GL BAJAJ INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT,

GREATER NOIDA

SUMMER INTERNSHIP PROJECT REPORT ON

“CONSUMER PREFERENCE FOR TIMES GROUP PUBLICATION”
TOWARDS THE PARTIAL FULLFILLMENT FOR THE AWARD OF DEGREE OF

MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATON (MBA)

DR. APJ ABDUL KALAM TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY

(Formerly Uttar Pradesh Technical University) LUCKNOW

by
SHAHIL SINGH
(Roll No. : 2301920700380)

Under the Supervision of

Dr. Swati Raj
Faculty, Department of Management Studies, ITM, Greater
Noida 2024-25

1
DECLARATION

I hereby declare that the work presented in this report entitled “Consumer
Preference for Times group Publication", was carried out by me. I have not
submitted the matter embodied in this report for the award of any other
degree or diploma from any other University or Institute. I have given due
credit to the original authors/sources for all the words, ideas, diagrams,
graphics, computer programs, experiments, and results, that are not my
original contribution. I have used quotation marks to identify verbatim
sentences and given credit to the original authors/sources.
I affirm that no portion of my work is plagiarized, and the experiments and results
reported in the report are not manipulated. In the event of a complaint of
plagiarism and the manipulation of the experiments and results, I shall be
fully responsible and answerable.

Name : SHAHIL SINGH

Roll. No. : 2301920700380

Specialization: Marketing & Operations

(Candidate Signature)

2
 GL BAJAJ
INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY & MANAGEMENT
Approved by A.I.C.T.E. & affiliated to Dr. A.P.J Abdul Kalam Technical University

CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that SHAHIL SINGH , Roll No. 2301920700380
has undertaken this project titled “Consumer Preference for
Times group Publication” forthe partial fulfilment of the award
of Master of Business Administration degree from DR. A P J
Abdul Kalam Technical University, Lucknow (U. P.).
I wish him/ her all the best for his/her bright future ahead.

Date: Dec 28th,2024

3
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The internship opportunity I had with Times of India was a great chance for
learning and professional development. Therefore, I am also grateful for having a
chance to meet so many wonderful people and professionals who led me through
this internship period. Bearing in mind the previous I am using this
opportunity to express my deepest gratitude and special thanks to the Mr.
Gaurav Sharma of The Times Of India who in spite of being extraordinarily busy
with his duties, took time out to hear, guide and keep me on the correct path
allowing me to carry out my project at their esteemed organization and
extending
during the training.
I express my deepest thanks to my mentor Dr. Swati Raj For taking part in useful
decisions & giving necessary pieces of advice and guidance to make the project
easier. I choose this moment to acknowledge her contribution gratefully.
I am using this opportunity to express my gratitude to Dr. Vikas Tripathi
(HOD) who supported me throughout the course and constantly reviewed my
work and provide guidance of this MBA project.

Project Supervisor
Department of Management Studies

Head of Department
Department of Management Studies

4
 TABLE OF CONTENT
Particular Page No.
CHAPTER - 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 INDUSTRY OVERVIEW
1.1.1 Historical Industry Trend 7-8
1.1.2 Current Industry Trends 9-10
1.1.3 Economic state of Industry 11-12
1.1.4 Competitiveness of Industry 13-14
1.2 INTRODUCTION TO COMPANY
1.2.1 Company origin and foundation
1.2.2 Mission, Vision & Company Objectives
15-17
1.2.3 Company Product and Services
18
1.2.4 Michael Porter's Five Forces Model
1.2.5 SWOT Analysis 19-25
1.2.6 Distribution Structure of The Times of India 26-29

30-35
CHAPTER - 2 LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Evolution of The Times of India 36-37
2.2 Consumer Behaviour and Audience Engagement 38
2.3 Organizational Strategy and Business Model 39
2.4 The Role of Digital Media in The Times of India’s Transformation 40
2.5 Future Outlook and Strategic Adaptations 41
2.6 Gaps in Literature and Areas for Further Research 41

CHAPTER-3RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.1 Define Research Problem 42-43
3.2 Research Design. 44
3.3 Sample Design 45
3.4 Formulation of Hypothesis 46

CHAPTER - 4 DEVELOPMENT OF QUESTIONNAIRE AND DATA

COLLECTION
4.1 Types of Questionnaire Used 47-49
4.2 Types of Source of Data 50-51
4.3 Data Collection Methodology 52

CHAPTER - 5 DATA ANALYSIS & INTERPRETATION

5.1 Data Analysis Tool 53-54
5.2 Data Interpretation (Results and Findings) 55-82
CHAPTER - 6 FINAL CHAPTER
6.1 Discussion 83-84
6.2 Recommendations 85
6.3 Suggestions 86
6.4 Conclusion 87
6.5 Future Scope 88
6.6 Limitations 89

5
BIBLIOGRAPHY 90
APPENDICES 91

6
 CHAPTER 1:
INDUSTRY OVERVIEW

7
1.1 Industry Overview

1.1.1 Historical Industry Trend

The media industry has evolved through distinct eras, each de5ined by advancements in
technology, shifts in societal needs, and the changing dynamics of communication. The
earliest form of media can be traced back to the spoken word, where oral traditions
served as the primary method of sharing stories, news, and knowledge. This period relied
heavily on human memory and interpersonal communication. The development of
written scripts and the invention of papyrus in ancient Egypt marked the transition to a
more structured and durable form of record-keeping, paving the way for the development
of print media.

The invention of the printing press by Johannes Gutenberg in the mid-15th century
revolutionized the dissemination of information. For the 5irst time, books, pamphlets, and
other written materials could be produced on a large scale, breaking the monopoly of the
literate elite and democratizing access to information. Newspapers soon followed in the
17th century, with The Relation (1605) in Germany often cited as the 5irst modern
newspaper. The industrial revolution of the 19th century was another turning point,
as technological innovations like the steam-powered press drastically reduced
production costs, enabling newspapers and magazines to reach a broader audience.

In India, the media industry began to take shape under British colonial rule. The Bengal
Gazette (1780), widely regarded as India’s 5irst newspaper, emerged as a voice of the
educated elite. Over the next century, print media became a critical tool for social and
political movements, playing a key role in India’s struggle for independence.
Publications like The Times of India, founded in 1838, chronicled both colonial
perspectives and, later, nationalist ideologies.

The 20th century introduced radio as the next signi5icant medium. The establishment of
All India Radio in 1936 marked the beginning of centralized broadcasting in India,
delivering news, cultural programs, and entertainment. Television followed in the 1950s
and 60s, transforming media consumption by combining visual and auditory
elements. The launch of Doordarshan, India's public service broadcaster, in 1959 signaled a
new era, with programs reaching rural and urban audiences alike.

The late 20th century witnessed the digital revolution. The rise of the internet
disrupted traditional media paradigms, enabling instantaneous access to news and
entertainment. Social media platforms, which emerged in the early 21st century,
further democratized content creation and distribution, challenging established
players and reshaping consumer behaviour.

8
1.1.2 Current Industry Trends
The media and journalism industry has been evolving rapidly due to technological
advancements, shifting consumer behaviours, and changing revenue models. These
trends have reshaped how news is created, distributed, and consumed, pushing media
companies like The Times of India (TOI) to adapt and innovate. Below is a detailed
overview of the current industry trends that de5ine the sector.

1. Digital Transformation
The digital revolution has signi5icantly transformed the media landscape, making online
platforms the primary medium for news consumption. Media companies are adopting
digital-5irst strategies, offering content across websites, mobile apps, and social
media. Real-time news updates, live streams, and multimedia storytelling have become
essential components of digital media offerings. However, challenges like information
overload and misinformation require innovative solutions, including fact-checking
initiatives and the use of arti5icial intelligence to verify content.

2. Rise of Subscription Models

Declining advertising revenues have led media organizations to explore subscription-
based models. Paywalls and premium content subscriptions are increasingly
common, with companies like TOI offering exclusive content to subscribers. This trend
emphasizes quality journalism, as consumers are willing to pay for trustworthy and in-
depth reporting. Subscription models also help media organizations build closer
relationships with their audiences while ensuring a steady revenue stream.

3. Personalized Content and Data Analytics

The integration of arti5icial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) allows
media companies to deliver personalized content tailored to individual preferences.
Algorithms analyze user behaviour to recommend articles, videos, and other content,
enhancing engagement. Personalized advertising, driven by data analytics, further
boosts revenue. Advanced analytics also enable media organizations to track
audience metrics, re5ine content strategies, and deliver targeted content.

4. Growth of Regional and Vernacular Content

Regional and vernacular content is a major growth driver in India, driven by the
increasing internet penetration in rural and semi-urban areas. Media companies are
expanding offerings in regional languages to cater to diverse audiences. TOI, for
instance, provides content in multiple Indian languages, capturing a broader
demographic. This trend also bene5its advertisers seeking to target speci5ic regional
markets.

5. Social Media as a News Source

Social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram play a crucial role in news
dissemination. They provide real-time updates and facilitate audience interaction. Media
organizations use social platforms to amplify their reach and drive traf5ic to their
websites. However, the reliance on social media also brings challenges like algorithmic
biases and the proliferation of fake news, necessitating robust social media strategies and
partnerships with platforms to promote credible content.

6. Popularity of Podcasts and Video Content

9
Podcasts and video content are gaining traction, re5lecting a shift in audience preferences
toward on-the-go and visual storytelling. Podcasts offer an alternative to traditional news
formats, allowing users to consume content during commutes or leisure time. Similarly,
short videos, explainer animations, and live broadcasts dominate digital platforms,
making video production a key focus for media companies. These formats not only
increase audience engagement but also attract premium advertising opportunities.

7. Combating Misinformation
Misinformation remains a pressing challenge for the industry. Media organizations are
investing in fact-checking teams and leveraging AI to detect and counter fake news.
Educating audiences about media literacy and promoting transparency are critical to
rebuilding trust and reinforcing the credibility of news outlets.

8. Sustainability and Responsibility

Media companies are increasingly adopting sustainable practices, such as reducing paper
usage and covering environmental issues. Organizations are also incorporating corporate
social responsibility (CSR) initiatives into their strategies, re5lecting a commitment
to positive societal impact.

10
1.1.3 Economic State of the Industry
The economic state of the media industry is a re5lection of its dynamic and rapidly
evolving nature. Driven by advancements in technology, shifts in consumer behaviour,
and changes in revenue models, the industry has seen both growth and challenges in
recent years. While digitalization has opened new revenue streams, traditional sectors of
the industry, such as print media, have faced signi5icant economic pressures.

1. Revenue DiversiLication and Digital Growth

The media industry has increasingly diversi5ied its revenue streams to adapt to the digital
era. The rise of digital platforms has shifted the focus from traditional advertising
and subscription models to online advertising, content paywalls, and partnerships.
Companies are investing heavily in digital transformation to capture new audiences,
particularly through social media, streaming platforms, and mobile apps. The digital
advertising market has grown exponentially, contributing signi5icantly to the
industry's economic stability.
India, for example, has seen substantial growth in digital media consumption. This trend
has fuelled investments in technology and analytics to enhance content delivery and user
engagement. Media organizations like The Times of India have adopted digital-5irst
strategies, emphasizing online subscriptions and premium content to generate
sustainable revenues.

2. Challenges in Print Media

The print media segment has been under signi5icant economic strain, primarily due
to declining readership and reduced advertising revenues. The shift to digital
platforms, coupled with the increasing cost of newsprint, has forced traditional
newspapers to re- evaluate their business models. Despite these challenges, print media
continues to play a vital role in regions where digital penetration is limited. Many
companies are adopting hybrid models, combining digital initiatives with traditional
print offerings to sustain their operations.

3. Impact of Global Events

Global events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, have profoundly impacted the
media industry's economic state. The pandemic accelerated digital adoption as
consumers turned to online platforms for news and entertainment. However, it also
led to a temporary decline in advertising revenues due to economic uncertainty. Post-
pandemic recovery has seen a resurgence in advertising spending, particularly in
digital and outdoor media, helping the industry regain its footing.

4. Role of Government Policies and Regulations

Government policies and regulations signi5icantly in5luence the economic environment
of the media industry. Taxation policies, foreign direct investment (FDI) norms, and
content regulation laws can impact the industry's growth trajectory. For example, India’s
liberalized FDI policies in digital media have attracted investments, fostering innovation
and competition. At the same time, stringent regulations on content and licensing fees
can pose economic challenges for media companies.

11
5. Economic Contributions and Job Creation
The media industry is a vital contributor to the economy, generating signi5icant revenue
and employment opportunities. It encompasses a wide range of sectors, including
journalism, entertainment, advertising, and technology, each contributing to
economic growth. The industry's integration with technology has further created jobs
in data analytics, content creation, and digital marketing, highlighting its role as a
driver of economic progress.

12
1.1.4 Competitiveness of the Industry

The media industry is one of the most competitive sectors globally, characterized by rapid
innovation, diverse content offerings, and intense rivalry across various platforms.
The competition is fuelled by technological advancements, changing consumer
preferences, and the emergence of new players disrupting traditional business models.
The competitiveness of the industry can be analyzed through factors like market
dynamics, audience engagement, technological integration, and the ability to adapt to
evolving trends.

1. Market Dynamics and Rivalry

The media industry operates in a highly fragmented market with numerous players
competing for audience attention. Traditional media outlets like newspapers and
television face stiff competition from digital platforms, including online news
portals, social media, and streaming services. Companies like The Times of India compete
not only with other print media giants but also with digital-5irst organizations like Scroll, The
Wire, and regional language platforms catering to localized
audiences. The advertising revenue pie is another area of 5ierce competition.
Advertisers now allocate budgets across multiple platforms, making it essential for
media companies to demonstrate high engagement and return on investment (ROI). This
dynamic has created a race to attract advertisers through innovative formats, targeted
advertising, and data- driven insights.

2. Technological Advancements
The integration of technology has heightened competition in the media industry. The
adoption of arti5icial intelligence (AI), machine learning, and data analytics allows
companies to deliver personalized content and improve audience retention. Media
companies are competing to create more sophisticated algorithms for content
recommendations, real-time updates, and targeted advertisements. Additionally,
advancements in mobile technology and internet penetration have intensi5ied
competition in digital media, with companies striving to deliver seamless user
experiences on mobile platforms.

3. Consumer-Centric Strategies
In a crowded marketplace, understanding and catering to consumer preferences is a
critical competitive advantage. Media companies are leveraging audience insights to
produce relevant and engaging content. For instance, regional language content has
gained prominence as companies recognize the growing demand for vernacular news and
entertainment. Players like The Times of India have expanded their regional offerings to
capture diverse audience segments.
Moreover, audience engagement through interactive content, social media presence, and
community building has become a key differentiator. Media outlets compete to foster
loyalty among their audiences, often using gami5ied experiences, surveys, and live
interactions.

4. Barriers to Entry and New Players

The media industry has relatively low barriers to entry in the digital age, enabling new
players to challenge established organizations. The rise of independent content creators,
bloggers, and YouTubers has intensi5ied competition, particularly in niche markets.
These

13
new entrants often operate with lower overhead costs and greater agility, allowing
them to experiment with innovative content formats and disrupt traditional media
business models.
However, established players retain a competitive edge through their extensive networks,
credibility, and access to resources. Organizations like The Times of India leverage their
historical presence and brand recognition to maintain their market position amidst
new competition.

5. Globalization and Regional Adaptation

Global media companies increasingly compete with local players as markets become
more interconnected. Streaming platforms like Net5lix and Amazon Prime compete with
regional providers like Hotstar in India. This globalization has encouraged local players
to innovate and offer culturally relevant content, thereby intensifying competition. Media
companies that successfully balance global trends with localized offerings stand out
in this competitive environment.

6. Innovation and Differentiation

Innovation is the cornerstone of competitiveness in the media industry. Companies
differentiate themselves through unique content formats, immersive experiences, and
cutting-edge technologies like augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR). For
example, interactive storytelling and immersive journalism are emerging trends
where companies vie for leadership to engage tech-savvy
audiences. In addition, partnerships and collaborations with technology providers, content
creators, and advertisers allow companies to enhance their offerings and stay ahead of
competitors.

14
1.2 INTRODUCTION TO THE COMPANY

1.2.1 Company Origin and Foundation

The Times of India (TOI) is one of India's oldest and most

in5luential English-language daily newspapers, with its roots
dating back to 1838. Established as The Bombay Times and
Journal of Commerce, it was initially a bi-weekly publication
catering to British residents in India. The paper focused on delivering news from Europe,
America, and the Indian subcontinent, 5illing the gap for commercial and political news
relevant to the expatriate community.
Founded by Rao Bahadur Narayan Dinanath Velkar, The Bombay Times played a crucial
role in documenting the socio-political evolution of India. From the British colonial era to
the nation's independence, the publication has mirrored the changing landscapes of
Indian society. Its editorial content evolved to re5lect these transformations, maintaining
a balance between journalistic integrity and the demands of a competitive market.
In 1892, The Times of India came under the ownership of Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd.
(BCCL), marking the beginning of its journey as a 5lagship publication of what would
become India’s largest media conglomerate. This transition brought modernization in
editorial policies, production processes, and distribution networks, signi5icantly
expanding its readership.
Over the decades, The Times of India has grown beyond traditional print media. It now
encompasses digital platforms, mobile applications, television channels, radio, and event
management, making it a multimedia powerhouse. Through consistent innovation and
adaptability, TOI has retained its position as a leading voice in Indian journalism,
continuing to in5luence public discourse and opinion.
This history underscores TOI's enduring legacy as a witness to India's transformation
from a British colony to an independent nation and now as a global economic power. Its
ability to adapt while retaining its core values has been central to its success and
relevance in modern times.

15
History of The Times of India
1838: The Birth of Bombay Times and Journal of Commerce
The inception of The Times of India traces back to 1838, when it was 5irst published
as The Bombay Times and Journal of Commerce. Initially, it served as a bi-weekly
newspaper aimed at the British residents of Bombay (now Mumbai). The paper primarily
focused on commercial news and public notices relevant to traders and colonial of5icials.
Its establishment marked the beginning of organized journalism in India.

1850s: Expansion of Content and Readership

By the 1850s, the newspaper expanded its focus to cover broader topics, including social and
political issues, attracting a diverse readership. Its reputation for reliable and timely news
began to grow, cementing its role in the local community.

1861: Formation of The Times of India

In 1861, The Bombay Times merged with two other newspapers, Bombay
Standard and Chronicle of Western India, to form The Times of India. This pivotal merger
provided the foundation for its transformation into a daily publication. The paper began
addressing the concerns of Indian citizens and became a bridge between the colonizers and
the local populace.

1892: Ownership Transition to Bennett and Coleman

Thomas Bennett and Frank Morris Coleman acquired the newspaper in 1892. Under their
leadership, The Times of India modernized its operations and increased circulation. This
period marked the advent of new editorial policies that embraced diverse viewpoints, catering
to an increasingly aware Indian audience.

Early 20th Century: National Movement Coverage

During the Indian freedom movement, The Times of India played a dual role. While
maintaining its colonial roots, it also provided space for discussions on India’s socio-political
landscape. This era witnessed significant editorial courage in covering events like the Non-
Cooperation Movement and the Civil Disobedience Movement.

Post-Independence: Shaping Modern India

After India gained independence in 1947, The Times of India became a crucial platform for
debates on nation-building. Its coverage shifted towards highlighting India's progress in
infrastructure, education, and industrialization, aligning with the aspirations of a newly
independent nation.

2000s: Digital Transformation

16
Recognizing the rise of the internet, The Times of India launched its online platform,
TimesofIndia.com, in the early 2000s. This move allowed the paper to expand its global reach
and cater to a tech-savvy audience. The introduction of digital advertising and multimedia
content further enhanced its appeal.

2010s: Multimedia Expansion

During this decade, the company ventured into television, radio, and online platforms,
establishing itself as a multimedia conglomerate. Products like Times Now (news
channel), ET Now (business channel), and Radio Mirchi became household names.

Present Day
Today, The Times of India is India’s largest English-language daily, with a readership
spanning millions. It continues to innovate with cutting-edge technology, engaging
content, and initiatives aimed at social development.

17
1.2.2 Mission
The Times of India’s mission is rooted in providing unbiased, accurate, and relevant news
to its readers while fostering an informed and engaged citizenry. By embracing
technological advancements, the organization aims to bridge the gap between
information dissemination and reader engagement, ensuring its content remains
accessible, impactful, and transformative.

Vision
TOI envisions itself as a global leader in media and communication, committed to
innovation and excellence. Its vision emphasizes leveraging cutting-edge technologies to
expand its reach while preserving the journalistic values of integrity, accountability, and
inclusivity. TOI aspires to empower its audiences by delivering news that resonates,
informs, and inspires action.

Company Objectives
The company’s primary objectives include:
1. Delivering high-quality journalism that informs public discourse.
2. Expanding its digital footprint to cater to the evolving preferences of younger
audiences.
3. Sustaining pro5itability through diversi5ied revenue streams such as digital
subscriptions, events, and advertising.
4. Supporting social causes through impactful campaigns and initiatives, reinforcing
its role as a socially responsible corporate entity.
5. Embracing innovation in content creation, distribution, and audience engagement
to maintain a competitive edge in a rapidly evolving media landscape.

18
1.2.3 Company Products and Services
TOI’s offerings span multiple platforms and formats. The print newspaper remains a
cornerstone of its business, with editions in major cities across India. Its digital
presence is robust, with TOI’s website and mobile app providing real-time news
updates, video content, and interactive features.
Additionally, TOI operates under the Times Group umbrella, which includes other
publications like The Economic Times and Navbharat Times, as well as television channels
like Times Now. Event management is another signi5icant vertical, with TOI organizing
high-pro5ile events like the Times LitFest and Times Food Awards. Through these
diverse offerings, TOI has established itself as a multifaceted media powerhouse.

About The Newspapers

A. The Times of India
Under the ownership of The Times Group, The Times of India (TOI) is a highly regarded
English- language daily newspaper. It ranks as the fourth-largest newspaper in India by
circulation, holding a notable place in the media landscape. Globally, it claims the title of
the largest-selling English-language daily, a recognition endorsed by the Audit Bureau of
Circulations (India).
With a rich historical background, TOI is a testament to India's enduring media tradition.
Originating in 1838, it stands as the oldest English-language newspaper to maintain its
presence in the country. This remarkable legacy is further emphasized by the fact that
The Times of India is the second-oldest Indian newspaper still in circulation, trailing only
the Bombay Samachar in this regard.
As the 20th century dawned, The Times of India garnered considerable praise from Lord
Curzon, who served as the Viceroy of India during that period. He bestowed upon
the newspaper the distinguished title of "the foremost paper in Asia," a testament to
its signi5icant in5luence and standing in the region. This recognition solidi5ied the
newspaper's reputation as a venerable force in the realm of journalism.
In 1991, The Times of India received further validation of its excellence on the
global stage. The BBC, a renowned international broadcasting institution, placed the
newspaper among the world's elite, af5irming its exceptional quality and far-reaching
impact.
In conclusion, The Times of India's enduring legacy, widespread circulation, and
both national and international acclaim emphasize its role as a leading English-language
daily. With its illustrious history spanning back to the 19th century and a trail of
achievements throughout the decades, the newspaper remains a signi5icant contributor to
India's media landscape and a globally recognized source of information and insights.
The Times of India (TOI) is a leading English-language daily newspaper published
in India, renowned as the world's largest circulated English broadsheet newspaper,
with editions across the country reaching millions of readers daily.

Key points about The Times of India:

History:
Founded in 1838 in Mumbai (then Bombay), it is considered the oldest English
newspaper in India, making it a signi5icant part of the country's media landscape.

Publisher:
The Times of India is published by Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd., which is part of The Times
Group, a major Indian media conglomerate.

19
Content Focus:
The newspaper covers a wide range of news topics including national and international
politics, business, sports, entertainment, lifestyle, and local news.

Digital Presence:
Besides its print editions, TOI has a strong online presence with a popular website and
mobile app, providing readers with access to news updates and multimedia content.

Criticisms:
While widely read, the Times of India has sometimes faced criticism for its sensationalist
reporting style and perceived bias towards certain political viewpoints.

B. The Economic Times

Delivered to readers by the esteemed publishing house
Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd., The Economic Times is a notable
English-language daily newspaper. Its inception in 1961 has
marked its ascendancy as a signi5icant player in the arena of
business journalism. This prominence extends globally, positioning it as the second-most
widely read English-language business newspaper across the world. With an impressive
readership exceeding 800,000 individuals, it stands second only to the Wall Street
Journal in this specialized domain.
Operating within a network encompassing 12 cities, The Economic Times ensures a
simultaneous presence in major urban centers. These cities include Mumbai, Bangalore,
Delhi, Chennai, Kolkata, Lucknow, Hyderabad, Jaipur, Ahmedabad, Nagpur,
Chandigarh, and Pune. The newspaper's headquarters is located in the vibrant city of
Mumbai, nestled within The Times of India building. The crux of The Economic Times'
content revolves around the multifaceted landscape of the Indian economy. It offers
insights into international 5inance, share prices, commodity prices, and a comprehensive
range of 5inancial matters. This comprehensive coverage caters to professionals,
enthusiasts, and decision-makers keen on staying abreast of economic and 5inancial
developments.

Commencing its journey in 1961, The Economic Times found its initial direction
under the guidance of its founding editor, PS Hariharan. He played a pivotal role in shaping
its early trajectory. Currently, the editorial helm is skillfully managed by Bodhisattva
Ganguli, who holds the position of the newspaper's current editor.
In summation, The Economic Times holds a pivotal role as a critical conduit of business
information, offering a glimpse into the dynamic realm of commerce and 5inance. With
its extensive readership and widespread presence across cities in India, it continues to
provide valuable insights to a diverse audience, thus impacting business decisions and
nurturing well-informed viewpoints on economic affairs.
Key points about The Economic Times:
Focus on Business:
The primary focus of the newspaper is on business news, including stock market trends,
company performance, mergers and acquisitions, policy changes impacting businesses,
and economic indicators.

Wide Reach:

20
Published across major Indian cities, the ET reaches a large audience of business
professionals, investors, entrepreneurs, and policymakers.

Digital Presence:
Besides print publication, ET has a strong online presence with a comprehensive website
and mobile app, offering real-time updates, market data, and exclusive articles.

ET Prime:
A premium subscription service on the ET platform providing in-depth analysis, expert
opinions, and exclusive research reports on various business sectors.
Notable Features:
• Market Watch: Detailed coverage of stock market movements, including analysis of
key indices and individual stocks.
• Industry Reports: In-depth analysis of speci5ic sectors like technology, healthcare,
automobiles, and real estate.
• Leadership Interviews: Exclusive interviews with prominent business leaders and
policymakers.
• Personal Finance: Articles on personal investment strategies, 5inancial planning, and tax
matters.

History:
• Launched in 1961, The Economic Times quickly established itself as a leading
business news source in India.
• It is part of The Times Group, which also publishes the widely read general news
publication, The Times of India.

C. Nav-Bharat Times (NBT)

Nav-bharat Times (NBT) is one of the largest
circulated as well as largest read Hindi newspapers of
Delhi and Mumbai and Lucknow. It is from the stable
of Bennett Coleman & Co. Ltd (BCCL).
Nav-Bharat Times (NBT), a prominent publication within the Bennett Coleman & Co.
Ltd (BCCL) consortium, holds a notable position as one of the foremost players in the
realm of Hindi newspapers. This publication boasts an expansive distribution network,
ensuring its wide availability across key urban centers such as Delhi, Mumbai, and
Lucknow. The newspaper's in5luence is underscored by its signi5icant readership,
capturing the attention of a diverse and widespread audience.
NBT's af5iliation with the reputable media conglomerate BCCL not only emphasizes its
substantial reach but also speaks to its commitment to quality journalism and meaningful
content. As part of BCCL's portfolio, NBT aligns itself with a lineage of media
excellence and innovation.

In Delhi, Mumbai, and Lucknow, NBT's presence is keenly felt, with its pages reaching
households, businesses, and individuals who seek reliable and informative news in the
Hindi language. This extensive circulation is a testament to NBT's relevance and
resonance with readers from various walks of life.

21
Subsidiaries Of Times Group

A. Times Internet Limited:

Times Internet is an Indian company that owns, operates and invests in various Internet-
led products, services and technology. It is the digital arm of the Times Group, one of the
largest media and entertainment companies in India.
Time Internet currently owns and operates 39+ digital products across news, sports,
music, video, trivia, spirituality & a suite of transaction-led market-places across real
estate, personal 5inance, education, jobs, table reservation, personal concierge etc.
Time Internet reaches over 270 million unique monthly visitors who collectively
spent over 10 billion minutes across all its products and services.

B. Times Music:
Times Music was established in 1998 under the leadership of Arun Arora, who was then
the President and Executive Director of The Times of India and Times Global
Broadcasting Co. Ltd. In 2000, the Indian music industry was ruled by Bollywood and
International Music. The intent of the label was to create albums tailored to appeal to the
discerning audience, which resulted in Times Music the concepts of spiritual, world and
remix music in India.
Times Music, a division of The Times Group, is an Indian record label and music publisher.
Headquartered in Mumbai, Times Music started operations in 1998[2] and has a
catalogue of more than 21,000 tracks. Times Music is also the Indian sub-publisher
for global music publishing 5irms Warner/Chappell Music and Peer music.[3] Times
Music was one of the early pioneers of remixes[4] in India and was an early leader in
the devotional and spiritual music genre. The label has also published regional, folk,
Bollywood and traditional albums in languages such as Punjabi, Bengali, Gujarati,
and Kannada, and has a strong regional presence.

C. Times Business Solution Limited:

Times Business Solutions (TBS) – a division of Times Internet Limited – the ―Life
Interactive arm of the Times Group, provides global internet users interactive media to
provide support, assistance, and guidance throughout their life

TimesJobs.com is TBS‘s 5lagship business and has been in

existence since 2004 and has established a strong competitive position in the online
recruitments space amidst tough competition.

SimplyMarry.com has been in operations since 2007 and

was adjudged having with the best practices of any matrimonial site in a recent study of
121 most popular websites in the country by independent online research 5irm
JuxtConsult. In the same study, all three of our websites were adjudged as among the
―Most User-Friendly‖ websites in the country.

22
 Ads2Book.com is the only ―Net to Print‖ publication neutral,
global booking engine, where users can log on and book print classi5ied ads In over
10 partner publications and 800 editions.

D. Dineout:
Dineout is a restaurant table reservation service company founded in
2012 by Ankit Mehrotra, Vivek Kapoor, Nikhil Bakshi and Sahil Jain based
in New Delhi, India.
Since its acquisition by Times Internet Ltd in 2014 (then Times City),
Dineout claims to have grown over 200%. According to the company, it
provides online reservations for about 3,500 restaurants around the
country and serves over 500K diners a month (as of 23 September 2016)
across 8 cities. Reservations can be made online through its website, the
Android and iOS Application, or their concierge desk.

Dine out also launched a product division called Dineout Plus primarily
targeting the Premium Dining Section. It entitles annual subscribers to a
25% discount at over 300 five- star restaurants.

E. World Wide Media Private Limited:

Born in 2005 with like minded group of promoters with successful businesses in the
Indian media and 5ilm landscape, Celebrities Management & Shree Venkatesh Films
provided the right environment for Media Worldwide Network. In a media landscape of
over 800 television channels, the company has managed to grow and sustain the ups and
downs of several economic turmoil known to us in recent times.

F. Times Guaranty Limited:

Times Guaranty Limited (Earlier known as Times Guaranty Finance Limited
Incorporated on 27th November 1989, received the certi5icate of commencement of
business on 04th December 1989 and became active in February, 1990.
Times Guaranty Limited is promoted by Bennett Coleman and Company Ltd. (BCCL)
who are the proprietors of The Times of India group of publications. BCCL has been in
the publishing business for over 170 years and has come to acquire a reputation for
reporting credible, analysed and unbiased news. The 5lagship daily of the company The
Times of India has been recognised by BBC as one of the six most in5luential dailies of
the world. The other well known publications of the group are The Economic Times,
Navbharat Times, Femina and Film fare.‘

G. Times Innovative Media Private Ltd.:

Established in 2005, Times OOH has emerged as the undisputed leader in the Indian
outdoor Advertising industry. Our success stems from the ability to provide a
national network of comprehensive and customized. Out-of Home (OOH) solutions to
advertisers, giving them the 5lexibility to target mass as well as niche segments.
1.5 million consumers daily.

H. Times Publishing House Limited:

Times Publishing House Limited provides newspaper publishing services. The company
was founded in 1983 and is based in New Delhi, India. Times Publishing House Limited
operates as a subsidiary of Bennett Coleman & Co Ltd.

23
 I. Times Infotainment Media Limited:
Times Infotainment Media Ltd. operates as a media company. The company handles
marketing, 5ilm, and radio rights. Times Infotainment Media Ltd. was incorporated
in 2002 and is based in Mumbai, India. The company operates as a subsidiary of
Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd.

J. The Times Global Broadcasting Co. Ltd:

Times Global Broadcasting Company Limited is a Public incorporated on 13 June 1986.
It is classi5ied as Non-govt company and is registered at Registrar of Companies,
Mumbai. Its authorized share capital is Rs.
2,849,999,870 and its paid up capital is Rs. 644,339,260.It is involved in Manufacture of
electronic valves and tubes and other electronic Components.

K. Zoom Tv Channel:
The channel was launched in September 2004 and caters primarily to urban audiences. It
started out as a music/Bollywood/serial channel, but quickly pulled serials off the air,
becoming a music and Bollywood news channel within months. It is a part of The Times
Group, one of India's largest media conglomerates. An internet pioneer, it has been
available on mobile internet since March 2009. Zoom is available across 60 countries
worldwide along with a digital presence.

Editions And Publications Of The Times Of India

The Times of India is published by the media group Bennett, Coleman C

Co. Ltd. The company, along with its other group of companies, known as
The Times Group, also publishes Ahmedabad Mirror Bangalore Mirror;
Bangalore Times, Delhi Times: The Economic Times; ET Panache (Mumbai,
Delhi Bengaluru on Monday to Friday and as Times of India ET Panache in
Pune and Chennai, Every Saturday Ei Samay, (a Bengali daily); the
Maharashtra Times, (a Marathi language daily broadsheet); Mumba Mirror;
the Navbharat Times, (a Hindi-language daily broadsheet); and Pune
Mirror.

The Times of India has its markets in major cities such as Mumbai,
Ahmedabad, Allahabad, Aurangabad, Bangalore, Bhopal, Bhubaneswar,
Calicut, Chandigarh, Chennai, Coimbatore, Delhi, Guwahati Hubli, Hyderabad,
Indore, Jaipur, Kochi, Kolhapur, Kolkata, Lucknow, Madurai, Mangalore,
Mysore Nagpur, Nashik, Panaji, Patna, Puducherry, Pune, Raipur, Ranchi,
Surat, Trichy, Trivandrum, Varanasi Vijayawada and Visakhapatnam.

The Times of India (TOI) is published by Bennett, Coleman C Co. Ltd., a media
group that also publishes other newspapers and magazines:

The Economic Times: The world's second largest circulating English business
Daily Navbharat Times: A Hindi-language daily broadsheet
Maharashtra Times: A Marathi-language daily broadsheet Ei Samay: A Bengali
daily
Mumbai Mirror: A newspaper Bangalore Mirror: A newspaper Pune Mirror: A
newspaper
24
ET Panache: A publication that appears in Mumbai, Delhi, and Bangalore
Monday to Friday, and in Pune and Chennai on Saturday

The Times Group, which includes Bennett, Coleman C Co. Ltd., is a leading
media conglomerate in India that also offers internet services and
entertainment.

25
1.2.4 Michael Porter's Five Forces Model

1. Threat of New Entrants

1.1 Barriers to Entry:
 High Barriers (Print Model): The print newspaper industry requires signi5icant
investment in infrastructure, including printing presses, distribution networks,
and editorial teams. For example, The Times of India has a nationwide distribution
network and large-scale production capabilities that are not easy to replicate.
 Brand Recognition and Loyalty: Established newspapers like The Times of India
have decades of brand history, loyalty, and authority in the market, making it
dif5icult for new entrants to gain a foothold. The audience trusts the credibility of
established players, which adds another layer of entry barrier.
 Government Regulations: Newspapers are subject to regulatory requirements,
which can be a barrier for new entrants. The Press Council of India and other
bodies monitor content and ensure compliance with ethical standards, which
can add complexity and cost for new newspapers.

1.2 Digital Media (Lower Barriers):

 Low Barriers for Digital-Only News: The emergence of digital news platforms
has lowered the entry barriers. New entrants in the form of blogs, online news
platforms, or smaller digital startups can enter the market with limited capital.
They can reach audiences via social media, mobile apps, and websites at a fraction
of the cost of traditional print operations.
 Audience Reach: Social media platforms, such as Facebook, Twitter, and
Instagram, allow anyone to create and distribute news content to a wide audience,
providing an easy alternative to traditional newspapers. This digital shift
intensi5ies competition and makes it easier for new entrants to disrupt the
market.
 Cost of Entry: Starting a digital news website or app involves much lower
costs compared to a traditional print newspaper, which requires investment in
presses, paper, distribution, etc.

26
1.3 Impact of New Entrants:
 The threat of new entrants is moderate in the print segment but high in the
digital space. Traditional newspapers like The Times of India face pressure
from these new, more agile digital competitors.

2. Bargaining Power of Suppliers

2.1 Print Media Suppliers:
 Raw Materials: For traditional newspapers, key suppliers include paper
manufacturers, ink suppliers, and printing press operators. The number of
suppliers in this space can be limited, and if these suppliers increase their
prices, it can impact the pro5itability of print newspapers.
 Technology and Equipment: Suppliers of printing machinery, digital
infrastructure, and software are also important. For example, the cost of
maintaining printing presses and digital systems for content management can
be signi5icant.
 Moderate Supplier Power: Although the paper and ink suppliers do have some
degree of bargaining power, large players like The Times of India generally have
multiple suppliers and bulk purchasing power, which reduces their individual
bargaining leverage.

2.2 Digital Media Suppliers:

 Technology Providers: For digital operations, newspapers rely on software
providers, website hosting services, cloud storage, and data analytics tools.
The power of technology suppliers is moderate because there are numerous
options available in the market.
 Content Suppliers: For digital news, external content providers or journalists
may have bargaining power, especially if they are known for high-quality
reporting. Newspapers may depend on top journalists, columnists, or news
agencies like Reuters or AFP for speci5ic content.

2.3 Impact of Supplier Power:

 Overall, supplier power in the newspaper industry is moderate. Traditional
print suppliers may hold some leverage, but established players like The Times of
India can negotiate favourable terms. In the digital space, competition among
suppliers of technology and content reduces their individual bargaining power.

3. Bargaining Power of Buyers

3.1 Consumers (Readers):
 High Consumer Power: Readers have signi5icant bargaining power in both
print and digital formats. The internet has made information readily available to
anyone with an internet connection, leading to abundant free alternatives.
Traditional newspapers face competition from online-only platforms, blogs, and
social media, all of which are often free or low-cost.
 Price Sensitivity: The cost of digital subscriptions is low compared to print
subscriptions. With the rise of free news sources, consumers can easily switch
from one news source to another. Many readers are reluctant to pay for digital
news, leading to a decrease in newspaper subscriptions.

27
  Access to Alternatives: There are plenty of free or low-cost alternatives to
traditional newspapers. People can get breaking news on social media,
through blogs, or on news apps, all of which often don’t require a
subscription.

3.2 Advertisers:
 High Power of Advertisers: Advertisers, which are a primary revenue source
for newspapers, also hold bargaining power. With digital platforms like Google
and Facebook commanding a large share of advertising budgets, traditional
newspapers face challenges in maintaining advertising revenue. Advertisers can
choose where they allocate their budgets, and digital ads offer more precise
targeting and often a better return on investment.

3.3 Impact of Buyer Power:

 The bargaining power of both readers and advertisers is high. Readers can
easily 5ind alternative news sources, and advertisers are shifting to digital platforms
with more targeted advertising opportunities.

4. Threat of Substitute Products or Services

4.1 Digital News:
 High Threat of Substitutes: Digital news platforms are the biggest threat to
traditional print newspapers. Platforms like Google News, Flipboard, and
social media news feeds provide real-time, free news that is accessible on-
demand. People are moving away from print newspapers to consume content
on smartphones, tablets, and desktops.
 Social Media and Blogs: Social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook
have become primary sources for breaking news. Blogs and online forums also
provide alternative viewpoints and more niche content, further eroding the
traditional newspaper audience.

4.2 TV and Streaming Platforms:

 High Threat from TV News: News channels and streaming services (like
YouTube News) present a strong substitute to traditional newspapers, providing
live, real- time updates. These platforms can reach audiences immediately and
provide video content, which newspapers can’t replicate.

4.3 Impact of Substitutes:

 The threat of substitutes is very high in the media industry. Digital and social
media platforms have signi5icantly increased the availability of free news and
reduced the need for traditional print media.

5. Industry Rivalry
5.1 High Competition Among Traditional Newspapers:
 Newspapers like The Times of India, The Hindu, Hindustan Times, Economic
Times, and Indian Express all compete for the same audience and advertising
revenue. This rivalry is particularly intense in metro cities, where there are
multiple players in the same market.
 Price Wars: As print circulation declines, many newspapers resort to
offering discounted subscriptions or even free content to maintain readership,
leading to price competition.

28
  Differentiation: To stand out, newspapers are increasingly focusing on
digital transformation, offering interactive websites, apps, and multimedia
content to attract readers. However, this has also intensi5ied competition in the
online space, where new digital-only competitors are emerging rapidly.

5.2 Online-Only News Platforms:

 As more readers switch to online platforms, traditional newspapers are competing
with new entrants like Scroll, The Wire, HuffPost India, and various news
apps. These digital platforms often provide news with a faster turnaround,
lower cost, and more personalized content for users.

5.3 Impact of Rivalry:

 Rivalry in the newspaper industry is high, with intense competition in both
print and digital formats. Established newspapers face challenges from new
digital players, and the competition for advertising dollars is 5ierce as more
advertisers move online.

Summary

In conclusion, applying Porter’s Five Forces to the newspaper segment of the media
industry, especially for a major player like The Times of India, reveals several challenges:

 Threat of New Entrants: Moderate to high in the digital space.

 Bargaining Power of Suppliers: Moderate, with suppliers holding some
power in print but less in digital.
 Bargaining Power of Buyers: High, as readers have many free alternatives,
and advertisers have numerous options for ad placement.
 Threat of Substitutes: Very high, especially from digital news, social media, and
TV news.
 Industry Rivalry: Very high, with intense competition from both
traditional newspapers and emerging digital-only platforms.

29
1.2.5 SWOT Analysis

Strengths:

1. Brand Recognition:
 The Times of India is a household name with decades of brand history, which
gives it a significant competitive edge. It has a vast, loyal readership base
across India and internationally.
 It has been a leader in the Indian newspaper industry for decades, and its brand
is associated with credibility, in-depth news, and high-quality journalism.

2. Strong Distribution Network:

 The newspaper has an extensive physical and digital distribution network,
ensuring wide reach in both urban and rural areas. This helps in targeting
diverse audience groups across the country.

3. High-Quality Content:
 The Times of India offers diverse content, from national and international news
to entertainment, sports, lifestyle, and business. Its editorial quality and variety
have helped retain readers across different segments.

4. Digital Transformation:
 The newspaper has successfully adapted to the digital age with its online
presence, including the Times of India website and mobile app. This digital
push has helped it reach a younger audience, keeping pace with the decline of
traditional print media.
 It has also ventured into video content, podcasts, and other multimedia
formats, allowing it to diversify its content delivery.

5. Revenue from Multiple Sources:

 The newspaper generates revenue from print subscriptions, digital
subscriptions, advertising (both print and digital), and events. This diversified
revenue model provides stability even amid changes in media consumption
habits.

Weaknesses:

1. Decline in Print Circulation:

 Like many traditional newspapers, The Times of India has seen a decline in
print circulation as more people shift to online news platforms. This trend
poses a long-term challenge for the print business model.

2. Dependence on Advertising Revenue:

 A large portion of its revenue comes from advertising, which is highly
sensitive to economic conditions. In times of economic downturn, advertising
spending typically declines, affecting the newspaper’s revenue.
 Digital advertising, particularly on social media platforms like Facebook and
Google, is increasingly competing for the same advertising dollars.

30
 3. Perception of Sensationalism:

 Some critics have accused The Times of India of sensationalism and

prioritizing clickbait content, particularly in its entertainment and celebrity
sections. This can sometimes affect its credibility among discerning readers.

4. High Operational Costs (Print Model):

 Operating a large-scale print newspaper involves high costs in terms of paper,
ink, distribution, and printing. As print circulation declines, these fixed costs
remain a significant burden on profitability.

Opportunities:

1. Expanding Digital Audience:

 As digital media continues to grow, The Times of India has the opportunity to
further expand its digital readership through enhanced content, better user
experience on its digital platforms, and more targeted digital marketing
strategies.
 The shift towards mobile news consumption presents an opportunity to
enhance its app experience and monetize mobile advertising.

2. Paid Subscription Models:

 There is an opportunity to boost its paid subscription model by offering
exclusive, premium content such as in-depth reports, behind-the-scenes
stories, and expert opinions. This model could help mitigate the decline in
print subscriptions.

3. Video and Multimedia Content:

 With the rise of video content consumption, there is an opportunity to grow its
presence in the video and multimedia segments. Expanding its news video
channels or offering live video reporting could attract a wider audience.

4. Strategic Partnerships and Collaborations:

 The Times of India can explore partnerships with digital platforms, news
aggregators, and even other media outlets to increase content reach and
diversify its content offerings (e.g., co-branded podcasts, special
reports).

5. Focus on Local and Regional Content:

 Expanding its focus on regional and localized content could attract more
readers, especially in tier-2 and tier-3 cities. These regions are growing in
terms of digital penetration and could become key targets for both print and
digital editions.

Threats:

1. Intense Competition from Digital Media:

 The rise of digital-only news platforms such as Scroll.in, The Wire, HuffPost
India, and even global outlets like BBC and CNN is a serious threat to The

31
 Times of India's dominance. These platforms can offer faster, free news, often
with a focus on breaking stories and niche topics that attract younger
audiences.
 Social media platforms (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.) also provide
instant news updates and a space for user-generated content, further
diminishing the need for traditional newspaper sources.

2. Declining Print Revenue:

 Print advertising revenue is on the decline, as businesses increasingly turn to
digital advertising due to its cost-effectiveness and targeting capabilities.
Newspapers like The Times of India must find new ways to monetize print
editions as print ad revenue shrinks.

3. Changing Consumer Preferences:

 Younger generations prefer digital news consumption, often in shorter, more
interactive formats (e.g., Twitter threads, Instagram stories). This shift poses a
challenge for traditional newspapers, which are often perceived as slow and
more formal.

4. Fake News and Misinformation:

 The rise of fake news and misinformation on digital platforms is a growing
concern. While The Times of India is a trusted news source, maintaining
credibility in a time of rampant misinformation on social media is increasingly
difficult.

5. Economic Volatility:
 Economic slowdowns, such as recessions, directly impact advertising budgets,
which are essential for generating revenue for newspapers. Reduced ad
spending can hurt both print and digital revenue streams.

32
1.2.6 Distribution Structure of The Times of India

The distribution structure of The Times of India (TOI) is an extensive, well-organized

process designed to ensure timely delivery of the newspaper to millions of readers
across urban and rural areas. The 5lowchart provides a visual representation of how
the newspaper reaches its 5inal audience. Here’s a detailed breakdown of each step
in the structure:

1. Printing Press
The distribution process begins at TOI’s printing presses, which are strategically
located across the country. These printing presses are responsible for:
 Printing newspapers based on region-specific editions (e.g., Delhi Times,
Bombay Times).
 Meeting high-volume requirements to produce millions of copies daily.
 Aligning with strict deadlines to ensure timely delivery for the morning
readership.
The newspapers are sorted based on their destination and packed for transportation.

2. Depots and Agents

Once the newspapers are printed, they are transported to depots and agents, which
serve as intermediate distribution hubs.
a. Depots
 Depots act as storage and redistribution centers.
 Located in various zones, they ensure that newspapers are distributed to local
vendors in a specific geographical area.
b. Agents
 Agents are intermediaries who take bulk copies from the printing press and
distribute them to vendors within their allocated zones.
 They act as the link between the printing press and vendors, ensuring smooth
transportation and allocation.
Agents and depots work in tandem to facilitate quick distribution, minimizing delays.

3. Vendors
Vendors play a crucial role in the last-mile delivery of newspapers. They collect
newspapers from depots or agents and prepare them for distribution. Their
responsibilities include:
 Sorting newspapers according to delivery routes and customer orders.
 Ensuring the correct number of copies reach the intended recipients.
 Managing relationships with both agents and the final delivery personnel (beat
boys).

4. Beat Boys and Newspaper Stands

The vendors distribute newspapers through two primary channels:
a. Beat Boys
 Beat boys are delivery personnel who are responsible for door-to-door
distribution.

33
  They deliver newspapers directly to subscribers, ensuring timely and convenient
delivery (usually early morning).
 Beat boys often use bicycles, motorcycles, or walk their routes to cover specific
neighborhoods.
b. Newspaper Stands
 Vendors also supply newspapers to local newspaper stands, kiosks, and
retail outlets.
 This channel caters to individuals who prefer to purchase newspapers from public
points of sale rather than subscribing.
Both channels together provide comprehensive coverage, ensuring the availability of
newspapers across all demographics.

5. Readers
The final stage in the distribution process is the readers, who are the end consumers.
They receive newspapers through two means:
 Direct Delivery: Subscribers receive their copies at their homes or offices via beat
boys.
 Retail Purchase: Non-subscribers can purchase newspapers from
newspaper stands or retail outlets.
TOI ensures that both distribution methods work seamlessly to meet the demands of
readers from diverse regions and backgrounds.

Features of the Distribution Structure

a. Extensive Reach
 TOI’s distribution network covers urban, semi-urban, and rural areas,
making it one of the most far-reaching newspaper networks in India.
b. Regional Customization
 Regional editions like Navbharat Times (Hindi), Maharashtra Times (Marathi),
and others help cater to the linguistic and cultural preferences of different regions.
c. Early Morning Deliveries
 The structure is designed to ensure newspapers reach readers early in the
morning, making it a critical part of the daily routine for many.
d. Efficient Logistics
 The network employs optimized logistics, including trucks, trains, and local
delivery vehicles, to ensure timely distribution across vast distances.
e. Technology Integration
 The use of modern technology, such as route optimization tools and demand
forecasting, helps streamline the process, reducing waste and enhancing
efficiency.

Challenges in Distribution
Despite its efficiency, TOI faces several challenges:
 Rising Costs: Increasing printing and fuel costs strain profitability.
 Logistics Management: Coordinating a vast network in a geographically
diverse country is complex.
 Digital Disruption: The shift to digital media consumption is reducing
demand for physical newspapers.
 Weather and External Factors: Monsoons or political disturbances can
disrupt delivery timelines.

34
35
 CHAPTER - 2:
LITERATURE REVIEW

36
The literature review for The Times of India (TOI) focuses on the evolution of the
newspaper within the broader context of the Indian media industry, exploring its
historical signi5icance, organizational strategies, and the transition to digital media.
Through an examination of scholarly research, industry reports, and case studies, this
review aims to provide a detailed understanding of TOI’s role in shaping the media
landscape, the challenges it faces, and its adaptive strategies.

2.1 Evolution of The Times of India

The Times of India, one of the oldest English-language newspapers in India, was founded
in 1838 under the name The Bombay Times and Journal of Commerce. It began as a colonial
publication but gradually became an important voice in India’s freedom struggle and
in shaping modern Indian society. Numerous studies highlight TOI’s role as a
pioneer in print journalism, not only in India but also in the larger context of British
colonialism’s in5luence on Indian media. The transition from print to digital has been a
signi5icant phase in TOI’s evolution. Research by McChesney (2007) on the impact of digital
technology on the media industry shows that TOI has had to adapt to the digital age
while maintaining its stronghold as a print leader. This shift is re5lected in TOI’s online
presence, its mobile app, and its digital subscription services.

Studies have pointed out that TOI’s digital transformation was imperative for staying
relevant in an increasingly digital-5irst media environment. According to an article
by Sinha (2020), The Times of India made a signi5icant push towards digital by launching
its e-paper and mobile app, which provided a platform for younger, tech-savvy readers who
prefer accessing news on mobile devices. This shift mirrored the broader industry
trend of declining print subscriptions and rising digital media consumption, a challenge
faced by all traditional media outlets in the country.

37
2.2 Consumer Behaviour and Audience Engagement
Consumer behaviour in the media sector, particularly regarding print and digital
news consumption, has shifted dramatically over the past decade. As noted by Kumar
(2017), there is a growing preference for digital news consumption among the
younger demographic, especially with the rise of smartphones and the internet. Research by
PwC (2018) highlights that the proliferation of mobile devices and affordable internet
has resulted in a major transformation in how audiences engage with news content. Younger
readers tend to Favor real-time updates, multimedia content, and interactive
platforms, which is where TOI’s online presence has seen growth.

Additionally, there has been a rising demand for regional content due to India's diverse
linguistic landscape. The Times of India, with its regional editions in Hindi, Marathi, and
other languages, has responded to this demand, which has helped it maintain relevance
among local readers. The Times of India's regional expansion is an important strategic
move, as it allows the brand to cater to various linguistic and cultural groups, thereby
broadening its reach and audience base. According to a report by Bhushan and Gupta
(2019), this regionalization strategy has been instrumental in TOI's attempt to balance
national and local content.

Moreover, audience engagement on social media platforms has also in5luenced

TOI’s content strategy. According to a study by Taneja (2019), TOI’s integration of social
media channels into its content distribution model allows it to interact directly with readers
and engage them in real-time discussions. This engagement also enables TOI to track
audience preferences, adapt content based on real-time feedback, and increase its digital
footprint.

38
2.3 Organizational Strategy and Business Model
The business model of The Times of India has evolved considerably, from relying
primarily on print subscriptions and advertising to embracing digital revenue streams.
The digital transformation of TOI involved shifting from a traditional advertising model
to a more diverse strategy, including digital subscriptions, targeted online ads, and
partnerships with digital platforms like Google and Facebook. Research by Dube (2015)
emphasizes that TOI’s adoption of paywalls through TOI+ is a key component of its
strategy to generate revenue from premium content. The paid subscription model has
become increasingly popular as traditional advertising revenues in print media have
declined.

TOI’s organizational strategies have focused on diversifying content and platforms.

TOI’s successful integration of multimedia, including video, infographics, and podcasts,
into its digital platforms re5lects the broader media industry's shift towards multimedia
content. Research by Chandrasekar (2018) discusses how media houses like TOI are
investing in technology and digital infrastructure to create a seamless experience for
users across platforms, whether it’s mobile, tablet, or desktop. This strategic
diversi5ication allows TOI to capture a wider audience while adapting to changing
consumption habits.

Additionally, TOI’s emphasis on social responsibility through campaigns like Lead

India, Save Water, and others has been well-documented in literature. According to
research by Wang (2019), these initiatives enhance TOI’s brand image, appeal to the
public's social consciousness, and promote public service in an impactful manner. These
campaigns contribute to TOI's positive public perception and distinguish it from
competitors, making it more than just a source of news, but also a driver of social
change.

39
2.4 The Role of Digital Media in The Times of India’s Transformation
The digital revolution has posed both challenges and opportunities for traditional media
outlets like The Times of India. Research by Jenkins (2006) on participatory culture and
user-generated content highlights how the rise of social media platforms has shifted
power from traditional media outlets to consumers. This transformation has forced
TOI to adapt its content delivery and business models. The launch of TOI’s e-paper and
digital platforms allowed it to reach a more tech-savvy audience, bridging the gap
between traditional print media and the growing digital audience.

A study by Sinha (2020) on the impact of social media on traditional media highlights
how TOI has capitalized on social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, and
Instagram to distribute news and engage with its audience. These platforms have become
essential tools for driving traf5ic to TOI’s website, fostering real-time discussions, and
enhancing user interaction. TOI’s digital strategy integrates a blend of both paid and
organic content on social media, positioning it as a dynamic, interactive news outlet.

40
2.5 Future Outlook and Strategic Adaptations
As the media industry continues to evolve, The Times of India must navigate several
challenges, including increasing competition from digital-5irst media outlets and
changing reader preferences. Research by Sahu (2020) emphasizes that the future of
traditional media, particularly print, lies in adopting hybrid models that combine both
digital and print to maximize reach. The success of TOI’s subscription model, along with
its strategy to invest in arti5icial intelligence and data analytics for personalized
content delivery, positions it to be at the forefront of the digital media revolution in
India.

Studies also indicate that with the growing prominence of regional content and
vernacular media, TOI’s continued investment in these areas will be critical for its long-
term success. Regional content, particularly localized news, is expected to be a signi5icant
growth area for TOI as it seeks to expand its readership beyond metropolitan cities
and tap into smaller towns and rural areas.

2.6 Gaps in Literature and Areas for Further Research

While substantial literature exists on the media industry’s transition to digital platforms,
there are areas that require further investigation. The sustainability of hybrid business
models, particularly in markets like India, needs further exploration. The challenges and
opportunities of integrating vernacular content into mainstream media are also under-
researched. Moreover, the long-term impact of social media on the credibility and
in5luence of traditional media outlets like The Times of India remains an open area
for inquiry.

41
CHAPTER 3: RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY

42
This chapter provides an in-depth explanation of the research methodology used to
analyse the membership renewal process at The Times of India. The aim of the research
was to explore the factors in5luencing membership renewals, identify strategies to
improve the renewal rate, and analyse the overall effectiveness of current membership
renewal practices.

3.1 DeLine Research Problem

The primary research problem addressed in this study revolves around identifying the
key factors affecting membership renewals at The Times of India (TOI). Speci5ically, the
research focuses on the following questions:
 What are the primary factors that lead to non-renewal of memberships at The
Times of India?
 How effective are the current strategies employed by TOI to encourage
membership renewal?
 What role do customer satisfaction, engagement, and personalized services play
in the renewal process?
 How can TOI improve its membership renewal rate through targeted
strategies? The problem is critical as understanding the drivers of membership renewal can
help TOI increase its revenue, retain loyal customers, and improve its brand value.
Furthermore, the 5indings can guide TOI to adjust its strategies and offer better
customer-centric solutions.

43
3.2 Research Design
For this research, a descriptive and analytical research design was adopted, aimed
at exploring the factors in5luencing membership renewal and evaluating the effectiveness
of renewal strategies. The research design has several key components:
 Exploratory Phase: The initial phase involved reviewing existing literature
on membership retention strategies in the media industry and identifying
common factors contributing to membership renewal challenges. It also included
analysing TOI's internal documents, reports, and data related to previous
membership renewal campaigns.
 Descriptive and Analytical Approach: The research adopts a mix of
qualitative and quantitative methods to describe the current state of
membership renewals at TOI. Quantitative data is collected through surveys,
while qualitative insights are derived from interviews with key stakeholders, such
as customers and TOI staff. This combination allows for an in-depth
understanding of renewal trends, customer preferences, and potential
improvements.
 Comparative Analysis: A comparison of TOI’s renewal strategies with those of
other media organizations and membership-based services was undertaken to
highlight best practices and potential areas for improvement.

44
3.3 Sample Design
The sample design is crucial in ensuring that the data collected represents the
relevant population, which includes both TOI members and non-members who may
have previously considered renewing their subscriptions.

 Target Population: The research focuses on the following segments:

1. Existing Members: Individuals who currently have active memberships
with TOI.
2. Lapsed Members: Subscribers whose memberships have expired and
have not renewed.
3. Prospective Members: Individuals who have been in contact with
TOI about membership or were part of promotional campaigns.

 Sampling Method: A stratiLied random sampling technique was employed to

ensure that each segment (existing members, lapsed members, and prospective
members) is proportionally represented. This sampling technique ensures that
the study captures the experiences and opinions of all relevant customer
groups.

 Sample Size: A total of 500 participants were targeted for the survey, which
included:
o 200 existing members,
o 150 lapsed members,
o 150 prospective members.

The sample size is considered large enough to provide statistically signi5icant results and
insights.
 Data Collection Methods:
o Surveys: A structured questionnaire was used to gather quantitative data
from the members and non-members. The survey includes questions
related to customer satisfaction, reasons for non-renewal, engagement
levels, and the effectiveness of communication.
o Interviews: In-depth interviews were conducted with TOI's internal staff,
including membership managers and marketing teams, to gain insights into
the company’s current membership renewal strategies, challenges, and
proposed solutions.

45
3.4 Formulation of Hypothesis
Based on the research problem, several hypotheses were formulated to test the various
factors affecting membership renewal at The Times of India.

1. H1: The lack of personalized communication is a major factor contributing to the

non-renewal of memberships at The Times of India.
o Rationale: Research indicates that personalized experiences, such as
tailored communication and offers, are crucial in increasing customer
retention. This hypothesis will be tested by comparing the renewal rates of
members who received personalized renewal reminders versus those who
did not.

2. H2: A high level of customer satisfaction with TOI’s services leads to a higher
likelihood of membership renewal.
o Rationale: Customer satisfaction is often correlated with renewal intent.
This hypothesis will be tested by analyzing survey responses about
satisfaction levels and renewal intentions.

3. H3: The introduction of loyalty rewards or exclusive offers for existing members
increases the membership renewal rate at The Times of India.
o Rationale: Offering loyalty rewards or exclusive perks is known to
incentivize renewals. This hypothesis will be tested by evaluating the
effectiveness of any ongoing loyalty programs or special offers that TOI
may have implemented.

4. H4: The frequency and timing of membership renewal reminders have a

direct impact on the renewal rate at TOI.
o Rationale: Timely and well-structured reminders are crucial for
encouraging renewals. This hypothesis will be tested by examining
renewal rates during different times of the year and assessing the timing
and frequency of reminder communication.

46
 CHAPTER 4:
DEVELOPMENT OF
QUESTIONNAIRE
AND DATA
COLLECTION

47
This chapter elaborates on the development of the questionnaire used for gathering
data and the methodology employed to collect, analyze, and interpret the data. The
objective was to ensure that the research process was thorough, effective, and
provided valuable insights into the membership renewal process at The Times of
India (TOI). The questionnaire design, selection of data sources, and the overall data
collection methodology are described in this section.

4.1 Types of Questionnaire Used

In order to comprehensively address the research problem and collect actionable data,
two types of questionnaires were developed: structured questionnaires and semi-
structured questionnaires. These two types of questionnaires served different
purposes in the data collection process and helped capture a range of insights, from
quantitative data that could be statistically analyzed to qualitative insights that provided
deeper understanding.
 Structured Questionnaire:
o The structured questionnaire was designed to collect quantitative data
from a large number of participants. The purpose of using structured
questions was to ensure uniformity in responses and to simplify the
process of data analysis. This questionnaire consisted mostly of
closed- ended questions, allowing respondents to choose from prede5ined
answer options.
o The key focus of the structured questionnaire was to assess patterns,
preferences, and behaviors related to membership renewals. It also
aimed to understand the factors in5luencing membership decisions.
o Examples of areas covered in the structured questionnaire:
 Membership Status: A simple question asking whether the
respondent’s membership is current, expired, or lapsed.
 Renewal Factors: Questions regarding what in5luences
renewal decisions, such as pricing, content quality, customer
service, or promotional offers.
 Effectiveness of TOI’s Communication: The respondents were
asked about their satisfaction with TOI’s reminders and renewal
prompts (e.g., email, phone calls).
 Likelihood of Future Renewal: This section aimed to gauge how
likely members were to renew their subscriptions in the future.
 Demographic Details: Demographic data such as age, income,
location, and subscription history were also captured to segment
and analyze data more effectively.
o BeneLits of Structured Questionnaire:
 Easy to administer to a large group.
 Ef5icient in gathering quanti5iable data.
 Results can be easily analyzed using statistical tools.

 Semi-Structured Questionnaire:
o While structured questionnaires helped in gathering standardized data,
the semi-structured questionnaire allowed for more 5lexibility and
depth in responses. This questionnaire was designed for in-depth
interviewswith both internal stakeholders (e.g., TOI’s marketing and
membership teams) and a smaller sample of members. The questions in
this format were open-

48
 ended and allowed participants to share detailed insights and personal
experiences regarding the membership renewal process.
o Examples of areas covered in the semi-structured questionnaire:
 Personal Experiences with the Renewal Process: Members were
encouraged to describe their individual experiences with the
renewal process, including ease of renewal, communication
effectiveness, and customer support.
 Internal Perspectives: TOI staff were asked about internal
strategies used to encourage renewals, challenges faced during
renewal periods, and their perspective on customer satisfaction.
 Suggestions for Improvement: Open-ended questions were
included to allow participants to provide suggestions on how TOI
could improve its renewal process, communication strategies, or
member engagement.
 Barriers to Renewal: A key part of the semi-structured interview
was to understand any barriers that might prevent members from
renewing, such as cost, perceived value, or alternative media
options.
o BeneLits of Semi-Structured Questionnaire:
 More 5lexibility in gathering qualitative data.
 In-depth exploration of respondent opinions, beliefs, and
experiences.
 Ability to explore complex topics that may not be captured by
structured questions.

49
4.2 Types of Source of Data
Data was collected from both primary and secondary sources to provide a
comprehensive view of the membership renewal process at TOI. The combination of both
types of data allowed for richer analysis and understanding.
 Primary Data:
o Primary data refers to the original data collected 5irsthand from the
participants. The primary data collection involved engaging directly
with current members, lapsed members, prospective members, and
internal staff to gather fresh and relevant insights.
o Participants involved in primary data collection:
 Current Members: These were individuals who actively subscribed
to TOI. Understanding their reasons for renewing and their level of
satisfaction was key to the research.
 Lapsed Members: This group included individuals whose
memberships had expired and who had not renewed. Their
feedback was crucial in understanding why they chose not to renew,
and identifying potential gaps in TOI’s renewal strategies.
 Prospective Members: These were people who had
previously shown interest in TOI’s subscription but had not yet
become members. Their feedback provided insights into factors that
would encourage them to subscribe in the future.
 Internal Stakeholders: This included the marketing, sales,
and membership teams at TOI. These stakeholders provided
internal perspectives on the strategies, challenges, and goals
related to membership renewal.

o Data Collection Methods for Primary Data:

 Surveys: A signi5icant portion of the data came from online and
phone surveys. Respondents were asked to provide demographic
information and respond to both closed and open-ended questions.
These surveys were designed to capture a wide range of feedback in
an ef5icient manner.
 Interviews: In-depth interviews were conducted with a smaller
sample of members and internal staff. These interviews were
designed to capture qualitative insights on personal experiences
and challenges with the renewal process.
 Focus Groups: Focus group discussions were held with members
and lapsed members to encourage a dialogue about their
perceptions of TOI’s renewal strategies and overall satisfaction.

50
 Secondary Data:
o Secondary data refers to the information already available from previous
reports, publications, and research studies. This data helped to provide
a context for the primary data and complemented it by offering a
historical view of TOI’s membership renewal strategies.
o Sources of secondary data included:
 Internal Reports: TOI’s previous membership renewal campaigns,
data on renewal rates, and insights from past marketing efforts.
 Industry Reports: Industry-wide data on media subscription
models and membership renewal trends provided valuable
comparative benchmarks.
 Publications and Media: Articles, case studies, and market
research on successful membership models in other media
organizations, which helped in understanding what strategies might
be applicable for TOI.

51
4.3 Data Collection Methodology
The data collection methodology employed was systematic and aimed to ensure that the
research captured both qualitative and quantitative data in a robust and reliable
manner. The methods chosen allowed for a comprehensive understanding of the
membership renewal process and provided a mix of perspectives that contributed to
answering the research questions effectively.

 Survey Administration:
o The structured questionnaire was administered using online survey tools,
such as Google Forms or SurveyMonkey, to reach a broad audience of
current and prospective members. Additionally, surveys were also
distributed through phone calls to non-digital members. This ensured
that the study was inclusive and reached a diverse range of respondents.
o Surveys were incentivized with discounts or promotional offers to increase
response rates. The survey was designed to take no more than 10-15
minutes to complete, ensuring that it was easy for respondents to
participate.

 In-depth Interviews and Focus Groups:

o Interviews were conducted one-on-one with internal staff and a small
group of members. The semi-structured interviews allowed for more
5lexibility, and the researcher followed up with probing questions based on
the initial responses to gather deeper insights.
o Focus group discussions were held with a diverse group of members,
including those with varying subscription histories (active, expired,
non- subscribers). These discussions were guided by a moderator to ensure
that all aspects of membership renewal were covered, and all
participants had an opportunity to share their perspectives.

 Data Analysis:
o Once the data was collected, quantitative responses from the structured
questionnaire were entered into statistical software like SPSS or Excel for
analysis. Statistical methods, including frequency distribution, cross-
tabulation, and regression analysis, were used to identify trends and
correlations between variables such as age, renewal likelihood, and
customer satisfaction.
o Qualitative data from semi-structured interviews and focus groups was
coded and analyzed using thematic analysis. Themes such as customer
satisfaction, service quality, communication effectiveness, and barriers to
renewal were identi5ied and analyzed to provide deeper insights into the
membership renewal process.

52
CHAPTER-5: DATA
ANALYSIS &
INTERPRETATION

53
5.1 Data Analysis Tool
In order to analyse the data collected during the research, several tools and
techniques were utilized to ensure that the data was processed effectively and
meaningful insights could be drawn. These tools helped in organizing, analyzing, and
presenting the data to derive actionable conclusions. The main data analysis tools employed
during the project were:
1. Microsoft Excel: Microsoft Excel played a crucial role in analyzing the data for this
study. It was used for data cleaning, data organization, and performing basic
statistical analysis. Excel's pivot tables were particularly useful in summarizing
large volumes of data and extracting relevant insights. Charts and graphs were
also used to present the 5indings visually, making it easier to understand patterns
and trends in the data.

2. SPSS (Statistical Package for the Social Sciences): SPSS was used for more
advanced statistical analysis. The software allowed for in-depth analysis of
variables such as member satisfaction, the correlation between membership
renewal and the offer of gifts, and the impact of other subscription bene5its. SPSS
was used to run descriptive statistics, correlation tests, and regression
analysis to understand the relationships between the various factors in5luencing
membership renewal.

3. Google Forms: Google Forms was used for data collection in the form of surveys
and questionnaires. This tool allowed for easy collection of responses from
participants. After the data was gathered, it was transferred to Excel for
further analysis.

4. Tableau (for Visualization): Tableau was used for creating interactive

dashboards that presented the data in a more visually appealing manner. It
allowed for the creation of dynamic charts that helped in understanding the
distribution of survey responses, the correlation between variables, and the
identi5ication of patterns.

5. Qualitative Analysis Tools: In addition to the quantitative analysis tools

mentioned above, qualitative responses from the surveys and open-ended
questions were also analyzed using thematic analysis. Key themes, words, and
phrases were identi5ied from the text responses, which helped in interpreting
member sentiments about the subscription and gifts offered by The Times of India.

54
 Questionnaire 1

OBJECTIVE: To study the behaviour and reading habits towards physical copy of The
Times of India(TOI)/ The Economic Times (ET)

Name: -
Age: -
Student: - college school
1. Are you Exposed/ getting newspaper regularly at the end ?(Home, Room)
o Yes
o No
If yes then,
2. Do you read newspaper?
o Yes
o No
3. How often do you read newspaper?
o Regularly
o Sometimes
4. Which language do you prefer to read newspaper?
o English
o Vernacular
If no then,
5. Is there any other medium which you prefer to get yourself updated?
o Digital Media (Over Mobile)
o Digital Media (Over laptop/PC)
o Electronic Media (TV/Radio)
o Others (specify)

If print then,
1. What are the reasons for using print media?
o Enjoy having something physical to read
o More Structured & cohesive

55
 o Habitual
o Others (Please specify)

If digital media then,

2. What are the reasons for using digital media?
o Availablefor free
o Easily accessible
o Find out information up to date
o Multiple access of types of media (Music, videos, etc.)
o More convenient
o Others (Please specify)

Behavioural Analysis
a. Whether the reading of print newspaper will help you in your carrier?
oYe
s
oNo
b. If yes, check with question no. 2 (Behavioural check)
c. If no, reasons

d. In which medium do you 5ind retention of information is more?

o Print media
o Digital Media
e. Given an opportunity (easily available in front of you) and having time, will
you browse the print newspaper?

o Yes
o No
f. What are the basic parameters on which print is different from digital?

56
g. Will any kind of promotional scheme allure you to go for print newspaper?
o Yes
o No
Suggestion GComments:-

57
1. Are you Exposed/ getting newspaper regularly at the end ?(Home, Room)

Particulars Data
Yes 67
No 37
Total 104
Table 1

Are you exposed/ getting newspaper

regularly at your end?(Home, room)

No
35%

Yes
65%

Figure 1

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected we came to know that 65% (67 peoples
sample from 104) of the people are exposed for getting newspaper
regularly at their ends.
 Likewise, we came to know that 35% (37 peoples sample from 104) of the
people are not exposed for getting newspaper regularly at their ends.

58
2. Question-2 Do you read newspaper?

Particulars Data
Yes 81
No 23
Total 104
Table 2

Do you read Newspaper?

Yes No

22%

78%

Figure 2

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we can say that 78% (81 people out of
104) of the people are reading newspaper.
 Likewise, we can say that 22% (23 people out of 104) of the people are
not reading newspaper.

59
3. Question-3 How often do you read newspaper?

Particulars Data
Regularly 47
Sometimes 57
Total 104
Table 3

How often do you read newspaper?

Regularly
45%
Sometimes
55%

Figure 3

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we can say that 45% (47 people out of
104) of the people are reading newspaper regularly.
 Likewise, 55% (57 people out of 104) of the people are reading newspaper
sometimes.

60
4. Question-4 Which language do you prefer to read newspaper?

Particulars Data
English 96
Vernacular 8
Total 104
Table 4

Which language do you prefer to read

newspaper?
Vernacular
8%

English
92%

Figure 4

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we can say that 92% (96 people out of 104) of
the people prefer reading English Newspaper.
 Likewise, we can say that 8% (8 people out of 104) of the people
prefer reading different newspaper other than English i.e. Regional
languages like Guajarati, Hindi Marathi, etc.

61
5. Question-5 Is there any other medium which you prefer to get
yourself updated?

Particulars Data
Digital Media 80
Over Laptop 21
TV Radio 03
Others 00
Total 104
Table 5

IS THERE ANY OTHER MEDIUM WHICH

YOU PREFER TO GET YOURSELF
UPDATED?
tv/radio
3%

over
laptop
20%

digital media
77%

Figure 5

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we can say that 77% (80 people out of
104) of the people prefer reading through digital media.
 As we studied more, we came to know that 20% (21 people out of 104)
of the people prefer reading through laptop.
 While only 3 % of people prefer having updated to news through TV/Radio.

62
6. Question-6 What are the reasons for using print media?

Particulars Data
More structured 12
Habitual 30
Enjoy having physical to read 52
Others 10
Total 104
Table 6

What are the reasons for using

print
media?

habitua enjoying
l having
physical to

more
structured
Figure 6

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we came to know that 50% (52 people out
of 104) of the people prefer reading through print media because they
enjoy having physical to read.
 As we studied more, we came to know that12% (12 people out of 104)
of the people prefer reading print media because it is more structured.
 While 28 %(30 out of 104) of people prefer having print media
because they are habituated.
 While 10% (10 out of 104) of people prefer having print media because
of other than the above reasons.

63
7. Question 7 What are the reasons for using digital media?

Particulars Data
Easily Accessible 38
Available for free 24
Up to date 24
Multiple Access 8
More convenient 10
Total 104
Table 7

What are the reasons for using digital

media?
multiple 9
access
available for
free

up
to
date
easilyn
accessible

Figure 7

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we came to know that37% (38 people out
of 104) of the people prefer reading through digital media because it is
easily accessible.
 As we studied more, we came to know that 23% (24 people out of 104)
of the people prefer reading digital media because it is available for
free.
 While 23 % (24 out of 104) of people prefer having digital media
because it is up to date.
 While 8% (9 out of 104) of people prefer having digital media because of
it can be used between multiple access.
 While 9% (10 out of 104) of people prefer having digital media
because it is more convenient.

64
Behavioural Analysis: -
A. Whether the reading of print newspaper will help you in your career?

Particulars Data
Yes 90
No 14
Total 104
Table 8

Whether the reading of newspaper will help

you in your career?

no
13%

yes
87%

Figure 8

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the samples collected, we came to know that 87% (90 people out
of 104) of the people think that reading newspaper would help them in
building their carrier.
 As 13% (14 people out of 104) of the people think that reading
newspaper would not help them in building their carrier

65
B. In which medium do you Lind retention of information is more?

Particulars Data
Regularly 83
Sometimes 21
Total 104
Table 9

In which medium do you find retention

of information is more?

digital media
20%

printmedia
80%

Figure 9

INTERPRETATION: -
 From the samples collected, we came to know that 80% (90 people out of 104) of the
people think that reading print media has better retention of information over
digital media
 As 20% (14 people out of 104) of the people think that reading news through
digital media has better retention of information over print media.

66
C. Given an opportunity (easily available in front of you) and having time, will
you browse the print newspaper?

Particulars Data
Yes 82
No 22
Total 104
Table 10

Given an opportunity and having time , will

you browse the print newspaper?

no
21%

yes
79%

Figure 10

INTERPRETATION:-
 We came to know that 79% (82 people out of 104) of the people think that if
opportunity and time is given than they may browse the print newspaper.
 We came to know that 21% (22 people out of 104) of the people think that if
opportunity and time is given than they may not browse the print newspaper.

67
D. Will any kind of promotional scheme allure you to go for print newspaper?

Particulars Data
Yes 80
No 24
Total 104
Table 11

Will any kind of promotional scheme allure

you to go for print newspaper?

No
23%

Yes
77%

Figure 11

INTERPRETATION:-
 We came to know that 77% (80 people out of 104) of the people think that if
promotional scheme are given then they may go for print newspaper.
 We came to know that 23% (24 people out of 104) of the people think that if
opportunity and time is given than they may not browse the print newspaper.

68
 Questionnaire 2
OBJECTIVE: To analyze and to determine the ways to make our products available
to our valuable readers (OOH category).
Name: -
Age: -
Occupation: -

1. Are you reading TOI/ET print newspaper on daily basis?

o Yes (which)
o No (Reason)

2. Whether reading TOI/ET could help you in building your career or

enhance your knowledge or relax your mood?
o Yes
o No
3. Are you willing to spend 15-30 minutes time in reading TOI/ET?
o Yes
o No
4. Are you having price constraint as a barrier in subscribing TOI/ET?
o Yes
o No
5. What other value addition could be meaningful in reading TOI/ET?
o Industrial visit
o Imparting English pro5iciency workshops
o Imparting Carrier related workshops
o Availability
o Others (specify)

6. If discounts and value addition are provided then would you like to go for this
product?
o Yes
o No
7. On a scale of 1-5, how much would you rate while choosing your
product decision?

69
 2.1. Are you reading TOI/ET print newspaper on daily basis?

Particulars Data
Regularly 48
Sometimes 64
Total 112
Table 12

57
60
43
50

40

30

20

10

0
Yes No

Are you reading TOI/ET print newspaper on daily basis?

Figure 12

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the survey conducted, we found that 43% of the people are reading TOI/ET
on daily basis.
 Likewise we found that 57% of people are not reading TOI/ET on daily basis .

70
 2.2. Whether reading TOI/ET could help you in building your carrier
or enhance your knowledge or relax your mood?

Particulars Data
Yes 68
No 36
Total 104
Table 13

Whether reading TOI/ET could help you in

building your carrier or enhance your
knowledge or relax your mood?

70
60
50
40
30
20
10

Figure 13

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the survey conducted, we found that 61% of the people think that reading
newspaper would help them in building their carrier or enhance their knowledge
or relax your mood.
 From the survey conducted, we found that 39% of the people think that reading
newspaper would not help them in building their carrier or enhance their
knowledge or relax your mood.

71
 2.3. Are you willing to spend 15-30 minutes time in reading TOI/ET?

Particulars Data
Regularly 68
Sometimes 36
Total 112
Table 14

Are you willing to spend 15-30 minutes time

in reading TOI/ET?

70
60
50
40
30
20
10

Figure 14

INTERPRETATION:-
 From the survey conducted, we found that 61% of the people are willing to spend 15-
20 minutes in reading TOI/ET.
 . From the survey conducted, we found that 61% of the people are willing to spend
15- 20 minutes in reading TOI/ET.

72
 2.4. Are you having price constraint as a barrier in subscribing TOI/ET?

Particulars Data
Regularly 10
Sometimes 102
Total 112
Table 15

Are you having price constraint as a barrier in

subscribing TOI/ET?

100
80
60
40
20

Figure 15
INTERPRETATION
:-
 From the survey conducted, we found that 9% of the people are having
price barriers in subscribing TOI/ET.
 From the survey conducted, we found that 91% of the people are not
having price barriers in subscribing TOI/ET.

73
 2.5. What other value addition could be meaningful in reading TOI/ET?

Particulars Data
Industrial Visit 15
Imparting English Proficiency 29
Imparting carrier related workshops 41
Availability 12
Others 15
Total 112
Table 15

What other value addition could

be
meaningful in reading TOI/ET?

37
26
13 11 13

industrial Visit Imparting Imparting Availablity Others

English Carrier
Proficency related
workshops
Figure 15

INTERPETATION:-
 People prefer to have carrier related workshops the most which is 37%(41 people
out of 112).
 People then prefer to have English pro5iciency workshops because in today's world
English has became the most important language (26% i.e. 29 people out of 104)
 People prefer having industrial visit (13% i.e. 15 people out of 112)
 People are also wanting to have the Availability as the main factor (12 out of 112
people)

74
 2.6. If discounts and value addition are provided then would you like to go
for this product?
Particulars Data
Yes 21
No 43
Total 64
Table 16

If discounts and value addition are provided

then would you like to go for this product?
If discounts and value addition are provided then would you like to go for this
product?

38

19

Yes No

Figure 16
INTERPRETATION
:-
 In this we cam e across through 64 responses from which 19% (21 out of 114 people)
told us that if discounts and value addition are provided than they would like to go for
this product.
 38% ( 43 out of 114 people) told us that if discounts and value addition are
provided than they would not go for this product.

75
 2.7. Given an opportunity which product would you pick up Lirst?

Particulars Data
TOI 50
ET 32
AM 11
Others 18
Total 112
Table 17

Given an opportunity which product

would
you pick up first?

45
29
16
10

TOI ET AM Others/None
Figure 17

INTERPRETATION:-
 45% of people would prefer reading TOI (50 out of 112 ).
 29% of people prefer reading ET (32 out of 112).
 10% of people prefer reading AM (11 out of 112).
 16% of people prefer reading others (18 out of 112).

76
5.2Data Interpretation

The data analysis revealed several significant insights regarding membership

renewal in The Times of India and the impact of gifts on renewal
decisions. The findings of the analysis are as follows:

1. Effect of Gifts on Membership Renewal

One of the primary objectives of this research was to understand how
offering gifts affects membership renewal rates. The survey results
showed that a significant proportion of subscribers (about 65%)
expressed that they were more likely to renew their subscription if a gift
was offered as part of the renewal package. This suggests that gifts serve
as an effective incentive to boost subscriber retention.
 Renewal Likelihood with Gifts: 65% of respondents indicated that a
gift would make them more likely to renew, while 20% stated that it
would not impact their decision to renew. Only 15% said they would
not prefer to receive a gift with their subscription renewal. This
demonstrates the high perceived value of gifts among most
subscribers.
 Gift Preferences: Among those who favoured receiving gifts, 50%
preferred discounts on products or services related to their interests,
while 30% preferred exclusive content or special editions. The
remaining 20% showed interest in physical gifts, such as
merchandise or event tickets. This indicates that gifts directly
related to the core business of TOI (e.g., access to premium content)
are highly valued by subscribers.

2. Member Satisfaction and Loyalty

The analysis revealed that offering gifts improves overall member
satisfaction and contributes to increased loyalty. Subscribers who
received gifts were 30% more likely to express satisfaction with their
subscription compared to those who did not. This highlights the potential
benefits of implementing gift-based incentives in TOI’s subscription
model.
 Satisfaction Score: Subscribers who received gifts reported a
satisfaction score of 4.5/5 on average, compared to 3.2/5 for those
who did not receive gifts. This indicates that gifting leads to a
positive emotional connection with the brand, improving overall
customer satisfaction.

3. Impact of Subscription Plans on Renewal Rates

The data also indicated that premium subscription plans were more
likely to result in higher membership renewals when combined with a
gift incentive. Members who subscribed to premium plans valued exclusive
content and additional services, and offering a gift tailored to these
needs significantly enhanced the value proposition of these plans.
Premium Plan Subscribers: About 80% of premium plan subscribers stated they
would be more inclined to renew if a gift was included in the offer, as
opposed to only 55% of regular plan subscribers

77
4. Demographics of Subscribers
Demographic factors also played a role in determining the impact of gifts
on renewal behaviour. The survey found that younger subscribers,
particularly those aged 18-34, were more responsive to gift
incentives. This age group values digital content and experiential
rewards, such as online coupons, event passes, and exclusive
digital access.
 Age-based Preferences: 45% of young adults (aged 18-34)
preferred discounts or free trials for digital platforms, while older
subscribers (aged 45+) showed a preference for physical gifts, like
gift cards and branded merchandise. This suggests the importance of
personalizing gift options based on age and interests to maximize appeal.

5. Correlation Between Gift Type and Subscriber Retention

Further analysis using regression analysis revealed a strong positive
correlation between the type of gift offered and subscriber
retention. Specifically, exclusive digital access (such as premium
articles, ad-free content, and early access to news) was found to have the
highest positive impact on membership renewal, followed by event
tickets and discount vouchers.
 Impact of Exclusive Content: Members who received premium
digital content as a gift were 40% more likelyto renew their
subscription than those who received physical gifts like merchandise.

6. Financial Implications of Offering Gifts

From a financial perspective, the data showed that offering gifts was cost-
effective in terms of its impact on renewal rates. While providing gifts
involves additional expenditure, the increase in renewal rates (by
approximately 25-30%) outweighed the costs associated with the gifts.
 Renewal Growth: The analysis revealed that TOI could see an
increase in membership renewals by as much as 20-25% annually if
gifts were strategically offered as part of the renewal process.

78
Which medium do you choose to get aware of the news from around the world?

INTERPRETATION:-
 Around 75% of the total respondents prefer digital news to newspaper.
 Within the responses for digital news viewers
 41.57% are females and 58.43% are males
 41.57% are from 18-25 age group, 20.22% are from 26-35 age group,
 25.84% are from 36-45 age group, 4.49% are from 46-55 age group.
 2.24% are from above 55 age group and 5.61% are from below 18 age
group.

The age group 18-25 has the highest digital news preferences and as obvious the
above 55 age group has the lowest penetration in digital news.

Within the respondents for the newspaper readership -

26.66% are females and 73.33% are 6 are males 16.66% are from 18-25 age group,
13.33% are from 26-35 age group, 16.66% are from 36-45 age group, 20% are from 46-
55 age group, 30% are from above 55 age group and below 18 it is 3.33%

The age group of above 55 has the highest newspaper readership and below 18 age group
has the lowest penetration in newspaper readership. And in other age groups the
newspaper readership is uniform

Within the respondents for the newspaper readership –

26.66% are females and 73.33% are 6 are males 16.66% are from 18-25 age group,
13.33% are from 26-35 age group, 16.66% are from 36-45 age group, 20% are from 46-
55 age group, 30% are from above 55 age group and below 18 it is 3.33%

79
The age group of above 55 has the highest newspaper readership and below 18 age group
has the lowest penetration in newspaper readership. And in other age groups the
newspaper readership is uniform

Questionnaire: section (from newspaper readers)

INTERPRETATION:-
Almost 83% of the total newspaper readers prefer newspaper daily. So newspaper is
almost a morning habit for them. The weekly newspapers have low demand and the
penetration of "Twice a week' and 'Once a fortnight" must be very low and hence it is nil
in my survey.

80
 Which of the following newspaper brands are you aware of?

INTERPRETATION:-
 The highest awareness is with The Times of India newspaper WHICH REFLECTS THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF SALES AND PROMOTIONAL STRATEGY OF THE TIMES OF INDIA
NEWSPAPER.
 And following The Times of India, The Hindu has the next highest awareness, which
is also considered as The Times of India's one the closest competitors.
 The Statesman has the lowest awareness.

81
 After the Lirst use, have you repeated the purchase of the
following newspaper?

INTERPRETATION:-
 Most of the respondents have repeated the purchase of Hindustan Times, more
than The Times of India.
 The repeat for The Times of India is also considerably high as compared to the other
newspapers.
The possible reasons for these actions of the readers will be explored in the
upcoming part of the questionnaire which will I clarify what in5luences the purchase of the
several newspapers.

82
 CHAPTER-6
FINAL
CHAPTER

83
6.1 Discussion

The study highlights the critical relationship between customer incentives, such as gift
offerings, and membership renewal rates within the subscription model of The Times of
India (TOI). The results illustrate how strategic incentives can signi5icantly enhance
customer satisfaction, retention, and brand loyalty. This discussion synthesizes the key
5indings while examining their implications for TOI’s broader business strategies.

The 5indings indicate that 65% of subscribers are more likely to renew their
subscriptions when gifts are included as part of the offering. This demonstrates that
gifts serve as a psychological motivator, fostering a sense of value and appreciation
among subscribers. The data also underscores demographic nuances, with younger
subscribers favouring digital incentives like premium content, and older demographics
leaning toward tangible gifts like branded merchandise. This segmentation re5lects the
importance of personalizing offerings to align with customer preferences.

Additionally, the correlation between premium plans and renewal rates reinforces the
idea that higher-value subscriptions paired with tailored gifts create a compelling
value proposition. Subscribers of premium plans demonstrated an 80% inclination
toward renewal when a gift was provided. This 5inding aligns with theories in
consumer behavior, where perceived value drives purchase decisions.

From an operational perspective, offering gifts presents 5inancial implications. While it

involves additional costs, the increase in renewal rates (20-25%) suggests a substantial
return on investment. This validates the viability of such strategies as part of TOI’s
subscription business model. However, the study also reveals challenges, including
varying preferences among demographics and the need to balance cost-effectiveness with
customer satisfaction.

The discussion further emphasizes the growing importance of data-driven decision-

making in subscription models. Tools like Microsoft Excel, SPSS, and Tableau enabled the
effective analysis of subscriber behavior and preferences, providing actionable insights.
This approach aligns with the industry's shift toward leveraging analytics to enhance
customer experience and operational ef5iciency.

84
6.2 Recommendations

The 5indings from this study form the basis for actionable recommendations designed to
improve membership renewal rates and enhance the overall subscriber experience at
TOI. These recommendations are aligned with industry best practices and are aimed
at optimizing customer retention strategies.

1. Segment-Based Gift Strategies:

TOI should develop gift strategies tailored to the preferences of speci5ic demographic
segments. For instance, younger subscribers (aged 18-35) could be offered digital
rewards such as exclusive content, while older subscribers might appreciate tangible
items such as branded merchandise or household items. By aligning gifts with customer
preferences, TOI can maximize the effectiveness of its incentive programs.

2. Predictive Analytics for Personalization:

Leveraging data analytics tools, TOI can predict subscriber behaviour and design
personalized offers. For example, subscribers identi5ied as at risk of churn could be
targeted with exclusive gift offers tailored to their preferences. This proactive approach
ensures that interventions are timely and effective.

3. Partnerships for Co-Branded Gifts:

Collaborating with other brands can expand the range of gift options available to
subscribers. For instance, partnerships with e-commerce platforms or entertainment
companies can provide high-value, low-cost gifts that appeal to a wide audience.

4. Incentives for Premium Plans:

To drive adoption of higher-value subscriptions, TOI should bundle premium plans with
exclusive bene5its such as early access to content, special event invitations, or high-
value gifts. This not only incentivizes renewals but also encourages upgrades to
premium tiers.

5. Feedback Loops:
Regularly collecting and analysing subscriber feedback on gift preferences and
satisfaction levels is crucial. Feedback can be gathered through surveys, focus groups, or
digital interactions, and the insights can inform the continuous re5inement of incentive
strategies.

6. Monitor Financial Viability:

The 5inancial impact of gift programs should be closely monitored to ensure
sustainability. TOI should periodically review the cost-bene5it ratio of its incentive
strategies, adjusting offerings as necessary to maintain pro5itability while maximizing
customer satisfaction.
In conclusion, the implementation of these recommendations can help TOI achieve a
balance between enhancing subscriber loyalty and maintaining 5inancial sustainability.

85
6.3 Suggestions

Based on the insights derived from the research, the following suggestions can be
implemented to further enhance TOI's membership renewal strategy:
1. Enhance Communication Channels:
TOI should strengthen its communication channels to effectively convey the
value of subscriptions and associated bene5its. For example, personalized email
campaigns, app noti5ications, and social media posts can create awareness about
renewal bene5its and upcoming gift offers.

2. Focus on Emotional Connection:

Gifts should not only serve as incentives but also resonate emotionally with
subscribers. TOI can consider offering gifts that align with themes like nostalgia
(e.g., limited edition prints) or social responsibility (e.g., eco-friendly products).

3. Introduce Loyalty Programs:

A structured loyalty program can encourage long-term commitment. Subscribers
can earn points for renewals, referrals, or engagement activities, which can be
redeemed for rewards or discounts.

4. Adopt Eco-Friendly Practices:

In line with global sustainability trends, TOI should prioritize environmentally
friendly gift options. This approach not only enhances brand reputation but also
appeals to environmentally conscious subscribers.

5. Expand Digital Offerings:

Given the increasing digitization of media consumption, TOI should consider
bundling digital subscriptions with exclusive online content, early access to news,
or ad-free experiences as part of its renewal incentives.

86
6.4 Conclusion

The research on membership renewal strategies for The Times of India provides critical
insights into the dynamics of customer retention in a competitive subscription-based
industry. Central to the 5indings is the effectiveness of gift-based incentives, which
signi5icantly impact renewal rates by fostering a sense of value and appreciation among
subscribers. This study underscores the importance of understanding subscriber
preferences, behavioural patterns, and the psychological drivers behind customer loyalty.
By analyzing the preferences of diverse subscriber demographics, the study highlights the
need for personalized approaches to retention. While younger subscribers gravitate
toward digital rewards, older demographics prefer tangible gifts. This segmentation
demonstrates that a tailored strategy is more effective than generic incentives. The
integration of tools like predictive analytics further enhances the ability to identify at-risk
subscribers, proactively addressing potential churn.

Another key insight is the role of premium subscriptions, which show a stronger
correlation between gift offerings and renewal rates. Subscribers of higher-value plans
tend to expect enhanced bene5its, and addressing these expectations not only improves
retention but also drives upgrades to premium tiers. The study also highlights the
principle of reciprocity, where the perception of receiving a gift fosters goodwill and
increases the likelihood of renewal.

Operational challenges, however, remain a crucial consideration. Cost management,

logistics, and sustainability of incentive programs require careful planning. While gifts are
effective, their implementation must be 5inancially viable and aligned with the
organization's pro5itability goals. The 5indings suggest a balanced approach, combining
thoughtful incentive strategies with advanced technological tools to streamline
operations and improve outcomes.

The research contributes valuable insights to the media industry, showcasing how
customer-centric strategies, supported by data analytics and innovative technologies, can
address retention challenges. By continually adapting to changing market dynamics and
subscriber expectations, TOI can solidify its position as a leader in the subscription
space.

87
6.5 Future Scope

This research opens several avenues for future exploration in membership renewal
strategies at The Times of India. The insights derived from this study serve as a foundation
for further innovation and optimization in customer retention efforts.

One signi5icant area for future research is the long-term impact of gift-based
incentives on subscriber loyalty and lifetime value. While the current study focuses on
immediate renewal rates, an extended analysis of the relationship between gifts and
sustained loyalty over multiple renewal cycles can provide a deeper understanding of
their ef5icacy.

The integration of artifLicial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML)

offers immense potential. Advanced algorithms can predict subscriber behaviour, automate
the personalization of gift offerings, and provide real-time insights into customer
preferences. Future studies could explore how AI-driven personalization can re5ine
the ef5iciency and effectiveness of incentive strategies.

Another area worth exploring is the diversification of incentives. Beyond gifts, TOI
can experiment with other approaches, such as offering exclusive access to premium
content, discounted services from partners, or experiential rewards like event invitations.
Research could evaluate the comparative effectiveness of these incentives in retaining
subscribers.

Expanding the study to rural and semi-urban markets is another promising direction.
These areas remain largely untapped, and understanding the unique preferences and
behaviours of subscribers in these regions could unlock new growth opportunities for
TOI.

Lastly, the application of gamification elements in subscriber engagement, such as

loyalty programs or point-based rewards systems, can be explored as an innovative
approach to retention. Future research can examine the impact of gami5ication on
customer satisfaction and retention.

88
6.6 Limitations

Despite the valuable insights offered by this study, several limitations must be
acknowledged to contextualize the 5indings and identify areas for improvement in future
research.

The 5irst limitation is the geographical scope of the research. The study primarily
focused on urban subscribers, which may not accurately represent the preferences
and behaviours of rural and semi-urban audiences. Expanding the research to include a more
diverse demographic pro5ile could provide a comprehensive understanding of subscriber
needs across regions.

A second limitation is the short-term focus of the analysis. The study emphasizes
immediate outcomes, such as renewal rates, without delving into the long-term effects of
gift-based incentives on subscriber loyalty and lifetime value. Future research should
consider the sustained impact of such strategies to evaluate their true effectiveness.
The scope of incentives explored in the study was relatively narrow, focusing
predominantly on gifts. This limitation excludes other potential factors that in5luence
renewals, such as pricing models, content quality, and alternative retention strategies. A
broader exploration of these elements could yield a more holistic understanding of
subscriber retention.

The sample size and representativeness of the data also pose a limitation. The 5indings
were derived from a speci5ic subset of TOI’s subscriber base, which may not fully
represent the behaviours and preferences of the entire audience. Larger and more diverse
sample sizes could enhance the generalizability of the results.

Lastly, the study does not account for external factors such as market trends, economic
conditions, and competition, which may in5luence subscriber decisions.
Incorporating these variables into future research could provide a more nuanced
perspective on the challenges and opportunities in membership renewal strategies.

By addressing these limitations, future research can build on the 5indings of this study to
further optimize customer retention strategies and strengthen TOI’s position in the
competitive media landscape.

89
 BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Books and Journals

o Kotler, P., C Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing Management (15th
Edition). Pearson Education.
o Zeithaml, V. A., Bitner, M. J., C Gremler, D. D. (2013). Services
Marketing: Integrating Customer Focus Across the Firm.
McGraw-Hill Education.
o Levitt, T. (1983). The Marketing Imagination. The Free Press.

2. Web Articles
o "Media Industry Trends and Outlook." Deloitte Insights.
Retrieved from www.deloitte.com.
o "Customer Retention Strategies in Subscription Models."
Harvard Business Review. Retrieved from www.hbr.org.
o "The Role of Incentives in Subscriber Retention." Forbes.
Retrieved from www.forbes.com.

3. Reports
o Ernst C Young. (2023). Digital Media and Subscription Economy
Report.
o KPMG. (2022). The Future of the Indian Media Industry.
o PwC. (2023). Entertainment and Media Outlook 2023.

4. Company Publications
o The Times of India. (2024). Annual Report 2023-24.
o The Times Group. (2022). Subscriber Retention Insights.

5. Government and Industry Data

o Ministry of Information and Broadcasting,Government of
India. (2023). Media and Entertainment Industry Report.
o FICCI-EY Report. (2023). The Indian Media and Entertainment
Industry: Trends and Challenges.

6. Academic Papers
o Sharma, R., C Gupta, S. (2022). "Impact of Gift-Based
Incentives on Customer Retention in Indian Newspapers."
Journal of Media Economics.
o Singh, A., C Patel, M. (2023). "Changing Dynamics of
Subscription Models in the Digital Age." International Journal of
Marketing Studies.

7. Online Databases and Research Tools

o Statista. (2023). "Indian Media Industry Revenue Statistics."
Retrieved from www.statista.com.
o IBISWorld. (2023). "Indian Newspaper Publishing Industry Report."

90
 APPENDICES

Appendix A: Ǫuestionnaire Used for Data Collection

The questionnaire was designed to gather insights into customer
preferences, expectations, and satisfaction regarding membership renewal
with The Times of India. Below are the sample questions:
1. Demographic Information:
o Age:
o Gender: Male/Female/Other
o Location:
2. Subscription Details:
o How long have you been a subscriber of The Times of India?
o What type of subscription do you currently have? (Print/Digital/Both)
3. Customer Preferences and Expectations:
o What motivates you to renew your subscription?
o Are you satisfied with the current subscription benefits? (Yes/No)
o Would a gift or additional incentive encourage you to
renew your membership?
4. Feedback on Past Schemes:
o Have you previously availed any gifting schemes? (Yes/No)
o Rate your satisfaction with the gifting scheme on a scale of 1 to 5.
5. Suggestions:
o What additional features or services would you like included
with your subscription?
o Any other comments or feedback:

Appendix B: Tools Used for Analysis

1. Microsoft Excel:
o Used for compiling, organizing, and analyzing survey data.
o Functions like Pivot Tables and Charts were employed for
visualizing customer trends.
2. Google Forms:
o Utilized for digital distribution of the questionnaire to subscribers.

91