REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES
COURT OF TAX APPEALS
QUEZON CITY
THIRD DIVISION
COURT CALENDAR FOR TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 29, 2022 at 9:00 A.M.
PRESENT:
HON. MARIA ROWENA MODESTO-SAN PEDRO Associate Justice/
Acting Chairperson
HON. CORAZON G. FERRER-FLORES Associate Justice/ Member
ATTY. AMELIA DOLORES B. CASTILLO ESQUIVEL Executive Clerk of Court II
MS. MARITES N. CRUZ Court Stenographer IV
MS. RAMONNE DJ. BALOR Interpreter II
ON LEAVE:
HON. MA. BELEN M. RINGPIS-LIBAN Associate Justice/ Chairperson
CIVIL CASES
1. WILLIAMS-SONOMA PHILIPPINES, INC.
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10325
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(For the presentation of evidence for respondent, for the testimony of Group Supervisor Clariza M.
Barangan)
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Group Supervisor Clariza M. Barangan executed on June 30, 2022 and
filed on July 4, 2022
CP: Atty. Angelique Claudine T. Lim (notified) CR: Atty. Clarissa J. Virtudes-Babaran
Atty. Martin Victorino S. Cusi (notified) (notified)
2. SONY PHILIPPINES INCORPORATED
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10585
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(For the continuation of the presentation of evidence for the petitioner, for the testimony of the ICPA,
Joseph Cedric V. Calica)
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Joseph Cedric V. Calica executed on November 11, 2022 and filed on
November 14, 2022
- With the ICPA Report and USB received by the Court on November 4, 2022
CP: Atty. Gemmalu O. Molleno-Placido CR: Atty. Clarissa J. Virtudes-Babaran
(notified) (notified)
Atty. Roy N. Relato (notified)
3rd Division Calendar
November 29, 2022
Page 2 of 5
3. MARVIN RULONA REYES
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10340
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS, BUREAU
OF CUSTOMS
(For the recall of the testimony of Mr. Marvin R. Reyes)
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Marvin Rulona Reyes executed on September 9, 2022 and filed on
September 9, 2022
*With petitioner’s Formal Offer of Evidence filed on May 6, 2022
*With respondent’s Comment/Opposition (re Formal Offer of Evidence) filed on June 2, 2022
CP: Atty. Jan Michael R. Jongko (notified) CR: Atty. Jun Marr M. Denila (notified)
4. FCF MINERALS CORPORATION
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10447
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(For the initial presentation of evidence for petitioner, for the testimonies of Tommy E. Alfonso and
Francisco Caasi)
*With the Amended Judicial Affidavit of Tommy E. Alfonso executed and filed on November 25, 2022
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Tommy E. Alfonso executed on August 31, 2022 and filed on September
2, 2022
*With the Amended Judicial Affidavit of Francisco Caasi executed and filed on November 25, 2022
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Francisco Caasi executed on August 31, 2022 and filed on September 2,
2022
CP: Atty. Kristine R. Ferrer (notified) CR: Atty. Marveen B. De La Paz (notified)
Atty. Domingo Angelo F. Cayosa (notified)
5. CANLUBANG WATERWORKS
CORPORATION
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10682
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(For the presentation of evidence for petitioner, for the testimony of Marlene F. Galeos)
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Marlene F. Galeos executed on November 18, 2021 and filed on
November 22, 2021
CP: Atty. Maria Isabelle J. Poblete (notified) CR: Atty. Lara Nicole T. Gonzales (notified)
Atty. Christine Abu-Bangcola (notified)
3rd Division Calendar
November 29, 2022
Page 3 of 5
6. ZENOREX MARKETING CORPORATION
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10729
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(For the presentation of evidence for petitioner, for the testimony of Cheryl R. Samonte)
*With petitioner’s “Motion For Extension (Re: Submission of ICPA Report on November 25, 2022)” filed
on November 24, 2022
*With the Amended and Supplemental Judicial Affidavit of Cheryl R. Samonte executed on November 24,
2022
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Cheryl R. Samonte executed on January 26, 2022 and filed on February 2,
2022
CP: Atty. Hazelmer S. Fernandez (notified) CR: Atty. Dave Adrian V. Bruzon (notified)
Atty. Abrillius Raffy C. Laguesma
(notified)
Atty. Mary Antonette U. Uy
7. THE GREENBELT MADISON
CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, INC.
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10789
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(For the initial presentation of evidence for petitioner, for the testimonies of John Mark Baldonado and
Robert Fuentes)
*With the Judicial Affidavit of John Mark Baldonado executed on September 14, 2022 and filed on
September 15, 2022
*With the Judicial Affidavit of Robert Fuentes executed on January 12, 2022 and filed through registered
mail on January 13, 2022 and received by the Court on February 28, 2022
CP: Atty. Dan Mikee V. Caronan CR: Atty.Norwidad R. Solaiman (notified)
Atty. Erica Tuico(notified)
3rd Division Calendar
November 29, 2022
Page 4 of 5
COMMISSIONER’S HEARING FOR TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 29, 2022
(GROUND FLOOR, OFFICE OF THE DIVISION CLERK OF COURT, CTA BUILDING II)
1. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
- versus - CTA CRIM. CASE NO. O-869
TIMBER WOOD DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION,
PHIVIDEC INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, MUHON
TAGOLOAN, MISAMIS ORIENTAL TING-PI
HUANG, PHIVIDEC INDUSTRIAL ESTATE,
MUHON TAGOLOAN, MISAMIS ORIENTAL CHIU-
LING SU, PHIVIDEC INDUSTRIAL ESTATE,
MUHON TAGOLOAN, MISAMIS ORIENTAL MA.
SHARON L. REMO PUROM 3, IMELDA,
VILLANUEVA MISAMIS ORIENTAL NENITO P.
PIALAN AND CHRISTIAN M. TONG ZONE 4, STA.
ANA, TAGOLOAN, MISAMIS ORIENTAL
(Before Atty. Christine C. Maza-Guarin, Clerk of Court III, at 9:00 a.m.)
2. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
- versus - CTA CRIM. CASE NO. O-869
TIMBER WOOD DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION, PHIVIDEC INDUSTRIAL
ESTATE, MUHON TAGOLOAN, MISAMIS
ORIENTAL TING-PI HUANG, PHIVIDEC
INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, MUHON TAGOLOAN,
MISAMIS ORIENTAL CHIU-LING SU, PHIVIDEC
INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, MUHON TAGOLOAN,
MISAMIS ORIENTAL MA. SHARON L. REMO
PUROM 3, IMELDA, VILLANUEVA MISAMIS
ORIENTAL NENITO P. PIALAN AND CHRISTIAN
M. TONG ZONE 4, STA. ANA, TAGOLOAN,
MISAMIS ORIENTAL
(Before Atty. Christine C. Maza-Guarin, Clerk of Court III, at 9:30 a.m.)
3. SEAOIL PHILIPPINES, INC.
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10639
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS
(Before Atty. Christine C. Maza-Guarin, Clerk of Court III, at 1:00 - 2:00 p.m.)
4. SEAOIL PHILIPPINES, INC.
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10639
COMMISSIONER OF OF CUSTOMS
(Before Atty. Christine C. Maza-Guarin, Clerk of Court III, at 2:00 - 2:30 p.m.)
3rd Division Calendar
November 29, 2022
Page 5 of 5
5. WILLIAMS-SONOMA PHILIPPINES, INC.
- versus - CTA CASE NO. 10325
COMMISSIONER OF INTERNAL REVENUE
(Before Atty. Amelia Dolores B. Castillo-Esquivel, Clerk of Court II, at 3:00 p.m.)
- end -
