All Substantive Procedures
All Substantive Procedures
REV SCHEDULE
ASSET TYPE CV FV SURPLUS
XX (FROM FAR) XX XX
XX XX XX XX
EXPENSES
COMPLETENESS Obtain expenses ledger, check mathematical accuracy and
trace total of expenses to financial statements.
CUT OFF Reviewing the expense transactions around year-end, e.g. ten
days before year-end and after year-end. And examine
whether they are recorded in the correcting period by
vouching to the supporting documents.
OCCURRENCE 1. Select a sample of recorded expenses transactions from
the general ledger.
2. Vouch the selected transactions to the supplier's invoices
to ensure transactions recorded are based on the supplier's
invoices.
3. Trace the supplier's invoices to the purchased orders and
goods received notes (receiving reports) to ensure that the
goods had been received when the expense was recorded.
ACCURACY By agreeing the expense transactions in the general ledger to
supporting documents, such as supplier's invoice, goods
received note (receiving report) and purchase order, we can
ensure both accuracy and occurrence assertion.
CLASSIFICATION 1. By agreeing the expense transactions in the general
ledger to supporting documents ensure whether
classification is correct or not?
2. Scan ledger for unusual expenses.
TAXES
1. Obtain tax working from client.
2. Evaluate whether adjustments to arrive at taxable income have been made as
per ITO 2001.
3. For complex issues consider appointing auditor's expert.
4. Inspect rate of tax from ITO 2001.
5. Recalculate current tax expense.
6. Recalculate deferred tax on temporary differences.
7. Evaluate reasonableness of the disclosures related to taxation.
LEASES
Risks:
1. Total leases might not be accounted for.
2. Classification of lease
3. Lease term assessment is not correct.
4. Discount rate might be inappropriate.
5. Risk that proper disclosure might not be provided.
Substantive Procedures:
1. Obtain lease schedule from management, Check mathematical accuracy and
match total to the financial statements.
2. Inspect board minutes to identify approval of any new lease agreement.
3. Inspect and scan rental ledger to identify possible lease agreement.
4. Select a sample of leases (Additions) and inspect rental amount, interest rate
(if any) and lease term.
5. If there is no interest rate mentioned in the lease agreement, then assess
whether entity has taken appropriate IRR for purpose of calculations
6. Assess reasonableness of the lease term.
7. Recalculate ROUA and lease liability and match with lease schedules provided
by the client.
8. Recalculate depreciation on ROUA.
9. Recalculate interest expense on lease liabilities.
10. Inspect bank statement to verify payments of rentals.
11. Check reasonableness of the disclosures made in the FS.
INVESTMENTS
COMPLETENESS Obtain schedule of investments, check mathematical
accuracy and trace total to financial statements.
EXISTENCE 1. Perform direct confirmation with the brokerage (for
investments held by broker).
2. Physically inspect all investments (for investments
held by the client).
3. Vouch new purchases and disposals of investments to
supporting documents, e.g. broker's advice.
VALUATION 1. Recalculate value of investment by multiplying
number of shares / debentures with fair value at
reporting date.
2. Determine whether gains or losses, as a result of
changes in market value, have been properly recorded
3. Recalculate interest income or dividend income from
investments.
RIGHTS & OBLIGATIONS 1. Inquire management about any restrictions placed on
investments.
2. Examine related documents to determine whether
there are any restrictions on investments.
ACCRUALS
1. Obtain or prepare a listing of accruals as at the end of the reporting period.
2. If the list is prepared by the client company, check the calculations and additions for
arithmetical accuracy. Check the amounts in the listing against the balances in the
relevant main ledger expense accounts and ensure that the amounts are the same.
3. Where invoices have been received, or payments made, after the year end, confirm that
the amount accrued appears reasonable in relation to this evidence. For example,
suppose that a company makes an accrual for two months of electricity charges, and
receives an invoice for three months' supply of electricity one month after the year-
end. If the accrual for electricity is, say, Rs. 60,000 (Rs. 30,000 per month), the auditor
should expect the total invoice to be for about Rs. 90,000.
4. Compare the list of accruals with the list that was prepared at the same date in the
previous financial year, and enquire about items not listed in the current year that were
in the list in the previous year.
5. Review the list of accruals for completeness, based on the auditor's knowledge of the
business.
6. Relate items on the list of accruals to other audit areas, such as the bank confirmation
letter (which might provide details of unpaid/accrued bank charges).
SALARY EXPENSE
1. Obtain payroll data for the year (for each month), check mathematical
accuracy and trace the total back to GL.
3. Select a sample of employees from payroll file and check their salaries from
their employee records /appointment
4. Obtain/extract time in and time out records from the system and check
whether hours for each month have been appropriately reflecting in the payroll
sheet
5. For bonus check BOD approval
6. Check approval of BOD for increment
7. Recalculate salary expense for each month.
8. Check payment of salaries from the bank statements
9. Check that salary expense / salary accrued in a relevant period.
10. for accrued salaries check subsequent payment by obtaining subsequent
bank statements
11. Check whether deductions have been made in accordance with ITO 2001.
12. Check whether tax deducted from the employee's salary have been
deposited timely.
CHANGE IN ACCOUNTING POLICY
In entity / in question it is given that the
company has changed its accounting policy
RISKS:
RISK #1: There is a risk that accounting policy might have been changed to
manipulate results or it might not be allowed
EXAMPLE: (IP -> Carried at FV -> Cost pe nahi ja saktey) Change in accounting
policy is allowed only when it will result in reliable and more accurate
information
Risk #2: There is a risk that accounting policy impact might not have been
adjusted retrospectively.
Risk #3: There is a risk that retrospective adjustments might not have been
parked correctly.
Risk # 4: Proper disclosures required by IFRS might not have been prepared
PROCEDURES:
1. Evaluate that whether change in accounting policy is reasonable and will
result in reliable and more accurate information.
a. Check whether it is allowed by applicable financial reporting
framework
b. Check whether it is not done to manipulate results
2. Obtain management working of restatement
3. Evaluate whether the change in accounting policy has been accounted for
retrospectively (where practicable)
4. Check management working and perform recalculations
5. Ensure that amounts have been parked in financial statements
appropriately.
6. Ensure that proper disclosures have been as required by IFRS
7. Whether change in accounting policy is approved by BOD.
INTANGIBLES
COMPLETENESS 1. Review purchase agreements, contracts, and invoices for any
acquired intangible assets.
2. Verify internally generated intangibles (e.g., software, R&D) are
recorded per accounting standards.
3. Cross-check amortization schedules with the general ledger to
confirm all intangibles are included.
VALUATION & 1. Verify that intangibles are recorded at cost or fair value, as required
ALLOCATION by accounting standards.
2. Check the amortization calculations for definite-life intangibles and
ensure compliance with the company’s policy.
3. For indefinite-life intangibles (e.g., goodwill), review the impairment
testing methodology and key assumptions (discount rate, growth
rate, etc.).
4. Compare carrying amounts with market values or comparable
industry data to assess reasonableness.
5. Review the treatment of acquisition costs, R&D capitalization, and
software development costs to ensure proper accounting treatment.
EXISTENCE 1. Confirm existence by reviewing legal documents, contracts, and
registrations (e.g., patent filings, trademark registrations).
2. Verify the physical or operational presence of software, trademarks,
or customer lists through system checks or business records.
3. Obtain third-party confirmations for intangibles acquired from
vendors or through mergers and acquisitions.
RIGHTS & 1. Inspect patent registrations, trademark filings, copyright certificates,
OBLIGATIONS and licensing agreements to confirm ownership.
2. Review legal disputes or contractual restrictions that may limit the
company’s rights to use or transfer intangibles.
3. Check for any licensing arrangements, royalty agreements, or shared
ownership contracts that could affect rights.
4. Verify that intangibles pledged as collateral for loans are properly
disclosed.
CUT OFF 1. Review purchase documents and contract dates to ensure newly
acquired intangibles are recorded in the correct period.
2. Inspect amortization and impairment schedules to verify that
expenses are recorded in the appropriate accounting periods.
PRESENTATION AND 1. Verify that intangibles are correctly classified as either definite-life or
DISCLOSURE indefinite-life in the balance sheet.
2. Check that amortization and impairment losses are disclosed
separately in the financial statements.
3. Ensure compliance with IFRS (IAS 38) disclosure requirements.
IMPAIREMENT TESTING OF PPE/INTANGIBLES (PROCEDURES)
1. Obtain an understanding of management process related to identifying,
estimating and recording impairments for PPE.
2. Obtain management working related to impairment of PPE, including VIU & its
reasonableness
o Methodology of calculating VIU.
o Check demand of units by obtaining subsequent sales ledger
o Check demand of units by inspecting market research reports
o Evaluate assess reasonableness / accuracy of source data
o Check quantity by evaluating capacity of the company.
o Check internal consistency of the data
o Check appropriateness of discount rate
o Check mathematical accuracy of the model.
o Maker checker principle (Ik bnda working bnae dusra review kry)
3. Review the source data used by the management for impairment testing.
4. Assess the reasonableness of assumptions taken by the management. Such as
by checking subsequent period sales (inflows), subsequent cost incurred,
discount rate used and fair value assessment etc.
5. Consider involving auditor's expert.