CH 3
CH 3
01/24/24 1
Who should tax foreign source income?
01/24/24 2
What is International taxation?
• International taxation –imposing taxes on taxable activities
abroad by a person or company subject to taxes;
• International taxation generally refers to the tax treatment of
cross-national transactions.
• may include:
– Sales between companies in different countries;
– Individuals travel from one country to the other for
business or any other purpose;
– Generation of income in one country as a result of
investments made by individuals or corporations of another
country; or
– Services rendered by residents of one country to persons in
01/24/24
another country etc. 3
• International taxation deals with the taxation of income
originated in different countries;
01/24/24 5
01/24/24 6
• Companies residency rules usually consider:
– Where the headquarter is,
– Where the ownership is,
– Where the effective (central) management is etc.
01/24/24 9
Residence and Source based taxation
Residence based taxation:
•All incomes (both foreign & domestic source incomes) are
taxable in the country of residence only;
01/24/24 12
• Territorial system - a citizen (a company) earning income
abroad needs to pay tax only to the host government;
01/24/24 15
• Double taxation has effects on the cost of operations
and effectively may act as a hindrance to cross border
activities (investments);
01/24/24 17
• Double tax treaties (or conventions) are bilateral
agreements between two countries, which allocate
taxing rights over income between those
countries, thereby preventing double taxation of
income. ... Double tax treaty models are generally
used by countries as a starting point when negotiating
bilateral tax treaties.
01/24/24 18
Objectives of a tax treaty
include:
– Prevent double taxation;
01/24/24 21
1. Exemption method- the residence country exempts income
that has arisen in the source country;
– Example Netherlands
01/24/24 22
2. Credit method -residence country grants credit for taxes
paid by its resident in the source country;
01/24/24 23
3. Deduction method – resident countries allow residents to
deduct tax paid to a foreign country in respect of foreign
income in the determination of taxable income in the
resident country. ;
01/24/24 24
Illustrative data:
• ABC Company is a resident in country A and it has operations in country B as
well.
• Country A is a resident state while country B is a source state;
• During the year ended in Dec. 2016, tax relevant figures were as follows:
01/24/24 26
2. Measures are taken to eliminate double taxation :-
2.1 Exemption method – exempts foreign source income from taxation in the country of residence.
•Taxable income in the country of residence $2,000,000 as the foreign source income is exempted.
01/24/24 27
• 2.2 Credit method – allows the tax paid in the source country to be credited against the tax
liability in the source country;
01/24/24 28
• What if the tax rate in the source country were higher
than maximum tax rate in the residence country?
• If the tax rate in the source country were higher the credit
is limited to the amount that would have been paid if the
maximum tax rate in the residence were applied.
01/24/24 29
• For example if we change the tax rate in the source country to
40 % instead of 20 %.
• The tax that should have been paid in the source country would
be 1,200,000 @40 = $480,000
01/24/24 32
01/24/24 33
What are Multinational Enterprises?
01/24/24 34
Multinational enterprises (companies)
• MNE is an entity that conducts business in more than one
jurisdiction;
– Home office in one country-branch in another country
– Parent Company in one country- Subsidiaries in other
countries
– Affiliated companies: Sole agent, Distributor etc
• Multinational corporations are subject to tax in their home
country depending on the specific multinational taxation
system adopted by the home country.
• Multinational corporations are subject to tax in their home
country depending on the specific multinational taxation
system adopted by the home country.
01/24/24 35
Taxation and MNE
01/24/24 36
A. Affiliates
Branch and subsidiary
An overseas affiliate of MNC can be organized as a
branch or a subsidiary;
• A foreign branch is not an independently incorporated
firm separate from the parent;
• Branch income becomes part of parent’s income;
• Subsidiary income
• A foreign subsidiary is an affiliate organization of the
MNE that is independently incorporated;
01/24/24 37
• In the case of the US for example, a foreign
subsidiary is a company owned by a US corporation
but incorporated abroad and hence a separate
corporation from a legal point of view;
01/24/24 39
1. Tax if no income is repatriated assuming credit method:
•US parent
Income tax = $2,000,000 @ $35% = $700,000
•HK subsidiary
Income tax = $5,000,000 @ 15% = 750,000
•Total tax for the company as a whole = $1450,000
01/24/24 40
2. If all subsidiary income is repatriated:
01/24/24 41
2. Tax Havens and Transfer pricing
01/24/24 42
Tax havens may be identified by reference to the
following factors:
01/24/24 43
A Good example:
•Panama
•Switzerland, Ireland
01/24/24 44
• An important reason for the stiff competitive
pressure in corporate taxation is that multinational
integrated companies can perform ‘tax arbitrage’;
01/24/24 49
• Many empirical studies have investigated whether and
how strongly tax differences between countries
influence decisions on where companies transfer their
‘profits’;
01/24/24 52
Cont’d
01/24/24 53
• These prices can be used to shift profits to
preferential tax regimes or tax havens;
01/24/24 56
• Then Haven Inc. sells the product to USA Inc. at a
very high price – almost as high as the final retail
price at which USA Inc. sells the processed product.
So USA Inc. also has artificially low profits, and an
artificially low tax bill in the U.S.
01/24/24 57
• Most countries have transfer pricing rules which regulate
the prices charged by related Companies.
01/24/24 58
…………………visit the proclamation for more
01/24/24 59
End of Chapter 3
01/24/24 60
Chapter 4
Taxation and corporate decision making
Points of Discussion
01/24/24 61
•Taxes have impacts on investment and economic
activities;
01/24/24 63
Taxation and choice of finance
01/24/24 64
• All interest paid by a corporation to its lenders is tax-
deductible, generating a tax shield;
01/24/24 66
• Others show that corporations use significant amount
of equity capital;
01/24/24 70
• Companies try to use tax havens in their choice of investment
location;
01/24/24 71
Involvement in Charities
• Taxation influences firms involvement in charities
01/24/24 72
Employee Benefit Decisions
• Limiting tax free and other benefits:
– Transportation allowances
– Pension contributions
– Representation allowances
01/24/24 73
End of Chapter 4
01/24/24 74
Chapter 5
Tax avoidance and evasion
Points of Discussion
• Meaning
• Factors Causing Tax Evasion
• Tax Planning
01/24/24 75
• Tax avoidance - an attempt to reduce tax liability by
legal means, for example, by exploiting loopholes;
01/24/24 76
• Tax evasion - attempting to reduce tax
liability illegally (by breaking laws);
01/24/24 77
• Tax evasion may be through suppression of income or
exaggeration of expenditures;
01/24/24 78
Factors Causing Tax Evasion
• Theoretically, there are a number of factors causing tax evasion:
• high tax rates- first and foremost reason for evasion which
makes the evasion attractive and profitable
01/24/24 79
• Low penalty rate- nominal penalty or no penalty
01/24/24 80
Tax planning
• Obtaining deductions;
• Use exclusions
01/24/24 83
Objectives of Tax Planning
• Claim Deductions
• It will reduce your tax liability and you have to pay less tax,
• Minimize the war between Tax Payer and Tax Administrator, Tax
payer wants to pay less tax and Tax Administrator wants to extract
most of the tax, by using Tax Planning this war is minimized as tax
payer is using all legal ways to reduce tax liability,
• Makes Investments :- By tax planning, a Tax payer will invest his
money in some good funds which will result in productive returns
for tax payer and transfer money to government for investment too.
• Helps in growth of economy,
• Makes society grow,
• Money saved by you will result in investment which will result in
employment generation.
01/24/24 84
Basics of tax planning
•Defer: A deferral strategy is to try to push having to pay tax now into
future years. Deferring tax means you might eliminate the tax this year
but you will eventually have to pay the tax down the road.
01/24/24
The End 85