Diversification and firm performance:
Diversification is defined as a firm entering a new business other
than its existing businesses. These new businesses may or may not be
closely related to the existing business. If the new business is related to
the existing business, it is called related diversification while if the new
business is unrelated to the existing business, it is called unrelated
diversification.
A variety of reasons could prompt a firm to go for diversification.
Economies of scope to improve utilization rate of resources that can be
shared in production of different products (Panzar and Willig, 1981) could
be one reason. Lack of availability of external capital can force firms to
use internal capital resources for a new business leading to diversification
(Williamson, 1975). High external transactions leading to market failure
could be another reason (Chatterjee and Wernerfelt, 1988). In addition,
managerial motives to reduce their employment risk (Amihud and Lev,
1981) and increase executive compensation (Tosi and Gomez-Mejia, 1989)
could lead to diversification. Even policy measures like anti-trust laws in
USA during the 1960s could lead to diversification (Bhagat et al. (1990),
Hoskisson and Turk (1990), Shleifer and Vishny (1990, 1991)).
Given that firms have incentives to diversify, does diversification
improve profitability of firms? Related diversification seems to improve
profitability while unrelated diversification seems to reduce it (Rumelt,
1982). This might be due to benefits like economies of scope. Profitability
might also depend on the ability of top corporate management to adapt
their logic to new business (Prahalad et al, 1986). Additionally,
diversification may not lead to profitability improvement when it is
excessive (Markides, 1995), in which case diversification leads to decline
in profitability. Thus, the effect of diversification on firm profitability is
contingent on a lot of factors and a careful combination of these factors
could lead to successful diversification by improving profitability.