26384
26384
CRO
KMO 5 april 1985
Summary
The current 'wet' phosphoric acid processes are based on the digestion of
phosphate rock with sulphuric acid. Disadvantages of these processes are that
usually concentrated.phosporic acid can be obtained only by evaporation, and
that the phosphoric acid and the by-product, gypsum, are contaminated.with,Ra,
As, Cd and other heavy metals.
To avoid these drawbacks, a new process with a so-called pre-digestion route
has been proposed. In this process, the phosphate rock is first digested with
phosphoric acid, in this phase radium can be precipitated. Next, A s , Cd and
possibly other heavy metals are separated out, and only then Ca is removed
with sulphuric acid. During a gypsum colloquium in 1982, organized by the
14inistry for Physical Planning, and Environment of the Netherlands, DSM
pointed out that this is the only way to obtain both clean phosphoric acid and
clean gypsum. In September 1982, a government-sponsored-project for the deve-
lopment of this process on laboratory scale was started, with agreement from
the other producers of phosphate fertilizers.
The project is carried out by three doctoral candidates, under the respon-
sibility and supervision of UKF and DSM. The work on Cd-removal concentrates
on binding Cd to an immobilized organic complex, but other methods are also
.
invest igat ed
With regard to the removal of Ca, the final step in the production of
phosphoric acid, attention focusses on crystallization of a clean calcium-
sulphate-hemihydrate, that is, a hemihydrate containing the smallest possible
amount of co-crystallized phosphate. In this report, the several aspects of
the new phosphoric acid process will be discussed in detail, and particular
attention is paid to hemihydrate crystallization. The destiny of the clean -
hemihydrate can be further processing or, now that it is Cd-free, disposal as
a waste product.
Table of contents
1. Introduction
5 . Purification
6 . Hemihydrate crystallization
7. Literature
,
1. Introductionl,
Phosphoric acid is an important chemical intermediate, which is used mainly in
the fertilizer industry.
Phosphate-containing fertilizers are produced from calcium phosphate rock.
The rock usually is converted first to phosphoric acid, because in this way
readily soluble fertilizers with a high nutrient content can be obtained. Glo-
bal phosphoric acid production i s directly related to the steadily growing
demand for phosphate fertilizers, to meet the food needs of increasing world
population. Phosphoric acid is produced either by the wet process or by the
electric furnace process. In the electric furnace process, phosphate rock is
reduced, with the aid of coke, in an electric furnace.
Si02 (gravel) is added to bind the CaO released to form CaSi03. The overall
reaction is given by
1500 OC
2 Ca3(P04)2 +6 Si02 + 10 C -
-) P4 + 6 (CaO, SiO2) + 10 CaO (OH = +730 kcal)
In this reaction scheme, the presence of other impurities (F, Cog) is ignored.
Since virtually all of the impurities in the rock remain behind in the by-
product (calcium silicate slags and a ferrophosphorus alloy), the electric
furnace process yields a very pure product acid, which is used in detergents
and as nutrient phosphate.
The energy demand of the electric furnace process however is enormous.
Therefore, the world demand for phosphoric acid for use in the fertilizer
industry is met by wet-process phosphoric acid plant; the impurities in the
phosphoric acid are usually not detrimental and may even be essential as
micronutrients and for granulating the fertilizers. Total wet-process
lo6 tonnes (World-1983),. In
phosphoric acid production is enormous: ca. 32
the Netherlands, the output is 0.6 .
106 tonnes. These quantities are
expressed as 100 X H3PO4. Conversion of phosphate rock to phosphoric acid
usually takes place by reaction of the rock with sulphuric acid; calcium pre-
cipitates as calcium-sulphate-hydrate, Cas04 2 H20 or Cas04 .
35. H20, which
is subsequently filtered off.
H3P04
/* evapors- acid - 0.58
- / / t ion e
/
52 Z T205
b
+ DH/
. /
c
75-80 "C
[Ca3(P04)2]3.CaF2 + 10 H2SO4 ____* 6 H3PO4 -I- 10 Cas04 2 H20 J. + 2 HF 3.
water
0
- the gypsum as well a1 the phosphoric acid contain Ra, As, Cd and other heavy
metals.
H3P04 /
/
evapo ra-
acid - 0.58
,HH -WDH . /
t ion *
-,+ HH 1 *
/
1 complex
5 2 27 P205
50 B 60 "C
10 Cas04 .f H20 I 10 Cas04 2 H20
H2S04/H3POq/water
-4-
-
2 . Reasons for a clean phosphoric acid process4)
* UKF-Pernis
The table shows that phosphogypsum is slightly contaminated with heavy metals
(ppm-level). In Western Europe there are international skeletal agreements __
aiming at progressive reduction of gypsum dumping.
Since 1975, the Dutch National Working Party on Phosphogypsum, in which the
. governement and the phosphate fertilizer industry are represented, has been ~
I J I. hemihydrate 1.3
1 T;: lattice P205
/
4
H3P0 /
- 0
HH 1, /
/
product acid
-
'
. return acid -c
ca. 42 ,"d P205
- H3P04
+ HH /
-
0
/
/
0
HH - DH
-
- ,
/
/
/
/
L A /
In principle, there are three ways to obiain clean gypsum, possibly in com-
bination with clean'phosphoric acid:
- using clean phosphate rock;
- gypsum purification
- a clean phosphoric acid process.
Almost all phosphate rocks are sedimentary deposits. Igneous rocks are much
purer, especially with regard to heavy metals (Cd 8 ppm; Ra 1-2.10'6 ppm).
However, their lead content is the same or higher. The world reserves of
igneous rock are very limited, so that the use of igneous phosphate as raw
material is no solution of the purity problem.
product acid -
pre-
diges-
purif i-
cation
HH-
precipi- L /
- 9.64
L-
/
t ion tation / 47 % P*05
I ,/ / -
I
impurities
I I I 11
After the pre-digestion step, during which special measures are taken to pre-
cipitate radium, first As, Cd and possibly other heavy metals are removed;
after this Ca is removed by HH-precipitation with H2SO4:
- Pre-digestion:
[Ca3(P04)2]3 .
CaF2 + excessive amount of phosphoric acid + Ca(H2P04)~ in
phosphoric acid.
- Purification: measures for removal of undes€rable elements. Possibly,
measures are taken to prevent incorporation of Cd in HH. In that case, only
the product acid still needs to be purified.
- Calcium sulphate precipitation:
2 Ca(H~P04)2 + 2 H2SO4 + H20 -+ 2 Cas04 . +
f H20 + 4 H3PO4.
Since the current phosphoric acid processes (e.&, UKF Pernis) involve a high
energy cost for evaporation of product acid (30 X P2O5) to concentrated
phosphoric acid (52 % P2O5>, the variable production costst of phosphoric acid
production according to the pre-digestion route, in which concentrated acid is
obtained directly, may well be lower than the variable costs of current
-
processes, so that production of clean phosphoric acid and gypsum according td
the pre-digestion route may be possible at not too high additional costs.
In cooperation with DSM and UKF, the Delft Institute of Technology has been
doing exploratory work on pre-digestion and on removal of Ra and heavy metals.
In particular, the precipitation of Cd as a Cd complex has been studied.
During a gypsum colloquium in March 1982, which was organized by the then
Mihistry of Health and Environment of the Netherlands, DSM pointed out that
production of clean phosphoric acid and clean gypsum required new technology,
and in September 1982 a government-sponsored development project was started
at the Delft Institute of Technology, with agreement from the Dutch Phosphate
Fertilizer Industry and under the responsibility and supervision of UKF and
DSM, Since late 1983 early 1984 and early 1985 three doctoral candidates are
working on the project.
Figure 6 . The relation between the phosphoric acid concentration and the tem-
perature at which the maximum percentage of CaO dissolves
% P O 2./
5.5
2t5 47 % P,O,
/-120 I o (y boiling
point)
dissolved CaO
/
constant at about 5 . 7 0
lo 1I
0
I
20
1
40
I
60
I
80 100
I I
120
I
140
I
160
-t
__
Temp. in OC
phosphoric acid technology which is being developed. If too many sulphate ions
are present in the recycled acid, precipitation of calcium sulphate on the
surface of the phosphate rock particles may present a major problem, because
the resultant impermeable coating around the particles blocks further
digestion. This problem may also arise in current processes with also a large
amount of HH already being produced in the predigestion step. When the con-
-7-
5. Purification
---------------
5.1. Ra-removal
In one version of the process (DSM), the pre-digestion of the phosphate with
phosphoric acid (return acid) is combined with simultaneous precipitation of
ca. 10 % of the calcium ions by addition of a suitable quantity of sulphuric
acid to the return acid. By, for example, flocculation, followed by
f.iltration, the fine RaS04 particles are removed together with the hemihydrate*
obtained. Next, after removal of Cd etc., the actual hemihydrate precipiation
step takes place. In another process (Giulini),.BaC03 is added to precipitate
RaS04 *together with Bas04 and hemihydrate:
Ca3(P04)2 + excessive amount of phosphoric acide + very deficient amount of
sulphuric acid + (possibly) BaC03 +
Ca(H2P04)2 in phosphoric acid + Cas04 .
f H20 J. f Ba(Ra)SOq + .
Other methods of removing Ra are being studied by the DelEt Institute of
Technology.
---------------
5.2. Cd-removal
The problem of Cd storage and disposal is least when cadmium and other unde-
sirable elements are removed after the contaminated HH and inerts formed
during digestion have been separated from the monocalcium-sulphate-in-
phosphoric-acid-solution.
In principle, there are many ways to remove Cd, for example precipitation, ion
exchange, absorption, adsorption, electrodialysis etc. Some methods are not
economically feasible, e.g. extraction. Others are chemically or technically
impossible (zeolites cannot be used for example, because of the pH of the
solution and the presence of Ca in the digestion liquor). In practice, the
choice of Cd-removal method is restricted to (co)-precipitation, adsorption
(whether or not preceded by precipitation) and ion exchange. The most obvious
technique, precipitation as CdS (with Na2S or H2S), will result in the for-
mation of colloidally dispersed CdS due to the small quantities involved,
while H2S will inevitably also be formed, which is undesirable. H2S formation
is also a drawback of co-precipitation of CdS with, for example, CuS or MCP.
A possibility which has been researched extensively, is precipitation of Cd as
a Cd-complex. For this purpose a selection was made out of. organic
S-compounds. A problem is the stability demands under the prevailing con-
ditions (95 "C, 47 % P2O5).
The indicated stability demands are important as well in the method of
ion-exchange. -
Next to the above-mentioned methods, studies are in progress to prevent Cd-
incorporation in HH. In that case, only the product acid still needs to be
purified, which, because-of the smaller quantity to be treated and the
possibly l e a s stringent c o n d i t i o n s , could offer an attractive alternative.
-1u-
6 . Hemihydrate crystallization5)
a
digestion liquor
this s t e p may be
3.2 % CaO; 45 X P 3 0 5
4.”
left 01 It I
1
I d
with 17 2 H2S04
7 - 7 b
. O X -H b
-1 % H, 0
Besides S0q'-ions, impurities also have a large influence. In view of the poor
solubility of a salt like hemihydrate, there should be sufficient crystal sur-
face area (more than 10 wt % crystals present).
In order for the crystals to be maximally pure, they should not grow too East;
otherwise, co-precipitation and inclusion of impurities are likely to occur.
Phosphate losses, by imperfect digestion do not occur in the pre-digestion
route. Phosphate losses by inclusion of phosphoric acid and lattice P2O5, can
be prevented by quick levelling of-local high calcium sulphate supersaturation
in the medium and a well-controlled, slow crystallization of the HH, that i s ,
an optimum concentration of free SOq2' at a constant Ca-supply. At a par-
ticular percentage of free acid, high supply rat-es of monocalcium phosphate
solution and, hence, of H2SOq/phosphoric acid mixture, which are both factors
determ-ining the degree of supersaturation, always yield higher amounts of lat-
tice P2O5 than low supply rates'). Further, at a particular supply rate the
amount of lattice P2O5 first decreases, as the concentration of free acid
increases from 1 X to about 2.2 % but then increases. The minimum is about
0.35 % lattice P2O5 (relative to DH) at a phosphate rock throughput of 100
kg/hr.m3.
In the classical DH-process and its process variations (e.g. HH .+ DH and HH),
Z lattice P 0 I
2 5
(calculated re- I
lative to DH) I
1 e is present
k 250 pre-digestion
* 100
(47 2 '205)
classical DH-proces
(30 Z P205)
1 I I I a
-1 0 1 2 3 4
Z free H2S04
3
Phosphate-rock throughput in kg/m .hr
which occurs at free sulphuric acid concentrations of more than about 2.2 % is
probably due to the fact that HH is instantaneously formed from Ca2+ and
S042', whereas in the classical phosphate digestion with H2S04, HH and DH are
formed from S042' and phosphate rock. Furthermore if the concentration of
free sulphuric acid becomes too high, the increased degree of.secondary
nucleation that may result from this will cause the amount of phosphate
' included in crystals to increase.
As indicated in Figure 7 , first HH is precipitated to yield a free-sulphuric-
acid concentration of 2 %.The excess sulphuric acid is compensated in the
second crystallizer. Fig. 9 below shows that at 0 % H2SO4 much HH i s dissolved
in the phosphoric acid. If this phosphoric acid is used for dissolving __
(digesting) the phosphate rock, a large amount of Ca-ions will be returned
together with the phosphoric acid, so that during pre-digestion the dissolved
HH will crystallize (again see Fig. 9). This can be prevented by adding mono-
calciumphosphate to the return acid in a third crystallizer, for example until -
the free-sulphuric-acid conentration is -1 %, so that most of the HH will
crystallize there.
Figure 9. The solubility of hemihydrate, as % CaS04, as a function of the
percentage of free S042', at 90 "C and 45 % P2O5
1 .o
0.94.
7, CaS04 \
-3 -2 -1 1 2 3
.
? * 0
7. Literature
1. Fertilizer Science and Technology series
Volume I, part I and 11, Phosphoric acid
edited by A.V. Slack; Marcel Delcker inc., New York-1968
3. K. Weterings
Verwerking van afvalgips uit de fosforzuurbereiding (phosphogypsum processing)
PT-procestechniek -
35, 1980, no. 2, pp. 79 - 86
Chemisch Magazine, April 1980, M 233 and 234.
4. K. Weterings
The Utilisation of phosphogypsum
The Fertilizer Society, Londen 21110182, Proceedings no. 208
6 . S . E . Dahlgren
Physico-chemical aspects of phosphoric acid by-produced calciumsulphate as a
raw material.
Chemie-1ng.-Techn. MS 104174.