CAR UK - May 2025
CAR UK - May 2025
2025
ISSUE 754
£6.50
£7k BOXSTER
WHAT ARE YOU
WAITING FOR? HALF-PRICE 911
HAPPINESS IS A
MANUAL 991.1
CAR is thriving – join us on the journey
WHERE
WILL CAR What other magazine would dare to take a (briefly) shiny new Ferrari Purosangue
to the windblown expanses of the Sahara desert? Or drive a very secondhand Fiat
TAKE YOU? Panda all the way back from Andorra to the UK? It’s these stories – along with our
uncompromising road tests, insightful analysis and candid interviews – that make
CAR an unmissable package, not only every month but every day, via our various
online channels.
CAR is home to the world’s greatest motoring journalists and photographers,
creating beautifully crafted stories aimed at entertaining, informing and occasionally
outraging our loyal and equally opinionated readers around the world.
In CAR’s 60-plus years the world has rarely known so much change and
uncertainty. Technological developments, challenging legislation, new trends,
emerging powers – nothing moves in the automotive world without us having a
well-informed opinion on it. CAR is your guiding star, helping to cut through all the
PR-babble and deliver an honest verdict on what actually matters to you, the people
driving these cars. No wonder CAR is Britain’s most successful motoring title, with a
growing global reach.
No matter how you prefer to enjoy our stories, CAR has an outlet for you. The
magazine continues to thrive, and there’s never been a better time to take out a
subscription (see p60). Not only does doing so represent great value for money, you get
access to each new issue days ahead of the on-sale date via the CAR app. Powered by
the same incredible storytelling as the magazine, the app lets you read all our content
and watch all our videos on your phone or tablet. We’re also available on Apple
News+, which has exclusive stories as well as the complete monthly issue, and for the
latest news and reviews visit carmagazine.co.uk. And while you’re online, be sure to
subscribe to CAR magazine on YouTube – the channel has all the hot tests and epic
adventures you’d expect from a title that never stops pushing; never stops exploring.
Exploring Italy’s
heartland in the Alfa
Romeo Junior
Get more
and get it earlier
SPECIAL OFFER: GET 3 ISSUES
OF CAR FOR JUST £5!
FOR DETAILS OF THIS AND OTHER OFFERS SEE
TIKTOK
PAGE 60 OR VISIT GREATMAGAZINES.CO.UK/CAR @car.magazine.uk
Agenda
6 Lewis Hamilton took a risk when he left
Mercedes. We ask Ferrari veterans just
what he’s let himself in for
10 Four very different newcomers all leaning
hard on some old ideas
12 The new CLA isn’t just the replacement
for a pretty decent compact saloon – it’s
the start of a new era for Mercedes
16 Volvo’s on-off, off-on, on-off relationship
with saloons and estates seems to be
heading to a permanent off. Probably!
Boss Jim Rowan talks us through the logic
18 Maserati is struggling again, and Stellantis
ownership doesn’t seem to be helping.
Let’s have a whip-round…
20 Inside the McLaren W1 engine
22 BMW’s ingenious new strategy for
Our Cars
108 The low-key delights of the Mercedes
GLC, plus Audi S3 meets RS3
They’re smiling
working at Ferrari is unique. Nothing compares.’
Hamilton will have so much coming at him in months
to come – not least the challenge of dealing with a young,
now. But how long fast team-mate. Scheckter knows all about that. In the
early months of his first season Gilles Villeneuve blew
him away. The odds of an echo in 2025 via Charles Leclerc,
Maranello won the first two races [actually, the third and fourth of
1979. Jacques Laffite won the first two, for Ligier] and I
was the number one driver in contract. In reality he was
honeymoon last? becoming number one. So I just had to knuckle down and
do better, which I did. It took everything – and more.’
Scheckter won back-to-back at Zolder and Monaco to
Damien Smith F1 writer take the points lead, scored consistently through the
summer and clinched the title with two rounds to spare,
leading Villeneuve to a Ferrari 1-2 at Monza. Hamilton
can only dream.
Seven Ferrari F1 drivers have managed to win in their
first race for the team, one of them being Nigel Mansell
who took the most unlikely of victories, 10 years after
Scheckter’s title, in Rio in 1989. Villadelprat was Mansell’s
chief mechanic that day. He recalls Mansell’s doubts
about John Barnard’s stunning but revolutionary Ferrari
640, the first F1 car driven through a semi-automatic
gearbox, with steering wheel paddles for the changes –
sensational then, common today on road cars.
‘It was the best car ever designed by John Barnard,’ says
Villadelprat. ‘But in testing it was not reliable. Anyway,
Mansell arrived. He was an old-fashioned man: “Where’s
the gearlever? I don’t want to drive like that.” He drove at
Fiorano – and after 10 laps he said “This is brilliant!”’
In Rio, Mansell was so sure his Ferrari debut wouldn’t
last long he tried to book an early flight home via a British
Airways captain he met on the grid… Yet less than two
hours later, there he was, taking the chequered flag ahead
of Alain Prost’s McLaren. Villadelprat drew blood to get
that svelte 640 across the line. ‘Mid-race we had a radio ⊲
Scheckter:
lemons then,
beef now
something to the public when you do a press release – but life. Lewis has been fantastic, probably the best of all time. Schumacher had
don’t talk to the press,’ advises Joan. ‘Don’t even look at the same result [in terms of world championships], but he tended to be dirty in
them!’ his racing. Lewis has always raced clean. But at 40? People are different. I got
Scheckter chuckles about his relationship with jour- bored and retired early, then changed careers. Lewis still seems to be enthusi-
nalists and takes some pride in his status as a three-time astic and is in a good place personally, although that isn’t always good for per-
consecutive winner of the ‘lemon prize’ – for being the formance.’
most difficult F1 driver to deal with. ‘At least I went to Villadelprat is more emphatic. ‘If the car is good Hamilton will beat Leclerc
fetch my prize, so it wasn’t too bad,’ he says with a smile. and win the championship,’ he states. ‘If the car is not so good Leclerc will beat
‘I always said to everybody in the team, “Let’s stick togeth- Hamilton. Simple. Hamilton has got too many things in life to think about,
er; don’t listen to the stuff that they write.” I think guys has a lot of money, has seven championships, so he’s not going to risk his life to
before me worried more. People like [Carlos] Reutemann. gain one more position. I saw it in all the F1 champions I knew: when the car is
But we stuck together and it didn’t really bother me what good you see the real driver.’
they said.’
Then again, imagine outspoken Scheckter in F1 today,
with social media waiting to pour scorn and castigation.
It would probably be unfair to say Hamilton faces more
pressure than his predecessors, but the nature of modern
communication and the toxicity in tone – direct from the
public more than the media – is harder to insulate
against. Then again, Hamilton has been F1’s most famous
driver since 2007. ‘For me, I always kept the mania in per-
spective,’ says Scheckter. ‘When people were jumping at
me for an autograph, I knew the next year they’d be
stamping on my body going to the next guy. Lewis is so
popular now he’s on a different planet.’ The car just
So predictions: how will Hamilton fare at Ferrari? needs to be as
‘George Russell outperformed him at Mercedes last year,’ good as it looks
says Scheckter. ‘You can’t stay good for the rest of your
Grille team
didn’t get the
memo about
clean, simple
design
Expect to see
these details
on other new
Mercs
stances than ever, even in chaotic urban environments. CLA is first to eral, it’s just a matter of what model you start with. Go
The CLA’s ‘surround navigation’ displays all the driver as- get the latest back to 2018 and the A-Class was the first car with MBUX.
sistance systems that are active, as well as a 3D representa- infotainment The latest E-Class, for example, was technically the first
tion of the car in the instruments. Mercedes says the tech car to have elements of MB.OS.’
means drivers will ‘benefit from improved situational Östberg notes: ‘The fact this was the starting point was
awareness, seeing what the CLA sees and how the assis- simply down to timing reasons. One vehicle had to have it
tance systems support them.’ first. Naturally, the S-Class will get this same technology,
That’s an awful lot of innovation for Merc’s smallest but what I’d say with the CLA is that the technology is
car. It’s a shame, then, that the CLA’s bodywork is so… dedicated to those in the front. Where does the owner sit
predictable. Schäfer told CAR in 2024 that Mercedes in an S-Class? There’ll be more emphasis on the rear-seat
would be stepping away from creating cars that look like passengers when it comes to the S-Class.’
bars of soap and sticking to its ‘iconic’ designs. And yet as
Gorden Wagener, Merc’s head of design, tells the CLA
event about purity and ‘taking details away’ to keep de-
signs clean, we can’t help but scoff. A fake grille arrange-
ment with 142 individually animated LEDs, for example,
isn’t everyone’s idea of design purity.
Either way, the amount of new technology on board
and the engineering developments are enough to put the
CLA head and shoulders above natural rivals such as the
Audi A3 saloon and BMW 2-series Gran Coupe, at least on
paper. It’s the sort of night-and-day difference that tradi-
tionally the range-topping S-Class has enjoyed when
compared to any would-be competitors.
So where does that leave the S-Class, if it’s no longer the
model that gets all the clever kit first, before it trickles
down to the rest of the range? Merc execs have different
perspectives. Starzynski says there’s a precedent: ‘In gen-
New Volvo estate? does not fit in with conventional ideas: ‘It is in a class of its
own. It’s got a long wheelbase, pushing those wheels into
the corner of the car, short front and rear overhangs.’ Its
Forget it. Forget jacked-up ride height puts it somewhere between a nor-
mal saloon and an SUV. And it’s not a booted saloon but a
hatchback. ‘It is fundamentally a large sedan, but with
:KHWKHUQHZRUSUHRZQHGIURPDGHDOHUVKLSRUSULYDWHVHOOHUEXLOWWRRUGHUDFODVVLFRU
ORRNLQJWRSXUFKDVHDWDXFWLRQVSHDNWR\RXU$FFFRXQW0DQDJHUDERXW\RXUIXQGLQJRSWLRQV
:($5($&5(',7%52.(5$1'127$/(1'(57KLVPHDQVZHDFWLQGHSHQGHQWO\WKURXJKDZLGHUDQJHRIOHQGHUVWRRHUDEURDGDQG
FRPSHWLWLYHFKRLFHRISURGXFWVDQGVROXWLRQV2UDFOH$VVHW)LQDQFHLVQRWD OLDWHGWRDQ\PRWRUPDQXIDFWXUHU2UDFOH)LQDQFHDQG2UDFOH&DU)LQDQFH
DUHWUDGLQJQDPHVRI2UDFOH$VVHW)LQDQFH/LPLWHG2UDFOH$VVHW)LQDQFH/LPLWHG &51 LVDXWKRULVHGDQGUHJXODWHGE\WKH)LQDQFLDO&RQGXFW
$XWKRULW\IRUWKHVDOHRIFRQVXPHUFUHGLW )LQDQFLDO6HUYLFHV5HJLVWHU1R )RUPRUHLQIRUPDWLRQSOHDVHYLVLWRUDFOHQDQFHFRXN
Maserati at its
best straddles
tradition and
modernity
Maybe Stellantis
beautiful and one of the most successful F1 cars of the ’50s,
was outclassed by the new-age machinery.
Stirling Moss’s winning Lotus 18-Climax was small,
is the problem,
mid-engined and showcased the future. Drake’s 250F, on
the other hand, was a glorious relic of the past, and fin-
ished seven laps adrift. It would be the 250F’s last GP.
not Maserati
There is a parallel between the 250F in 1960 and Mase-
rati today. A company whose cars once oozed desirability
is now a serial underperformer. A performance brand fa-
mous for its tuneful and characterful engines, and some
wonderful old GTs, must now navigate an uncertain new Gavin Green Contributor in chief
age. And just as the 250F finished its career in the autumn
of 1960, so there are doubts about Maserati’s future today.
Only a few months ago, Carlos Tavares, then boss of want,’ says Del Vecchio. The electric MC20 Folgore has
Maserati’s owner Stellantis, threatened to shut down un- been canned.
profitable brands, a clear reference to Maserati. The GranCabrio and GranTurismo Folgore models are
Last year global sales collapsed to 11,300, from 26,600 technically ambitious EVs: bespoke 800-volt architec-
the year before. In the UK, they were down 47 per cent. In tures, dedicated three-motor powertrains, low centre of
Italy, by 41 per cent. Production fell 64 per cent. Even new gravity and scorching performance elevate them above
models, like the Grecale SUV, suffered big falls. any other platform-shared Stellantis cars. The Gran-
In total, Maserati sold fewer cars than Ferrari, and was Cabrio Folgore is the world’s only GT convertible EV.
not far ahead of Lamborghini – both of which operate on a I drove both electric GranCabrio and GranTurismo
much higher and more profitable plane. Instead of invest- soon after talking to Del Vecchio. They are exquisitely
ing more in its sole luxury brand to boost product, Stellan- handsome cars and fearsomely fast, the most powerful
tis has written off £1.2 billion of investment in Maserati, Maseratis ever – and with more torque than the original
leaving some future models in doubt. Bugatti Veyron.
Under-achievement at Maserati is not new. Fifty years Jaguar insists its new-age EVs will sell because of the
ago almost exactly, Maserati was put into liquidation. sheer desirability of their design. If so, the outstandingly
Every decade since it’s regularly missed sales targets, as handsome GranCabrio and GranTurismo should also
various owners – including Ferrari – grappled with famil- succeed. (Although they’re expensive: the GranTurismo
iar and recurring problems: investment was delayed, Folgore starts at just under £180,000.) And you’d expect a
models aged, and so the circle of strife continued. new Quattroporte to look wonderful, given past efforts.
There have been some gloriously good cars, but many of Del Vecchio insists EVs are an opportunity for Maserati.
those have soldiered on well past retirement age. Platform ‘Electric power suits luxury and grand touring very well.’
sharing to go downmarket hasn’t helped. The Grecale The idea of Stellantis selling Maserati is also quickly dis-
SUV uses Alfa Stelvio underpinnings. It is an appealing missed. When Tavares left last December, the second Stel-
sports luxury SUV, but the electric Folgore version costs lantis brand that chairman John Elkann visited was Mase-
over £100,000. rati, she says. Elkann is also executive chairman of Ferrari,
Just over a decade ago, then-owner Fiat said Maserati MC20’s another brand with a distinguished racing past – but also a
would sell 75,000 cars a year. In fact, in 2025 it will be lucky electric highly successful present.
to sell one-seventh of that. version has It makes you wonder if a switch from Stellantis to Ferra-
Like Jaguar, Alfa Romeo, Lotus and Aston Martin, Ma- now been ri management would do the trick. Some of that Prancing
serati is a wonderful old European brand that has strug- cancelled Horse magic is clearly needed at its Modenese neighbour.
gled for decades. Stellantis has threatened to transform
Maserati but, so far, there are no signs of a Jaguar-style
rivoluzione.
The management, though, has changed. A new CEO,
Santo Ficili, was appointed by Tavares last October. A new
head for Maserati Northern Europe, which includes the
UK, was installed at the same time. Mariangela Del Vec-
chio, ex BMW, will tell you that in the past year three key
models were phased out – Quattroporte, Levante and
Ghibli – so it’s little wonder sales were affected.
On the other hand, new Folgore EV models were intro-
duced, which should have boosted demand. There were
technical issues that affected production and, as with
most new EVs, sales have disappointed. ‘New entry-level
versions of the Grecale [the 300] and GranTurismo and
GranCabrio [the 490 versions] are now available, as well as
the new GT2 Stradale and a full range of Folgore models,’
Del Vecchio points out.
She promises that 2025 will be better. An enhanced cus-
tomisation programme should also earn good money: it’s
a major source of Ferrari’s impressive profits.
A new Quattroporte – which also replaces the Ghibli –
is due in 2028 and a new Levante in 2027. The current plan
is for Maserati to be EV-only by 2030, but that is surely
now in doubt, given the shaky EV market, Donald Trump’s
pro-oil blusterings and slow initial sales of Folgore vari-
ants. ‘We are committed to electro mobility but we are
customer driven and will produce what our customers
decade looks… yet so hushed you can, if you listen hard enough, hear
McLaren’s test drivers firing up LinkedIn.
Part of their problem’s going to be this powertrain’s re-
SAVE
ON SHOP
PRICES
Front drive
unit relatively
cost-effective
to produce
and light
BMW and
be clear, this is not new clear thinking. BMW may have
pulled the covers off its next-gen electric powertrains re-
cently, as it gears up to deliver the first of its Neue Klasse
blb|;7 -u|m;uv_br _b1_ =ou ];m;u-Ѵ bmvu-m1; 7bv|ub0ঞom bv -m rrobm|;7
!;ru;v;m|-ঞ; o= (-v| (bvb0bѴb| blb|;7ķ Ѷ ubm1;v -u-7;ķ b;urooѴķ ƒ Ɛ ķ
$şv -rrѴ ";; ;0vb|; =ou 7;|-bѴv |_oubv;7 -m7 u;]Ѵ-|;7 0 |_; bm-m1b-Ѵ _b1_bv-|_oubv;7-m7u;]Ѵ-|;70 |_; bm-m1b-Ѵom71||_oub| m7;u bul
om71| |_oub| v|-u7 1o h bv - |u-7bm] m-l; o= |_; -;u 0Ѵbv_bm] !;=;u;m1;l0;uƔѵѵƖƕƒ +o1-m1_;1h|_;v;7;|-bѴvom|_; !;]bv|;u
All Toyota
engines
will get a
sprinkling
of this
No more dull
That allows us more freedom for our designers and engi-
neers when it comes to packaging.’
They’re designed to run on conventional petrol, and
Toyota engines,
there’s speculation that outputs could be as high as
400bhp. However, they’re also designed to be able to
combine with e-motors to create hybrids (both with and
without plug-in capability). And they are being developed
Meet the next ‘For our types of cars, which do very low mileage on av-
erage, a lot of the environmental impact is not in the us-
age phase but in the manufacturing phase,’ says Laun-
Gordon Murray berg. ‘So we’re using materials which have been used
before, and looking at how to minimise the use of car-
bonfibre at the design stage, and minimising waste in the
DACIA BIGSTER
Gambler, anonymous
Dacia risks heading into new territory with its most
expensive, least quirky car ever. Time for a trip to
Monaco, one of the costliest corners of Europe
Words Ted Welford Photography Jordan Butters
Family look
dominates
over Bigster
uniqueness
While Fiat is Baguette devoured, and aware that the light will soon
focusing on fade, it’s time to hit the road again and make some real
small cars,
Dacia’s moving progress as we join the A8 to get us to our overnight stop in
on up Grasse. The Bigster neatly gets up to the 130km/h limit
(about 80mph), and now we’re making good progress. It’s
relaxed enough at this speed, although it lacks the refine-
ment of a Qashqai and Sportage. The Bigster comes with a
new windscreen, shaped for improved acoustic perfor-
mance and thicker than the Duster’s, but it’s no match for
the wind noise generated by the blocky door mirrors.
Adaptive cruise control is another first for Dacia, and
since I’m pretty lazy on longer trips I enjoy the consistency
that ACC affords. It works well – intelligently slowing the
car down without jamming the anchors on just because
there’s a car on the horizon, and speeding up to overtake
as soon as you indicate.
The Bigster starts at £24,995, making it one of the most
affordable cars in this class. It’s £6000 less than the cheap-
est Qashqai but matches the price of an MG HS, a larger
and better-equipped car still. Dacia is also offering a new
hybrid version, priced from £27,095, but £29,495 in the
case of our Journey-trim test car. It’s a different set-up to
the Duster and seven-seat Jogger, using a new 1.8-litre
petrol engine paired to the same two electric motors as the
older cars. It puts out 153bhp and uses an automatic gear-
box made up of four gears for the engine and two for the
electric motors. Gone are the days when Dacia got Re-
nault’s hand-me-downs, as the Bigster is the first car from
across the Renault Group to get this hybrid system – a tes- Good economy
takes anxiety
tament to how highly the brand is valued by Renault. out of longer
As we leave Grasse the following morning, it’s time to journeys
start heading north into the mountains to test the O
Boot is usefully
big; there’s no
seven-seater
Sportback has
barely any less
luggage space
than the SUV
AUDI SQ5
Rarest of
rarities: a
Roller on track
V O L K S W A G E N TAY R O N
PE R FO R M A N C E S U VS + G O LF R BAC K O N TO P + VA S T E VS
ciding what sort of cars we should way that makes such objections
drive, how much we should pay for fade into the background. CO
them, where they will be made, and
much else besides. All hands
Perhaps I’m naive to think that There was an intriguing photo in
this hasn’t always been going on, but your coverage of the Dakar Rally
to my mind the people best qualified (March issue), showing the drivers
on those matters are engineers and and co-drivers of two Dacias work-
designers, and perhaps climate sci- ing on one of the cars. Your story
entists. If the politicians went back to made it clear that this level of co-op-
trying to fund the health service eration is common at the Dakar,
properly and making sure the bins where drivers are prepared to lose
are emptied on time, I suspect the time themselves rather than leave a
sum of human happiness would in- team-mate stranded.
crease considerably. Am I being fanciful, or is this close
Dave Brinkley in spirit to the sort of thing that hap-
Reality bites Nice to be able pened 100 or more years ago, when
to sing the
A refreshing outbreak of praises of a Category error motorsport was less about lap times
Letter real world in the March VW again I’m baffled by high-performance and more about reliability?
of the issue, with the VW Golf R 4x4s, such as the Land Rover De- Technically dazzling as the latest
comparison test against fender Octa that was the subject of F1 cars may be, and the drivers hugely
month the AMG A35 and BMW the 300-Mile Test in the March issue. talented, but it all feels very remote
M135. My concern is not over whether from my motoring life of potholes,
These are the kind of cars I can ac- one is better than another, but why speed bumps, 20mph limits, blown
tually own, and they offer the sort of they exist at all. If I want to enjoy headlamp bulbs and sweet wrappers
performance that now and again I driving on the road, something low I can’t get out of the door pockets.
can use on the road. and light would be optimal. If I need Les Wilde
As a serial VW buyer I’m also to venture off the beaten track, I
pleased to hear that the Golf R has want something with good ground Hard choices
received the necessary improve- clearance, long-travel suspension, Why does anyone like cars without
ments. Weird that it wasn’t right first low gears and a hose-out interior. roofs? I just don’t get it. Never have. I
time, but welcome nonetheless. But if I wish to drive fast off the drove a Mazda MX-5 once and
Gary Edmunds road, I should probably be arrested. thought it was very good, but wished
It’s not what the countryside is for. it had a roof. And reading your story
Stay in your lane Ian Rowlands about the Maserati and Bentley in
Back in the day, it seemed that the the March issue, I just kept thinking:
only time politicians ever became in- Logic may well be on your side, yes, but these cars are both also avail-
No one is left
volved in automotive affairs was behind at the but some of these cars are able with proper fixed roofs, so
when they lowered a speed limit or Dakar Rally remarkably good to drive, in a they’re quieter, stiffer, the air-con
made seatbelts compulsory for pas- works properly, you can hear the au-
sengers, that sort of thing. But now, dio and you don’t look like a pillock.
as your CAR Power List (March issue) But clearly other people disagree.
makes clear, they seem intent on de- What’s the appeal?
Liam Anderson
Big problems
I’m not sad to read the new large Lo-
tus products aren’t selling (Agenda,
February), despite my affection for
the brand as a whole. An Eletre
parked in front of my Tesla Model 3
recently and my car was dwarfed in
all dimensions. It’s not until you see
EDITORIAL
Editor
Ben Miller
Group editor
Phil Bell
Deputy editor
one in a typical street scene that you Rivals pale into which makes as much sense as a Piers Ward
insignificance
notice how big they are. next to the convertible van, or that the real range Production editor
Colin Overland
Despite the relative affluence of Vantage falls 20 per cent short of that prom- Deputy news editor
my area of Hampshire, very few are ised at a paltry 270 miles. The ele- Jake Groves
seen locally, primarily I suspect be- phant in the room is that it has de- New cars editor
Alan Taylor-Jones
cause they won’t fit in our city-centre preciated by £24k, or 41 per cent, in Director of content – digital
underground car park or be able to 10,000 miles and seven months. Tim Pollard
negotiate the ramp at Waitrose. Danyel Mills Digital editor
Curtis Moldrich
The electric Ferrari looks neatly Head of automotive video
styled (New Cars 2025, March). I do Kettle vs Audi James Dennison
hope it’s not too big, though – other- I’ve read every CAR magazine since Group art director
Garry Mears
wise I won’t see many of them either. passing my test in 1974. I’ll continue App designer
Simon Hutton to read it for the quality of the writ- Chelsea Nelms
Editors-at-large
ing, the illuminating industry analy- Chris Chilton, Mark Walton,
Blind ambition sis, and the photography. Ben Barry
Contributor-in-chief
I find it intriguing to hear that the However, through no fault of Gavin Green
DVSA, which oversees driving in- yours, in recent years the cars them- European editor
structors and tests, says we should all selves have increasingly merged into Georg Kacher
Contributing editors
reverse into parking bays or drive- Have minor variations on the same theme. Ben Oliver, Ben Whitworth,
ways for safety reasons. your say: Meanwhile, the prices of unremark- Anthony ffrench-Constant,
As most cars are equipped with re- able cars have galloped to previously Steve Moody, Sam Smith
was there for a reason. It was a car pleasingly free from jewellery and Former CAR editor and brief visitor to the dark side Gavin Green is
embellishment, for the simple reason that no embroidery was neces- now one of the world’s foremost automotive commentators
Enjoy 5 ISSUES
every mile
FOR £5
Motor Cycle News
(MCN), is your
bible on all things
motorcycling with
news, reviews,
events and sport
in every weekly
Get out on the road this spring and enjoy issue.
3 ISSUES
FOR £5
Your ticket to
motorcycling’s
heroic past
with nostalgia,
workshop fixes
and buying guides
to help you land
your dream
classic.
3 ISSUES
FOR £5
The UK’s
most useful
motorcycling
magazine with
routes to ride,
in-depth product
tests. RiDE –
telling it like it is
since 1995.
greatmagazines.co.uk/motorcycling
Terms & Conditions: *Saving applies to initial trial term. The minimum term is 12 months. Offer closes on 29th May 2025. Subscriptions will start with the next available issue. Offers
cannot be used in conjunction with any other offer. Trial offers are only available on recurring payment and will auto-renew to a price of £34.99 every 3 months after the initial trial period
(for MCN), and will auto-renew to a price of £29.99 every 6 months after the initial trial period (for Bike, Classic Bike and RiDE), based on the print+ subscription option. If you wish to
cancel before the end of your trial period, please notify customer services at least 10 days before the end of your trial. Should the next payment have already been taken by the time you
cancel, please contact us as soon as possible to arrange a refund. Any subsequent payments are non-refundable, and any cancellations will be from the next payment date. Order line
open 0800hrs – 2100hrs (Mon-Fri). 1000hrs – 1600hrs (Sat). Calls may be monitored or recorded for training purposes. Call costs from mobiles vary according to the calling plan chosen.
Typically, they are included in free call packages. However, if you call an 01/02 number outside of any inclusive minutes, they can cost between 3p and 65p per minute. Calls from landlines
to 01 numbers are typically charged up to 16p per minute. Many providers charge a 23p call set-up fee (or ‘connection charge’), but this can vary. Please refer to ofcom.org.uk for updated
pricing. Costs for calls from overseas vary depending on the location. For general terms and conditions please visit: www.greatmagazines.co.uk/offer-terms-and-conditions
50 CARMAGAZINE.CO.UK | MAY 2025
Georg and his Bentley
ONE IN
A MILLION
CAR’s European editor has straddled the
industry like a colossus for half a century. He
could own virtually anything. So how did this
old Bentley steal his heart?
Words Georg Kacher Photography Steffen Jahn
Frida became the new Tessa, and the fox-red lab also loved to share box and chassis are also largely untouched since Mr Toad first saw
the front-row lookout with her hatted keeper. The rest of the family the light of day exactly 61,188 miles ago. It gets an MoT check-up
were, however, unconvinced. Eventually, a few years later, I made every other year, and has passed the last five inspections without dif-
peace with them by trading in the extrovert Azure for an early Conti- ficulty. Yes, there are a few oily spots between engine and transmis-
nental GTC Supersports, which went like stink, handled like a proper sion, around the differential and on parts of the rear suspension.
sports car and was kitted out to perfection with Bugatti Veyron seats That said, over the years it’s had a fair bit of money spent on regular
and carbon-ceramic brakes. maintenance and running repairs. The brake calipers needed re-
We eventually sold the Conti too, but it turned out that life with- building and new discs and pads were fitted, along with fresh cut-to-
out a Bentley was a bit like life without a dog. Hence the two-tone T1 size front brake lines. The air-con has needed refilling at three-year
acquired in 2013, which felt right, but took some adjusting to since it intervals, the exhaust manifold gaskets needed replacing, the rear
was from an earlier, pre-VW era. central locking system and one window winder were infested with
There have been many other Bentleys over the five decades, some stubborn electric bugs, the sagging self-levelling rear end received
of which I may have liked the idea of owning… others not so much. new adjustment valves twice, a broken speedometer cable was
The wide-body Corniche was a charming piece of kit, the last-of-line replaced, and we also renewed just about every rubber bushing,
turbocharged Corniche soft-tops were instant collectibles, and even mount, bearing and seal.
the fatboy Turbo R somehow still captured that irresistible and en- At an authorised Bentley dealer, this treatment would have cost a
Timber. Smiths
instruments.
That smell
small fortune, but Jo Appl’s specialist workshop in Halfing near The flying G
Rosenheim did a fantastic job at mate’s rates. We agreed he should and his flying B
leave the gigantic old car phone and massive amplifier squatting side
by side in the boot, untouched.
The bodywork was in good condition when Mr Toad joined us.
But after a couple of years the corroding upper parts of all four doors
needed a respray, and last year the small rust bubble which had blos-
somed on the nearside front wing begged for some filler, primer and
paint. I’ve always shied away from a close inspection of the car’s
Waxoyl anti-rust-treated underside. The odd dark flake of a material
previously known as metal has been shed, but the MoT man is happy
they’re not from structurally critical areas.
Fresh blemishes include a couple of hairline cracks on the cowl
where steel and alloy meet. The chrome is now beginning to pit on
the bumpers. The aftermarket foglamps and the tinted windscreen
show small signs of de-lamination. The electric Kienzle clock has al-
ways taken the scenic route, ever since the car’s purchase in July 2013,
initially dropping about an hour per day. Eleven years later, one lap of
the small hand equals a week and a bit. The gauge indicating the fuel
level in the cavernous 100-litre tank does work, but needs tapping
after every restart to make it jump into life.
Unlike the hostility attracted by the Azures, Mr Toad seems to
have nothing but fans and admirers. A similar level of affection O
ruled out the Bristol 408. At the time, I also owned a Porsche 968 CS, but a darker colour with a matching interior would be nice to have.
a Lancia Kappa coupe and an Audi Coupe S, so buying a sports car Trouble is, I would have to sell my T1 five times over to afford one.
wasn’t my priority. Having previously possessed an Ami 6, a DS21 and In any case, Mr Toad is no slouch, thanks to the legendary 6750cc
an SM (a keeper for almost 15 years), a very early chrome-less pre-Pal- V8, type-approved in Germany at 193bhp. The brochure described
las Citroën CX would have made a compelling substitute. But again, the peak power output nonchalantly as ‘adequate’, and didn’t even
no luck – all the market had to offer were GTI and Prestige models. A quantify the maximum twist action of 406lb ft, available from
low-mileage manual Audi S8 MkI was sold under my nose to a higher 2500rpm. Mated to a three-speed auto that struggles with take-off
bidder, a pristine Lancia Thesis was ultimately too quirky even for and upshift torque slip like a tipsy juggler, the cam-in-block two-val-
me, and a Buick Grand National popped up only to be dismissed ver accelerates the majestic five-seater 0-60mph in around 11 sec-
again for its third-world handling. Next in line were a bunch of inter- onds. The advertised top speed is 118mph. This one rarely exceeds
esting coupes. The list stretched from the way too expensive Facel 100mph because doing so would drive up the petrol and oil con-
Vega HK500 over the Jensen Interceptor I and the Alfa 2600 Sprint to sumption along with the owner’s fears of a costly breakdown.
the Fiat 2300S Abarth, Volvo 780 by Bertone, Renault 17TS with fab- We are currently running a very mixed bag of six cars: the T1, a
ric sunroof, Mercedes 250SE W111 and Fiat 130. Mini Countryman PHEV firmly in the hands of Mrs Kacher (and
I also wondered about a different Bentley. A pre-facelift gen-two Pucki the former Roman street dog, new to the team), the 1972 Baro-
Mulsanne would have been the perfect piece of driveway furniture. lo red 2002tii (which has featured in CAR), the aforementioned Yugo
It’s extremely yet tastefully plush inside, cosmetically not as OTT as 45L (ditto) and 6-series, plus a BMW X5 M60i for the winter on a
the post-facelift version, effortless thanks to the twin-turbo 506bhp, short-term lease.
752lb ft V8, a much better drive than the compromised Arnage and a The Bentley would have to go if I were to get another car – there
true gem in terms of craftsmanship and build quality. But it’s also simply isn’t room. If it’s a modern collectible, it could be a base Alpine
two sizes bigger than the T1, ostentatious, vastly more expensive to A110 GT. Or a Ferrari 599 GTB. Or an Alpina D5 Touring. If it’s a
buy and to run, in many ways even more a thing of the past than its classic, it better be a zero-depreciation investment like Mr Toad, who
slimmer, non-catalyst predecessor. has been a cost-neutral boarder even with all the repair and running
I also wondered about a Brooklands coupe, that epitome of ele- expenses factored in. But what else could generate anything like the
gance and period splendour. I don’t need the fancy extra-cost brakes, same feelgood factor? I’m really struggling.
BENTLEY T1
P R I C E £35,000 (1973)
V A L U E N O W £40,000
P O W E R T R A I N 6750cc 16v V8,
three-speed automatic, rear-wheel drive
P E R F O R M A N C E 193bhp @ 4000rpm,
406lb ft @ 2500rpm, 10.9sec 0-60mph, 118mph
W E I G H T 2103kg
E F F I C I E N C Y 10-12mpg
3 ISSUES FOR £5
Terms & Conditions: *Saving applies to initial trial term. 3 issues for £5 applies to the initial trial term on a CAR Print+ Subscription. The minimum term is 12 months. Offer closes
at 11:59pm 29/05/25. UK only. Subscriptions will start with the next available issue. Offers cannot be used in conjunction with any other offer. Trial offers are only available on
recurring payment and will auto-renew to a price of £32.99 every 6 months after the initial trial period, based on the Print+ Subscription option. If you wish to cancel before the
end of your trial period, please notify customer services at least 10 days before the end of your trial. Should the next payment have already been taken by the time you
cancel, please contact us as soon as possible to arrange a refund. Any subsequent payments are non-refundable, and any cancellations will be from the next payment date.
Order line open 8am to 9pm (Mon-Fri), 10am to 4pm (Sat). Calls may be monitored or recorded for training purposes. Call costs from mobiles vary according to the calling plan
chosen. Typically, they are included in free call packages. However, if you call an 01/02 number outside of any inclusive minutes, they can cost between 3p and 65p per
minute. Calls from landlines to 01 numbers are typically charged up to 16p per minute. Many providers charge a 23p call set-up fee (or ‘connection charge’), but this can vary.
Please refer to ofcom.org.uk for updated pricing. Costs for calls from overseas vary depending on the location.
For general terms and conditions please visit: www.greatmagazines.co.uk/offer-terms-and-conditions.
SPRING WITH CAR
WHY • Read every new issue first in
SUBSCRIBE? the CAR app with digital access
• Access past issues, videos &
bonus content in the CAR app
• Digital subscribers can
unlock discounts and rewards
including money off motorsport
events
• Save 73% on shop prices*
• Receive the exclusive
monthly CAR Supercharged
e-newsletter from the editor
OFFE R
ENDS
29TH
MAY
OR SCAN
HERE
THE ROME
THAT STROLL
BUILT
Aston Martin is gearing up to
conquer F1’s next era. Step inside the
£200 million facility it calls home
Words Ben Miller Photography Olgun Kordal & AMF1
Andy Cowell
knows what
it takes to
become a
winning team
– and stay
there
elcome to the most re- Mercedes-AMG weren’t (so, evenings and weekends) and wore
cently completed of the grooves in a nine-mile stretch of the A43 as a consequence. Elsewhere
three sleek buildings that on the campus, the greatest car designer the sport has ever seen,
comprise the Aston Mar- Adrian Newey, stands at the world’s most famous drawing board.
tin Formula One Team After 18 riotously successful years with Red Bull, he started at Aston
campus. More secretive in March. His office – a glass beacon of experience and creativity in a
than the other two, it’s sea of CAD monitors and furrowed brows – feels as much a display
furthest from prying eyes case for this talismanic hire as a place of work.
and has fewer windows. Next door, in Building Two, there’s another state-of-the-art piece
And it’s called Building of equipment, AMF1’s new driver-in-the-loop simulator (as opposed
Three. Clearly when to a simulator without a driver, which is also a thing). Unseen servers
you’re spending hun- run warm as Aston engineers collaborate with those of Honda Mo-
dreds of millions, chasing tenths and laying the foundations for a tor Company and HRC half a world away. The Japanese company,
trophy-laden dynasty, there’s no time to sit around brainstorming creator of some of the finest and fiercest engines the sport has ever
cute building names. seen, will be AMF1’s powertrain partner for the sport’s new-regula-
Deep in Building Three’s bowels, the ambience is more outer space tion era, arriving 2026. And outside, amid beautiful planting and
than just outside Silverstone. In the gloom, certainly when you walk grasses that sway in the stiff spring breeze, there’s a helipad – a heli-
here directly from the bright-as-day build bays, rows of expensive pad that, once a week, receives the man driving this revolution. Wel-
machines hum as they work. They’re printing resin parts for 60 per come to the Aston Martin Formula One Team, the Rome that Law-
cent wind tunnel models. Since the process is like building a full- rence Stroll built. ⊲
sized skyscraper in Lego, one tiny layer at a time, it is not fast. The
display on one indicates it’ll be finished some time tomorrow. Oth-
ers, their windows flashing a ghoulish green, are printing elaborate The greatest car designer the
parts in aluminium and titanium. AMF1 is more than a customer for
these machines. Its competitive hunger puts it at the vanguard of the
sport has ever seen stands
technology – along with NASA. After all, why burn fuel taking a set at the world’s most famous
of spanners into space when you can print the one you need up there?
Also in Building Three, the new wind tunnel has just passed its fi- drawing board
nal checks. Previously, the team used Mercedes-AMG’s tunnel when
Amid beautiful planting there’s these things, and it stems from Lawrence’s vision for the team.’
Billionaire businessman Lawrence Stroll headed up a consortium
a helipad – a helipad that, that bought Force India’s assets in 2018, re-branding the team first as
Racing Point and then Aston Martin when another Stroll-led con-
once a week, receives the man sortium acquired a controlling interest in the car company in 2020.
driving this revolution ‘He came in and said, “I want this team to win. I want this team to
get to the front.” And he’s taken the time to speak to people and un-
derstand what’s required. So, the wind tunnel. The driver-in-the
loop simulator. A significantly bigger factory. Works team status, a
Organisations often talk about being more than the sum of their partnership with Honda and developing our own transmission. [Be-
parts. As of right now, if this team were anything like the sum of its cause F1 gearboxes are fundamental to both the car’s aerodynamics
parts it’d win every race it entered. Its facilities are, by virtue of being and its rear suspension layout, designing your own is seen as essen-
the newest, arguably the best in the sport. Its recent hires read like an tial for a works team with title aspirations.] Bringing together a larger
F1 super group, from the aforementioned Newey through ex-Ferrari group of people as we transition from surviving customer team to
aerodynamics man Enrico Cardile to former Mercedes-AMG power- works entity, in which we create everything ourselves. It’s all here.
train guru Andy Cowell, who joined as group CEO and was recently Now it’s about bringing it all together efficiently and effectively.’
appointed team principal too. Its title sponsor Aramco, Saudi Ara- Cowell was a part of Mercedes as it geared up to dominate F1’s first
bia’s majority state-owned gas and oil company, isn’t short of funds. V6 hybrid era, which started with the 2014 season. Does being a part
And on the power unit side, Honda will replace current supplier of this team now feel anything like being a part of Mercedes-AMG
Mercedes-AMG for 2026. Honda engines have won the last four then? Is there a familiarity to this calm before the storm of cham-
drivers’ championships and two of the last three constructors’ titles. pagne and championship wins?
This team, which started life as plucky underdogs Jordan more ‘It comes down to the vision. At Mercedes that was “the best or
than 35 years ago, stands poised to dominate a sport transformed out nothing” – that was our approach,’ he says. ‘It took a few years to em-
of all recognition – a sport that’s gone from Ecclestone’s personal bed, but you could see that by the middle of 2013 [when Cowell
plaything to conquering Netflix, hijacking the global news agenda was managing director of Mercedes-AMG High Performance Pow-
on Premier League transfer deadline day (Lewis Hamilton to Ferra- ertrains] Mercedes were capable of winning races. The new power
ri!) and making the teams that contest it wealthier in the process. If unit [in 2014] provided a step, as did the aero changes that came with
AMF1 can become serial winners it’ll be the result of an acquisition it. Then there was just a determination to stay there – that even
of excellence so clear-eyed and uncompromising it’d make Pep though we were at the front, we wanted to keep winning.
Guardiola blush. And if it happens it’ll be because Andy Cowell and ‘Here the job is to instil the same focus. If our performance im-
the rest of the senior team managed to tune this engine of a thou- provement over time is greater than our opponents, we’ll overtake
sand people and an awful lot of raw talent into a winning machine. them. And if we can keep our gradient of improvement over time
‘You can’t point to a single aspect of what we’re doing here as pivot- greater than our opponents, we’ll stay ahead of them. For every de-
al, and that’s the whole point,’ Cowell tells CAR. ‘It’s a union of all of partment, whether it’s communications or HR or vehicle dynamics ⊲
H OW N OT TO S PE N D IT: TOYOTA I N F1
Sport, fortunately, is about only in detail, and all the Toyota also under- Cologne rather than the UK
more than just throwing teams are in the same estimated the manpower (making hiring more
money at the problem – boat. Toyota got off to a required, made some odd difficult), quickly got into
just ask Toyota. The stuttering start by initially hires initially (too many the corrosive habit of
Japanese giant arrived in developing a V12 engine were winners in other blaming its lack of pace on
F1 in 2002, stuck around the rules then outlawed, disciplines but had little to its drivers and saddled the
for eight seasons and failed requiring the team to no F1 experience), insisted team with an unwieldy
to win a single race, let hurriedly create a new V10. on basing the team in corporate approach that
alone a title. The return on mired it in bureaucracy and
its monumental investment made it slow to respond.
amounted to three poles Many of Aston’s senior
and a handful of podiums. people were in the sport
So, what went wrong – when Toyota foundered,
and how is ambitious watching on from the likes
Aston avoiding the pitfalls of Red Bull and Mercedes.
that sunk Toyota? For one, Certainly Aston Martin’s
the target at which Cowell approach – ruthlessly
Getty Images/Darren Heath
Measurement
arms feature
throughout the
building, for
quality control
Cowell’s also encouraged by the direction of travel. ‘Last year we the king of upgrades, though that’s operational king, of course. My
won the championship in terms of the quantity of upgrades, but the contribution is getting the upgrades to the car as quickly as possible.’
quality of those upgrades wasn’t strong enough,’ he explains. ‘The Ben joined AMF1 in January 2023. Efficiently accommodating its
idea generation and the confirmation of those ideas within the facto- workforce, together with facilitating the move from a procure-
ry wasn’t robust enough. You end up with so much information you ment-based organisation to one that now makes 70 per cent of its
can easily get lost. We’ve worked to simplify that; to get down to the cars by volume (up from 40 per cent, a leap from 80,000-ish manu-
core things that make a race car quicker. That way we can be sure factured parts per year to more like 250,000, reducing external spend
we’ve got a valuable update before we press the figurative button, re- by 30 per cent) is Ben’s remit – and he loves it. ‘We’re one of the most
leasing the data to manufacturing, and robustly land performance at operationally effective teams on the grid – albeit that’s not being
the track. That’s the thing I would say we struggled with last year.’ translated into performance just yet – and a lot of that is down to this
While managing technical partner Newey’s focus is firmly on the campus,’ explains Fitzgerald. ‘The first of these buildings opened in
new regulations, 2026 and beyond, Cowell’s confident he’ll help turn May 2023, and we produced our first parts within 24 hours. But the
theoretical speed into actual lap times. planning began four years before that, in mid-2019. That’s when we
‘Adrian understands the whole car, and he understands the feed- really established what the future of this team was going to look like,
back from the circuit and from the drivers,’ continues Cowell. ‘I be- and the role this building would play in that future.’
lieve he will bring great value in terms of translating what the drivers In total, AMF1’s currently at about 400,000 square metres, having
are saying, translating what the car is doing, into targets within the come from a building of just 50,000 square metres. And with £200
factory. My role is to pull a business together that enables the work million invested to date, it’s not done yet. ‘We are making huge steps
that Adrian wants. His experience is incredible across many different forward as a team, but you’ve only got to consider what else is going
regulation sets, and his competitiveness is tremendous – undimmed, on – new partnerships, another set of regulations, more in-sourcing
I would say. I’ve just had lunch with him in and he’s a very friendly, – to see the challenge,’ continues Fitzgerald. ‘We make 70 per cent of
very warm guy. But there were a couple of things we talked about… the car, okay, but there’s still a handsome sum to go at.’
It’s lifting the bar, you know? Setting a new level of expectation. There’s much Ben’s proud of, from the rich data pouring from the
There’s no ambiguity there and that’s great – it’s wonderful to have.’ simulator and wind tunnel to the building’s A+ energy rating and the
A big part of the reason Newey’s in Aston Martin green is the beehives in the grounds that surround it. But it’s what this place says
team’s wind tunnel – just one aspect of this carefully choreographed about AMF1 he’s most happy with. ‘This is the team’s home. When
rapid expansion overseen by chief operating officer Ben Fitzgerald. we think about the past, that wasn’t so clear cut. This is our home,
‘He saw the tunnel before it was finished, and I understand it was a and the sheer brand presence when you come to this building is fan-
key part of his decision,’ says Fitzgerald. ‘Lawrence introduced me as tastic. It’s an emphatic statement of intent.’
I S T H I S T H E
MO ST I TA LI A N
T H I NG E V E R?
It’s built in Poland and uses hardware shared across
continents. But where does the Alfa Romeo Junior call
home? We tour Italy in search of its soul
Words Mark Walton Photography Lee Brimble
ast year, the morning after Which again got me blinking with confusion. Wait a minute – did
Alfa Romeo launched its you just say you’re calling it the Alfa Romeo Junior to make sure it
new Milano, Italy’s indus- DOESN’T sound Italian? Bu.. eh… wha…?? I can’t think of a name
try minister, Adolfo Urso, that sounds MORE Italian than the gloriously lyrical, roll-off-the-
expressed his outrage. tongue Alfa Junior. The original GT Junior – a smaller-capacity,
The government had 1.3-litre version of the 105 Coupe – was launched in 1965, so it’s been a
known for months that legendary part of Alfa’s heritage for 60 years now. Sophia Loren
the car was being built in downing a mug of prosecco while sitting in a gondola wouldn’t be
Poland but Urso panto- any more Italian than an Alfa Junior.
mimed his full, Ah – but would it? Maybe Urso the angry minister is right – maybe
pearl-clutching horror. we’re being duped? Maybe the new Junior really is just a rebadged,
‘A car called Milano pan-European Stellantis platform – more Jeep Avenger than Giulia
cannot be produced in Poland!’ he fumed. ‘This is forbidden by Ital- Sprint? Maybe Alfa is trolling us with a postcard of the Colosseum
ian law!’ (He was referring to new EU legislation, designed to prohib- but with a Polish postage stamp! Clearly we need to put it to the test
it ‘evocative’ or ‘Italian sounding’ products that aren’t actually made – a stress-test of really Italian, Made in Italy Italianness. In Italy.
in Italy.) ‘A car called Milano must be produced in Italy! Otherwise, it So, is there anything more Italian than mamma’s traditional spa-
gives a misleading indication!’ ghetti bolognese, poured lovingly from a jar with lashings of cheese
This struck me as weird. Arguably, calling it an Alfa Romeo is a on top? Turns out there is.
pretty big indication that it’s from Italy, and most people probably We arrive in Bologna on a sharp, cold winter’s day and I immedi-
don’t even realise Milano refers to a city (‘Isn’t that a football club?’). ately fall in love with the new Junior’s styling. Seeing it on the street,
But two days later, Alfa backed down and renamed the car. riding on its spectacular 20-inch Venti alloys, it looks sensational, all
‘Although we think the Milano name met all legal requirements, the way from that unusual cut-out grille to its pert, cut-off tail. This
we took the decision to change it to Junior to ease relations with the is the top-of-the-range Veloce model, fully electric, 276bhp and
Italian government,’ Alfa’s then CEO, Jean-Philippe Imparato, told priced at a heady £42,295. Add in an optional paint finish, parking
the press. cameras and the Sport pack (more about that later) and you’re ⊲
It’s quite stiffly sprung but it’s never crashy or aggravating over
Bologna’s many historic, Renaissance-era potholes
Altogether, the Veloce feels out of its comfort zone in what should There are a couple of ways round it: if you book a rental car or stay
be hot-hatch heaven. Alfa boasts about the car’s 1635kg weight – in a hotel inside the zone you get a few hours’ grace; or you can drive
which may be less than some competitors, but we need a sense of into the city in the evenings or on a Sunday. (For our photo shoot we
proportion. A Peugeot 205 GTI in the ’90s weighed under 900kg; a applied to the city and got an exemption for the day, which cost €5.)
Mk5 VW Golf GTI in 2003 was 1300kg… Things are just getting Early next day we drive the Junior down to the River Arno and
heavier, and as Galileo Galilei once said, there’s no escaping physics. watch the sun rise over Florence’s bridges. Old Florence, like Bolo-
The best thing to do, then, is back off to seven-tenths and just en- gna, is a maze of tiny one-way streets, and once again the Junior’s in-
joy the scenery. Cypress trees! It’s like we’re in a scene from Gladiator. stant punch of torque and quick steering make it a pleasure to drive,
We arrive on the outskirts of Florence and charge the car over- squirting down alleyways and wedging its way into traffic.
night. At 54kWh, the Junior’s battery isn’t huge and I work out we’ve Part of the pleasure is down to the Sport pack. For £2200 you get a
done just 96 miles that day, draining down from 100 per cent to a bit of extra alcantara on your steering wheel, plus different pedals,
quarter full. That gives us a theoretical range of just 130 miles – a lot kick plates and some nice mats, but more importantly you get qua-
less than the 200 miles Alfa claims. Maybe cold weather and some si-bucket seats by Italian motorsport supplier Sabelt. The option is
hard driving have had an effect, but it’s clear the Junior is no long-dis- expensive, I grant you, but these seats are superb – high-bolstered,
tance cruiser. Thankfully the hotel charger works and four hours rib-stitched and supportive, and they raise the interior ambience.
later we’re back to full capacity at a cost of £28, around 29p per mile. Given that driving is so tightly controlled in the old town, the city
Next morning we drive into Florence, a short journey but one is still rammed with traffic and it seems to come at you from every
fraught with some Byzantine administrative stress these days. Since direction, like you’re permanently trapped on a deranged, two-way
the summer of 2024 this beautiful city has been protected by what Arc de Triomphe roundabout.
they call the scudo verde, or green shield. More than a regular conges- Time, then, to have the most Italian experience of all. There are
tion zone, this is a no-go area for cars, monitored by cameras and lots of scooter rental companies across Florence, and I rent a classic
strictly enforced. If you’re not a resident, driving into the restricted Vespa 125 from a small local firm, Tuscany by Car. It costs £50 a day,
zone during the day will mean a swift fine, and the city is pocketing including helmet, and on two wheels you’re free to roam the restrict-
millions from hapless drivers. ed zone. Scooters are everywhere in the city, lining up at traffic ⊲
A L F A’ S N O T T H E O N LY O N E
MAKING CARS ELSEWHERE
(The current Land Rover
Defender is built in Slovakia.)
Dacia is proud of its Romanian
history, as it represents
everything we love about the
The Toyota GR Supra might seem brand: cheap, pragmatic,
like the epitome of the PlayStation- resourceful, zero frills. Exactly the self-deprecating national character.
generation, midnight-racing same reasons why the Dacia Jogger BMW understands this, which is why
Japanese sports coupe, but as a joint is made in Morocco. the swanky current Countryman is
venture with BMW it’s actually built in The original Mini was made in Germany.
Graz, Austria. quintessentially British, personifying When you choose an Audi Q8
Driving a Jeep Renegade is like our contrary, penny-pinching, e-Tron you like to think you’re buying
having a bald eagle tattooed on one a bit of Vorsprung durch Technik –in
arm and a small espresso on the fact it’s Vooruitgang door
other – this symbol of American Technologie. It’s built in Brussels.
freedom and adventure is made in If Donald Trump wants to make
Melfi, Italy. Canada the 51st state of the USA, the
Originally created as a WW2 Stellantis plant in Brampton, Ontario
aero-engine factory, the Solihull plant is his beach head – the stars-and-
in the West Midlands built the Land stripes Dodge Charger is
Rover – and Land Rover built Britain! manufactured there.
don’t. Ciro tells me: ‘The secret to gelato… after you have eaten, you
High-spec
versions count to 10 and then your mouth should feel clean.’
get logo cut It’s so delicious and moreish I want to sample all 26 flavours, but
into grille the day is drawing to a close and I don’t want to puke on my Vespa. So
we’re soon back in the Alfa and mulling over the big question: just
how Italian is this car?
Well, the worst thing about the Junior is the price. I checked, and a
few short years ago the entry-level Alfa, the Mito, cost less than £19k.
Electric cars are stupidly expensive.
But if you accept that rampant, liver-filleting inflation is just a fact
of modern life, the Junior holds up very well. It really does feel Italian,
as though the team who did the Giulia and Stelvio really did develop
this car too. While its battery weight might limit the fun, there’s
something irrepressibly spirited and stylish about the Veloce – it feels
zingy and confident like an Italian car should.
So ignore the fact it’s built in Poland – the whole Made in Italy ar-
gument is out of date. These days, your iPhone is made in China,
Branston Pickle is owned by the Japanese and AC Milan, the legend-
ary football team, is owned by Americans. To use the Italian industry
minister’s phrase, the world is full of misleading indications. But I
reckon the Alfa Junior is the real deal.
Thinking big with small cars has worked before. But as VW unveils the
electric ID. Every1 concept, the stakes have never been higher
Words Piers Ward Photography John Wycherley
Physical
buttons are
promised
THE V W WILL
S I G N I F I C A N T LY U N D E R C U T
T H E R E N A U LT 5 , P R A I S E D
FOR ITS KEEN PRICING
can put one, two or three, four zones in the car – if I’ve got a vehicle in
the lower price segment, with lower functionalities, [it would need]
just one zone … it can be very cost effective in the ID. Every1 as it’s still
the same software.’ This approach allows VW to integrate new func-
tions without changing the software, leading to an upgradable sys-
tem that adapts during the life of the car.
VW is not the only major manufacturer cottoning onto this –
BMW is testing it out with its Heart of Joy architecture. Thankfully
VW has resisted the questionable naming strategy.
The ID. 1 will manage 155 miles between charges and will do
81mph thanks to an all-new electric motor providing 94bhp. This is
where we hit the first snag with the production ID. 1, in that the elec-
tric Up from six years ago managed 161 miles and produced 82bhp.
The Dacia Spring is £15k and will do 140 miles. You can see where
this is going – the ID. 1 might be VW’s next great hope, but the price
Wheelarch
points at this end of the market are so compressed that you don’t get crease is
much margin for error. Schäfer admits as much: ‘If you look at it only cleverer than
from profit maximisation, walk away from it [the electric city car]. I’d you'd think
rather do large SUVs.’ ⊲
V W ’ S R E S E T S TA R T S H E R E
ID. 2
The standard 2 hatch
(previewed here by
the concept ID. 2All)
is due in early 2026
and, starting at
around £21,000, will
be in effect the electric
Polo. EV packaging efficiencies mean it will be short
but vast inside.
ID. 2X
The T-Cross equivalent. Just front-wheel drive, it’ll
come with a choice of batteries that give a maximum
range of 280 miles. Built in Spain alongside the
Skoda and Cupra equivalents, it’ll likely be the big
seller of the family.
ID. 2 GTI
The one to get excited about. The latest Golf GTI
shows Volkswagen has regained its grasp on what a
hot hatch should be, so there’s
hope for the electric GTI.
VW promises it’ll
prioritise
excitement
over raw
power.
NOT AS FLAT
AS IT LOOKS
The double-bubble roof
is only possible because
the ID. 1 will be a strict
four-seater. With no
human heads in the way,
it can dip in the middle.
The roof shape has an
additional bonus in that
it helps channel air over
the top and cleanly away
at the rear, making the
car more efficient.
same reveal event in Düsseldorf and looked completely under- and how he designed cars – he did the Golf Mk1, the DeLorean, the
whelming, hunching its shoulders like a shy teenager, the computer [Lotus] Esprit and so on – he had very flat surfaces, super flat. But
nerd to the cheerleader ID. 1. then he had very nice acceleration at the end of it.
The Every1 has some neat aero touches designed to extract maxi- ‘When you look closely at the [Ferrari] P4, you had a guideline for
mum range from the battery. Sharp edges at the rear give the air a your eye. It was not like a piece of soap. It was guided by some creases
clean break as it leaves the car’s surface, with three vertical lines and this is exactly what we did here. The surfaces are not flat, they
forming the basis for this: one at the bumper, one at the light and the have tension towards the end of them.’
other at the C-pillar. There’s obviously been a lot of soul-searching at Volkswagen. All
Along the car’s flanks, it’s the opposite – you need smooth surfaces the execs I speak to are focused on brand identity and really trying to
so as not to disturb the air too much. Around the front and rear nail down what a Volkswagen actually is; what it stands for in today’s
wheelarches, instead of a crease that flows all the way around the world. There does seem to be more energy about the company now,
wheel from sill to sill, the metal folding is confined to a small area and a sense of renewal. Mindt, never a man to say one word if he can
above the top of the wheel. It’s enough to help give the car a purpose- say 15, is so enthusiastic about it that he keeps banging the table for
ful stance but without the aero trade-off. emphasis during our interview.
Mindt is keen to stress his aversion to the ‘bar of soap’ style that’s VW knows it won’t be easy: Grünitz admits the company isn’t
all too prevalent among EVs. ‘When you look at [Giorgetto] Giugiaro planning to build the ID. 1 in vast numbers – ‘we’ve been very con-
PORT ON THE
STARBOARD SIDE
The charging port is
in the front right wing
of the concept, and
the production car will
follow its lead. Cost is
one reason – when all
the major components
are under the bonnet,
why run the wiring to the
rear flank? It also means
there’s more space in the
cabin because you don’t
need to hide the charge
port behind interior trim.
servative’. The production systems are flexible, so output of particu- follow in the Lupo and Up’s wheel tracks. Cheap in EV terms it may
lar models can swiftly be scaled up or down depending on demand. be, but its lack of range means it’s unlikely to be a great democratiser
But even with the low-ish goals, both Grünitz and Schäfer claim it like the Polo or Golf. Rather than a brilliant compact all-rounder, it
will make money. It has to, given all the recent travails. it’ll likely be a second car for a lot of families. It’s not the sort of car
The timetable – a production car in 2027 – looks laggy, given that that will be crammed with tents and wet wipes and pointed in the
the Kia EV1 and Renault Twingo will be with us by then, which direction of Glastonbury.
means some of the ID. 1’s oxygen might have been stolen by the time On the other hand, it looks very good, and it represents a continu-
it arrives. Volkswagen is aware but counters that the sort of upheaval ation of Volkswagen’s reset and a chance to look forward to a brighter
it’s been through was never going to be a quick fix. Grünitz claims the future. If the ID. 2 (see panel) is the debut of VW’s new line-up, the ID.
time taken to go from design to road is roughly three years, which is 1 is the tricky second album.
much faster than VW used to be: ‘We are not slower than competi- Does the future of the European car industry rest on it? Given the
tors in China.’ quality and quantity of newcomers from Korea, China and else-
And if the rivals the new car will face in 2027 offer better range for where, buyers will have a lot of choice. Schäfer predicts that small
less money, Volkswagen might regret the ID. 1’s likely stats. It’s possi- electric VWs will ‘drive the adoption rate of electrification’. He
ble the stars might align in terms of infrastructure improvements stresses: ‘We have to make this car successful. It’s in our name … If
and people’s shifting attitude to range, but I fear it’ll struggle to truly anybody can do it, it’s us.’
E VE R Y POCKET
From Micra-priced roadsters to Bugatti-budget rarities, the pre-
owned Porsche market contains many cherishable treasures but
also plentiful pitfalls for the unwary. We’re here to help
Words Ben Barry Photography John Wycherley
Base-spec
Cayman viewed
from insane-
spec GT3
Similar cars start from £25,000, rising to £30k for the 3.4 S and
£40k-plus for the GTS, which bundled desirable options like the
Sport Chrono package (lap timer, adaptive engine mounts), a sports
exhaust and dynamic bi-xenon lights.
But for Richard Gotch of Porsche Club GB, base spec is best.
‘They’re fabulous cars, peak Porsche,’ he says. ‘The steering in par-
ticular is fantastic in the 2.7s. I remember driving a 3.4 GTS with
larger wheels and brakes and some of the sweetness was lost.’
This is not a particularly fast car, with 271bhp, but it steers with
trademark Porsche precision (although the now electrically assisted
rack can feel slightly isolated), rides beautifully, and everything from
the bite of the brakes to the shift of the six-speed manual has the
mechanical immediacy and consistency we love of Porsche. Even
driven at a fraction of its potential, it feels alive.
Dan Baines praises their reliability and predicts that they’ll hold
their values – so long, that is, as the spec is right, with buyers favour-
ing the PDK transmission, Bose audio upgrade and full leather inte-
rior. ‘Don’t get the plastic dashboard,’ he urges.
For some, the urge to go Cayman became stronger because the 911
grew larger when the 991 era debuted for 2011, adding 100mm to the
wheelbase (bringing more stability for the handling, and more space
in those plus-two rear seats), not to mention controversial electric
assistance for the steering. Perhaps surprisingly, weight actually fell
about 40kg.
Now 10 years old, the early 991 models are in their slightly unloved
middle age, no longer new, not yet classic, as the owner of this im-
maculate Carrera S, Russell Connelly, attests. ‘People at meets have
been a bit sniffy,’ he comments. ‘It’s not a new 992, it’s not a classic
997, but it’s more modern and usable than the older models and you
still get the naturally aspirated engine.’
Bang on. An early 991 remains a fantastically satisfying 911, par-
ticularly for regular use, with the sense of interior quality and extra
space a marked step on from both the previous 911 and the Cayman.
Baines reports no known engine issues, and 991 Carreras are also
relatively affordable – the cheapest, earliest cars start from £40,000
for a 3.4 Carrera with 340bhp, with the Carrera S upsizing to a 394bhp
3.8-litre flat-six and sweetening the deal with extra kit including
adaptive dampers.
This car does not ride as well as the Cayman, feeling a little too re-
active to bumps when driven gently, and it absolutely feels like a larg-
er, more luxurious, more isolated sports car in comparison.
But the ride eases with speed, and there’s real dynamic purity to
tap, whether that’s the eagerness of the turn-in or the way it hunkers
down and bites into the surface on acceleration and feels so ⊲
What’s £100k
between
friends?
98 CARMAGAZINE.CO.UK | MAY 2025
Porsches for peanuts
A re-engineered 4.0-litre
flat-six with 26bhp extra is
a key reason why later 991.2
versions command such
premiums
THE RARITIES
Since the 2010s Porsche has been selling special 911s to
select customers. Dan Baines from TOP 555 is your guide
968 is great
value, but
don’t expect
it to be
bulletproof
Anyone fancy
a drink?
Martini, by
any chance?
Acceleration from low Acceleration from low speeds is astonishing, but it’s the midrange
punch that leaves me reeling – third, fourth and fifth gear basically
speeds is astonishing, but feel like the same ratio, all allowing devastating acceleration.
Brake pedal feel is woeful, road noise roars through the carbonfi-
it’s the midrange punch that bre tub like breakers on a pebbly beach and integration between pure
leaves me reeling electric and hybridised V8 power can be lumpy, but this remains a
very special drive – particularly the unwavering composure through
corners, how it steers so precisely despite the big hit of e-power flow-
ing through the front axle, and the way it combines the whizzy futur-
ism of its powertrain with a reassuringly mechanical, gritty feel.
quite live up to the ‘sports car handling in an SUV body’ dream when ‘Prices peaked about two years ago, and now they’ve dropped back
you drive it like Waitrose is closing early. Air suspension is standard, and are stable,’ says Jaconelli. He recommends getting a car with the
but the wheels go at the road surface like chimpanzees banging at Weissach pack – a factory option that included magnesium wheels,
bongos, front-end bite isn’t entirely convincing even on P Zero Cor- alcantara trim, and carbonfibre for the windscreen frame, roof, rear
sas and the last bit of dynamic polish is lacking. wings and mirrors. It cost £70k when the cars were new but it adds
A Taycan is the better driver’s car – Porsche’s first EV and one it £200k; a Weissach-spec cars on delivery miles can cost £1.5m.
created from a clean sheet. Once again, ours is the GTS. There are Both Baines and Jaconelli point out that while much of the Weis-
faster, more brutal Taycans including the Turbo S (the original’s sach pack can be retro-fitted by Porsche, it costs more and adds less
740bhp now pushed beyond 900bhp), but arguably a GTS is sweetest value than the original factory specification.
of the lot. With 590bhp, its performance is more measured and ex- But with the all-electric Mission X on the horizon as Porsche’s hy-
ploitable, if still unhinged, and a more granular feel tingles through percar follow-up, it seems likely the 918 Spyder will follow its prede-
its controls. Above all else, the Taycan GTS glides over a B-road where cessors in steadily accruing value over time.
a Macan fights – it’s in the unflappable damping, the cool precision of For the lucky few, investing in a 918 Spyder probably makes a lot of
its steering, how it’s so agile yet so planted with its wide track and low sense. The rest of us can dream – and perhaps keep an eye out for
centre of gravity. It’s a 968 Club Sport on rollerblades. that £3k Boxster.
The Taycan is not perfect. We’ve often struggled to squeeze 200
miles out of a fully charged battery (the latest models have improved
range) but the larger chink in a Taycan’s armour is depreciation once
they’ve ceased being four-wheeled tax breaks. Baines recalls a cus-
tomer paying £80k for a Turbo S that’d listed at double that just 3000
miles before. A company fleet’s loss is your gain.
‘Depreciation has been awful,’ concurs Jaconelli. ‘The Turbo de-
preciated most, the 4S has been most sensible, with the GTS pick of
the bunch. We’re selling to private buyers now they’re in the
£50k-£70k bracket, and I think they’ll start to hold their value.’
Just pick your spec carefully. Body styles range from the saloon you
see here to a shooting-brake-style Sport Turismo and the Cross Tu-
rismo that adds a little SUV flavour to the same recipe. Then there
are battery sizes and even seating layouts to consider.
Jaconelli notes that currently the Cross Turismo is the most in-de-
mand among his customers, but stresses battery size is more impor-
tant than body style. ‘The Performance battery is only standard on As if you’d
ever forget
higher trims and that can be a deal breaker,’ he warns. He also sug- what you
gests holding out for a five-seater rather than the roomier but less were driving
versatile four-seat cabin layout. ‘And the panoramic roof helps
brighten what can be quite a dark interior.’
Baines suggests checking for recalls. ‘They’ve not been without is-
sues – they’re something of a test bed, after all.’ At least Porsche cov-
ers batteries for eight years or 100,000 miles.
If the Taycan was a test bed, the earlier 918 Spyder was a laboratory
on wheels. Picking up where the 959 and Carrera GT supercars left
off, it riffed on the (four-cylinder) 919 Le Mans winner with a natu-
rally aspirated V8 good for 600bhp, with twin e-motors up front
adding another 282bhp, all-wheel drive and emissions-free running
for up to 18 miles. All in, the 918 Spyder is good for 875bhp with a
monster 940lb ft.
Porsche built more 918s than its LaFerrari and McLaren P1 rear-
drive contemporaries combined (918 units versus 499 and 375 respec-
tively) and the 918 perhaps lacked their edge. A decade on, Baines sees
the positives: ‘It was the least hyper of the hypercars, but a 918 is easy
to just jump in and drive, they feel like they’ll last 100 years and all-
wheel drive makes the power accessible,’ he notes. ‘They’re also
known to be reliable cars, which makes a huge difference.’
C AY M A N (9 8 1 ) 9 1 1 GT 3 (99 1 . 2)
Sharper to drive and This is the modern GT3
better looking than the sweet spot for value,
original, 2012’s Mk3 kept durability and British
the naturally-aspirated B-roads, dating from 2017.
flat-six. It’s peak base-spec Surprisingly easy to live
Cayman with given its race heritage
M AC A N GTS 9 1 8 S PY D ER
Hot hatch fun meets SUV Epic drive and sci-fi tech
practicality. A big seller for a for Porsche’s once-in-a-
decade, so there are plenty generation hypercar from
around, with the price of 2013. It’s currently one
entry around £16k, and the third the price of LaFerrari,
looks have aged well but more usable than the
Ferrari or McLaren P1
⊲ Expert’s view
‘Macans hold their money ⊲ Expert’s view
really well. A GTS is the ‘They’re very sensitive
sweet spot since they to mileage: 5k-10k is
stopped making the Turbo. considered high and those
If you can stretch, the 2022 cars are £1m. The Weissach
facelift is highly desirable, pack is also important: £70k
and in terms of spec look new but worth £200k now
9 68 C LU B S P O RT out for the GTS interior pack TAYC A N GTS – delivery-miles Weissach-
Club Sport from 1993 is the with contrast stitching.’ Depreciates as quickly as spec cars command £1.5m.’
peak of Stuttgart’s transaxle Tom Jaconelli, Romans it accelerates but Taycan is Tom Jaconelli, Romans
era. A beautifully balanced International a sublime Porsche driving International
car, it gets you into a track- experience for into the EV
focused Porsche for VW PRICE WHEN NEW era. Way ahead of its time PRICE WHEN NEW
Golf money. But given the £73,400 £651,092
car’s age, bear in mind that A P P R O X VA L U E ⊲ Expert’s view A P P R O X VA L U E
it will need extra care N O W £52,000 ‘It’s a proper Porsche but N O W £1.1m
P O W E R T R A I N 2894cc deprecation has been P O W E R T R A I N 4593cc
⊲ Expert’s view 24v V6 turbo, seven-speed awful. There’s fresh interest 48v V8, two e-motors,
‘I’d love one, and they look PDK, all-wheel drive now they’re £50k-£70k, seven-speed PDK, all-
so much fresher than a PERFORMANCE with the Cross Turismo wheel drive
944 Turbo. Don’t overlook 434bhp @ 5700rpm, 406lb most popular for us. The PERFORMANCE
the UK-only Sport, which ft @ 1900rpm, 4.5sec Performance battery is only 875bhp @ 8600rpm, 940lb
added a few more features 0-62mph, 169mph standard on higher trims. I’d ft @ 6600rpm, 2.6sec
back into the spec. Neither W E I G H T 1960kg recommend the five- rather 0-62mph, 211mph
are going anywhere in E F F I C I E N C Y 24.1- than four-seat layout.’ W E I G H T 1674kg
terms of value.’ 25.0mpg, 255-265g/km Tom Jaconelli, Romans E F F I C I E N C Y 94mpg,
Dan Baines, Top 555 CO2 International 71g/km CO2
Plugging Hello
the gap
Only Mercedes combines the range
of diesel with zero-emissions electric
power. The best of both? By Ben Barry
walks up through three differ- makers don’t do plug-in diesels. 300d’s 49.6mpg, while the plug- My driving routine is proba-
ent AMG Line variants with a One is expense, because a diesel in hybrid petrol posts a 1117 per bly representative of the ideal
big ta-da! at £75,610. We’re test- engine is already more expen- cent increase with 470.8mpg customer, with lots of short and
ing the entry-level trim, with sive to produce than petrol be- compared to the 300 e’s best of medium trips achievable on a
only this car’s attractive Spec- fore you start adding hybridisa- 38.7mpg. battery charged from home,
tral Blue metallic paint adding tion. Plug-in hybrids are the most then less frequent longer runs
to the RRP, to the tune of £715. And then there’s the fact that use-case dependent of all pow- to random locations where I
Adaptive LED headlights, a diesel is also more efficient than ertrains, of course, which don’t want to be hostage to the
parking package with reversing petrol, so you’re into diminish- makes the official triple-digit hassle, uncertainty or much
camera, heated electric door ing returns with trying to make WLTP mpg figures even more higher prices of public charging
mirrors and moody black exte- it more efficient still with plug- meaningless than usual. It’s points.
rior trim are all standard. This in hybrid tech. also where this long-term test It’s going to be fascinating to
spec level also brings 20-inch Because Mercedes – rather comes in. see how we get on.
multi-spoke alloys with coil remarkably – also offers a petrol
springs up front and air suspen- plug-in GLC as well as equiva-
sion for the rear. lent four-cylinder petrol and Running
More important for my two diesels, it’s possible to directly low doesn’t
mean you
teenagers is the infotainment: compare all this. need to
the MBUX multimedia system The GLC petrol plug-in is charge
with its 12.3-inch digital instru- £2250 cheaper than our diesel,
ment binnacle and 11.9-inch though that’s true across the
portrait-orientated touch- line-up for petrols and diesels.
screen, wireless charging pad As for efficiency… Well, the offi-
and – most crucial of all – mul- cial stats do show a bigger gain
ti-colour ambient lighting and for the petrol, but the improve-
huge puddle lights that project ments are so extreme they
the three-pointed star on the should be taken with a pinch of
ground like a reverse bat signal. salt – my calculator says the
A couple of key reasons are plug-in diesel’s 565mpg is 1039
usually cited as to why other car per cent more efficient than the
The story so far tremely soggy and bland. But, shove – to the point that I’d tainment, like the daft rotating
Not one but two Seals have on the other hand, the electric suggest going for that one over screen, and some frustratingly
been tested over six months Seal had come a close second the Excellence model. Design fiddly swipes and taps needed
+ A refined, slick, fast and behind a Tesla Model 3 and saves you around £5k and gives to adjust the climate control or
well-built EV ahead of a Polestar 2 in a test a bit more range, making it even safety aids. Having no easily ac-
- Efficiency hasn’t been that conducted by Ben Barry, who’s more competitive against a cessible switch for the regenera-
great long-term
not easily won over. similarly-spec’d Model 3 or tive braking meant I left it in
Logbook During the last six months, Polestar 2. one mode almost the entire
I’ve run not one but two Seals – Is it perfect? No. There are time I had the car. Despite two
Price £45,695 (£46,571 as
tested) Performance 82.5kWh a blue all-wheel-drive Excel- some weird quirks to the info- software updates, the
battery, e-motor, 308bhp, lence and this green rear-wheel-
5.9sec 0-62mph, 112mph drive Design – and I can safely
Efficiency 3.4 miles per kWh say both have been among the
(official), 2.66 (tested) Range
354 miles (official), 342 miles most impressive EVs I’ve ever
(tested) Energy cost 5.8p per spent time with. Those anony-
mile Miles this month 650 mous looks hide a fabulously
Total miles 3070
appointed interior, with thick,
soft seats and a driving position
The mission was to keep an to die for. The ride quality is a
open mind. Before starting my good balance, offering cushion-
six months as a Seal driver, I’d ing without being too sloppy,
had mixed experiences with and the steering feels alert and
BYD. Some versions of the Dol- communicative.
phin hatchback were much bet- And it’s quick. Even the lesser Interior a high-
Alex Tapley
quality place to
ter than others, and the Seal U Design version with its single spend time
DM-i plug-in hybrid felt ex- motor wasn’t exactly lacking in
Better in
small doses
Just because a sportier version is
available, does that mean the S3 is
second best? By Curtis Moldrich
S and RS both
available as
hatch and saloon
Goodbye
Ecology of economy
An upgraded home charger makes Mini life cheaper. By Piers Ward
The story so far per kWh. The other is from An- some others, the installers are was the only blot on the Mini’s
Mini’s sense of fun will be dersen, a British company that all Andersen employees, not record, aside from the tiny boot.
missed, lack of interior space offers stylish car chargers at sub-contractors. That gives a Overall, it’s been a remarka-
less so 7kW and, assuming you have a reassuring continuity of ser- bly easy car to enjoy. Right-sized
+ Fun handling; infotainment; three-phase connection, 22kW vice. It comes with a unique, for UK parking spaces, the
styling
speeds, which is rare for domes- seven-year warranty and, Cooper SE has spent six months
- Efficiency plunged in winter;
tiny boot and rear seats tic chargers. Going for 22kW thanks to the hidden tethered darting and nipping and gener-
means you can dump juice into cable, never looks untidy. ally entertaining, with a sense
Logbook the Mini at its maximum 11kW Not that it’s cheap. The total of engagement lacking in a lot
Price £34,500 (£39,799 as
AC rate, so it’ll fully charge at bill came to £2844 including of other EVs. The steering was
tested) Performance 49kWh the cheaper Eon tariff. VAT, but my ancient house, the highlight for me, not in
battery, e-motor, 215bhp, 6.7sec Cheap tariff and efficient with its bespoke requirements, terms of feel but more the way it
0-62mph, 106mph Efficiency charger combined to allow me did cause the final number to is so pin sharp, reacting well to
4.2-4.4 miles per kWh (official),
3.4 miles per kWh (tested) Range to charge the Mini from zero to balloon more than it would on a the exuberant torque steer.
240-249 miles (official), 167 miles 100 per cent for less than the standard install. There was never a dull journey
(tested) Energy cost 6.0p per cost of a pint. Even during the What all this has done is em- thanks to how fighty those
mile Miles this month 463 Total
miles 6298 winter, when the car’s efficiency phasise how easy and cheap fronts tyres could be under full
plunged from a summer high of electric cars can be, once you’ve power – pulling out of junctions
At last, I’ve got my home energy 4.93 miles per kWh to a low of got your infrastructure sorted. became a lesson in restraint.
ecosystem all sorted. Like CAR’s 2.49, it still meant cheap jour- Despite the Mini’s small 49kW It’s an impressive car, with
equivalent of Martin Lewis, I’m neys. The car’s overall pence per battery, I only needed to use a the warm glow boosted by the
making savings everywhere. mile figure actually dropped re- public charger once in nearly pleasingly low running costs.
Efficiency is my watchword. cently, despite that efficiency 5000 miles. On that occasion,
It’s all thanks to two up- fall in cold weather. with the Mini app being incred- Count the cost
grades. One is from Eon Next, Getting the Andersen in- ibly unhelpful, I came close to
which has joined Octopus and stalled was simple. As with a lot being stranded – quite a con- Cost new £39,799 Part
exchange £25,855 Cost per
others in offering cheap over- of these companies, you need a trast to the ease and conveni- mile 6.0p Cost per mile
night electricity rates – just 6p site survey first. But unlike ence of charging at home. That including depreciation £2.26
The story so far daily drive is a much-loved impressively robust and solid cameras a necessity for junc-
Readers offer some fresh leased Mazda CX-30 that has to doesn’t it? Very sophisticated tions and parking.'
perspectives on our i5 estate cover both her work and private and silent on the move, with a A mixed bag, then, but it’s the
+ Plenty of typically BMW transport requirements. ride quality that’s much BMW’s cost and range that
goodness to be found here… ‘I really dislike all that black smoother and quieter than my put’s Lucy firmly in the nice-
- …but it’s diluted by some shiny plastic around the grille, Mazda. For a big car it’s pretty but-no camp. ‘I just don’t see
unexpected mediocrity
and those wheels look like impressive through the corners how I could ever justify over
Logbook they’ll be a kerbing nightmare.’ and there’s plenty of punch, too. £1200 a month for a car that
Not a good start, and things Pity that bonnet is so long, struggles to get more than 220
Price £78,450 (£94,995 as
tested) Performance 81.2kWh don’t improve from the driver’s though, because it makes the miles on a full charge, no mat-
battery, e-motor, 340bhp, seat. ‘It’s so much smaller in
6.1sec 0-62mph, 120mph here than I expected. Sure, the
Efficiency 3.7 miles per kWh boot is a decent size, but I don’t
(official), 2.7 miles per kWh
(tested) Energy cost 3.5p per think my three teenagers would
mile Miles this month 2015 find it comfortable in the back.’
Total miles 9199 Accustomed to her more an-
alogue CX-30, she finds the i5’s
With just over 9000 miles cov- cockpit challenging. ‘It feels like
ered in the BMW, I feel I’ve real- there’s a lot of technology
ly got under its skin and beyond crammed in here, and I’d ques-
its £94,995 price tag to see its tion how much would I actually
pros and cons. But what would use every day.’
a trio of readers make of it? Out on the road, Lucy falls
Lucy Wilson is head of for the i5’s winning combina- Lucy enjoyed
the drive, but
Chichester-based interior de- tion of performance, refine- had doubts
sign studio Walnutblue. Her ment and dynamism. ‘It feels
T: 01938 561717
E: [email protected]
Reader discount code: CA-CAR
www.classicadditions.co.uk *Discount applies to standard fit covers & accessories only
Your ticket to Hollywood
3 issues of Empire for £5*
H O N DA C IVI C T YPE R
THE BAD: Road noise THE BAD: Pity the THE BAD: Now £60k; THE BAD: The stats
like a death-metal gig; Mk8 wasn’t that small boot for both don’t really shine in a
joke rear seats already 2025 context
THE UGLY: RS is still
THE UGLY: Long THE UGLY: Still not better, but S3 does a THE UGLY: Mk8.5 a
waiting list, even with quite there with the lot for less money and definite improvement,
some versions priced infotainment is impressive in its but interface still offers
at £60,000, although own right plenty to gripe about
it starts at £44,250 THE ONE TO BUY:
Estate is about £1.5k THE ONE TO BUY: THE ONE TO BUY:
THE ONE TO BUY: more than the hatch £60,105 for the hatch; £42,155 for a very
Now has optional auto and more practical an extra grand for the good Golf is pretty
but go for the manual but not so sharp saloon decent value
SHOP.RINGAUTOMOTIVE.COM Use CARMAG for 10% off your first order MAY 2025 | CARMAGAZINE.CO.UK 123
TOP 5 SPORTS CARS
GIANT
TEST
WINNER
P O R S C H E 9 11
GIANT GIANT
TEST TEST
WINNER WINNER
124 SHOP.RINGAUTOMOTIVE.COM Use CARMAG for 10% off your first order
The Good, the Bad & the Ugly
PCM (per calendar month) figures are typical prices for PCP (personal contract purchase) deals available at the time of writing. For guidance only
B MW M2 M A S E R ATI M E RCE D E S - M A Z DA M X- 5 A STO N
M C2 0 AMG SL MARTI N
THE GOOD: THE GOOD: VAN QU I S H
The longitudinal- THE GOOD: A THE GOOD: Latest Closest thing to a
engined two-door no-excuses excellent SL is developed by modern-day Lotus THE GOOD: Fast
BMW coupe lives Maserati. Handling AMG but it’s still a Elan; genius and comfortable,
and ride to match the cruiser, and all the folds-flat-in- and utterly
THE BAD: looks; a GT as well as better for it seconds roof gorgeous
Bigger and heavier a sports car
than we’d like but THE BAD: Engines THE BAD: Lashings THE BAD: Gets
outrageous fun THE BAD: Throttle are still better than of bodyroll; the 1.5 very thirsty without
could be sharper in the ride and can’t climb hills too much
THE UGLY: normal mode handling provocation
You need £66k to THE UGLY: If you’re
get involved; THE UGLY: THE UGLY: over 6ft tall you THE UGLY: DB12
steering can feel a Convincing your Cabin designed by simply won’t fit and Vantage are
shade rubbery mates you did mean touchpad also very good
to buy the Maser scattergun THE ONE TO BUY:
THE ONE TO BUY: and not the 296 Motorised-metal- THE ONE TO BUY:
Manual or auto THE ONE TO BUY: roof RF doesn’t £333,000 will get
transmission THE ONE TO BUY: The £148k, 469bhp quite make sense; you a very fine long,
options – get the The droptop Cielo. SL55; also look at 1.5 starts at £28k, low, two-seat sports
knob. We’d go M All the coupe’s go the coupe cousin, punchier 2.0 from car/GT/near-
carbon seats, too with added style the AMG GT £32k with an LSD supercar coupe
THE GOOD: THE GOOD: Spine- THE GOOD: The THE GOOD: Lighter, THE GOOD: A
Timeless styling and tingling sound; monstrous, more powerful, beautifully balanced
a driving experience 9000rpm redline; naturally-aspirated better: evolution of performance
as good as any of total immersion V12 lives on – now 720S is another package that can
Maranello’s finest e-boosted and corker from Woking stand tall among the
THE BAD: Nothing wrapped in such a supercar aristocracy
THE BAD: You to see here hard-to-crash THE BAD: 30 per
need reflexes like a package insurance cent new but you’d THE BAD: Interior
fighter pilot to drive THE UGLY: Getting should be a tenner. struggle to tell quality and kit not
it as fast as it can go on the waiting list is Vastly improved quite there
like winning both cabin, too THE UGLY:
THE UGLY: The X Factor and Convincing your THE UGLY: Will
Touch-sensitive The Apprentice THE BAD: Price has mates you actually future electrification
steering-wheel pads skyrocketed bought the new car kill the thrill?
make the interface THE ONE TO BUY:
borderline unusable RS is somehow THE UGLY: EV-only THE ONE TO BUY: THE ONE TO BUY:
more focused than range is six miles Stick to the comfort- Add the Z07 pack
THE ONE TO BUY: the GT3 but more spec seats and for upgraded aero,
Fiorano pack is road-compliant at THE ONE TO BUY: avoid the harnesses suspension, brakes
£25k+ overkill. GTS the same time. How There is only one on the top ‘super and wheels; expect
adds sunshine do they do it? for now carbon’ ones to pay £140k
126 SHOP.RINGAUTOMOTIVE.COM Use CARMAG for 10% off your first order
The Good, the Bad & the Ugly
R E NAU LT 5 E -TE CH
PCM (per calendar month) figures are typical prices for PCP (personal contract purchase) deals available at the time of writing. For guidance only
GIANT
TEST
WINNER
H Y U N DAI P OR SC H E KIA E V 3 R E N AU LT
IONIQ 5 N TAYCAN SCE N IC
THE GOOD: Roomy
THE GOOD: Electric THE GOOD: Totally and clever interior; THE GOOD: Good
and exciting – overhauled but still great value for such value; long range;
synthetic drive modes fast, responsive and long range; funky pleasant to drive;
and gearchange are fluid; now more looks – it’s a shrunken looks smart inside and
game changers efficient EV9 or EV6 out
THE BAD: Breadth of THE BAD: Info screen THE BAD: Air trim THE BAD: Sometimes
configurability takes in front of the feels cheap inside, but lumpy ride; poor rear
getting used to. passenger is faintly only when compared visibility; rear seats
Ignore that it’s ridiculous to bigger Kia EVs don’t slide or do other
software-driven – it family-friendly tricks
feels real THE UGLY: Prices are THE UGLY: That weird
all up, and be aware climate-control screen THE UGLY: The boot
THE UGLY: Interior of poor demand for is very deep, but not
quality below par for a used Taycans THE ONE TO BUY: actually that big, and
£65k car The 270-mile-range you have to pay extra
THE ONE TO BUY: car is brilliant value for a variable floor
THE ONE TO BUY: Prices start at £86.5k but most will want the
Just one model; paint for the rear-drive basic longer-range option. THE ONE TO BUY:
and a sunroof the only Taycan; you can pay a GT-Line is our pick for Go for the big battery
options – all the drive lot more and get a bit value-to-comfort in Techno trim; your
modes are included more performance goodness family will thank you
L AN D ROV E R D E F E N D E R
GIANT
TEST
WINNER
128 SHOP.RINGAUTOMOTIVE.COM Use CARMAG for 10% off your first order
The Good, the Bad & the Ugly
US postal information: CAR ISSN 0008-5987 (USPS 9287) is published monthly by H Bauer Publishing Ltd, Media House, Peterborough Business Park, Lynch Wood, Peterborough PE2 6EA,
United Kingdom. Airfreight and mailing in the USA by agent named World Container Inc, 150-15, 183rd St, Jamaica, NY 11413, USA. Periodicals Postage paid at Brooklyn, NY 11256.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to CAR, Air Business Ltd, c/o World Container Inc, 150-15, 183rd St, Jamaica, NY 11413, USA. Subscription records are maintained at Bauer Media
Subscriptions, CDS Global, Tower House, Sovereign Park, Lathkill Street, Market Harborough, Leicester LE16 9EF, United Kingdom. Air Business Ltd is acting as our mailing agent.
Pr r c les
yo 20%
ot ar s!
u
ec fo
t r
ѴѴŊbmŊom;1-uruo|;1ঞom0m7Ѵ;ĺ
ķѴѴo ķşovl;ঞ1mvu-m1; o1-m|uv|
Gap InsuranceŊruo|;1ঞombm|_;;;m|o=-ub|;o@
ѴѴo)_;;Ѵmvu-m1;Ŋmolou;h;u0;7-ѴѴo v
ovl;ঞ1!;r-bumvu-m1;ŋ b7;m|v-m77bm]v-| ou_ol;ououh
CAR WARRANTY | GAP INSURANCE | COSMETIC REPAIR INSURANCE | ALLOY WHEEL INSURANCE | BREAKDOWN | MOT | SERVICING
MotorEasy™ Ltd, Company No. 08423198 and MotorEasy Services Ltd, Company No. 10109424 are registered in the UK at 60 Portman Road, Reading, Berkshire, RG30 1EA. MotorEasy™
|7bv-mm|uo71;urrobm|;7!;ru;v;m|-ঞ;o=o|ou -v Ť";ub1;v|7ķ_b1_bv-|_oubv;7-m7u;]Ѵ-|;70 |_; bm-m1b-Ѵom71||_oub| ķ!;]bv|;uoƕƓƕѶƖƏ