Wastewater Instrumentation For Monitoring and Control
Wastewater Instrumentation For Monitoring and Control
1
Introduction
• N & P discharged into Surface Waters
• Algae consume N & P and reproduce
• Bacteria eat algae and “breathe” O2
• Low DO kills fish, shellfish, invertebrates
Effects of Eutrophication
Effects of Eutrophication
Impaired Waters
• EPA (2008)
– 168 Hypoxic Areas in USA
– 1200 Nitrate Effluent Violations at DW plants
– Mandate: States to establish nutrient limits in surface
waters
CO2
VFA Glycogen
CO2 + H2O
Glycogen
EMP
Ac-COA
O2
NADH
Energy PHA
PHA
Poly-P
Poly-P
PO4
PO4 PO4
PO4 PO4
PO4 PO4
PO4
AlPO4 FePO4
FePO4
AlPO4 FePO4
AlPO4
AlPO4 FePO4
Phosphorus
Real
Time
Controller
• Measuring Plant Effluent orthophosphate
• Measuring Plant Effluent flow
• Output exact dose to meet 0.60mg/L PO4-P setpoint
• Saving 55% compared to previous static dose
$ $ $ $ $
Biological N Removal
Y can’t
You ’t control
t lb bacteria
t i
You can only control their environment
NO3 NO3 NO3
ANOXIC AEROBIC
DO < 0.5mg/L, Nitrate Present DO > 0.5mg/L
NO3
BOD N2 NH4
O2
HCO3
NO3
CO2
+
H2 O
Q PO4
HW UV
Anoxic Aerobic
Phosphate Analyzer
• Orthophosphate
– Molybdovanadate
• “Yellow method”
– 0.05 – 15.0 mg/L PO4-P
– +/- 2% accuracy
– Self Filtering
Pinery Water & Wastewater
Parker, CO
• 2 MGD, TP < 0.05 mg/L
• 5 Stage System with alum addition
and mixed media filters
• Instrumentation:
– 4 ORP Sensors
– 5 pH Sensors
– 4 LDO Sensors
– 2 Phosphate Analyzers
– 2 Turbidimeters
Stamford WPCF (CT)
• 24 MGD, TN 1057lbs/day
• 4 Stage System with methanol feed and
UV disinfection
• Instrumentation:
– 4 Ammonia analyzers
– 1 Ammonia sensor
– 6 Nitrate/Nitrite sensors
– 1 MLSS sensor
– 4 LDO sensor
– 2 Sludge Blanket sensors
• 2009: Earned $961,118 with credits
Nitrate Sensors
• Nitrate Nitrogen
– Reagentless
– UV absorbance
– Ion Selective Electrode
Wyoming Valley San. Auth.
(PA)
• 32 MGD, Load Limits
– TN limit: 584,000 lbs/yr
– TP limit: 77,000 lbs/yr
• Schreiber™ System
• Pilot Test: control aeration
– Ammonia Sensors
– Nitrate Sensors
– LDO sensors
• Meets new limits, $20M
upgrade unnecessary
Online Methods for Analysis
• Total Nitrogen
– Digestion with Ozone
and Hydroxyl Radical
• Oxidizes everything to
nitrate
• Measured with UV
absorbance
• 0.3 – 100,000mg/L N
• < 8 min. cycle time
• +/- 3% Accuracy
Online Methods for Analysis
• Total Phosphorus
– Digestion with Ozone
and Hydroxyl Radical
• Oxidizes everything to
phosphate
• Measured with
molybdovanadate
reagent
• 0.3 – 100,000mg/L P
• < 20 min. cycle time
• +/- 3% Accuracy
Other Valuable Tests
• Dissolved Oxygen
• Oxidation – Reduction Potential (ORP)
• Total Suspended Solids
• Volatile Fatty Acids
• pH
• Alkalinity
• COD
ORP Sensor
ORP
ORP in SBR
ORP in SBR
ORP in BNR
Take Home Messages
7
Luminescent Dissolved Oxygen
Probe • The sensor is coated with
luminescent material
Sensor
• Blue light from an LED excites the
Photo Diode material
• The excited material emits red
light
• Oxygen ‘steals’ energy from the
O O2 O2 luminescent material
O2 O2 2
O2 O2
O2 • The time it takes for the material
to stop emitting light directly
relates to the amount of
dissolved oxygen present in the
sample
Aeration Control
• Solution – Long Term
– Automated Blower Control with online
luminescent dissolved oxygen sensors (LDO)
desired value
current
VFD value
O2
Aeration Basin
9
**RESULTS**
1 Kiser,
Phil “Advances in Online Dissolved Oxygen Measurement Using Luminescent Technology”. Presented at 2006
ISA Automation Week Conference
Verify online readings with a portable
.39
.43 75.3F
74.6F
11
Problem
• Larger WWTP with 10mg/L TN Limit (Total
Nitrogen)
• Poor Effluent Quality Forcing Construction
– Additional Clarifier and Filter
• Have LDO sensors & use for Aeration Control
– Ammonia sensor was faulty—repairs in Europe
• No budget for additional capital construction
• Operational budget cut by $50,000
AMMONIA SENSOR
Nitrified
recycle
DO DO
Filter UV
Anoxic Aerobic
Ammonium Probe
• Ion Selective Electrodes
• Direct in basin measurement
• High Range
• Medium Precision
• Change cartridge every 3 – 6 mo
Ammonia Analyzer
• Low Range, High precision
applications
• Sample Prep & Delivery:
– Filter probe for mixed liquor
– Filtrax for Primary Effluent
• Gasification Method
• Change reagents 3 – 6 mo
Results
• Controlling Aeration by Ammonia
• From 9,500 – 12,000 to 8,000 – 9,000 kwh/d
• $90,000/yr Energy Savings
• ROI: 2.8 Months
• Sludge Quality Improved
– No need for additional Clarifier & Filter
– Estimated at $3,200,000
Aeration
Suspended Solids
What are Suspended Solids?
Total Suspended Solids or TSS is defined as - the
amount of filterable solids in a water sample
Why Measure Suspended Solids
• Determine the Mixed Liquor Suspended Solids
• Calculate the Return Activated Sludge (RAS)
• Calculate the Waste Activated Sludge (WAS)
• Calculate the Sludge Retention time (SRT)
• Calculate Mean Cell Residence Time (MCRT or Sludge Age)
• Determine the depth/height of the Sludge Blanket
• Determine the efficiency of the dewatering mechanics
• Solids interfere with disinfection
Control of Solids Inventory- Can:
• Allow additional capacity to be realized in individual unit processes;
• Reduce the energy use & costs associated with aeration in biological processes
• Reduce biosolids mgnt costs by reducing the quantity of solids requiring processing
# of Bacteria
time
Sludge Age
• The right sludge age for your system means:
– The bacteria will remove pollutants
– The sludge will settle
• “Off” 8 min
• “On” 2 min
– Aerobic Digester
Sludge
• Clear water in WAS Aerobic Holding Drying
Digester Tank Beds
RAS
14000
12000
10000
mg/L TSS
8000
6000
4000
2000
0
TSS Sensors
• Emit an infrared 860nm light
• 90° detector for turbidity
• 90° and the 140° detectors for
Suspended Solids
• Color does not interfere
• Compensates for particle size
& shape
• Range: 0.1mg/L – 15%+
• +/- 5% Accuracy
Automatic Sludge Age Control
• No guessing if
sc200 Aeration Basin TSS
sample was (BOD & Ammonia Removal)
representative
PLC
• Use today’s Return Activated Sludge
• Free up Q
Valve
operators to Waste Activated Sludge (Bacteria
• Overfeed of Polymer
• Underfeed of Polymer
• Thickened sludge
variability
DAF- Dissolved Air Flotation
• What is a DAF? A vessel that uses chemicals and
dissolved gases to remove contaminates
Influent
Effluent
Centrate
Wastewater Influent
Wastewater Effluent
EQ Basin
1
Typical pH Applications
*Wastewater treatment • Odor scrubbers
*Drinking water • Pharmaceutical
*Neutralization of effluent • Chemical &
– Steel Petrochemical
– Pulp and Paper • Reverse osmosis
– Food • Cooling tower control
– Chemical • Food processing
– Pharmaceutical – Carbon dioxide
Chrome destruct control
Cyanide destruct – Cleaning
High purity water – Canning
2
Where do you measure pH?
Odor Control
Why measure pH in wastewater?
• Inlet
– protect biological treatment (bacteria)
• Aeration Basins/Denitrification
– monitor biological activity
• Digester
– control reactor pH levels (bacteria)
• Outlet:
– protect environment (fish etc.)
• Neutralization
– largely industrial requirement
pH Measurement Problems
• Lab vs. Online
• Fouling
• Reference Electrolyte
• Ground Loops
• Low Conductivity (industrial)
• Lifecycle
• How accurate do you need?
Process pH Accuracy
• Real life reproducibility is +/- 0.1 or 0.2 pH units if:
– Proper Sensor Chosen
– Proper Installation
– Properly Maintained
• “The best results are often obtained by going to three
electrodes and leaving them alone.”
– Choose the middle signal
– Only recalibrate when:
• Sensor is cleaned & gel layer disturbed
• Difference between lab & process consistently large
Source: McMillan, G.K. and Cameron, R.A., Advanced pH Measurement and Control, 3rd
Edition, ISA – The Instrumentation, Systems, and Automation Society, 2005.
Selecting the right Sensor
Technical
Support
Dirty Samples Quick Sampling
Process Lab
Applications Applications
Technical
Quick Sampling
Dirty Samples Support
• Rugged portable meters for rapid
• Probe life extended with references analysis throughout plant
protected from sulfides & proteins • Measure multiple parameters right
• Clogging reduced with junctions designed inside the meter – no probe needed
for particulates and suspensions
Industrial Pre-treatment
•Industrial dischargers may
send their waste directly to
municipal wastewater plants.
•Acids
Acid Feed Caustic Feed
•Heavy metals
•Solvents
Solenoid Valves
Influent
-These substances must be
monitored to ensure the health pH Effluent
of the bio-system and ensure Mixer
Sensor
Equalization Basin
Acid Feed Caustic Feed
Modulating Valves
Modulating Valves
Influent
pH Effluent
Mixer Sensor
10
Odor Control
Odors are released
as they enter the
primary clarifier and
sludge drying areas.
There are
mechanical systems
that use pH
measurement to
make chemical
feed adjustment to
control odor. 11
Wastewater Influent
Wastewater Effluent
EQ Basin
13
Managing Organics
humic acid
cellulose
nicotinic acid
estradiol
naphthalene
carboxylic acids dodecane (and other alkanes/paraffins)
1
Biggest Issues with Organics
SAC
Mineral Oils
BOD
COD TOC
3
What we are seeing…
Type Definition Accuracy*
Bio-available organics and other compounds that can be
BOD 15%
oxidized through consumption of dissolved oxygen
Bio-available organics with an inhibiting agent added to
CBOD prevent nitrogen oxidation through consumption of 15%
dissolved oxygen
Chemical oxygen demand, measuring the reduction of
COD (Cr) chromium: Cr2O72- (orange-colored) Cr3+ (green- <3%
colored)
Chemical oxygen demand, measuring the reduction of
COD (Mn) <3%
manganese: Manganese Mn(III) purple-colored Mn(II)
Total organic carbon, measuring the amount of CO2
TOC <3%
generated after oxidation of carbon
Spectral absorbance coefficient, measuring the
Trending
SAC absorbance of 254nm by certain organic molecules with
Tool
double & triple bonds
humic acid
cellulose
nicotinic acid
estradiol
naphthalene
carboxylic acids dodecane (and other alkanes/paraffins)
5
Key Applications and
Issues with Each
Measurement
6
BOD & CBOD
7
Issues and Root Causes
Failure Mode Key Root Cause(s)
Organic contamination in
Blank depletion dilution water or bottles
Drift in DO sensor
Effluent fails to achieve Insufficient nutrient or seed
2 ppm depletion Toxicity
Inaccurate G/GA
Fail G/GA reference Toxicity
Insufficient seed
www.boddoctor.com 8
Products for BOD
Chemical Oxygen Demand
• Food estimate?
• Tracking industrial dischargers?
• Anyone charging industrial discharges
based on COD instead of BOD?
COD for Rapid Organic Estimates
12
The COD Problem…Waste…
• EZ COD recycling
– Fill bucket with used COD Vials
– Heritage Environmental will pick
up and recycle
300
250
Organics spiked
200
to >3X normal
Organics, SAC/m
150
within 2 hours UV Organics (m-1)
100
50
0
2/16/2005 19:12 2/17/2005 0:00 2/17/2005 4:48 2/17/2005 9:36 2/17/2005 14:24 2/17/2005 19:12 2/18/2005 0:00 2/18/2005 4:48
Date/Time
Total Organic Carbon
humic acid
cellulose
nicotinic acid
estradiol
naphthalene
carboxylic acids dodecane (and other alkanes/paraffins)
19
Online Total Organic Carbon
• Accuracy: +/- 3%
• Automatic cleaning
0.8 mm ID
D
3.2 mm ID
D
UV254 Organics Discussion
humic acid
cellulose
nicotinic acid
estradiol
naphthalene
carboxylic acids dodecane (and other alkanes/paraffins)
22
Spectral Absorbance Coefficient
300
200
100
0
0 24 48 72 96 120 144 168
time [h]
• Target: - steady loading to the aeration basin
->optimal denitrification and biological phosphorus removal
• Solution: - bypass the primary clarifier during low loading
- supplement external carbon sources
26
Comparison between
SAC/TOC and SAC/COD
Ganglinienvergleich der Geräte TOCTAX und UVASplus
am Ablauf einer Vorklärung
160
Konzentration [mg/l TOC bzw. mg/l DOCuv]
140
120
SAC / TOC
100
80
Primary Effluent
60
40
20
0
28. Sep 29. Sep 30. Sep 1. Okt 2. Okt 3. Okt 4. Okt
400 40
SAC / COD
300 30
Raw Influent
200 20
100 10
t [h]
0 0
0 24 48 72 96 120
27
Dissolved Organics
28
29
Wastewater Instrumentation for Monitoring
and Control
Transforming Data into Information to
Ensure Wastewater Quality
Data is dumb.
Result Step
INFORMATION
Calculation Step
METRIC
Input Step
DATA
DATA
Symbols Individual facts
Answers th
A the questions
ti
Who, what, where, when
Answers th
A the questions
ti
WHY
Lab Data
• Excel Sheet #2
spreadsheet
Field Data
• Excel Sheet #3
spreadsheet
Reports
LAB
SCADA Audit trail FIELD
Central
Database
Solution
Trending
Reports Notifications
Analysis
KNOWLEDGE
• DO NOTHING
– Wait for things to happen, hope for the best
• DO THE SAME THING
– Try to react to the ever-changing environment we live in
• EMPLOY A INFORMATION MANAGEMENT STRATEGY
– Maintain all of your data into a single database
– Put into into context
– Transform it into information
– Create knowledge by bringing your data and information together
– Use that knowledge to make the best decisions in the shortest time
– Manage your risk, before it manages you.
Use a Compliance
Troubleshoot Issues
Let Software do the Detective Work
– Compliance issues
– Customer complaints
• Use predictive modeling tools to prevent future issues from
occurring
– Develop "what if" scenarios
• Perform simple or complex search queries
– Find the exact information you need
Automatically Compare & Verify All Info
Immediately
identify
Flag change in the
problemss so
so system
you know
exactly
where they
occurred
Maintain Accurate Records with Audit Trails
Audit trails
show who
touched
the data
Waste water example-Inf flow v. rainfall
it to your advantage
Turn Raw Data into Actionable Information
Waste Water
Example Discharge
Monitoring Report
Example Inflow/
Infiltration Study
45
Case 1: Improving Aeration Efficiency
Oxygen transfer efficiency is a function of bubble size. The smaller the bubble, the
higher the efficiency. Ceramic or membrane diffusers will foul in time, causing the
bubble size to increase. To minimize energy used and reduce downtime, it is important
to determine when diffusers need to be cleaned.
47
Case 3: Real-time estimation of BOD
The time-lag in obtaining BOD results, a 5-day lab test, make it challenging for plant
operations to adjust treatment processes to adverse levels of BOD. A site-specific
correlation between on-line UV absorbance against lab BOD measurements was
obtained. With this BOD can be estimated in real-time, allowing for the optimization for
treatment processes and avoidance of potential violations.
48