TA Instruments BATT SEL Guide Ebook en
TA Instruments BATT SEL Guide Ebook en
Materials Characterization
A Selection Guide for Analytical Solutions
Battery Materials 6
• Electrodes 6
• Separators 11
• Electrolytes 13
The race for the next generation of battery technology is well underway. In just a few decades, rechargeable batteries have
grown well beyond their roots in consumer electronics and now support sustainable transportation and renewable energy
storage. Tremendous advancements in battery efficiency, power, output, and safety have primed batteries, especially lithium-
ion batteries, for these demanding applications.
Now, battery developers are tasked with optimizing their designs for both current and new applications. In addition to building
safer, low-cost electric vehicles, batteries must reach even higher energy density for use in freight trucks and buses. Similarly,
batteries with higher capacity and lower costs will be the formulations of choice for grid energy storage. And above all else,
battery developers must meet demand for sustainable, affordable material sourcing in the face of lithium and cobalt scarcity.
The frontier for battery innovation is vast but the challenges are steep. Success will be determined by small margins in energy,
power output, cycle life, safety, and cost – all of which require superior optimization of battery materials and electrochemical
reactions. Leading labs rely on TA Instruments for analytical characterization and testing of their batteries.
Using the right techniques and instruments gives you the upper hand in efficiently advancing battery technology with proven
quality and performance. From R&D and material selection to manufacturing and quality control, TA Instruments’ solutions
support the full breadth of battery innovation. This guide explains our comprehensive battery offerings by battery component,
so you can find the right technique to enhance your battery development.
3
Cathode Manufacturing Binder & Additive
• Slurry viscosity and • Incoming materials QC Cathode Materials
coating performance • Verify materials • High temp stability
• Slurry structure and • Degradation • Sintering process
conductive network • Melting temperature
Electrodes
Battery Separators
Materials • Incoming materials QC Mechanical Integrity
• Verify materials • Thermal sinkage
• Degradation • Modulus
• Composition • Creep
• Inorganic coating content
• Melting temperature
• Incoming materials QC
• Verify materials Gel Polymer Electrolytes
• Degradation • Viscoelasticity
• Composition • Gel point
• Melting temperature
• Glass transition temp
Full Battery
• Cell Discharge
Full Battery • Heat capacity
HR Rheometer
• Parasitic reaction
Cell • Decomposition analysis
TGA and DSC
• Lithium Plating
• SEI formation
TMA/DMA
SDT
Thermal Conductivity
TAM
Numerous notable battery labs, including the Jeff Dahn group and 3M,
have published research using TA Instruments isothermal microcalorimeters
paired with battery cyclers for full cell testing. The new Battery Cycler
Microcalorimeter Solution is built with this application in mind. The
solution pairs TA Instruments’ state-of-the-art TAM IV Microcalorimeter
to measure the thermal behavior of samples with the BioLogic VSP-
300 Potentiostat, a research-grade electrochemical analysis tool to
probe the electrical properties of materials. The result is an end-to-end,
in-operando measurement tool for elucidating the thermodynamic and
electrochemical details of battery cells in real time, in a flexible and intuitive
system with pre-programmed methods.
Method Description
Measures heat flow during cycling, primarily used for thermal management applications.
Heat Management (CCCV) This method will program different charging profiles (variable charge / discharge rates)
using constant current constant voltage (CCCV) parameters.
This method consists of a slow cycle (C/20) followed by a very slow cycle (C/100) for maximum
Entropy Changes
resolution into the structural and phase changes that occur during lithiation/delithiation.
Method designed to study the SEI formation reactions. This method applies a small charging
First Cycle Reaction
current in the low voltage range where SEI formation occurs (typically below 3.0 V), then applies
(SEI formation)
a higher charging current until the standard upper voltage limit is reached (typically 4.2 V).
Method to measure the parasitic power over the full voltage range. The term “parasitics” is a
Full Cycle Parasitics
blanket term for any non-reversible side reaction that contributes to battery degradation.
Experiment for measuring the self-discharge rate. This combines the conventional technique
Self-Discharge (monitoring open circuit voltage over time, then discharging to measure the remaining capacity)
and the thermal method of integrating the total heat produced over the open circuit time.
Custom experiments, programmed by selecting actions, wait times, and event markers
Manual
in the run sequence menu.
5
Battery Materials
Electrodes
Electrodes connect battery terminals to the electrolyte and house the chemical reactions for charging and discharging.
Electrodes therefore must demonstrate good electrochemical stability with the electrolyte as well as hold large amounts of
ions without changing their structure. Cathode materials have been at the forefront of battery innovation in recent years, with
anode materials now gaining attention as the next area of development.
Electrode Manufacturing
All batteries require cathode and anode coatings on a current collector. Modern industrial battery manufacturing uses slot-
die coating, in which the electrode slurry is deposited onto the current collector to form a smooth, uniform coating. In order
to speed up battery manufacturing, researchers are optimizing slurry formulations and testing different drying temperatures.
Rheology enables engineers to produce consistent slurry viscosities that result in uniform coatings for high performing and
safer batteries. A rheological profile measurement can help ensure a uniform, defect-free coating that leads to production of
consistent, high-quality electrodes with high batch-to-batch repeatability and low scrap rates. Engineering new slurry materials,
formulations, or processing methods all require thorough rheological characterization to verify the slurry’s quality.
Using accurate, reliable rheometers gives labs the upper hand in predicting slurry behavior before application, saving
valuable resources and time. Screening incoming raw materials or new formulations helps users detect unexpected behavior
and avoid large-scale production issues. While viscometers measure basic viscosity and flow, rheometers add shear or stress
measurements that provide crucial information on slurry structure and behavior.
Ensure optimal
Shear-dependent Discovery HR
Impedance Rheo- conductive network
conductive network and Rheo-Impedance
under Shear Flow Impedance under the relevant
structure change Spectroscopy
processing conditions
ed Peltier Pl
v a nc ate
Ad
centric Cy
r Con lind
ltie er
Pe
d er Rheolog
Pow y
ce Spec
p edan tro
-Im sc
o op
e y
Rh
7
Binder and Additive
In addition to ensuring proper electrode coating, the binder and additive in electrode slurries greatly contribute to the overall
performance. Binders require high thermal stability, good adhesion, and flexibility to facilitate proper battery performance. Low
quality binders and additives can cause cracking and chipping on the electrode coating.
Battery developers typically test binder and additive at two key stages:
• To verify incoming materials’ quality
• To measure the binder and additive’s composition and electrode performance
Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) measures weight change (loss or gain) and the rate of
weight change as a function of temperature, time, and atmosphere. Loss of mass indicates
possible decomposition or vaporization, while a gain in mass indicates possible oxidation,
sorption or that the material is reacting with the purge gas.
In batteries, TGA quantifies the amount of binder and additive in the electrode. This
measurement helps ensure the same amount of active material, binder and additive are in
each batch of electrode. On the Discovery TGA, the high sensitivity Tru-Mass Balance is ideal
for binder and additive testing as it ensures accurate measurement of each component in
the electrode. Insufficient amounts of binder will affect the active the electrode material’s
adhesion to the metal collector; too much binder will reduce the active material’s content and affect the electrochemical
reaction. Optimization of binder/additive ratios is essential for optimal battery performance and improvement of battery life.
TGA also measures the thermal stability, degradation temperatures, and content and composition of binder and additive.
Thermal stability can help identify the right composition and types of the binder to ensure proper performance during
electrode manufacturing.
• Thermal stability
Thermal stability of of binder
Decomposition temperature TGA Discovery TGA
the binders • Ensure incoming
materials quality
• Ensure incoming
Phase transition on the
Melting and Crystallization DSC materials quality Discovery DSC
polymer properties
• Process optimization
Battery researchers are investigating cathodes and anodes with higher specific capacities while maintaining structural,
chemical, and thermal stabilities along with low cost. Thermal analysis enables researchers and engineers to understand the
thermal stability (phase transition, melting, and decomposition) of electrode and binder materials for safer and longer lasting
batteries across all operational temperatures.
9
Electrode Problem Solving
What it
Challenge Solution Technique TA Instrument
Measures
Measure incoming powder
Inhomogeneous and Power flowability, Discovery HR with
batches for critical parameters
aggregated slurry caused Powder rheology cohesion and yield Powder Rheology
like powder cohesion and yield
by low quality powders strength Accessory
strength
Delamination or electrode
Quantify binder content in final Binder and additive
chipping from poor TGA Discovery TGA
electrode to verify specifications composition
adhesion
Discovery HR
Poor Conductivity in Characterize conductive Impedance under
Rheo-Impedance Rheo-Impedance
Electrode material network in slurry process conditions
Spectroscopy
Simultaneous electrical
Predict electrode Conductive network Discovery HR
impedance and rheological
conductivity from slurry Rheo-Impedance structure under Rheo-Impedance
measurements to gain insight in
coating processing conditions Spectroscopy
slurry conductive network
A number of analysis techniques are useful for determining separators’ quality, stability, and integrity.
Thermal stability,
TGA decomposition, polymer Discovery TGA
Thermal assessments and inorganic content
Selecting high quality and
to understand
performing materials
material parameters
Melting temperature,
DSC Discovery DSC
crystallinity
Understand melt
Dimensional change
integrity, rupture
Separator shrinkage and loss as a function of
temperature, and TMA Discovery TMA
integrity at high temperature temperature, shrinkage
orientation effects to
and rupture temperature
aid material selection
Understand tensile
strength, tensile strain,
Temperature dependent
Prevent deformation during and rupture point
DMA mechanical response, Discovery DMA
manufacturing under tension to identify material
modulus and strength
capabilities and
limitation
That data can then help them determine the composition or 465.1 ºC
2
495.5 ºC
20
percentage of individual compounds in the separator, a key 0
11
Thermogravimetric data is critical to setting proper temperature limits for Differential Scanning Calorimetry method
development. Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) measures temperatures and heat flows associated with thermal
transitions in a material. DSC helps battery separator researchers analyze the melting temperature, impact on melting, and
further understand properties of the polymer content determined from the TGA results. DSC data is crucial in predicting how
different materials will impact the separators’ final properties.
When thermal analysis is combined with mechanical testing, it’s possible to understand
dimensional stability of a polymer’s length and shape, e.g., the polymer separator. This thermal and dimensional insight can
help prevent separator failure and ensure battery safety.
For mechanical analysis of separators, researchers use Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) which
measures the mechanical properties of materials as a function of time, temperature, and frequency.
One particular challenge is preventing undesired elongation of separator material, which leads to
deformation. DMA helps researchers understand tensile strength, tensile strain, and rupture point
to identify material capabilities and limitation. This data empowers labs to optimize separators for
specific applications, choosing adequate materials to offer the desired thermal and mechanical
stability at end-use conditions.
Storage modulus, loss modulus, and tan delta curves for uncoated and coated separators
Example Experiments
See how TGA, DSC, TMA, and DMA contribute to efficient and effective separator characterization in these application notes
with real experimental data:
TGA elucidates the decomposition temperature and solvent loss profile of electrolytes at high temperatures. This data
contributes to understanding the overall thermal stability of the electrolyte. Additionally, DSC measurements identify the onset
temperature and heat of reaction during exothermic decomposition. The heat of reaction can be used to estimate the heat
released during the battery runaway. Combining TGA and DSC helps researchers evaluate the safety hazards of their batteries
under chemical abuse and design effective thermal management systems.
How can you optimize the gel polymer electrolyte’s mechanical properties?
Gel polymer electrolytes uniquely act as both the electrolyte and the separator, so the mechanical concerns of a separator’s
ability to separate the electrodes also apply to this electrolyte formulation. Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) measures
the electrolyte’s temperature-dependent mechanical response, offering key insights into the electrolyte’s tensile strength,
tensile strain, and rupture point under specific conditions. DMA helps battery scientists identify their electrolyte’s material
capabilities and limitations, facilitating stages of electrolyte development through to QA/QC of electrolyte formulation. Gel
polymer electrolytes are a new formulation of interest as they offer strong electrochemical properties and improved safety over
traditional solvent-based electrolytes. Despite these advantages, gel polymer electrolytes still require significant improvements
to fully contend with liquid electrolytes.
13
How can you facilitate efficient electrolyte manufacturing with effective formulations?
A key area of electrolyte research involves optimizing formulations for ideal pumpability during manufacturing. This step offers
ample opportunity for reduced cost and increased efficiency. Rheology enables engineers to measure viscosity and produce
electrolyte solvents with optimal pumpability during manufacturing.
Components in lithium-ion batteries, such as electrolytes, lithiated materials and solid-electrolytes interface on electrode, are
highly sensitive and reactive materials with atmosphere. Testing and handling of such materials must be done in an inert
environment. It can be challenging but necessary to analysis those samples under an inert testing environment to prevent
sample integrity is compromised by a brief exposure to nitrogen, oxygen, or water.
TA Instrument Discovery TGA and Discovery Hybrid Rheometers enable glovebox operation for Argon and Nitrogen environments,
providing reliable material data of atmosphere-sensitive samples.
Resources
Application Note: Thermogravimetry of Air Sensitive Materials - TA Instruments
Optimizing thermal management systems with DSC, thermal conductivity meter and laser flash will reduce the overall cost of
the battery pack, plus ensure battery safety and efficiency.
Thermally conductive adhesive successfully holds the battery in place despite heat and offsets heat that could otherwise
impede performance. Laser Flash and thermal conductivity meter are used to measure thermal diffusivity and thermal
conductivity. This data helps battery developers select the best materials to dissipate heat.
Successful thermal interface materials must offer excellent thermal conductivity and thermal stability. All of these parameters
can be evaluated using material analysis techniques.
Measure
Evaluating an adhesive’s Thermogravimetric Analysis Degradation, thermal
degradation Discovery TGA
operating temperature limit (TGA) stability
point
Understand
Design and optimize polymer Curing, glass transition
Differential Scanning
materials and processing structure temperature, heat Discovery DSC
Calorimetry (DSC)
conditions and thermal capacity
properties
Understand flow
Optimize application
and reaction Rheology Curing, viscoelasticity Discovery HR
conditions
time
15
Casing and Enclosure
The battery, which commonly weighs 300 kilograms (661 pounds), is mounted to the casing or enclosure. Battery casings are
integral for overall battery performance, as they protect all internal components against contamination, adverse atmospheric
changes, and damage from impact. Casings are commonly made of steel, aluminum or polymers composite. Battery casings
must be molded or formed into their required shapes while providing protection for the inner components, which can be
achieved through detailed material analysis and testing.
Identify
dimensional Thermal expansion
Part delamination or failure Thermomechanical Analysis
changes that or shrinkage, thermal Discovery TMA
due to thermal change (TMA)
occur with expansion coefficient
temperature
17
TA Instruments Waters Corporation
159 Lukens Drive 34 Maple Street
TA Instruments and Waters are trademarks of Waters Corporation.
New Castle, DE 19720 U.S.A. Milford, MA 01757 U.S.A.
All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
T: 1 302 427 4000 T: 1 508 478 2000
©2024 Waters Corporation. All rights reserved. F: 1 302 427 4041 F: 1 508 872 1990
July 2024 BAT00002EN Rev. A www.tainstruments.com www.waters.com