State of Employee Benefits 24 by Plum
State of Employee Benefits 24 by Plum
of Employee
Benefits ‘24
We welcome you to the second edition of The State of Employee Benefits. This Over the next 50 odd pages, we give you the 30,000 feet view into India’s
report is our annual exercise in curiosity, as we look at working India’s evolving blossoming healthcare story, and the role we have to play as employers.
relationship with their health, and their employers’ investments in their health.
We’ve analysed plans across company sizes, and shared our opinion on why
Last year, we gave you a snapshot into how India’s companies built employee India’s Unicorns and global organisations stand out from the median. We’ve
benefits plans, and offered our recommendations. This year’s edition is slightly looked at the finer details of insurance policies, to find out if the benefits
different.
companies offer are truly inclusive, comprehensive, and useful. We’ve collated
our observations from India’s most progressive benefit plans, and have
To us, The State of Employee Benefits isn’t just a benchmarking report — treat documented trends we think will drive employee health in 2024 and beyond.
this as our inner monologue on the state of employee benefits in the country,
built on insights from 4500+ employee healthcare plans and conversations with And finally, we offer our recommendations.
both employees and HR experts.
If you liked it, talk about it, share it with your community, and play your part in
Therefore, this report not only highlights India’s employee benefits benchmarks, helping companies craft more holistic policies. If you have feedback, reach out to
but also is our commentary on the health benefits offered by companies, us at [email protected].
India’s benchmarks
But when it comes to the top five percentile employee benefits, size doesn’t matter 10
Our observations
Emerging trends
Glossary
Parting words 41
Citations 42
Out of pocket expenditure in India has been pegged at around 62% of the
total healthcare expenditure. These spends impoverish close to 55 million India USA Canada Germany Japan France
Indians annually, with over 17 per cent households incurring catastrophic
levels of health expenditures every year. [1]
While government initiatives like Ayushman Bharat can potentially provide free
health coverage for India’s underprivileged, India’s high population and budget
constraints imply that they can only cover a projected 40% of the country’s
total population. Social health insurance, and private voluntary health
insurance can potentially cover another 20%. The remaining 40% form India’s
missing middle – neither are they eligible for government sponsored
schemes, nor are they financially strong to purchase a health insurance
[2]
policy.
/ The State of Employee Benefits 2024 / INDIA INC AND INDIA’S HEALTH STORY 01
India’s health story is being written
by employers who care
In 2020, the IRDAI released a circular, making it mandatory for companies to offer their employees medical insurance. This move was a step in the right
[3]
direction, as witnessed by the rapid growth of group health insurance, and the impact it has had on health insurance penetration over the last few years.
40 18
35 16
30 14
25 12
Higher penetration
20 10
The number of lives covered by
15 8
group health insurance schemes
has almost doubled over the last 10 6
five years. 5 4
FY 17 FY 18 FY 19 FY 20 FY 21 FY 22 FY 23 FY 17 FY 18 FY 19 FY 20 FY 21 FY 22 FY 23
We’re confident that the healthcare – and growth story of this decade will be driven by companies
/ The State of Employee Benefits 2024 / INDIA INC AND INDIA’S HEALTH STORY 02
Covering the gaps in India’s
retail health policies
Employer sponsored healthcare isn’t merely increasing insurance penetration in the country, it’s also helping Indians cover treatments that wouldn’t be
18%
40
Unlike group policies, retail health policies come
% with lengthy waiting periods on pre-existing 11%
have to pay for expensive add-ons and riders. 8% Infectious and viral
diseases
5% Cancer
4% Cataracts
insurance, a holistic and comprehensive group health policy can complement a Respiratory
3% illnesses
retail health plan – offering broader protection and deeper coverage.
/ The State of Employee Benefits 2024 / INDIA INC AND INDIA’S HEALTH STORY 03
Despite a cost conscious environment,
India Inc is raising the bar
India’s companies have understood the brief, and have delivered. Since the State of Employee Benefits 2023, companies have improved
the kind of benefits they offer their employees across primary, preventive, and in-patient care. That said, there is still room for improvement,
which you will observe as we explore themes around comprehensive and inclusive benefits plans in Chapter III.
But for now, we celebrate every employer who moved the needle on team health since last year.
66% 15%
increase in median sum insured, with
the amount going from ₹3,00,000 to increase in companies offering
2x 110%
increase in first time buyers of
group health insurance investing in
adoption in flexible benefits by
primary health care initiatives for
Indian enterprises
their employees
/ The State of Employee Benefits 2024 / INDIA INC AND INDIA’s HEALTH STORY 04
02
India’s Benchmarks
Sum insured 1-3L (41%) 4-6L (32%) 7-10L (22%) >10L (5%)
Exceptions apply.
Copay 10% (Yes) 16% (Parental) 74% (No)
Maternity No (17%) Yes, <=75k cover (58%) Yes, >75k cover (25%)
This segment also includes companies
operating in the service and consulting
IVF Yes (24%) No (76%)
sector.
Sum insured 1-3L (20%) 4-6L (50%) 7-10L (28%) >10L (2%)
Status quo 90%ile Status quo 90%ile Status quo 90%ile Status quo 90%ile
Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse, Employee, Spouse,
Family definition
Child Child, Parent Child Child, Parent Child, Parent Child, Parent Child, Parent Child, Parent
Median sum insured ₹5,00,000 ₹10,00,000 ₹5,00,000 ₹10,00,000 ₹5,00,000 ₹8,00,000 ₹5,00,000 ₹8,00,000
Maternity Offered by 59% of Offered, limit of Offered by 67% of Offered, limit of Offered by 83% of Offered, limit of Offered by 94% of Offered, limit of
companies, limit of ₹75,000 and above companies, limit of ₹1,00,000 and companies, limit of ₹1,00,000 and companies, limit of ₹1,00,000 and
Offered by 12% of Offered by all Offered by 15% of Offered by all Offered by 15% of Offered by all Offered by 18% of Offered by all
OPD
companies companies companies companies
Progressive benefits Offered by 10% of LGBTQ+ friendly Offered by 15% of LGBTQ+ friendly Offered by 30% of LGBTQ+ friendly Offered by 33% of LGBTQ+ friendly
(Gender affirmation, companies policies, cover for compnies policies, cover for companies policies, cover for companies policies, cover for
,
autism cover for infertility and gender infertility and gender infertility and gender infertility and gender
differently abled reaffirmation offered reaffirmation offered reaffirmation offered reaffirmation offered
36% of g g from
Offered, ran in Offered by 52% of
g g from
Offered, ran in
75% of g g from
Offered, ran in
76% of
g g from
Offered, ran in
Group personal accident Offered by Offered by Offered by
₹10,00,000 to ₹25,00,000 to ₹30,00,000 to ₹30,00,000 to
insurance companies companies companies companies
₹25,00,000 ₹50,00,000 ₹1,00,00,000 ₹1,00,00,000
Offered by 9% of g g from
Offered, ran in Offered by 14% of Offered by 35% of Offered, ₹50,00,000
Offered by 60% of Offered, ₹50,00,000
Offered, ₹50,00,000
Group term life insurance ₹30,00,000 to
companies companies
g
or hi her/3 X CTC
companies
g
or hi her/3 X CTC companies
g - X CTC
or hi her/3 5
₹50,00,000
investment in talent;
Employee, Spouse, Parents/Parents in law, children covere $ spend,
experience
Employee, Spouse,
Policy structure Employee, Spouse, Child
Child, Parents
In the words of Vina Uriarte, Global Benefits Manager at
Notion:
Maternity benefits 60%, avg maternity cover 95%, avg maternity cover
For the most part we try to keep our employee benefits of ₹60,000 of ₹1,00,000
in other countries.
Employer sponsored
18% 80%
primary healthcare
To make in India, companies need to match global
Group personal
45% 60%
benefit standards. accident cover
More international companies will set up shop in India. They will Group term
14% 30%
compete for top talent with their employer brands and benefit life cover
structures. The bar has been raised – and India Inc will have to match it.
Plan A Plan B
+
+
no accident or term life cover generous accident and term life cover
great perks
70% of employees would choose a job offer which offers better health benefits and slightly lower pay over a job offer with poor health benefits and a
slightly better pay. In an increasingly cost conscious environment, companies need to focus on building sustainable benefit plans.
been higher.
Sustainable
This means the primary concern for most HRs this year is
increasing costs measures, and how you can craft a sustainable benefits
policy.
Also results in smaller claims Removing parents would result in treatments, but they’re the ones who
responsible decisions.
What’s Introduce a parental copay first.
Introduce cost sharing through Not recommended if you offer a sum
Don’t be Dwight. recommended voluntary parental covers. This would insured in the 3-5 lakh range.
In S1E3 of The Office, Michael Scott and If costs are still high, introduce a be less expensive and more
Influenced by
Recruitment
The cost of attrition is
12.5% Hours
Loss
lost interviewing candidates
of institutional knowledge
While economist Thomas Sowell was not thinking about employee benefits when he said “there are no solutions, only tradeoffs”, it’s relevant all the same.
Remember that the best bargains leave all parties slightly unhappy. While budgetary constraints might prevent you from building the perfect policy, you can
build a policy that your team can appreciate. When in doubt, refer to the 3Ps of Benefit Planning, proposed by Aditya Bagarka, Vice President of Insurance
Partnerships at Plum.
benefits truly
actually impact an employee’s health
spends.
comprehensive?
In this section, we analyse the state of
maternity policies, inclusive and
progressive policies being provided by
employers in India today and how India Inc
has been keeping up with modern
treatments.
Infertility treatments 1 out of 15 Indian couples suffer from Inclusion of surrogacy, IVF, egg-
(IVF, egg freezing, <5% infertility, and IVF treatment costs around freezing in the policy construct.
sperm freezing) ₹1,50,000 lakh on average.
Pre and post natal; Checkups, medicines, therapy, vaccinations Ensure it is covered; consider
well mother and well
50% etc – add up over 9 months and post including these expense as part of
baby expenses
delivery. OPD benefits.
Insurance for mummies, feat. Three
Idiots.
Surrogate mother Surrogate mothers aren’t considered
Cover medical expenses incurred for
While Mona, Pia’s sister from Three Idiots was on expenses <15% dependents in an insurance policy, unless
the conception and delivery of the
complications.
Therefore, if a couple expects twins during their cover. To go above and beyond, also
Her costs, had she been taken to a hospital, <10%
second pregnancy, the third child won’t be include triplets.
would have looked something like this:
covered.
Miscarriage and The cost of an abortion can be as high as To be covered within the maternity
Complications: ₹50,000
limit.
abortion <10% ₹40,000. 67% of abortions in India are
NICU: ₹10,000/day unsafe.
Benefit
% of Companies Why this is important Recommendation
The benefits that you offer are vital in signalling offering this
benefit
to employees that you’re ready to walk the talk
when it comes to inclusion. LGBTQ+ and live in The LGBTQ+ community makes up 1 0% of
LGBTQ+ and live-in Include coverage for same-sex
partner covers 60% India’s population, their needs should be
partner covers partners and live in relationships.
reflected in benefit plans.
Gender reaffirmation Gender Reaffirmation Surgeries (GRS) cost Cover Gender Reaffirmation Surgeries,
surgeries <15% around ₹2,00,000 to ₹5,00,000 for men and including pre and post hospitalisation
Cover for differently Differently abled children still depend on Cover differently abled children
They want to have a baby together, and have Prosthetics cover The cost of prosthetics is very high – Expenses covered within overall sum
approached a surrogate mother to help. <1% artificial limbs can cost lakhs. insured.
neurological conditions
copay.
j
Intravitreal In ections Retinal conditions j
₹10,000 and ₹45,000 per in ection
benefits
Vaporisation of the prostate Benign prostatic hyperplasia ₹1,00,000
To ensure that the policyholders are not denied
health.
healthcare is
demand for more holistic healthcare
initiatives.
evolving
In this section, we discuss if insurance
of rising costs.
The tamasha of employee health. Age-related and other hearing loss 19% Diagnostic tests
57%
of HRs believe there’s an improvement in
consultations
employee morale due to good benefits
y
of emplo ees believe availing healthcare
18% Plum telehealth consultations
34% y
pla ed an impact in them taking fe
sick leaves
wer
10%
Obgyn consultations make up 10% of all Plum
telehealth consultations
The ideal healthcare policy caters to diverse Invest in relevant employee healthcare initiatives that cater to employee needs
healthcare trends
The Age of
mixture of spreadsheets and paperwork.
In 2024, employee benefits need to Tech intervention and their impact in different points in the healthcare journey
enhance the overall employee experience.
Adoption of digital experiences could be the first what’s covered, and what’s coverage for self and family.
step towards untangling a hairy, complex not covered through detailed Proactive communication on
j
digital onboarding ourneys.
D
Health I s Automated health ID D
Health I s available in under
made in heaven.
Jaspreet Kaur (Jazz to her friends) works at a Claims experience Fully digital, paperless claims 79 claims NPS (vs traditional
popular wedding planning company in Mumbai. -
experience, with pre filled score of 49)
She uses Meesho to shop, Fi to bank, Zomato for KYC, guided support, and AI 68% of tickets resolved
ordering in, and Google Fit to track her workouts. claims support using AI
She represents India’s corporate employees –
Benefits management
Automated additions and 11 working days saved every
tasks?
The unification
kirana store to get sugar. In addition, you
have to use your neighbour’s oven to bake
it. If this doesn’t make sense, why should
of employee
you tolerate the same thing for employee
health?
v
Employee healthcare today is all o er the place .
traditional
Companies rely on multiple
EAP and
employee broker A
TPA offered healthcare needs.
by player D
digital, some are
health from
Player E
Some aspects of health are
h sical, some are phygita
p y
from Player C
from player B
Employers cannot measure impact – due to the lack
of a single source of truth, 40% of employers have
insufficient data to make informed decisions.
HR gets
The future is
Parents, children, live-in partners, same-
sex partners, and even siblings, there will
be minimal boundaries for who you are
flex
covering, and what is covered.
Arjun (32M) is married and lives Reema (22F) lives alone with her Alex (40F) lives with their partner. Arjun, Reema, and Alex get the same benefits.
with his parents. As a first dogs. She’s financially literate, and They ’re looking to adopt a child,
generation employee, nobody in his has invested in a retail health while undergoing hormone therapy While they might find a few useful, they will not use a
family has health insurance. He’s insurance policy. She’s just moved for gender affirmation. majority of benefits offered.
currently planning to have children. cities, and is having trouble building
her fitness and wellness regime.
Arjun chooses the following plan Reema chooses the following plan Alex chooses the following plan Despite the best interests of a company, it is impossible
ESCP plan E-only plan ESC plan, live in partner cover to craft a health benefits plan that will work perfectly for
₹5,00,000 sum insured ₹3 ,00,000 sum insured ₹1 0,00,000 sum insured, with Arjun, Reema, and Alex.
Super top up for parents Employer sponsored primary gender affirmation surgery and
Employer sponsored primary healthcar surrogate mother covers A flex benefits plan is a more efficient use of benefits
healthcare Gym subscriptio included budgets, because employees get to choose the
Annual health checkups, Mental health benefits Employer sponsored primary benefits they want — and will eventually use.
discounted medicines. Period care healthcare
Supplements and nutritional Mental health benefits
benefits
Everyone cares for à la carte benefits How Indian companies are adopting Flex
Organisations are realising the importance of giving employees great benefits - but
more importantly, the freedom to choose.
Swiggy offers graded cover to suit
different income brackets with optional
add-ons
better benefits
These benefits are the bare necessities of any employee health benefits plan.
Knowing that they can avail these benefits offers a sense of security to
employees, and impacts overall morale and happiness.
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
Family members Employee, Spouse, 2 children Employee, spouse, 2 children and 2 parent/in-laws (without Employee, spouse, 4 children and 2 parent/in-laws
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
Live-in Partner Not covered Covered; only one live-in partner allowed in a year Covered; only one live-in partner allowed in a year
Not covered Upto 2 dependent siblings covered, upto age of 25yrs, Upto 2 dependent siblings covered, upto age of 25yrs,
Siblings
allowed only if children are not covered by that employee allowed only if children are not covered by that
employee
Up to 2 children
Up to 2 children; automatic coverage for 3rd and 4th child in Up to 4 children
# of Children /
case of twins triplets
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
Maternity Cover Offered, maternity cover of Covers first 2 successful deliveries. In case a pregnancy is Covers first 4 successful deliveries. In case a pregnancy
₹50,000 terminated, it is not counted in the limit of 2 deliveries. is terminated, it is not counted in the limit of 2 deliveries.
Miscarriage and abortion Not offered Covered within maternity sublimit Covered within maternity sublimit
Pre-post Natal Expenses Not offered Upto ₹10,000 within maternity limit.
Within maternity limit.
Includes cost incurred 6 months before or after delivery. Includes cost incurred 6 months before or after delivery.
treatment
Outside the maternity limit. Outside the maternity limit.
Covered upto family sum insured Covered upto family sum insured
Maternity related Not offered
complications
Covered within maternity limit; includes room rent expenses for Covered within maternity limit; includes room rent
Well mother expenses Not offered
mother in case of <2yrs baby being hospitalised expenses for mother in case of <2yrs baby being
hospitalised
Surrogate mother's expenses (who may not be part of the active Surrogate mother's expenses (who may not be part of
Surrogate mother expenses Not offered
list) covered within maternity limit the active list) covered within maternity limit
Child Vaccinations Not offered Covered upto ₹10,000, IPD and OPD, outside maternity limit, Covered upto ₹10,000, IPD and OPD, outside maternity
upto age of 2yrs limit, upto age of 2yrs
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
HIV & AIDS Not covered Covered up to sum insured Covered up to sum insured
Mental illness, Psychiatric, Not covered Covered up to ₹1,00,000 for IPD in a recognized psychiatric unit Covered up to sum insured on IPD basis
of a hospital
Psychosomatic Ailments
Modern Treatments Covered , with co-pay Covered upto 50% of sum insured Covered upto sum insured
External Congenital Diseases Not covered Covered only in life threatening situations Covered only in life threatening situations
Surgical cancer Not covered Covered up to sum insured Covered up to sum insured
Organ Donor Expenses Not covered Covered up to sum insured Covered up to sum insured
Gender affirmation Not covered Gender affirmation surgery covered with 0% copay Gender affirmation surgery covered with 0% copay
procedures
Cochlear implants Not covered Covered up to sum insured Covered up to sum insured
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
Animal or serpent attack Not covered Covered on IPD basis Covered on IPD basis
Fracture Covered on IPD basis Covered on IPD and OPD basis. Covered on IPD and OPD basis.
Physiotherapy Covered on IPD basis. Covered Covered on OPD and IPD basis. Covered on OPD and IPD basis.
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
Doctor/Specialist Consultations Covered through telehealth Covered up to OPD sum insured and telehealth Covered up to OPD sum insured and telehealth
Covered up to OPD sum insured; employer sponsored health Covered up to OPD sum insured; employer sponsored
Diagnostics Not covered
checkups health checkups
Medicines Not covered Covered upto OPD sum insured Covered upto OPD sum insured
Vaccinations Not covered Covered upto OPD sum insured Covered upto OPD sum insured
Annual Health Checkups Not covered Employer sponsored annual master health checkups Employer sponsored annual master health checkups
Physiotherapy Not covered Covered up to OPD sum insured Covered upto OPD sum insured
COVID homecare treatment Not covered Covered up to sum insured Covered up to sum insured
Cervical and other vaccinations Not covered Employer sponsored health camps Employer sponsored health camps
Mental health Not covered Covered up to OPD sum insured; dedicated programs Covered up to sum insured; dedicated programs
Benefits Median Cover offered by the top 1%ile Cover offered by the top 1%ile
companies in India companies in the world (in India)
Cataract ₹40,000 Covered up to sum insured. No restriction on lens type. Covered up to sum insured. No restriction on lens type.
LASIK Covered, +/-7.5D Covered for correction above +/- 5D Covered for correction above +/- 4D
Dental Not covered Covered only if necessitated due to accident and Covered only if necessitated due to accident and
Sum Insured Top-up Not covered Options upto ₹15,00,000 Options upto ₹15,00,000
Covered up to OPD sum insured; employer sponsored vision Covered up to OPD sum insured;
Thank you for going through The State of Employee Benefits 2024. We hope you Take the case of Kavya who despite being the only one in her entire company
found it useful. Before you go, here’s some food for thought. making a claim, found absolute comfort that her decision to opt for IVF was
supported, or Ankita — the only openly transgender employee in your 1000+ org
We constantly look at insurance and what it does for your employees - most of
whose surgeries are covered, or Rohit who was able to speak to a paediatrician
your employees - for employees that need any and all types of care. And that’s
for his 1 year old at 2:00 a.m. in the night, or Srihari who can find comfort in the
how we discuss impact. Impact is one of those words that, as for-profit
fact that his 26 year old special needs child can stay on the insurance policy.
companies, we use interchangeably to suit context. And much like every brand
that chooses words carefully, we figured we must be able to measure it. Healthcare and benefits aren’t just about all the data you just saw. Care is also
about people, their challenges, and their stories. Benefits aren’t just about the
And there lies the problem — what’s the true impact of a great employee objective bottomline — there are multiple qualitative factors that influence your
benefits policy? How do we deeply think about people and work, people at employee’s health, well-being, and general morale. And progressive companies
work? We’ve been taught to measure this in terms of how many of our don’t do this because of compliance, they do it because they believe cultivating a
employees were able to avail the type and quality of care that we pay for. culture of care is the right thing to do.
Policy matters. To everyone. But those who need its support the most. We’ve The State of Employee Benefits are ever evolving, and so shall this report. See
observed this through insurance. We’ve observed this through care. Is adoption you next year. Until then, write to us at [email protected] for all the
the measure of impact? Is value? bouquets and brickbats.
4500+ employee benefits plans World Health Organization. (n.d.). India health system review. Retrieved
from https://apo.who.int/publications/i/item/india-health-system-revie
18000+ claims raised by Plum users over the period
of Jan’23 to Jan’2 NITI Aayog. (2021, December 8). Health insurance for India’s missing middle.
hubfs/email%20marketing/Gated%20Content/Benefits_Guide-compressed.pd
www.business-standard.com/finance/news/employer-sponsored-health-
insurance-cost-to-rise-11-in-2024-report-123122001303_1.htm
The Economic Times. (n.d.). Cost cutting on employees can be a bad idea: A
blog/cost-cutting-on-employees-can-be-a-bad-idea-a-cfos-
calculation/10639382
Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation. (n.d.). GBD Compare | India.
www.plumhq.com/corporate-health-report-2023
City
City % of companies Average claim % offering % offering maternity Average claim
Prasun Jain
Design at Plum
Aditya Bagarka