Review On Conventional Concrete and Nylon Fiber Reinforced Concrete Behavior
Review On Conventional Concrete and Nylon Fiber Reinforced Concrete Behavior
Journal Of Civil
Engineering
REVIEW ON CONVENTIONAL CONCRETE AND Article history
Received
NYLON FIBER REINFORCED CONCRETE 21 August 2022
Received in revised form
BEHAVIOR 06 December 2022
Accepted
Mir Mohiuddin, Abhijit Nath Abhi, Maysha Ulfat, Sharmin Reza 06 December 2022
Chowdhury* Published online
31 March 2023
Department of Civil Engineering, Ahsanullah University of Science and
Technology, Dhaka-1208 *Corresponding author
[email protected]
The addition of fibers to reinforced cement concrete enhances the suitability of structures under impacts and
earthquake loads by boosting firmness or energy-consuming proficiency of the hardened concrete material.
During cracking of concrete, one of the most relevant behaviors of fiber like “bridge effect” starts functioning.
As a result of this, fiber blocks crack formation and propagation, and hence strength and ductility of concrete
structure improve. The goal of this study is to compare the mechanical properties of reinforced cement
concrete by mixing nylon fibers and without mixing nylon fibers. In this study, data from existing article are
assessed to compare the strengths of nylon fiber reinforced concrete and conventional concrete by using
concrete strength measuring test results such as compressive strength test, flexural strength test, and split
tensile strength test. Adding fiber with concrete mix reduces the moisture content, thereby lessening the
workability of concrete which produces fiber ball. Due to the obvious lack of homogeneity caused by fiber
balling, the efficiency of fiber reinforced concrete is reduced. During the mixing of small portions of fibers with
dry concrete the difficulty of fiber separation can prevent by providing good distribution and scattering within
the mixtures which enhance concrete strength and thus the balling incident can escape. The dynamic
transmission of stress between concrete mix and the fiber achieves by considering significant factors like
aspect ratio, volume, and orientation of the fiber. Nylon fiber provides mechanical improvement of reinforced
concrete by enhancing impact resistance and increasing flexural toughness, as a result the load-bearing
capacity of concrete develops effectively. Introducing nylon fibers with concrete mixture promotes strong
tensile comportment of concrete outstandingly after the post peak stage.
Keywords: Bridge Effect, Compressive Strength, Ductility, Flexural Toughness, Split Tensile Strength.
1.0 INTRODUCTION shows modest resistance to cracking. It has been seen that with
the addition of small, closely spaced and uniformly fibers into
In this modern world concrete is one of the most resilient, the concrete act to just like a crack arrester means when
durable, and extensively used manufacturing material. Concrete concrete starts cracking, the fibers start functioning and arrest
is a composite material which is made up with the mixture of the crack propagation and those fibers improve the properties
aggregate, cement, and water. Because of its inherent of concrete and make concrete as a homogeneous and isotropic
brittleness and low tensile strength, the use of concrete is material. The term "Fiber Reinforced Concrete," abbreviated as
bounded. As reinforced cement concrete is normally used in "FRC," is used to describe this type of concrete. FRC is used in
developing projects, concrete's limitations like poor ductility and mostly developing projects like highway and airport pavement,
low tensile strength need to be reduced to ensure the earthquake resistant structures etc.
sustainability of concrete structures. Concrete is particularly Among all fibers, nylon fiber is widely used because of its
strong in compression yet relatively weak in tension, and it easy availability, hydrophilic characteristics, and low cost and
are acknowledged for its strength, durability, and resilience. during curing, intercepting the fissures, resisting to spalling, &
When nylon fibers are added to concrete, the concrete's quality impact and abrasion resistance. However, the main purpose of
improves. Nylon Fiber Reinforced Concrete has greater flexural using nylon fiber reinforced concrete is to increase the
strength, tensile strength, impact resistance, excellent mechanical and ductility properties of concrete.
permeability and frost resistance as compared to conventional Strength improvement of concrete by using nylon fiber depends
cement concrete. The use of nylon fiber in construction projects on factors like fiber length and fiber mix percentage. These two
offer excellent opportunity to enhance concrete's strength factors, fiber length and fiber mix percentage both are related to
characteristics. In reinforced cement concrete structure, the term fiber balling which becomes the most prominent issue
corrosion of steel reinforcement is the major problem because to gain expected outcome (Dewangan et al. 2019). In nylon fiber
it may affect the durability and sustainability of existing RC reinforced concrete, balling develops frequently with long fibers
structures. Corrosion impact can be reduced by using nylon fiber but seldom with short fibers. Higher amounts of nylon fiber in
reinforced concrete. the concrete mix are so much more likely to generate
fiber balling; this results in a significant reduction in strength.
Some nylon fiber reinforced cube and cylinder specimens
2.0 NYLON FIBER REINFORCED CONCRETE (NFRC) are shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4 represents nylon fiber
blended with concrete mix.
The term "NFRC" refers to a composite made of nylon fiber and
concrete to which variable percentages and lengths of nylon
fiber are added. The main advantage of NFRC is that it can
improve the mechanical property of concrete. Analyzing the
literatures that are currently available, it is found that two types
of nylon fibers are mostly used in construction projects-
1. Nylon 6
2. Nylon 6.6
Table 1 Compressive Strength Test Result on Cubic Specimens (Vaisakhi beams for each nylon fiber percentage combination were
et al. 2019) studied the 28 days compressive strength of cylinder and cube
along with tensile strength of cylinder and flexural strength of
beam.
Compressive Compressive
Serial Concrete The results obtained from DAS & GHOSH (2020) are shown
strength (N/mm2) strength (N/mm2)
No. Type
[after 7 days] [after 28 days]
in Figures 5, 6, 7 & 8-
Conventional
1 23.556 24.4
concrete
Nylon fiber
2 reinforced 24.4 25.33
concrete
Conventional
1 2.13 2.97
concrete
Nylon fiber
2 reinforced 3.4 3.82
concrete
Nylon fiber
2 reinforced 5.6 6
concrete
Table 5 Split Tensile Strength at Various Fiber Lengths and Fiber Contents
(Ummahat 2019)
(Every result represented the mean of 4 test samples.) Table 6 Flexural Strength at Various Fiber Lengths and Fiber Contents
(Ummahat 2019)
Comparing the
Split Tensile
Length of Amount of percentage as
Strength
Fiber (mm) fiber (%) opposed to
(MPa) Comparing the
fiber-free mix Flexure
Length of Amount of percentage as
Null fiber Null fiber 1.59 - Strength
Fiber (mm) fiber (%) opposed to fiber-
(MPa)
19 0.5 1.68 5.66 free mix
Null fiber Null fiber 2.98 -
25 0.5 1.58 0.63
19 0.5 2.61 12.42
50 0.5 1.57 1.26 25 0.5 2.86 4.03
19 0.37 1.36 14.47 50 0.5 3.49 17.11
19 0.37 2.76 7.38
25 0.37 1.46 8.18
25 0.37 2.8 6.04
50 0.37 1.55 2.52 50 0.37 2.76 7.38
19 0.25 2.25 41.51 19 0.25 2.98 0
25 0.25 3.56 19.46
25 0.25 2.28 43.40 50 0.25 2.78 6.71
50 0.25 1.79 12.58
11 Mir Mohiuddin et al / Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering 35:1 (2023) 7–15
In this experiment, the lowest compressive strength had Table 8 Compressive Strength (Manikandan et al. 2017)
been revealed at mix code DS-6. In the composites the
microfiber samples had more splitting tensile strength and net Compressive strength on average
flexural strength than macro fiber samples. During crack Serial Amount of fiber (N/mm²)
propagation a few fibers were broken, and several fibers No. (%)
7 days 14 days 28 days
departed from the matrix.
In the research by Ozsar et al. (2017), a closed loop testing 1 0% 19.40 23.59 32.22
instrument was calibrated to a maximal ability of 100 kN to 2 2% 21.74 25.88 33.88
measure the fracture energy. The beams that were constructed 3 4% 22.22 28.55 34.86
for the fracture energy testing had dimensions of 500 mm in
4 6% 24.45 30.24 36.56
length and 100 mm in cross-section. The beams were pushed at
a consistent velocity of 0.004 mm/min up to 0.5 mm of
deflection, and after 4 mm of deformation, the speed was 0.05
mm/min.
12 Mir Mohiuddin et al / Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering 35:1 (2023) 7–15
Figure 10 Compressive Strength (Manikandan et al. 2017) From the experimental data analysis of Manikandan et al.
(2017) the mechanical properties of concrete specimen vary
with respect to the percentage of nylon fiber. Maximum
Table 9 Split Tensile Strength (Manikandan et al. 2017) compressive strength of 1.18% increase was found with 4%
nylon fiber NRFC specimen by comparing with conventional
Split Tensile Strength on average
concrete. When the mechanical properties of conventional
Amount of (N/mm²) concrete and nylon fiber reinforced concrete was compared,
Serial No.
fiber (%) maximum split tensile strength of concrete was increased by
7 days 14 days 28 days 1.18% with 6% nylon fiber and maximum flexural strength
1 0% 1.90 2.45 3.3 was increased by 1.29% with 2% nylon fiber.
2 2% 2.26 2.63 3.5 So, from the study it can be said that by using different
percentages of nylon fiber with concrete specimens, the overall
3 4% 2.25 2.88 3.67
mechanical properties were improved by gaining more strength
4 6% 2.36 3.02 3.9 when compared to conventional concrete.
Strength of conventional concrete was compared with NFRC
by Subramanian et al. (2016) by using cylinder and cube
specimens. For that purpose, nylon fiber (0.75 inch) mix ratio
was taken from 0% to 3%. The study was conducted by casting
M20 of concrete. Here, total 24 cubic specimens and 48
cylindrical specimens were casted.
The results obtained from Subramanian et al. (2016) are shown
below in Tables 11, 12 & 13-
Ultimate
Amount Ultimate Compressive
Figure 11 Split Tensile Strength (Manikandan et al. 2017) Loads on
Items of Nylon Loads Strength
average
fiber (%) (kN) (N/mm2)
(kN)
Table 10 Flexural Strength (Manikandan et al. 2017) 590
Normal
0% 610 613.33 27.25
mix
640
Flexural Strength on average (N/mm²)
Amount of 725
Serial No.
fiber (%)
NFM -1 1% 745 745 33.11
7 days 14 days 28 days
765
1 0% 3.82 4.78 6.97 590
2 2% 4.49 7.28 8.49
NFM -2 2% 625 621.66 27.69
3 4% 4.297 6.82 0.75
650
4 6% 4.08 6.44 7.07
475
NFM -3 3% 485 495 22.00
525
13 Mir Mohiuddin et al / Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering 35:1 (2023) 7–15
Table 12 Cylinder specimens’ compressive strength after 28th days compressive strength and the flexural strength of the concrete
(Subramanian et al. 2016) were tested less than 28 days curing period.
The compressive strength and flexure strength of concrete tests
Ultimate
Amount Ultimate Compressive results obtained from BABY SINGH et al. (2019) are shown in
Loads on
Items of Nylon Loads
average
Strength Tables 14 & 15 and Figures 13 & 14-
fiber (%) (kN) (N/mm2)
(kN)
620 Table 14 Compressive Strength of Concrete (BABY SINGH et al.
Normal 2019)
0% 650 631.33 28.07
mix
625 Compressive Strength
615 Amount of Nylon fiber (%) (N/mm2)
NFM -1 1% 630 628.33 35.56 28th day
640 0% 35.50
575 1% 35.65
NFM -2 2% 495 531.66 30.0
2% 38.20
525
475 3% 40.54
NFM -3 3% 380 443.66 25.08
475
Ultimate
Amount of Ultimate Split Tensile
Loads on
Items Nylon Loads Strength
average
fiber (%) (kN) (N/mm2)
(kN)
120
Normal
0% 150 133.33 1.88
mix
130
Figure 13 Compressive Strength of Concrete (BABY SINGH et al. 2019)
290
190
value after curing 28 days was 35.65 N/mm2, compared to the concrete, they make the movement of aggregate more
conventional concrete mix the compressive strength value was difficult by lowering the lubricating action of the cement
found 35.50 N/mm2. When 3% Nylon Fiber was added with paste, resulting in decreased workability, and increased
concrete, about 28.57% increase in Compressive Strength was mechanical strength.
attained. • Use of fiber produced extra intently spaced cracks and
Similarly, the Flexural Strength value for the conventional decreased crack width.
mix was 4.17 N/mm2 and for 1% addition of Nylon Fiber was 5.02 • The measurements showed that Nylon fibers notably
N/mm2 at 28th day of curing. When 3% Nylon Fiber was added reduce the plastic shrinkage of concrete.
with concrete, about 23.8% increase in Compressive Strength • Nylon Fiber Reinforced Concrete controls deformation &
was attained. cracking under impact load better than conventional
The structural behavior of conventional concrete was concrete.
compared with NFRC by LOGESH (2021). In this test M30 grade • Compared to the conventional concrete compressive
concrete and 3 different percentages of nylon fiber with a length strength, nylon fiber reinforced concrete was more
of 10 mm and diameter of 0.19 mm were used. Total test favorable to splitting tensile strength.
specimens were 24 cubes and 12 cylinders. • Most studies concluded that including approximately 2%
Tables 16 & 17 are obtained from LOGESH (2021)- nylon fiber in the concrete mix had produced the best
compressive, tensile, and flexural strength; however, few of
Table 16 Compressive Strength of Concrete (LOGESH 2021 other studies suggested adding 3% nylon fiber to the
) concrete mixture to boost strength. So, to increase the
Compressive
Compressive % strength of concrete, incorporating up to 2% nylon fiber
Amount strength
Grade of Nylon
strength
(N/mm2)
Increase with concrete mix may be the appropriate approach.
(N/mm2) in • Finally, it can be said that Nylon Fiber is used in reinforced
fiber (%) [after 28
[after 7 days] Strength concrete to increase the mechanical properties of concrete.
days]
0 29.43 43.89 -
1 32.73 50.49 15% Future research will be beneficial for improving nylon fiber
M30
2 35.93 55.69 27% reinforced concrete and creating stronger concrete.
3 34.20 53.80 23%
0 27.5 3.82 -
M30 1 32.1 4.45 16 References
2 33.5 4.65 22
3 33 4.58 20 [1] Ahmad, J., Zaid, O., Aslam, F., Martínez-García, R., Alharthi, Y. M.,
Hechmi EI Ouni, M., Tufail, R. F. & Sharaky, I. A. 2021. Mechanical
With the addition of 2% nylon fiber, concrete achieved 27% properties and durability assessment of nylon fiber reinforced self-
greater compressive strength. Additionally, the split tensile compacting concrete. Journal of Engineered Fibers and Fabrics. 16: 1-
13.
strength of concrete improved by 22% with the inclusion of 2% [2] Baby Singh, R., Ravi, Er. C. & Lumina, J. S. 2019. Mechanical Behaviour
nylon fiber. By further expanding the fiber content, the of Reinforced Cement Concrete with Addition of Nylon Fibre.
compressive and split tensile strengths were both reduced. International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET),
6(2): 798-801.
[3] Das, S., & Ghosh, G. 2020. A Study On Nylon Fiber Reinforced High
Tensile Concrete. International Research Journal of Engineering and
4.0 CONCLUSIONS Technology (IRJET), 7(6): 3355-3358.
[4] Dewangan, R., Khare, G. P., & Sahu, P. 2019. Influence of variation of
A comprehensive literature overview and analysis of published length and dosage of nylon fiber on compressive and split tensile
strength of concrete. International Research Journal of Engineering and
test results was done on compressive, tensile, and flexural
Technology, 6(3): 1349-1355.
properties of NRFC. The addition of 2% and 3% nylon fiber in [5] Faisal, A. M. 1990. Properties and Applications of Fibre Reinforced
concrete mix was found effective for concrete. At 2%, Nylon Concrete. Journal of King Abdulaziz University: Engineering Sciences 2:
fiber reinforced concrete showed a better crack resistance than 49-56.
non-fiber reinforced concrete. Following conclusions can be [6] Ishtiaq, M. 2019. Experimental Evaluation of Nylon Fiber Reinforced
Concrete (NFRC) for Shear Strength Enhancement of Deep Beams
drawn from the discussion and analysis.
(Doctoral dissertation, Capital University).
Analyzing experimental results from literature review, it may [7] Jalasutram, S., Sahoo, D. R., & Matsagar, V. 2017. Experimental
be feasible to summaries that: investigation of the mechanical properties of basalt fiber‐reinforced
• Nylon Fiber Reinforced Concrete (NFRC) had considerably concrete. Structural Concrete, 18(2): 292-302.
better strength than normal concrete with respect to
percentage of Nylon fiber. When nylon fibers are added to
15 Mir Mohiuddin et al / Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering 35:1 (2023) 7–15
[8] LOGESH S., 2021. An Investigation on Squander Nylon Fiber in Concrete. Aspect for Sustainable Building Envelopes, Khairatabad, Hyderabad,
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET), India, 10-11
8(4): 4627-4635. [13] Saxena, J., & Saxena, A. 2015. Enhancement the strength of
[9] Manikandan, K., Arun Kumar, A., Deepak Kumar, M., Manikandan, V., & conventional concrete by using nylon fibre. International Journal of
Sathish Kumar, K. 2017. Experimental investigation on nylon fiber Engineering Science, 5(2): 56-59.
reinforced concrete. International Research Journal of Engineering and [14] Subramanian, E. S., Vaishnave, V. R., & Vignesh, V. T. S. 2016.
Technology (IRJET), 4(3): 2479-2482. Experimental investigation of concrete composite using nylon fibre.
[10] Maruthachalam, D. 2012. Studies of durability aspects of fibre International Journal of Engineering Sciences & Research Technology,
reinforced concrete. International Journal of Engineering Science and 998-1002 ISSN, 2277-9655.
Technology, 4(02): 620-628. [15] Ummahat, N. (2019). Effect of nylon fiber aspect ratio on the
[11] Ozsar, D. S., Ozalp, F., Dilsad Yilmaz, H., & Akcay, B. 2017. Effects of mechanical properties of fiber reinforced concrete. M. Sc. Thesis,
nylon fibre and concrete strength on the shrinkage and fracture Bangladesh University of Science & Technology, 2-3, 125.
behaviour of fibre reinforced concrete. In International Conference on [16] Vaisakhi A., Alfiya S., Arathy K. S., Shahina E. S. & Jisha I. 2019.
Strain-Hardening Cement-Based Composites 188-194. Springer, Comparative Analysis of Strength of Concrete by using Various
Dordrecht. Materials Coir fibre, Plastic fibre and nylon fibre. IJIRAE: International
[12] Ragavendra, S., Reddy, I. P., & Dongre, A. 2017. Fibre reinforced Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering, 6(6): 389-395.
concrete-A case study. Proceedings of the Architectural Engineering