Teachers' Experiences in Last Mile Schools
Teachers' Experiences in Last Mile Schools
Volume: 23
Issue 3
Pages: 311-324
Document ID: 2024PEMJ2159
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.13256035
Manuscript Accepted: 07-27-2024
Psych Educ, 2024, 16(1): 311-324, Document ID:2024PEMJ2159, doi:10.5281/zenodo.13256035, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article
Change Gear, Gear Up: Understanding the School-Based Management Experiences of the
Teachers in the Last Mile Schools
Princess Marynee V. Morga,* Johnny S. Bantulo
For affiliations and correspondence, see the last page.
Abstract
This phenomenological study aimed to understand teachers' School-Based Management experiences in the last-mile
schools. This study recorded their challenges, their coping mechanisms, and what learning and insights they can share.
Moreover, it involved twenty (20) teachers from the Division of South Cotabato in the T’boli II district located at
Barangay Maan, T’boli, South Cotabato, Philippines. They underwent in-depth interviews and Focus Group
Discussion (FGD) using the validated research instrument. The findings of this study revealed that teachers
encountered the challenges of Burdening Pressure, Overwhelming Paperwork, Wavering Confidence, Emerging
Passiveness, Occurring Misunderstanding, Varying Loads, Unravelling Authenticity, Lacking Knowledge, and
Believing in Competence. In addition, they could cope with it by Uplifting Themselves, Receiving Compliments,
Free-flowing Dialogue, Safe-Keeping Documents, Preparing Themselves, Replenishing Environment, Sharing
Informal Conversation, and Learning Accountability. Finally, their insights were about Becoming One’s Best Version,
Having a Compassionate Heart, Stepping out of Comfort Zone, Lagging in Action, Hoping in Sanguinity, Laboring
in Bliss, and Thriving Values. Further, the data of this study would contribute meaningfully to understanding the
realest predicaments of mountain teachers. Likewise, this study would motivate and impact the teachers serving the
last-mile schools.
Keywords: educational management, school-based management, last mile schools, experiences, challenges, coping
mechanisms, insights, phenomenological study
Introduction
Education is one of the most essential experiences in human life. It will continue to embrace the changes in whatever age of time. It is
common knowledge that innovation and upgrades are part of the story of educational development in all phases of education. Thus, the
effective use of School-Based Management (SBM) as an integrative and developmental management paradigm can be considered.
Likewise, school management, also called school autonomy or site-based Management, aids in bringing about long-term change in the
primary education sector (Llego, 2020; Maca, 2019; Malik, 2018).
Moreover, a qualitative study conducted in Jakarta, Indonesia, showed that implementing School-Based Management improves the
country's quality of education and raises community awareness of their responsibilities. In addition, SBM highlights the significance
of the school's vision and mission and modifications to the educational system and curriculum programs. The principal organizes by
delegating authority and responsibilities to staff (Amon & Bustami, 2021; Garcia & Cerado, 2020; Ghani et al., 2020).
In the Philippines, the Department of Education (DepEd) also used the SBM to evaluate the continuous improvement program in
educational institution. Furthermore, SBM is thought to create more effective student learning environments by engaging teachers,
parents, and other community stakeholders. Additionally, SBM gives administrators, teachers, students, and parents more say over how
the educational process is carried out by entrusting them with making decisions on the budget, hiring, and curriculum (David et al.,
2019; Ghani et al., 2020; Llego, 2020).
However, administrative tasks are separate from the staffing patterns in public institutions. It means that teachers are carrying out
administrative tasks, a circumstance that, albeit disguised from the view of the standard metrics, can degrade teaching quality.
According to some teachers, the workload restricts their teaching time. Individual and situational factors fundamentally influence
performance (David et al., 2019; Llego, 2020; Rohma et al., 2020).
In addition, researchers indicated that the experience of high-level stress may negatively affect the teachers' well-being. Besides, it
influences instructors to quit and look for employment elsewhere. Therefore, it is crucial to determine the underlying source of this
issue so that a quick fix may be suggested. Furthermore, the majority was due to intrinsic factors such as workload, time constraints,
classroom management, class size, and the rate of educational change and reform. In addition to that, the decision-making power,
physical working conditions, professional autonomy, workplace relationships (colleagues, parents, superiors), and organizational
culture, just like the general feeling of the workplace and management style, are some of the factors that affect the teacher's well-being
(Harmsen et al., 2018; Smith & Yang, 2017).
Nevertheless, it cannot be disregarded that the Schools Division of South Cotabato has been constantly encouraging institutions to
embrace the SBM in all types of schools within the province and take this kind of elevation. Based on my readings, I have yet to come
across a parallel study on the setting of last-mile schools. The T'boli District II was one of the districts that did not have a validated
school on the SBM level of practice. The thought of it scares the core of every teacher in Barangay Maan area. Everyone understood
the magnitude of work that SBM could bring. However, reality remains constant; it evolves, so teachers must cope with the changes in
educational structure.
Furthermore, the implementation of School-Based Management is not a piece of cake. School-based Management is a motion of
changing gears and gearing it up to face that tremendous task. It goes out of the shell, discovering every layer of one's being and taking
responsibility. Moreover, the researcher has yet to come across the same phenomenon that explores the lofty experiences of teachers
of the SBM work in the last-mile schools. Likewise, she had also seen the significance and essence of the journey of stabilizing a
system within an institution. Thus, many discoveries need to be made in the quest for school-based Management.
With those mentioned above, the researcher aimed to understand and study the structures of experience and consciousness of the
teachers in their School-Based Management (SBM) experiences in the last mile schools.
Research Questions
The study aimed to understand how teachers change gear and gear up based on their school-based management experiences in last-
mile schools. This study specifically sought to respond to the following questions:
1. How do teachers describe their School-Based Management (SBM) experiences in the last mile schools?
1.1 How do teachers describe the challenges in doing the School-Based Management (SBM) journey in the last mile schools?
1.2 How do teachers describe their coping mechanisms for navigating the School-Based Management (SBM) journey in last-
mile schools?
1.3 What insights can the teachers share with others about their School-Based Management (SBM) journey in the last mile
schools?
Methodology
This section presents the research design, the role of the researcher, research participants, data collection, data analysis, trustworthiness,
and ethical considerations.
Research Design
In this research, the qualitative phenomenological method was employed. The researcher went to a particular setting of interest to
collect the data, to describe the natural setting of the direct source of data, and the researcher as well as the key instrument. The goal
of the study was to gather data, such as interview transcripts, field notes, audio recordings, diaries, personal comments, official records,
or anything else that could capture the actual words or deeds of the study's subjects; thus, this research method was used (Fitchett &
Heafner, 2017).
Additionally, as the primary study's main goal was to understand how people interpret their lives, according to Miller et al. (2018), the
qualitative research design was suited to employ such a goal. The researcher’s focus was the participants’ assumptions, motives,
reasons, goals, and values about the experiences they encountered in their journey. With that, the researcher tried to capture the thinking
of the participants’ perspectives as accurately as possible. Moreover, Leavy (2017) affirmed that descriptive qualitative design focused
on describing special or essential events as experienced by the teachers participating in their SBM experiences, and these experiences
of the participants were noted and recorded. In this study, aside from collecting the unique or essential events the teachers experienced
in their journey, the researcher investigated these experiences' various reactions to or perceptions of a particular phenomenon where
she hoped to gain some insight from their quest.
In qualitative research, Alam (2021) stated that researchers can use the "what" question to form the research questions. Additionally,
it might investigate the "what" as well as the "why" and "how" of a phenomenon in a more comprehensive, detailed, and wide-ranging
manner. Further, while it occasionally uses images, videos, or other conduct records, qualitative research frequently uses language as
its data, whether written or spoken. The focus group method, interviews, or observations are frequently used to gather qualitative data.
The goal of qualitative research is to illuminate the viewpoints of the participants or patients who are the topic of the study. It uses an
iterative procedure called "emergent design," which combines data analysis, preliminary data inspection, and data collection (Haven
& Van Grootel, 2019).
In summary, the researcher mainly focused on the essential structure of a single phenomenon (experiences of teachers and their School-
Based Management journey) by interviewing in-depth and Focusing group discussion. Several individuals who had experienced this
phenomenon served as participants in the study. Then extracted what was considered to be relevant statements for each subject’s
description of the phenomenon and then clustered these statements into themes. The researcher then integrated these themes into a
narrative description of the phenomenon. Lastly, these experiences were clustered into emergent themes of experiences, coping
mechanisms, and insights from the informants.
Participants
This study used purposive sampling to identify my participants. The researcher purposely included at least twenty (20) participants
who have experienced in School-Based Management. The participants came from six last-mile schools of Barangay Maan in Tboli,
South Cotabato. These participants were teachers who have experience in SBM undertakings and who have served the Department of
Education for at least three years or more. Additionally, in-depth interviews with the 10 participants were conducted, and the FGD was
divided into two sessions with five participants each, consisting of nine females and one man. They were all chosen in the same manner
as the informants and were all from the same area. The teaching experiences of the focus group participants ranged from three to five
years. The discussions were conducted to gain additional insights into the SBM journey of teachers in the last mile schools and to
strengthen and confirm the findings. During the discussion, the participants' real names were not used to protect their identities. They
were also assigned pseudonyms. Furthermore, most in-depth interviews were done on the premises of the participants' houses.
Moreover, some were conducted in the four corners of their classrooms. In contrast, the Focus Group Discussions were conducted in
their schools. According to Adams (2017), the focus group approach is assembling a group of participants to talk about a topic to learn
what participants believe about the topic, how they think about it, and why they think the way they do.
Data Collection
Data collection started by identifying the problem or phenomenon of interest, determining the research objective, and collecting the
participant's experiences. First, I submitted a Protocol Application to the Ethics Review Committee. Upon approval, I sought the
Graduate School Dean's permission to conduct my research study. Then, I communicated my goals and intentions through letters to
the Department of Education Schools Division of South Cotabato superintendent, and the school heads followed. Further, the letter to
the key informants and informed consent were given, and all the terms and conditions applicable to their participation were explained.
Furthermore, this study followed steps to get the required data. With this, In-depth interviews and Focus Group Discussions (FGD)
were conducted with the participants to record notes. Ethics was taken into account before the interview was conducted. According to
Arfin (2018), in every research project, it is crucial to protect human subjects by putting the proper ethical standards into practice. It
balances the ethical issues of research and its expected benefits.
In-depth interviews were one strategy used to gather information from research informants. The in-depth interview technique depicts
the participant's viewpoint on the research issue. Further, DeJonckheere and Vaughn (2019) stated that In-depth interviews are the most
frequently utilized qualitative data source in health services research and are frequently employed in qualitative research. This method
often involves a discussion between the researcher and the participant, facilitated by a flexible interview style and strengthened by
follow-up questions, requests for further information, and comments. The method enables the researcher to collect unstructured data,
explore participants' thoughts, feelings, and views about a particular topic, and delve deeply into delicate and occasionally private
issues.
Moreover, according to Creswell and Creswell (2017), if phenomenological methods are used in qualitative research, it is advised that
researchers conduct in-depth interviews with 5–25 individuals who have participated in the same phenomenon if one wants to
accomplish the objective of using the criteria of representativeness and generalizability, a modest number of research subjects.
Furthermore, I understood that it was crucial to give the participant a safe and comfortable environment for sharing personal
experiences; a comfortable and welcoming atmosphere invites and encourages the participants to converse and share personal
information and experiences. It shows that language and environment are key issues that impact the participant's feeling of safety, as
Novek and Wilkins (2019) stated. Along with this recommendation, I ensured the interview would be conducted in a quiet place to
provide privacy and avoid distractions. The interviews took place in a convenient place that the participants preferred. Most of the in-
depth interviews were conducted on the premises of the participants' houses, and some were conducted in the four corners of their
classrooms.
On the other hand, the same principle was used in Focus Group Discussion (FGD). According to Morgan (2018), the focus group
approach is assembling a group of participants to talk about a topic to learn what participants believe about it, how they think about it,
and why they think the way they do. Additionally, Adams (2017) affirmed that focus groups resemble interviews. However, in focus
group talks, a focus group's strengths and limitations stem from its two distinguishing characteristics: the reliance on the researcher's
emphasis and the group's involvement. Therefore, to do this, I focused entirely on the subjects during the FGD, taking in every detail
as they described their experiences and refraining from offering my viewpoint or objecting to the comments made by the participants.
I made sure there were no interruptions or noises that could distract from the conversation.
According to Varpio and McCarthy (2017), an interviewer must be sensitive to the reactions and moods of the interviewees. They may
occasionally be able to manage these feelings independently. However, other times, as the interviewer, you may need to intervene to
safeguard your subject. Moreover, Note-taking should be used to make sure that all material is thoroughly captured and that no
significant detail is omitted. Ince audio or video recording enhanced the accuracy of the information revealed in the focus group or in-
depth interview, as well as the speaker's intonations, data were gathered through audio recordings of interviews (Huang, 2021).
In addition, the interview's audio tapes were verbatim transcribed, and the participants approved the accuracy of the transcription. All
sessions and interactions with all informants were conducted in strict confidence. Quantitative and qualitative researchers are concerned
with preserving the privacy and safety of research participants. According to Kirilova and Karcher (2017), providing them with a safe
and comfortable environment to share their experiences is vital. In addition, to strengthen trust and confidence, all the tapes recorded
Morgan & Bantulo 313/324
Psych Educ, 2024, 16(1): 311-324, Document ID:2024PEMJ2159, doi:10.5281/zenodo.13256035, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article
were played for them. If there were issues they wanted to delete, then action should be taken. Further, the notes recorded were shown
to them for scrutiny and affirmation.
Furthermore, Surmiak (2018) encouraged using pseudonyms to conceal the participant’s identity. For that reason, this study employed
that method. Also, I prepared my open-ended research questions as listed in the interview guide to maintain a smooth flow during the
in-depth interview. I also let the interviewees know I may have additional questions besides the interview guide as part of probing.
They were necessary for gaining additional information for the study; it encouraged openness and trust among the participants.
During data collection, I saw that the principles of listening were observed. This data collection allowed the participants to unveil their
feelings, especially those working alone in the assigned SBM principle. I tried to show them that I was with them throughout the time
they told their experiences in the SBM journey. It is unavoidable that during their revelation, some issues needed clarification. However,
when these were asked again, it was done respectfully to win the participants' trust.
Withal, I saw to it that they signed the certificate of consent and that all the equipment, such as audio tapes, phone recorders, and pen
audio recorders as backup, was used with the assurance that everything that happened during the interview and group discussions was
held in anonymity. In addition, McGrath et al. (2019) saw the importance of needing ethical approval in whatever form, from the
convenient place to conduct the interviews throughout the recorded interview.
As the researcher, I focused on my field of interest (phenomenon) with confidence and trust. I had the necessary knowledge and skills
to conduct interviews, group discussions, and note-taking. The objective of conducting this research was a success. With the respect I
showed my participants, they cooperated and fully supported this work.
Analysis of Data
The analysis came after the collection of every piece of data needed. The study employed thematic analysis to categorize all the data
acquired to comprehend it better. With that, I sought the assistance of an independent data analyst. Data analysis is one of the most
significant components of qualitative research. A thorough procedure helps enlighten the complexity of human conduct and inform
interventions, leading to hearing the voices of people's lived experiences (Raskind et al., 2019).
In addition, as stated, thematic analysis was used to identify the themes and patterns in the gathered qualitative data. The study used
and followed the six-phase guides of Braun & Clarke (2006), as cited by Maguire and Delahunt (2017). It was a valuable framework
for conducting this analysis. These included getting to know the data, developing preliminary codes, looking for themes, going over,
clarifying, and documenting them.
Data transcription must be done before proceeding to the first stage of the process. I sought help transcribing my data while translating
it. I then went on to the first phase, reviewing and rereading the data to familiarize myself. The data taken from the participants were
combinations of Tagalog and Cebuano dialects, as well as some English terms.
Furthermore, in generating codes, I asked for help from an independent data analyst to meaningfully and methodically organize our
data. Coding compresses a large amount of information to digestible meaning. There are various ways of coding. Thus, the strategy
would depend on your viewpoint and study objectives. We discussed the relevant ideas for the research questions. We talked about
them and came up with some early concepts for codes. Then, we each started separately coding a transcript. Every passage of text that
was pertinent to or mainly addressed our study issue was coded as we went through each transcript. After we were done, we compared
our codes, spoke about them, and made changes before going on to the remaining transcripts.
After that, we proceeded to search for themes. Then, we looked at the codes in this instance; some made up a theme. The themes
derived described trends in the data that were important to the research questions. The next stage is reviewing the themes by modifying
and developing the initial themes and investigating if they are helpful and relevant. We examined each theme's corresponding data and
evaluated whether the evidence supported it. It was considered whether the themes made sense when seen in the context of the complete
data set at the following stage.
Moreover, the final refinement of the themes followed the fifth stage, which was to define themes. Considering the following questions,
what was the theme trying to say? If there were sub-themes, how did they relate to and interact with the central theme? What connections
were there between the themes? These were the necessary steps I took to analyze the data gathered.
Results
This section presented the findings of the study based on the gathered data taken from the participants.
6.1 Participants
This study had twenty key informants, sixteen women, and four men. These teachers serve the sitio schools at Barangay Maan,
Municipality of T’boli, also known as T’boli II District in the Division of South Cotabato. Their teaching experiences ranged from
three years to seven years. They were selected based on their experiences in the School-Based Management journey. The experiences
and narration of these teachers were heard, observed, and written, whether pleasant, joyful, painful, or fearful; the stories of teachers,
like the support they received from their colleagues, their hopes and dreams as teachers, and the insights they could share with other
teachers. For purposes of confidentiality, the participants were given pseudonyms.
The in-depth interview was conducted with three males and seven females. To begin with, my first informant is a teacher, Abby. She
is 31 years old and a teacher at Datal Tablo Integrated School. She has been serving DepEd for four years now. On the other hand,
Teacher Bella is a 28-year-old teacher currently serving at Coong Elementary School and is in her fifth year of service. Further, another
fellow from a last-mile school happily accepted the chance to be part of this research Teacher Clint, a 28-year-old educator serving
Balnabo Elementary School for four years.
Moreover, another teacher from Datal Tablo Integrated School participated in the interview. She is Teacher Debby who is 29 years old
and has served her station for four years. Another participant from Balnabo Elementary School contributed to the data collection is 29-
year-old Teacher, Eli, who has been in the service for five years. Furthermore, Teacher Franz is a 29-year-old male teacher at Coong
Elementary School. He has been in that school for four years.
Additionally, Teacher Gem is a 31-year-old teacher assigned to the farthest schools in the barangay, namely, Lamdamay Elementary
School. She has been fervently giving her service for four years. Furthermore, Teacher Hans, a 28 male teacher from Begue Integrated
School, purposefully participated in the interview. He has been serving his station for three years. Likewise, Teacher Iris, a 28-year-
old educator, has served the Begue Integrated School for four years. Lastly, Teacher Jin, a 31-year-old female teacher from Lamdamay
Elementary School, also participated in the data collection for this study. She has been serving the farthest school for five years.
Two focus group discussions were conducted with five participants per FGD, nine females and one male. All of them were from the
same locale and were selected in the same way as the informants. The teaching experiences of the focus group participants ranged from
three to five years. The discussion was conducted to gain additional insights and constructs on the SBM journey of teachers from the
last mile schools and to strengthen and confirm the findings. In order to conceal the true identity of the participants, the use of the
participants' real names during the discussion was avoided. They were given pseudonyms as well.
Both study groups answered the same set of questions. The first few participants selected were my acquaintances. Thus, during our
get-together, I learned that our experiences in the SBM validation were similar. Purposive sampling was the sampling strategy
employed, and through their recommendations and referrals, I could locate additional informants. I arranged meetings with the
recommended informants and participants with the help of their school heads and my colleagues. Their lending hands helped me collect
data and information.
The first focus group discussion group was the Datal Calon Elementary School teachers. It consisted of five enthusiastic informants.
Teacher Kara is 27 years old and has served the school for four years. Teacher Lisa is 34 years old and has been successfully serving
the school for three years. Similarly, Teacher Mona is 34 years old and has been at that station for four years. Further, the last participant
for the FGD on this particular station is Teacher Oli. She is 29 years of age and has been in school for four years.
Secondly, the following participants for the Focus Group Discussion came from Datal Tablo Integrated School. The data collection
was taken from five brilliant and bright informants consisting of one male and four females. Teacher Pearl is a 30-year-old teacher who
has been teaching for three years. Further, Teacher Queeny is a 28-year-old teacher whose service has reached four years. Likewise,
Teacher Rose has served the institution for four years. She is a 30 year old female teacher. Similarly, Teacher Sara has rendered four
years of service. She is a 31-year-old enthusiastic educator. Further, the last informant was the only male in the group, a 28-year-old
teacher named Tom, who has also served the school for four years.
Notably, these participants were associated with my friends. That is why I eventually got much help from them, which made my
connection with the target informants manageable. This action-built trust, which was deemed significant in extracting their personal
information, and they genuinely shared their SBM experiences and journeys. All informants in the in-depth interview were my friends,
but some participants in the Focus Group Discussion (FGD) were referred to me. Though some were initially anxious, they eventually
felt comfortable with my assurance of confidentiality. They were very cooperative in answering each of my interview questions.
Through their voice and facial expressions, one could still feel their joy and sadness because of their experiences with the school-Based
Management validation.
In addition, the focus group discussion was fascinating, and the interaction was spontaneous. You could hear, in their low voices, how
they reacted to the experiences of the other participants. Some had similar experiences, but each had his/her own exciting story to tell
of their difficulties and takeaways from that quest.
The interviews took place in different places, depending on the participants' preferences. Some were interviewed in a quiet area of their
school campus, or in their humble abode, in the four corners of their classroom, and for the FGD, I went to their schools and interviewed
in the actual premise of their SBM room in their schools. Moreover, I saw to it that they signed the certificate of consent and that all
the equipment like audio tapes, recorder of my phone, and pen audio recorders as backup were used with the assurance that everything
that happened during the interview and group discussions would be held in anonymity.
6.2 Challenges of the Teachers in School-Based Management (SBM) Journey
From the data collected on the challenges encountered by the study participants, nine emergent themes appeared, as presented in Table
1. These themes are Burdening Pressure, Overwhelming Paperwork, Wavering Confidence, Emerging Passiveness, Occurring
Misunderstanding, Varying Loads, Unraveling Authenticity, Lacking of Knowledge, and Believing in Competence.
Table 1. Challenges of the Teachers in SBM Journey
Cluster Themes Emergent Themes
Worried and pressured in the task
Retrieval of documents from 3 years back
Burdening Pressure
Additional tasks to work
Expectations in achieving Level 3
Never-ending paperwork
Additional work for teachers Overwhelming Paperwork
There are tons of files to accomplish
Lack of guidance
First time to be evaluated Wavering Confidence
Lack of experiences
They are not performing the task
Lack of manpower Emerging Passiveness
Different work ethics
Occurrence of misunderstanding among teachers
Misinterpretation of instructions Occuring Misunderstanding
Resentment among teachers
Unequal task distribution
The given task is based on teacher’s competence Varying Loads
Difference work pacing
Fabrication of documents
Lack of Means of Verification Unraveling Authenticity
Lack of supportting documents
Difficulty in figuring out the task
Lacking Knowledge
Dfficulty is supporting verbal explanation
Lack of Technical Assistance
Belief in their abilities
Colleagues are competitive Believing in Competence
Everyone has strength and potential
The varying loads were normally to the competence of the teachers. These have put some teachers in a tough situation, in doing more
compared to others. It was apparent that the workloads were not distributed equally. Some teachers ended up working more on other
tasks and covering for others.
6.2.7 Unraveling Authenticity
The legitimacy of data was one of the hardest parts to comply with in the SBM journey. Since most last mile schools are not equipped
in following the standard system of the School-Based Management in gathering the data. Teacher participants shared the same agony
when it comes to finding and providing authentic documents.
6.2.8 Lacking Knowledge
It was an extra challenge for the last mile schools that not everyone is equipped to do School-Based Management. In general, schools
from far-flung areas do not always have the spotlight and standardization that urban schools have. The serving teachers of these sitio
schools were more focused on their teaching inside their classrooms. This shows that most of them lack the knowledge when it comes
to School-Based Management.
6.2.9 Believing in Competence
The participants had gone through a lot on this SBM journey, nevertheless, most of them had faith in the capabilities of their co-
workers. On the edge of toughness, they still managed to see the competence of their teaching force. Most teachers had confidence big
or small in their teaching force despite the disadvantages they have experienced.
6.3 Coping Mechanisms of the Teachers in Doing School-Based Management (SBM) Journey
Table 2: Coping Mechanisms of the Teachers in SBM Journey
Cluster Themes Emergent Themes
We can achieve level 3
We will not give up
Uplifting Oneself
No retreat, no surrender
Colleagues appropriate the task done.
Hearing works of thanks.
Affirming a job well done. Receiving Compliments
There are tons of files to accomplish
Brainstorming about SBM with colleagues.
Communicate clearly.
Free flowing Dialogue
Planning the task carefully.
Intensify school and community communication
Save and secure evidence.
Secure and print documents. Safe keeping of Documents.
Document every activity.
Focus on the given task
Be familiar with the assigned task Preparing Oneself
Review the documents.
Prepare school enviroment.
Maintain school cleanliness. Replenishing Environment
Improve physical environment.
Integrate SBM tasks on daily activities.
Informal interaction with colleagues. Sharing Informal Conversation
Cross-checking accomplished documents.
Provide means of verification.
Learning Accountability
Be responsible for the tasks given.
Perform task accordingly.
From the data collected on how teachers cope with the challenges while doing the School-Based Management endeavor; eight emergent
themes appeared as presented in Table 2. These themes are; Uplifting Oneself, Receiving Compliments, Free-flowing Dialogue, Safe-
Keeping of Documents, Preparing Oneself, Replenishing Environment, Sharing Informal Conversation and Learning Accountability.
1.1.1 Uplifting Oneself
Every one of us has a tagline in boosting ourselves in face of difficulties. The participants have been chanting their personal mantra
every time they wanted to give up on this SBM endeavor. In addition, words that affirm them are like oil that fuels them to continue
and serves a comfort that inspires them to hold on until the validation day. (Most of the teachers have similar taglines, that is, “to fight
validation. Nevertheless, significant feelings and thoughts surfaced about the mountain of additional paperwork to work on.
Eight emergent themes emerged in the participant's responses to the challenges encountered: Uplifting Oneself, Receiving
Compliments, Free-flowing Dialogue, Safe-Keeping the Documents, Preparing Oneself, Replenishing the Environment, Sharing
Informal Conversation, and Learning Accountability.
Furthermore, participants chanted their mantra whenever they fetl like giving up, always fighting because they believed they could.
Additionally, receiving compliments encouraged the participants to work. The affirmations that brought excitement to the participants
were the words “thank you” and “Good Job”. On the other hand, free-flowing dialogue was an inevitable realization for the participants
in solving conflict matters. Another urgent realization was the practice of safekeeping the documents because securing the documents
was necessary to acquire authentic evidence.
It was equally important to put effort into preparation. There are different faces of preparation, depending on one’s preferences.
Likewise, replenishing the school environment was also a priority since the learning environment depicts the school's conduciveness.
As a team, participants coped in different ways and shapes. It may be in a formal or informal set-up; as long as there were interactions
and discussions related to SBM, there was learning and progress. Moreover, finally, being accountable for one's task was vital along
the journey.
Seven emergent themes emerged from the insights shared by the participants: Becoming One's Best Version, Having a Compassionate
Heart, Stepping out of Comfort Zone, Lagging in Action, Hoping in Sanguinity, Laboring in Bliss, and Thriving Values. The teacher
participants admitted that they had improved and leveled up because it was a quest to rediscover themselves and light a spark of new
versions of themselves. Similarly, SBM made teachers extend more patience and understanding to the situation and people.
In addition, the improvement that manifested in the informants was seen as they stepped out of their comfort zone. Teachers learned
personally, interpersonally, and professionally. Many realizations and gearing up happened throughout this undertaking. However,
caution also came from them, such as lagging in action. In other words, passiveness was a nemesis on this journey. This paralyzed and
sometimes could leave a sour taste in people's relationships, as per experience.
Eventually, after all the hardships, a Hope in Sanguinity manifested. Overwhelming happiness unfolded after the fruit of labor was
tasted. All the effort had paid off. That Laboring Bliss was evident and manifested when the result was announced. Indeed, these were
all possible with all the Thriving Values executed by the participants as the School-Based Management journey progressed.
Disscusion
This section presents the discussion, implications for practice, and implications for future research based on the themes developed
during the data analysis.
With a clear indication, this study aimed to understand the School-Based Management experiences of the teachers in the last mile
schools. It aimed to unravel the feelings and insights the participants came across from the beginning to the SBM validation. The
outcome of this study would pave the way to a deeper understanding and reflection of how teachers from the last mile schools cope up
with the changes in educational structure. Moreover, it sought to go deeper into the issue's core from the experiences of participants
and insights that may determine what concepts and themes from the findings.
In exploring and building the participant’s experiences, the researcher believed that phenomenology is a powerful research strategy
that was well suited for it. Moreover, Merriam and Grenier (2019) stated that for this qualitative research design, the lived experiences
about the event or events experienced by the participants during in-depth interviews were recorded and, with the survey questionnaire,
were put out and put together, sorted and categorized into different themes. The commonality of the stories told was structured and
classified for easy analysis for a common understanding.
Conclusion
They say that a teacher should keep bringing the light, whether in a mountain or a city. Indeed, there is a distinguished joy in mountain
teachers like us; I am proud to witness the journey of my informants who accepted the challenge to change gear and gear up, to dance
the tango of the School-Based Management journey. Teachers from last-mile schools have been subtly dodging the SBM task. The
thought scares every teacher's core since an undeniable workload and responsibility knocks before them. Moreover, SBM is like
massive entropy that rushes when one takes the challenge of embracing it.
The experiences of burdening pressure and additional workload are a starting pack at the beginning of the journey. In addition, the
majority of the teachers need to gain Knowledge of how it works. Indeed, doubts and hesitation were evident. These led to some stories
of bickering and misunderstanding, which affected the relationship of the teaching force. It created an environment that made some
teachers idle and dependent on colleagues they deemed competent to do more excellent work.
Relatedly, as a researcher who experienced the difficulty of this journey, I could attest that these problems were real and tangible.
However, just like an infamous quote says, 'What does not kill you makes you stronger’ has proven that we always find the strength to
fight back while breaking. Despite all of the disadvantages and hesitations, there lies a chink of positive aspect in the confidence that
Morgan & Bantulo 320/324
Psych Educ, 2024, 16(1): 311-324, Document ID:2024PEMJ2159, doi:10.5281/zenodo.13256035, ISSN 2822-4353
Research Article
DeJonckheere, M., & Vaughn, L. M. (2019). Semistructured interviewing in primary care research: A balance of relationship and
rigour. Family medicine and community health, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.1136/fmch-2018-000057
Dowie, I., & Griffith, R. (2019). Dimond's legal aspects of nursing: a definitive guide to law for nurses. Pearson Higher Ed.
Fitchett, P. G., & Heafner, T. L. (2017). Quantitative research and Large‐Scale secondary analysis in social studies. , 68–94.
https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118768747.ch4
Garcia, M. A., & Cerado, E. C. (2020). Developing an Evidence-Based Evaluation Tool for Continuous Improvement Program of the
Department of Education. American Journal of Educational Research, 8(7), 502–507. https://doi.org/10.12691/education-8-7-8
Ghani, A. R. A., Fatayan, A., Yatri, I., Qodariah, L., Bunyamin, B., & Burmansah, B. (2020). Evaluation of school-based management
implementation (sbm) in madrasah jakarta. Talent Development & Excellence, 12(1). 3490–3511.
http://iratde.com/index.php/jtde/article/view/1309
Harmsen, R., Helms-Lorenz, M., Maulana, R., & Van Veen, K. (2018). The relationship between beginning teachers’ stress causes,
stress responses, teaching behaviour and attrition. Teachers and Teaching, 24(6), 626-643.
https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2018.1465404
Haven, T., & Van Grootel, L. (2019). Preregistering qualitative research. Accountability in Research, 26(3), 229–244.
https://doi.org/10.1080/08989621.2019.1580147
Hero, J. L. (2020). Level shifting, workload, school location, teacher competency and principal leadership skills in public elementary
schools. Online Submission, 4(7), 8-13. http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED607090.pdf
Herzberg, F. (2017). Motivation to work. Routledge.
Hopper, E. (2020, February 24). Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs Explained. ThoughtCo. https://www.thoughtco.com/maslows-
hierarchy-of-needs-4582571
Hopper, E. (2021, August 11). Understanding Self-Efficacy. ThoughtCo. https://www.thoughtco.com/self-efficacy-4177970
Huang, H. W. (2021). Effects of smartphone-based collaborative vlog projects on EFL learners’ speaking performance and learning
engagement. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 37(6), 18-40. https://doi.org/10.14742/ajet.6623
Into, C. A. D., & Gempes, G. P. (2018). Untold stories of teachers with multiple ancillary functions: A phenomenology of fortitude.
Journal of Advances in Humanities and Social Sciences, 4(1), 13-25. https://www.tafpublications.com/platform/Articles/full-
jahss4.1.2.php
Iyore, C. (2018). Stressors, effects and coping strategies among teachers in secondary schools in Edo State, Nigeria. International
Journal of Research-Granthaalayah, 6(9), 137-147. https://doi.org/10.29121/granthaalayah.v6.i9.2018.1216
Jendle, H., & Wallnäs, A. (2017). Effects of exercise, social support and hardiness on occupational stress in swedish teachers. Effects
of Exercise, Social Support and Hardiness on Occupational Stress in Swedish Teachers. http://oru.diva-
portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:1120081
Jerrim, J., & Sims, S. (2021). When is high workload bad for teacher wellbeing? Accounting for the non-linear contribution of specific
teaching tasks. Teaching and Teacher Education, 105, 103395. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2021.103395
Jomuad, P. D., Antiquina, L. M. M., Cericos, E. U., Bacus, J. A., Vallejo, J. H., Dionio, B. B., & Clarin, A. S. (2021). Teachers’
workload in relation to burnout and work performance. International Journal of Educational Policy Research and Review.
https://doi.org/10.15739/IJEPRR.21.007
Jung, H. S., & Yoon, H. H. (2018). Improving frontline service employees' innovative behavior using conflict management in the
hospitality industry: The mediating role of engagement. Tourism Management, 69, 498-507.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tourman.2018.06.035
Kigenyi, E.M., Kakuru, D. & Ziwa, G. (2017). School environment and performance of public primary school teachers in Uganda.
International Journal of Technology and Management, 2(1), 14. http://ijotm.utamu.ac.ug/index.php/ijotm/article/view/18
Kim, K. N. (2019). Teachers’ administrative workload crowding out instructional activities. Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 39(1),
31-49. https://doi.org/10.1080/02188791.2019.1572592
Kirilova, D., & Karcher, S. (2017). Rethinking data sharing and human participant protection in social science research: Applications
from the qualitative realm. Data Science Journal, 16. https://doi.org/10.5334/dsj-2017-043
Lawrie, G. A., Schultz, M., Bailey, C. H., & Dargaville, B. L. (2019). Personal journeys of teachers: An investigation of the
development of teacher professional knowledge and skill by expert tertiary chemistry teachers. Chemistry Education Research and