CM504
NET CULTURE AND ONLINE JOURNALISM
NEIL CULLEN, PIERS DILLON-SCOTT, PATRICK O’GRADY
“Human creativity, technological affordance and
economic advantage each contribute to shaping our
own individual networked media experiences - as both
producers and consumers”
“Facts are sacred, comment is free”
History
Combination of different technologies
Background:
• 1969 US military created ARPANET, a series of interconnected
computers.
• It was designed as a communication network that would allow the
US government to function after a nuclear attack.
World Wide Web:
• 1968 Doug Engelbart demonstraits the modern office PC, mouse,
internet, email
• 1989/1990 Tim Berners-Lee proposes what will eventually
become the world wide web
• 2005 - Web 2.0 - link to blog
Online Journalism
Remediation
New technologies are integrated into pre-existing social
systems (while others are repressed altogether) (Winston)
New media is usually used to reproduce the functions of
established media. (Winston)
The development of established technologies has been a
battle between what the consumer wants and what
corporations think they should have. (Finton)
Technology is an extension of the human experience (cameras
extend human vision, flash drives-human brains). (Marshall Mcluhan)
Existence online is not dependent on a physical presence (See
Allucquere Rosanne cited in the Lister Book).
New Forms of Journalism
Blogs:
“To some people, weblogs... will pass once the
novelty wears off” -Deuze
Metajournalism:
Citizen Journalism:
“New media technologies will never stabilise in
these conditions of permanent upgrade culture.
…[new] media will always be novel.” (Dovey and
Kennedy 2006a: 52 in Lister)
Remediation - (TV didn’t kill cinema)
It can brings the audience close to the source
• CNN iReport
• Twitter
• Newstalk
• RTE iPlayer
• Podcasting
Journalistic Values
The ‘democratic nature’ of the web is over played
according to Herbert Schiller.
“Transforming information into a salable good, available
only to those with the ability to pay for it, changes the
goal of information access from an egalitarian to a
privileged condition” (Schiller)
“It is important that journalists posses quality principles,
such as authority, legitimacy, and credibility.” (Deuze)
The success of wikipedia shows the potential for
community based information sharing that is completely
free. Peer-review is the only way of guaranteeing
knowledge (Lister)
It grows through the collective action of people.
Unwritten ethical codes that give it order.
A world all can enter without privilege or prejudice.
-The Declaration of the Independence of the Web
(Barlow)
Challenges for Journalists
Paywalls:
Financial Times, Wall Street Journal.
New Revenue Streams: Example
10% of the world advertisements online by the end of
2009 (Lister)
Gatekeeping, new style of research.
During the first 6 months of 2009
• 105 newspapers have been shuttered.
• 10,000 newspaper jobs have been lost.
• Print ad sales fell 30% in Q1 '09.
• 23 of the top 25 newspapers reported circulation declines
between 7% and 20%.
Source: Business Insider
Online paywalls are seen as a possible solution to
falling profits.
Three months after The New York Observer went
behind a paywall it has only 35 subscribers.
Paywalls could be viable, according to Chris
Anderson, editor of wired, if offered for niche content
within a larger, free, structure.
Challenges for Journalism
Real-Time:
The challenge for journalists is to create accurate
content as quickly as possible
Facebook, twitter, BBC, CNN, Google News crashed
Stats from America
• 59% get news from both online and offline sources on a
typical day
• The internet is the third most popular news platform after TV
• 35% have a favourite site
• 33% of cell owners get news on their mobile devices
• 28% of internet users have personalised their news
experience
Source - Pew
Discussion
Paywall?
Citizen Journalism?
Where will your job begin and end?