IS INDIA REALLY FREE?
1
HISTORICAL CONTEXT
• 200 years ago, a struggle was initiated, aimed at making the country free from the colonial rule.
• 71 years ago, the struggle finally resulted in India breaking the colonial chains and finally
attaining freedom
• It is that freedom we won that day, which enables us to question one of the core values which is a
fundamental pillar of the country- Freedom itself.
2
DEFINITIONS OF FREEDOM
• Absence of constraints (Thomas Hobbes)
• Protection of the Right to life, Right to liberty and Right to property (John Locke)
• Following general will over individual will (Jean-Jacques Rousseau)
• Quantity of happiness is freedom (Jeremy Bentham)
• Quality of happiness is freedom (John Stuart Mill)
3
WHEN IS A COUNTRY FREE?
• A country is said to be free when its citizns are not denied their fundamental rights, basic rights
or natural rights.
• The Indian constitution safeguards and provides us liberty to practice our rights and enhance
theme
• A big question arises: Doesn't being free also mean being free from the will of the government?
4
WHY CONSTITUTION ISN’T A CONSTRAINT
• It is the citizens of our democratic country who elect the people forming the rules for
implementation of the states power.
• Since the constitution was made by representatives of the people, the statements of the
constitution are a representation of collective freewill
• So the rules of the constitution are not constraints imposed on us, rather they are rules that we
ourselves have chosen to abide by
• We are free and are restricted by nothing but our choices
5
EXAMPLES OF FREEDOM IN INDIA
• Every individual, from rich industrialists to beggars, can criticize the Prime Ministers actions.
• All citizens have the right vote and also the right to pick NOTA while voting in any election.
• Any individual can get information about working and progress of government by the Right to
Information act.
• Any individual can drive a change in governance/administration via Public Interest Litigation.
• An individual is free to worship a god from any religion.
6
CONSIDERING THE OTHER POINT OF VIEW
• Opponents may argue that women are unsafe in our country, so are minorities with a surge in
incidents such as mob lynching.
• While we agree that such problems exist in the country, we would like our opponents to view
these incidents are more of a failure of law enforcement rather than a deliberate attack on
individual freedom.
• With laws already in place, improvement in law enforcement would ensure such incidents do not
occur as frequently.
7
CONCLUSION
• So, is present day India a free country?
• Although some flaws exist in the system, we find no deliberate attack on individual or group
freedom in the country.
• India safeguards the rights of its citizens and ensures the highest form of individual freedom as
well as press freedom.
• So we would like to conclude by claiming that present India is truly a free country.