Peds 2023060221b
Peds 2023060221b
Throughout the world, there has childhood and adolescence, and to neural plasticity and sensitivity to
been widespread recognition that become healthy, caring, and environmental interactions, leading to
children’s development is shaped by productive adults, assuming long-term negative consequences on
the cultural context and interactions responsibilities for their family, children’s health and development.11
that begin prenatally and extend community, and society. With The effects of poverty on the
throughout childhood.1,2 Children declines in child mortality5 and developing brain are mediated by
raised in stable and nurturing fertility over the past 30 years,6 caregiving behavior and stressful
settings that provide adequate resulting in smaller family sizes, experiences, illustrating the
nutrition, responsive caregiving, along with increases in early powerful potential of responsive
protection from adversities, and childcare7 and parents’ interest in caregiving.12,13
opportunities for learning, along with their young children’s learning
health and educational services, have opportunities,8 it is not surprising In the United States, between 2017
the best chance of reaching their full that The World Health Organization and 2020, 17% of children under 18
developmental potential.3,4 Nurturing and other international organizations years of age (12.6 million children)
interactions begin with families and regard investments in children as an lived in families with incomes below
extend to community programs and essential strategy to achieving the the poverty line ($26 246 for 2 adults
services, including childcare United National Sustainable and 2 children).14 Throughout the
providers, and to policies that shape Development Goals.1,9,10 world, hundreds of millions of
the macrosocial environment. children experience poverty and
Children’s early competencies can Poverty and environmental adverse experiences in their
prepare them to achieve increasingly deprivation disrupt children’s early communities or households that can
complex competencies throughout brain development during periods of disrupt their developmental
a
University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland; bRTI International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina; cCaribbean Institute for Health Research, The University of the
West Indies, Kingston, Jamaica; dYale University, New Haven, Connecticut; eInter-American Development Bank, Washington, District of Columbia; fInternational Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease
Research, Bangladesh, Dhaka, Bangladesh; gUniversity of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, California; and hInstitute of Child Health, University College London, London, England
Dr Black was part of the Working Group for the supplement, conceptualized and designed the supplement, reviewed the paper included in the supplement, and drafted the
introductory manuscript. Drs Walker, Attanasio, Rubio-Codina, Meghir, Hamadani, Fernald, Kowalski, and Grantham-McGregor were part of the Working Group for the supplement,
conceptualized and designed the supplement, reviewed the papers included in the supplement, and reviewed and revised the introductory manuscript; and all authors approved the
final introductory manuscript as submitted and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
This paper and supplement present the authors’ views and not those of the institutions they represent, including the Inter-American Development Bank, its board of directors, or the
countries they represent.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2023-060221B
Accepted for publication Feb 17, 2023
Address correspondence to Maureen M. Black, PhD, Department of Pediatrics, University of Maryland School of Medicine, 737 W. Lombard St, Rm 161, Baltimore, Maryland 21201. E-mail: mblack@som.
umaryland.edu
PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275).
Copyright © 2023 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
FUNDING: Funding for the supplement was provided by the New Venture Fund to the University of Maryland School of Medicine and the Jacobs Foundation to Yale University.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST DISCLOSURES: The authors have indicated they have no conflicts of interest relevant to this article to disclose.
S2 BLACK et al
Downloaded from http://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-pdf/151/Supplement 2/e2023060221B/1476481/peds_2023060221b.pdf
by guest
difficult settings, integrating early and instant messages among to an existing parenting program in
intervention with other services, caregivers of young children rural Colombia and found benefits
delivering services remotely, and recruited from health centers in to childhood development and to
partnering with government Brazil and Jamaica who met risk caregiving practices, particularly
agencies, among others. criteria.33 Through a mixed methods maternal engagement, when quality
design, they documented the was high.38 Their observational
The initial commentary is written by positive effects of remote delivery of measure of quality has the potential
Professor Heckman, a Nobel laureate the intervention on caregiving to promote and maintain
in economics who demonstrated the practices. intervention quality at scale. In
economic benefits of investing in 2019, over 71 million children
early childhood development.30 His Although there have been multiple under age 5 had spent their entire
commentary highlights the central calls for integrated interventions,10 lives in crisis and conflict zones.
role of the family in building few have been implemented. Tofail Based on their experiences of
successful pathways for young et al implemented a group-delivered implementing adapted versions of
children. The first paper in the intervention in health facilities in Reach Up in crisis and conflict areas
supplement is a meta-analysis of 18 Bangladesh that addressed of Bangladesh, Syria, and Venezuela,
studies across 8 countries that childhood development, along with Wilton et al documented the
implemented the Reach Up program. maternal mental health.34 Their importance of cultural adaptation of
Jervis et al found benefits on findings of beneficial effects on interventions from a holistic
children’s development and home multiple domains of children’s perspective of children and
stimulation across 2 delivery development and improvements in caregivers, the inclusion of safety
strategies (home visits and small mothers’ depressive symptoms and and linkages to complementary
groups), implemented at varying caregiving illustrate the merits of services, and incorporating blended
levels of scale.31 This analysis group-delivery of integrated models and costing analyses.39
highlights how Reach Up has been interventions in health facilities. In
successfully implemented across an innovative design, Meghir et al Exposure to violence early in life
studied the timing and duration of can disrupt children’s brain
multiple settings and among diverse
interventions by comparing children development, increasing their risk
populations, even as a national
in India randomized to receive for socio-emotional problems.40 Two
program. In the second paper,
interventions delivered before age 3 papers in the supplement addressed
Hossain et al examined the effects of
and/or following age 3.35 violence prevention. Jensen et al
early childhood intervention among
Interventions among both age examined associations between
children in Bangladesh after 6 years
categories benefited children’s IQ intimate partner violence and harsh
and found sustained effects of
and school readiness. The finding child discipline in Rwanda.41 They
cognitive development among
that children receiving interventions implemented an intervention that
children without a history of
at both time periods did not reduced harsh discipline by
anemia.32 The anemic group did not
experience differential benefits increasing father engagement and
experience benefits either
requires additional investigation. parenting warmth among female
immediately following the
The Reach Up program has been caregivers, illustrating that violence
intervention or at the 6-year follow- implemented among approximately reduction can be effectively
up, suggesting that specialized 1500 children in an impoverished integrated into early childhood
interventions are necessary for region of Western China.36 Zhou et development programs to reduce
children with specific conditions, al found that the intervention was harsh discipline and intimate
such as anemia and disabilities. successfully implemented at scale, partner violence. Baker-Henningham
These findings add to the evidence with effect sizes that were et al used implementation science
on the sustainability of early comparable to those found among principles in the design,
intervention, as well as the harmful the original Jamaica Program. They implementation, and scaling of 2
effects of anemia. The coronavirus note the benefits of starting early violence-prevention caregiver-
disease 2019 pandemic disrupted and report on program costs. training programs for preschoolers
many early intervention programs. in Jamaica: a teacher-training
Smith et al evaluated the Although the importance of program program and a caregiving
development, adaptation, quality has been well established,37 program.42
implementation, and impact of a there has been limited attention to
remote version of Reach Up strategies to advance quality. Bernal The final paper in the supplement,
implemented through phone, text, et al developed quality enhancement by King et al, describes a protocol
S4 BLACK et al
Downloaded from http://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-pdf/151/Supplement 2/e2023060221B/1476481/peds_2023060221b.pdf
by guest
Kenya: the case for centre-based child 19. Duncan GJ, Sojourner AJ. Can intensive early childhood stimulation trial. J Child
care. J Fam Stud. 2022;27(1):93–111 early childhood intervention programs Psychol Psychiatry. 2022;63(6):626–635
9. World Health Organization. Sustainable eliminate income- based cognitive and 30. Heckman JJ. Jamaica Reach Up: its con-
development goals. Available at: https:// achievement gaps? J Hum Resour. tribution to policy and science. Pediat-
www.who.int/europe/about-us/our-work/ 2013;48(4):945–968 rics. 2023;151(Suppl 2):e2023060221C
sustainable-development-goals. Accessed 20. Lee SY, Kim R, Rodgers J, Subramanian 31. Jervis P, Coore-Hall J, Pitchik HO, et al.
February 4, 2023 SV. Treatment effect heterogeneity in the The Reach Up parenting program, child
10. Daelmans B, Darmstadt GL, Lombardi J, head start impact study: a systematic re- development, and maternal depression: a
et al; Lancet Early Childhood Development view of study characteristics and find- meta-analysis. Pediatrics. 2023;151(Suppl
Series Steering Committee. Early child- ings. SSM Popul Health. 2021;16:100916 2):e2023060221D
hood development: the foundation of sus- 21. Olds DL, Kitzman H, Cole R, et al. Effects 32. Hossain SJ, Tofail F, Mehrin SF, Hamadani
tainable development. Lancet. 2017; of nurse home-visiting on maternal life JD. Six year follow up of childhood of
389(10064):9–11 course and child development: age 6 fol- childhood stimulation on development of
11. Johnson SB, Riis JL, Noble KG. State of low-up results of a randomized trial. Pe- children with and without anemia. Pediat-
the art review: poverty and the develop- diatrics. 2004;114(6):1550–1559 rics. 2023;151(Suppl 2):e2023060221E
ing brain. Pediatrics. 2016;137(4): 22. Zigler E, Pfannenstiel JC, Seitz V. The Pa- 33. Smith JA, Chang SM, Brentani A, et al. A
e20153075 rents as Teachers program and school remote parenting program and parent
12. Luby JL, Baram TZ, Rogers CE, Barch DM. success: a replication and extension. J and staff perspectives: A randomized
Neurodevelopmental optimization after Prim Prev. 2008;29(2):103–120 trial. Pediatrics. 2023;151(Suppl
early-life adversity: cross-species studies 23. Grantham-McGregor SM, Powell CA, 2):e2023060221F
to elucidate sensitive periods and brain Walker SP, Himes JH. Nutritional supple- 34. Tofail F, Islam M, Akter F, et al. An inte-
mechanisms to inform early intervention. mentation, psychosocial stimulation, and grated mother-child Intervention on child
Trends Neurosci. 2020;43(10):744–751 mental development of stunted children: development and maternal mental
13. Luby J, Belden A, Botteron K, et al. The ef- the Jamaican Study. Lancet. 1991; health. Pediatrics. 2023;151(Suppl
fects of poverty on childhood brain devel- 338(8758):1–5 2):e2023060221G
opment: the mediating effect of 24. Gertler P, Heckman J, Pinto R, et al. Labor 35. Meghir C, Attanasio O, Jervis P, et al.
caregiving and stressful life events. JAMA market returns to an early childhood Early stimulation and enhanced pre-
Pediatr. 2013;167(12):1135–1142 stimulation intervention in Jamaica. Sci- school: A randomized trial. Pediatrics.
14. The Annie E. Casey Foundation. 2022 Kids ence. 2014;344(6187):998–1001 2023;151(Suppl 2):e2023060221H
Count Data Book. Baltimore, MD: The An- 25. Lucas JE, Richter LM, Daelmans B. Care 36. Zhou J, Heckman JJ, Liu B, Lu M, Chang
nie E. Casey Foundation; 2022 for Child Development: an intervention in SM, Grantham-McGregor S. Comparing
15. Grantham-McGregor S, Cheung YB, Cueto support of responsive caregiving and China REACH and the Jamaica Home Vis-
S, Glewwe P, Richter L, Strupp B; Interna- early child development. Child Care iting Program. Pediatrics. 2023;151(Suppl
Health Dev. 2018;44(1):41–49 2):e2023060221I
tional Child Development Steering Group.
Developmental potential in the first 5 26. Jeong J, Franchett EE, Ramos de Oliveira 37. Araujo MC, Marta M, Schady N. Child
years for children in developing coun- CV, Rehmani K, Yousafzai AK. Parenting in- care quality and child development. J
tries. Lancet. 2007;369(9555):60–70 terventions to promote early child devel- Hum Resour. 2019;54(3):656–682
16. Lu C, Black MM, Richter LM. Risk of poor opment in the first three years of life: a 38. Bernal R, Gomez ML, Perez-Cardona S,
development in young children in low-in- global systematic review and meta-analy- Baker-Henningham H. Implementation
come and middle-income countries: an sis. PLoS Med. 2021;18(5):e1003602 quality of an early childhood parenting
estimation and analysis at the global, re- 27. Bronfenbrenner U, Morris PA. The bioeco- program in Colombia and child develop-
gional, and country level. Lancet Glob logical model of human development. In: ment. Pediatrics. 2023;151(Suppl
Health. 2016;4(12):e916–e922 Lerner RM, Damon W, eds. Handbook of 2):e2023060221J
17. American Academy of Pediatrics. Early Child Psychology: Theoretical Models of 39. Wilton KS, Murphy KM, Mahmud A, et al.
childhood health and development. Avail- Human Development. Hoboken, NJ: John Adapting Reach Up and Learn in crisis
able at: https://www.aap.org/en/ Wiley & Sons Inc.; 2006:793–828 and conflict settings: an exploratory mul-
patient-care/early-childhood/ 28. Sameroff AJ. The Transactional Model of tiple case study. Pediatrics.
early-childhood-health-and-development/. Development: How Children and Contexts 2023;151(4):e2023060221K
Accessed February 4, 2023 Shape Each Other. Washington, DC: Amer- 40. Miguel PM, Pereira LO, Silveira PP,
18. Brooks-Gunn J, McCarton CM, Casey PH, ican Psychological Association Press; Meaney MJ. Early environmental influen-
et al. Early intervention in low-birth- 2009 ces on the development of children’s
weight premature infants. Results 29. Walker SP, Chang SM, Wright AS, Pinto R, brain structure and function. Dev Med
through age 5 years from the Infant Heckman JJ, Grantham-McGregor SM. Child Neurol. 2019;61(10):1127–1133
Health and Development Program. JAMA. Cognitive, psychosocial, and behaviour 41. Jensen SKG, Murray SM, Placencio-Castro
1994;272(16):1257–1262 gains at age 31 years from the Jamaica M, et al. Family violence reduction within
S6 BLACK et al
Downloaded from http://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article-pdf/151/Supplement 2/e2023060221B/1476481/peds_2023060221b.pdf
by guest