Design a “Perfect” Milk Tea Store for
00-10 generation
Abstract
Considering the popular yet low-quality status quo of the milk tea industry, our project
intended to explore possible marketing systems for milk tea companies to prevail under the modern
environment. The overarching aim was to define and apply the “perfection” in our heart and
enhance consumers’ overall happiness subtly by innovating niche business models whilst
investigating our targeted consumer groups. Firstly, we encouraged the customization of products in
which menus are adapted towards greater flexibility and individual preferences on APPs. Charity
institutions, non-governmental organizations are also included in cooperation, allowing consumers
to visualize their efforts and donations towards philanthropic programs based on their personal
willingness with well-aimed interactive design. With regard to the concerns arising with quality and
health issues, we decreased caloric intake by investigating new possible alternatives and health
limitations available for consumers. In response to our survey and interviews, we intensified the
usage of APP/miniprograms by transferring the physical ordering procedures to APPs, providing
more flexibility and even discounts. Surveys and interviews were the main methods to attain
information of our intended audience’s preferences. Throughout the process, the SWOT model
(Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats) was applied in assessing the validity of our
outcomes. The innovation has a general popularity and approvals among our intended
audience,those born from 00-10, however, concerns based on profit making and business format
arise. Limitations of this innovation have occurred in its high dependence on consumers’
acceptance. High risks are foreseen in applying this innovation. Yet we insist on our idea to choose
responsibility towards health and wellbeing rather than short-term profit, and we continue to seek
other ways of profiting. Additionally, our innovation has great potential in improving the market
strategy as well as the industry standard by its niche concepts provided to the consumers.
Keywords: Milk tea, software design, donation, food health, DIY
1. Introduction
With the increasingly fierce competition in the beverage market, consumers are demanding
quality and innovation on a larger scale. In recent years, milk tea as a newly emerged beverage is
most preferred by consumers, especially the younger generation. Yet new concerns arise
accompanied with the development of this industry, including food safety, nutritious value,
overpricing and the homogeneous products. Milk tea market, are one of the undoubtedly
controversial topics on the table.
Even more remarkably, teenagers, especially those born from 2000-2010, were found to be
the targeted and major crowd of consumers in this market. As part of this generation ourselves, we
are deeply aware of the impact of milk tea industry among our peers, and the possible potential
values it can bring to the society and the generation. Vice versa, this huge impact can also bring
serious results to this highly directed crowd including health and addiction issues, which is fatal.
Despite the above, the ongoing remarkable expansion of the milk tea industry can be
attributed to consumers’ rising demand for freshness, style, flavor and price. In this scenario, major
brands still have rapidly flooded and grown in the market, bringing drastic rivalry among the
proprietors. Regarding this clear trend of the milk tea market in China as a whole, we decided to
focus on developing a new business structure that is more flexible, healthy, and social-friendlier as a
whole.
Throughout our investigation of the current inadequacy of the industry, we discovered
several aspects. First, the supreme popularity of milk tea is seriously affecting the obesity and
unhealthy rate of teenagers. Second, technology and innovation included in this industry is not
equivalent to its foreseeable popularity. Third, stores commonly show scarce social responsibility in
terms of even industry-related issues.
On the other hand, as people's quality of life improves, consumers' demand for milk tea is
becoming more and more diversified, not only satisfied with the basic taste and flavor, but also
more concerned about health, nutrition and environmental protection. With the emphasis on health,
the milk tea industry has continued to introduce various healthy fashion products. Throughout this
process, more types of drinks derived from the initial cup milk tea. Zero-sugar yogurt, alvocado
bowl, etc. Milk tea store is not only symbolic for selling milk tea with bubbles, but with these
innovative healthy products.
Meanwhile, milk tea market has been remarkably saturated, which means brands need to
continue to innovate flavors to attract consumers. New born brands are hard to survive, old brands
are hard to persist. Different innovation started to emerge as a new form of competition. For
example: many stores combine traditional milk tea flavors with local popular symbolic “tastes” to
launch a unique local flavor milk tea; Chinese traditional thematic names of milk tea and
decoration; seasonal fruits added in drinks to diversify the colors, etc. But none of these trends can
be compared with the dramatic trend of online channels. In short and on paper, milk tea brands need
to integrate online and offline sales channels to provide a more convenient purchasing experience
because of the vareity types of drinks existing for the demand. This may also serve to enhance
brand influence through online platforms. Combining these market issues and trends, we hope to
create the “perfect” milk tea store that meets the needs of most people.
2. Essential Research
Our research question focuses on identifying the elements that make a ‘perfect’ milk tea
store.
2.1 Market investigation
The importance of this research lies in the significant growth and evolution of the milk tea
industry. The global bubble tea market size was valued at $2.29 billion in 2022, and is projected to
grow from $2.46 billion in 2023 to $4.08 billion by 2030.[1] With a tendency to shift into the online
sector.[2]
Thus, we aim to create a model that concludes elements current popular milk tea stores share
that contributes to their popularity, considering factors such as taste, variety, packaging, etc. This
research gains significance in the context of the dynamic growth and transformation within the milk
tea industry, marked by evolving consumer demands for freshness, health, fashion, flavor, and
reasonable pricing.
In the context of our research, the term “universally appealing” refers to the set of attributes
or characteristics possessed by a milk tea store that resonate positively with the targeted consumer
base. [2] However, due to the specialty of our project, not as much academic papers and anlysis can
be found in the database available. So far our conclusions and schemes are made upon both paper
reviews and physical survey, as well as interview.
2.2 Consumer preferences
Earlier research has explored topics related to milk tea and the application of conjoint
analysis in studying various beverages. A study examining consumer beverage purchase behavior
and preferences for different beverage categories in Tainan, Taiwan using descriptive statistics and
pearson correlation coefficients gave findings that indicated a positive correlation between product
attributes and consumers' purchasing decisions.[3] Therefore, visual elements and making products
attractive contribute to higher popularity. Focusing on unique and visually appealing store logos and
drink cups can create a memorable and distinctive brand image, attracting customers and fostering
brand loyalty.[4]
Likewise, an analysis to comprehend the factors influencing consumer preferences and the
changing purchase intentions across a wide array of products within the dynamic beverage
industries was conducted. The findings revealed that significant shifts in consumer focus towards
milk and fruit-based drinks were primarily influenced by factors such as health benefits and calorie
content.[5] Therefore, focusing on healthier product contents and lesser calories is a strategy to
attract more customers.
2.3 Our current Approach
Our proposed approach revolves around personalized customer experiences through the
implementation of a special mini program. Although there are various milk tea brands utilizing mini
programs, these programs are only designed to order, our mini program will include a DIY format
and prioritize personalized designs for each customer.
To enhance convenience, we transition to an online-only ordering system. Our physical
stores will transform into vehicle stations or workshops, maintaining a tranquil environment for
order pickups. Instructions will be prominently displayed outside for easy navigation, ensuring a
seamless and accessible experience for all customers.
We prioritize health-conscious choices by linking the calories intake to sugar restrictions.
Compared to current existing healthy-milk-tea products, the products we produce are more
personalized, as customers are encouraged to make healthier choices with options selecting lesser
sugar, different types of milk, substitutes for pearls, etc. For example, we also researched about the
accessbility of the healthier alternative for bubbles—-grass jelly.[6] Other than this, consumers are
able to try out more diverse tastes.
Embracing innovation, our new DIY format empowers customers to design their own milk
tea with limitless combinations. However, with non-uniformed products, every single product will
experience different procedures to make, and every choice of design has to be carefully recognized
for the products to be totally matching with what consumers demand.
However, providing completely personalized products might be costly, as a larger variety of
substitutes are demanded and more time is taken for a single product’s production, compared to
making uniformed products with the same procedures for each cup of drink. Therefore, we suggest
the mini program to include the ability to present and show the price and expected time of their
drink completion of the customers’ creation as they choose.
Additionally, customers can extend their creativity to designing their own special wrap for
the milk tea, VIP privileges are granted annually for this unique customization.
In comparison with current existing milk tea stores, our implementation of the mini program stands
out, providing a personalized and interactive platform for customers. This goes beyond
conventional ordering systems, fostering a deeper connection between the brand and the consumer.
The emphasis on health-conscious choices allows customers to customize sugar levels and offers
substitutes for pearls, distinguishing our solution by catering to the growing demand for healthier
beverage options.
Furthermore, the introduction of the DIY format, where customers design their own milk tea
with the ability to determine its price, adds a unique and engaging dimension to the user experience
that almost no current brand produces. These features collectively elevate our solution, providing a
more dynamic and customer-centric approach compared to current existing milk tea stores.
2.4 Statistical survey
For the purpose of how to design a ‘perfect’ milk-tea-shop, we did social surveys and held a
heated discussion according to the results of the investigations. We got a large amount (more than
100) of useful responses and ideas about the milk tea store ideas. For instance, according to our
survey, 96.25% of people prefer to buy milk tea online and 100% people agree with the argument
that milk tea shops need to have their own small order program because they think buying milk tea
offline is extremely inconvenient. Therefore, we should try our best to improve the online channels
and make customers take pride, comfort and satisfaction. As a result, we also did an investigation
about the reviews and suggestions in regard to the online channels from consumers. We also found
that special demand for some consumers are hard to be claimed through online portal. For instance,
for some consumers who dislike sugars or other pellets like pearls, there is no choice to remove
them when they want to order milk-tea with the Apps and there are only three choices about sugar
( 30%,70% and 100%). Thus, online channels of ordering milk-tea have lots of room for
improvement and we have had many discussions on such issues and would put it into practice as
soon as possible.
2.5 Current solutions
Not as many people so far gave successful solutions in the problem of our project. We
concluded three of the major questions: First, teenagers are out of the management of family,
school, and have weaker self-descipline comparatively. Thus it’s hard to impose sugar limiting
policy on the sake of milk tea store. [7] Second, despite the willingness of some stores to use
healthier ingredients, these materials are substantially more expensive. Thus we need to find other
ways to make profit that can afford these actions.[8] Third, New technologies of solving the
inefficiency in space utilizing have emerged, but it’s both inconvenient and expensive for a milk tea
store. We need a clean and accessible way in order for this innovation to be spread.[9]
2.6 Persoanl Interview
We also consulted the experience and precautions of relevant milk tea shops. According to
these activities, we also got a lot of important information about a “perfect” milk-tea-shop. Too
many milk-tea-shops owners argue that they have to launch many more new kinds of milk tea for
different people and in different seasons. And according to our survey, 80.79% people think the
diversity of milk-tea is the most important thing for an ordering program.
We also found that many of the workers at milk tea store complained about the bad working
environment, most of which is face-to-face ordering. The crowded and noisy atmosphere and the
variety choices of customers are overloading their work.
Combining these information, we decided to create this online portal with more kinds of
milk-tea like low sugar, healthy milk tea and better warm milk tea material in winter and so on.
Siting location is also a really significant part of operating a milk-tea-shop. Neither a little corner in
the middle of nowhere in a city nor a crowded but competitive area. We need to continue to study
the strategy and wisdom of siting locations. According to the interview with the employees,
patience and a smile is the most important thing for them. These not only can increase customer
satisfaction but also can make themselves more hAppy. What’s more, we also learned that a milk-
tea shop doesn’t need too many employees. The best number of employees may be 2 or 3. One
employee must be patient and he is in charge of entertaining customers, another one or two in
charge of making milk-tea. If necessary, the owner can hire one or two more to stand in front of the
store as an anime character to attract customers. Only if we consider as many things as possible, the
more chances we have to create a “perfect” milk-tea-shop.
(Both of surveys and interviews related files will be uploaded in the submission portal)
3. Innovation Design
3.1 Intended audience
Based on our literature and first-stage market research, we have identified the teenage
crowd, born specifically from 2000~2010, was the major consumer in the milk tea industry. We
noticed that this crowd is taking both the pros, and the cons of the milk tea industry. They show
high enthusiasm and preference in milk tea, yet endergo high potential health threats accordingly.
The ideology among elder groups makes milk tea harder for them to accept, leaving only teenagers
as the major consumers.
Being separated and isolated from society, teenagers are easily addicted without proper
management. A great amount of them are away from their guardian, or parents, resulting in a more
severe and uncontrollable situation for drinking milk tea. One milk tea per day is common for this
crowd based on our survey. Thus because of the potential and natural purchasing power our
intended audience have, we decide to turn our focus onto innovative ideas in order to attract them.
Having so many homogeneous products and business formats of advertising, the market has shown
a tiring trend, and many past-day big sales have been shut down due to their lack of competitive
power.
Consequently, after our background research of this generation, as well as our own
generation, we proudly found that we are a generation with high standards, high acceptance of new
things, and high sense of responsibility in society. Based on which we started our next stage of
innovation. We are confident that our innovation is highly correlated to our intended audience who
are easily accessibly throughout the research.
3.2 Innovation
To echo what we have in audience research, we have concluded 3 major innovations of ours.
On the final terminal, these modules are called “drink to sea”, “DIY”, and “Short-GAR”.
First and foremost, “DIY” is the only terminal to order in our design. No more purchases can be
made physically. Throughout our field research, we have found that milk tea stores are relatively
small compared to other shops. This is mainly due to the conventional thought starting from the
start of this industry. However, no one realizes that the status quo no longer matches with the
growing market demand and consumer demand. Despite the urge of expanding the store area,
limitation in funds and desire of making profit withdraw the impulse of the natural market. Thus
this innovation optimized the in store area usage by eliminating the long lines and huge amount of
online order drivers awaiting. This innovation also raises the level of consumers’ freedom and
flexibility. We included different functions in the DIY module, allowing consumers to design their
own package, milk tea seasoning, even materials of straw within provided choices. This includes
one of the vital parts of our revenue, of a monthly premium policy.
Our next innovation is “drink to sea”, meaning “drink your ideas to own a sea”. Our
audience is a crowd filled with passion and speculation towards society. But being restricted in
school and curriculum has refrained their ability to advocate for their willingness. “Drink to sea”
provides teengers with the ability to make an impact, based on their consideration. As a teenager of
this era myself, we sincerely understand the App and pursuit of our own generation. For those that
are younger than us, this function helps to build a sense of responsibility in society. A designated
amount of money in each bottle of milk tea we sold can be donated to the specific individual in
need, organizations, or even a fundraising committee. We researched for a widely spread list
possible for us to access, in order to provide this opportunity to our generation.
Our final major innovation is regarding the current arising concern of the health issues
relating to the milk tea industry. With the high addictive characteristics and directness towards our
young generation, the milk tea industry should be more strictly managed in its quality and
ingredients, as well as hygiene. In our App/miniprograms, the function “Short-GAR” is designed
towards the current problems of obesity due to excessive intake of milk tea among teenagers. In this
function, consumers can choose to design their own plan of diet on sugar, or just to use our
suggested template. During our research, we have investigated the price and nutritious value of
many alternatives to the unhealthy boba now predominant in the industry. With those alternatives,
consumers will definitely have a better chance to keep their health while drinking milk tea.
3.3 Interactive design
In order to be more easily accepted by both consumers and the market, our innovation is all
choices available for the consumers to experience. In order to make it more accessible for
consumers, QR code will also lead consumers to the same terminal to order. Advertising will be a
vital part for this idea to be spread and popular. Cooperation with other enterprises and IPs are also
significant by learning from other existing successful examples in the market. Below is the original
design and blueprint for the 3 basic functions of our APP/ miniprograms. (The words below in the
image are intro)
4. Verification results
4.1 Online portal
We have been working on online portal for more than a month. We decided to start with app,
considering the convenience for most customers to come to our store without having to download
an APP. So far we have done the basic interactive design and conceptual input. Now we are
currently using JavaScript to write the code to run the app. Our script will be attached on the
submission portal. Below is the basic construction of our code.
However, applying for a app as teenagers need extra time for them to validate. So far we
have input our code into the WeChat developer tool. But we need to finalize our idea and time for
validation our idea and code in order to really get it transferred into a real app. Thus recently
starting from January, we started to develop the website. The link will be attached in the submission
portal as well. The website is to be updated and consummated. Many functions that require coding
wasn’t all done.
4.2 Validation
We used the SWOT model to validate our results. SWOT stands for strengths, weaknesses,
opportunities, and threats. The strengths of our project is clearly stated to be the innovation of this
brand new business model and its applicable usage in any milk tea store that will soon accustom
anywhere in China. However, our weakness is also obvious. We highly depend on the acceptance of
our intended audience, as well as the initial crowd of consumers. But higher risks always stand for
higher payoffs. In this project so far, we haven’t really reach the part of consolidating the location
choice and the raw material sources, although we have collected data of them. Submission will not
be the end of our project. In February, we have a continuous plan for tidying the JavaScipt and
consummate the website as well. Opportunities in thi project will be the CTB national site seminar,
where we can hear from others’ opinion about the current shortcomings we have and more ideas
about our future directions. Basing on our foundamental core thought of environmental friendly and
positive externality to society, we are confident that this project has no potential threats on any
aspect. On possible effect might be employment change for eliminating the physical order, but since
most stores are hiring workers for multi-purposes, this should not have a negative impact.
As a result of the particularity of our project, it’s nearly impossible to have any direct
outcome and feedback before our app/ website is out for a period of time. But in our surveys we
have concluded that this project ends up being revolutionary, innovative, and fresh to our intended
audience.
5. Discussion and conclusion
5.1 Discussion
Throughout the process of our project, lacking of resources might be one of the vital
questions that we have. As students, none of us have really stepped into real society, or business
world. Even though we had interview with professional people, as well as survey to gather
everyone’s ideas, we are still pinned on theoretic dimension. In the future, we might continue to
research the market, and dive deeper into the industry to find more painpoint and details. We will
also consummate our App/webpage and publish them to get real user feedbacks from other angles.
We also planned for advertising part that is not included so far in our project. As an integral part,
advertising and promoting strategy is the key to success.
5.2 Conclusions
In the process of this project, we’ve been sparing our efforts to improve the unhealthy
ingredients in the industry, the inefficiency of store usage, as well as the limitation of flexibility on
the consumer side. Our innovation provided solutions and ideas according to those respectively. The
function accumulating App/webpage assembles our optimal alternatives for the consumers,
including DIY, sugar cutting plans, and social engagement. Our surveys adequately provide us with
insights on the points of view from our targeted audience and questions arised. Interviews also
helped us find many shortcomings in both consideration and pracctical Application. We used SWOT
theory to test our effectiveness that got.a satisfactory result. We have developed a rather mature
system of business model that can be Applied in any milk tea store, and an ongoing improving
webpage/App terminal that can be accessible as well. We think the ultimate goal for this project is
to have responsibility and use advanced mindset to revolute the tradition.
References
1. Bubble Tea Market Size, Share, growth | Industry Trends [2023]. (n.d.). https://
www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/industry-reports/bubble-tea-market-101564
2. The next horizon for grocery e-commerce: Beyond the pandemic bump. (2022, April 29).
McKinsey & Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/retail/our-insights/the-next-horizon-
for-grocery-ecommerce-beyond-the-pandemic-bump
3. Shih, S.P.; Yu, S.; Tseng, H.C. The Study of Consumers’ Buying Behavior and Consumer
Satisfaction in Beverages Industry in Tainan, Taiwan. J. Econ. Bus. Manag. 2015, https://
joebm.com/papers/215-A00031.pdf
4. Ong, A. K. S., Prasetyo, Y. T., Libiran, M. a. D. C., Lontoc, Y. M. A., Lunaria, J. a. V., Manalo, A.
M., Miraja, B. A., Young, M. N., Chuenyindee, T., Persada, S. F., & Redi, A. a. N. P. (2021).
Consumer Preference Analysis on Attributes of Milk Tea: A Conjoint Analysis
approach. Foods, 10(6), 1382. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods10061382
5. Khanna, V. A Study on Factors Impacting Consumer Preference And Purchase Intention: With
Special Reference To Beverage Industry. In Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on
Recent Innovations in Science, Technology, Management, and Environment; 2016, http://
data.conferenceworld.in/IFUNA18DEC16/P493-512.pdf
6. Rizal, Samsul, et al. "The effects of low-temperature storage on the viability of Lactobacillus
casei and the stability of antibacterial activity in green grass jelly synbiotic drinks." Biodiversitas
Journal of Biological Diversity 21.8 (2020).
7.Yahya, Nurul A., Nor AA Zulkifli, and Nadhierah AM Rosni. "Knowledge and awareness on
consumption of bubble tea towards obesity and caries risks: A cross-sectional study." Journal of
Dentomaxillofacial Science 8.2 (2023).
8.ZUBAIRI, SAIFUL IRWAN, et al. "Health Concern of Phenomenally Premium Boba Milk Tea
and Pearls Beverages in Kuala Lumpur: Sugary Content and Physico-chemical Profiles Analysis."
Current Research in Nutrition & Food Science 11.2 (2023).
9.林豪, et al. "奶茶店作业空间设计的改善." 机电 程技术 49.2 (2020): 37-41.
工