Case Study #1
Global Ophthalmology
Disclosure
The speaker has no financial interest in the subject
matter of this presentation and is not representing
the Ethics Committee of the American Academy of
Ophthalmology with this presentation.
For questions about the material contained herein or
about the Academy’s ethics program in general,
please contact the ethics program manager, Mara
Pearse Burke at [email protected].
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Case History
Practicing ophthalmologist, Dr. Z, wishes to
participate in a surgical program in a
developing country.
• Dr. Z has not performed surgery for 5 years and
wishes to start operating again.
• Dr. Z has heard that there is a good place to
practice surgery in another county.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Case History
Dr. Z contacts a surgical instrument company and asks them to
sponsor his trip in the developing country and arranges a visit.
When asked by the program in the developing country about
his experience with surgery, Dr. Z states he has been operating
for over 10 years.
• The surgical instrument company offers to sponsor Dr. Z’s
visit if he uses their new instrument which has not yet
been approved in Dr. Z’s country.
Dr. Z arrives in the developing country and immediately starts
to operate on patients with advanced cataract.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Case History
Dr. Z spends a week in the developing country
and performs 50 surgeries.
• Dr. Z did not perform pre-operative or post-
operative assessments.
• Dr. Z did not perform informed consent.
• Dr. Z did not arrange for post-operative
assessment by a qualified healthcare provider.
• Dr. Z’s surgery was not supervised by another
ophthalmologist or healthcare provider skilled in
cataract surgery.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Case History
Dr. Z returns home and wishes to publish his
outcomes using the sponsoring surgical instrument
company’s equipment.
• Dr. Z publishes his results and presents case studies
revealing patient names and testimonials about how Dr. Z
helped them.
Dr. Z is then paid as a consultant for the surgical
company.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 1. Competence
An ophthalmologist is a physician who is educated
and trained to provide medical and surgical care of
the eyes and related structures. An ophthalmologist
should perform only those procedures in which the
ophthalmologist is competent by virtue of specific
training or experience or is assisted by one who is.
An ophthalmologist must not misrepresent
credentials, training, experience, ability or results.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 2. Informed Consent
The performance of medical or surgical
procedures shall be preceded by
appropriate informed consent.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 3. Research & Innovation
Research and innovation shall be approved by appropriate
review mechanisms to protect patients from being subjected to
or potentially affected by inappropriate, ill-considered, or
fraudulent basic science or patient-oriented research. Basic
science and clinical research are conducted to develop adequate
information on which to base prognostic or therapeutic decisions
or to determine etiology or pathogenesis, in circumstances in
which insufficient information exists. Appropriate informed
consent for research and innovative procedures must recognize
their special nature and ramifications. In emerging areas of
ophthalmic treatment where recognized guidelines do not exist,
the ophthalmologist should exercise careful judgment and take
appropriate precautions to safeguard patient welfare.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 6. Pretreatment Assessment
Treatment shall be recommended only after a careful
consideration of the patient's physical, social,
emotional and occupational needs. The
ophthalmologist must evaluate the patient and
assure that the evaluation accurately documents the
ophthalmic findings and the indications for
treatment. Recommendation of unnecessary
treatment or withholding of necessary treatment is
unethical.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 8. Postoperative Care
The providing of postoperative eye care until the patient has recovered
is integral to patient management. The operating ophthalmologist
should provide those aspects of postoperative eye care within the
unique competence of the ophthalmologist (which do not include
those permitted by law to be performed by auxiliaries). Otherwise, the
operating ophthalmologist must make arrangements before surgery for
referral of the patient to another ophthalmologist, with the patient's
approval and that of the other ophthalmologist. The operating
ophthalmologist may make different arrangements for the provision of
those aspects of postoperative eye care within the unique competence
of the ophthalmologist in special circumstances, such as emergencies
or when no ophthalmologist is available, so long as the patient's
welfare and rights are the primary considerations. Fees should reflect
postoperative eye care arrangements with advance disclosure to the
patient.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 10. Procedures & Materials
Ophthalmologists should order only those
laboratory procedures, optical devices or
pharmacological agents that are in the best
interest of the patient. Ordering unnecessary
procedures or materials or withholding
necessary procedures or materials is
unethical.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 11. Commercial
Relationshps
An ophthalmologist's clinical judgment and
practice must not be affected by economic
interest in, commitment to, or benefit from
professionally-related commercial enterprises.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 15. Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest exists when professional
judgment concerning the well-being of the
patient has a reasonable chance of being
influenced by other interests of the provider.
Disclosure of a conflict of interest is required
in communications to patients, the public, and
colleagues.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
Rule 17. Confidentiality
An ophthalmologist shall respect the
confidential physician-patient relationship and
safeguard confidential information consistent
with the law.
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
What Do You Think?
Do Dr. Z’s actions comply with the noted
Rules of the Code of Ethics?
Do you consider one of the Rules breaches
to be the most egregious? If yes, which
one?
AMERICAN ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY WWW.AAO.ORG
