MANGALA DEVELOPMENT - PIPELINE PROJECT

TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR NEUTRAL GROUNDING RESISTOR

EVALUATION
M/s. Ampcontrol equipmens
Sr. No. Technical Particulars MR requirement M/s Narkhede Engg Pvt Ltd M/s RSI Switchgear Pvt. Ltd
Pvt Ltd.
1.0 VENDOR STATUS CEIL Approved Approved Approved Not Approved
NGR - DATA SHEET A
2.0 GENERAL
2.1 Application/ Designation Transformer Grounding Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.2 Qty.(Nos.) 1 Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2 3 Type
2.3 T off Material
M t i l St i ttype elment
Strip l t (St i l
(Stainless t l)
steel) C fi d
Confirmed C fi d
Confirmed C fi d
Confirmed
a) Wire wound (Stainless Steel)
b) Strip Type Element
2.4 Installation Outdoor Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.5 Enclosure Totally enclosed dust & vermin proof Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.5.1 Sheet steel thickness 2 MM Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.5.2 Tank type weatherproof with Aluminium covers (YES/ Yes with CRCA Cover Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
NO)
2.5.3 Tank type with Galvanised screen covers (YES/ NO) Yes Not required Not applicable Not Applicable
2.5.4 Safety screened enclosure for personnel protection (YES/ Optional Cost to be taken from
Yes Optionally quoted Optionally quoted
NO) vendor
2.5.5 Degree of Protection IP55 Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.5.6 Colour shade RAL 7032 (Seimens Grey) Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.5.7 Canopy FRP/ CRCA Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.6 Cooling Naturally air cooled Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.7 Site conditions
a) Area classification
As p
per MR and Specification
p - - -
b) Gas group
c) Temperature class
2.8 Design temperature for NGR 50oC Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.9 Access of operation Front access Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.10 Busbar Type COPPER Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.11 Earthing BusBar Type COPPER 25 x 3 mm Excluded from scope Excluded from scope Excluded from scope
2.12 Cable Entry From bottom Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.13 Panel Single front Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.14 Spare Terminal *20% Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
2.15 Colour Shade of Panel Epoxy painted having colour shade pebble grey (RAL Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
7032)
3.0 RATINGS
3.1 Ohmic Value (ohms) 20 ohms Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
3.2 Taps (in %) Not applicable Not applicable Not applicable
3.3 Rated current (A) 200A Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
3.4 Duration of rating 10 seconds Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
Continuous/ 60 sec.
3.5
3 5 Line to neutral voltage (V) 6.93/
6 93/ √3 KV Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
3.6 Insulation Class (V) As per specification 7.2kV 7.2kV 7.2kV
Bank support insulators will
be of 11KV voltage class.
Stand off insulators are not
considered in the offer.
3.7 Voltage class of stand Insulators (kV) As per specification 11kV However, if required, they will Vendor to confirm
be provided at an additional
cost

3.8 Rated Power (kW) 800 kW Not commented 800 kW

4.0 CURRENT TRANSFORMER
a) Required & Part of supply (YES/NO) YES One CT with dual core with One CT with dual core with 2 different CTs provided with
b) Ratio (A) 1. 600/1A FOR 64R 2. 600/1A FOR 51NS ratio and specification as per ratio and specification as per ratios as per specification and
data sheet and specification. data sheet and specification. data sheet
c) Rating (VA) 2. 15VA Confirmed Confirmed
d) Class 1. PS 2. 5P20

BSPL-1244-IOT2-EL-TBE-0013 C1 Page 2 of 4
 MANGALA DEVELOPMENT - PIPELINE PROJECT
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR NEUTRAL GROUNDING RESISTOR

EVALUATION
M/s. Ampcontrol equipmens
Sr. No. Technical Particulars MR requirement M/s Narkhede Engg Pvt Ltd M/s RSI Switchgear Pvt. Ltd
Pvt Ltd.
5.0 TERMINAL CONNECTIONS
Incoming to Terminal box
a) Cable type The connection between transformer neutral & NGR shall
5.1 b) Size (in sq.mm) be by 1C X 185 sq. mm, 6.6kV(UE), Cu, XLPE, Armoured Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
c) Overall Diameter (in sq.mm) cable
d) Gl
Glandd or Entry
E t type
t & Size
Si
5.2 Outgoing from Resistor All taps of resistors shall be brought to terminal box. Taps are not required Taps are not required Taps are not required
Outgoing from Terminal Box
a) Cable Type
It shall be suitable for Copper flat connection. Size will be
5.3 b) Size (in sq.mm) Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
furnished during detailed engineering.
c) Overall DiameterR (in sq.mm)
d) Gland or Entry type & Size
Resistor Earthing Bushing Terminal Suitable for conductor
of Porcelain Bushing Porcelain Bushing ,with M12
5.4 Confirmed
a) Material Size to be furnished by IOT Brass Stud.
b) Size
6.0 APPLICABLE STANDARDS
a) Neutal Grounding Resistor IEEE 32 Confirmed Confirmed Confirmed
b) Current Transformer IEC 185 Confirmed IS 2705 Confirmed
c) Degree of Protection Provided by Enclosures IS 2147 Confirmed IS 12063 Confirmed
7.0 Vaccum Contactor
1 No. mechanically latched, 1 ph., 7.2kV, 400A, 230V AC Confirmed, Vaccum contactor Confirmed
Provided
coil and minimum 4NO & 4NC contacts. make : Areva
8.0 Corrosion Protection All metal parts shall be protected against corrosion. Confirmed Confirmed Vendor to confirm

NGR - DATA SHEET B

1.0 Max. current carrying capacity for 60 sec. (Amps.) 200A for 10 sec. 200A for 10 sec. 200A for 10 sec.
Temp. rise (not exceeding safe temperature of insulation), a) 740oC above ambient of o
a) 360 C above ambient of
when carrying: 50oC for duty of 10 sec. 50oC.
2.0 As per IEEE 32, Table 6, Column 7. Confirmed as per IEEE 32
a) Max. current for 60 secs. (o C) b) NA Vendor to provide as per IEC
b) Continuous rated current (o C) standard
Change in resistance with temperature (for 100 Deg
3.0 10% 15% ±10%
increase)
4.0 Lists of tests to be carried out enclosed (Yes / No) Yes Enclosed Enclosed Enclosed
5.0 Applicable standard/s IEEE 32 IEEE 32 IEEE 32
6.0 Total weight of each resistor (Kg.) 500Kg (Approx.) 400Kg (Approx.) 575Kg (Approx.)
7.0 Overall Dimension of enclosure (mm) L X D X H in mm 1000 x 1050 x 1400 1300 x 1300 x 1200 1210 x 1410 x 1815
8.0 Neutal earthing resistor element material grade, as per Stainless steel AISI-304 grade Stainless steel ASTMA240-304
AISI 430
applicable standards punched type.
General outline dimensioned drawing with binding
9.0 dimentions & weights, showing the resistor with all its During detail engineering During detail engineering During detail engineering
fittings & accessories in plan.
Detialed outline drawing showing plan, front elevation, end
10.0 elevation, inner view, locating dimensions of cable entries, During detail engineering During detail engineering During detail engineering
terminal details, structure/ floor fixing details.
Schematic dig. Of resistor with taps, terminal box
11.0 connections, terminal details, ohms, current & voltage During detail engineering During detail engineering During detail engineering
rating, voltage classof the stand insulators.
12.0 Temperature coefficient of resistance 0.00094 0.0015 0.0009
13.0 Resistivity of resistance material (micro ohm-cm) 72 60 72

14.0 List of Referred Documents 1. BSPL-1244-TCEL-EL-SP-0014-C1 - Specification for

Neutral Grounding Resistor
15.0 List of Deviation No deviation No deviation Deviation list NOT submitted Deviation list NOT submitted
16.0 Technical Recommendation Technically Acceptable Technically NOT Acceptable Technically NOT Acceptable

TECHNICAL RECOMMANDATION
A) M/s AMPCONTROL PVT LTD.

BSPL-1244-IOT2-EL-TBE-0013 C1 Page 3 of 4
 MANGALA DEVELOPMENT - PIPELINE PROJECT
TECHNICAL BID EVALUATION FOR NEUTRAL GROUNDING RESISTOR

EVALUATION
M/s. Ampcontrol equipmens
Sr. No. Technical Particulars MR requirement M/s Narkhede Engg Pvt Ltd M/s RSI Switchgear Pvt. Ltd
Pvt Ltd.
M/s AMPCONTROL PVT LTD. Is meeting all MR requirements. Hence, their offer is technically acceptable.

B) M/s NARKHEDE ENGG PVT LTD

M/s NARKHEDE ENGG PVT LTD is technically NOT acceptable due to the following reasons :
1 They have taken deviations against MR requirement given in TBE sr no 6 of Data sheet A : Applicable standards for CT and Degree of Protection.
2 They have neither submitted any Deviation List nor given any "No Deviation" confirmation w.r.t. MR specs.

C) M/s RSI Switchgear Pvt. Ltd

M/s RSI Switchgear Pvt. Ltd is technically NOT acceptable due to the following reasons :
1 This vendor is not in approved vendor list
2 They have till date not given compliance against MR requirements given in TBE Sr No 3.7 and 8
3 They have neither submitted any Deviation List nor given any "No Deviation" confirmation w.r.t. MR specs.

Note : Price quoted by all vendors shall be inclusive of Stand-off Insulators (TBE Sr. No. 3.7)

Of the above vendors, only M/s AMPCONTROL PVT LTD. is technically acceptable due to reasons mentioned above.

BSPL-1244-IOT2-EL-TBE-0013 C1 Page 4 of 4