Feminism
Feminism
THEORY
AND PRACTICE
Dr Anehi
Mundra
AISS
Feminism is said to be the movement to end women's oppression.
One possible way to understand ‘woman’ in this claim is to take it as a sex term:
Feminist theorising of the sex/gender distinction
‘woman’ picks out human females and being a human female depends on
various biological and anatomical features (like genitalia).
men because (according to Geddes and Thompson) “what was decided among the prehistoric
Political results: It would be inappropriate to grant women political rights, as they are simply not
suited to have those rights; it would also be futile since women (due to their biology) would simply
To counter this kind of biological determinism, feminists have argued that behavioural and
psychological differences have social, rather than biological, causes. For instance, Simone de
Beauvoir famously claimed that one is not born, but rather becomes a woman, and that
that they appear to be caused by nature”. Commonly observed behavioural traits associated
with women and men, then, are not caused by anatomy or chromosomes.
airline pilots since they will be
hormonally unstable once a month and,
therefore, unable to perform their duties
Corpus Callosum
as well as men. More recently,
differences in male and female brains
have been said to explain behavioural
differences; in particular, the anatomy of
corpus callosum, a bundle of nerves that
connects the right and left cerebral
hemispheres, is thought to be
responsible for various psychological and
behavioural differences.
behave.
reform.
cultural, rather than biological bases” that result from differential treatment. For her, gender is “the sum
Gender as Socially
total of the parents', the peers', and the culture's notions of what is appropriate to each gender by way of
temperament, character, interests, status, worth, gesture, and expression.” Thus, we can unlearn gender
roles. constructed
The distinction started from infants. When parents have been asked to describe their 24-hour old infants,
they have done so using gender-stereotypic language: boys are describing as strong, alert and
Children are dressed in gender stereotypical toys and dress. Boys are told not to ‘cry like a baby’. Books
Gendered personalities develop because women tend to be the primary caretakers of small children.
Crudely put: the mother-daughter relationship differs from the mother-son relationship because mothers
are more likely to identify with their daughters than their sons. This unconsciously prompts the mother to
encourage her son to psychologically individuate himself from her thereby prompting him to develop well
defined and rigid ego boundaries. However, the mother unconsciously discourages the daughter from
individuating herself thereby prompting the daughter to develop flexible and blurry ego boundaries.
This perspective has its roots in Freudian psychoanalytic theory, although Chodorow's approach differs in
Chodorow: Women are stereotypically more emotional and emotionally dependent upon others around
them, supposedly finding it difficult to distinguish their own interests and wellbeing from the interests
and wellbeing of their children and partners. This is said to be because of their blurry and (somewhat)
subordinate status that stems from their gender.
RACE: The history of racist oppression illustrates that during slavery black women were ‘hypersexualised’ and thought
to be always sexually available whereas white women were thought to be pure and sexually virtuous. In fact, the rape of
a black woman was thought to be impossible. So, (the argument goes) sexual objectification cannot serve as the
common condition for womanhood since it varies considerably depending on one's race and class.
White Western middle-class feminists accounted for the shared features simply by reflecting on the cultural features
that condition their gender as women thus supposing that “the womaness underneath the Black woman's skin is a white
woman's, and deep down inside the Latina woman is an Anglo woman waiting to burst through an obscuring cultural
shroud”.
gender dimorphism only serves a heterosexist social order by implying that since women and men are sharply opposed,
Further, being feminine and desiring men (for instance) are standardly assumed to be expressions of one's gender as a
woman. Butler denies this and holds that gender is really performative. It is not “a stable identity or locus of agency
from which various acts follow; rather, gender is instituted through a stylized repetition of acts”: through wearing certain
gender-coded clothing, walking and sitting in certain gender-coded ways, styling one's hair in gender-coded manner and
so on. Gender is not something one is, it is something one does; it is a sequence of acts, a doing rather than a being.
People think that there are true and real genders, and those deemed to be doing their gender ‘wrong’ are not socially
sanctioned. But, genders are true and real only to the extent that they are performed.
the trans-person's gender is just as real or true as anyone else's who is a ‘traditionally’ feminine female or
masculine male. Without heterosexism that compels people to engage in certain gendering acts, there
would not be any genders at all. And ultimately the aim should be to abolish norms that compel people to
Take the idea-construction of sex concepts. Our concept of sex is said to be a product of social
forces in the sense that what counts as sex is shaped by social meanings. To illustrate further the
idea-construction of sex, consider the case of the athlete Maria Patiño. Patiño has female
genitalia, has always considered herself to be female and was considered so by others. However,
she was discovered to have XY chromosomes and was barred from competing in women's sports.
Intersexes, like Patiño, illustrate that our understandings of sex differ and suggest that there is no
immediately obvious way to settle what sex amounts to purely biologically or scientifically.
According to Butler, first, the idea that sex is a social construct, boils down to the view that our
sexed bodies are also performative and so, they have “no ontological status apart from the
various acts which constitute reality”. Prima facie, this implausibly implies that female and male
bodies do not have independent existence and that if gendering activities ceased, so would
physical bodies. This is not Butler's claim; rather, her position is that bodies viewed as the
material foundations on which gender is constructed, are themselves constructed as if they
provide such material foundations. Cultural conceptions about gender figure in “the very
apparatus of production whereby sexes themselves are established”.
Biological determinism is exactly that the belief that biology determines such
characteristics as behaviour, ability, likes, dislikes, etc. Biological
Biologism versus Social Constructivism
determinism is the theory behind the phrase: “boys will be boys.” This
phrase is associated with “boyish” behavioural characteristics, which we can
all easily identify, that are believed to be essential and natural in boys.
Social constructionism, on the other hand, is the theory that social identifiers,
like race and gender, among others, are created by society rather than
biology. Many argue that social constructionism is a much stronger force in
shaping behaviour and other social characteristics. Though social
constructionists do have differing opinions on the influence of society or
biology over male/female characteristics, a popular opinion is that though
there are some innate biological differences between men and women,
society is overwhelmingly more influential in the long-term. Social
constructionism is a theory of knowledge that holds that characteristics
typically thought to be immutable and solely biological—such as gender,
race, class, ability, and sexuality—are products of human definition and
interpretation shaped by cultural and historical contexts.
Essentialism typically relies on a biological determinist theory of identity. Biological determinism can
be defined as a general theory, which holds that a group’s biological or genetic makeup shapes its
social, political, and economic destiny. For example, “sex” is typically thought to be a biological “fact,”
where bodies are classified into two categories, male and female.
For example, feminist law professor Julie Greenberg writes that in the late 19 th century and early 20th
century, “when reproductive function was considered one of a woman’s essential characteristics, the
medical community decided that the presence or absence of ovaries was the ultimate criterion of
sex”. Thus, sexual difference was produced through the hetero-normative assumption that women are
defined by their ability to have children. Instead of assigning sex based on the presence or absence of
ovaries, medical practitioners in the contemporary US typically assign sex based on the appearance of
genitalia.
Differential definitions of sex point to two other primary aspects of the social construction
of reality. First, it makes apparent how even the things commonly thought to be “natural”
or “essential” in the world are socially constructed. Understandings of “nature” change
through history and across place according to systems of human knowledge. Second, the
social construction of difference occurs within relations of power and privilege.
Notions of disability are similarly socially constructed within the context of ableist power relations. The
medical model of disability frames body and mind differences and perceived challenges as flaws that
perspective suggests that existing inequalities are neither inevitable nor immutable. By
centering the processes through which inequality and power relations produce racialized,
sexualized, and gendered difference, social constructionist analyses challenge the
pathologization of minorities who have been thought to be essentially or inherently inferior to
privileged groups.
When researchers critically examine commonly held characteristics that are often believed to
be based in biology, often we can easily see the ways in which society has a direct influence
in these outcomes. One example of this is a study assessing the ways in which parents
perceive their children’s physical ability differently based on whether their child is a boy or a
girl. Researchers asked parents to estimate the level of slope their eleven-month-old babies
could successfully descend. Results did not show any real difference in the athletic ability of
the two sexes; the interesting result was in the ways in which parents estimated their child’s
ability to descend the slope. Mothers of baby girls under estimated their ability by an average
of nine degrees. Mothers who had baby boys only underestimated their baby’s ability by an
average of one degree. Lise Eliot, an author, who applies a social constructionist approach,
uses this study as an example of the ways preconceived notions about varying abilities
between the sexes alters the expectations we have for our children.
This expectation has real repercussions. If parents believe their daughters to be less
physically capable than their sons are, than they are less likely to enrol girls in athletic
extracurricular activities.
V. Geetha elaborates the broader implications of the term in the following words: What is
patriarchy? Where does the word come from? At its simplest, the term means 'the absolute rule of
Understanding Patriarchy
the father or the eldest male member of the family' not only over all women in the family, but also
The term patriarchy is not only a descriptive term that explains how different societies construct
male authority and power, but also become an analytical category. This change of the use of the
term patriarchy from a descriptive to an analytical category took place in the 1970s,
At the Universities women demanded that their experiences and points of view be taken seriously
that patriarchy emerged as a way of both describing and explaining the world. Since this time,
patriarchy has been used critically to explain the main components of authority and power in any
social system.
Patriarchy links masculinity with power, independence, self-assertion, domination and activity.
Feminine is linked with weakness, dependence, helplessness, docility, passivity and subservience.
She is always required to find fulfilment in submissive domesticity. Gender defined roles serve male
need for domination. This is what Kate Millet calls sexual politics. Patriarchy provides congenial
It silences and marginalizes them and makes them believe that femininity is inherently linked with
inferiority and that their inferiority is natural. The terms 'female,' 'feminine' and 'feminist' also
apply to literature.
by the male elders in the community. When used in this sense, the term “patriarchy” is often
contrasted with the term “matriarchy”, which referred to social system where women exercised
political authority
Both wifehood and motherhood become glorified in the patriarchal system. These roles are
granted social sanctions and at the same time are also eulogized in local folk lore, in literature,
and religion.
Patriarchy has both productive and punitive aspects. Thus, women who wish to remain single
and refuse marriage and treated with disdain by the society. Similarly, women who are not
fertile or those who cannot bear children especially male are ridiculed and held in contempt and
their position in the family is a non-existent one. The position of widow, especially upper caste
For example, in India, upper caste widows were required to shave their heads, wear no
ornaments, or colour garments as they were viewed with suspicion. They were women who had
deviated from the conventional norms of reproduction and had to be relegated to a lowly status
Patriarchy has been viewed as more than just the subordination of women. It has been pointed
out that not all men are powerful in a patriarchal system. For example, younger men in the
Despite this, that certain classes and category of men are the targets of patriarchal authority,
the fact remains that all men can claim resources and power more easily than women in their
decide how many children they want, whether to use contraceptives, or a decision to terminate pregnancy.
This ideology of motherhood is considered one of the bases of women’s oppression. It also creates feminine
and masculine character types and perpetuates patriarchy. It restricts women’s mobility and it reproduces
What do men control in the Patriarchal System?
male dominance.
3. Control over Women’s Sexuality: Women are obliged to provide sexual services to their husbands according
4. Women’s Mobility: Besides control of women’s sexuality, production and reproduction, men also control
5. Property and other Economic Resources: Most property and other productive resources. This control over the
resources later gets translated into control over the production and reproduction of women.
Patriarchy and Tribal Society: According to Lemer, "The first gender-defined role for women was that of the
"stand-in" wife, which became established and institutionalised for women of elite groups. This role gave such
women considerable power and privileges, but it depended on their attachment to elite men and based,
minimally, on their satisfactory performance in rendering these men's sexual and reproductive services. If a
woman failed to meet these demands, she was quickly replaced and thereby lost all her privileges and
standing.
Patriarchy and Agrarian Society : ”Patriarchy can best be understood as the reproduction of state hierarchy
within the family. A well-known example of this is the ptria potesta of the Roman Empire: the emperor rules the
empire; the father rules the home and the family. The father was clearly considered the emperor's
representative in the home; the emperor was the father's representative in the state. Similar kinds of ideology
Women's lack of knowledge of their own history of struggle and achievement has been
one of the major means of keeping them subordinate. Emergent women face a challenge
to her very definition of self. In stepping out of the constructs of patriarchal thought, she
Women's Acceptance of Patriarchal Thought
faces the threat of loss of communication with, approved by, and love from the man (or
the men) in her life. Withdrawal of love and the designation of thinking women as
"deviant" have historically been the means of discouraging women's intellect. With the
significance of the gender control, as a force restraining women from full participation in
the process of creating thought systems.
If both men and women regard the subordination of women as "natural", it is impossible
to establish or envision a society in which differences do not connote either dominance or
subordination.
the concept of selective exchange of women to a certain caste or castes. In this way the sexuality of
DOMINANCE
and hypo-gamy demonstrates a strict control over the female sexuality. Hyper-gamy to some extent is
permitted where a man of higher caste can have union with a woman of lower caste but hypogamous
There are numerous such examples where honour killings took place in the name of such unaccepted
This exemplifies that the control over the sexuality of women becomes an instrument of reproducing caste
hierarchies
In this kind of control female sexuality gets attached with the honour of an entire village, caste,
community or family and any infringement over the same can bring a lot of dishonour to the entire group.
This kind of corporate control over the sexuality of women is also demonstrated by anthropologists like D.
N. Majumdar who in his monograph named ‘The Himalyan Polyandry’ on the people of Jaunsar Bawar
region of Dehradun documented fraternal polyandrous marriage alliance between a bride and all the
brothers of a household where the marriage gets solemnised. Here the main issue is related with the right
of access to the female sexuality which by such alliances gets restricted to the family or household as a
unit.
At the level of family, the sexuality of women is under the control of her brothers and father. Leela Dubey
explains this with the help of a very general yet powerful observation that brothers in the context of South Asian
An important point made by the socialist feminist Zillah Eisenstein in her edited volume Capitalist
Patriarchy and the case for Socialist Feminism, is to distinguish between the worker (whether man
or woman) under capitalism and the woman in the household. Workers are exploited in the
CAPITALIST PATRIARCHY
workplace (by the capitalist factory owner or the landlord) by paying them wages that are less than
the value of the labour they do, so that the surplus goes to the owner. However, most women are
dependent for their livelihood and security on a specific set of social relations, defined by marriage
and motherhood, and their daily work takes place in the context of these relations. In this situation
where women are working in the home but not being paid wages, the nature of their domination in
the household is similar and different to that of someone engaging in paid work.
This relationship is not very easy to define and has been called a relationship of patriarchal
oppression by feminists. It should be obvious why it is so difficult to name, because firstly, most
women do not think of themselves as workers, since they are not being paid a wage, and secondly,
because their labour is interwoven with notions of love, care and duty to the family – typically
towards their husband, children and others who may be living with them.
Should women then be paid just wages for this kind of work as a step forward? Or would this only
serve to further confine them to the home? Is the solution to transform housework in a social
activity, such as through collective kitchens, creches for children and so on, so that women no
longer have to undertake this kind of work alone and can be freed up like men to work elsewhere?
What about the domestic work of servants, who receive some of the worst wages ever to be paid to
a worker anywhere?
According to Walby, at present time, patriarchy has six relatively autonomous
structures.
Patriarchal Relations in the State: the state, on its part, in its policies and actions are patriarchal
towards women.
Mother’s Brother (MB) and Mother’s Brother’s Son (MBS) holds immense importance in
MARRIAGE PATTERN
the life of women andAND THE INSTITUTIONALISATION
her children. OFBrother)
MyB (Mother’s younger PATRIARCHY ANDare
and MBS MALE
DOMINANCE
considered as prospective grooms for a woman’s daughter.
MB is also obliged to give expensive gifts during the life cycle rituals of his sister’s
children. This ceremonial gift is known as ‘sir’ which is considered to be a replacement for
a woman’s share in her parental property. Thus, it is both obligatory and woman’s share
in true sense in contrast with the institution of dowry and streedhan practiced among the
patrilineal groups.
Kate Millet in her work on Sexual Politics has tried to define patriarchy in two ways:
A kind of hierarchy is set based on the notion of male dominance which is evident in the
form of bride takers having a superior status than the bride givers. This male dominance
and inequality gets reflected in certain marriage ceremonies like pao pooja (worshipping
the feet) of the groom which the father of the bride giver must perform. This reflects a
kind of ritual hierarchy.
The very process of giving birth to a male child places the woman on the bride takers
side. This is also the reason that even women long for a male child. The control of
STRUCTURES OF PATRIARCHY
The Indian joint family is the "patriarchal family” and it was constituted by a group of persons
related in the male line and subject to absolute power of the senior most male member.
The differential access of men and women to the material and symbolic resources of society.
According to Gerda Lerner, family plays an important role in creating a hierarchical system as it
not only mirrors the order in the state and educates its children but also creates and constantly
reinforces that order. Family is therefore important for socializing the next generation in
patriarchal values. The boys learn to be dominating and aggressive and girls learn to be caring,
loving and submissive. These stereotypes of masculinity and femininity are not only social
constructs but also have been internalized by both men and women. While the pressure to earn
and look after the family is more on the man, the women are supposed to do the menial jobs and
take care of their children and even other members of the family.
Patriarchal constructions of knowledge perpetuate patriarchal ideology, and this is reflected in
educational institutions, knowledge system and media which reinforce male dominance.
through legends highlighting the self-sacrificing, self-effacing pure image of women and through ritual
practice which emphasized the dominant role of women as a faithful wife and devout mother.
Laws of Manu insist that since women by their very nature are disloyal they should be made
dependent on men. The husband should be constantly worshiped as a god, which symbolized that man
is a lord, master, owner, or provider and the shudras and women were the subordinates.
Similarly, caste and gender are closely related, and the sexuality of women is directly linked to the
question of purity of race. The caste system and caste endogamy retained control over the labour and
sexuality of women. Anuloma and pratiloma marriage by definition denigrate women. Caste not only
determines social division of labour but also sexual division of labour. Ideologically concepts of caste
purity of women to maintain patrilineal succession justified subordination of women. The prohibition of
sacred thread ceremony for both women and shudra, similar punishment for killing women and
shudra, denial of religious privileges are illustrations which indicate how caste and gender get
STRUCTURES OF PATRIARCHY
Patriarchy idealises motherhood and thereby forces women to be mothers and
determines the conditions of their motherhood. Patriarchy restricts women’s
mobility and reproduces male dominance.
Uma Chakrawati argues that the establishment of private property and the need to
have caste purity required subordination of women and strict control over their
mobility and sexuality. Female sexuality was channelled into legitimate
motherhood within a controlled structure of reproduction to ensure patrilineal
succession.
• b.) laws, customs as per the brahminical order which poses wife fidelity and chastity as
the highest duty of women.
Feminism is diverse and multifaceted grouping of ideas. Hence all feminists call for
change in social, cultural, religious, political and economic fields.
The second definition further states that this oppression takes place because of
patriarchal control. Hence awareness of women takes place at both level material and at
ideological level. This oppression may be done by men or by women for both the
definition all over the world.
There is general notion that feminist is against marriage, peaceful names and household
Scholars have divided the history of Western feminism into three ‘waves’.
The first wave in the 19th and early 20th century primarily focused on women’s voting rights.
Evolution of the Three Waves of Feminism
The second wave refers to the women’s liberation movement which began in the 1960’s and
was concerned with the legal and social equality of women. Black feminists felt that since the
second wave feminists were largely white, the feminism of the 1960s ended up universalizing
all women in terms of white feminism
The third wave, beginning in the 1990’s, builds on the apparent failures of second wave and
tries to address them.
The term ‘feminism’ initially referred to a group of white middle-class women in Europe and
America who protested against patriarchal oppression and the hierarchical male-female
binary structure of the society
The term ‘multicultural feminism’ was used first by Alison M. Jagger and Paula M. Rothenberg.
Multicultural feminism focuses on the significance of race, ethnicity and culture and how
these issues have been neglected in mainstream western feminist discourse.
Interestingly, bell hooks, the well-known feminist black critic comments that the flaw of
feminist discourse is its inability to arrive at definition(s) that could serve as points of
unification. This marks out the impossibility of solidarity between women across racial and
movement. In her magna carta, “A Vindication of the Rights of Women”, Wollstonecraft advocates for equal opportunity for both men
and women. She emphasises that it is imperative that women are educated and made aware of their political and social rights in order
Liberal Feminism
to claim equal status at par with men. In the 19 century John Stuart Mill emerged as the leading scholar of Liberal Feminism and
th
advocated that women are required to participate equally and pro-actively in various societal affairs and hence strive for equality.
Liberal feminists advocated that women should not only be confined to the domestic domain and there should be equal opportunity for
them to participate in the public and political spheres of life. According to them patriarchy has confined women to the four walls of the
house and therefore they need to get liberated in order to come out of the clutches of patriarchy. Liberals attacked the myth that
women, because of their feminine behaviour are not suited for outside world and therefore they seek refuge and security within the
domestic sphere of life. However, Liberal Feminism is being criticised on the issue of being very individualistic and therefore totally
overlooking the structural, societal and familial basis for male dominance and patriarchy. Liberal feminists do not take a critical view of
family and are focused solely on capturing space and rights for individual women in the public domain. They are also being criticised
for being elitists since most of the rights gathered in this manner will be availed by the so-called upper class/caste women. Therefore,
this stream of feminism did not voice the concern of other differentially suppressed women on the
Liberal feminists aimed at the equality of men and women through reform without altering the structure of society.
Individualism means individual’s freedom to do what one wishes to do what one wishes to do without
interference from other. Feminist writer Mary Wollstonecraft wrote in this a book called “Violation of the
rights of women”. The critical theme of the book is “women are first and foremost human being rational
creatures and not sexual being. They can govern themselves by reason. Hence, if women are to be
denied natural right, then it must be proved that they are not rational creature
• Classical Liberalism: expects the state to concentrate on protecting the civil liberties of each citizen, and
without interfering with the free market, to provide all individuals with an equal opportunity to function
within that market. Gender is a social construct. If men were being se cages as women, they would
develop sam concerns.
Marxist
dominance. Marxist feminists are of the view that patriarchy originated with the
origin of private property. It is with the emergence of private ownership of property
and its transfer through the male line of descent that patriarchy as a social structure
was born. They also relate the concept of patriarchy with the capitalist mode of
production. However they have been criticised for just adding the issue of gender to
their already existing framework of class oppression. They are also silent on the
issue of women oppression before the advent of private property. There are
empirical evidences that point to the fact that women oppression and male
dominance was present even before the advent of private property. Claude Levi-
Strauss observed that the exchange of women is the basic form of exchange and it
took place because of some taboo on incestuous relationships (sexual relations
between close relatives like father and daughter, brother and sister, mother and son
etc.) in each society. This kind of taboo required that women be acquired from a
group outside one’s own and thus clan, lineage, village exogamy originated. This
gave rise to the manipulation of female sexuality and hence the emergence of male
dominance.
socialist feminists found a link between the oppression of women and their
explain the origin of patriarchy and male dominance through the notion of female sexuality and its
manipulation by the male. They are of the view that biologically women are different from men. This is
the basic fact recognised by this brand of feminism. This biological difference defines the role of women
Radical feminism
as child bearers. This biological role is however translated and interpreted as related to the notion of
“motherhood” which defines the role of mother in terms of both child bearing and child rearing. They are
of the view that biology alone is not responsible for such skewed power relations between male and
female, but their cultural interpretation is responsible for the same. ‘Gendering of sex’ takes place in the
socio-cultural context. In other words, the control of male over the reproductive capacity of female is the
root cause of patriarchy.
Sheila Jeffrey, one of the revolutionary feminist puts her point on the origin of patriarchy by saying that
there are basically two systems of class that operate in a society:
The class based on and originating from the relations of production and
The class that is based on and originates from the relation of reproduction.
It is the second system of class that is responsible for women subordination and patriarchy. Similarly,
Finella McKenzie argued that the first kind of division of labour was between men and women and it
originated from women’s reproductive capacity and men’s greater strength. This made women
dependent on men and thus gave rise to unequal power distribution. However, she also writes that it is
not only because of this differential reproductive capacity that subordinates women, but this biological
differentiation is turned into psychological dependency by men and the social structure. This stream of
feminism is however criticised for being biological determinist and reductionist. It also does not provide
any alternative to end patriarchy or improve the condition of women. They advocate that women should
• Socialist, New Feminist Schools/Traditions
slavery in Swartekill, New York, but escaped with her
essentialism.
1944
and right to secular and professional education for girls. They also demanded suppression of the
distinction between married women and concubines, between legitimate and natural children, the
The Suffragettes
In 1909, French noblewoman and feminist Jeanne Elizabeth Schmahl founded the French Union for
Despite some cultural changes following World War I, which had resulted in women replacing the male
workers who had gone to the front, they were known as the Années folles and their exuberance was
restricted to a very small group of female elites. Victor Margueritte's La Garçonne, depicting an
emancipated woman, was seen as scandalous and caused him to lose his Légion d'honneur.
During the Third Republic, the suffragettes movement championed the right to vote for women, but did
Despite this campaign and the new role of women following World War I, the Third Republic declined to
grant them voting rights, mainly because of fear of the influence of clericalism among them, echoing the
conservative vote of rural areas for Louis-Napoleon Bonaparte during the Second Republic. After the 1936
Popular Front victory, although he had defended voting rights for women (a proposition included in the
program of the French Section of the Workers' International party since 1906), left-wing Prime Minister
Léon Blum did not implement the measure, because of the fear of the Radical-Socialist Party.
Women obtained the right to vote only after the Provisional Government of the French Republic (GPRF)
confirmed, on 5 October 1944, the ordinance of 21 April 1944 of the French Committee of National
th st
Post-war Period
During the baby boom period, feminism became a minor movement, despite forerunners such as Simone de Beauvoir, who
a feminist existentialism which prescribes a moral revolution. As an existentialist, de Beauvoir accepted Jean-Paul Sartre's
precept that existence precedes essence; hence "one is not born a woman, but becomes one".
She argues that women have historically been considered deviant and abnormal, and contends that even Mary
Wollstonecraft considered men to be the ideal toward which women should aspire. De Beauvoir argues that for feminism to
Married French women obtained the right to work without their husband's consent in 1965. The Neuwirth Law legalized birth
control in 1967, but the relative executive decrees were blocked for a couple years by the conservative government.
A strong feminist movement would only emerge in the aftermath of May 1968, with the creation of the Mouvement de
libération des femmes (Women's Liberation Movement, MLF), allegedly by Antoinette Fouque, Monique Wittig and Josiane
Chanel in 1968. The name itself was given by the press, in reference to the US Women's Lib movement. In the frame of the
cultural and social changes that occurred during the Fifth Republic, they advocated the right of autonomy from their
The paternal authority of a man over his family in France was ended in 1970 (before those parental responsibilities belonged
solely to the father who made all legal decisions concerning the children).
From 1970, the procedures for the use of the title "Mademoiselle" were challenged in France, particularly by feminist groups
who wanted it banned. A circular from François Fillon, then Prime Minister, dated 21 February 2012, called for the deletion of
st
the word "Mademoiselle" in all official documents. On 26 December 2012, the Council of State approved the deletion.
th
other hand, a "third wave" of the feminist movement arose,
Wars (both World War I and World War II) had seen the
Defence) secretary."
The stereotype of the Victorian gentle lady became unacceptable and even intolerable. The first organised
movement for British women's suffrage was the Langham Place Circle of the 1850s, led by Barbara Bodichon
On June 7, 1866 a petition from 1,499 women calling for women’s suffrage was presented to the Parliament, but
Florence Nightingale demonstrated the necessity of professional nursing and warfare, and set up an educational
system that tracked women into that field in the second half of the nineteenth century. Teaching was not quite
as easy to break into, but the low salaries were less of the barrier to the single woman than to the married man.
By the late 1860s a number of schools were preparing women for careers as governesses or teachers.
Oxford and Cambridge minimized the role of women, allowing small all-female colleges to operate. However, the
new redbrick universities and the other major cities were open to women.
One route to entry was to go to the United States where there were suitable schools for women as early as 1850.
Britain was the last major country to train women physicians, so 80 to 90% of the British women came to
Child custody: Before 1839 after divorce rich women lost control of their children as those children would
continue in the family unit with the father, as head of the household, and who continued to be responsible for
them.
Parliament in the 1860s in the Contagious Diseases Acts ("CD") adopted the French system of licensed
prostitution. The "regulationist policy" was to isolate, segregate, and control prostitution
Young women officially became prostitutes and were trapped for life in the system. After a nationwide crusade
led by Josephine Butler and the Ladies National Association for the Repeal of the Contagious Diseases Acts,
A series of four laws each called the Married Women's Property Act passed Parliament from 1870 to 1893 that
effectively removed the restrictions that kept wealthy married women from controlling their own property.
In 1906, the Daily Mail first coined the term "suffragettes" as a form of ridicule, but the term was quickly
embraced in Britain by women who used militant tactics in the cause of women's suffrage.
The radical protests slowly became more violent, and included heckling, banging on doors, smashing shop
windows, and arson. Emily Davison, a WSPU member, unexpectedly ran onto the track during the 1913 Epsom
The First World War advanced the feminist cause, as women's sacrifices and paid employment were much
appreciated. Prime Minister David Lloyd George was clear about how important the women were:
It would have been utterly impossible for us to have waged a successful war had it not been for the skill and
ardour, enthusiasm and industry which the women of this country have thrown into the war.
The Sex Disqualification (Removal) Act, 1919 received Royal Assent on 23 December 1919. The basic purpose of the act was, as
rd
stated in its long title, "to amend the Law with respect to disqualification on account of sex",
Despite women being admitted to the House of Commons from 1918, Mackworth, a Viscountess in her own right, spent a lifetime
fighting to take her seat in the House of Lords against bitter opposition, a battle which only achieved its goal in the year of her
death.
Reproductive Rights
In 1803 the United Kingdom enacted Lord Ellenborough's Act, making abortion after quickening a capital crime, and providing
Annie Besant was tried in 1877 for publishing Charles Knowlton's Fruits of Philosophy, a work on family planning, under the
In 1929, the Infant Life (Preservation) Act, 1929 was enacted; it created the offence of child destruction. It also amended the law
so that an abortion carried out in good faith, for the sole purpose of preserving the life of the mother, would not be an offence.
In 1938, Dr. Aleck Bourne aborted the pregnancy of a young girl who had been raped by soldiers. Bourne was acquitted after
1950s - 21 Century
st
While at the end of the war, childcare facilities were closed and assistance for working women became limited, the social reforms
implemented by the new welfare state included family allowances meant to subsidize families, that is, to support women in the
“capacity as wife and mother.” Sue Bruley argues that “the progressive vision of the New Britain of 1945 was flawed by a
Feminist writers of that period, such as Alva Myrdal and Viola Klein, started to allow for the possibility that women should be able
to combine home with outside employment. 1950s’ form of feminism is often derogatorily termed “welfare feminism.” Indeed,
many activists went to great length to stress that their position was that of ‘reasonable modern feminism,’
full B rate received by men. At the time, it was common practice for companies to pay women less than men,
The 1968 strike was a trigger cause of the passing of the Equal Pay Act, 1970.
The Sex Discrimination Act 1975 was an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom which protected people from discrimination on
the grounds of sex or marital status. The Act concerned employment, training, education, harassment, the provision of goods and
services, and the disposal of premises. The Gender Recognition Act, 2004 and The Sex Discrimination Act, 1975 (Amendment)
Regulations, 2008 were amended parts of this Act to apply to transsexual peop
R v R UKHL is a court judgment delivered in 1991, in which the House of Lords determined that under English criminal law it is
21 Century
st
The Sex Discrimination (Election Candidates) Act 2002 (c.2) is an Act of Parliament of the United Kingdom. The purpose of the Act
was to exempt the selection of candidates in parliamentary elections from the provisions in the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 and the
Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976 that outlaw sexual discrimination.
The purposes of the Act allow political parties to select candidates based on gender in an effort to increase representation of women
in British politics.
The Female Genital Mutilation Act, 2003 and the Prohibition of Female Genital Mutilation (Scotland) Act, 2005 made it an offence to
arrange FGM outside the country for British citizens or permanent residents, whether or not it is lawful in the country to which the
In April 2012 after being sexually harassed on London public transport English journalist Laura Bates founded the Everyday Sexism
Project, a website which documents everyday examples of sexism experienced by contributors from around the world. The site
quickly became successful and a book compilation of submissions from the project was published in 2014.
Sisters Uncut was founded in 2014 to take direct action in response to cuts to domestic violence services by the UK government,
which has included demonstrating against cuts at the 7 October London premiere of the 2015 film Suffragette. Sisters Uncut
intellectual Gloria Jean Watkins (who uses the pseudonym
race and class and thus failed to address "the issues that
FEMINISM IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
divided women." She highlighted the lack of minority voices in
Margin to Centre.
First-wave Feminism
their gender.
all men and women are created equal and endowed by their
Woodhull became the first woman to run for president, although she could not vote and only
Second-wave Feminism
In 1963 Betty Friedan, influenced by The Second Sex, wrote the bestselling book The Feminine
Mystique in which she explicitly objected to the mainstream media image of women, stating that
placing women at home limited their possibilities, and wasted talent and potential.
Also in 1963, freelance journalist Gloria Steinem gained widespread popularity among feminists
after a diary she authored while working undercover as a Playboy Bunny waitress at the Playboy
Club was published as a two-part feature in the May and June issues of Show. The feature was "A
Bunny's Tale" (Part I and Part II). Steinem alleged the club was mistreating its waitresses in order to
gain male customers and exploited the Playboy Bunnies as symbols of male chauvinism, noting
that the club's manual instructed the Bunnies that "there are many pleasing ways they can employ
The movement grew with legal victories such as the Equal Pay Act of 1963, Title VII of the Civil
The criminalization of marital rape in the United States started in the mid-1970s and by 1993
The feminist movement in the late 1970s, led by NOW, briefly attempted a program to help older
divorced and widowed women. Many widows were ineligible for Social Security benefits, few
divorcees actually received any alimony, and after a career as a housewife, few had skills to enter
Supreme Court, of sexual harassment. Thomas denied the accusations and, after
extensive debate, the United States Senate voted 52–48 in favour of Thomas.
feminists sought to question, reclaim, and redefine the ideas, words, and media that
have transmitted ideas about gender, gender roles, womanhood, beauty, and
sexuality, among other things. Third-wave feminism saw many new feminist icons
such as Madonna, Queen Latifah, Angelina Jolie, Emma Watson,
Fourth-wave Feminism
associated with the use of social media. According to feminist scholar Prudence
Chamberlain, the focus of the fourth wave is justice for women and opposition to
sexual harassment and violence against women. Its essence, she writes, is
"incredulity that certain attitudes can still exist".
Criticisms
The General Motors Corporation had never hired a Black woman for its workforce
until 1964 because this was the year of the Civil rights Act was passed through
Feminism in Socialist
A socialist country is a country where the government or the public as a
countries
whole has control over the economy. In a socialist country, the producing and
dispersing of goods is owned by the government. Socialism is placed in
between capitalism and communism.
China
hierarchical order of the universe. The I Ching stated that "Great Righteousness is shown in that
man and woman occupy their correct places; the relative positions of Heaven and Earth."
The situation only began to change as result of the Xinhai Revolution in 1911. In course of this
widespread uprising against the ruling Qing dynasty, several women rebel units were raised
such as Wu Shuqing's Women's Revolutionary Army,
All these units are disbanded by the Provisional Government of the Republic of China on 26 th
February 1912, mostly for chauvinistic reasons. Nevertheless, the fact that they had fought
alongside men encouraged many of the women who had taken part in the women militias to
become politically active, striving for change.
In 2001, China amended its marriage law, so that abuse was considered grounds for divorce.
In 2005, China added new provisions to the Law on Women's Right Protection to include sexual
harassment. In 2006 "The Shanghai Supplement" was drafted to help further define sexual
harassment in China.
In 2013, the first woman to bring a gender discrimination lawsuit in China, a 23-year-old who
went by the pseudonym of Cao Ju, won a small settlement of 30,000 yuan and an official
apology from the Juren Academy.
In 2015, China enacted its first nationwide law prohibiting domestic violence, although it
most of the
Feminist leaders
Issues in Chinese feminism movements are men not women, while in
in China
western countries, women are the main sponsors of movements for Woman's
Rights.
Li Xiaojiang is often credited as the founder of women's studies in China. Her 1983 essay
"Progress of Mankind and Women's Liberation" (Renlei jinbu yu funü jiefang) was the first
women's studies publication in China; the Association of Women's Studies was founded two
years later.
One-child policy:
Sexuality in China:
Domestic Violence: a 2005 American Journal of Public Health report found that 1 out of 5
Chinese women had experienced physical violence from their partner in the past year.
Although China acknowledged that domestic violence was a problem in the 1930s, it has only
become a visible issue in the past few decades due to economic and social changes in the
1980s.
• LGBTQIA+ rights: Same-sex sexual activity has been legal in China since 1997. Additionally,
In 1933, during the 100-day government of Ramón Grau, Cuban women received the vote. In 1934, the
FEMINISM IN CUBA
percentages of Cuban women working outside the home, attending school, and practicing birth control
surpassed the corresponding percentages in nearly every other Latin American country.
Cuban constitution of 1940 is one of the most progressive in the western hemisphere.
During the Cuban Revolution, women were mobilized and obtained unparalleled rights compared to the rest of
Latin America. For example, they were able to obtain the 1975 Cuban Family Code. This code outlawed
Even though Cuban women achieved a lot of parity during the Cuban Revolution, there was still a lot of disparity
"During the 1990s, when subsidies from the Soviet Union ended, the maintenance of social
services often fell back on women as mothers, wives, and caregivers, indicative that Cuba had not fully
"This persistence of women's inequality in the political arena was apparent in the speculation
over who was to succeed Fidel Castro as head of state, when he became ill in 2006. Of the 12- 15 names
mentioned, which included the inner circles of Cuba's leadership, not one was a woman.
. As per the World Bank’s Gender Data Portal, women represent 42% of the labour force
participation.
career-paths (including politics) as well as income inequality and a greater burden of household work.
.
FEMINISM IN ERSTWHILE USSR
After the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991, feminist circles arose among the intelligentsia, though the term
continues to carry negative connotations among contemporary Russians. In the 21 century some Russian feminists, such as
st
the punk-rock band Pussy Riot, have again aligned themselves with revolutionary anti-government movements, as in the
2012 demonstrations against President Vladimir Putin, which led to a lawyer representing the Russian Orthodox Church
In his influential novel What is to be Done?, the writer Nikolai Chernyshevski embodied the new feminist ideas in the novel's
heroine, Vera Pavlovna, who dreams of a future utopian society with perfect equality among the sexes.
Notable Russian intellectual figures like Alexander Pushkin and Alexander Herzen wrote positively about the increased power and
independence of women in their society and supported the growing concern for gender equality.
• 19th century
The male Decembrists were a group of aristocratic revolutionaries who in 1825 were convicted of plotting to overthrow Emperor
Nicholas I, and many of whom were sentenced to serve in labor camps in Siberia. Though the wives, sisters, and mothers of the
Decembrist men shared the same liberal democratic political views as their male relatives, they were not charged with treason
because they were women; however, 11 of them, including Sheremeteva and Princess Mariya Volkonskaya, still chose to
accompany their husbands, brothers, and sons to the labor camps. Though they were portrayed as heroes in popular culture, the
Decembrist women insisted that they were simply doing their duty to their family.
In his later years, Leo Tolstoy argued against the traditional institution of marriage, comparing it to forced prostitution and slavery,
a theme that he also touched on in his novel Anna Karenina. In his plays and short stories, Anton Chekhov portrayed a variety of
working female protagonists, from actresses to governesses, who sacrificed social esteem and affluence for the sake of financial
Vladimir Lenin, who led the Bolsheviks to power in the October Revolution, recognized the importance of women's equality in the
Soviet Union (USSR) they established. "To effect [woman's] emancipation and make her the equal of man," he wrote in 1919,
The Revolution and Soviet Era
In practice, Russian women saw mixed gains in their rights under Communism. Women's suffrage was granted, though voting
meant little in Soviet society owing to the Communist Party's monopoly on power. This monopoly also meant that many
independent feminist organizations and journals were shut down. Abortion was legalized in 1920, making the Soviet Union the
first country to do so; however, it was banned again between 1936 and 1955. Generous maternity leave was legally required, and
a national network of child-care centres was established. The country's first constitution recognized the equal rights of women.
• 1970s: There were also double standards in social norms and expectations. "A man can fool around with other women, drink,
even be lackadaisical toward his job, and this is generally forgiven," wrote Hedrick Smith, former Russian correspondent for The
New York Times, but "if a woman does the same things, she is criticized for taking a light-hearted approach toward her marriage
Pre-Revolution Russia was a very backwards country that was far behind in industrialization and politics. Most other European
countries were experimenting with constitutions and democracy yet Russia still had serfdom and strong nobility. The industrial
class rose up multiple times finally during World War I they won and Lenin took power and created Soviet communism, this
liberated women and gave them opportunities to pursue careers as doctors and engineers along with many other professions.
In 1918 legislature was created to try to weaken marriage and the family to create a unified society focused on the country not
the family. The ability to perform marriages was taken away from the church and given solely to the state.
Under Lenin, divorce was made much easier. Abortion was also legalised. This is because of a Marxist belief that marriage was a
bourgeois institution, and that women were to be "freed from the bondage of children and family". This did not last too long
however
Lenin) soon came to question its previous decisions. By the late 1930s, divorce rates in the Soviet Union were the highest in
Stalin also noticed that there were a great number of orphaned children living on the streets,
USSR..
formed into gangs. This further caused Stalin to recreate the importance of the family in the
Soviet Union.
In June 1936, he reversed much of the social policy regarding women which had been written
under Lenin, importantly:
Marriages now had to be registered to be recognised Divorce was once again made difficult
The family was declared the "basis of Soviet society" Homosexuality was made illegal
Mothers with more than two children were declared "heroines of the revolution"
The right to inherit family property (restricted under Lenin) was re-established.
1936, Stalin created a "Housewives' Movement" which was charged with "civilising the tastes"
and improving the working conditions of women, but in actual fact the USSR was so rapt on its
war economy that the group received little attention.
Women did become better represented in the workforce, largely due to a lack of men because
of the war. In 1936, there were 9 million women in the industrial workforce of the USSR. By
FEMINIST ISSUES AND WOMEN’S PARTICIPATION IN INDIA