Argument by Example
Argument by Example
Subtitle
Definition
• an argument in which a claim is supported by providing examples.
• Here, the examples given serve as the factual evidence of the arguer to support
the truth of a generalization.
Actual Hypothetical
Examples
Examples
illuminate vague Examples
and abstract
terms
Cases which
Imaginary situations
actually happened.
Form
• Premise 1: Example 1 is an example that supports claim P.
In this case n is a variable standing for the number of the premise in question and P is a
variable standing for the claim under consideration.
Premise 1: Lena ate pizza two months ago and did not contribute any money.
Premise 2: Lena ate pizza a month ago and did not contribute any money.
Premise 3: Lena ate pizza two weeks ago and did not contribute any money.
Premise 4: Lena ate pizza a week ago and did not contribute any money.
Conclusion: Lena is a pizza mooch who eats but does not contribute.
Assessing Argument by Examples
• The more examples, the stronger the argument.
• The more relevant the examples
• the examples must be specific and clearly identified.
• counter-examples must be considered – example that supports the denial of the
conclusion being argued for.
• The more counter-examples, the weaker the argument.
Issues to be argued:
• Is Trillanes a hero or a menace in todays Philippine context.
• Is Duterte’s current policy against drugs effective?
• Philippines must pursue socialism instead of capitalism.