Ethics in Biotechnology
• Bioethics considers the moral and social aspects of biotechnology
and medicine
• Society is confronted with numerous issues in bioethics
• Should we allow:
• Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) to be used for human food?
• Mandatory DNA sampling of everyone who is arrested?
• Genetic engineering of animals to produce human organs?
• The goal of bioethics is to understand the costs and benefits of
decisions as well as the values and conflicts
• What are the costs (bad impacts) of a decision?
• What are the benefits (good impacts)?
• What values are being given priority (“winning”) over other values?
Why ethics in biotechnology is complex
• Many players involved:
• Big multinational corporations(e.g. Big pharmaceutical
companies)
• Academic and political groups
• Legal and religious organizations
• Government agencies
• NGO’s and International developmental organizations
COVID 19 and Ethics
• COVID 19 vaccine
• Which vaccine to choose?
• Can poor countries make choices?
• Have all these vaccines passed through proper
scientific protocol for vaccine development?
• Should we allow people to not be vaccinated even
though it puts others at risk?
• Vaccine passport, why is it controversial?
Agriculture/Environment and biotech Ethics
• Agricultural biotechnology depends on what governments and
consumers view as ethical
• What are the main costs and benefits of using GMO crops?
• Environmental applications of biotechnology face ethical questions
• Should we use cloning to save an endangered species?
• If rDNA bacteria can clean up an oil spill but will alter the natural ecosystem, should we
use them?
• If a genetically modified soybean produces better biofuel, should we use it?
Forensic science and Biotechnology Ethics
• Bioethical questions are increasing in forensic science
• Is taking DNA from someone an unreasonable search?
• What about taking DNA from something they handled, like a soda can?
• Who should be required to be in the government DNA database? Convicts? People
who get arrested? Everyone?
• Who can refuse not to give out their DNA samples?
Biotech. Research and Ethics
• Basic research usually requires approval by an ethics board
• any risks in requiring experiments to get advance approval?
• What are the risks and benefits?