculum that local schools
put into place. It was argued that uniformity/diversity in the implemented curriculum reflects
macro-level factors that is, structural and institutional characteristics of national educational
systems and meso-level factors such as community and local school characteristics. Specifically,
it investigated between-school variation in curricular implementation in two major sectors of the
Israeli public educational system: Jewish (secular), and Arab. School-based differences are
reported in course offerings and time-allocations to subject areas in each sector. In addition, it
compared actual curricular implementation in relation to official guidelines established by
central authorities. Implementation patterns between and within sectors are discussed in light of
educational governance differences and key macro- and local-level factors.
Likisa (2018), observed that Technical and Vocational Education and Training is one of the
noticeable priority areas in Ethiopian education system. Technical and Vocational Education and
Training was designed to redress the challenges of poverty, unemployment, low technological
development, and low productivity of the economy (Michael and O’Connell, 2014). The
Technical and Vocational Education and Training along with competence‐based curriculum
(CBC) were introduced in Ethiopia in 2004 in response to the skill needs in the labor market. The
primary aim of this study was to examine whether the Technical and Vocational Education and
Training curricula clearly aligned with occupational standards to ensure graduates’ employability
(Mitchell, 2015). It also examined whether the curriculum is adequate to ensure entry‐level
competence. Also in Uganda’s secondary school curriculum has undergone significant changes
from a teacher-centered/knowledge based approach to a learner-centered/competence-based
approach (Baguma, 2020). Martin and Griffiths, (2014) noted that this change was necessary to
ensure that learners can easily understand the concepts being taught in this approach without
undue stress though its Implementation is not clearly understood.
In Tanzania, Competence Based Education and Training was an approach that emphasized the
development of skills or competencies which were required in the world of work. In Competence
Based Education and Training, the focus shifted from the content or knowledge to outcomes
derived from the requirements of employment (Kyobe and Rugumayo, 2005). There were
various challenges hindering effective implementation of Competency Based Education and
Training system. For instance, effective implementation of Competence - Based Curriculum
requires proper teachers’ orientation and training, appropriate teaching and learning resources
and adequate classrooms.
2
Despite the fact that the competence-based curriculum has been implemented for eighteen years
in Tanzania it appears that students’ education achievement as seen in self-employment,
creativity, innovation and talent exploration is below the expectation of the general public
(Mokoro, 2020). This implies that challenges related to Competence- Based Curriculum
implementation have not been addressed hence the need to carry out a study in order to
adequately tackle the challenges. The issue of concern for the current study was to find out how
the practices of Competence - Based Curriculum affect the learners’ education achievement. It is
in this regard that this study aimed to assess the Effects of Competence- Based Curriculum on
Students’ Education Achievement at Secondary Schools in Bagamoyo district council in
Tanzania.
3
1.3 Objective of the Study.
1. To examine the understanding of students and teachers on the issue of competence based
curriculum
2. To describe the best teaching pedagogies that can be used in delivering competence based
curriculum
3. To determine the factors that affect the implementation and effectiveness of competence
based curriculum on secondary school at Bagamoyo district council Tanzania.
4. To explain the role of competence based curriculum on student performance at
Bagamoyo district council Tanzania.
4
1.5 Significance of the study.
Investigating the role of competence-based curriculum on student performance holds significant
implications for educational policy, curriculum development, and instructional practices.
Understanding the impact of competence-based curriculum on students' performance can provide
valuable insights for educational stakeholders, policymakers, and curriculum developers,
facilitating evidence-based decision-making and informing reforms in educational systems
5
1.8 Operational Definitions
1. Competence-Based Curriculum: This refers to an educational framework that emphasizes
the development of practical skills, knowledge, and attitudes necessary for effective
performance in real-world contexts. Competence-based curriculum focuses on the
acquisition of specific competencies, encompassing cognitive, interpersonal, and practical
skills, and often integrates authentic assessments and experiential learning approaches.
2. Student Performance: In the context of this study, student performance refers to the
demonstrated achievement, capabilities, and outcomes of learners within an educational
setting. This includes academic performance as reflected in grades, test scores, and subject
mastery, as well as the development of critical thinking, problem-solving skills, and
practical competencies essential for success in diverse academic and real-world
environments.
6
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
This chapter consists of description of competence based education, theoretical frame work,
empirical studies, students’ performance and Synthesis of Literature Review and research gap.
Therefore, according to Moon (2007) competence-based education is the one that identifies and
cultivates the potential abilities of each student, and produce manpower which is needed to carry
out the maintenance of society and support its development. Gervais (2016) also stated
Competency-based education (CBE) as “a synthesis between a liberal arts education and the
professional education movement.” Briefly, it is the redesign of the system that has developed
over the last two centuries (Everett 2019). Also, this reform has been considered among
"innovative approaches and best practices" by the US Department of Education (ED 2011). In
addition, increasingly, organizations such as the Carnegie Institute and the United Nations focus
primarily on “competence-based learning” in education reform efforts (Sullivan andDowney
2015).
7
effort to improve educational outcomes through targeted strategies and programs" (Borman and
Dowling, 2008, p. 367). This can encompass a variety of activities such as tutoring, mentoring,
educational technology implementation, curriculum modifications, and teacher professional
development.
1. Social Cognitive Theory: This theory, proposed by Albert Bandura, (1997) emphasizes the
role of observational learning and self-efficacy in shaping behavior. In the context of a
competence-based curriculum, students' performance can be influenced by them believes in
their own abilities to succeed in the tasks required by the curriculum. According to this
theory, students who perceive themselves as competent in the skills and knowledge
emphasized by the curriculum are more likely to exert effort and persist in the face of
challenges, ultimately leading to improved performance. This theory will influence this study
in the aspect of investigating the effective teaching pedagogies that can be used in delivering
the competence based curriculum. This is simply because it explains the significance of
observation in developing the competence of an individual.
8
2.3 Empirical Studies
Several empirical studies have investigated the impact of competence-based curricula on student
performance. For instance, a study by Ong'ondo (2019) examined the implementation of a
competence-based curriculum in a secondary school setting and found that students who were
exposed to this curriculum demonstrated significant improvements in their academic
performance. The study attributed these improvements to the emphasis on practical skills and
competencies embedded within the Competence-based Curriculum framework.
Another empirical study by Van den Berg, et al., (2006) explored the impact of a competence-
based curriculum on student engagement and academic achievement. The researchers found that
students who experienced a competence-based approach reported higher levels of engagement
and motivation, which subsequently contributed to improved academic performance. A more
recent study by Cobo-Rendó, et al.,(2020) investigated the effects of a competence-based
curriculum on student performance in the context of higher education. The study found that the
implementation of a competence-based approach was associated with improved academic
achievement and higher levels of satisfaction among students.
9
A study conducted by Luambano, (2018), shows that knowledge and understanding of teachers
constitute an important aspect in the implementation of competency-based curriculum during the
teaching and learning process. Indeed, the effectiveness and efficiency of Competence Based
Carriculum depends on teacher’s ability to carry out teaching and learning activities responsibly
and effectively. Also a study of Mosha (2012), students work at their own pace to demonstrate
mastery in the competencies necessary for their chosen field of study. Competency based
programs are very flexible as their structure depends on the individual learner. There is no rigid
schedule in these programs, no set semesters and no classes. Instead, students guide their
learning and control when and where they complete projects and assessments.
10
Skill Mastery: Competence-based curriculum encourages students to master specific skills,
leading to a more practical and hands-on approach to learning. This mastery can enhance
their ability to apply knowledge in real-world situations, positively influencing overall
performance.
Engagement: The focus on practical skills and real-world relevance can increase student
engagement. When students see the direct connection between what they are learning and its
practical application, they are more likely to be motivated and actively participate in the
learning process, potentially leading to improved performance.
Critical Thinking and Problem Solving: Competence-based education often places a strong
emphasis on critical thinking and problem-solving skills. As students engage with real-world
scenarios and challenges, they develop the ability to analyze situations, think critically, and
apply their knowledge to solve problems, which can positively impact their performance in
various academic tasks.
Applicability of Knowledge: Instead of rote memorization, competence-based curriculum
encourages students to understand how to apply knowledge in different contexts. This
practical application of knowledge can lead to a deeper understanding of concepts, which
may contribute to improved performance in assessments and examinations.
Despite the existing literature on the topic, there is a notable in research regarding the long-term
effects of competence-based curriculum on students' performance beyond academic
achievement. Further exploration is needed to understand the broader implications of the
Competence based Curriculum framework on students' socioemotional development, career
readiness, and lifelong learning skills. This study aims to address these gaps by examining the
role of competence-based curriculum on students' performance and identifying its multifaceted
impact on various aspects of student development.
11
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This chapter involves the methodology that will be used in carrying out the study. This chapter it
consists of research approaches and designs, population, sample size, sampling techniques, data
collection tools, data processing and analysis and ethical issues.
3.1Research Approach
The research approach for this study will be qualitative approach, Qualitative approach will be
the best research approach because it will help to obtain data which directly explain the effect of
competence based curriculum on student performance as well as giving deep information’s
concerning with the competence based education where by in-depth interview will be used as the
major method of collecting data. In in-depth Interviews the research will involves conducting in-
depth interviews with teachers, students, and educational administrators to explore their
perceptions, experiences, and attitudes towards competence-based curriculum and its impact on
student performance.
12
3.4 Sample and Sampling Techniques
3.4.1 Population
This study will include two secondary schools that are present at Bagamoyo municipal, which
are Hassanali Damji memorial trust secondary school which is located at magomeni ward and
Kingani secondary school located at Dunda ward.
This study will include secondary schools’ students, teachers and school administrators from
these two different schools.
Form four student will also be used as the sample because they are mentally mature enough and
they can be able to understand what we mean when we shall be talking about competence based
curriculum, therefore they can provide us the appropriate information compared to other lower
ordinary level classes.
13
3.5 Data Collection Tools
The study will utilize structured interviews as data collection tools. The interviews will be
designed to explore in-depth insights students, teachers and heads of schools understanding on
the issue of competence based curriculum. This instrument will be developed in the local
language to enhance understanding and will be administered by trained researchers.
Interview Method: The researcher will be done by conducting interviews with guiding
questions to gather information on the effect of competence-based curriculum in student
performance at Hassanali Damji memorial trust and kingani secondary schools at Bagamoyo
district council. This method will be used because it will allow us to clarify questions and allow
informants to respond in any way they see fit, as well as allowing us to observe verbal and
nonverbal behavior of the respondents.
1. Preparing the interview by defining the job requirements and creating the list of questions
2. Introducing the interviews by start with making a warm welcome, explaining the
interview structure and purpose
3. Asking casual question to help the candidate feel at ease.
4. Asking questions about past experiences to understand how the candidate handled
specific situations.
5. Assessing the candidate's skills and knowledge relevant to the job.
6. Exploring the candidate's values and work style to ensure alignment with the company
culture.
7. Giving the candidate an opportunity to ask questions about the role or company.
8. Summarizing key points, discuss next steps, and thank the candidate for their time.
9. After the interview, assess the candidate's responses and compare them against the job
requirements.
10. Making follow up by Communicating with the candidate regarding the outcome and
provide feedback if possible.
14
SAMPLE OF THE QUESTIONS THAT WILL BE USED IN INTERVIEWING
RESPONDENTS
Questions to the teachers and head of schools
1. What did you understand about competence based curriculum?
2. Is the competence based curriculum implemented in your school?
3. How do you plan and develop your lesson before teaching?
4. Which teaching pedagogies are used in delivering the competence based curriculum?
5. How do you evaluate your student on the competence based curriculum?
6. What are the effects of competence based curriculum on students’ performance?
7. How to improve the implementation of competent based curriculum?
15
anonymity, storage of data and privacy for the results. The researcher will ask for permission to
conduct the research and the respondents will be informed about the purpose of the study, and
that their identities would not be disclosed to other people, and that the information they
provided would remain confidential and used only for this study. Also, the question of language
barriers will be solved by producing English and Swahili that will allow all respondents to
volunteer their participation in the study.
16
APPENDICES
BUDGET
17
RESEARCH PROPOSAL SCHEDULE
The whole research processes will be conducted approximately within seven months, from
august 2024 to February 2025.
Activity Timing
Writing
proposal
Proposal
submission
Data
collection &
Data
analysis
Data
analysis &
Report
writing
Report
submission
18
REFERENCES
20
STUDENT’S NAME AND DATE
STUDENT’S NAME…………………………………………
Signature………………………………………
Date…………….
SUPERVISOR’S NAME………………………………………….
Signature……………………...
Date……………....
21